FLP site-specific recombinase of yeast 2-micron plasmid. Topological features of the reaction

Real-time single-molecule tethered particle motion experiments reveal the kinetics and mechanisms of Cre-mediated site-specific recombination

Tyrosine family recombinases (YRs) are widely utilized in genome engineering systems because they can easily direct DNA rearrangement. Cre recombinases, one of the most commonly used types of YRs, catalyze site-specific recombination between two loxP sites without the need for high-energy cofactors, other accessory proteins or a specific DNA target sequence between the loxP sites. Previous structural, analytical ultracentrifuge and electrophoretic analyses have provided details of the reaction kinetics and mechanisms of Cre recombinase activity; whether there are reaction intermediates or side pathways involved has been left unaddressed. Using tethered particle motion (TPM), the Cre-mediated site-specific recombination process has been delineated, from beginning to end, at the single-molecule level, including the formation of abortive complexes and wayward complexes blocking inactive nucleoprotein complexes from entering the recombination process. Reversibility in the strand-cleavage/-ligation process and the formation of a thermally stable Holliday junction intermediate were observed within the Cre-mediated site-specific recombination process. Rate constants for each elementary step, which explain the overall reaction outcomes under various conditions, were determined. Taking the findings of this study together, they demonstrate the potential of single-molecule methodology as an alternative approach for exploring reaction mechanisms in detail.

Protein-induced local DNA bends regulate global topology of recombination products

The tyrosine family of recombinases produces two smaller DNA circles when acting on circular DNA harboring two recombination sites in head-to-tail orientation. If the substrate is supercoiled, these circles can be unlinked or form multiply linked catenanes. The topological complexity of the products varies strongly even for similar recombination systems. This dependence has been solved here. Our computer simulation of the synapsis showed that the bend angles, phi, created in isolated recombination sites by protein binding before assembly of the full complex, determine the product topology. To verify the validity of this theoretical finding we measured the values of phi for Cre/loxP and Flp/FRT systems. The measurement was based on cyclization of the protein-bound short DNA fragments in solution. Despite the striking similarity of the synapses for these recombinases, action of Cre on head-to-tail target sites produces mainly unlinked circles, while that of Flp yields multiply linked catenanes. In full agreement with theoretical expectations we found that the values of phi for these systems are very different, close to 35 degrees and 80 degrees, respectively. Our findings have general implications in how small protein machines acting locally on large DNA molecules exploit statistical properties of their substrates to bring about directed global changes in topology.

The mu transpososome through a topological lens

Phage Mu is the most efficient transposable element known, its high efficiency being conferred by an enhancer DNA element. Transposition is the end result of a series of well choreographed steps that juxtapose the enhancer and the two Mu ends within a nucleoprotein complex called the 'transpososome.' The particular arrangement of DNA and protein components lends extraordinary stability to the transpososome and regulates the frequency, precision, directionality, and mechanism of transposition. The structure of the transpososome, therefore, holds the key to understanding all of these attributes, and ultimately to explaining the runaway genetic success of transposable elements throughout the biological world. This review focuses on the path of the DNA within the Mu transpososome, as uncovered by recent topological analyses. It discusses why Mu topology cannot be analyzed by standard methods, and how knowledge of the geometry of site alignment during Flp and Cre site-specific recombination was harnessed to design a new methodology called 'difference topology.' This methodology has also revealed the order and dynamics of association of the three interacting DNA sites, as well as the role of the enhancer in assembly of the Mu transpososome.

Enhancer-independent Mu transposition from two topologically distinct synapses

Transposition of Mu is strictly dependent on a specific orientation of the left (L) and right (R) ends of Mu and a distant enhancer site (E) located on supercoiled DNA. Five DNA crossings are trapped in the three-site synapse, two of which are contributed by the interwrapping of L and R. To determine the contribution of E to the interwrapping of Mu ends, we examined the topology of the LR synapse under two different enhancer-independent reaction conditions. One of these conditions, which also alleviates the requirement for a specific orientation of Mu ends, revealed two topologically distinct arrangements of the ends. In their normal relative orientation, L and R were either plectonemically interwrapped or aligned by random collision. Addition of the enhancer to this system channeled synapsis toward the interwrapped pathway. When the ends were in the wrong relative orientation, synapsis occurred exclusively by random collision. In the second enhancer-independent condition, which retains the requirement for a specific orientation of Mu ends, synapsis of L and R was entirely by interwrapping. The two distinct kinds of synapses also were identified by gel electrophoresis. We discuss these results in the context of the "topological filter" model and consider the many contributions the enhancer makes to the biologically relevant interwrapped synapse.

Interactions of protein complexes on supercoiled DNA: the mechanism of selective synapsis by Tn3 resolvase

"Looping" interactions of distant sites on DNA molecules, mediated by DNA-binding proteins, feature in many regulated genetic processes. We used plasmids containing up to six res recombination sites for Tn3 resolvase to analyse looping interactions (synapsis) in this system. We observed that in plasmids with four or more res sites, certain pairs of sites recombine faster than others. The relative rates of recombination depend on the number, relative orientation, and arrangement of the sites. To account for the differences in rate, we propose that pairing interactions between resolvase-bound res sites are in a state of rapid flux, leading to configurations in which the maximum number of sites within each supercoiled substrate molecule are synapsed in a topologically simple arrangement. Recombination rates reflect the steady state concentrations of these synapse configurations. Our results are at variance with models for selective synapsis that rely on ordered motions within supercoiled DNA, "slithering" or "tracking", but are compatible with models that call for reversible synapsis of pairs of sites by random collision, followed by formation of an interwound productive synapse.

The Mu enhancer is functionally asymmetric both in cis and in trans. Topological selectivity of Mu transposition is enhancer-independent

Mu DNA transposition from a negatively supercoiled DNA substrate requires interaction of an enhancer element with the left (attL) and right (attR) ends of Mu. The orientation of the L and R ends with respect to each other (inverted) and with respect to the enhancer is normally inviolate. We show that when the enhancer is provided in trans as a linear fragment, the head to head orientation of the L/R ends is still required. Each functional half of the linear enhancer maintains the same "cross-wise" interaction with the subsites L1 and R1, when present in cis or in trans. In reactions catalyzed by an enhancer-independent variant of the Mu transposase, the need for negative supercoiling of the substrate and the inverted orientation of L and R ends is not relaxed. These results show that the orientation specificity of the enhancer is not determined by its topological linkage to the Mu ends. There is a functional asymmetry inherent to the enhancer. Furthermore, the enhancer does not directly impose topological constraints on the transposition reaction or specify the reactive orientation of the Mu ends.

Geometry of site alignment during int family recombination: antiparallel synapsis by the Flp recombinase

The Flp site-specific recombinase functions in the copy number amplification of the yeast 2 microm plasmid. The recombination reaction is catalyzed by four monomers of Flp bound to two separate, but identical, recombination sites (FRT sites) and occurs in two sequential pairs of strand exchanges. The relative orientation of the two recombination sites during synapsis was examined. Topoisomerase relaxation and nick ligation were used to detect topological nodes introduced by the synapse prior to the chemical steps of recombination. A single negative supercoil was found to be trapped by Flp in substrates with inverted FRT sites whereas no trapped supercoils were observed with direct repeats. The topology of products resulting from Flp-mediated recombination adjacent to a well characterised synapse, that of Tn3 resolvase/res, was analyzed. The deletion and inversion reactions yielded the four noded catenane and the three noded knot, respectively, as the simplest and the most abundant products. The linking number change introduced by the Flp-mediated inversion reaction was determined to be +/-2. The most parsimonious explanation of these results is that Flp aligns its recombination sites with antiparallel geometry. The majority of synapses appear to occur without entrapment of additional random plectonemic DNA supercoils between the sites and no additional crossings are introduced as a result of the chemical steps of recombination.

Topological selectivity of a hybrid site-specific recombination system with elements from Tn3 res/resolvase and bacteriophage P1 loxP/Cre

In order to investigate the functions of the parts of the Tn 3 recombination site res, we created hybrid recombination sites by placing the loxP site for Cre recombinase adjacent to the "accessory" resolvase-binding sites II and III of res. The efficiency and product topology of in vitro recombination by Cre between two of these hybrid sites were affected by the addition of Tn 3 resolvase. The effects of resolvase addition were dependent on the relative orientation and spacing of the elements of the hybrid sites. Substrates with sites II and III of res close to loxP gave specific catenated or knotted products (four-noded catenane, three-noded knot) when resolvase and Cre were added together. The product topological complexity increased when the length of the spacer DNA segment between loxP and res site II was increased. Similar resolvase-induced effects on Cre recombination product topology were observed in reactions of substrates with loxP sites adjacent to full res sites. The results demonstrate that the res accessory sites are sufficient to impose topological selectivity on recombination, and imply that intertwining of two sets of accessory sites defines the simple catenane product topology in normal resolvase-mediated recombination. They are also consistent with current models for the mechanism of catalysis by Cre.

The topological mechanism of phage lambda integrase

Bacteriophage lambda integrase (Int) is a versatile site-specific recombinase. In concert with other proteins, it mediates phage integration into and excision out of the bacterial chromosome. Int recombines intramolecular sites in inverse or direct orientation or sites on separate DNA molecules. This wide spectrum of Int-mediated reactions has, however, hindered our understanding of the topology of Int recombination. By systematically analyzing the topology of Int reaction products and using a mathematical method called tangles, we deduce a unified model for Int recombination. We find that, even in the absence of (-) supercoiling, all Int reactions are chiral, producing one of two possible enantiomers of each product. We propose that this chirality reflects a right-handed DNA crossing within or between recombination sites in the synaptic complex that favors formation of right-handed Holliday junction intermediates. We demonstrate that the change in linking number associated with excisive inversion with relaxed DNA is equally +2 and -2, reflecting two different substrates with different topology but the same chirality. Additionally, we deduce that integrative Int recombination differs from excisive recombination only by additional plectonemic (-) DNA crossings in the synaptic complex: two with supercoiled substrates and one with relaxed substrates. The generality of our results is indicated by our finding that two other members of the integrase superfamily of recombinases, Flp of yeast and Cre of phage P1, show the same intrinsic chirality as lambda Int.

Site-specific recombination at dif by Haemophilus influenzae XerC

Xer site-specific recombination at the Escherichia coli chromosomal site dif converts chromosomal dimers to monomers, thereby allowing chromosome segregation during cell division. dif is located in the replication terminus region and binds the E. coli site-specific recombinases EcoXerC and EcoXerD. The Haemophilus influenzae Xer homologues, HinXerC and HinXerD, bind E. coli dif and exchange strands of dif Holliday junctions in vitro. Supercoiled dif sites are not recombined by EcoXerC and EcoXerD in vitro, possibly as a consequence of a regulatory process, which ensures that in vivo recombination at dif is confined to cells that can initiate cell division and contain dimeric chromosomes. In contrast, the combined action of HinXerC and EcoXerD supports in vitro recombination between supercoiled dif sites, thereby overcoming the barrier to dif recombination exhibited by EcoXerC and EcoXerD. The recombination products are catenated and knotted molecules, consistent with recombination occurring with synaptic complexes that have entrapped variable numbers of negative supercoils. Use of catalytically inactive recombinases provides support for a recombination pathway in which HinXerC-mediated strand exchange between directly repeated duplex dif sites generates a Holliday junction intermediate that is resolved by EcoXerD to catenated products. These can undergo a second recombination reaction to generate odd-noded knots.

Comparative kinetic analysis of FLP and cre recombinases: mathematical models for DNA binding and recombination

The integrase class site specific recombinases FLP from Saccharomyces cerevisiae, and Cre from bacteriophage P1, have been extensively used to direct DNA rearrangements in heterologous organisms. Although their reaction mechanisms have been relatively well characterised, little comparative analysis of the two enzymes has been published. We present a comparative kinetic analysis of FLP and Cre, which identifies important differences. Gel mobility shift assays show that Cre has a higher affinity for its target, loxP (7. 4x10(10) M-1), than FLP for its target, FRT (8.92x10(8) M-1). We show that both recombinases bind the two halves of their target sites cooperatively, and that Cre shows approximately threefold higher cooperativity than FLP. Using a mathematical model describing the sequential binding of recombinase monomers to DNA, we have determined values for the association and dissociation rate constants for FLP and Cre.FLP and Cre also showed different characteristics in in vitro recombination assays. In particular, approximately tenfold more active FLP was required than Cre to optimally recombine a given quantity of excision substrate. FLP was able to reach maximum excision levels approaching 100%, whilst Cre-mediated excision did not exceed 75%. To investigate possible reasons for these differences a mathematical model describing the excision recombination reaction was established. Using measured DNA binding parameters for FLP and Cre in the model, and comparing simulated and experimental recombination data, the values of the remaining unknown parameters were determined. This analysis indicates that the synaptic complex is more stable for Cre than for FLP.

Expression and mutational analysis of the baculovirus very late factor 1 (vlf-1) gene

We have examined the expression and function of a gene, vlf-1, of Autographa californica nuclear polyhedrosis virus that is known to encode a regulator of very late gene transcription. Western blot analysis revealed that vlf-1 is expressed during the late phase of infection, primarily from 15 to 24 h postinfection. VLF-1 localized in the cell nucleus and was also present in the nucleocapsids of virus particles. Mapping of vlf-1 mRNA by primer extension showed that transcription initiates at a TAAG motif 71 bp upstream of the vlf-1 open reading frame. Disruption of this TAAG motif abolished the ability of vlf-1 to stimulate transcription from the very late polyhedrin gene (polh) promoter in transient expression assays, suggesting that vlf-1 expression is controlled by the TAAG motif. Using a highly efficient system to construct recombinant viruses with modifications in vlf-1, we confirmed that the TAAG motif was essential. Furthermore, efforts to construct null mutants of vlf-1 failed, suggesting that vlf-1 is an essential gene for virus replication. Computer-assisted sequence homology searches place vlf-1 in the lambda phage integrase family (McLachlin and Miller, 1994). None of the strictly conserved residues of this family which are found in vlf-1 could be changed in the viral genome, implying that the putative integrase activity of VLF-1 is associated with the essential function of vlf-1. However, mutation of a crucial active-site tyrosine did not affect the ability of vlf-1 to transactivate the polh promoter in transient expression assays, indicating that the very late transcriptional activity of VLF-1 does not require the integrase activity.

Topological analysis of the role of homology in Flp-mediated recombination

Recombination by the Flp recombinase of Saccharomyces cerevisiae is known to be inhibited by heterology of the overlap regions of the two recombining DNA targets (FRT sites). We have used topological analysis to show that Flp can promote two rounds of intramolecular recombination between heterologous FRT sites contained within the same supercoiled plasmid. The products are in parental nonrecombinant configuration. Thus, heterology may appear to "block" recombination by rendering the heteroduplex recombinant products unstable, thus favoring a second round of recombination to homoduplex (but parental) products. Hence, homology in the core region is not a requirement for the recombination reaction by Flp but for the formation of recombinant products.

Topological selectivity in Xer site-specific recombination

The product topology of Xer-mediated site-specific recombination at plasmid sites has been determined. The product of deletion at pSC101 psi is a right-handed antiparallel 4-noded catenane. The ColE1 cer deletion product has an identical topology, except that only one pair of strands is exchanged. These specific product topologies imply that the productive synaptic complex and the strand exchange mechanism have fixed topologies. Further analysis suggests that synapsis traps exactly three negative supercoils between recombining sites, and that strand exchange introduces a further negative topological node in the deletion reaction. We present a model in which the requirement for a specific synaptic stucture, with two recombination sites interwrapped around the accessory proteins ArgR and PepA, ensures that recombination only occurs efficiently between directly repeated sites on the same DNA molecule.

Analysis of the mechanism of DNA recombination using tangles

The DNA of all organisms has a complex and essential topology. The three topological properties of naturally occurring DNA are supercoiling, catenation, and knotting. Although these properties are denned rigorously only for closed circular DNA, even linear DNAin vivocan have topological properties because it is divided into topologically separate subdomains (Drlica 1987; Roberge & Gasser, 1992). The essentiality of topological properties is demonstrated by the lethal consequence of interfering with topoisomerases, the enzymes that regulate the level of DNA supercoiling and that unlink DNA during its replication (reviewed in Wang, 1991; Bjornsti, 1991; Drlica, 1992; Ullspergeret al. 1995).

Ligand-regulated site-specific recombination

Site-specific recombination offers a potential way to alter a living genome by design in a precise and stable manner. This potential requires strategies which can be used to regulate the recombination event. We describe a strategy to regulate FLP recombinase activity which relies on expressing FLP as a fusion protein with steroid hormone receptor ligand binding domains (LBDs). In the absence of a ligand cognate to the LBD, the recombinase activity of the fusion protein is extremely low. Upon ligand administration, recombinase activity is rapidly induced. These results outline the basis for inducible expression or disruption strategies based on inducible recombination. Additionally, we have exploited the conditional nature of FLP-LBD fusion proteins to direct integration of a plasmid into a specific genomic site at frequencies approaching the frequency of random integration.

In vivo excision and amplification of large segments of the Escherichia coli genome

In vivo excision and amplification of large segments of a genome offer an alternative to heterologous DNA cloning. By obtaining predetermined fragments of the chromosome directly from the original organism, the problems of clone stability and clone identification are alleviated. This approach involves the insertion of two recognition sequences for a site-specific recombinase into the genome at predetermined sites, 50-100 kb apart. The integration of these sequences, together with a conditional replication origin (ori), is targeted by homologous recombination. The strain carrying the insertions is stably maintained until, upon induction of specifically engineered genes, the host cell expresses the site-specific recombinase and an ori-specific replication protein. The recombinase then excises and circularizes the genomic segment flanked by the two insertions. This excised DNA, which contains ori, is amplified with the aid of the replication protein and can be isolated as a large plasmid. The feasibility of such an approach is demonstrated here for E. coli. Using the yeast FLP/FRT site-specific recombination system and the pi/gamma-ori replication initiation of plasmid R6K, we have devised a procedure that should allow the isolation of virtually any segment of the E. coli genome. This was shown by excising, amplifying and isolating the 51-kb lacZ--phoB and the 110-kb dapX--dsdC region of the E. coli MG1655 genome.

Stereoselectivity of DNA catenane fusion by resolvase

Communications between distant sites on DNA often depend on the way in which the sites are connected. For example, site-specific recombination catalysed by Tn3 resolvase is most efficient when the 114-base-pair res recombination sites are directly repeated in the same DNA molecule. In vitro a supercoiled plasmid substrate containing two directly repeated res sites gives a resolution product in which the two recombinant circles are topologically linked as a simple (two-noded) catenane (Fig. 1a). Resolvase is highly selective in forming this product rather than unlinked circles or more complex catenanes. It does not catalyse recombination between sites on separate supercoiled molecules, or between inverted sites in the same supercoiled molecule. Tn3 resolution removes four negative supercoils from the substrate, an energetically favourable change which may drive the reaction: in relaxed or nicked circular substrates, resolution is incomplete and slower. Resolvase can catalyse fusion of the circles of a nicked or relaxed catenane, giving a single unknotted circular product. The fusion is the precise topological reversal of resolution, introducing four negative supercoils into a relaxed catenane substrate, and should therefore not proceed if the catenane is already negatively supercoiled. Here we study recombination between res sites in non-supercoiled DNA circles linked into simple catenanes. We used (+2) and (-2) catenanes, which differ only in the direction in which one circle is threaded through the other (Fig. 2a). Although stereoselectivity is a feature of enzyme catalysis, it is not obvious how resolvase can distinguish between these subtly different catenane diastereomers. A model for the intertwining of the res site DNA in the catalytically active complex predicts that only the (-2) catenane will recombine, giving unknotted and 4-noded knot circular products. We have confirmed this prediction for the Tn3 and Tn21 resolvases.

FLP protein of 2 mu circle plasmid of yeast induces multiple bends in the FLP recognition target site

The FLP recombinase of the 2 mu plasmid of Saccharomyces cerevisiae binds to a target containing three 13 base-pair symmetry elements called a, b and c. The symmetry elements b and c are in direct orientation while the a element is in inverted orientation with respect to b and c on the opposite side of an eight base-pair core region. Each symmetry element acts as a binding site for the FLP protein. The FLP protein can form three different complexes with the FLP recognition target (FRT site) according to the number of elements within the site that are occupied by the FLP protein. Binding of FLP to the FRT site induces DNA bending. We have measured the angles of bends caused by the binding of the FLP protein to full and partial FRT sites. We find that FLP induces three types of bend in the FRT-containing DNA. The type I bend is approximately 60 degrees and results from a molecule of FLP bound to one symmetry element. The type II bend is greater than 144 degrees and results from FLP molecules bound to symmetry elements a and b. The type III bend is approximately 65 degrees and results from FLP proteins bound to symmetry elements b and c. Certain FLP proteins that are defective in recombination can generate the type I and type III bends but are impaired in their ability to induce the type II bend. We discuss the role of bending in FLP-mediated recombination.

Synaptic intermediates promoted by the FLP recombinase

We have devised a novel assay to trap nucleoprotein synaptic intermediates of the FLP recombination reaction. DNase I footprinting analysis of these intermediates indicates that synapsis is mediated by protein-protein interactions between FLP molecules bound to each FLP recombination target (FRT) site. Under certain conditions we have observed a synaptic structure in which the FRT sites have come together in an aberrant arrangement. Although our analysis shows that homology between the core sequences of the sites is not a prerequisite for synapsis, the data suggest that homology between cores dictates the directionality of the reaction. Many of the intermediates contain a Holliday junction indicating that the FLP protein has catalysed strand exchanges between the FRT sites. The general scheme of the assay should prove useful to analyse nucleoprotein intermediates in other site-specific recombination systems, and to investigate protein-protein and protein-DNA interactions in intermediates important for DNA replication and transcription.

Synthesis of an enzymatically active FLP recombinase in vitro: search for a DNA-binding domain

We have used an in vitro transcription and translation system to synthesize an enzymatically active FLP protein. The FLP mRNA synthesized in vitro by SP6 polymerase is translated efficiently in a rabbit reticulocyte lysate to produce enzymatically active FLP. Using this system, we assessed the effect of deletions and tetrapeptide insertions on the ability of the respective variant proteins synthesized in vitro to bind to the FLP recognition target site and to carry out excisive recombination. Deletions of as few as six amino acids from either the carboxy- or amino-terminal region of FLP resulted in loss of binding activity. Likewise, insertions at amino acid positions 79, 203, and 286 abolished DNA-binding activity. On the other hand, a protein with an insertion at amino acid 364 retained significant DNA-binding activity but had no detectable recombination activity. Also, an insertion at amino acid 115 had no measurable effect on DNA binding, but recombination was reduced by 95%. In addition, an insertion at amino acid 411 had no effect on DNA binding and recombination. On the basis of these results, we conclude that this approach fails to define a discrete DNA-binding domain. The possible reasons for this result are discussed.

Synthesis of an enzymatically active FLP recombinase in vitro: search for a DNA-binding domain

We have used an in vitro transcription and translation system to synthesize an enzymatically active FLP protein. The FLP mRNA synthesized in vitro by SP6 polymerase is translated efficiently in a rabbit reticulocyte lysate to produce enzymatically active FLP. Using this system, we assessed the effect of deletions and tetrapeptide insertions on the ability of the respective variant proteins synthesized in vitro to bind to the FLP recognition target site and to carry out excisive recombination. Deletions of as few as six amino acids from either the carboxy- or amino-terminal region of FLP resulted in loss of binding activity. Likewise, insertions at amino acid positions 79, 203, and 286 abolished DNA-binding activity. On the other hand, a protein with an insertion at amino acid 364 retained significant DNA-binding activity but had no detectable recombination activity. Also, an insertion at amino acid 115 had no measurable effect on DNA binding, but recombination was reduced by 95%. In addition, an insertion at amino acid 411 had no effect on DNA binding and recombination. On the basis of these results, we conclude that this approach fails to define a discrete DNA-binding domain. The possible reasons for this result are discussed.