The concomitant presence of gastroschisis and prune belly syndrome in a twin

A clinical-pathogenetic approach on associated anomalies and chromosomal defects supports novel candidate critical regions and genes for gastroschisis

BACKGROUND

Gastroschisis has been assumed to have a low rate of syndromic and primary malformations. We aimed to systematically review and explore the frequency and type of malformations/chromosomal syndromes and to identify significant biological/genetic roles in gastroschisis.

METHODS

Population-based, gastroschisis-associated anomalies/chromosomal defects published 1950-2018 (PubMed/MEDLINE) were independently searched by two reviewers. Associated anomalies/chromosomal defects and selected clinical characteristics were subdivided and pooled by race, system/region, isolated, and associated cases (descriptive analysis and chi-square test were performed). Critical regions/genes from representative chromosomal syndromes including an enrichment analysis using Gene Ontology Consortium/Panther Classification System databases were explored. Fisher's exact test with False Discovery Rate multiple test correction was performed.

RESULTS

Sixty-eight articles and 18525 cases as a base were identified (prevalence of 17.9 and 3% for associated anomalies/chromosomal defects, respectively). There were 3596 associated anomalies, prevailing those cardiovascular (23.3%) and digestive (20.3%). Co-occurring anomalies were associated with male, female, American Indian, Caucasian, prenatally diagnosed, chromosomal defects, and mortality (P < 0.00001). Gene clusters on 21q22.11 and 21q22.3 (KRTAP), 18q21.33 (SERPINB), 18q22.1 (CDH7, CDH19), 13q12.3 (FLT1), 13q22.1 (KLF5), 13q22.3 (EDNRB), and 13q34 (COL4A1, COL4A2, F7, F10) were significantly related to biological processes: blood pressure regulation and/or vessel integrity, angiogenesis, coagulation, cell-cell and/or cell-matrix adhesion, dermis integrity, and wound healing (P < 0.05).

CONCLUSIONS

Our findings suggest that gastroschisis may result from the interaction of several chromosomal regions in an additive manner as a pool of candidate genes were identified from critical regions supporting a role for vascular disruption, thrombosis, and mesodermal deficiency in the pathogenesis of gastroschisis.

A classic twin study of isolated gastroschisis

The etiology of gastroschisis remains elusive. A classic twin study was used to assess the relative contribution of environmental and genetic factors in its development. Screening of 4872 twin pregnancies identified three unreported twin pairs comprising two monozygous and one dizygous discordant pair of twins. Review of the literature identified an additional 21 twin pairs. We observed lower pair- and proband-wise concordance rates for monozygotic compared to dizygotic twin pairs, pair- and proband-wise concordance ratios below 1.0. Our results suggest environmental to play a greater role than genetic factors in the development of gastroschisis.

Familial recurrence of gastroschisis: literature review and data from the population-based birth registry "Mainz Model"

BACKGROUND

Familial forms of gastroschisis are considered rare. A search for these forms in a population-based birth registry in 1993 found a recurrence risk of 3.5% among first-degree relatives. Since then, similar investigations in population-based registries have led to contradictory results.

METHODS

A search of the population-based birth registry "Mainz Model" for familial cases of gastroschisis and a systematic review of the literature were performed.

RESULTS

The Mainz Model database yielded 1 familial recurrence out of 27 gastroschisis cases. From the literature, 37 affected families could be retrieved. Among 412 gastroschises from population-based registries, 10 familial recurrences have been found. These translate into a recurrence risk of 2.4%, with a strong tendency toward underestimation.

CONCLUSION

The existing data support the hypothesis that familial recurrence of gastroschisis is much more likely than previously thought.

Prune-belly syndrome associated with omphalocele in a female newborn

The authors report on a female newborn with prune-belly syndrome (PBS) in association with omphalocele. This case raises the total of omphalocele associated with PBS to seven. The authors suggest that this case lends support to the concept of PBS being caused by an early disturbance of mesodermal development in both the abdominal wall and the urinary tract.

Monozygotic twins discordant for gastroschisis: case report and review of the literature of twins and familial occurrence of gastroschisis

We describe a pair of monozygotic (MZ) female twins discordant for gastrochisis. To our knowledge, this is the first such case reported. The zygosity was verified by DNA analysis using highly polymorphic microsatellites. There was no family history of gastroschisis. During pregnancy there was no suspicion of any exposure responsible for the malformation. The number of twin cases described so far does not allow any conclusion as to hereditary factors in the cause of gastroschisis, but the number of families reported with familial gastroschisis suggests that the recurrence risk is higher than previously thought.

Prune belly syndrome: clinicopathologic study of 29 cases

The clinical course and the pathologic features of 29 patients with the prune belly syndrome (PBS) are reviewed. There were 26 males and 3 females. In addition to the classical triad of deficient abdominal musculature, urinary tract abnormalities, and cryptorchidism, a broader spectrum of other defects was found including musculoskeletal (58%) and gastrointestinal (31%) abnormalities. Genital anomalies were present in all three female patients. Many of these defects may be inapparent at birth, but are the cause of morbidity and mortality later in life. Severe urinary tract maldevelopment and pulmonary hypoplasia as part of the oligohydramnios syndrome was the most common cause of perinatal deaths. In these patients, major portions of the renal parenchyma were dysplastic, but in survivors, renal dysplasia, when present, was minor by comparison, and affected less than 1/3 of the parenchyma. Although several questions remain unanswered, we believe that the PBS results from the effect of one or more teratogenic agents on the somatic mesoderm, producing inappropriate mesenchymal development and inadequate mesenchymal-epithelial interactions that lead to abnormal development and dilatation of some of its derivatives (abdominal muscles, ureter, bladder, prostate, urethra, and gubernaculum). Although abnormalities in derivatives of the intermediate mesoderm (kidney) may also be produced by the injurious agent(s), they are more likely a result of urinary obstruction. Abnormalities in other organs and systems are the consequence of oligohydramnios.

Prune belly syndrome associated with exomphalos and anorectal agenesis

We have recently treated a child with prune belly syndrome in association with exomphalos and anorectal agenesis. This case raises the total incidence of exomphalos and anorectal agenesis to four and five, respectively, in our series of 13 cases of prune belly syndrome. Our case report lays emphasis on the severe respiratory problems that can complicate surgery in prune belly patients. We also attempt to relate the pattern of anomalies in our series to the controversy surrounding the embryogenesis of prune belly syndrome and suggest that our case material lends support to the concept of prune belly syndrome being due to an early disturbance of mesodermal development in both the abdominal wall and the urinary tract. We also suggest that the reported occurrence of gastroschisis in association with prune belly syndrome adds weight to the unifying theory of the embryogenesis of gastroschisis and exomphalos.