Acetowhitening of the cervix and vulva as a predictor of subclinical human papillomavirus infection: sensitivity and specificity in a population-based study

The Normal Vulva, Vulvar Examination, and Evaluation Tools

The appearance of the female external genitalia is key for understanding and diagnosing many diseases that women of all ages encounter. Alas, the normal appearance of the vulva is an elusive concept, scarcely represented in textbooks, and the growing number of vulvar cosmetic surgery calls for a review of the normal appearance of the vulva and its diversity. In this paper I will review vulvar embryology, anatomy, the current literature discussing vulvar appearance, and describe meticulous vulvar examination, including the diagnostic tools.

Screening and follow up of vulval skin disorders

Vulval squamous cell carcinoma is relatively rare; however, up to 20% of women have significant vulval symptoms during their lifetime. Formal screening programmes for vulval disease have not been established. The evidence for the use of vulval cytology and vulvoscopy is reviewed. No randomised-controlled trials have compared follow-up regimens, and although a few consensus documents have been published, formal guidelines are lacking in Grade A evidence. With increasing pressure on healthcare resources, the possibility of identifying high-risk groups to optimise the use of follow up in specialist clinics is explored. Vulval disease is uncommon and there is no evidence that screening would decrease incidence. If high-risk groups can be identified, follow up should take place in specialised vulval clinics with experienced clinicians who are trained in vulval disease. Women with uncomplicated vulval conditions should be discharged to patient-initiated follow up or primary care. Central to the reduction of mortality and morbidity is increased awareness of vulval conditions among women and improved education of healthcare professionals, with particular understanding of the importance of physical examination.

Effectiveness of VIA, Pap, and HPV DNA testing in a cervical cancer screening program in a peri-urban community in Andhra Pradesh, India

Background

While many studies have compared the efficacy of Pap cytology, visual inspection with acetic acid (VIA) and human papillomavirus (HPV) DNA assays for the detection cervical intraepithelial neoplasia and cancer, few have evaluated the program effectiveness.

Methods and Findings

A population-based sample of 5603 women from Medchal Mandal in Andhra Pradesh, India were invited to participate in a study comparing Pap cytology, VIA, and HPV DNA screening for the detection of CIN3+. Participation in primary screening and all subsequent follow-up visits was rigorously tracked. A 20% random sample of all women screened, in addition to all women with a positive screening test result underwent colposcopy with directed biopsy for final diagnosis. Sensitivity, specificity, positive and negative predictive values were adjusted for verification bias. HPV testing had a higher sensitivity (100%) and specificity (90.6%) compared to Pap cytology (sensitivity  =  78.2%; specificity = 86.0%) and VIA (sensitivity = 31.6%; specificity = 87.5%). Since 58% of the sample refused involvement and another 28% refused colposcopy or biopsy, we estimated that potentially 87.6% of the total underlying cases of CIN3 and cancer may have been missed due to program failures.

Conclusions

We conclude that despite our use of available resources, infrastructure, and guidelines for cervical cancer screening implementation in resource limited areas, community participation and non-compliance remain the major obstacles to successful reduction in cervical cancer mortality in this Indian population. HPV DNA testing was both more sensitive and specific than Pap cytology and VIA. The use of a less invasive and more user-friendly primary screening strategy (such as self-collected swabs for HPV DNA testing) may be required to achieve the coverage necessary for effective reduction in cervical cancer mortality.

Value of the International Federation for Cervical Pathology and Colposcopy (IFCPC) Terminology in Predicting Cervical Disease

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate the colposcopic accuracy according to the International Federation for Cervical Pathology and Colposcopy (IFCPC) 2002 terminology.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

A series of 3,040 women derived from a general population were screened by means of Pap smear, unaided visual inspection, and high-risk human papillomavirus testing. All colposcopic examination results with abnormal findings and with biopsy confirmation (n = 468) were recorded, reviewed by 2 blinded colposcopists according to the IFCPC nomenclature, and included in this analysis.

RESULTS

The IFCPC terminology was easily reproduced by the 2 observers with excellent interobserver agreement (kappa =.843). Colposcopy had a sensitivity of 86% and a specificity of 30.3% in distinguishing healthy cervix from that with cervical intraepithelial neoplasia (CIN)/carcinoma. In distinguishing healthy cervix/low-grade lesions (CIN 1) from that with high-grade lesions (CIN 2/3)/carcinoma, colposcopy had a sensitivity of 61.1% and a specificity of 94.4%. Colposcopic findings graded as major changes had the highest positive predictive value for detecting high-grade lesion/carcinoma. The colposcopic abnormalities within the transformation zone and large lesions were more closely related to high-grade lesion/carcinoma, whereas a sharp outer border, multiple colposcopic abnormalities, and iodine negativity were not statistically related to severe lesions.

CONCLUSIONS

Colposcopy using the new IFCPC classification is a potentially effective screening method; when used for diagnosis, a histological sampling is necessary. The categorization of major changes and minor changes is appropriate. It is important to describe the lesion localization in relation to the transformation zone and the lesion size because these characteristics are related to high-grade lesions.

Acetowhite epithelium

OBJECTIVE

The study was undertaken to provide further understanding of the phenomenon of "acetowhite epithelium".

METHODS

Solutions of acetic and similar acids were applied to the atypical transformation zone to demonstrate (or not) acetowhite epithelium.

RESULTS

Acetowhite epithelium is not unique to acetic acid, but can be mimicked by other water soluble carboxylic acids.

CONCLUSIONS

Acetowhite epithelium is probably due to the reflection of light from the superficial layers of epithelium when they become opaque following the rapid penetration of these non-coagulant fixatives and their effect on nucleoprotein.

In vivo detection of human papilloma virus-induced lesions of anogenital area after application of acetic acid: a novel and accurate approach to a trivial method

Human papilloma virus infection is increasing at an alarming rate. The ability of the virus to establish a subclinical infection and its association with malignancy of the lower genital tract make the statistics even more worrisome. Topical application of acetic acid solution provokes temporal alterations of the light-scattering properties of human papilloma virus-induced lesions of anogenital area. For the in vivo study of the phenomenon, an imaging system has been employed, which performs time-lapse imaging and enables the calculation and display of the kinetics of the provoked alterations in any point within the examined area. Confirmation of diagnosis has been established with conventional histology and polymerase chain reaction. It has been shown that the method provides early detection and staging of skin alteration or transformation due to human papilloma virus infection and enables mapping of the infected area.

The prevalence of genital human papillomavirus infections in abused and nonabused preadolescent girls

OBJECTIVE

To compare the prevalence of genital human papillomavirus (HPV) infections in sexually abused and nonabused preadolescent girls and assess the feasibility of conducting a longitudinal study of the natural history of HPV infection in this population.

METHOD

Consecutively referred, 5- to 12-year-old girls who were evaluated for sexual abuse by a Child Advocacy and Protection Team were invited to participate in the study. During a standard forensic medical examination, 2 specimens for HPV testing were obtained (one by rubbing a Dacron swab over the perineum and the other by lavaging the vagina with phosphate-buffered saline). The specimens were evaluated for HPV DNA by polymerase chain reaction using MY09/11 consensus primers and high-risk (16,18,31,33,35,39,45,51,52, 56,58) and low-risk (6,11,42,43,44) types were detected with a solution hybridization assay, the SHARP Signal System (Digene Diagnostics). The genital area was examined for warts and subclinical, colposcopic evidence of HPV. Participants were invited to return for longitudinal evaluation at 4-month intervals for 2 years.

RESULTS

Sexual abuse was confirmed in 29 (72.5%) of the 40 study participants, suspected in 2 (5%), and ruled out in 9 (22.5%). None of the girls had genital warts or abnormal colposcopic findings. HPV DNA was detected in 5 (16%) of the 31 girls with confirmed or suspected sexual abuse (1 with high-risk and 4 with low-risk types) and none of the nonabused girls (Fisher's exact test). Girls who tested positive and negative for HPV did not differ significantly in age or type of abuse. Despite close telephone follow-up and numerous attempts to schedule appointments, none of the participants returned for follow-up.

CONCLUSIONS

Genital HPV infection is more common among sexually abused than nonsexually abused girls, with the majority of infections not clinically apparent. Because it is so difficult to study the natural history of these infections in abused children, it may be necessary to draw inferences about the long-term sequelae of pediatric HPV infections from longitudinal studies of girls who voluntarily initiate sexual activity soon after menarche.

Short fragment polymerase chain reaction reverse hybridization line probe assay to detect and genotype a broad spectrum of human papillomavirus types. Clinical evaluation and follow-up

The purpose of this study was to detect and genotype 16 different human papilloma virus (HPV) types simultaneously using a short fragment polymerase chain reaction (SPF) hybridization line probe assay (LiPA). 152 women who were referred to the gynecologist because of abnormal cervical smear underwent colposcopic examination and repeat cervical smear. In addition, the cervical scrapes were analyzed for the presence of HPV by a novel general HPV polymerase chain reaction assay followed by a single reaction genotyping assay allowing for a simultaneous detection and identification of 16 different HPV types. HPV DNA was detected in 38% of normal follow-up cervical scrapes, 51% of scrapes with atypical squamous cells of undetermined significance, 78% of scrapes with mild dysplasia (low grade squamous intraepithelial lesions), 86% of scrapes with moderate dysplasia (high grade squamous intraepithelial lesions), and in 88% of scrapes with severe dysplasia and carcinoma in situ. One case of invasive squamous cell carcinoma was positive for HPV 16. Overall, a single HPV type was detected in 56% of HPV positive scrapes, with HPV 16 being the most common and accounting for 45% of all single infections. Forty-four percent of the positive scrapes contained multiple HPV types, of which double infections prevailed. Follow-up results proved the reproducibility and reliability of SPF HPV LiPA. In conclusion, we have used and evaluated the SPF-HPV-LiPA system for the detection and genotyping of HPV infections. The combined detection-typing method proved to be sensitive, specific, simple, and fast, making mass screening of cervical scrapes accessible for routine practice and facilitating individual patient management.

Visual inspection with acetic acid for cervical-cancer screening: test qualities in a primary-care setting. University of Zimbabwe/JHPIEGO Cervical Cancer Project

BACKGROUND

Naked-eye visual inspection of the cervix with acetic-acid wash (VIA), or cervicoscopy, is an alternative to cytology in screening for cervical cancer in poorly resourced locations. We tested the sensitivity, specificity, and predictive value of VIA done by nurse-midwives in a less-developed country.

METHODS

Women were screened by six trained nurse-midwives in a two-phase, cross-sectional study at 15 primary-care clinics in Zimbabwe. VIA and Pap smears were done concurrently, and their sensitivity and specificity compared. Colposcopy, with biopsy as indicated, was used as the reference test to allow a direct comparison of the test unaffected by verification bias.

FINDINGS

10934 women were screened. In phase II, 2148 (97.5%) of the 2203 participants for whom there was a screening result also had a reference test result. Also in phase II, VIA was more sensitive but less specific than cytology. Sensitivity (95% CI) was 76.7% (70.3-82.3) for VIA and 44.3% (37.3-51.4) for cytology. Specificity was 64.1% (61.9-66.2) for VIA and 90.6% (89.2-91.9) for cytology.

INTERPRETATION

The high sensitivity of VIA shows that the test could be valuable in detection of precancerous lesions of the cervix. However, there are costs to the patient and system costs associated with high numbers of false-positive results, so attention should be given to improving the specificity of VIA.

Human papillomavirus. Subclinical and atypical manifestations

Subclinical HPV infections, together with latent infections, are probably the most likely outcome after exposure to HPV. Subclinical infection is associated with symptoms such as burning, fissuring, and dyspareunia in some patients. Only these patients should be offered treatment. Diagnosing and treating asymptomatic HPV infection cannot be recommended until better knowledge about the infectious potential of the infection in that phase is obtained. Recently, results have been presented showing a median duration of HPV infection of only 8 months, and after 24 months, only 9% of the women studied continued to be infected. This provides the possibility to reassure patients with HPV infection that it is most likely a transient infection, and one should not worry unduly. In light of this knowledge, it seems unwise to diagnose an asymptomatic infection for which no effective treatment is available and for which the natural history and consequences remain unclear; however, if these lesions were found to have the potential to transmit HPV, the patient should be so counseled.