Open Surgical Techniques for Laryngotracheal Stenosis

Surgical management of scleromatous laryngotracheal stenosis

OBJECTIVE

Scleroma is a chronic specific granulomatous disease of the upper respiratory tract caused by Klebsiella Rhinoscleromatis. It usually affects the subglottic region and upper trachea resulting in various degrees of stenosis. Patients with laryngotracheal stenosis may present with stridor, shortness of breath or exercise intolerance and may be tracheostomy dependent. In this work, we presented the experience of our Institute in the management of patients with scleromatous laryngotracheal stenosis using the already designed procedures for traumatic laryngotracheal stenosis.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

The study was a non controlled prospective study. It was conducted in Oto-Rhino-Laryngology and Head and Neck Surgery Department of Zagazig University Hospitals, Egypt. It included 38 patients with scleromatous subglottic stenosis and/or upper tracheal stenosis. The patients were classified into four grades according to Myer-Cotton's scale. The surgical treatment modalities included endoscopic CO2 laser surgery with dilatation, laryngotracheal reconstruction, and partial cricotracheal resection with thyrotracheal anastomosis.

RESULTS

The average follow-up period was 32.1 months. Twenty four patients (63%) had an excellent outcome. Nine patients (24%) had a good outcome. Five patients (13%) were still tracheostomy dependent. Eleven patients (29%) developed postoperative granulation tissue. The overall success rate was 87%.

CONCLUSION

Scleromatous laryngotracheal stenosis is considered a challenging surgical problem. It requires a multidisciplinary approach by well-trained personnel. The surgical techniques designed for cases of laryngotracheal stenosis of a traumatic etiology can be applied for cases of scleroma with approximately the same success rates.

Non-intubation traumatic laryngotracheal stenosis: management policies and results

Traumatic laryngotracheal stenosis (LTS) is increasing in clinical practice. Causes include external trauma, post-intubation, and iatrogenic injuries. It is a complex problem and many patients undergo multiple procedures to achieve a stable and well-protected airway with adequate voice. We present our experience at Ain-Shams University Hospitals on 15 patients followed-up for 7 years. All patients had traumatic LTS excluding post-intubation injuries. Patients were aged 4-58 years. Nine were the victims of road traffic accidents; five were occupational trauma victims; and one tried to commit suicide by strangulation. The patients underwent a total of 53 procedures (mean 3.5 per patient). A total of seven laryngotracheal reconstruction, six partial cricotracheal resection, and four laser recanalization with stenting were performed. Six patients have mean follow-up of 26.5 months (3-60 months). Six patients had normal speech (GRBAS 0-5), three had a moderate degree of voice disturbance (GRBAS 5-10), and five had severe dysphonia (GRBAS > 10). As regards tolerance for daily activities, we used a modification of the McMaster University asthma quality of life questionnaire [Rea et al. Eur J Cardiothorac Surg 22(3):352, 2002] (using the activities and emotional scores total 112). Four patients could perform above the 90th percentile; all the remaining patients were above the 50th percentile. No patient was totally handicapped as a result of their airway problem and they could tend for their basic activities. The aim of this work is to demonstrate that non-intubation traumatic LTS is a complex problem that usually needs a longer time for reconstruction and a different way of approach. However, most of the patients can be finally rehabilitated with a stable, protected airway and adequate voice albeit at the price of a prolonged series of interventions and a long follow-up.

Tracheal resection with primary anastomosis in cadavers: the effects of releasing maneuvers and length of tracheal resection on tension

To determine the relationships among length of trachea resected, total tracheal length, and anastomotic tension when using various release maneuvers, we studied 10 adult human cadavers: 5 male and 5 female. The trachea was transected between rings 2 and 3. Precision, handheld spring tensiometers (Geneva Gage, LLC) were used to measure the tension required to approximate, and then overlap, the proximal segment relative to the distal segment, and the distal segment relative to the proximal segment after these maneuvers: no release, blunt dissection, neck flexion, suprahyoid release (SHR) without neck flexion, SHR with neck flexion, and right hilar release. After the tension measurements were recorded, the trachea was harvested and the total tracheal length was measured. Length-tension curves were plotted for both the superior and inferior tracheal segments after each release maneuver. The stiffness coefficient for the trachea and the resting load on the trachea following each release maneuver were calculated. An exponential length-tension relationship existed for the distal tracheal segment regardless of whether release maneuvers were performed. The proximal tracheal segment exhibited a linear length-tension relationship initially, but displayed an exponential relationship after SHR. We could resect 6.68 cm (range, 4.2 to 9.9 cm), 13.3 rings (range, 10 to 20 rings), or 65.5% (range, 42% to 100%) of the trachea without undue tension (<1,000 g) on the anastomosis. We conclude that various tracheal release maneuvers are effective in increasing the length of trachea that can be relatively safely resected. However, these maneuvers are not uniformly effective across subjects.

[Iatrogenic tracheal stenosis following endotracheal intubation: a study of 20 clinical cases]

The authors report a case review series of 20 patients with tracheal stenosis after prolonged oral or nasotracheal intubation who underwent surgical treatment between 1995 and 1999. Seventeen were male (85%) and three (15%) were female. The age varied between 9 and 68 years (32.8 +/- 14.9 years). The stenotic area of the airway was limited to the trachea, and its length varied between 2 and 5 cm (3.3 +/- 1.2 cm.). All patients were treated surgically with an external approach for reconstruction after stenosis ablation. Follow up was at three and six months after surgery there were: 16 cases with (80%) good results, two (10%) with satisfactory results and two unsatisfactory (10%). We found a statistically significant correlation (Spearman correlation) of 5% level between the period of tracheal intubation and patient's age (R = 0.478, p = 0.033).

Laryngotracheal reconstruction in subglottic stenosis: an ancient problem still present

BACKGROUND

Subglottic stenosis is an ancient but persistent problem as a cause of airway obstruction. The etiology and the results of surgical treatment with thyrotracheal anastomosis were reviewed.

METHODS

Fifty-six patients with subglottic stenosis were studied. All were subjected to laryngotracheal reconstruction by thyrotracheal anastomosis with partial resection of the cricoid.

RESULTS

Of all 56 cases of subglottic stenosis, 48 (86%) had history of previous tracheal intubation, and only 8 (14%) had different non-neoplastic obstructive processes such as scleroma, direct injury, hamartoma, and amyloidosis. Immediate results were good in all cases. After 1 year follow-up, results of thyrotracheal anastomosis were successful in 44 (91%). In 4 other cases a restenosis was observed. Eight patients were lost to follow-up.

CONCLUSIONS

Subglottic stenosis is still frequent after tracheal intubation, but other causes must be considered. Laryngotracheal reconstruction with thyrotracheal anastomosis with partial cricoid resection was feasible with good results in 91% of the cases with follow-up, but this procedure must be performed by a skilled surgical team.

Laryngotracheal reconstruction in the adult: a ten year experience

The purpose of this study is to retrospectively analyze our experience with airway reconstruction, to outline a new staging system for laryngotracheal (LT) stenosis, and to identify preoperatively those patients likely to fail reconstruction. We reviewed 41 patients who underwent 46 LT reconstructions over the past 10 years. Success was judged by the ability to decannulate patients within 1 year postoperatively. Of our patients, 63% were treated successfully, and an additional 17% had intermediate success. The techniques used for laryngotracheoplasty with augmentation grafting and tracheal resection are reviewed. Major complications, thoracic complications, and wound complications are presented. Each patient was staged by the McCaffrey staging system and Cotton grades. We propose a new staging system based on the extent of the stenosis throughout the glottis, subglottis, and trachea. It is logical and easy to use. Applied to our cases of LT stenosis retrospectively, the new system predicts clinical success (chi2, p = .05). Using contingency tables and chi2 testing for statistical evaluation, we found that diabetics have a significantly higher failure rate (chi2, p = .0002). Further, we identified a group of patients who in addition to the airway stenosis also had comorbid medical conditions that frequently necessitate a tracheostomy. These patients have a significantly higher failure rate (chi2, p = .009). Using this information and applying the staging system prior to reconstruction, we can identify patients likely to fail.