Ovine fetal development following embryo culture in synthetic oviductal fluid with added ammonium

The effects of chemical and physical factors on mammalian embryo culture and their importance for the practice of assisted human reproduction

BACKGROUND

Although laboratory procedures, along with culture media formulations, have improved over the past two decades, the issue remains that human IVF is performed in vitro (literally 'in glass').

METHODS

Using PubMed, electronic searches were performed using keywords from a list of chemical and physical factors with no limits placed on time. Examples of keywords include oxygen, ammonium, volatile organics, temperature, pH, oil overlays and incubation volume/embryo density. Available clinical and scientific evidence surrounding physical and chemical factors have been assessed and presented here.

RESULTS AND CONCLUSIONS

Development of the embryo outside the body means that it is constantly exposed to stresses that it would not experience in vivo. Sources of stress on the human embryo include identified factors such as pH and temperature shifts, exposure to atmospheric (20%) oxygen and the build-up of toxins in the media due to the static nature of culture. However, there are other sources of stress not typically considered, such as the act of pipetting itself, or the release of organic compounds from the very tissue culture ware upon which the embryo develops. Further, when more than one stress is present in the laboratory, there is evidence that negative synergies can result, culminating in significant trauma to the developing embryo. It is evident that embryos are sensitive to both chemical and physical signals within their microenvironment, and that these factors play a significant role in influencing development and events post transfer. From the viewpoint of assisted human reproduction, a major concern with chemical and physical factors lies in their adverse effects on the viability of embryos, and their long-term effects on the fetus, even as a result of a relatively brief exposure. This review presents data on the adverse effects of chemical and physical factors on mammalian embryos and the importance of identifying, and thereby minimizing, them in the practice of human IVF. Hence, optimizing the in vitro environment involves far more than improving culture media formulations.

Ovine fetal development is more sensitive to perturbation by the presence of serum in embryo culture before rather than after compaction

The effects on subsequent fetal development of the presence or absence of serum at different times during IVC of ovine zygotes were studied. Zygotes, recovered from superovulated ewes 36h after intrauterine AI using semen from a single sire, were cultured for 5 days in synthetic oviductal fluid (SOF) media supplemented with either BSA and amino acids (SOF-) or with 10% (v/v) steer serum (SOF+). Serum was present or absent during the first two and last 2 days of IVC giving four treatments (SOF-/SOF-; SOF-/SOF+;SOF+/SOF- and SOF+/SOF+). In total, 224 embryos, including 26 in vivo controls, were transferred singly at day 6 post-AI to synchronous recipients and the products of conception recovered at day 125 of gestation. Presence of serum during IVC had a biphasic effect on embryo development. The inclusion of serum during the first 2 days of IVC retarded early embryo development while the inclusion of serum during the last 2 days of IVC produced more blastocysts by day 6. These effects were independent of each other. The presence of serum during the first 2 days of IVC resulted in increased weights of gravid uterus, placenta, fetus, fetal heart and liver. The incidence of fetuses whose total or organ weights were greater than three standard deviations above the corresponding mean weights of control fetuses was also greater when serum was present during the first 2 days of IVC. However, even when serum was absent throughout IVC there was still an infrequent incidence of fetal weights greater than three standard deviations above the mean for control fetuses. These observations provide evidence that it is the early pre-compaction stages of embryo development that are particularly sensitive to perturbations leading to abnormal fetal development.

Manipulation of domestic animal embryos and implications for development

Assisted reproductive technologies, as applied to domestic animals, can exert both novel and wide-ranging influences on the development, viability and welfare of offspring. Some of the changes are evident immediately or soon after the time at which a manipulative procedure is carried out, while other changes may not be evident until later in development or, perhaps, may remain undetected throughout an animal's lifetime. The present review explores some of the consequences - in terms of foetal, placental, neonatal and post-natal effects - of exposing embryos of cattle, sheep and other species to in vitro culture per se or, during culture, to physically invasive technologies including gene injection and nuclear transfer. The innate sensitivity of oocytes and recently fertilized eggs to their in vitro environment is illustrated by an examination of the later developmental repercussions resulting from apparently innocuous choices related to in vitro culture medium formulations. In contrast, an inherent resilience and paradoxical readiness to resume development following the traumas of nuclear transfer procedures is also in evidence. The extent to which assisted reproductive technologies will succeed, where relevant, in the domestic animal sector will be influenced by our appreciation of embryo requirements, for both short- and long-term developmental fitness, during their earliest developmental stages. Evidence of species-specific needs is testimony to the challenges ahead. Ultimately, our ability and inclination to resolve the limitations associated with current procedures will probably be greatly enhanced if predictive indicators (genetic, epigenetic or functional markers) of later developmental fitness can be identified.

Large offspring syndrome and other consequences of ruminant embryo culture in vitro: relevance to blastocyst culture in human ART

In vitro production of embryos from domestic animals is used to augment conventional genetic improvement programmes in agriculture and to facilitate advances in gene transfer and cloning. However, production of embryos in vitro exposes them to hazards not normally encountered in vivo and, as a result, there have been unforeseen consequences including the large offspring syndrome. This syndrome is manifest as abnormal growth and development at fetal, neonatal and later stages after transfer of embryos cultured in vitro for up to 1 week after fertilization. Our embryo culture and fetal development studies have begun to characterize many of the genetic, metabolic and developmental features associated with the syndrome. This review considers the findings of these studies in the context of blastocyst production in vitro, emphasizing the impact of culture strategies on ruminant (cattle and sheep) embryo composition and developmental competence. The need to alter in vitro production strategies to safeguard oocytes and embryos during culture is discussed. Finally, the implications of experiences gained in domestic animal studies are considered in the context of current options for human embryo culture. The need for an appreciation of the sensitivity of the embryo to its environment and the possible short- and long-term consequences of inappropriate in vitro production strategies are considered.

Influence of in vitro systems on embryo survival and fetal development in cattle

In vitro systems are commonly used for the production of bovine embryos. Comparisons between in vivo and in vitro produced embryos illustrate that the morphology of preimplantation-stage embryos differ significantly, the survival of embryos and fetuses is decreased, the size distributions of the populations of conceptuses and fetuses are altered throughout gestation, and placental development is significantly changed. Taken together these findings indicate that exposure to some in vitro environments during the first 7 days of life can profoundly influence fetal and placental development in cattle. An understanding of how in vitro oocyte maturation, in vitro fertilization, and embryo culture systems influence both fetal and placental development should result in systems that consistently produce normal embryos, fetuses, and calves.

In vitro culture and embryo metabolism of cattle and sheep embryos - a decade of achievement

At the beginning of the 1990s, co-culture of cattle and sheep embryos was the most favoured method to support embryo development, but the use of this system has hampered progress in raising the efficiency of embryo production. Furthermore, little was known of the requirements of embryos and the biochemistry of early embryo development. As the decade progressed, energy metabolism studies improved our understanding of the energy substrate requirements for embryo development. Furthermore, an appreciation of the reproductive tract environment increased. This resulted in more "defined" systems, which have evolved further in the development of "sequential" media systems, where components change in accordance to the needs of the embryo. Nevertheless, wholly defined systems, such as the replacement of albumin with PVA, are less able to support similar levels of development as protein-containing medium, and the resulting embryos are metabolically compromised. This highlights the nutritive role of albumin. One area in which much work has been conducted, but yet no unifying theory has emerged, is that of the interactive roles of growth factors (including autocrine/paracrine), cytokines and extra-cellular matrix molecules in the development of a viable embryo. A new concept is that of regulation of energy metabolism. Compounds such as ethylenediamine tetraacetic acid (EDTA), NaN(3) and 2,4-dinitrophenol have been shown to increase embryo development and quality of resulting embryos. This demonstrates that the process of ATP production is a key regulator of in vitro embryo development.

Effects of different reproduction techniques: AI MOET or IVP, on health and welfare of bovine offspring

Since the introduction of in vitro production (IVP) of bovine and sheep pre-implantation embryos, increased birth weights and other deviations of IVP calves and lambs compared with AI or MOET offspring have been reported. Study 1 of the present paper, a comparison between AI, MOET and IVP (co-culture/serum) calves with respect to calf and calving characteristics in large-scale field conditions, confirms these reports. In addition, it is shown that MOET calves tend towards higher birth weights and have significantly longer gestations and more difficult calvings than AI calves. It is presently unknown if the effect of IVP is also observed later in life. In this paper, data on reproduction characteristics of bovine IVP co-culture/serum offspring are presented. Semen production--and non return data of one year old IVP bulls and superovulation-, AI- and OPU/IVP results of one year old IVP heifers are compared with those of one year old AI and MOET animals producing semen or embryos in the same time period. So far, there are no indications that the use of IVP is reflected in deviate reproduction characteristics of bovine IVP offspring. It has been suggested that use of co-culture cells and serum during in vitro culture of bovine (and sheep) embryos may partially explain the increased birth weights and other deviations of bovine and sheep IVP offspring. Deletion of these factors in semi-defined culture media, e.g. Synthetic Oviductal Fluid (SOF), could result in more normal offspring. Study 2 investigates this hypothesis in both field conditions (Study 2a, comparing AI, IVP co-culture/serum and IVP SOF calves) and in semi-standardized conditions (Study 2b, comparing MOET, IVP co-culture/serum and IVP SOF calves at one herd). In Study 2a, although IVP SOF calves showed (non-significant) shorter gestations, easier calvings and lower percentages of perinatal mortality and congenital malformations than IVP co-culture calves, birth weights were not decreased. In Study 2b however, the difference between IVP co-culture and IVP SOF calves in birth weight and ease of calving was significant (P < 0.05), IVP SOF calves resembling MOET calves more. IVP calves differed significantly from MOET calves with respect to several physiological parameters, such as blood oxygen saturation level, heart beat frequency and some measures of the heart. In addition, in Study 2b, recipients receiving an IVP SOF embryo showed a more regular return to estrus than those receiving an IVP co-culture embryo. From Study 2 it can be concluded that using a semi-defined medium for in vitro culture (SOF) may improve characteristics of IVP calves born.