Isolation of a virus from chimpanzee liver cell cultures inoculated with sera containing the agent of non-A, non-B hepatitis

The long and winding road leading to the identification of the hepatitis C virus

This review describes work conducted largely in my laboratory at the Chiron Corporation between 1982 and 1989 that led to the identification of the hepatitis C virus (HCV). Key colleagues included Dr. Qui-Lim Choo in my laboratory and Dr. George Kuo also of Chiron as well as my collaborator Dr. Daniel Bradley at the CDC who provided many biological samples from the NANBH chimpanzee model. Numerous molecular approaches were explored including the screening of tens of millions of bacterial cDNA clones derived from these materials. While this early genomics approach resulted in the identification of many host gene activities associated with NANBH, no genes of proven infectious etiology could be identified. A separate avenue of our research led to the molecular characterization of the complete hepatitis delta viral genome but unfortunately, this could not be used as a molecular handle for HCV. Largely following input from Dr. Kuo, I initiated a blind cDNA immunoscreening approach involving the large-scale screening of bacterial proteomic cDNA libraries derived from NANBH-infectious chimpanzee materials (prior to the development of PCR technology) using sera from NANBH patients as a presumptive source of viral antibodies. Eventually, this novel approach to identifying agents of infectious etiology led to the isolation of a single small cDNA clone that was proven to be derived from the HCV genome using various molecular and serological criteria. This discovery has facilitated the development of effective diagnostics, blood screening tests and the elucidation of promising drug and vaccine targets to control this global pathogen.

N/A

N/A

[From non-A non-B hepatitis to hepatitis C]

In 1974, the existence of hepatitis serologically distinct from hepatitis A and B was recognized. They were tentatively designated non-A non-B. They accounted for 90% of post-transfusional hepatitis. During 15 years numerous studies failed to identify agent(s) responsible for these hepatitis. In 1989 the virus responsible for parenteral non-A non-B hepatitis was identified and named hepatitis C virus. Shortly after, the virus responsible for enteral non-A, non-B was also discovered (hepatitis E virus). During these 15 years, a 60% reduction of post-transfusional hepatitis was obtained both by the measures instituted to prevent AIDS transmission and by the introduction of surrogate assays (ALT levels and anti-HBc antibody).

Identification of hepatitis C virus by immunoelectron microscopy

Sequencing of the hepatitis C virus (HCV) has provided a better understanding of the natural history, immunology, and epidemiology of this virus. However, the morphology of HCV has not been definitively characterized. In this study, through a sequence of concentration processes, virus-like particles were isolated from human serum and liver tissue, visualized by transmission electron microscopy and identified as hepatitis C virion by immunoelectron microscopy. Spherical flavi-like virus particles, approximately 70 nm in diameter, were observed in the fraction with 1.04-1.12 g ml-1 sucrose density and bound to immunogold particles with monoclonal antibodies (mAb) against hepatitis C. The nucleocapsid of the particles, which were 50 nm in diameter, appeared to be icosahedral in structure and surrounded by an envelope covered with surface projections. A 'tadpole' form of particles was also observed. The findings indicate that the low buoyant density in sucrose and the morphological features of the hepatitis C virion are consistent with the characteristics of flaviviruses and pestiviruses.

Multiple positive and negative cis-acting elements that mediate transactivation by bel1 in the long terminal repeat of human foamy virus

The bel1 protein of human foamy virus (HFV), a retrovirus, regulates expression of the gene linked to the HFV long terminal repeat (LTR) and is essential for viral gene expression. The mechanism of action of the bel1 protein is unknown, but its action is mediated through the U3 region of the LTR. To determine which U3 sequences are critical for transactivation by bel1, a series of hybrid vectors consisting of a mutant HFV LTR and the chloramphenicol acetyltransferase gene were constructed and tested for their responsiveness to the bel1 protein by using transient assays after transfection. The target sequences for transactivation by bel1 were mapped to five regions in the U3 domain of the LTR: nucleotides -559 to -506, -454 to -418, -360 to -342, -327 to -284, and -116 to -89 (+1 represents the transcription initiation site). No significant sequence similarity was identified among the five target sites. The observation that the multiple distinct elements in the HFV LTR are the targets for bel1 transactivation is different from observations with other human retroviral systems. The regulation mechanism of HFV bel1 protein-mediated transactivation appears to be analogous to that of some DNA virus transactivators that increase transcription from numerous different viral promoters with little sequence similarity shared among them. We demonstrated that multiple bel1-responsive elements (BRE) can act as bel1-dependent enhancer elements, while a single copy of one BRE, BREe, can serve as an upstream activating element in both orientations. In addition, the region between -466 and -498 was identified as responsible for the downregulation of gene expression directed by BREa, which requires its upstream sequence element to act as a bel1-dependent enhancer element in a heterologous promoter.

A cDNA clone closely associated with non-A, non-B hepatitis

A lambda gt11 cDNA library was constructed from RNA purified from hepatitis B viral surface antigen-negative human plasma with high alanine aminotransferase activity. A cDNA clone, designated as C8-2, was isolated by immunoscreening with mixed sera from non-A, non-B hepatitis (NANBH) carrier and convalescent chimpanzees. The recombinant protein produced by C8-2 reacted specifically with sera of patients in the chronic phase of NANBH. The sequence of C8-2, 269 bp, did not hybridized with any human or chimpanzee genomic DNA, and had no homology with those of primates and viruses. The existence of this sequence in RNA of possibly infectious plasma was shown by RNA blot hybridization and by Southern blot analysis of products amplified by the polymerase chain reaction. These results strongly suggest that C8-2 is derived from the agent of this viral hepatitis.

Toga-like virus as a cause of fulminant hepatitis attributed to sporadic non-A, non-B

Virus-like particles (60-70 nm) with spiked surfaces budding into cell vacuoles and rod-shaped inclusions were detected in nuclei of hepatocytes from a British patient transplanted for sporadic non-A, non-B fulminant hepatitis (NANB-FHF), probably contracted in Kenya. Identical particles were seen in two successive grafts (days 2 and 10) at regrafting for recurrent FHF. Ultrastructural features resembled those of the RNA-containing arbovirus, Rift Valley fever virus, but serological markers against a representative panel for arboviruses (Togaviruses) and transmission in mice proved negative. The particles shared features with the different arboviruses seen in the hepatectomy specimen of a second patient with NANB-FHF, and in both patients an insect vector was implicated in the clinical history. The particles were identical in size to those of a third patient with NANB-FHF, who had remained in the United Kingdom. These findings, together with the recent report of isolation of an RNA-containing virus resembling the Togaviridae, in parenteral NANB, suggest that several exotic virus-like agents resembling the arboviruses may be involved in the aetiology of NANB, including in the sporadic forms of FHF in the United Kingdom.

Viruslike particles in liver in sporadic non-A, non-B fulminant hepatitis

In a patient who followed the typical clinical course of fulminant hepatitis attributable to "sporadic" non-A,non-B (NANB) hepatitis and who finally received treatment by orthotopic liver grafting, three, apparently separate, virus-like agents (26, 45, and 80 nm) and cytoplasmic, reticular tubular structures (CTS) were identified in collapsed and regenerating areas of liver using electron microscopy. The 80-nm particles present within vacuoles, together with the finding of intranuclear rods in association with the smaller particles (26 nm), are similar to those found in the nuclei of cells infected with several different arboviruses. The third type of particle, existing as 45-nm spheres and rods, is similar in morphology only to some form of polyoma virus, which, hitherto, has not been reported as affecting the liver. Unlike typical polyoma virus, replication of the virus "cores" (25-26 nm) was extranuclear and appeared to be occurring in vacuoles. Although analysis for serological markers against a representative panel for arboviruses, flaviviruses, phleboviruses, arenavirus, and nairovirus was negative, an insect vector was implicated in the clinical history.

Analysis of the primary structure of the long terminal repeat and the gag and pol genes of the human spumaretrovirus

The nucleotide sequence of the human spumaretrovirus (HSRV) genome was determined. The 5' long terminal repeat region was analyzed by strong stop cDNA synthesis and S1 nuclease mapping. The length of the RU5 region was determined and found to be 346 nucleotides long. The 5' long terminal repeat is 1,123 base pairs long and is bound by an 18-base-pair primer-binding site complementary to the 3' end of mammalian lysine-1,2-specific tRNA. Open reading frames for gag and pol genes were identified. Surprisingly, the HSRV gag protein does not contain the cysteine motif of the nucleic acid-binding proteins found in and typical of all other retroviral gag proteins; instead the HSRV gag gene encodes a strongly basic protein reminiscent of those of hepatitis B virus and retrotransposons. The carboxy-terminal part of the HSRV gag gene products encodes a protease domain. The pol gene overlaps the gag gene and is postulated to be synthesized as a gag/pol precursor via translational frameshifting analogous to that of Rous sarcoma virus, with 7 nucleotides immediately upstream of the termination codons of gag conserved between the two viral genomes. The HSRV pol gene is 2,730 nucleotides long, and its deduced protein sequence is readily subdivided into three well-conserved domains, the reverse transcriptase, the RNase H, and the integrase. Although the degree of homology of the HSRV reverse transcriptase domain is highest to that of murine leukemia virus, the HSRV genomic organization is more similar to that of human and simian immunodeficiency viruses. The data justify classifying the spumaretroviruses as a third subfamily of Retroviridae.

Spumaviruses isolated from sources containing agents of non-A, non-B (NANB) hepatitis do not cause NANB hepatitis

Serum and liver tissue containing infective non-A, non-B hepatitis virus were shown to contain a retrovirus-like agent that replicated when inoculated into chimpanzee liver cell cultures in vitro. The virus appeared to assemble its core particles in association with tubular structures reminiscent of those characteristically seen in non-A, non-B hepatitis virus-infected chimpanzee liver in vivo, and produced syncytial cytopathic effects in a number of continuous and a primary mammalian liver cells. The agents were neutralized by acute and convalescent sera from human and chimpanzee cases of non-A, non-B hepatitis, as well as by antisera against simian spumavirus type 7, but not type 6. Aluminum chloride failed to abolish viral infectivity. There was no evidence of virus replication or hepatitis in chimpanzees inoculated with a seventh passage of one of the isolates. Thus the data suggest that the isolates are not causally related to non-A, non-B hepatitis, as was previously postulated.

Microbial structures in a patient with sporadic non-A, non-B fulminant hepatitis treated by liver transplantation

Double-shelled virus-like particles (60 nm) and long cytoplasmic tubular structures were found in the cytoplasm of hepatocytes from areas of collapsed and regenerating areas of hepatectomised liver in a 13-year-old boy who received a liver graft for fulminant hepatitis attributed to sporadic non-A, non-B hepatitis. The patient died on the ninth postoperative day from acute graft failure. Although virus-like particles were not found, instead, gram-negative rods were identified in the necrotic graft and the most likely cause of death was a gram-negative septicaemia with a Shwartzman-like reaction localized to the liver.

Viral hepatitis

Developments over the last four years in our understanding of viral hepatitis are analyzed. The molecular structure of hepatitis A has been established, and vaccines for prevention are under development. The recognition of the replicative and integrated stages of hepatitis B infection has allowed more rational approaches to therapy. Vaccines are of proven value. Delta virus infection has assumed an important role world wide as a cause of serious and fulminant liver disease in hepatitis B carriers. The agents for non-A, non-B virus hepatitis have eluded identification. These are important causes of chronic liver disease particularly in recipients of blood transfusion.

Non-A, non-B hepatitis: an update

The definition of non-A, non-B hepatitis (NANB) is improved by further characterization of what it is not (like the delta agent or non-A epidemic hepatitis) rather than by providing convincing evidence of isolation of the agent responsible for blood transfusion- or blood product-related NANB or specific markers thereof. Yet, NANB research is in disquieting movement. Modern biotechnology yielded its blessings to the field. However, monoclonal antibodies and molecular probes will have to be evaluated with the same scrutiny that unmasked so many test systems and viral agents thus far. Recent victims appear to be published reports on NANB being identified as a retroviral agent and NANB virus being propagated in primary cultures of chimpanzee hepatocytes. Yet the application of these powerful new tools, together with the availability of cultured human and chimpanzee hepatocytes for propagation of the agent may improve the chances for substantial progress. Our finding of involvement of lymphocytes in transmission of the disease may add another approach to reach the ultimate goal of characterization of the causative agent and development of diagnostic methods to detect it in patients and biological materials derived from carriers of the disease.

Fulminant hepatitis. An ultrastructural study

Ultrastructural changes were observed in 23 consecutive patients who died from fulminant hepatic failure due to hepatitis B virus (4 cases), sporadic non-A, non-B (7), or paracetamol (acetaminophen) overdose (12) and in 3 patients with subacute hepatic necrosis of unknown cause. The findings are described in detail in 12 of these patients. Fatal fulminant hepatitis was characterised by massive confluent necrosis accompanied by collapse of reticulin framework and sudden drop-out of liver cells. No aetiological distinction could be made between different viral causes of fulminant hepatitis on the basis of ultrastructural pathology. Parenchymal changes in viral cases varied from reversible non-specific necrosis to irreversible changes where fragmentation of endoplasmic reticulum, mitochondria and nuclei had occurred. Differences in ultrastructural pathology between non-viral (paracetamol overdose-induced) and viral fulminant hepatitis were apparent. Modification of endoplasmic reticulum with enlarged attached polyribosomes, breakdown of plasma membrane, accumulation of cytoplasmic amorphous material and karyorrhexis and karyolysis of nuclei were the most prominent features in non-viral cases.

Seroepidemiological studies on a non-A, non-B hepatitis specific antigen/antibody system (SO-antigen/anti-SO)

The patients and staff members of a haemodialysis unit were examined for their serological responses to SO-antigen, which was isolated from the urine of epidemic type non-A, non-B hepatitis patients at Tohoku University Hospital. To understand how SO-antigen or SO-antigen-related aetiology can be incriminated for the hepatitis found in the haemodialysis unit, the prevalence of SO-antigen/anti-SO system and hepatitis A and B virus-related antibodies was compared in the sera of patients and staff members. Although the SO-antigen was rarely detected in the serum, anti-SO antibody was frequently detected in the sera of patients and staff. A significantly higher prevalence was found in the serum of patients (15%, 54 out of 361) than staff members (7.1%, 13 out of 184) and volunteer blood donors (1%, 3 out of 305). The same prevalence percentages of HBV-related antibodies (either positive for anti-HBs or anti-HBc) and anti-HAV were observed among the patients, staff, and volunteer blood donors, irrespective of whether the sera were anti-SO positive or negative. Among the staff, anti-SO antibody was more frequently found in those with a history of acute hepatitis (16.7%, 3 out of 18) than in those without (6%, 10 out of 166). These prevalence ratios conformed with those of HBV-related antibodies, but the same prevalence ratios of antibody to HAV were observed between the staff with and without a history of acute hepatitis. These results indicate that the SO-antigen/anti-SO system or entity related to this immune system is distinct from HBV or HAV, and this immune system was found widely in the haemodialysis unit where type B and non-A, non-B hepatitis were also found frequently.

The current status of non-A, non-B viral hepatitis

It is probable that two or more different viruses account for non-A, non-B hepatitis throughout the world, with a third agent causing epidemic hepatitis in India and neighboring countries. NANB virus(es) is the major cause of transfusion-associated hepatitis, and is responsible for roughly 20% of sporadic hepatitis cases. NANB postransfusion hepatitis progresses to chronic hepatitis in half or more of cases. This form of chronic hepatitis, while usually minimally symptomatic, causes progressive liver destruction and eventual cirrhosis in a significant proportion of cases. To date, the NANB virus(es) has not been specifically identified, either serologically or by electron microscopy. When developed, serologic assays will find their most immediate application in the identification of NANB virus carriers among blood donors, thereby being applied to the prevention of post-transfusion hepatitis. No specific therapy is available for NANB virus infection. Gamma globulin is of uncertain prophylactic efficacy.

[Hepatitis non-A, non-B: epidemiologic, clinical, serologic and morphologic aspects]

Hepatitis non-A, non-B (HNANB) is due to one or more transmissible agents, probably viruses. Epidemiologically, HNANB is transmitted predominantly by transfusion of blood or plasma derivatives, and percutaneous inoculation, but a non-percutaneous transmission by the fecal-oral route is also established. However, despite 10 years of intense world-wide research, the transmissible agent, or agents, have not been identified and there are no serological assays for either an antigen or an antibody that can be used to detect this infection. The clinical diagnosis of HNANB remains, therefore, a diagnosis of exclusion mainly of hepatitis A and B, Epstein-Barr virus, cytomegalovirus and drug-induced liver disease. In contrast to hepatitis A and B, the clinical and biochemical course of HNANB tends to be less severe and the proportion of asymptomatic and anicteric cases is higher, but fulminant hepatitis and fatalities also occur. Typically, there is a fluctuating waxing and waning pattern of the serum aminotransferase activities in HNANB. HNANB has a relative high tendency to progress to a chronic stage. The exact frequency of HNANB-induced liver cirrhosis and convincing evidence for an association with hepatocellular carcinoma cannot be assessed, although the persistence of the infectious agent in chronic HNANB and the existence of a chronic asymptomatic carrier state have been proved. By light microscopy there is a broad morphologic spectrum of acute and chronic viral hepatitis, but no single pathognomonic lesion exists that allows a reliable distinction to be made of HNANB from hepatitis A and B. Electron microscopy of liver biopsy specimens of chimpanzees, experimentally infected with HNANB agents, permits the visualisation of cytoplasmic changes, which appear to be specific for infection with HNANB viruses. In human liver biopsy specimens from patients with HNANB, identical ultrastructural cytoplasmic changes could not consistently be demonstrated. In contrast, intranuclear aggregates of spherical and tubular particles measuring 20-29 nm, first described in experimental HNANB in chimpanzees, have been repeatedly demonstrated in acute and chronic HNANB in man. These nuclear particles have been considered as compelling evidence of human HNANB infection. The specificity has been challenged, however, by the demonstration of identical particles in other viral and non-viral hepatopathies and in liver biopsies of healthy volunteers. By immune electron microscopy, a multiplicity of virus-like particles are described in association with HNANB.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)