Measuring adherence to depression treatment guidelines in a VA primary care clinic

Suicidal Risk Behaviors in Adolescents With Rare Neurodevelopmental Disorders: The Role of Sex, Autistic Traits, and Mental Health Difficulties

OBJECTIVE

Autistic traits are associated with mental health difficulties and risk of suicidal risk behaviors among adolescents. Little is known about how autistic traits affect the mental health of adolescents with rare neurodevelopmental disorders (RNDs). The aim of this study was to investigate the relationship between autistic traits, mental health difficulties, and suicidal risk behaviors in adolescents with RNDs.

METHODS

Parents (N = 93) completed the Child Behavior Checklist, Social Communication Questionnaire, and Social Responsiveness Scale about their adolescent (Mage = 13.1, SD = 2.3, 62.4% females) with an RND (e.g., sex chromosome aneuploidies, Fragile X syndrome, 22q11.2 deletion syndrome). The data were analyzed with hierarchical logistic regression analysis.

RESULTS

The prevalence of suicidal risk behaviors (16.1%) was similar to that reported among autistic youth and was higher among boys than girls. More autistic traits were associated with suicidal risk behaviors in bivariate analysis. In multivariate analysis, more anxiety/depressive symptoms were associated with more suicidal risk behaviors and externalizing problems associated with suicidal risk behaviors beyond autistic traits and anxiety/depressive symptoms.

CONCLUSION

Adolescents with RNDs are at risk of suicidal risk behaviors, especially those with higher levels of autistic traits, anxiety/depressive symptoms, and externalizing problems. Assessment of autistic traits, mental health difficulties, and suicide risk may be indicated for adolescents with RNDs to determine if corresponding intervention is needed.

Are we ready for conformance checking in healthcare? Measuring adherence to clinical guidelines: A scoping systematic literature review

Clinical guidelines are recommendations of how to diagnose, treat, and manage a patient's medical condition. Health organizations must measure adherence to clinical guidelines to enhance the quality of service, but due to the complexity of the medical environment, there is no simple way of measuring adherence to clinical guidelines. This scoping review will systematically assess the criteria used to measure adherence to clinical guidelines in the past 20 years and explore the suitability of using process mining techniques. We will use a workflow protocol based on declarative and temporal constraints to translate the narrative text rules in the publications into a high-level process model. This approach will enable us to explore the main patterns and gaps identified when measuring adherence to clinical guidelines and how they affect the adoption of process mining techniques. The main contributions of this paper are a) a comprehensive analysis of the criteria used for measuring adherence, considering a diverse set of medical conditions b) a framework that will classify the level of complexity of the rules used to measure adherence based on declarative and temporal constraints c) list of key trends and gaps identified in the literature and how they relate to the use of process mining techniques in healthcare.

Psychotherapists' Knowledge of Guideline Recommendations for the Treatment of Depressed Suicidal Patients

Objective

Clinical practice guidelines present expert consensus on the treatment of mental disorders. Yet, studies have shown that knowledge of and adherence to recommendations are moderate. The aim of the present study was to investigate, whether and to what extent psychotherapists are aware of and follow the German guideline recommendations for the treatment of suicidal depressed patients.

Methods

174 participants (licensed psychotherapists, psychotherapists-in-training) were presented with five groups of guideline recommendations (referring to inpatient admission, psychotherapy, acute pharmacotherapy, pharmacologic relapse prevention, follow-up appointments) and were asked to identify the guideline recommendation and indicate whether they provided treatment according to the guideline.

Results

Knowledge and adherence to the guidelines recommendations on psychotherapy and inpatient admission were well present. However, knowledge about pharmacological treatment recommendations was low; same as the knowledge on the necessity of immediate follow-up appointments after discharge of patients hospitalized due to suicidality.

Discussion

The results highlight the importance of greater dissemination of various facts about the management of suicidal patients.

Assessing adherence to guidelines with administrative data in psychiatric outpatients

RATIONALE, AIMS AND OBJECTIVES

To assess (feasibility) of adherence to treatment guidelines among outpatients with common mental disorders in a routine Dutch clinical outpatient setting for common mental disorders using administrative data.

METHODS

In a retrospective cohort study, we analysed routinely collected administrative data of 5346 patients, treated for mood, anxiety or somatoform disorders with pharmacotherapy, psychotherapy or a combination of both. Available administrative data allowed assessment of guideline adherence with a disorder-independent set of five quality indicators, assessing psychotherapy, pharmacotherapy, a combination of both and routine outcome measurements (ROM) during diagnostic and therapeutic phases. Associations between the socio-demographic variables age, gender, clinical diagnosis and treatment type on the one hand and non-adherence to guidelines were tested using logistic regression analysis.

RESULTS

Patients were aged 39.5 years (SD 13.0) on average. The majority of patients were treated with a combination of pharmacotherapy and psychotherapy (50.1%), followed by psychotherapy (44.2%) and pharmacotherapy (5.6%). The majority of patients were suffering from a mood disorder (50.0%), followed by anxiety (43.9%) and somatoform disorders (6.1%). A diagnosis of anxiety or somatoform disorder was associated with higher odds of suboptimal duration [odds ratio (OR): 1.55 and 1.82[ and suboptimal frequency of psychotherapeutic treatment (OR of 0.89 and 0.63), and absence of ROM in the diagnostic phase (ORs 1.31 and 1.36, respectively) compared with depressive disorders. No ROM in the diagnostic phase was also predicted for by increasing age (ORs for the age categories of 56 and older of 1.48).

CONCLUSIONS

In this proof of principal study, we were able to assess some key indicators assessing adherence to clinical guidelines by using administrative data. Also, we could identify predictors of adherence with simple parameters available in every administrative data. Administrative data could help to monitor and aid guideline adherence in routine care, although quality may vary between settings.

Primary care clinician responses to positive suicidal ideation risk assessments in veterans of Iraq and Afghanistan

OBJECTIVE

To examine primary care clinician actions following positive suicide risk assessments administered to Operation Enduring Freedom/Operation Iraqi Freedom (OEF/OIF) veterans.

METHODS

We identified OEF/OIF veterans with positive templated suicide risk assessments administered in primary care settings of three Veterans Affairs (VA) Medical Centers. National VA datasets and manual record review were used to identify and code clinician discussions and actions following positive assessments. Bivariate analyses were used to examine relationships between patient characteristics and discussions of firearms access and alcohol/drug use.

RESULTS

Primary care clinicians documented awareness of suicide risk assessment results for 157 of 199 (79%) patients with positive assessments. Most patients were assessed for mental health conditions and referred for mental health follow-up. Clinicians documented discussions about firearms access for only 15% of patients. Among patients whose clinicians assessed for substance abuse, 34% received recommendations to reduce alcohol or drug use. Depression diagnoses and suicidal ideation/behavior severity were significantly associated with firearms access discussions, while patient sex, military service branch, and substance abuse diagnoses were significantly associated with recommendations to reduce substance use.

CONCLUSION

Greater efforts are needed to understand barriers to clinicians' assessing, documenting and counseling once suicidal ideation is detected, and to develop training programs and systems changes to address these barriers.

Quality of care for major depression and its determinants: a multilevel analysis

BACKGROUND

Numerous studies highlight an important gap in the quality of care for depression in primary care. However, basic indicators were often used. Few of these studies examined factors associated with receiving adequate treatment, particularly with a simultaneous consideration of individual and organizational characteristics. The purpose of this study was to estimate the proportion of primary care patients with a major depressive episode (MDE) who receive adequate treatment and to examine the individual and organizational (i.e., clinic-level) characteristics associated with the receipt of at least one minimally adequate treatment for depression.

METHODS

The sample used for this study included 915 adults consulting a general practitioner (GP), regardless of the motive of consultation, meeting DSM-IV criteria for MDE during the 12 months preceding the survey (T1), and nested within 65 primary care clinics. Data reported in this study were obtained from the "Dialogue" project. Adherence rates for 27 quality indicators selected to cover the most important components of depression treatment were estimated. Multilevel analyses were conducted.

RESULTS

Adherence to guidelines was high (>75%) for one third of the quality indicators that were measured but was low (<60%) for nearly half of the measures. Just over half of the sample (52.2%) received at least one minimally adequate treatment for depression. At the individual level, determinants of receipt of minimally adequate care included age, having a family physician, a supplementary insurance coverage, a comorbid anxiety disorder and the severity of depression. At the clinic level, determinants included the availability of psychotherapy on-site, the use of treatment algorithms, and the mode of remuneration.

CONCLUSIONS

Our findings suggest that interventions are needed to increase the extent to which primary mental health care conforms to evidence-based recommendations. These interventions should target specific populations (i.e. the younger adults and the elderly), enhance accessibility to psychotherapy and to a regular family physician, and support primary care physicians in their clinical practice with patients suffering from depression in different ways such as developing knowledge to treat depression and adapting mode of remuneration.

Physician prescribing patterns of innovative antidepressants in the United States: the case of MDD patients 1993-2007

OBJECTIVE

Innovative antidepressants such as SSRIs and SNRIs have been widely adopted. However, the differences in their adoption across patients' and physicians' characteristics, geographic regions, and insurance status need to be further explored. This study was trying to disentangle the patterns of physician antidepressant prescribing and medication choice for major depressive disorder treatment.

METHOD

A retrospective cross-sectional study was conducted using the 1993-2007 National Ambulatory Medical Care Survey database. A multinomial logistic regression with the Heckman two-step selection procedure was applied to capture the two-step nature of physician prescription decision making.

RESULTS

The weighted logistic regression indicated that patients' race/ethnicity and primary source of payment for services, physician ownership status, and physicians' practice regions were associated with differential likelihood of physician' antidepressant prescribing. Non-Hispanic white patients were more likely to be prescribed antidepressants compared to Hispanic patients (OR = 1.52, 95% CI 1.24-1.87). Physicians' choice on antidepressant varied across with patient age and health insurance status. Compared to private insurance, patients who were primarily covered by Medicare were less likely to be prescribed only SSRIs/SNRIs or other newer antidepressants (RRRs = 0.42 and 0.39; 95% CIs 0.21-0.83 and 0.18-0.84, respectively).

CONCLUSIONS

We observed strong associations between sociological factors and physicians' antidepressant prescribing patterns. Possible health disparities and gaps between optimal and suboptimal healthcare for patient mental health caused by systematic differences in sociological factors need to be mitigated. We need policy makers to design effective policy interventions to improve physician practice guidelines adherence to eliminate possible variations among physician practices.

Age group differences among veterans enrolled in a clinical service for behavioral health issues in primary care

OBJECTIVES

: To examine age group differences in the identification, engagement, clinical outcomes, and monitoring of older, relative to middle aged and younger, veterans with behavioral health needs enrolled in an integrated care management program

DESIGN

: Cross-sectional and longitudinal

SETTING

: Primary care clinics affiliated with two Veterans Affairs Medical Centers

PARTICIPANTS

: A total of 9,087 veterans were referred to the Behavioral Health Laboratory (BHL) for a behavioral health assessment and 7,251 completed an initial assessment

MEASUREMENTS

: Data on consult source and reason for the referral, clinical assessment outcomes, and engagement were collected during a 3-year period. Variations in process and patient-level factors were examined as a function of age group.

RESULTS

: Although all age groups evidenced high rates of engagement in clinical assessment calls, older adults were slightly more likely to complete the assessments than young/middle-aged veterans. Clinical assessment outcomes revealed that although older adults were less likely to meet criteria for more complex, severe conditions, rates of disorder remained clinically significant, and comorbidity was common. Finally, older veterans receiving treatment monitoring for a newly prescribed antide- pressant consistently reported high rates of antidepressant adherence during the course of the monitoring calls and showed significant reductions in depressive symptomatology during the course of monitoring.

CONCLUSIONS

: Results indicate age-related variability in processes and outcomes among veterans referred to the BHL and suggest that older veterans are just as likely to benefit from a program designed to facilitate the identification, engagement, monitoring, and care management of primary care patients experiencing behavioral health issues.

Is major depression adequately diagnosed and treated by general practitioners? Results from an epidemiological study

OBJECTIVES

The aim of this study was to (1) to explore the validity of the depression diagnosis made by the general practitioner (GP) and factors associated with it, (2) to estimate rates of treatment adequacy for depression and factors associated with it and (3) to study how rates of treatment adequacy vary when using different assessment methods and criteria.

METHODS

Epidemiological survey carried out in 77 primary care centres representative of Catalonia. A total of 3815 patients were assessed.

RESULTS

GPs identified 69 out of the 339 individuals who were diagnosed with a major depressive episode according to the Structured Clinical Interview for DSM-IV Axis I Disorders (SCID-I) (sensitivity 0.22; kappa value: 0.16). The presence of emotional problems as the patients' primary complaint was associated with an increased probability of recognition. Rates of adequacy differed according to criteria: in the cases detected with the SCID-I interview, adequacy was 39.35% when using only patient self-reported data and 54.91% when taking into account data from the clinical chart. Rates of adequacy were higher when assessing adequacy among those considered depressed by the GP.

CONCLUSION

GPs adequately treat most of those whom they consider to be depressed. However, they fail to recognise depressed patients when compared to a psychiatric gold standard. Rates of treatment adequacy varied widely depending on the method used to assess them.

Adherence to practice guidelines, clinical outcomes, and costs among Medicaid enrollees with severe mental illnesses

The treatment of Medicaid enrollees diagnosed with depression or schizophrenia was examined to determine whether adherence to treatment guideline was associated with health care financing strategy, clinical outcomes, and cost-effectiveness. Individuals in a fee-for-service condition were significantly more likely to receive treatment consistent with guidelines than those in managed care. Mental health costs were higher for individuals diagnosed with schizophrenia, individuals in an acute phase of illness at intake into the study, and those receiving treatment consistent with practice guidelines. Being in an acute phase of illness and having treatment that comported with recommended practice guidelines were associated with higher total social costs. Policy implications of the findings and recommendations for future research are discussed.

Exploring clinician adoption of a novel evidence request feature in an electronic medical record system

OBJECTIVE

The research evaluated strategies for facilitating physician adoption of an evidence-based medicine literature request feature recently integrated into an existing electronic medical record (EMR) system.

METHODS

This prospective study explored use of the service by 137 primary care physicians by using service usage statistics and focus group and survey components. The frequency of physicians' requests for literature via the EMR during a 10-month period was examined to explore the impact of several enhanced communication strategies launched mid-way through the observation period. A focus group and a 25-item survey explored physicians' experiences with the service.

RESULTS

There was no detectable difference in the proportion of physicians utilizing the service after implementation of the customized communication strategies (11% in each time period, P=1.0, McNemar's test). Forty-eight physicians (35%) responded to the survey. Respondents who had used the service (n=19) indicated that information provided through the service was highly relevant to clinical practice (mean rating 4.6, scale 1 "not relevant"-5 "highly relevant"), and most (n=15) reported sharing the information with colleagues.

CONCLUSION

The enhanced communication strategies, though well received, did not significantly affect use of the service. However, physicians noted the relevance and utility of librarian-summarized evidence from the literature, highlighting the potential benefits of providing expert librarian services in clinical workflow.

Depression treatment preferences of VA primary care patients

The authors identified veterans' depression treatment preferences and explored relationships between preferences, process of care, and clinical outcomes. Patients entering a collaborative depression intervention trial in primary care completed an assessment of treatment preferences. Medical record review was used to identify treatments offered and received over a 12-month period. Of 314 patients, 32% preferred antidepressants; 19%, individual counseling; 18%, anti-depressants plus counseling; 7%, group counseling; and 25%, "watchful waiting." Although the treatment that was offered was associated with treatment preferences, being offered preferred treatment was not associated with receiving treatment or with changes in depression severity or satisfaction over time.

Let's not talk about it: suicide inquiry in primary care

PURPOSE

The purpose of this study was to ascertain physician characteristics associated with exploring suicidality in patients with depressive symptoms and the influence of patient antidepressant requests.

METHODS

Primary care physicians were randomly recruited from 4 sites in northern California and Rochester, NY; 152 physicians participated (53%-61% of those approached). Standardized patients portraying 2 conditions (major depression and adjustment disorder) and 3 antidepressant request types (brand specific, general, or none) made unannounced visits to these physicians between May 2003 and May 2004. We examined factors associated with physician exploration of suicidality.

RESULTS

Suicide was explored in 36% of 298 encounters. Exploration was more common when the patient portrayed major depression (vs adjustment disorder) (P = .03), with an antidepressant request (vs no request) (P=.02), in academic settings (P <.01), and among physicians with personal experience with depression (P <.01). The random effects logistic model revealed a significant physician variance component with rho = 0.57 (95% confidence interval, 0.45-0.68) indicating that there were additional, unspecified physician factors determining the tendency to explore suicide risk. These factors are unrelated to physician specialty (family medicine or internal medicine), sex, communication style, or perceived barriers to or confidence in treating depression.

CONCLUSIONS

When seeing patients with depressive symptoms, primary care physicians do not consistently inquire about suicidality. Their inquiries into suicidal thinking may be enhanced through advertising or public service messaging that prompts patients to ask for help. Research is needed to further elucidate physician characteristics associated with the assessment of suicidality.

Do Patient Requests for Antidepressants Enhance or Hinder Physicians’ Evaluation of Depression?

OBJECTIVE

We sought to ascertain whether patients' requests for antidepressants affect visit duration or history taking by primary care physicians (PCPs) for patients with depressive symptoms and a coexisting musculoskeletal disorder and to determine whether more thorough history taking is associated with diagnostic accuracy or with provision of minimally acceptable initial care for major depression.

DESIGN

This was a randomized trial using standardized patients (SPs). Six roles involved 2 conditions (major depression and adjustment disorder, both with coexisting musculoskeletal conditions) and 3 patient request types (brand-specific, general, or none). We conducted the study in 152 PCP offices in Northern California and Rochester, New York. Physicians were assigned randomly to see 2 SPs with depression/wrist pain or adjustment disorder/back pain.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Physician history-taking for depression and the musculoskeletal condition; depression diagnosis in the medical record; antidepressant prescriptions/samples; referral/follow-up recommendations; visit duration; and provision of minimally acceptable initial depression care.

RESULTS

General antidepressant requests were associated with more depression history-taking (Adjusted Parameter Estimate = 0.80 more questions of 10 (95% confidence interval = 0.31-1.29, P < 0.001); brand-specific requests were marginally associated with more depression history-taking (Adjusted Parameter Estimate = 0.45, 95% confidence interval = -0.04-0.93, P = 0.07). Antidepressant medication requests were not related to musculo-skeletal question asking (P > 0.3) or visit length (P > 0.8). Depression history taking was directly associated with the likelihood of a chart diagnosis of depression and the provision of minimally acceptable initial depression care.

CONCLUSION

General antidepressant requests increase depression history taking, including screening for suicide. Patients' requests for medication do not appear to short-circuit history taking for depression or distract the physician's attention from coexisting musculoskeletal conditions.

Inadequate follow-up care for depression and its impact on antidepressant treatment duration among veterans with and without diabetes mellitus in the Veterans Health Administration

OBJECTIVE

Our objective was to describe the adequacy of follow-up care for depression and its association with antidepressant treatment duration among veterans with and without diabetes mellitus (DM).

METHOD

This was a retrospective study (1997-2005) of 2178 veterans (33% with DM) in a Midwestern Veterans Health Administration facility who had a new episode of unipolar depression. Adequate follow-up care was defined by a health care visit within 7 and 14 days, and >/=3 visits following antidepressant treatment initiation. Adequate treatment duration was defined by a medication possession ratio of >/=80%. Multivariate logistic regression was used to calculate odds ratios (ORs) adjusted for demographic, clinical and health care utilization characteristics.

RESULTS

Only 27% received >/=3 follow-up visits within 12 weeks, and <23% received follow-up within 2 weeks of antidepressant initiation. Subjects with DM were 1.36-fold more likely [95% confidence interval (95% CI)=1.05-1.75] to have received >/=3 visits but were similarly likely to have received follow-up within 7 days (OR=1.02; 95% CI=0.74-1.41) or 14 days (OR=1.08; 95% CI=0.83-1.40) of antidepressant initiation. Adequate follow-up care was the most important predictor of adequate treatment duration (OR=2.10; 95% CI=1.54-2.88).

CONCLUSION

DM had little influence on the adequacy of follow-up care for depression, with few exceptions. Follow-up care for depression is underutilized and has a significant impact on antidepressant treatment duration. Strategies to more effectively manage depression treatment are required.

Validation of 2 depression screening tools in dialysis patients

BACKGROUND

Depression is the most common psychiatric disorder in long-term dialysis patients and is a risk factor for morbidity and mortality. An efficient and valid method of diagnosing depression might facilitate recognition and treatment. We sought to validate 2 depression assessment tools, the 21-question Beck Depression Inventory (BDI) and the 9-question Patient Health Questionnaire (PHQ-9), in a dialysis population.

METHODS

We surveyed patients who had received dialysis for at least 90 days in Portland, OR. We excluded patients with dementia, delirium, or a history of major psychiatric disorders other than depression. The Structured Clinical Interview for Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, Fourth Edition, a gold-standard measure for depression, was administered by trained psychologists within 2 weeks of the BDI and PHQ-9.

RESULTS

Of 62 enrolled subjects, 16 were diagnosed with a depressive disorder, including 12 patients (19%) with major depression, 3 patients with dysthymia, and 1 patient with minor depression. Optimal BDI and PHQ-9 cutoff values for depressive disorders combined was 16 or greater and 10 or greater, respectively. Sensitivities were 91% and 92%, specificities were 86% and 92%, positive predictive values were 59% and 71%, and negative predictive values were both 98%, with kappa values of 0.65 and 0.75, respectively. The difference between the 2 receiver operating characteristic curves was not statistically significant (P > 0.9).

CONCLUSION

Our results validate the PHQ-9 and revalidate the BDI against a gold-standard measure for depressive disorders in the dialysis population. Both tools performed equally well. Because depression is prevalent, readily diagnosed, and associated with poor outcomes, screening by means of short and valid measurement tools may lead to better diagnosis and treatment of this modifiable risk factor. This may lead to improved clinical outcomes in dialysis patients.