Clonal evolution from trisomy into tetrasomy of chromosome 8 associated with the development of acute myeloid leukemia from myelodysplastic syndrome

A case of acute myeloid leukemia (AML) with an unreported combination of chromosomal abnormalities: gain of isochromosome 5p, tetrasomy 8 and unbalanced translocation der(19)t(17;19)(q23;p13)

BACKGROUND

Acute myeloid leukemia (AML) comprises a spectrum of myeloid malignancies which are often associated with distinct chromosomal abnormalities, and the analysis of such abnormalities provides us with important information for disease classification, treatment selection and prognosis. Some chromosomal abnormalities albeit recurrent are rare such as tetrasomy 8 or isochromosome 5p. In addition, erratic chromosomal rearrangements may occur in AML, sometimes unbalanced and also accompanied by other abnormalities. Knowledge on the contribution of rare abnormalities to AML disease, progression and prognosis is limited.Here we report a unique case of acute monoblastic leukemia with gain of i(5)(p10), tetrasomy 8, an unbalanced translocation der(19)t(17;19)(q23;p13.3) and mutated NPM1.

RESULTS

Bone marrow cells were examined by conventional karyotyping, fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) and mutation analysis at diagnosis and follow-up. At diagnosis we detected trisomy 8, an unbalanced translocation der(19)t(17;19)(q23;p13.3) and mutated NPM1. During the course of the disease we observed clonal evolution with gain of i(5)(p10), tetrasomy 8 and eventually duplication of der(19)t(17;19)(q23;p13.3). By using the der(19)t(17;19) as clonal marker, we found that i(5)(p10) and tetrasomy 8 were secondary genetic events and that tetrasomy 8 had clonally evolved from trisomy 8.

CONCLUSIONS

This case of acute monoblastic leukemia presents a combination of rare chromosomal abnormalities including the unbalanced translocation der(19)t(17;19)(q23;p13.3), hitherto un-reported in AML. In addition, our case supports the hypothesis of a step-wise clonal evolution from trisomy 8 to tetrasomy 8 in AML. Reporting and collecting data of rare chromosomal abnormalities will add information to AML disease, progression and prognosis, and may eventually translate to improved patient management.

Trisomy 8 in leukemia: A GCRI experience

Trisomy of chromosome 8 is frequently reported in myeloid lineage disorders and also detected in lymphoid neoplasms as well as solid tumors suggesting its role in neoplastic progression in general. It is likely to be a disease-modulating secondary event with underlying cryptic aberrations as it has been frequently reported in addition to known abnormalities contributing to clinical heterogeneity and modifying prognosis. Here, we share our findings of trisomy 8 in leukemia patients referred for diagnostic and prognostic cytogenetic assessment. Total 60 cases of trisomy 8, as a sole anomaly or in addition to other chromosomal aberrations, were reported (January 2005–September 2008). Unstimulated bone marrow or blood samples were cultured, followed by GTG banding and karyotyping as per the ISCN 2005. Patients with +8 were chronic myeloid leukemia (CML) (36), acute myeloid leukemia (AML) (17), and acute lymphoblastic leukemia (ALL) (7). In 7 patients, trisomy 8 was the sole anomaly, whereas in 6 patients +8 was in addition to normal clone, in 47 patients, the +8 was in addition to t(9;22), t(15;17), and others, including 3 with tetrasomy 8. Only one patient showed constitutional +8. The present study will form the basis of further cumulative studies to correlate potential differential effects of various karyotypic anomalies on disease progression and survival following a therapeutic regime. To unravel the role of extra 8 chromosome, constitutional chromosomal analysis and uniparental disomy will be considered.

Depletion of cytotoxic T-cells does not protect NUP98-HOXD13 mice from myelodysplastic syndrome but reveals a modest tumor immunosurveillance effect

Myelodysplastic syndrome (MDS) and aplastic anemia (AA) patients both present with symptoms of bone marrow failure. In many AA patients, these features are thought to result from an oligoclonal expansion of cytotoxic T-cells that destroy haematopoietic stem or progenitor cells. This notion is supported by the observation that AA patients respond to immunosuppressive therapy. A fraction of MDS patients also respond well to immunosuppressive therapy suggesting a similar role for cytotoxic T-cells in the etiology of MDS, however the role of cytotoxic T-cells in MDS remains unclear. Mice that express a NUP98-HOXD13 (NHD13) transgene develop a MDS that closely mimics the human condition in terms of dysplasia, ineffective hematopoiesis, and transformation to acute myeloid leukemia (AML). We followed a cohort of NHD13 mice lacking the Rag1 protein (NHD13/Rag1KO) to determine if the absence of lymphocytes might 1) delay the onset and/or diminish the severity of the MDS, or 2) effect malignant transformation and survival of the NHD13 mice. No difference was seen in the onset or severity of MDS between the NHD13 and NHD13/Rag1KO mice. However, NHD13/Rag1KO mice had decreased survival and showed a trend toward increased incidence of transformation to AML compared to the NHD13 mice, suggesting protection from AML transformation by a modest immuno-surveillance effect. In the absence of functional Tcrb signaling in the NHD13/Rag1KO T-cell tumors, Pak7 was identified as a potential Tcrb surrogate survival signal.

Tetrasomy 8 in a patient with acute monoblastic leukemia

Trisomy 8 is one of the most frequent numerical chromosomal abnormalities observed in hematological malignancies, whereas tetrasomy 8 is a clonal aberration seen mainly in myeloid disorders such as acute myelod leukemia (AML) and myelodysplastic syndromes. In contrast to trisomy 8, tetrasomy 8 is a rare chromosomal aberration, in that only 17 reported AML cases with isolated tetrasomy 8 have been documented. Interestingly, the majority of reported cases were associated with monocytic-lineage leukemias. According to recent reports, tetrasomy 8 is regarded as a poor prognostic factor, and most patients having this abnormality relapsed and died within 1 yr. Here, we report a patient with acute monoblastic leukemia having tetrasomy 8 and a very aggressive disease course.

Acute myelogenous leukemia with tetrasomy 8 is a disease with a poor prognosis

Tetrasomy 8 is an extremely rare chromosome abnormality, one that has been reported in only a few cases with myeloid malignancies. The majority of reported cases consist of acute myelogenous leukemias (AML) of monocytic lineage. In slightly more than half of the patients, tetrasomy 8 was the single cytogenetic abnormality. Fluorescence in situ hybridization revealed tetrasomy 8 and trisomy 8 concurrently in all but one of the bone marrow samples. The clonal relationship between trisomy 8 and tetrasomy 8 in these cases remains to be clarified. Patients with tetrasomy 8 have a poor prognosis, and only 1 out of 33 patients was free of disease 3 years after autologous bone marrow transplantation. Here, we report the case of a 25-year-old female patient with monocytic leukemia and tetrasomy 8.

Polysomy 8 defines a clinico-cytogenetic entity representing a subset of myeloid hematologic malignancies associated with a poor prognosis: report on a cohort of 12 patients and review of 105 published cases

Tetrasomy, pentasomy, and hexasomy 8 (polysomy 8) are relatively rare compared to trisomy 8. Here we report on a series of 12 patients with acute myeloid leukemia (AML), myelodysplastic syndrome (MDS), or myeloproliferative disorder (MPD) associated with polysomy 8 as detected by conventional cytogenetics and fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH). In an attempt to better characterize the clinical and hematological profile of this cytogenetic entity, our data were combined with those of 105 published patients. Tetrasomy 8 was the most common presentation of polysomy 8. In 60.7% of patients, polysomy 8 occurred as part of complex changes (16.2% with 11q23 rearrangements). No cryptic MLL rearrangements were found in cases in which polysomy 8 was the only karyotypic change. Our study demonstrates the existence of a polysomy 8 syndrome, which represents a subtype of AML, MDS, and MPD characterized by a high incidence of secondary diseases, myelomonocytic or monocytic involvement in AML and poor overall survival (6 months). Age significantly reduced median survival, but associated cytogenetic abnormalities did not modify it. Cytogenetic results further demonstrate an in vitro preferential growth of the cells with a high level of aneuploidy suggesting a selective advantage for polysomy 8 cells.

Possibility of the diagnosis of subacute myeloid leukemia for a group of patients with trisomy 8: a report of 34 cases

The term subacute myeloid leukemia is not present in most hematologic textbooks, but clinically the disease does exist. During the past 13 years, 34 patients with trisomy 8 (+8) and previous diagnoses of refractory anemia with excess blasts in myelodysplastic syndromes were followed and studied in our institute. None of the patients had been given cytotoxic drugs before the leukemia became apparent. Eighteen patients (52.9%) had a history of 3 months to more than 20 years before cytogenetic detection of +8. Abnormalities of blood cell counts were seen in 1 to 3 cell lines, with a median blast cell percentage in the bone marrow of 8% (range, 5%-19%). At a median follow-up period of 21.5 months (range, 3-129 months), the median overall survival time was 20 months for all of the patients with +8, including the patients with chromosome abnormalities in addition to +8. In the group with +8 only, 11 (45.8%) of the 24 patients developed frank leukemia, and 9 of these 11 patients died. In conclusion, our results showed that this group of +8 patients had multilineage abnormalities in blood cell counts and increased numbers of blasts in the bone marrow. The diseases of these patients manifested an insidious onset and a subacute but progressive clinical course, and they all had cytogenetic clonal changes with +8. These facts suggest that this group of +8 patients all had evidence of a leukemic clone, and their conditions might conform to the diagnosis of subacute myeloid leukemia.

Pathogenesis, classification, and treatment of myelodysplastic syndromes (MDS)

Myelodysplastic syndromes (MDS) comprise a heterogeneous group of clonal myeloid disorders characterized by morphologic dysplasia in one or more cell lineages. Dysplasia in MDS is associated with insufficient production of blood cells and consecutive cytopenia(s). The natural course and prognosis of MDS vary among patients and depend on genetic defects that occur during clonal evolution. In a significant group of patients (roughly 30%) progression to secondary leukemia is observed. These patients appear to have a grave prognosis. The treatment of patients with MDS has to be adjusted to the individual situation and age in each case. In many patients, control of blast cell production by palliative cytoreduction, continuous support with red blood cells, as well as other supportive measures, seem appropriate. In other patients, however, curative therapy (chemotherapy, stem cell transplantation) should be considered. The final decision to offer curative therapy must be based on many different factors including age and the overall situation of the patient. Recently established scoring systems aimed at predicting survival and evolution of leukemia in MDS may be helpful in this regard.

[Chromosomal abnormalities in acute myeloid leukaemias]

Cytogenetic studies of acute myeloid leukaemias reveal non-random chromosomal abnormalities in 50-70% of karyotypes. Some are correlated with morphological and immunological parameters and constitute a prognostic factor independent of the other factors of risk: favourable for acute leukaemias myeloid with translocations t(8;21), t(15;17) and inversion or translocation of the chromosome 16, inv(16)/t(16;16), poor with deletion of the long arm of chromosome 5 del(5q), rearrangement of the 11q23 region and complex karyotypes. The distribution of the anomalies depends on the age: 11q23 and t(8;21) more frequent for the child, del(5q) and complex anomalies more frequent for the adult. The karyotypes are essential for the diagnosis, the follow-up of the patients and the evaluation of the relapse. It plays a fundamental part in the detection of new genes and their partners implied in the leucemogenese. The knowledge of their function is essential to open new therapeutic ways.

Pentasomy 8q in therapy-related myelodysplastic syndrome due to cyclophosphamide therapy for fibrosing alveolitis

Trisomy 8/8q is a common cytogenetic event in myelocytic malignancies, ranging from myelodysplastic syndrome (MDS) to acute myelocytic leukemia (AML) to blastic transformation of chronic myelocytic leukemia. Isochromosome 8q results in the same gene dosage effect. Duplication of i(8q), resulting in pentasomy 8q, has been reported only in two cases of AML. A patient with fibrosing alveolitis on prolonged cyclophosphamide treatment developed therapy-related MDS. Karyotyping, FISH, and CGH analysis showed a duplicated i(8q) among other complex abnormalities. The clinical features of 11 cases of myelocytic leukemia with pentasomy and hexasomy 8/8q were summarized. Compared with trisomy and tetrasomy 8, significant features included reduced median survival (90 days), treatment refractoriness (even with transplantation), monocytic differentiation, trilineage dysplasia, and radiation or toxin exposure. Increasing copy numbers of chromosome 8/8q may therefore be a marker of advanced leukemic evolution, exposure to toxins, underlying myelodysplasia, and an overall poor prognosis.