Genetic aberrations in pediatric acute lymphoblastic leukemia by comparative genomic hybridization

Karyotyping, FISH, and PCR in acute lymphoblastic leukemia: competing or complementary diagnostics?

BACKGROUND

Chromosomal abnormalities, such as t(9;22)(q34;q11) (ABL/BCR), t(12;21)(p13;q22) (TEL/AML1), and t(11q23) (MLL) are independent prognostic indicators in childhood acute lymphoblastic leukemia resulting in risk adapted therapy. Accurate and rapid detection of these abnormalities is mandatory, which is achieved by karyotyping, fluorescence in situ hybridization, and real time quantitative reverse transcriptase polymerase chain reaction (RQ-PCR). For cost-effective diagnostic approaches knowledge of diagnostic accuracy of these tests is required. Therefore, we aimed to determine the diagnostic accuracy of karyotyping, fluorescence in situ hybridization, and RQ-PCR analysis.

PROCEDURE

Retrospective study conducted between January 1, 1992 and January 1, 2007 in the Emma Children Hospital in Amsterdam. All consecutive patients under 18 years with acute lymphoblastic leukaemia were included. Diagnostic tests were performed according to international standards.

RESULTS

Diagnostic techniques show a high-reciprocal agreement and have a high-individual diagnostic accuracy in detecting the above-mentioned chromosomal translocations. However, the sensitivity of karyotyping for detecting the TEL-AML1 fusion gene and the sensitivity of RQ-PCR for detecting MLL-rearrangements was rather low.

CONCLUSIONS

Diagnostic accuracy of tests for detecting t(9;22), t(12;21), and t(11q23) is generally high, although sensitivity is not optimal for all anomalies. Despite the high-diagnostic accuracy, all diagnostic techniques should be used complementary, because any detection of a (significant) chromosomal aberration irrespective of diagnostic mode has to be considered in therapy.

Prognostic value of structural chromosomal rearrangements and small cell clones with high hyperdiploidy in children with acute lymphoblastic leukemia

In this study, 107 children with acute lymphoblastic leukemia (ALL) were analysed for the presence of hyperdiploidy by cytogenetics and interphase fluorescence in situ hybridisation (I-FISH). Structural aberrations in hyperdiploid cells were investigated by multiple colour FISH (mFISH). Clones with high hyperdiploidy (>50 chromosomes) (HeH) were found in 46 patients (43%). In nine of these (20%), the abnormal clone was present in <20% of the total cell population. There was no significant difference in EFS between those patients with HeH in 2.5-20% or >20% of cells. Structural rearrangements in the HeH clone were found in 10 patients (22%). In this study, HeH karyotypes containing structural aberrations were an indication of a poor prognosis in childhood ALL.

A strategy to detect chromosomal abnormalities in children with acute lymphoblastic leukemia

Conventional cytogenetics (CC) can be used to identify chromosomal abnormalities that are predictors of treatment outcome in acute lymphoblastic leukemia (ALL). The detection of abnormalities in ALL is difficult because low mitotic index and poor-quality metaphases are obtained. Flow cytometry (FC) and fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) can be used to detect aneuploidy in any phase of the cell cycle, increasing the number of analyzable cells. The aim of this study was to develop a strategy combining these methods to improve the frequency of chromosome abnormality detection. One hundred children with newly diagnosed ALL were included. CC and DNA content analysis by FC were performed in all patients. The numerical abnormalities identified by both methods were compared and patients were classified as concordant or discordant. FISH was used to support aneuploidy results in discrepant cases using centromeric probes for the chromosomes most frequently involved in aneuploidy. CC and FC showed high concordance (86%). Fourteen cases were discrepant: nine showed hypodiploidy and low hyperdiploidy by cytogenetics and five showed high hyperdiploidy by FC. FISH confirmed aneuploidy in 12 cases in which it could be performed. High hyperdiploidy was the most common abnormality; the 31 cases showing this aneuploidy were identified by FC. The search for abnormalities must begin by measuring DNA content to detect this aneuploidy, which is useful to evaluate the patient's risk. However, it is important to screen for structural abnormalities by CC or molecular techniques. This strategy may detect chromosomal abnormalities, optimizing resources in laboratories where not all the screening methods are available.

Preponderant mitotic activity of nonleukemic cells plays an important role in failures to detect abnormal clone in childhood acute lymphoblastic leukemia

At diagnosis, clonal chromosomal abnormalities are found in the bone marrow blasts in more than two thirds of children with acute lymphoblastic leukemia (ALL). Practically, however, failure to detect these abnormalities is frequent and usually attributed to poor marrow sampling, inadequate metaphases, and/or a preponderant mitotic activity among nonleukemic cells. The authors applied fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) techniques to re-examine 30 cases of karyotypically "normal" childhood ALL to explore the role of preponderant mitotic activities of nonleukemic cells in failures to detect clonal abnormalities. The FISH test were performed using TEL/AML1 fusion gene probe and the centromere probes for chromosome 8 and 10 to detect the t(12;21) translocation and/or hyperdiploidy. Half of the karyotypically "normal" ALL cases examined have been found to have abnormal clones with t(12;21) rearrangement and/or hyperdiploidy by this specially designed FISH assay. Contrary to expectation, the authors found a higher incidence (52%) of clonal abnormalities in cases where over 20 metaphases had been examined than in cases (44%) where fewer than 20 metaphases had been analyzed. These findings suggest that a preponderant mitotic activity of nonleukemic cells plays an important role in failures to detect an abnormal clone by conventional cytogenetic studies. Therefore, karyotypically "normal" childhood ALL patients should undergo FISH studies to rule out the presence of t(12;21) and/or hyperdiploid clone.

High-resolution comparative genomic hybridisation yields a high detection rate of chromosomal aberrations in childhood acute lymphoblastic leukaemia

BACKGROUND

Cytogenetic aberrations are of prognostic significance in childhood acute lymphoblastic leukaemias and a high detection rate could improve the biological understanding and classification of these diseases.

METHODS

Bone-marrow samples from 92 children with acute lymphoblastic leukaemia were studied by high-resolution comparative genomic hybridisation (HRCGH) using dynamic standard reference intervals that enhance both specificity and sensitivity in the detection of aberrations.

RESULTS

In 80 patients (87%) HRCGH revealed a total of 405 aberrations, mostly whole chromosome gains (n = 265) and partial losses (n = 80). The 25 leukaemias with a gain of more than five whole chromosomes by HRCGH harboured only 7% of all losses. With G-band karyotyping 59 patients (64%) had aberrations. HRCGH revealed more aberrations per patient than did G-band karyotyping (median: 3 vs. 1, P = 0.005), revealed aberrations in 27 of the 34 patients for whom the G-band karyotyping failed or was found to be normal, and specifically revealed more 9p losses (21% vs. 5%, P < 0.005), 12p losses (12% vs. 2%, P < 0.05) and 17q gains (11% vs. 1%, P < 0.01). Compared to the present study, the frequency of patients with aberrant karyotypes was significantly lower in previous conventional CGH studies (64% vs. 87%, P < 0.0001), as was the rate of partial aberrations per patient (1.1% vs. 1.7, P < 0.001), particularly with fewer 6q losses, 9p losses and 17q gains detected.

CONCLUSION

HRCGH is superior to conventional CGH as an adjunct to G-band karyotyping as it detects recurrent aberrations at a significantly higher rate than both these techniques.

Compilation of published comparative genomic hybridization studies

The power of comparative genomic hybridization (CGH) has been clearly proven since the first paper appeared in 1992 as a tool to characterize chromosomal imbalances in neoplasias. This review summarizes the chromosomal imbalances detected by CGH in solid tumors and in hemopathies. In May of 2001, we took a census of 430 articles providing information on 11,984 cases of human solid tumors or hematologic malignancies. Comparative generic hybridization has detected a number of recurrent regions of amplification or deletion that allows for identification of new chromosomal loci (oncogenes, tumor suppressor genes, or other genes) involved in the development, progression, and clonal evolution of tumors. When CGH data from different studies are combined, a pattern of nonrandom genetic aberrations appears. As expected, some of these gains and losses are common to different types of pathologies, while others are more tumor-specific.

Loss at 12p detected by comparative genomic hybridization (CGH): association with TEL-AML1 fusion and favorable prognostic features in childhood acute lymphoblastic leukemia (ALL). A multi-institutional study

BACKGROUND

Genetic aberrations provide prognostic information in childhood ALL. The proportion of patients with detectable aberrations can be increased by combining G-banding with comparative genomic hybridization (CGH).

PROCEDURE

We studied 79 children with ALL by CGH and G-banding, and explored the relationship of these findings to clinical features and outcome.

RESULTS

CGH revealed DNA copy number changes in 57 patients (72%), 9 of whom had normal karyotype by G-banding. Gains were more frequent than losses, and changes of whole chromosomes more frequent than partial aberrations. Two frequent partial losses were found; at 9p and 12p. The 9 patients with loss at 12p were studied for the deletion of TEL (ETV6) gene and the fusion of TEL and AML1 genes by fluorescent in situ hybridization (FISH). Eight out of the 9 children with loss at 12p harbored the TEL-AML1 translocation and all 9 had the deletion of a nontranslocated TEL allele. All 9 had precursor-B phenotype and L1 morphology, and 8/9 had WBC below 50 x 10(9)/liter. All children were treated according to Nordic ALL protocols, had a good response to treatment based on day 15 bone marrow morphology, and 7 out of the 9 survived in continuous complete remission (median follow-up 74 months).

CONCLUSIONS

CGH is a valuable tool in screening for genetic aberrations in childhood ALL. DNA copy number losses detected at 12p associate with TEL-AML1 fusion as well as with favorable prognostic features.

Identification of numerical and structural chromosome aberrations in 15 high hyperdiploid childhood acute lymphoblastic leukemias using spectral karyotyping

Spectral karyotyping (SKY) on metaphase spreads from 15 high hyperdiploid (>51 chromosomes) childhood acute lymphoblastic leukemias (ALL), which typically display a poor chromosome morphology, was performed in order to investigate the pattern of numerical abnormalities, reveal the chromosomal origin of marker chromosomes, and identify translocations and other interchromosomal rearrangements not detected by G-banding analysis. In all cases the numerical changes could be fully characterized, and a non-random pattern of chromosomal gain was identified, with chromosomes X, 21, 14, 17, 6, 18, 4, and 10 being most frequently gained. The numerical changes had been partly misinterpreted in 12 of the 15 ALL patients using G-banding, and the present study hence emphasizes the importance of SKY in identifying such anomalies, some of which, i.e. +4 and +10, have been suggested to be prognostically important. The chromosomal origin of all marker chromosomes and of seven structural rearrangements, one of which was the prognostically important Philadelphia chromosome, could be identified. Five rearrangements [der(1)t(1;14)(q32;q21), der(2)t(2;8)(q36;?), der(3)t(2;3)(q21;?), der(8)t(8;14)(?;?), and t(9;21)(q12;q22)] have previously not been reported in ALL, emphasizing the value of SKY in identifying novel chromosomal rearrangements.

Reassessment of childhood B-lineage lymphoblastic leukemia karyotypes using spectral analysis

We studied a stratified cohort of 51 childhood B-lineage acute lymphoblastic leukemias (B-ALLs) to evaluate the efficiency of spectral karyotyping (SKY) in the detection of chromosome aberrations previously diagnosed using chromosome banding and/or reverse transcriptase polymerase chain reaction. Despite the small number of cases analyzed, several important features emerge from the study: (a) The result of banding analysis was revised in two-thirds of the cases. Eighty-three chromosome anomalies previously undetected or not characterized using chromosome banding were identified by spectral karyotyping, even in patients with apparently normal karyotypes. (b) All hyperdiploidy cases showed one or more extra copies of chromosomes X, 14, and 21. (c) Two hidden rearrangements, a t(7;12)(?p12;p13), and a new translocation, a t(9;12)(q31;p13), both involving the TEL gene, were characterized. (d) Some cryptic rearrangements, such as the der(21) t(12;21) translocation, remained undetected. (e) No new recurrent chromosome anomalies were discovered with this technique. In conclusion, the present study confirms the efficiency of the SKY technique in resolving and characterizing many complex chromosome anomalies seen in childhood B-ALLs, but it raises questions about the ability of this technique to detect cryptic rearrangements, such as the t(12;21) translocation.

Comparative genomic hybridization study of de novo myeloid neoplasia

Comparative genomic hybridization (CGH) was used to detect chromosomal imbalances in 20 patients with a diagnosis of myelodysplastic syndrome (MDS) and acute myeloid leukaemia (AML). The results obtained were compared with G-banding analysis. This last methodology showed 50% of cases with clonal abnormalities whereas CGH detected 70% of cases with copy number changes. Gains were more frequent than losses and constituted 66% of total changes detected. The most common gains included chromosomes 21 and chromosome region 18p for AML and chromosome 17 and region 1p33p35 for MDS. Losses represent 34% of changes and the regions involved were 5q31q32, 7q22, 7p12 and 13q21q22. CGH revealed additional chromosome imbalances in 12 of 20 cases (60%) which were not detected by traditional cytogenetic studies, demonstrating complex karyotype in 50% (6/12). Combination of CGH and G-banding provides an efficient method to identify critical regions present in the malignant clone, which is of great value in the prognosis and outcome of myeloid neoplasias.

Comparative genomic hybridization in childhood acute lymphoblastic leukemia: correlation with interphase cytogenetics and loss of heterozygosity analysis

We used comparative genomic hybridization (CGH) to study DNA copy number changes in 71 children with acute lymphoblastic leukemia (ALL) including 50 B-lineage and 21 T-ALLs. Forty-two patients (59%) showed genomic imbalances whereby gains were more frequently observed than losses (127 vs. 29). Gains most commonly affected the entire chromosomes 21 and 10 (19.7% each), 6, 14, 18, X (15.5% each), 17 (14.1%) and 4 (11.3%). Highly hyperdiploid karyotypes (chromosome number >50) occurred more frequently in B-lineage than in T-lineage ALL (24% vs. 4.8%). In both cell lineages deletions were mainly detected on 9p (14.1%) and 12p (8.4%), and on 6q in T-lineage ALL (4.2%). These findings were compared with loss of heterozygosity (LOH) of 6q, 9p, 11q, and 12p previously performed in 56 of the 71 patients. Among 54 sites of LOH, CGH revealed losses of the respective chromosome arms in 17 LOH-positive regions (31.5%). G-banding analysis and interphase cytogenetics with subregional probes for 14 loci confirmed the presence of genomic imbalances as detected by CGH. We, therefore, conclude that, in the absence of cytogenetic data, CGH represents a suitable method for identifying hyperdiploid karyotypes as well as prognostically relevant deletions in ALL patients.

Comparative genomic hybridization-aided unraveling of complex karyotypes in human hematopoietic neoplasias

The information obtained by conventional cytogenetics (CC) in human leukemias is sometimes limited, in particular by complex karyotypes with many marker chromosomes. While CC is restricted to metaphases with a good quality, interphase fluorescence in situ hybridization (I-FISH) is also capable of analyzing specific anomalies in the interphase nuclei. Comparative genomic hybridization (CGH) gives additional information about the imbalanced karyotype changes in the whole genome. The aim of this study was to assess the contribution of CGH to the unraveling of complex GTG karyotypes, which are difficult to evaluate by banding analysis, and to compare these results with those by CC and FISH. Thirteen bone marrow samples and one sample obtained from peripheral blood of 13 leukemia patients were examined by CC, FISH and CGH. The GTG banding analysis showed complex karyotypes with many marker chromosomes. The most frequent abnormalities were numerical and structural aberrations on chromosomes 5 and 7. In 12 of the 14 samples, the CGH analysis was able to detect chromosomal imbalances with losses of material on chromosome 5 and 7 as the most frequent aberrations. In all 14 samples, additional FISH analyses were performed. For most of the studied neoplasias, a close correlation between CC, FISH and CGH data was observed. CGH was considerably helpful in adding additional information to classical karyotyping, if the low quality or number of metaphases was insufficient for a reliable CC analysis. Even in cases where whole chromosome painting could be applied, it added information on the breakpoints of the observed rearrangements. In only 2 of the studied 14 samples, neither CGH nor I-FISH could improve the result of karyotyping. CGH, nevertheless, can be regarded as a powerful additional technique in leukemias with unsuccessful CC, incomplete, or complex karyotypes with many marker chromosomes. A systematic analysis by three techniques such as CC, FISH and CGH guarantees an optimal genetic characterization of the neoplasias.

Importance of using comparative genomic hybridization to improve detection of chromosomal changes in childhood acute lymphoblastic leukemia

We used comparative genomic hybridization (CGH) and conventional cytogenetics (CC) to define chromosomal changes and to evaluate the usefulness of CGH in 65 patients having childhood acute lymphoblastic leukemia (ALL). Subsequently, fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) was used to evaluate the CGH and cytogenetic results. Comparative genomic hybridization revealed DNA copy number changes in 49 (75%) patients (including 7 patients with unsuccessful cytogenetics and 2 patients with normal karyotype). A total of 85 losses and 195 gains were detected. The most commonly gained chromosomes were 21 (35%), X (31%), 18 (27%), 10 (26%), 6 (25%), 17 (25%), 4 (23%), and 14 (22%). Losses were most frequently observed on chromosomes 9p (18%) and 12p (11%). Other losses were detected on chromosomes 13q (9%), 6q (9%), 7p (8%), and chromosome X (6%). Conventional cytogenetics revealed chromosomal changes in 53 (82%) patients. The employment of CGH and FISH together with CC analysis revealed chromosomal changes in 62 (95%) of the childhood ALL patients investigated. The CGH completed CC results in 36 patients; in 9 patients, the changes escaped detection without using CGH. The results of our study were compared to 6 other CGH studies previously reported. Our observations underline the benefits of supplementing routine cytogenetic investigation in childhood ALL by FISH and CGH, because small unbalanced changes may escape detection when conventional cytogenetics is the only diagnostic method used.

Comparative genomic hybridization: uses and limitations

Comparative genomic hybridization (CGH) has contributed significantly to the current knowledge of genomic alterations in hematologic malignancies. Characteristic patterns of genomic imbalances not only have confirmed recent classification schemes in non-Hodgkin's lymphoma, but they provide a basis for the successful identification of genes with previously unrecognized pathogenic roles in the development of different lymphomas. Based on its technical limitations, there is little reason to apply CGH to chromosomes of metaphase cells in routine diagnostic settings. However, the new approach of CGH to DNA microarrays, a procedure termed matrix-CGH, overcomes most of the limitations and opens new approaches for diagnostics and identification of genetically defined leukemia and lymphoma subgroups. Current efforts to develop leukemia specific matrix-CGH DNA chips, which are designed to meet the clinical needs, are presented and discussed.

Cytogenetic analysis from DNA by comparative genomic hybridization

Comparative genomic hybridization (CGH) is a modified in situ hybridization technique which allows detection and mapping of DNA sequence copy differences between two genomes in a single experiment. In CGH analysis, two differentially labelled genomic DNA (study and reference) are co-hybridized to normal metaphase spreads. Chromosomal locations of copy number changes in the DNA segments of the study genome are revealed by a variable fluorescence intensity ratio along each target chromosome. Since its development, CGH has been applied mostly as a research tool in the field of cancer cytogenetics to identify genetic changes in many previously unknown regions. CGH may also have a role in clinical cytogenetics for detection and identification of unbalanced chromosomal abnormalities.

Comparative genomic hybridization in pediatric acute lymphoblastic leukemia

Comparative genomic hybridization (CGH) was used to clarify the chromosomal status of 15 patients diagnosed with childhood acute lymphoblastic leukemia (ALL). Bone marrow samples from 10 of the 15 patients were selected because no metaphases were obtained for cytogenetic analysis. Three patients with normal trypsin and giemsa banding (GTG) karyotypes were also studied by CGH to determine whether significant abnormalities might have been missed by banding analysis, and samples from an additional 2 patients with hyperdiploidy were also included. Seven of the 10 patients with failed GTG banding analysis were found to be chromosomally abnormal by CGH; 2 out of 3 patients with normal GTG band karyotypes were abnormal, indicating that the metaphases available for karyotyping were not malignant cells, and that CGH analysis of hyperdiploid samples provided more accurate resolution than karyotyping alone. The prognostic value of chromosomal aberrations detected by CGII and the efficiency of the technique suggest a central role for CGH in routine clinical cytogenetics.

Fish analysis at diagnosis in acute lymphoblastic leukemia

Many recurrent cytogenetic abnormalities have been described in acute lymphoblastic leukemia (ALL). With improvement of survival, it became evident that some of these chromosomal changes had a major prognostic value: hyperdiploidy and t(12;21) are associated with very long disease free survival, whereas t(9;22) and 11q23 rearrangements correlate with a poor outcome. Because of this prognostic impact, detection of these four specific abnormalities has to be accurate and rapid at diagnosis. In order to reliably analyze ALL patients, we used fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH). We selected specific probes enabling the detection of the structural rearrangements [t(9;22), t(12;21) and 11q23 rearrangements] directly on interphase cells. Detection of hyperdiploidy was performed using comparative genomic hybridization (CGH). This technique enables to characterize chromosomal gains and losses without requiring metaphase obtention. We showed that this FISH-based approach was complementary to conventional cytogenetics, and should be systematically used in ALL at diagnosis.

Comparative genomic hybridization as a tool in tumour cytogenetics

The quality of cytogenetic analysis of solid tumours has greatly improved in the past decade, but a number of technical difficulties remain which limit the characterization of solid tumour chromosomes by conventional cytogenetics alone. The identification of regions of chromosomal abnormality has been aided by the introduction of molecular cytogenetic techniques such as fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH). Of these, a recently developed approach, comparative genomic hybridization (CGH), has had a particular impact on the cytogenetic analysis of solid tumours. It incorporates the sensitivity of in situ techniques and overcomes many of the drawbacks of conventional cytogenetic analysis. This review first outlines the CGH method, giving details for the preparation of DNA probes and target human metaphase chromosomes together with information on the in situ technique and data handling criteria used in our laboratory. It then presents an overview of some of the current applications of CGH, together with a discussion of future directions in the field.