Strategies for the modulation of neuroimmunological disease at the level of autoreactive T-lymphocytes

Diverse patterns of unresponsiveness in an acetylcholine receptor-specific T-cell clone from a myasthenia gravis patient after engaging the T-cell receptor with three different ligands

Using an acetylcholine receptor-specific T-cell clone (TCC) from a myasthenia gravis patient, we have compared the induction of unresponsiveness by three agents: an anti-V beta monoclonal antibody (mAb), complexes of MHC class II with specific peptide (DR4:peptide) and free peptide. Pretreatment with each agent without antigen-presenting cells specifically rendered the TCC unresponsive to a subsequent optimal stimulus. A substantial proportion of the DR4:peptide pretreated cells underwent apoptosis and the remainder were profoundly unresponsive. Apoptosis was less prominent after pretreatment with free peptide and was not significant with anti-V beta mab; with both, the unresponsiveness was transient in the survivors. These diverse effects of engaging the T-cell receptor in the absence of costimulation suggest that these agents act via different mechanisms, and give insights to the potential for specific immunotherapy.

Basic aspects of neuroimmunology as they relate to immunotherapeutic targets: present and future prospects

The neurological diseases with definite or putative immune pathogenesis include myasthenia gravis; Lambert-Eaton myasthenic syndrome; IgM monoclonal anti-myelin-associated glycoprotein-associated demyelinating polyneuropathy; Guillain-Barré syndrome; chronic inflammatory demyelinating polyneuropathy; multifocal motor neuropathy with or without GM1 antibodies; multiple sclerosis; inflammatory myopathies; stiff-man syndrome; autoimmune neuromyotonia; paraneoplastic neuronopathies and cerebellar degeneration; and neurological diseases associated with systemic autoimmune conditions, vasculitis, or viral infections. The events that lead to these autoimmune diseases are not clear but the following sequential steps are critical: (a) the breaking of tolerance, a process in which cytokines, molecular mimicry, or superantigens may play a role in rendering previously anergic T cells to recognize neural autoantigens; (b) antigen recognition by the T-cell receptor complex and processing of the antigen via the major histocompatibility complex class I or II; (c) costimulatory factors especially B7 and B7-binding proteins (CD28, CTLA-4) and intercellular adhesion molecule (ICAM)-1 and its leukocyte function-associated (LFA)-1 ligand; (d) traffic of the activated T cells across the blood-brain or blood-nerve barrier via a series of adhesion molecules that include selectins, leukocyte integrins (LFA-1, Mac-1, very late activating antigen [VLA]-4) and their counterreceptors (ICAM-1, vascular cell adhesion molecule [VCAM]) on the endothelial cells; and (e) tissue injury when the activated T cells, macrophages, or specific autoantibodies find their antigenic targets on glial cells, myelin, axon, calcium channels, or muscle. In designing specific immunotherapy, the main players involved in every step of the immune response need to be considered. Targets for specific therapy in neurological diseases include agents that (a) interfere or compete with antigen recognition or stimulation, (b) inhibit costimulatory signals or cytokines, (c) inhibit the traffic of the activated cells to tissues, and (d) intervene at the antigen recognition sites in the targeted organ. The various immunomodulating procedures and immunosuppressive drugs currently used for nonselective neuroimmunotherapy are discussed in the context of their interference with the above-described immune mediators.

Characterization of a 58- and a 78-kD monocytic membrane protein with affinity to the acetylcholine receptor in myasthenia gravis patients

The autoimmune disease myasthenia gravis (MG), caused by the effect of specific antibodies, directed towards the nicotinic acetylcholine receptor, is triggered by autoantigen-specific T cells. In order to investigate cellular parts of the immune response in MG, the authors investigated the binding of the nicotinic acetylcholine receptor (AChR) to peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMC) from MG patients. AChR binding cells were identified by rosetting experiments using AChR-coated fluorescein beads. Applying this technique, a significant percentage of PBMC (21.2 +/- 7.65%) from MG patients formed rosettes with AChR-coated beads. Membrane preparations of nycodenz- or percoll-separated monocytes from MG patients or T-cell depleted monocytic subpopulations were applied to SDS-PAGE under reducing conditions. Ligand-blotting studies with biotinylated AChRs revealed two cell-membrane proteins with molecular weights of 58- and 78-kD. In parallel the same results were obtained by affinity chromatography of monocytic membrane proteins using AChR-sepharose. A possible interference of anti-AChR IgG was excluded. The 58- and the 78-kD proteins are detectable under reducing conditions by ligand blotting with AChR-biotin, while under non-reducing conditions only the 58-kD protein can be detected. Furthermore, in experiments using Endoglycosidase-H, the 58-kD protein appears to be non-glycosylated, while the 78-kD protein bears carbohydrates. These findings suggest that monocytes which bind the AChR via specific membrane proteins on their surface might act as antigen-presenting cells and may lead to an induction of the T-cell response, in the early phase of the disease.

Approaches for studying the pathogenic T cells in autoimmune patients

Our provisional conclusions from this work are as follows. (1) For screening responses of established lines, native human AChR is not prohibitively scarce, especially if it is concentrated onto beads, and class II-transfected TE671 cells may be useful too; both may give vital evidence of AChR-specificity, but it is still crucial to confirm that with synthetic peptides. (2) For mapping epitopes, panels of full-length and shorter recombinant human polypeptides, and of synthetic peptides, are invaluable complementary material: longer peptides tend to stimulate particularly strongly. (3) Initial selection with pooled synthetic peptides can easily generate interesting lines from both patients and controls, but they may depend on the artificial processing sites that are an inevitable consequence of arbitrarily chosen start and stop points. Of course, these might conceivably be employed in unusual antigen-presenting cells (such as thymic myoid cells), so we cannot totally dismiss such "cryptic" epitopes. This system can sometimes select T cells responding to "natural" epitopes too, as now reported for tetanus toxin. Nevertheless, for these and other reasons, at present, we strongly favor using the longest human recombinant material possible, because it is apparently processed more naturally. This must be combined with rigorous screening for reactivity to E. coli-derived contaminants plus concomitant mapping of epitopes as above. Use of intact AChR for initiating lines may yet become feasible. (4) The T cells thus isolated and characterized so far are proving to be heterogeneous in the epitopes and presenting class II molecules they recognize, and in their T-cell receptor gene usage. It is premature to claim key myasthenogenic epitopes or clonotypes, but HLA-DR3 and the linked -DQw2 do not appear to monopolize presentation. (5) Assessing the disease-relevance of these T cells is a separate problem, highlighted by their apparent similarity in healthy controls. In the meantime, to test their potential pathogenicity, we are assaying their cytokine profiles and ability to help specific antibody production in vitro. In the hope that they do prove to be relevant, we are also using some of them to test possible therapeutic strategies that might prove applicable in the patients.

Critical role for the Val/Gly86 HLA-DR beta dimorphism in autoantigen presentation to human T cells

Helper T lymphocytes recognize fragments of foreign (or self) antigens in the peptide-binding clefts of major histocompatibility complex class II molecules; their activation is a crucial step in the induction of many immune and autoimmune responses. While studying the latter, we raised a T-cell line from the thymus of a myasthenia gravis patient against recombinant alpha subunit of the human acetylcholine receptor, the target of this autoimmune disease. The line responds to the 144-156 region of the human sequence and not to the same region of the electric fish homolog, which differs by only three residues. These CD4+ T cells recognize this epitope only in the context of HLA-DR4 class II molecules, of which the variants with Gly86 are absolutely required. Thus the naturally occurring alternatives Dw14.2 (Gly86) and Dw14.1 (Val86)--which differ only at this one position in the entire antigen-binding region--show an all-or-nothing difference in presenting activity. This dimorphism at position 86 is widespread, occurring in subtypes of DR1, DR2, DR3, DR5, and DR6 alleles as well as DR4. Since other DR4 subtypes with substitutions at positions 70-74 also fail to present this peptide, and glycine residues can be uniquely flexible, we suggest that this replacement at position 86 acts locally or at a distance by altering the conformation of the peptide-binding cleft. Such profound functional consequences for T-cell recognition as we report here may explain this example of conserved major histocompatibility complex diversity.

Neurological autoimmune disease and the trimolecular complex of T-lymphocytes

T-lymphocytes recognize antigen in a trimolecular complex: The T-cell receptor binds to a processed fragment of antigen that itself is bound to a major histocompatibility complex (MHC) molecule on the surface of an antigen-presenting cell. The trimolecular complex controls antigen-specific T-cell activation in normal and abnormal immune reactions. Recent progress in myasthenia gravis (MG) and experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis (EAE) exemplifies this, leading to the following conclusions: (1) Autoimmune T cells may act by interfering with immunoregulation (as in MG) or by directly mediating autoimmune damage (as in EAE), or both. (2) In both diseases, the autoimmune T cells are clonally heterogeneous but recognize only a limited number of epitopes on the autoantigen (acetylcholine receptor in MG; myelin basic protein in EAE). Many of these epitopes can be defined as short peptide fragments of antigen, bound to a particular type of MHC molecule. (3) The MHC determines which peptides are recognized by autoimmune T cells in a given patient or inbred animal strain. (4) The discovery of the limited repertoire of autoimmune T cells has allowed considerable progress in the immunotherapy of EAE, using either monoclonal antibodies or cytotoxic T cells directed against clonotypic determinants on the autoaggressive T cells. (5) One obstacle to this approach in human disease is the polymorphism of the MHC in the species and the commensurate heterogeneity of autoimmune T cells.

Amphipathic segment of the nicotinic receptor alpha subunit contains epitopes recognized by T lymphocytes in myasthenia gravis

Autoimmune helper T lymphocytes were selected from the blood of two myasthenic patients of different HLA-DR type, using acetylcholine receptor (AChR) from Torpedo californica. These polyclonal T cell lines were tested for reactivity with three synthetic peptides corresponding to the NH2-terminal region of the human AChR alpha subunit. This segment is a good candidate for T cell epitopes since it has a propensity to form an amphipathic alpha helix. The peptides elicited 10-30% of the response induced by native Torpedo AChR. Different peptides were recognized by the autoreactive T cells of the two patients. These results suggest that the NH2-terminal region of the AChR alpha chain contains T cell-stimulating epitopes, and that the T cell autoimmune response in myasthenia gravis, like the B cell response, is heterogeneous.

Human T-helper lymphocytes in myasthenia gravis recognize the nicotinic receptor alpha subunit

Myasthenia gravis is a human disease caused by an autoimmune response against the nicotinic acetylcholine receptor (AcChoR). Since the molecular structure of AcChoR is well known, myasthenia gravis is an excellent system for studying the recognition of a complex membrane antigen in the human immune system. Human T-helper (TH) cell lines reactive to the AcChoR were isolated from four myasthenic patients by selection with native AcChoR from Torpedo californica. The selected TH cells could efficiently recognize native and fully denatured AcChoR. The vast majority of the TH-stimulating AcChoR epitopes were located on the denatured alpha subunit of AcChoR. Antibody competition experiments using a panel of rat anti-AcChoR monoclonal antibodies showed that 39-45% of the autoantibodies present in the sera of these same patients bound to the conformation-sensitive "main immunogenic region" (MIR), also located on the alpha subunit. However, AcChoR-induced stimulation of the T cells could not be inhibited with up to 20-fold molar excess of different rat anti-MIR monoclonal antibodies. These results suggest that the Torpedo AcChoR alpha subunit contains conformation-insensitive epitopes that play a role in the autosensitization of TH cells and that seem to be physically separated from the MIR. The specificity of the TH cell response may contribute to directing the B-cell response to other alpha-subunit determinants, such as the MIR itself.