Photothrombotic lesions of the frontal cortex impair the performance of the delayed non-matching to position task by rats

The dynamics of disordered dialogue: Prefrontal, hippocampal and thalamic miscommunication underlying working memory deficits in schizophrenia

The prefrontal cortex is central to the orchestrated brain network communication that gives rise to working memory and other cognitive functions. Accordingly, working memory deficits in schizophrenia are increasingly thought to derive from prefrontal cortex dysfunction coupled with broader network disconnectivity. How the prefrontal cortex dynamically communicates with its distal network partners to support working memory and how this communication is disrupted in individuals with schizophrenia remain unclear. Here we review recent evidence that prefrontal cortex communication with the hippocampus and thalamus is essential for normal spatial working memory, and that miscommunication between these structures underlies spatial working memory deficits in schizophrenia. We focus on studies using normal rodents and rodent models designed to probe schizophrenia-related pathology to assess the dynamics of neural interaction between these brain regions. We also highlight recent preclinical work parsing roles for long-range prefrontal cortex connections with the hippocampus and thalamus in normal and disordered spatial working memory. Finally, we discuss how emerging rodent endophenotypes of hippocampal- and thalamo-prefrontal cortex dynamics in spatial working memory could translate into richer understanding of the neural bases of cognitive function and dysfunction in humans.

Early life stress leads to developmental and sex selective effects on performance in a novel object placement task

Disruptions in early life care, including neglect, extreme poverty, and trauma, influence neural development and increase the risk for and severity of pathology. Significant sex disparities have been identified for affective pathology, with females having an increased risk of developing anxiety and depressive disorder. However, the effects of early life stress (ELS) on cognitive development have not been as well characterized, especially in reference to sex specific impacts of ELS on cognitive abilities over development. In mice, fragmented maternal care resulting from maternal bedding restriction, was used to induce ELS. The development of spatial abilities were tracked using a novel object placement (NOP) task at several different ages across early development (P21, P28, P38, P50, and P75). Male mice exposed to ELS showed significant impairments in the NOP task compared with control reared mice at all ages tested. In female mice, ELS led to impaired NOP performance immediately following weaning (P21) and during peri-adolescence (P38), but these effects did not persist into early adulthood. Prior work has implicated impaired hippocampus neurogenesis as a possible mediator of negative outcomes in ELS males. In the hippocampus of behaviorally naïve animals there was a significant decrease in expression of Ki-67 (proliferative marker) and doublecortin (DCX-immature cell marker) as mice aged, and a more rapid developmental decline in these markers in ELS reared mice. However, the effect of ELS dissipated by P28 and no main effect of sex were observed. Together these results indicate that ELS impacts the development of spatial abilities in both male and female mice and that these effects are more profound and lasting in males.

•

ELS leads to sex differences in spatial memory abilities in mice.

•

Female mice show impaired performance that resolve prior to adolescence.

•

Male mice show persistent impairments across early life.

•

Effects are restricted to spatial abilities and not other task dimensions.

•

Effects are not related to markers of proliferation and differentiation in hippocampus.

The BACHD Rat Model of Huntington Disease Shows Signs of Fronto-Striatal Dysfunction in Two Operant Conditioning Tests of Short-Term Memory

The BACHD rat is a recently developed transgenic animal model of Huntington disease, a progressive neurodegenerative disorder characterized by extensive loss of striatal neurons. Cognitive impairments are common among patients, and characterization of similar deficits in animal models of the disease is therefore of interest. The present study assessed the BACHD rats' performance in the delayed alternation and the delayed non-matching to position test, two Skinner box-based tests of short-term memory function. The transgenic rats showed impaired performance in both tests, indicating general problems with handling basic aspects of the tests, while short-term memory appeared to be intact. Similar phenotypes have been found in rats with fronto-striatal lesions, suggesting that Huntington disease-related neuropathology might be present in the BACHD rats. Further analyses indicated that the performance deficit in the delayed alternation test might be due to impaired inhibitory control, which has also been implicated in Huntington disease patients. The study ultimately suggests that the BACHD rats might suffer from neuropathology and cognitive impairments reminiscent of those of Huntington disease patients.

Hippocampal-prefrontal input supports spatial encoding in working memory

Spatial working memory, the caching of behaviourally relevant spatial cues on a timescale of seconds, is a fundamental constituent of cognition. Although the prefrontal cortex and hippocampus are known to contribute jointly to successful spatial working memory, the anatomical pathway and temporal window for the interaction of these structures critical to spatial working memory has not yet been established. Here we find that direct hippocampal-prefrontal afferents are critical for encoding, but not for maintenance or retrieval, of spatial cues in mice. These cues are represented by the activity of individual prefrontal units in a manner that is dependent on hippocampal input only during the cue-encoding phase of a spatial working memory task. Successful encoding of these cues appears to be mediated by gamma-frequency synchrony between the two structures. These findings indicate a critical role for the direct hippocampal-prefrontal afferent pathway in the continuous updating of task-related spatial information during spatial working memory.

Transient inactivation of the medial prefrontal cortex impairs performance on a working memory-dependent conditional discrimination task

The rodent medial prefrontal cortex (mPFC) has been implicated in working memory function; lesions and inactivation of this region have been shown to result in impairments in spatial working memory (WM) tasks. Our laboratory has developed a tactile-visual conditional discrimination (CD) task, which uses floor insert cues to signal the correct goal-arm choice in a T maze. This task can be manipulated by altering the floor insert cues to be present throughout the trial (CDSTANDARD) or to be present only at the beginning of the trial (CDWM), thus making the task either WM-independent or WM-dependent, respectively. This ability to manipulate the working memory demand of the task while holding all other task features constant allows us to rule out the possibility that confounding performance variables contribute to the observed impairment. A previous study from our lab showed that mPFC inactivation did not impair performance on CDSTANDARD, confirming that mPFC inactivation does not induce sensorimotor or motivational deficits that could impact task performance. To examine whether mPFC inactivation impairs CDWM, the current study transiently inactivated the mPFC with bilateral microinfusions of muscimol immediately prior to testing on the CDWM task. As predicted, CDWM task performance was significantly impaired during the muscimol-infusion session compared with the control saline-infusion sessions. Together with our previous demonstration that the mPFC in not required for CDSTANDARD, these results not only confirm that the mPFC is crucial for working memory, but also set the stage for using the task-comparison approach to investigate corticolimbic interactions during working memory.

The effects of psychotomimetic and putative cognitive-enhancing drugs on the performance of a n-back working memory task in rats

RATIONALE

Working memory impairment is a core symptom of schizophrenia, but no existing treatment remediates this deficit. Inconsistent conceptualizations and few reliable translational measures are major hindrances to understanding the neurobiology of this aspect of cognition. Using comparable task designs may help bridge clinical and preclinical research efforts.

OBJECTIVE

A novel rodent procedure was designed to translate the n-back working memory task used in schizophrenic patients.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Rats were trained in five-lever operant chambers to recall either the last (one-back) or penultimate (two-back) lever from random sequences of lever presentations of variable lengths. Psychotomimetic doses of amphetamine, dizocilpine maleate (MK801), and (+/-)-2,5-dimethoxy-4-iodoamphetamine hydrochloride (DOI) were tested for disruption of accuracy, and cognitive-enhancing doses of amphetamine, nicotine, and (+/-)-1-phenyl-2,3,4,5-tetrahydro-(1H)-3-benzazepine-7,8-diol hydrochloride (SKF38393 hydrochloride) were examined for improvements in performance.

RESULTS

High doses of amphetamine (0.8 and 1.6 mg/kg) significantly reduced accuracy while increasing total trials; 0.1 mg/kg MK801 and 2.0 mg/kg DOI also reduced accuracy, but the latter concurrently impaired responding. At the lowest dose (0.2 mg/kg), amphetamine increased total trials and rewards without affecting accuracy; 1.0 mg/kg nicotine reduced accuracy without affecting total trials, whereas 10.0 mg/kg SKF38393 had the opposite effect.

DISCUSSION

Although the possibility for mediating behaviors may exist, the rodent n-back task provides a clinically relevant model of working memory. Amphetamine and MK801 produced selective impairments without disrupting responding. The cognitive enhancers did not improve working memory, but low doses of amphetamine improved response efficiency. This novel procedure may be useful for examining cognitive deficits and their potential reversal in animal models of schizophrenia.

Galanin and perseveration

Galanin is a 29/30 amino acid neuropeptide that has been shown to impair learning and memory task performance and also have roles in somatosensation, stress responses, sexual behavior, and feeding regulation. However, little is known about galanin involvement in higher cognitive processes, especially executive processes. Perseveration is a classic sign of frontal cortex damage and failure of executive control. Galanin has been shown to disrupt the performance of maze delayed alternation tasks and the operant, spatial delayed nonmatch-to-position (DNMTP) working memory task, tests especially sensitive to perseverative responding. To better understand this potential involvement of galanin in executive control, the present study tested the hypothesis that galanin induces perseveration. The first experiment examined the effects of galanin (10, 20 microg i.c.v.) on the performance of a simple operant response alternation task in which stimuli were assigned to one of two spatially distinct locations to produce extended sequences of presentations to one location, separated by a 10-s intertrial interval. The second experiment looked at the effects of galanin (5, 20 microg i.c.v.) on the performance of non-delayed match-to-position and nonmatch-to-position conditional discrimination operant tasks in which a minimal 1.0 s time interval separated responses. Finally, the effects of galanin (10, 20 microg i.c.v.) on delayed match-to-position (DMTP) performance were examined to determine whether response alternation (i.e., nonmatching) was critical to observing a galanin-induced impairment in this task. Galanin reduced the rate of trial completion in all the tasks, but did not alter simple or conditional discrimination accuracy. Galanin (10 microg) impaired DMTP performance in a delay-independent manner. Together, these data suggest that galanin does not produce perseveration, but are consistent with a galanin-induced decrease in reinforcer strength.

NMDA lesions in the medial prefrontal cortex impair the ability to inhibit responses during reversal of a simple spatial discrimination

Although lesion studies suggest that the rat medial prefrontal cortex (mPFc) is involved in the process necessary for reversal of a particular set of contingencies, the nature of lesion-induced deficits is unclear. The involvement of rat mPFc in reversal of a simple spatial discrimination was examined in the present study. Our hypothesis was that lesion-induced deficits may reflect a failure to inhibit a learned instrumental response. Lister Hooded rats were trained on a spatial discrimination task (SD), which required a correct barpress matching the cue location, then they were trained on reversal of SD (SDR), which required a correct barpress opposite to the cue location. Rats with mPFc lesions showed a slower learning rate compared to the controls. However, behavior of the lesioned rats during early and later reversal differed. During the initial SDR, the lesioned rats showed a greater number of barpresses during the intertrial interval and a slightly higher percent correct responses than that of the controls. Our data suggest that damage to mPFc may produce a lack of response inhibition, leading to an increase in nondiscriminated bapresses, thereby yielding a 'facilitation' during early reversal. mPFc lesion did not affect either open field activity or prepulse inhibition (PPI), a frequently used measure of sensorimotor gating. Disruption of reversal learning following damage to mPFc is partly due to a failure to inhibit instrumental responses, rather than to disruption of other processes involved in sensorimotor gating or general activity.

Medial prefrontal and neostriatal lesions disrupt performance in an operant delayed alternation task in rats

An operant version of the classical delayed alternation task is presented and applied to evaluate the effects of bilateral prefrontal and striatal lesions in rats. Retractable levers in a conventional operant chamber control discrete trial opportunities for making sequential choice responses to the two sides, and the rats are required to maintain repeated nose poke responses to a central panel during the delay interval, which is randomly varied. The operant task provides measures of the speed and accuracy of response alternation and side bias; analysis at different delay intervals provides an index of the memory demands of accurate performance; and analysis of accuracy depending on the response on preceding trials provides measures of proactive interference and perseveration. Following pretraining in the task contingencies, both striatal and prefrontal lesions induced profound deficits in task accuracy, with no change in side bias and only small changes in movement times. The deficit in the prefrontal lesion group recovered more rapidly, neither group showed any change in sensitivity to proactive interference, while the rats with striatal lesions alone exhibited an increased tendency to perseverate incorrect responses on either side. We conclude that the operant delayed alternation task should assist analysis of fronto-striatal function in rats as well as be useful for the analysis of strategies for fronto-striatal repair.

A comparison between the effects of medial septal lesions and entorhinal cortex lesions on performance of nonspatial working memory tasks and reversal learning

Rats with either electrolytic medial septal lesions or cytotoxic entorhinal lesions were compared to unoperated controls on a series of delayed matching-to-sample (DMS) tasks. A DMS trial consisted of two runs. In the first (information) run, the subject was familiarized with a sample discriminandum. In the second (choice) run, the subject was required to discriminate the sample discriminandum from a novel one. When a set of 20 discrete complex objects were used as discriminanda and each discriminandum was used once per day, neither lesions impaired choice accuracy. However, when a single pair of simple discriminanda was employed and re-used between trials within a day, rats with medial septal lesions were severely impaired whereas rats with entorhinal lesions performed at a level comparable to unoperated controls. Next, proactive interference was demonstrated by the introduction of an extra run prior to the information run. When this extra (pre-information) run required the subjects to visit the (eventual) negative discriminandum such that correct choice had to be guided by relative familiarity judgement, choice performance was reduced. Neither lesion group was selectively affected by this manipulation. But when the relative reinforcement history of the pre-information run and the information run was manipulated, such that a correct response required the subject to approach a discriminandum that had recently been non-rewarded, rats with entorhinal lesions were selectively impaired. The effect of delay was demonstrated when a 20-s interval was imposed between information run and choice run. This reduced overall choice accuracy, and this effect appeared to be more pronounced in both lesion groups, although not significantly so. Finally, neither lesion affected the acquisition of a simple discrimination task, but reversal learning was selectively enhanced in the entorhinal lesion group.

To what extent have functional studies of ischaemia in animals been useful in the assessment of potential neuroprotective agents?

A general consensus is being reached on the use of a combination of mortality and functional end-points in clinical trials of neuroprotective agents. However, to date, few preclinical studies have examined the effects of putative neuroprotective agents on functional outcome after ischaemia. The data described in this review show the importance of combining both histopathological and neurobehavioural studies when evaluating the neuroprotective efficacy of anti-ischaemic agents in animal models of cerebral ischaemia. Here, Jackie Hunter, Ken Mackay and Derek Rogers argue that measures of functional improvement in models of ischaemia should be incorporated to characterize further the neuroprotection afforded by a compound that could aid the selection of doses and end-point measures in early clinical trials.

Photothrombotic lesions of the rat cortex impair acquisition of the water maze

Photochemical induction of a thrombosis produces lesions of the cortex of reproducible area and depth, and it has been suggested that this may provide a relatively noninvasive model of the human condition of stroke. The cognitive effects of photothrombotic lesions centred at two different positions were assessed in rats using the Morris water maze test for spatial learning and memory, and it was demonstrated that profound deficits in acquisition of this task were produced by bilateral lesions of the frontal cortex. These effects were in the absence of overt motor deficits, and there was no significant correlation between lesion volume and functional deficits. Flunarizine (2 mg/kg) did not attenuate this ischaemic damage and had no effect on the functional deficits. This model has distinct advantages over more invasive global models of ischaemia and may also provide greater understanding of the functional role of the mammalian neocortex.

Motor dysfunction in a photothrombotic focal ischaemia model

The study of behavioural deficits resulting from cerebral infarction in animal models of stroke has in the past taken second place to histological assessment. This is particularly true of the photothrombotic lesion model. Most tests currently used to measure motor deficits use a scoring system to quantify parameters such as beam walking. The present study set out to characterise a simple and objective assessment for motor impairment in the photothrombotic cortical lesion model. Rats were assessed on a number of motor function tests, i.e. gross locomotor activity, rotarod, and grip strength. After the establishment of stable baselines, cortical photothrombotic lesions were induced, after which the animals were re-tested for a further 18 days. The presence of cortical photothrombotic lesions significantly imparied the rats' performance on the rotarod and grip-strength tests. The deficit observed with the grip-strength task appeared 24 h postsurgery, but was much reduced by day 18 postsurgery. The rotarod test revealed an effect that took longer to establish, but which was more persistent. Gross locomotor activity was not affected. These data suggest that bilateral photothrombotic lesions of the prefrontal cortex produce deficits that can be detected by rotarod and grip-strength tasks.

Animal models of acute ischaemic stroke: can they predict clinically successful neuroprotective drugs?

Substantial efforts are being made to develop drugs which will protect the brain from the neurodegeneration that follows an acute ischaemic stroke. However, while there are already a significant number of animal models of stroke, there is currently no information as to whether activity of a compound in any of them will predict clinical efficacy. In this article, Jackie Hunter, Richard Green and Alan Cross review the major models of acute cerebral ischaemia and propose rational protocols for examining novel neuroprotective agents.

SB 201823-A, a neuronal Ca2+ antagonist is neuroprotective in two models of cerebral ischaemia

We have characterised the Ca2+ channel blocking properties of a new non-peptide Ca2+ channel antagonist, SB 201823-A, in cultures of rat sensory neurones. The IC50 for SB 201823-A against total Ca2+ current in sensory neurones was 4.9 microM. SB 201823-A showed little selectivity for sub-types of neuronal Ca2+ channel but was selective for Ca2+ channels over Na+ and K+ channels. Efficacy against other types of cation channel such as agonist gated channels was not assessed. SB 201823-A was neuroprotective in vivo when administered post-ischaemia in one focal and one global model of neuronal ischaemia. In the rat photothrombotic focal lesion model, SB 201823-A administered i.p. 10 min post-ischaemia resulted in a dramatic reduction in lesion volume. In the gerbil bilateral carotid artery occlusion global model, SB 201823-A dosed i.p. 30 min post-occlusion resulted in both histological and functional improvements when compared to vehicle treated animals. These data suggest that such novel neuronal Ca2+ channel antagonists may have potential in ameliorating both the pathological and functional consequences of stroke in man.