Pathophysiologic and therapeutic implications of acid-base changes during CPR

Improved resuscitation outcome in emergency medical systems with increased usage of sodium bicarbonate during cardiopulmonary resuscitation

BACKGROUND

The use of sodium bicarbonate (SB) in cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR) is controversial. This study analyzes the effects of SB use on CPR outcome in the Brain Resuscitation Clinical Trial III (BRCT III), which was a multicenter randomized trial comparing high-dose to standard-dose epinephrine during CPR. Sodium bicarbonate use in BRCT III was optional.

METHODS

The entire BRCT III database was reviewed. Analysis included only patients who arrested out of the hospital and whose time from collapse to initiation of ACLS was no longer than 30 min (total n = 2122 patients). Sodium bicarbonate use by the 16 participating study sites was analyzed. The study sites were divided according to their SB usage profile: 'low SB user' sites administered SB in less than 50% of CPRs and their first epinephrine to SB time exceeded 10 min; and 'high SB user' sites used SB in over 50% of CPRs and their first epinephrine to SB time was <10 min.

RESULTS

Sites' SB usage rates ranged between 3.1% and 98.2% of CPRs. Sodium bicarbonate usage rates correlated inversely with the sites' intervals from collapse (r = - 0.579 P = 0.018) from initiation of ACLS (r = - 0.685 P = 0.003) and from first epinephrine (r = - 0.611 P = 0.012) to SB administration. Mean ROSC rate in the 'high SB user' sites was 33.5% (CI = 30.0-37.0) compared to 25.7% (CI = 23.1-28.4) in the 'low SB user' sites. In the 'high SB user' sites, hospital discharge rate was 5.3% (CI = 3.6-7.0) compared to 3% (CI = 2.0-4.0) in the 'low SB user' sites, and 5.3% (CI = 3.6-7.0) had a favorable neurological outcome compared to 2.1% (CI = 1.2-3.0) in the 'low SB user' sites. Collapse to ACLS interval was 8.5 min (CI = 8.1-9.0) in the 'high SB user' sites compared to 10.2 min (CI = 9.8-10.6) in the 'low SB user' sites, and their ACLS to first epinephrine interval was 7.0 min (CI = 6.5-7.5) compared to 9.7 min (CI = 9.3-10.2). Multivariate regression analysis found that belonging to 'high SB user' sites independently increased the chances for ROSC (OR 1.36, CI 1.08-1.7) and for achieving a good neurological outcome (OR 2.18, CI 1.23-3.86).

CONCLUSIONS

Earlier and more frequent use of SB was associated with higher early resuscitability rates and with better long-term outcome. Sodium bicarbonate may be beneficial during CPR, and it should be subjected to a randomized clinical trial.

Buffer administration during CPR promotes cerebral reperfusion after return of spontaneous circulation and mitigates post-resuscitation cerebral acidosis

To explore the effects of alkaline buffers on cerebral perfusion and cerebral acidosis during and after cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR), 45 anaesthetized piglets were studied. The animals were subjected to 5 min non-interventional circulatory arrest followed by 7 min closed chest CPR and received either 1 mmol/kg of sodium bicarbonate, 1 mmol/kg of tris buffer mixture, or the same volume of saline (n=15 in all groups), adrenaline (epinephrine) boluses and finally external defibrillatory shocks. Systemic haemodynamic variables, cerebral cortical blood flow, arterial, mixed venous, and internal jugular bulb blood acid-base status and blood gases as well as cerebral tissue pH and PCO(2) were monitored. Cerebral tissue acidosis was recorded much earlier than arterial acidaemia. After restoration of spontaneous circulation, during and after temporary arterial hypotension, pH in internal jugular bulb blood and in cerebral tissue as well as cerebral cortical blood flow was lower after saline than in animals receiving alkaline buffer. Buffer administration during CPR promoted cerebral cortical reperfusion and mitigated subsequent post-resuscitation cerebral acidosis during lower blood pressure and flow in the reperfusion phase. The arterial alkalosis often noticed during CPR after the administration of alkaline buffers was caused by low systemic blood flow, which also results in poor outcome.

Clinical use of sodium bicarbonate during cardiopulmonary resuscitation--is it used sensibly?

This study retrospectively analyzed the pattern of sodium bicarbonate (SB) use during cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR) in the Brain Resuscitation Clinical Trial III (BRCT III). BRCT III was a prospective clinical trial, which compared high-dose to standard-dose epinephrine during CPR. SB use was left optional in the study protocol. Records of 2915 patients were reviewed. Percentage, timing and dosage of SB administration were correlated with demographic and cardiac arrest variables and with times from collapse to Basic Life Support, to Advanced Cardiac Life Support (ACLS) and to the major interventions performed during CPR. SB was administered in 54.5% of the resuscitations. The rate of SB use decreased with increasing patient age-primarily reflecting shorter CPR attempts. Mean time intervals from arrest, from start of ACLS and from first epinephrine to administration of the first SB were 29+/-16, 19+/-13, and 10.8+/-11.1 min, respectively. No correlation was found between the rate of SB use and the pre-ACLS hypoxia times. On the other hand, a direct linear correlation was found between the rate of SB use and the duration of ACLS. We conclude that when SB was used, the time from initiation of ACLS to administration of its first dose was long and severe metabolic acidosis probably already existed at this point. Therefore, if SB is used, earlier administration may be considered. Contrary to physiological rationale, clinical decisions regarding SB use did not seem to take into consideration the duration of pre-ACLS hypoxia times. We suggest that guidelines for SB use during CPR should emphasize the importance of pre-ACLS hypoxia time in contributing to metabolic acidosis and should be more specific in defining the duration of "protracted CPR or long resuscitative efforts", the most frequent indication for SB administration.

Tribonat--a comprehensive summary of its properties

OBJECTIVE

To review available investigations describing the properties of the buffer mixture Tribonat.

DATA SOURCES

Original reports published in peer-reviewed medical journals.

STUDY SELECTION

Review of 76 citations, including four original studies on the effect of Tribonat performed by or supervised by the author, and six original studies concerning Tribonat originating from the institution to which the author is affiliated.

DATA EXTRACTION

Computer search of the literature regarding treatment with alkaline buffers during cardiopulmonary resuscitation.

DATA SYNTHESIS

Routine buffering of acidosis has been questioned, but clinical situations still exist where such treatment is regarded as indicated. In such cases, a buffer with advantageous qualities and few side-effects is desirable. The hitherto commonly used buffers do not always fulfill these requirements, and a more profound knowledge of the alternative Tribonat may therefore be warranted.

CONCLUSIONS

The reviewed articles support the assumption that Tribonat may offer important advantages over previously used buffers in situations where administration of an alkalinizing agent is indicated.

Comparison of sodium bicarbonate, Carbicarb, and THAM during cardiopulmonary resuscitation in dogs

OBJECTIVES

During cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR), elimination of CO2 was shown to be limited by low tissue perfusion, especially when very low perfusion pressures were generated. It has therefore been suggested that sodium bicarbonate (NaHCO3), by producing CO2, might aggravate the hypercarbic component of the existing acidosis and thereby worsen CPR outcome. The objectives of this study were to evaluate the effects of CO2 producing and non-CO2 producing buffers in a canine model of prolonged ventricular fibrillation followed by effective CPR.

DESIGN

Prospective, randomized, controlled, blinded trial.

SETTING

Experimental animal research laboratory in a university research center.

SUBJECTS

Thirty-eight adult dogs, weighing 20 to 35 kg.

INTERVENTIONS

Animals were prepared for study with thiopental followed by halothane, diazepam, and pancuronium. Ventricular fibrillation was electrically induced, and after 10 mins, CPR was initiated, including ventilation with an FIO2 of 1.0, manual chest compressions, administration of epinephrine (0.1 mg/kg every 5 mins), and defibrillation. A dose of buffer, equivalent to 1 mmol/kg of NaHCO3, was administered every 10 mins from start of CPR. Animals were randomized to receive either NaHCO3, Carbicarb, THAM, or 0.9% sodium chloride (NaCl). CPR was continued for up to 40 mins or until return of spontaneous circulation.

MEASUREMENTS AND MAIN RESULTS

Buffer-treated animals had a higher resuscitability rate compared with NaCl controls. Spontaneous circulation returned earlier and at a significantly higher rate after NaHCO3 (in seven of nine dogs), and after Carbicarb (six of ten dogs) compared with NaCl controls (two of ten dogs). Spontaneous circulation was achieved twice as fast after NaHCO3 compared with NaCl (14.6 vs. 28 mins, respectively). Hydrogen ion (H+) concentration and base excess, obtained 2 mins after the first buffer dose, were the best predictors of resuscitability. Arterial and mixed venous Pco2 did not increase after NaHCO3 or Carbicarb compared with NaCl.

CONCLUSIONS

Buffer therapy promotes successful resuscitation after prolonged cardiac arrest, regardless of coronary perfusion pressure. NaHCO3, and to a lesser degree, Carbicarb, are beneficial in promoting early return of spontaneous circulation. When epinephrine is used to promote tissue perfusion, there is no evidence for hypercarbic venous acidosis associated with the use of these CO2 generating buffers.

An evidence-based evaluation of the use of sodium bicarbonate during cardiopulmonary resuscitation

The use of bicarbonate is rooted in three decades of clinical experience and observational studies. For many years, bicarbonate passed the tried and true test for clinical therapies; however, administration of sodium bicarbonate during cardiac arrest and hypoxic acidosis has become increasingly controversial. The controversy provides an excellent opportunity to evaluate the impact an evidence-based approach might have on a common clinical practice. Is bicarbonate efficacious in the treatment of the severe acidosis that accompanies cardiac arrest during cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR)? Are the deleterious effects of bicarbonate clinically relevant? What is the evidence upon which a rational decision may be based? This review evaluates and ranks the evidence supporting the use of sodium bicarbonate in the therapy of acidosis associated with cardiac arrest during CPR.

Alkaline buffers for correction of metabolic acidosis during cardiopulmonary resuscitation with focus on Tribonat--a review

A combined hypercarbic and metabolic acidosis develops during the low flow state of cardiac arrest treated with cardiopulmonary resuscitation. Several negative consequences of the acidosis have been demonstrated, two of the most important being reduced contractility of the ischaemic but still beating myocardium and impaired resuscitability of the arrested heart. Even though interventions to re-establish a spontaneous circulation should be the number one priority during cardiopulmonary resuscitation, attempts to treat the acidosis are often carried out in order to avoid the reported negative inotropic effect. Different alkaline buffers have been used, but it has been demonstrated over the years that such treatment may aggravate the situation due to a variety of deleterious side-effects of the buffers. A mixture of THAM, acetate, sodium bicarbonate and phosphate registered as Tribonat has been suggested as a suitable alternative to conventional buffer substances. The problems preceding the designation of Tribonat as well as studies evaluating its effects are reviewed in this article. Tribonat seems to offer a more well-balanced buffering without any major disadvantages compared with previously used alkaline buffers, even though improved survival has not been reported.

Cardiopulmonary resuscitation: a review for clinicians

Attempts at cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR) date from antiquity, but it is only in the last 50 years that a scientifically-based methodology has been developed. External chest compressions is the standard method for managing circulatory arrest, however, numerous alterations of this technique have been proposed in attempts to improve outcome from CPR. Defibrillation is the single most important therapy for the management of ventricular fibrillation or pulseless ventricular tachycardia. Adrenergic agents used to improve myocardial and cerebral perfusion are also the subject of considerable investigation with new agents entering clinical study. This paper reviews the history, current techniques and pharmacotherapy as well as controversial issues in the management of patients with cardiac arrest.

Pharmacology of pediatric resuscitation

The resuscitation of children from cardiac arrest and shock remains a challenging goal. The pharmacologic principles underlying current recommendations for intervention in pediatric cardiac arrest have been reviewed. Current research efforts, points of controversy, and accepted practices that may not be most efficacious have been described. Epinephrine remains the most effective resuscitation adjunct. High-dose epinephrine is tolerated better in children than in adults, but its efficacy has not received full analysis. The preponderance of data continues to point toward the ineffectiveness and possible deleterious effects of overzealous sodium bicarbonate use. Calcium chloride is useful in the treatment of ionized hypocalcemia but may harm cells that have experienced asphyxial damage. Atropine is an effective agent for alleviating bradycardia induced by increased vagal tone, but because most bradycardia in children is caused by hypoxia, improved oxygenation is the intervention of choice. Adenosine is an effective and generally well-tolerated agent for the treatment of supraventricular tachycardia. Lidocaine is the drug of choice for ventricular dysrhythmias, and bretylium, still relatively unexplored, is in reserve. Many pediatricians use dopamine for shock in the postresuscitative period, but epinephrine is superior. Most animal research on cardiac arrest is based on models with ventricular fibrillation that probably are not reflective of cardiac arrest situations most often seen in pediatrics.

Unexpected return of cardiac action after termination of cardiopulmonary resuscitation

Application of sodium bicarbonate is still an option when resuscitation efforts remain unsuccessful. Despite this, there are no recommendations on how long resuscitation should be performed after administration of this drug. Here we describe a case in which prehospital resuscitation efforts were terminated about 35 min after cardiac arrest. Seven minutes after all efforts had been discontinued, spontaneous sinus rhythm appeared from a zero-line ECG, giving normal hemodynamic values. The underlying reason might be unexpected and unrecognized hyperkalemia, which was diminished by administration of sodium bicarbonate, even under the conditions of cardiocirculatory arrest.

Carbon dioxide transport in rats with acute pancreatitis

CONCLUSION

The production, release, and transport of carbon dioxide from tissues to blood are facilitated both systemically and in the gastrointestinal tract in acute pancreatitis. Red blood cells are responsible for the major exchange and transport of this increase in CO2. The existence of arteriovenous shunting within the intestine is associated with tissue ischemia, which may be involved in the etiology of gut barrier failure in acute pancreatitis.

BACKGROUND

Hemodynamic alterations in acute pancreatitis have been described, while little is known about CO2 metabolism.

METHODS

Carbon dioxide metabolism was evaluated by virtual values of venoarterial CO2 concentration differences in the early phase after sham operation or induction of acute pancreatitis by intraductal injection of 5% sodium taurocholate in rats.

RESULTS

In acute pancreatitis, virtual values of the CO2 concentration increased in arterial RBC at 6 and 12 h as well as in caval and portal vein RBC and plasma. Virtual values of the dissolved CO2 concentration were reduced in arterial and portal vein blood. The increment in blood CO2 concentration related to the increase in CO2 tension from arterial to caval or portal vein valves at constant CO2 tension. The total increment in CO2 concentration from arterial to caval or portal vein blood increased. Whole body oxygen extraction increased, whereas gut oxygen extraction decreased in pancreatitis.

Buffer therapy during out-of-hospital cardiopulmonary resuscitation

The effects of infusing a buffer solution on resuscitability and outcome was tested in patients during out-of-hospital cardiac arrest. A number (502) of adults with asystole or ventricular fibrillation with failure of first defibrillation attempt were entered into a prospective, randomized, double-blind, controlled trial. Of these, 245 patients received 250 ml of sodium bicarbonate-trometamol- phosphate mixture with buffering capacity 500 mmol/l and 257 patients received 250 ml 0.9% saline. Except for the investigational infusion, all patients were resuscitated according to international guidelines. Eighty-seven patients (36%) receiving buffer were admitted to hospital ICU and 24 (10%) were discharged from hospital alive, vs. 92 (36%) and 35 (14%) receiving saline (95% confidence interval (CI) for difference between groups: -6%-6% for rate of admission and -1%-9% for rate of discharge). Using a logistic regression analysis, ventricular fibrillation as initial rhythm (odds ratio 8.06, CI 3.70-17.56) improved the outcome, whereas buffer therapy had no effect (odds ratio 0.77, CI 0.43-1.41). Mean base excess at hospital admission was -9 after Tribonat vs. -11 after saline (P = 0.04, CI for difference 0.2-3.8). Only 16 of the 502 patients had arterial alkalosis on arrival in the hospital and no patient had a positive base excess. Patients resuscitated after out-of-hospital cardiac arrest had metabolic acidosis, but buffer therapy did not improve the outcome.

Emergency presentations of patients with methylmalonic acidemia, propionic acidemia and branched chain amino acidemia (MSUD)

The charts of 16 patients with branched chain amino acidemia (MSUD) who had 48 emergency room (ER) visits, of 10 patients with propionic acidemia (PA) who had 57 ER visit, and of 13 patients with methylmalonic acidemia (MMA) who had 154 ER visits, were reviewed retrospectively for the most common clinical presentations, physical and laboratory findings. The most common clinical presentation was acute or chronic vomiting and the most common physical finding was dehydration. When hypoglycemia was found, the mental status of 55% of patients with MSUD and MMA and 20% of patients with PA, was alert. Mixed acid/base disturbance, i.e. alkalosis caused by vomiting mixed with metabolic acidosis caused by the disease, was present in 30% of MSUD, in 33% of PA, and 45% of MMA. There was no relationship between acidosis detected by the blood pH and mental status of the patients. A good correlation between base excess < -5 and serum bicarbonate < 21 mmol/l was found. Blood cultures were positive for bacteria and fungi in 15% of the visits with MSUD, in 23% with PA, and 3% with MMA. Patients with positive blood cultures did not necessarily have a temperature > 39 degrees C nor hypothermia. The results suggest that the mental status of the patients should not detract the ER physician from obtaining blood pH, gases and glucose and in all instances a blood culture should be secured, even if the patient has no fever.