APIC and CDC survey of Mycobacterium tuberculosis isolation and control practices in hospitals caring for children. Part 2: Environmental and administrative controls. Association for Professionals in Infection control and Epidemiology, Inc

Tuberculosis among adult visitors of children with suspected tuberculosis and employees at a children's hospital

OBJECTIVE

Few children with tuberculosis (TB) have communicable disease, and most do not require isolation within the hospital. However, parents or adult visitors with unrecognized pulmonary TB may be a threat to hospital staff and other patients. We prospectively evaluated adults accompanying children hospitalized for suspected TB at a children's hospital to determine the frequency of undiagnosed, potentially contagious disease.

METHODS

From 1992 to 1998, chest radiographs were obtained from adult caretakers accompanying 59 consecutive children admitted to Texas Children's Hospital with suspected TB. A child and his or her family were placed under Airborne Precautions only if the child or the accompanying adult exhibited characteristics of potentially contagious disease. Annual rates of tuberculin skin test conversion in hospital employees were obtained for the same period.

RESULTS

Of the 105 screened adults, 16 (15%) had previously undetected pulmonary TB. These adults were associated with 14 (24%) of the 59 children. In all instances in which the adult was the patient's parent, he or she was the source of infection to the child. Only 8 (13.5%) of the 59 children required isolation. Tuberculin skin test conversion from a negative to a positive reaction occurred in 127 employees (8 per 1,000 employee-years at risk). Only 4 of these 127 employees performed activities involving direct patient contact. None was in contact with families with a known potentially contagious adult or pediatric patient.

CONCLUSIONS

The risk of infection of healthcare workers from pediatric patients with primary TB appeared to be minimal, and most children with TB did not need isolation. Infection control efforts should be focused on accompanying adults and adult visitors.

Observational study of the use of infection control interventions for Mycobacterium tuberculosis in pediatric facilities

INTRODUCTION

Hospital transmission of Mycobacterium tuberculosis (TB) is a problem in US facilities where adults are treated. However, specific guidelines for facilities in which pediatric patients are cared for have never been defined, nor has any study attempted to assess pediatric health care worker (HCW) compliance with TB infection control (IC) guidelines.

METHODS

An observational study was performed in two pediatric inpatient hospitals from May, 1996, to December, 1997. A trained observer tallied persons (i.e. professional HCWs, ancillary HCWs and non-HCWs) entering and leaving occupied TB isolation rooms and recorded adherence with IC practices (e.g. proper use of respirators, prompt door closures, door signage).

RESULTS

Thirty children with confirmed or suspected TB were admitted during the study period and observed for a total of 242 h during which 656 visits by professional (n = 391) and ancillary (n = 131) HCWs and by family members (n = 134) were recorded. During 30% of visits doors remained open an average of 10 min, and during 20% of visits no respiratory protection was worn. In all, visitors wore the correct respiratory protection appropriately only 55% of the time. HCWs were more likely to wear respiratory protection when caring for children with a positive acid-fast bacillus smear than family members, but professional staff were no more likely than ancillary staff to do so.

CONCLUSIONS

This is the first study to quantify compliance with IC practices for TB in pediatric hospitals. The majority of visitors entering TB isolation rooms occupied by children with confirmed or suspected TB complied with IC guidelines, but discrepancies were seen. Rather than relying on TB IC guidelines designed for adult facilities, guidelines specific for pediatric facilities that consider the local epidemiology of TB should be developed.

Costs associated with tuberculosis control programs at hospitals caring for children

OBJECTIVE

No data are available on the costs of implementing infection control measures for the control of Mycobacterium tuberculosis (MTB) in pediatric settings. In this study we determined the cost of MTB control measures at three hospitals caring for children.

DESIGN

Infection control and tuberculosis (TB) coordinators obtained cost data retrospectively for the years 1994 to 1995 for tuberculin skin test programs, respiratory protection programs and the retrofit or new construction of environmental controls in pediatric settings.

SETTING

Two pediatric hospitals and one pediatric ward in a large tertiary care hospital.

RESULTS

Total expenditures for TB controls ranged from $15270 to $28158 for the 2-year study period. Engineering controls involved the largest capital outlay at two of three facilities. Average yearly tuberculin skin test costs ranged from $949 to $12504/hospital. Respiratory protection programs cost from $480 to $1680 during the 2-year study period.

CONCLUSIONS

Costs associated with implementing control measures varied slightly by hospital but were less than those incurred by hospitals caring for adults. These costs represent improvements made to upgrade selected aspects of hospital TB control programs, not the cost of an optimal TB control program. Optimal TB control programs in pediatric settings have yet to be described.