Transection of the canine anterior cruciate ligament: a concise review of experience with this model of degenerative joint disease

A review of translational animal models for knee osteoarthritis

Knee osteoarthritis remains a tremendous public health concern, both in terms of health-related quality of life and financial burden of disease. Translational research is a critical step towards understanding and mitigating the long-term effects of this disease process. Animal models provide practical and clinically relevant ways to study both the natural history and response to treatment of knee osteoarthritis. Many factors including size, cost, and method of inducing osteoarthritis are important considerations for choosing an appropriate animal model. Smaller animals are useful because of their ease of use and cost, while larger animals are advantageous because of their anatomical similarity to humans. This evidence-based review will compare and contrast several different animal models for knee osteoarthritis. Our goal is to inform the clinician about current research models, in order to facilitate the transfer of knowledge from the "bench" to the "bedside."

High-resolution imaging of progressive articular cartilage degeneration

The objective of this study was to develop and verify a new technique for monitoring the progression of osteoarthritis (OA) by combining a rat model with the imaging modality optical coherence tomography (OCT). Time-sequential, in vivo, OCT imaging was performed on the left femoral condyles of 12 Wistar rats following sodium-iodoacetic acid-induced OA progression. The right femoral condyles (untreated) were also imaged and served as controls. Imaging was performed on days 0, 10, 20, 30, and 60 with an OCT system capable of acquiring images at four frames per second and an axial resolution of 5 microm. Progressive changes were analyzed using an OA scoring system. OCT successfully identified progressive cartilage degeneration as well as alteration of the cartilage/bone interface. Significant changes to both of these structures were observed in the sodium-iodoacetic acid-injected condyles. Structural changes detected with OCT were confirmed histologically. OCT in combination with a well-known model used in arthritis research represents a powerful tool for following degenerative joint disease progression in a given animal by detecting changes to the cartilage/bone interface and articular cartilage.

Kinematics of the ACL-deficient canine knee during gait: serial changes over two years

The ACL-deficient dog is a model for investigating the development and progression of mechanically driven osteoarthrosis of the knee. ACL loss creates dynamic instability in the ACL-deficient knee which presumably leads to progressive joint degeneration, but the nature of this instability over the time course of disease development is not well understood. The goal of this study was to characterize three-dimensional motion of the canine knee during gait, before and serially for two years after ACL transection. Canine tibial-femoral kinematics were assessed during treadmill gait before and serially for two years after ACL transection (ACL-D group; 18 dogs) or sham transection (ACL-I group; five dogs). Kinematic data was collected at 250 frames/s using a biplane video-radiographic system. Six degree-of-freedom motions of the tibia relative to the femur were calculated, and values immediately prior to pawstrike as well as the maximum, minimum, midpoint and range of motion during early/mid stance were extracted. Between-group differences relative to baseline (pre-transection) values, as well as changes over time post-transection, were determined with a repeated-measures ANCOVA. In the ACL-D group, peak anterior tibial translation (ATT) increased by 10 mm (p < 0.001), and did not change over time (p=0.76). Pre-pawstrike ATT was similar to ACL-intact values early on (2-4 months) but then increased significantly over time, by 3.5 mm (p < 0.001). The range of ab/adduction motion nearly doubled after ACL loss (from 3.3 degrees to 6.1 degrees). The magnitude (midpoint) of knee adduction also increased significantly over time (mean increase 3.0 degrees; p = 0.036). All changes occurred primarily between 6 and 12 months. There were no significant differences between groups in the transverse plane, and no significant changes over time in the ACL-I group. In summary, peak anterior tibial translation and coronal-plane instability increased immediately after ACL loss, and did not improve with time. ATT just prior to pawstrike and mean knee adduction throughout stance became progressively more abnormal with time, with the greatest changes occurring between 6 and 12 months after ACL transection. This may be due to overload failure of secondary restraints such as the medial meniscus, which has been reported to fail in a similar timeframe in the ACL-deficient dog. The relationships between these complex mechanical alterations and the rate of OA development/progression are currently under investigation.

Cartilage-derived biomarkers of osteoarthritis in synovial fluid of dogs with naturally acquired rupture of the cranial cruciate ligament

OBJECTIVE

To compare synovial fluid biomarkers of cartilage metabolism in joints with naturally acquired or experimentally induced cranial cruciate ligament (CCL) rupture and determine correlations with stage and severity of disease in dogs.

ANIMALS

95 dogs with ruptured CCL, 8 dogs with experimentally ruptured CCL, and 24 healthy dogs.

PROCEDURES

Synovial fluid was assayed for chondroitin sulfate neo-epitopes 3B3(-) and 7D4 and glycosaminoglycan (GAG) concentration. Results were correlated with demographic data, duration of lameness, radiographic osteoarthritis score, and intra-articular lesions.

RESULTS

The 7D4 concentrations and 7D4:GAG in synovial fluid from joints with naturally acquired CCL rupture and experimental CCL transection were similar and significantly greater than values for healthy control joints. The 3B3(-) concentrations in the CCL-deficient groups were not significantly different, although only values in the naturally acquired CCL rupture group were significantly greater than those in the healthy control group. Within the naturally acquired CCL rupture group there was a significant correlation between 3B3(-) and 7D4 concentrations. However, there were no significant correlations between biomarker concentrations and continuous demographic or disease-related variables or differences in biomarker concentrations with different categories of disease.

CONCLUSIONS AND CLINICAL RELEVANCE

Synovial fluid biomarker concentrations were significantly increased in joints with secondary osteoarthritis associated with naturally acquired or experimental CCL rupture; however, lack of apparently simple relationships with demographic variables or stage or severity of disease limits their clinical usefulness.

Concentrations of chondroitin sulfate epitopes 3B3 and 7D4 in synovial fluid after intra-articular and extracapsular reconstruction of the cranial cruciate ligament in dogs

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate effects of intra-articular and extracapsular reconstruction of the cranial cruciate ligament (CCL) on metabolism of articular cartilage as reflected by concentrations of chondroitin sulfate epitopes 3B3 and 7D4 in synovial fluid.

ANIMALS

13 adult dogs.

PROCEDURE

Each dog underwent unilateral CCL transection (CCLT). One month after CCLT, sham CCL reconstruction (3 dogs), intra-articular CCL reconstruction (5), or extracapsular CCL reconstruction (5) was performed. Synovial fluid was collected by direct arthrocentesis from CCLT and contralateral stifle joints immediately before (time 0) and 1, 3, and 5 months after CCLT. Fluid was examined for concentrations of 3B3 and 7D4 epitopes and total sulfated glycosaminoglycan (GAG) content.

RESULTS

Concentrations of 3B3, 7D4, and GAG, 3B3:GAG, or 7D4:GAG in CCLT joints did not differ significantly among treatment groups nor in the ratios of these variables in CCLT joints to contralateral joints at 3 months. In a longitudinal analysis, concentrations of 3B3 and 7D4, 3B3:GAG, and 7D4:GAG in CCLT joints in all groups changed significantly with time, but we did not detect time X group interactions.

CONCLUSIONS AND CLINICAL RELEVANCE

Transection of CCL resulted in significant perturbation in articular cartilage metabolism as reflected by alterations in concentrations of 3B3 and 7D4 in synovial fluid. These changes over time were not significantly influenced by method of CCL reconstruction. We did not find evidence that surgical stabilization of CCL-deficient joints by intra-articular or extracapsular techniques had any effect on preventing alterations in composition of synovial fluid that have been associated with secondary osteoarthritis.

Winner of the AlbertTrillat Young Investigator Award. The effects of aggressive notchplasty on the normal knee in dogs

We assessed the possible association between an aggressive intercondylar notchplasty and histopathologic, radiographic, and gait changes to the knee. Three groups of six adult greyhounds were observed for 6 months. Group I dogs had a sham operation. Group II dogs had a 4-mm notchplasty of the lateral femoral condyle where it articulates with the lateral tibial spine. Group III dogs had a 7- to 8-mm notchplasty of the lateral femoral condyle to simulate the long-term effects of an overly aggressive notchplasty. Force plate gait analyses were not significantly different for any dogs at 3 and 6 months. Histopathologic studies (hematoxylin and eosin and safranin O stains) revealed notchplasty area remodeling with a thin layer of lamellar bone covered by fibrous connective tissue. Both Group II and III dogs had significant loss of lateral femoral condyle and trochlear groove articular surface proteoglycans. The radiographic notch width index remained unchanged throughout the study for Group I; the indexes increased immediately after surgery in Groups II and III because of the notchplasty, but after 6 months these values returned to near-preoperative measurements. An aggressive intercondylar notchplasty caused articular cartilage histopathologic changes at 6 months consistent with those found in knees with early degenerative arthritis. Significant refilling of a non-impinged notchplasty occurred by 6 months after surgery. Our results raise concern about the effects of aggressive intercondylar notch widening in humans.

Low-field magnetic resonance imaging of the canine stifle joint: normal anatomy

Low-field magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) was performed on the stifle joints of four normal adult mongrel dogs using a 0.064 Tesla scanner. Markers were placed on each stifle joint to serve as reference points for comparing gross sections with the images. A T1-weighted sequence was used to image one stifle joint on each dog in the sagittal plane and the other stifle joint in the dorsal plane. The dogs were euthanized immediately following MRI and the stifle joints frozen intact. Each stifle joint was then embedded in paraffin, again frozen, and sectioned using the markers as reference points. On T1-weighted images, synovial fluid had low signal intensity (dark) compared to the infrapatellar fat pad which had a high signal intensity (bright). Articular cartilage was visualized as an intermediate bright signal and was separated from trabecular bone by a dark line representing subchondral bone. Menisci, fibrous joint capsule, and ligamentous structures appeared dark. In the true sagittal plane, the entire caudal cruciate ligament was often seen within one image slice. The patella was visualized as an intermediate bright signal (trabecular bone) surrounded by a low intensity signal (cortical bone). The trochlea and the intercondylar notch were difficult areas to analyze due to signal volume averaging of the curved surface of these areas and the presence of several types of tissues.

Characterization of a model of osteoarthritis in the rabbit knee

A new computerized method of histomorphometry was used to assess the development of osteoarthritis (OA) in a rabbit model. Three groups of 10 New Zealand White rabbits with closed epiphyses underwent unilateral anterior cruciate ligament transection (ACLT) and contralateral arthrotomy (sham). Groups were killed at 4, 8 and 12 weeks. At the time of death the femoral condyles were assessed grossly following the application of India ink using the following grading scale. Grade 1: intact surface; grade 2: minimal fibrillation; grade 3: overt fibrillation; grade 4: erosion. All histological sections were assessed using a color image analysis system. The mean thickness and area were measured for a defined cartilage region. The root mean square surface roughness (based on deviations from an idealized smooth surface) was calculated to assess the surface profile of the articular cartilage. The results were as follows. After ACLT, no full-thickness ulceration was noted at 4 weeks. Four of the medial femoral condyles at 8 weeks and six at 12 weeks showed full-thickness ulceration of the articular cartilage. The per cent cartilage area and cartilage thickness (ACLT divided by sham) in almost all regions showed decreases with time, indicating progressive erosion. The surface of the ACLT knees was much rougher than that of sham of the knees. These results demonstrate the usefulness of a quantitative methodology using a computerized video analysis system to assess the articular cartilage following ACLT in a rabbit model for the development of OA.

Evaluation of fibular head transposition for repair of experimental cranial cruciate ligament injury in dogs

Unilateral cranial cruciate ligament excision and fibular head transposition (FHT) were performed on 30 adult dogs. Vertical ground reaction forces were determined using force plate data before and after surgery. Cranial drawer motion, tibial rotation, and varus-valgus motion were measured at monthly intervals. Radiographic, gross, and histological examinations of the stifle joints that had been operated on were performed 3 weeks, 4 months, and 10 months after surgery. A scoring system was used to evaluate lameness, osteophyte formation, and meniscal damage. Rank correlation coefficients were calculated between variables tested in pairs. Cranial drawer motion and abnormal tibial rotation were present in all of the joints that had been operated on. Peak vertical force and associated impulse were not restored during the study time period. Meniscal damage was noted in 25% of the dogs at month 4 and in 50% of the dogs at month 10. Progressive gross and histological deterioration of the articular cartilage was observed in all joints. Positive correlations were noted between the degree of stifle joint instability and meniscal injury or radiographic changes. FHT did not control cranial drawer motion and rotational instability, was not successful in restoring limb function, and did not prevent joint degeneration, especially meniscal damage.

Immunohistochemical analysis of 3-B-(-) and 7-D-4 epitope expression in canine osteoarthritis

OBJECTIVE

To examine the distribution of the 3-B-3(-) and 7-D-4 epitopes in proteoglycans from morphologically normal and osteoarthritic (OA) canine articular cartilage.

METHODS

Cartilage samples from the femurs of stable and destabilized stifle joints of 9 dogs that had undergone transection of the cranial cruciate ligament were examined by immunohistochemistry.

RESULTS

The 3-B-3(-) and 7-D-4 epitopes were expressed in the superficial zone of cartilage from the destabilized femorotibial joints in the early stages of developing OA. The staining patterns with these two antibodies differed, with 3-B-3(-) reactivity confined to the superficial and upper middle zones of the articular cartilage, and 7-D-4 reactivity more prominent in the matrix, extending into the deeper zones and increasing with progression of the lesion. Both epitopes were also expressed in the superficial and upper middle zones of areas peripheral to the lesions and were detectable before the loss of matrix and proteoglycans could be identified by histochemical staining with toluidine blue.

CONCLUSION

In this study, the expression of atypical chondroitin sulfate proteoglycans was demonstrated in osteoarthritic canine cartilage, and the pattern of expression changed as the lesions progressed. The occurrence of 3-B-3(-) and 7-D-4 epitopes appears to be associated with changes in chondrocyte metabolism in the early stages of cartilage degeneration in experimental osteoarthritis.

Pressure distribution at the knee joint. Influence of varus and valgus deviation without and with ligament dissection

Traumata or repetitive microtraumata, malalignment with varus or valgus deviation, or chronic joint instability are discussed in the aetiology of osteoarthritis and osteochondritis dissecans of the knee. Biomechanical factors influencing the patterns of pressure distribution at the articular surface and the subchondral bone are suggested to be most important in the pathogenesis. Consequently, the patterns of pressure distribution at the femoral condyles of weight-bearing knee joints were investigated in a cadaveric biostatic model. The pressure in the articular joint space was evaluated with pressure-sensitive films of the knee in different joint positions in the coronal plane (10 degrees varus, 10 degrees valgus, and neutral position) without and with medial collateral ligament (MCL), lateral CL (LCL), MCL + anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) or LCL + ACL ligament division. Results demonstrated that the location of the contact area and the peak pressure depended on the joint position and stage of ligamentous division. Without ligament division, a maximum peak pressure was observed at the medial condyle in the neutral and varus positions. Only in the valgus position did the lateral condyle show a higher peak of pressure than the medial condyle. Ligament division of the LCL and LCL + ACL resulted in an increase of peak pressure at the medial condyle, particularly in the varus position. Division of the MCL and MCL + ACL ligament complex reduced the differences between the medial and lateral condyle. In the valgus position, the peak pressure was significantly higher at the lateral condyle. The absolute maximum peak pressure was measured in the varus position at the medial condyle after division of the LCL and ACL.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Synovitis and osteoarthritic changes in canine articular cartilage after anterior cruciate ligament transection. Effect of surgical hemostasis

Anterior cruciate ligament transection (ACLT) in the dog produces changes in the articular cartilage of the unstable knee that are consistent with those of osteoarthritis (OA). To determine whether the degrees of severity of OA cartilage changes, of synovitis, and of synovial iron deposition were related to adequacy of hemostasis at the time of ACLT, a modified surgical technique was devised, whereby electrocautery was used to obtain meticulous control of bleeding when the ligament was severed and irrigation was used to remove intraarticular blood before closure of the joint. When no particular attention was given to hemostasis, 69% of the dogs showed synovitis in the OA knee 10 weeks after ACLT; when electrocautery and irrigation were used to maintain hemostasis, synovitis was present in only 24% of the OA knees 10 weeks after ACLT (P less than 0.01). Iron deposits were present in 75% of synovial samples obtained after routine ACLT, but in only 6% (P less than 0.001) when attention was given to hemostasis. Hypertrophy of articular cartilage, chondrocyte cloning, fibrillation, and changes in tangential zone chondrocytes were less prominent in the OA knee when electrocautery and irrigation were used. However, the water content, uronic acid concentration, and rate of net 35S-labeled glycosaminoglycan synthesis were similarly increased regardless of the surgical technique used, and presumably, these changes reflect the reaction of joint cartilage to mechanical instability in this model of OA.

Osteoarthritis research: animal models

Although limited in scope and detail, the current review has sought to highlight the contribution of animal models in the study of OA. Further use of these and other models should provide information that may lead to methods for the early detection and successful treatment of human OA.

Gait alterations in dogs after transection of the anterior cruciate ligament

We calculated mean peak vertical forces (MFz) of each limb of 9 adult mongrel dogs before and 2 weeks, 6 weeks, and 12 weeks after left anterior cruciate ligament transection (ACLT). Five additional dogs were studied before and 2 weeks and 6 weeks after sham ACLT. The gaits of 3 dogs that had undergone ACLT 2.5 years previously were also analyzed. Preoperatively, there were no differences in the MFz of the right and left hind limbs of the 9 dogs; we found that each limb exerted approximately 70% of the dog's static body weight on the force plate. Two weeks following ACLT, the MFz of the operated limbs decreased to 25% of the static body weight, while at 6 weeks and 12 weeks after surgery, the MFz generated by the operated limbs rose to about 32% and 37% of static body weight, respectively. No change was noted in the MFz of the contralateral hind limbs. In the 3 dogs that had undergone ACLT 2.5 years earlier, the MFz in the unstable stifle joint was 50% of static body weight. At both 2 weeks and 6 weeks after surgery, the MFz values for all 4 limbs of the animals subjected to sham ACLT were comparable with baseline values. These observations indicate that the osteoarthritic changes seen in the unstable limb are associated with decreased loading of that limb, without increased (compensatory) loading of the contralateral hind limb.