Interpreting bodily changes as illness: a longitudinal study of older adults

Full-time employed and a family caregiver: a profile of women's workload, effort, and health

BACKGROUND

Women provide care for elderly family members while managing their other responsibilities, including full-time employment.

METHODS

This descriptive study used an inductively derived workload-effort-health theoretical model to examine workload, effort, and health among 46 full-time employed family caregivers [CG] of community-dwelling older adults from a larger, nonprobability, cross-sectional sample of 110 CGs.

FINDINGS

The women's caregiving workload (time, difficulty, care recipient's [CR] function), effort (perceived exertion of energy experienced in doing a workload), self-assessed health [SAH], depressive symptoms, and sources of help were richly described, and several associations were found, including higher physical and mental effort, were significantly correlated with higher workload time and difficulty and lower CR function, but not SAH. Higher mental effort and workload, and poorer SAH were significantly correlated with high depressive symptoms. Worse effort, workload, and health experiences were reported by daughters and by women who lived with their CR; those who did not have family or formal caregiving help had higher mental effort and were more depressed, suggesting an area for further study.

CONCLUSIONS

Suggestions are offered for richer measurement of employment status, caregiving workload, and effort. Findings provide a unique profile of full-time employed women CGs' workload, effort (that is, how they do the work), and health, toward a stronger understanding of how women manage multiple workloads. Workplace policies are needed to address workload, effort and health in this informal caregiving workforce.

Age, ethnicity, and use of complementary and alternative medicine in health self-management

Drawing on models of health self-management, we develop hypotheses that age and ethnicity will modify associations among indicators ofpoor health and use of complementary and alternative medicine. These hypotheses are evaluated using the 2002 National Health Interview Survey with the Alternative Health Supplement. Results produced partial support for hypotheses that the effects of ailments on use of complementary and alternative medicine differ by age. Results suggest that ailments such as bodily pain, chronic conditions, and functional impairment are associated with use of complementary and alternative medicine among midlife and younger adults, but these associations are generally attenuated among older adults. Hypothesized ethnic differences received weak support. These findings suggest that different interpretations of ailments and appropriate responses may explain why complementary and alternative medicine is used by fewer older adults. The results also highlight the significance of social and cultural factors in understanding patterns of complementary and alternative medicine use in the adult population.

Médicament et vieillesse

Cet article emprunte une approche socioculturelle de la problématique de la vieillesse par rapport au médicament. Il appréhende avec un regard critique le phénomène « médicament » à travers trois énoncés de relations : le « médicament-obligation » comme qualificatif de la relation des personnes âgées au médicament ; le « médicament-concession » en tant que trame de fond de la relation thérapeutique entre médecin et patient âgé ; le « médicament-compassion », enfin, comme métaphore du rôle des médicaments psychotropes en lien avec le statut de la vieillesse dans nos sociétés occidentales avancées.

The neglect of somatoform disorders by old age psychiatry: some explanations and suggestions for future research

AIM

The somatoform disorders have long been ignored by old age psychiatry. The main aim of this paper is to identify and examine possible reasons for this neglect.

METHOD

A selective review of the general literature on somatoform disorders.

RESULTS

Significant conceptual, diagnostic and classificatory problems have impeded the consideration of somatoform disorders in older people. There is a perception that somatoform disorders are infrequent and have not been validated as independent clinical disorders. However, we present evidence that the more broadly defined somatoform disorders are common in all age groups in primary care and meet criteria for the determination of clinical validity. General difficulties in the assessment of psychiatric disorders in primary care, the setting in which somatoform disorders are most common, are compounded by a lack of support from old age psychiatry services. Effective psychological therapies may not be readily available to sufferers.

CONCLUSION

There is a need for change in the conceptualisation and nosology of the somatoform disorders. The formulation of age appropriate diagnostic criteria and presentations is a prerequisite for determining the clinical validity of these disorders in older people. This can be followed by study of their frequency, associated risk factors and treatment. A system of education that enhances the management of these disorders within primary care and old age psychiatry services is needed.

Older people as health service consumers 3: obstacles to access in the village

Faster access to hospital services, swift advice and treatment in GP surgeries and quicker access to information at home are among the improvements brought about as a result of recent Government policies in England. These developments have increased the infrastructure, such as walk-in clinics and extended surgery hours, but the responsibility lies with the patient to present themselves. Although older people use NHS services proportionately more than other age groups, they also tend to normalize disease symptoms, attributing them to ageing (Tod et al, 200a). This article, the third in a series which addresses older people's beliefs and behaviour in relation to health care, discusses the factors which influence the accessing of health services within an older, white village community in South England.

Barriers to accessing health care: the perspective of elderly people within a village community

Many initiatives which emphasise the consumerist stance of patients make the apparent assumption that patients have the knowledge and desire to exercise their consumer rights. This study explores the extent to which there is a consumerist ethos among elderly people in a village community, and the factors which influence the accessing of health care in the community. Using a mini-ethnographic approach, nine key informants were observed and interviewed. Cultural factors were found to influence coping in health and illness, and in legitimising access to primary health care. No informant saw the need to exercise their rights as consumers of health care, suggesting that despite initiatives to involve patients as partners in health care, the hierarchical position of the elderly people in the village is unchanged from the days of the medical model in health care, and is a significant barrier to their use of health services.

Health of grandmothers: a comparison by caregiver status

OBJECTIVES

In this cross-sectional study, stress, coping, social support, and health were compared in 86 primary caregiver grandmothers, 85 partial/supplemental caregiver grandmothers in multigenerational homes, and 112 noncaregiver grandmothers. Whether support and coping reduced effects of stress on the physical and mental health of grandmother caregivers, including mediating and moderating effects, was examined.

METHODS

A convenience sample completed a mailed questionnaire that included measures of stress, health, support, and coping.

RESULTS

Primary caregivers reported worse self-assessed health, but partial/supplemental caregivers reported a tendency toward more depression and more instrumental support. Noncaregivers reported the least stress and less active and avoidant coping. Coping and subjective support added to the variance of depression and self-rated health. Subjective support and avoidant coping mediated between stress and health, and active coping moderated the effects of stress on health.

DISCUSSION

Implications of these findings relative to the health of grandmothers by caregiver status are discussed.

Recurrent symptoms: well-being and management

Although most older adults report one or more symptoms of a chronic health problem, little attention has been paid to the report of these symptoms over time and whether different symptom patterns affect well-being and symptom management in community-dwelling elders. Therefore, this study examined whether community-dwelling older adults in Ohio, U.S.A. who experience consistently recurring (a) arthritis or (b) cardiopulmonary symptoms report more depression and worse self-assessed health and show more symptom management than those who report inconsistent symptoms and if there are differences in well-being and symptom management over time. This secondary analysis used longitudinal data collected from a random sample of 387 older adults who reported their health complaints in four interviews over 27 months time. Subjects were included in this analysis if they reported either arthritis (n = 321) or cardiopulmonary (n = 232) symptoms at one or more times during 27 months, and then were classified as having either consistent (occurring at all four time points) or intermittent/inconsistent (occurring at three or fewer time points) symptoms. Data analysis included t-tests, chi-square tests, and Repeated Measures ANOVA. Results indicate that those with consistent symptoms reported greater depression and worse self-assessed health than those with less consistent symptoms. Specifically, those with consistent cardiopulmonary symptoms became more depressed over time. Those with consistent cardiopulmonary complaints were more likely than those with an inconsistent pattern to use an illness label to describe their symptoms. Those with consistent arthritis symptoms tended to use more self-care at all time points, to label their symptoms as an illness, and were more likely to consult a physician as their symptoms persisted. The implications of symptom recurrence on well-being, symptom management and the concept chronicity are discussed.

Health of grandmothers as caregivers: a ten month follow-up

This study examined changes, over 10 months, in self-assessed health, depression, anxiety, stress, coping and support in a convenience sample of 74 grandmothers living in the same home as grandchild(ren) and to compare them with grandmothers who had either primary (n = 49) or partial/supplemental (n = 25) responsibility for their grandchildren's care. Grandmothers showed high stability over ten months time, with many reporting elevated depression and parenting stress at both time points. Depression was associated with greater parenting stress, primary responsibility for caregiving, and with avoidant and minimizing coping. Better self-assessed health was linked with less parenting stress, and less formal and instrumental support. Study findings are discussed.