Calcifying epithelial odontogenic tumor (Pindborg tumor) case report

CEOT Variants or Entities: Time for a Rethink? A Case Series with Review of the Literature

The first detailed description of calcifying epithelial odontogenic tumor (CEOT) are ascribed to Jens Pindborg, but this tumor was described some years previously. Subsequently, CEOT was included in the 1971 WHO classification of odontogenic tumors and a since then number of variants have been described, which have added confusion to the diagnostic criteria. We aimed to survey the literature on the variants of CEOT, in parallel with a review of our single institution experience of CEOTs. Cases identified were collated, including available clinical, radiological and histological information and then reviewed, taking into account changes in the understanding and classifications of odontogenic tumors since initial diagnosis. We identified 26 cases from 1975 to 2017 for which histological material was available. Of these, only 13 (50%) showed the "classic" histological appearance, whilst two cases were identified as recognized variants. In 11 cases, other diagnoses or a differential diagnosis were preferred, with no agreed diagnosis in four of these. The proliferation fraction (Ki67) in the 10 cases tested was 2.1% ± 0.18. These findings illustrate the diagnostic challenges in this group of tumors and highlight the gaps in knowledge. Techniques, such as EWSR1 gene cytogenetic analysis, may be helpful in cases with clear cells. However, in other areas of controversy, including the non-calcifying and Langerhans cell rich variants, further investigation, perhaps utilizing sequencing technologies may be needed to refine the classification. Owing to the relative rarity of these lesions it would be beneficial if future work could be pursued as an international collaboration.

Clear-cell variant of calcifying epithelial odontogenic tumor (Pindborg tumor) in the mandible

We present an uncommon case (female patient aged 59 years) of the clear-cell variant of calcifying epithelial odontogenic tumor (CEOT) (also known as Pindborg tumor) in the mandible. The clinical characteristics and probable origins of the clear tumor cells of previously reported cases of clear-cell variant of intraosseous CEOT are also summarized and discussed.

Clear-cell variant of calcifying epithelial odontogenic tumor: clinical and radiographic characteristics

OBJECTIVES

Clear cells have been reported in approximately 8% of cases of calcifying epithelial odontogenic tumor (CEOT). The purpose of this study was to describe the clinical and radiographic features of clear-cell CEOT (CCEOT).

STUDY DESIGN

Eighteen cases of CCEOT were identified by review of the literature from 1958 to 2001, and a new one was added (total 19; 12 central, 7 peripheral).

RESULTS

Fourteen tumors (74%) were located in the mandible, with the central lesions favoring the posterior area and the peripheral lesions the anterior-bicuspid area. Radiographic features were as follows: 50% radiolucent, 50% mixed radiolucent-radiopaque; 92% unilocular; 64% well-defined noncorticated borders, 27% well-defined corticated borders, 9% irregular borders. Cortical perforation was common (67%) compared with CEOT without a clear-cell component (6.7%). Recurrence was reported in 17% of the central lesions and none of the peripheral ones.

CONCLUSIONS

CCEOT is a distinct variant of CEOT; its high tendency for cortical perforation may indicate a more aggressive behavior.

Peripheral clear cell variant of calcifying epithelial odontogenic tumor: Report of a case and immunohistochemical investigation

A case of peripheral calcifying epithelial odontogenic tumor, clear cell variant, located on the right gingival maxilla of a 48-year-old woman, presenting as a 2.0-cm solitary, firm nodule was studied. Microscopically, it was composed of polyhedral and clear epithelial cells associated with amyloid-like deposition. The clear epithelial cells exhibited granules that were positive for periodic acid-Schiff, and the amyloid-like deposit stained with Congo red showed a green birefringence in the polarized light. Polyhedral and clear epithelial cells were immunopositive for AE1/AE3 and cytokeratin 14. Immunoexpression of fibronectin and types I and III collagen were different between the amyloid-like deposits and the connective tissue stroma. Tenascin surrounded epithelial cells located inside the amyloid-like deposits. Laminin and type IV collagen were immunodetectable around the strands, cords, and nests of epithelial cells. This report represents the seventh case of peripheral calcifying epithelial odontogenic tumor, clear cell variant.

Calcifying epithelial odontogenic tumor showing microscopic features of potential malignant behavior

Calcifying epithelial odontogenic tumor (CEOT) is a rare benign, but locally aggressive, odontogenic tumor, and only 2 cases of malignant CEOT are reported in the literature. We describe a case of an atypical CEOT that penetrates the blood vessels, invades bone, and perforates the cortical plates of the mandible. On histologic examination, it shows marked pleomorphism and numerous mitotic figures, including a tripolar mitotic figure. Proliferating activity was found to be 5 times higher than typical CEOTs as demonstrated by the proliferating index, Ki-67, and analyzed by a computerized image analysis system. The Ki-67 labeling index of this case was also compared to various previously reported benign and malignant neoplasms. Although there is no clinical finding of metastasis, we believe this neoplasm has malignant potential on the basis of the histologic features of vascular invasion, significant mitotic activity, atypical mitotic figures, and an increased proliferating index.

Calcifying epithelial odontogenic tumour: biological profile based on 181 cases from the literature

The present profile of the calcifying epithelial odontogenic tumour (CEOT) is based on a literature survey of 181 published tumour cases. The CEOT is a benign, though occasional locally invasive, slow-growing neoplasm occurring as intraosseous (94%) and extraosseous (6%) variants. The intraosseous type appears radiographically as an irregular, uni- or multilocular radiolucent area containing radiopaque masses which increases in size and opacity with time. Some 60% of intraosseous CEOT are associated with an unerupted tooth (or odontoma). CEOT shows a relative frequency of 1-2%. The extraosseous variant is diagnosed slightly earlier (mean age 34.4 years) than the intraosseous type (mean age 38.9 years). Both variants have an almost 1:1 gender ratio. The intraosseous CEOT shows a maxilla:mandible site ratio of 1:2 and are mainly located in the premolar/molar region. The present authors present evidence that the CEOT originates from the complex system of dental laminae or remnants thereof. Histologically, the CEOT is characterized by the occurrence of sheets, nests and masses of polyhedral, eosinophilic epithelial cells which may show cellular abnormalities including giant cell formation and nuclear pleomorphism. Some cells increase in size and produce a homogeneous, eosinophilic, 'amyloid-like' substance which may become calcified and which may be liberated as the cells break down. The true nature of the amyloid-like material is still unresolved. Histological variants including CEOT with cementum-like components, clear-cell CEOT (15 cases reported so far), CEOT-containing Langerhans' cells, combined epithelial odontogenic tumour (CEOT/AOT) and CEOT with myoepithelial cells are discussed in detail. In view of the relatively indolent biological behaviour of the CEOT, mutilating procedures, such as wide resection or hemisection of the mandible, seem unwarranted. Enucleation with a margin of macroscopically normal tissue is, therefore, the recommended treatment for CEOT involving the mandible. Maxillary CEOT should, however, be treated more aggressively, as they tend to grow more rapidly and do not usually remain well confined. Generally, recurrences are rare. Five years is considered the absolute minimum follow-up period. The survey has revealed only one well-documented case of a mandibular CEOT in a 75-year-old man showing features of malignancy.

A clinicopathological and immunohistochemical study of the calcifying epithelial odontogenic tumour (Pindborg tumour) in Malaysians

We reviewed the clinicopathological characteristics of 13 cases of calcifying epithelial odontogenic tumour (CEOT) (Pindborg tumour) diagnosed in the Division on Stomatology, Institute for Medical Research, Kuala Lumpur, over a 29-year period. There were eight female and five male patients. These consisted of eight (61.5 per cent) Malays, three (23.1 per cent) Chinese, one (7.7 per cent) Indian and one (7.7 per cent) Melanau. Their ages at presentation ranged from 19-61 years (mean age, 31.8 years). There were 12 central and one peripheral CEOT. Of these, 76.9 per cent of cases were located in the maxilla, the remaining in the mandible. The commonest clinical diagnosis was a dentigerous cyst (66.7 per cent). Enucleation was the main mode of treatment. Histologically, sheets and strands of polyhedral epithelial cells containing eosinophilic, homogeneous globules with Liesegang rings were observed. One case also showed extensive calcification and clear cell differentiation. Immunohistochemistry revealed a variable keratin staining of the CEOT epithelium, confirming its heterogeneity.

The calcifying epithelial odontogenic tumor. A review and analysis of 113 cases

A review of the world literature has revealed 113 cases of the calcifying epithelial odontogenic tumor. The clinical, radiographic, and histopathologic features are analyzed. Various treatments that have been carried out are related to the frequency of recurrence. The theories of histogenesis are discussed and an attempt is made to explain the nature and origin of the amyloid-like substance.