Monoclonal Antibody Patterns in Cutaneous Lymphoid Infiltrates

Quantitation of intraepidermal T-cell subsets in formalin-fixed, paraffin-embedded tissue helps in the diagnosis of mycosis fungoides

Differentiation between mycosis fungoides (MF) and cutaneous inflammatory processes can usually be made on clinical and histologic grounds. In difficult cases, immunohistochemical studies can be helpful since MF infiltrates usually contain a predominance of CD4+ lymphocytes, while most inflammatory lesions usually have a mixture of CD4+ and CD8+ lymphocytes. However, this determination has traditionally required the use of frozen tissue, thus severely limiting its usefulness. Recently, antibodies that differentially label CD4+ and CD8+ lymphocytes in formalin-fixed, paraffin-embedded tissue have become available (OPD4 and C8/144B respectively, DAKO (Carpinteria, CA, USA). This study tests the utility of these antibodies in the pathologic diagnosis of MF and inflammatory lesions with significant exocytosis. In 9 cases of MF for which both frozen and fixed tissues were available for comparison, the OPD4+ cell count in fixed tissue was significantly lower than the Leu-3a+ cell count in frozen tissue. Also, the C8/144B+ cell count in fixed tissue was higher than the Leu-2a+ cell count in frozen tissue, although this difference was not significant statistically. In a larger series for which only fixed tissue was available, epidermal CD4:CD8 ratios were significantly greater in 23 MF cases (mean 4.0+/-4.76) than in 35 inflammatory cases (mean 0.6+/-0.42; p = 0.001). Thus, although the studied antibodies appear to detect different epitopes in frozen versus paraffin-embedded tissue, demonstration of an elevated CD4:CD8 ratio in fixed tissue supports the diagnosis of MF, and is a helpful adjunct to routine histopathology.

Clinical implications of immunologic phenotyping in cutaneous T cell lymphoma

The composition of cutaneous lesions from 158 patients with confirmed cutaneous T cell lymphoma, 91 patients with suspected cutaneous T cell lymphoma, and 145 patients with lymphoid disorders other than cutaneous T cell lymphoma was quantitated in situ with the use of commercially available murine monoclonal antibodies that identify the Pan T, T-helper/inducer (Th), T cytotoxic/suppressor (Ts), and Pan B lymphocyte subsets. On average, cutaneous infiltrates of confirmed cutaneous T cell lymphoma were found to contain significantly more Th and less Ts or Pan B cells compared to benign lymphoid disorders. Moreover, when analyzed in terms of the type of lesion examined by biopsy, the absolute amount of Th cells progressively expands with increasing magnitudes of infiltrate in the dermis while the amount of Ts and Pan B cells remains relatively constant among lesions. A useful diagnostic criterion (anti-Leu 1/4 greater than or equal to 70% and anti-Leu 3a/anti-Leu 2a ratio greater than or equal to 6) correctly discriminated between cutaneous T cell lymphoma and non-cutaneous T cell lymphoma in 87.5% of cases. A positive immunodiagnostic result also may be useful for the prediction of subsequent histopathologic confirmation of cutaneous T cell lymphoma in patients who have suspect lymphoid infiltrates, such as alopecia mucinosis or idiopathic generalized erythroderma, when first seen. With the use of multivariate analysis, stage and possibly the percentage of Th cells within the T cell component in cutaneous infiltrates were covariates with significant relationships to survival in patients with confirmed cutaneous T cell lymphoma. In addition, Ts cells in infiltrates did not correlate significantly with observed responses to topical treatment and subsequent course in pretumorous mycosis fungoides. These results indicate that Ts cells play little biologic role in modifying the natural history of cutaneous T cell lymphoma.