Superoxide production of neutrophils after severe injury: impact of subsequent surgery and sepsis

Neutrophil kinetics and function after major trauma: A systematic review

BACKGROUND

Immune dysfunction following major traumatic injury is complex and strongly associated with significant morbidity and mortality through the development of multiple organ dysfunction syndrome (MODS), persistent inflammation, immunosuppression, and catabolism syndrome and sepsis. Neutrophils are thought to be a pivotal mediator in the development of immune dysfunction.

AIM

To provide a review with a systematic approach of the recent literature describing neutrophil kinetics and functional changes after major trauma in humans and discuss hypotheses as to the mechanisms of the observed neutrophil dysfunction in this setting.

METHODS

Medline, Embase and PubMed were searched on January 15, 2021. Papers were screened by two reviewers and those included had their reference list hand searched for additional papers of interest. Inclusion criteria were adults > 18 years old, with an injury severity score > 12 requiring admission to an intensive care unit. Papers that analysed major trauma patients as a subgroup were included.

RESULTS

Of 107 papers screened, 48 were included in the review. Data were heterogeneous and most studies had a moderate to significant risk of bias owing to their observational nature and small sample sizes. Key findings included a persistently elevated neutrophil count, stereotyped alterations in cell-surface markers of activation, and the elaboration of heterogeneous and immunosuppressive populations of cells in the circulation. Some of these changes correlate with clinical outcomes such as MODS and secondary infection. Neutrophil phenotype remains a promising avenue for the development of predictive markers for immune dysfunction.

CONCLUSION

Understanding of neutrophil phenotypes after traumatic injury is expanding. A greater emphasis on incorporating functional and clinically significant markers, greater uniformity in study design and assessment of extravasated neutrophils may facilitate risk stratification in patients affected by major trauma.

Uncontrolled sepsis: a systematic review of translational immunology studies in intensive care medicine

BACKGROUND

The design of clinical immunology studies in sepsis presents several fundamental challenges to improving the translational understanding of pathologic mechanisms. We undertook a systematic review of bed-to-benchside studies to test the hypothesis that variable clinical design methodologies used to investigate immunologic function in sepsis contribute to apparently conflicting laboratory data, and identify potential alternatives that overcome various obstacles to improve experimental design.

METHODS

We performed a systematic review of the design methodology employed to study neutrophil function (respiratory burst), monocyte endotoxin tolerance and lymphocyte apoptosis in the intensive care setting, over the past 15 years. We specifically focussed on how control samples were defined, taking into account age, gender, ethnicity, concomitant therapies, timing of sample collection and the criteria used to diagnose sepsis.

RESULTS

We identified 57 eligible studies, the majority of which (74%) used case-control methodology. Healthy volunteers represented the control population selected in 83% of studies. Comprehensive demographic data on age, gender and ethnicity were provided in ≤48% of case control studies. Documentation of diseases associated with immunosuppression, malignancy and immunomodulatory therapies was rare. Less than half (44%) of studies undertook independent adjudication for the diagnosis of sepsis while 68% provided microbiological data. The timing of sample collection was defined by highly variable clinical criteria. By contrast, surgical studies avoided many such confounders, although only one study in surgical patients monitored the study group for development of sepsis.

CONCLUSIONS

We found several important and common limitations in the clinical design of translational immunologic studies in human sepsis. Major elective surgery overcame many of these methodological limitations. The failure of adequate clinical design in mechanistic studies may contribute to the lack of translational therapeutic progress in intensive care medicine.

Polymorphonuclear cell priming associated with NF-kB activation in patients with severe injury is partially dependent on macrophage migration inhibitory factor

BACKGROUND

Severe trauma may induce alternations of cytokine response and polymorphonuclear cell (PMN) activity in patients. This study investigated the correlation of plasma migration inhibitory factor (MIF) level and PMN activation after severe injury, and their relationship with clinical outcomes.

STUDY DESIGN

A prospective observational study was performed at the emergency department and intensive care unit of a university hospital. Thirty-two severe blunt trauma patients (Injury Severity Score greater than 16) with systemic inflammatory response syndrome (SIRS) were enrolled. Age- and gender-matched healthy persons were the controls. Patient blood samples were obtained within 24 hours of and at 72 hours after injury. PMNs were isolated and measured for NF-kBp65 translocation and respiratory burst. Plasma MIF, tumor necrosis factor (TNF)-alpha, interleukin (IL)-6, IL-8, and IL-10 concentrations were measured. Control PMNs were incubated with patient plasma preincubated with anti-MIF antibody or anti-IL-6 antibody; cytokine blockade effects were evaluated.

RESULTS

Twelve patients developed organ failure. Compared with patients without organ failure, patients with organ failure had lower blood pressure and a higher base deficit on admission, higher NF-kBp65 translocation and respiratory burst of PMNs, and higher plasma MIF (968 ± 246 pg/mL vs 564 ± 299 pg/mL) and IL-6 (202 ± 91 pg/mL vs 119 ± 84 pg/mL) levels within 24 hours after injury. Plasma MIF had significant positive correlation with NF-kB translocation of PMNs within 24 hours of incurring trauma (R = 0.668). The presence of anti-MIF antibody in patients' plasma obtained within 24 hours, but not at 72 hours, after injury could significantly partially block the NF-kBp65 translocation and respiratory activity of PMNs in the controls.

CONCLUSIONS

An early increase of plasma MIF associates with NF-kB translocation and respiratory burst in PMNs of severe trauma patients and correlates with higher morbidity. MIF is one of the important factors responsible for early PMN activation and may provide a target of immunomodulation after injury.

Increased oxidative activity in human blood neutrophils and monocytes after spinal cord injury

Traumatic injury can cause a systemic inflammatory response, increasing oxidative activity of circulating leukocytes and potentially exacerbating the original injury, as well as causing damage to initially unaffected organs. Although the importance of intraspinal inflammation after human spinal cord injury is appreciated, the role of the systemic inflammatory response to this injury is not widely recognised. We investigated oxidative activity of blood leukocytes from nine cord-injured subjects and six trauma controls (bone fractures without CNS injury) at 6 h-2 weeks after injury, comparing values to those of ten uninjured subjects. Neutrophil and monocyte free radical production, evaluated by flow cytometry, increased significantly more in cord injury subjects than in trauma controls (6-fold vs 50% increases). In leukocyte homogenates, the concentration of free radicals increased significantly more in cord injury subjects (2-fold) than in the trauma controls (1.6-fold) as did activity of myeloperoxidase (2.3-fold vs. 1.7-fold). Moreover, in homogenates and blood smears, expression of the NADPH oxidase subunit gp91(phox) and of the oxidative enzyme, inducible nitric oxide synthetase was 20-25% greater in cord injury subjects than in trauma controls. Expression of the pro-inflammatory transcription factor NF-kappaB and of cyclooxygenase-2 increased similarly after both injuries. Finally, aldehyde products of tissue-damaging lipid peroxidation also increased significantly more in the plasma of spinal cord injury subjects than in trauma controls (2.6 fold vs. 1.9-fold). Spinal cord injury causes a particularly intense systemic inflammatory response. Limiting this response briefly after cord injury should protect the spinal cord and tissues/organs outside the CNS from secondary damage.

The effect of continuous veno-venous hemofiltration or direct hemoperfusion with polymyxin B-immobilized fiber on neutrophil respiratory oxidative burst in patients with sepsis and septic shock

Neutrophil activates and injures tissues and organs during sepsis or septic shock. Blood purification therapies such as continuous veno-venous hemofiltration (CVVH) and direct hemoperfusion with polymyxin-immobilized fiber (PMX-DHP) have been used for the treatment of sepsis and septic shock, however, the effects of such therapies on neutrophil activation have previously been poorly understood. We sought to evaluate neutrophil reactive oxygen species (ROS), especially H2O2 production, in the pathophysiology of sepsis or septic shock and the effect of CVVH or PMX-DHP on neutrophil ROS. Seven critically ill septic patients requiring CVVH (and 12 matched septic patients who did not require CVVH as control) and seven septic shock patients treated with PMX-DHP were studied. We found that patients with sepsis or septic shock had significantly higher levels of neutrophil ROS compared with normal volunteers (183 +/- 42, 292 +/- 90, and 103 +/- 30) (P < 0.05, and < 0.005). Neutrophil ROS did not change over time in patients treated either with CVVH or without CVVH. In contrast, neutrophil ROS significantly inhibited PMX-DHP treatment in patients with septic shock (pretreatment; 292 +/- 88 vs. post-treatment; 205 +/- 93, P < 0.05). In conclusion, neutrophil ROS was significantly enhanced in the sepsis or septic shock affected patients. CVVH did not affect neutrophil ROS while PMX-DHP significant inhibited neutrophil ROS.

Complement-induced impairment of the innate immune system during sepsis

The complement system is an integral part of innate immunity and is chiefly responsible for controlling bacterial infections, especially those involving gram- negative organisms. To accomplish this task, serum proteins engage in a series of enzymatic cascades. The cleaved proteins assemble pores on membranous structures, which lead to cell lysis. During this process, powerful inflammatory mediators are produced, including the anaphylatoxins, C5a, C3a, and the membrane attack complex (MAC). Under systemic inflammatory conditions, an overactive complement system may compromise the effectiveness of innate immunity. We review the detrimental effects that are caused by uncontrolled complement activation during sepsis.

Complement-induced impairment of the innate immune system during sepsis

The complement system is an integral part of innate immunity and is chiefly responsible for controlling bacterial infections, especially those involving gram- negative organisms. To accomplish this task, serum proteins engage in a series of enzymatic cascades. The cleaved proteins assemble pores on membranous structures, which lead to cell lysis. During this process, powerful inflammatory mediators are produced, including the anaphylatoxins, C5a, C3a, and the membrane attack complex (MAC). Under systemic inflammatory conditions, an overactive complement system may compromise the effectiveness of innate immunity. We review the detrimental effects that are caused by uncontrolled complement activation during sepsis.

Red flags in patients presenting with headache: clinical indications for neuroimaging

Headache is a very common patient complaint but secondary causes for headache are unusual. Neuroimaging is both expensive and has a low yield in this group. Most patients with intracranial pathology have clinical features that would raise a "red flag". Appropriate selection of patients with headache for neuroimaging to look for secondary causes is very important. Red flags act as screening tools to help in identifying those patients presenting with headache who would benefit from prompt neuroimaging, and may increase the yield. The aim of this study is to evaluate clinical features in patients with headache using neuroimaging as a screening tool for intracranial pathology. 20 red flags were defined. A retrospective study of 111 patients was performed and the outcomes were divided into positive and negative. Abnormal neuroimaging was present in 39 patients. Results were analysed using the Logistic Regression model. Sensitivity and specificity of red flags were analysed to establish the cut-off point to predict abnormal neuroimaging and a receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curve plotted to show the sensitivity of the diagnostic test. Three red flag features proved to be statistically significant with the p-value of less than 0.05 on both univariate and multivariate analysis. These were: paralysis; papilloedema; and "drowsiness, confusion, memory impairment and loss of consciousness". In addition, if three or more red flags from the list were present, this showed strong indication of abnormal neuroimaging, from cut-off point of ROC curve (area under the curve =0.76).

Relationship between oxidative burst activity and CD11b expression in neutrophils and monocytes from healthy individuals: effects of race and gender

Oxidative burst activity and the expression of adhesion molecules have been used as indicators of leukocyte activation status. The aim of the study was to delineate the relationship of oxidative burst activity and the expression of adhesion molecules in neutrophils and monocytes from a pool of healthy volunteers (n = 96). We also tested the potential role of gender and a racial background in the individual response differences. Basal and phorbol myristate acetate (PMA)-stimulated oxidative burst and CD11b expression were determined using dihydrorhodamine 123 and phycoerythrin (PE)-conjugated anti-CD11b monoclonal antibodies. PMA markedly increased CD11b expression and cellular oxidant content in neutrophils and monocytes in all samples. However, the responses showed considerable variability among individuals. A positive correlation was observed between the responsiveness of neutrophils and monocytes in their basal or PMA-stimulated CD11b expressions and PMA-stimulated oxidative burst activities. In contrast, no correlation was found between the level of adhesion molecule expression and cellular oxidant content in monocytes or neutrophils either under basal or under PMA-stimulated conditions. The reactivity of oxidative burst (i.e., PMA-stimulated over basal) was significantly lower in neutrophils from African American males compared with cells from African American females, white females, or white males. In contrast, reactivity of monocytes was significantly elevated in white males compared with all other groups. These findings indicate that leukocytes with a relatively high degree of adhesion molecule expression may display an average or decreased oxidative burst activity, and vice versa. Our findings also indicate that ethnic background may influence the oxidative burst activity in neutrophils and monocytes. This needs consideration in clinical studies utilizing healthy volunteers with mixed gender and ethnic backgrounds.

Characterization of plasma magnesium concentration and oxidative stress following graded traumatic brain injury in humans

Plasma magnesium, calcium, and oxidative status were investigated in 31 male casualties with traumatic brain injury (TBI) during a 7-day posttraumatic period. The study group consisted of eight patients with mild closed head injury (Glasgow Coma Scale score [GCS] of 13-15), 10 patients with extensive penetrating head injury (GCS 4-6), and 13 patients with blast injuries but without direct head trauma. The latter group was included since previous experimental and clinical data have confirmed the development of indirect brain trauma in patients with blast injuries. Patients with multiple injuries were not included. Significant declines in plasma divalent cations were found in GCS 4-6 patients immediately after TBI and persisting for the entire 7-day study period. Similar changes in magnesium, but not calcium, were present in the GCS 13-15 and the blast injury groups, but only up until day 3 after injury. Alterations in lipid peroxidation products and superoxide anions were also observed following TBI. Increased lipid peroxidation was noted in all three groups over the entire posttraumatic period while increases in superoxide anion generation occurred transiently immediately following TBI. Thereafter, in the GCS 13-15 and blast injury groups, superoxide anions subsequently normalized, whereas in extensive head injury (GCS 4-6), superoxide anion generation significantly declined. A negative correlation between magnesium balance and oxidative stress was observed in all patients immediately after injury persisting in GCS 4-6 patients to the end of the observation period. Our findings suggest an interrelationship between magnesium changes and blood oxidants/antioxidants after TBI, which could be of both diagnostic and prognostic value in patients with neurotrauma.