Patellofemoral contact pressures exceed the compressive yield strength of UHMWPE in total knee arthroplasties

Factors that impact the patellofemoral contact stress in the TKA: a review

Abnormal retro patellar stress is believed to contribute to patellofemoral complications after total knee arthroplasty (TKA), but the causal link between TKA and patellofemoral contact stress remains unclear. By reviewing the relevant studies, we found that both TKA implantation and additional patellar resurfacing increase retro patellar pressure. The rotation and size of the femoral component, thickness and position of the patellar component, installation of the tibial component, prosthesis design and soft tissue balance further influence patellofemoral stress. Specific measures can be applied to reduce stress, including the installation of the femoral prosthesis with an appropriate external rotation angle, placing the tibial component at a more posterior position and the patellar button at a more medial position, avoiding over-sized femoral and patellar components, selecting posterior-stabilized design rather than cruciate-retaining design, using gender-specific prosthesis or mobile-bearing TKA system, and releasing the lateral retinaculum or performing partial lateral facetectomy. Despite these measures, the principle of individualization should be followed to optimize the patellofemoral biomechanics.

Metal-Backed Patella Implants in Knee Arthroplasty: Can the Past Predict the Future?

BACKGROUND

There is a renewed interest in uncemented total knee arthroplasty to potentially provide longer durability, including the use of newer design metal-backed patellae (MBPs). The purpose of this study was to review survivorship with failure mode and time to failure of an earlier version MBP at up to 10-30 years of follow-up that may influence the desirability of using these components today.

METHODS

A retrospective review was performed of patients that had uncemented total knee arthroplasty with an uncemented MBP. All-cause revision rates were obtained from chart reviews and telephone discussions with patients and family members of deceased patients. Kaplan-Meier plots were used to determine the implant survivorship. Outcome scores were compared between revised and nonrevised patients.

RESULTS

The 97 knees that had an end point of an aseptic revision or last known contact with implant survivorship averaged 15 years (range, 0-32 years). There were 40 knees that underwent revision that included 37 patella component failures (38.1%). All patellar failures had polyethylene wear or fracture. None were revised due to loosening. Survivorship was 97.9% at 5 years, 88.7% at 10 years, and 53.0% at 20 years. Median time to failure was 11 years.

CONCLUSION

Loosening is not a failure mode with this MBP. There were 75% of the failures occurring after 10 years. Use of contemporary MBP with improved but still thin polyethylene warrants guarded optimism when used in younger patients where longer survivorship than with a cemented all-polyethylene patellar component is the goal.

Differences in Trochlear Morphology from Native Using a Femoral Component Interfaced with an Anatomical Patellar Prosthesis in Kinematic Alignment and Mechanical Alignment

Patellofemoral complications following total knee arthroplasty can be traced in part to alignment of the femoral component. Kinematic alignment (KA) and mechanical alignment (MA) use the same femoral component but align the component differently. Our objective was to determine differences in trochlear morphology from native for a femoral component interfaced with an anatomical patellar prosthesis in KA and MA. Ten three-dimensional femur-cartilage models were created by combining computed tomography and laser scans of native human cadaveric femurs free of skeletal abnormalities. The femoral component was positioned using KA and MA. Measurements of the prosthetic and native trochlea were made along the arc length of the native trochlear groove and differences from native were computed for the medial-lateral and radial locations of the groove and sulcus angle. Mean medial-lateral locations of the prosthetic groove were within 1.5 and 3.5 mm of native for KA and MA, respectively. Mean radial locations of the prosthetic groove were as large as 5 mm less than native for KA and differences were greater for MA. Sulcus angles of the prosthetic trochlea were 10 degrees steeper proximally, and 10 degrees flatter distally than native for both KA and MA. Largest differences from native occurred for radial locations and sulcus angles for both KA and MA. The consistency of these results with those of other fundamentally different designs which use a modified dome (i.e., sombrero hat) patellar prosthesis highlights the need to reassess the design of the prosthetic trochlea on the part of multiple manufacturers worldwide.

Understanding the patellofemoral joint in total knee arthroplasty

Total knee arthroplasty (TKA) is one of the most successful procedures in orthopedic surgery. Nevertheless, postoperative patellofemoral complications remain a challenging problem, affecting a substantial proportion of patients. Complications involving the patellofemoral joint (PFJ) can occur in both resurfaced and nonresurfaced patellae. Types of PFJ complications include anterior knee pain, maltracking, fracture, avascular necrosis and patellar clunk. The causes of patellofemoral complications can be categorized into patient-, surgeon- and implant-related factors. Patient characteristics such as female sex, young age, depression and increased body mass index have been linked with increased complications. Important technical considerations to avoid complications include achieving appropriate rotational alignment of the femoral and tibial components, maintaining joint line height, medializing the patellar button and avoiding “overstuffing” the PFJ. Component design features such as conformity, shape and depth of the femoral trochlea have also been shown to be important. Although the cause of patellofemoral complications after TKA may sometimes be unknown, it remains important to minimize errors that can lead to these complications.

The influence of compressive forces across the patellofemoral joint on patient-reported outcome after bi-cruciate stabilized total knee arthroplasty

AIMS

Patellofemoral problems are a common complication of total knee arthroplasty. A high compressive force across the patellofemoral joint may affect patient-reported outcome. However, the relationship between patient-reported outcome and the intraoperative patellofemoral contact force has not been investigated. The purpose of this study was to determine whether or not a high intraoperative patellofemoral compressive force affects patient-reported outcome.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

This prospective study included 42 patients (42 knees) with varus-type osteoarthritis who underwent a bi-cruciate stabilized total knee arthroplasty and in whom the planned alignment was confirmed on 3D CT. Of the 42 patients, 36 were women and six were men. Their mean age was 72.3 years (61 to 87) and their mean body mass index (BMI) was 24.4 kg/m ² (18.2 to 34.3). After implantation of the femoral and tibial components, the compressive force across the patellofemoral joint was measured at 10°, 30°, 60°, 90°, 120°, and 140° of flexion using a load cell (Kyowa Electronic Instruments Co., Ltd., Tokyo, Japan) manufactured in the same shape as the patellar implant. Multiple regression analyses were conducted to investigate the relationship between intraoperative patellofemoral compressive force and patient-reported outcome two years after implantation.

RESULTS

No patient had anterior knee pain after total knee arthroplasty. The compressive force across the patellofemoral joint at 140°of flexion was negatively correlated with patient satisfaction (R ² = 0.458; β = -0.706; p = 0. 041) and Forgotten Joint Score-12 (FJS-12; R ² = .378; β = -0.636; p = 0. 036). The compressive force across the patellofemoral joint at 60° of flexion was negatively correlated with the patella score (R ² = 0.417; β = -0.688; p = 0. 046).

CONCLUSION

Patient satisfaction, FJS-12, and patella score were affected by the patellofemoral compressive force at 60° and 140° of flexion. Reduction of the patellofemoral compressive forces at 60° and 140° of flexion angle during total knee arthroplasty may improve patient-reported outcome, but has no effect on anterior knee pain.

Influence of Different Patellofemoral Design Variations Based on Genesis II Total Knee Endoprosthesis on Patellofemoral Pressure and Kinematics

In total knee arthroplasty (TKA), patellofemoral groove design varies greatly and likely has a distinct influence on patellofemoral biomechanics. To analyse the selective influence, five patellofemoral design variations were developed based on Genesis II total knee endoprosthesis (original design, being completely flat, being laterally elevated, being medially elevated, and both sides elevated) and made from polyamide using rapid prototyping. Muscle-loaded knee flexion was simulated on 10 human knee specimens using a custom-made knee simulator, measuring the patellofemoral pressure distribution and tibiofemoral and patellofemoral kinematics. The measurements were carried out in the native knee as well as after TKA with the 5 design prototypes. The overall influence of the different designs on the patellofemoral kinematics was small, but we found detectable effects for mediolateral tilt (p < 0.05 for 35°-80° flexion) and translation of the patella (p < 0.045 for 20°-65° and 75°-90°), especially for the completely flat design. Considering patellofemoral pressures, major interindividual differences were seen between the designs, which, on average, largely cancelled each other out. These results suggest that the elevation of the lateral margin of the patellofemoral groove is essential for providing mediolateral guidance, but smooth contouring as with original Genesis II design seems to be sufficient. The pronounced interindividual differences identify a need for more patellofemoral design options in TKA.

Influence of Total Knee Arthroplasty on Patellar Kinematics and Patellofemoral Pressure

BACKGROUND

Patellofemoral complications are one of the main problems after total knee arthroplasty (TKA). The design of the TKA component may affect the patellar biomechanics, which may be associated with this postoperative complication. The purpose of this study was to assess the influence of TKA and prosthesis designs on the patellar kinematics and patellofemoral pressure.

METHODS

Using fresh-frozen cadavers, we measured the patellofemoral pressure, patella offset, and patella tilt in the following 4 conditions: normal knee (patella replacement only), cruciate-retaining TKA, condylar-stabilizing TKA, and posterior-stabilized TKA.

RESULTS

The patellofemoral pressure increased significantly after the cruciate-retaining TKA and condylar-stabilizing TKA compared with the normal knee. The patella offset in the normal knee decreased with increasing knee flexion angles, while the patella offset in the TKA knees did not change significantly through the full range of motion. The amount of lateral patella tilt in the normal knee was significantly larger than the TKA knees in the full range of motion.

CONCLUSION

Although the femoral components are designed to reproduce an anatomical patellar tracking, the physiological patellar kinematics were not observed. Relatively high patellofemoral pressure and kinematic change after TKA may be associated with postoperative complications such as the anterior knee pain.

Stress distribution of the patellofemoral joint in the anatomic V-shape and curved dome-shape femoral component: a comparison of resurfaced and unresurfaced patellae

PURPOSE

Whether to resurface the patella in knee replacement remains a controversial issue. The geometrical design of the trochlear groove in the femoral component could play an important role in determining the stress distribution on the patellofemoral joint, but this has not been sufficiently reported on. This study attempted to determine the effect of implant design on contact mechanics by means of a finite element method.

METHODS

Two designs, an anatomical V-shape design (VSD) and a dome-shape design (DSD), for the anterior trochlear surface in a contemporary femoral component were chosen for examining the contact characteristics. The use and absence of patella resurfacing was simulated. The stress and strain distribution on the patellar bone and the polyethylene component were calculated for comparison.

RESULTS

Without patellar resurfacing, the maximal compressive strain in the patellar bone in the VSD model was about 20 % lower than the DSD model. On the other hand, with resurfacing, the maximal strain for the VSD model was 13.3 % greater than for DSD. Uneven stress distribution at the bone-implant interface was also noted for the two designs.

CONCLUSION

The femoral component with a V-shape trochlear groove reduced the compressive strain on the unresurfaced patella. If resurfacing the patella, the femoral component with a curved domed-shape design might reduce the strain in the remaining patellar bone. Uneven stress could occur at the bone-implant interface, so design modifications for improving fixation strength and medialization of the patellar button would be helpful in reducing the risk of peg fracture or loosening.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

III.

No difference in patellar kinematics between fixed-bearing cruciate-retaining and cruciate-substituting total knee arthroplasty: a cadaveric investigation

PURPOSE

The influence of cruciate-ligament-retaining (CR-TKA) and cruciate-ligament-substituting (CS-TKA) TKA on tibiofemoral kinematics was analysed in many investigations. However, the influence on patellar kinematics is unclear so far. The aim of this study was to compare patellar kinematics of the natural knee with those after CR- and CS-TKA.

METHODS

Patellar kinematics of nine healthy whole-body cadaveric knees before and after CR- and CS-TKA was investigated using a commercial optical computer navigation system. Patellar kinematics of the healthy knee was compared with those after CR- and CS-TKA.

RESULTS

No significant difference between the natural knee and the knee after TKA or between both types of TKA for patellar kinematics could be found. Interestingly, both types of TKA resulted in a more medial patellar shift and a contrary patellar tilt and rotation behaviour. CR- and CS-TKA resulted in smaller values for patellar epicondylar distance at all flexion angles.

CONCLUSIONS

Our study found no influence of prosthesis type on patellar kinematics. Factors like component alignment and prosthesis design seem to be more important in terms of adequate restoration of patellar kinematics in TKA than whether choosing CR- or CS-TKA.

FINITE ELEMENT ANALYSIS OF A RETRIEVED CUSTOM-MADE KNEE PROSTHESIS

Custom-made knee prostheses have been widely used to reconstruct the function of the lower limb in bone tumor resections. A custom-made tumor knee prosthesis was retrieved on account of prosthesis loosening post-surgery. Misalignment between the anatomical axis of the femur and the axis of the femoral stem as well as the material loss at the posterior region of the tibial plateau were considered to be the primary causes of the failure. Based on this hypothesis, finite element analysis was performed to investigate the contact mechanics of the prosthesis while implanted in vivo. The maximum deformation at the femur was 0.59 and 1.17 mm when the misalignment angle was 3° and 6°, respectively. Besides, the maximum contact pressure at the tibial plateau was 44.88 MPa at an extremely high flexion of angle 135° during squatting or kneeling. Uneven stress distribution at the femur, which came from the misalignment, was the main cause of loosening, which was aggravated indirectly with the material loss at the posterior region of the tibial plateau. Optimized prosthesis design and appropriate selection, with accurate surgical positioning and targeted rehabilitation training programme are important considerations for prolonging life-span of prostheses in vivo.

The biomechanical effect of increased valgus on total knee arthroplasty: a cadaveric study

The effects of valgus load on cadaveric knees following total knee arthroplasty (TKA) were investigated using a custom testing system. TKAs were performed on 8 cadaveric knees and tested at 0°, 30°, and 60° knee flexion in both neutral and 5° valgus. Fuji pressure sensitive film was used to quantify contact areas and pressures and MCL strain was determined using a Microscribe digitizing system. Lateral tibiofemoral pressures increased (P < 0.05) at all knee flexion angles with valgus loading. Patellofemoral contact characteristics did not change significantly (P > 0.05). Significant increases in strain were observed along the anterior and posterior border of the MCL at all knee flexion angles. These findings suggest that valgus loading increases TKA joint contact pressures and MCL strain with increasing knee flexion which may increase implant instability.

Increased patellofemoral pressure after TKA: an in vitro study

PURPOSE

Considering the discrepant results of the recent biomechanical studies, the purpose of this study was to simulate dynamic muscle-loaded knee flexion with a large number of specimens and to analyse the influence of total knee arthroplasty (TKA) without and with patellar resurfacing on the patellofemoral pressure distribution.

METHODS

In 22 cadaver knee specimens, dynamic muscle-loaded knee flexion (15°-90°) was simulated with a specially developed knee simulator applying variable muscle forces on the quadriceps muscles to maintain a constant ankle force. Patellofemoral pressures were measured with flexible, pressure-sensitive sensor foils (TEKSCAN) and patellofemoral offset with an ultrasound motion-tracking system (ZEBRIS). Measurements were taken on the native knee, after total knee arthroplasty and after patellar resurfacing. Correct positioning of the patellar implant was examined radiologically.

RESULTS

The maximal patellofemoral peak pressure partly increased from the native knee to the knee with TKA with intact patella (35°-90°, p < 0.012) and highly increased (twofold to threefold) after patellar resurfacing (20°-90°, p < 0.001). Concurrently, the patellofemoral contact area decreased and changed from a wide area distribution in the native knee, to a punctate area after TKA with intact patella and a line-shaped area after patellar resurfacing. Patellar resurfacing led to no increase in patellar thickness and patellofemoral offset.

CONCLUSIONS

Despite correct implantation of the patellar implants and largely unchanged patellofemoral offset, a highly significant increase in pressure after patellar resurfacing was measured. Therefore, from a biomechanical point of view, the preservation of the native patella seems reasonable if there is no higher grade patellar cartilage damage.

Patellar resurfacing complications in total knee arthroplasty

PURPOSE

The ideal management of the patella during total knee arthroplasty (TKA) is still controversial. Patellar retention is generally associated with an increased rate of anterior knee pain; however, patient satisfaction is similar in cases of replacement or retention. When the patella is replaced, potential severe complications can occur. Aim of this study was to retrospectively review results of a continuous series of patients having been treated with TKA and patella resurfacing.

METHODS

The charts of 1,600 consecutive total knee prostheses were analysed to evaluate the rate of patellar resurfacing. All implants were posterior stabilized; 310 patients having received a patellar replacement were reviewed at follow-up (FU) examination. Complete physical examination as well as administration of the Hospital for Special Surgery (HSS) score was performed. X-rays analysis included weightbearing anteroposterior (AP) and lateral views of the injured knee and bilateral skyline views at 30° flexion.

RESULTS

Two hundred and eighty patients were available for clinical and imaging investigation at an average FU of 96 (58-144) months. Mean age at the time of surgery was 70 (62-80) years. Mean HSS score was 85.9 ± 7.6. The overall rate of patellofemoral complications was 7% (19 cases); 13 patients claimed anterior knee pain, five had symptomatic patellar maltracking and one had patellar component loosening.

CONCLUSION

Our data are in accordance with those available in the literature. Recent meta-analyses demonstrated lower risk of re-operation after patellar resurfacing. However, when complications of the resurfaced patella occur, they can be potentially catastrophic events.

Failure modes of current total ankle replacement systems

Methodology for evaluation of total ankle replacements is described. Fusion and its problems are discussed as are those of total ankle joint replacement. Fusion is an imperfect solution because it reduces ankle functionality and has significant complications. Early fixed-bearing total ankles were long-term failures and abandoned. Currently available fixed-bearing ankles have proved inferior to fusion or are equivalent to earlier devices. Only mobile-bearing devices have been shown reasonably safe and effective. One such device, the STAR, has been approved by the Food and Drug Administration after a rigorous controlled clinical trial and is available for use in the United States.

The influence of patellar resurfacing on patellar kinetics and retropatellar contact characteristics

BACKGROUND

Femoropatellar complications are one of the most common problems after total knee arthroplasty (TKA). However, the question of whether to resurface the patella remains controversial. Therefore, we evaluated the kinetics and the retropatellar contact characteristics of patella resurfacing with fixed and gliding surfaces.

METHODS

Eight Thiel-embalmed cadaver knees were tested--first intact, then after TKA without patellar resurfacing, and finally with additional patellar resurfacing--while flexing the knee from 0° to 100°. We tested a fixed as well as a gliding patella surface. During the examination, quadriceps and hamstring forces were applied. The retropatellar pressure was determined with a special patella sensor, and the patellar kinetics were measured using an optical three-dimensional motion analysis system.

RESULTS

Resurfacing the patella caused a significant increase in retropatellar pressure and a significant decrease in retropatellar contact area. Using a fixed patella, the retropatellar pressure nearly quadrupled in higher flexion compared to the native patella. Furthermore, the lateral movement of the patella increased after TKA, especially after additional patellar resurfacing.

CONCLUSIONS

Resurfacing the patella routinely is not advised. When osteoarthritis of the patella is found, the gliding patella should be preferred.

The controversy of patellar resurfacing in total knee arthroplasty: Ibisne in medio tutissimus?

Early arthroplasty designs were associated with a high level of anterior knee pain as they failed to cater for the patello-femoral joint. Patellar resurfacing was heralded as the saviour safeguarding patient satisfaction and success but opinion on its necessity has since deeply divided the scientific community and has become synonymous to topics of religion or politics. Opponents of resurfacing contend that the native patella provides better patellar tracking, improved clinical function, and avoids implant-related complications, whilst proponents argue that patients have less pain, are overall more satisfied, and avert the need for secondary resurfacing. The question remains whether complications associated with patellar resurfacing including those arising from future component revision outweigh the somewhat increased incidence of anterior knee pain recorded in unresurfaced patients. The current scientific literature, which is often affected by methodological limitations and observer bias, remains confusing as it provides evidence in support of both sides of the argument, whilst blinded satisfaction studies comparing resurfaced and non-resurfaced knees generally reveal equivalent results. Even national arthroplasty register data show wide variations in the proportion of patellar resurfacing between countries that cannot be explained by cultural differences alone. Advocates who always resurface or never resurface indiscriminately expose the patella to a random choice. Selective resurfacing offers a compromise by providing a decision algorithm based on a propensity for improved clinical success, whilst avoiding potential complications associated with unnecessary resurfacing. Evidence regarding the validity of selection criteria, however, is missing, and the decision when to resurface is often based on intuitive reasoning. Our lack of understanding why, irrespective of pre-operative symptoms and patellar resurfacing, some patients may suffer pain following TKA and others may not have so far stifled our efforts to make the strategy of selective resurfacing succeed. We should hence devote our efforts in defining predictive criteria and indicators that will enable us to reliably identify those individuals who might benefit from a resurfacing procedure. Level of evidence V.

The patellar thinning osteotomy in patellofemoral arthritis: four to 18 years' follow-up

Isolated patellofemoral osteoarthritis can be a disabling disease. When conservative treatment fails, surgical options can be unpredictable and may be considered too aggressive for middle-aged and active people. We analysed the clinical and radiological results of a new coronal osteotomy involving thinning of the patella in a selected group of patients with isolated patellofemoral osteoarthritis. Since 1991, 31 patients (35 knees) have been treated, of whom 34 were available for follow-up at a mean of 9.1 years. The Knee Society Score, the Patellar score and the Short-form-36 questionnaire were used for clinical evaluation. We also examined the radiological features to confirm bone consolidation and assess the progression of osteoarthritis. A significant improvement in the functional scores and radiological parameters was noted. All patients except one were satisfied with the operation. Radiological progression of the patellofemoral osteoarthritis was slowed but radiological femorotibial osteoarthritis progressed in 23 (65%) cases, with a total knee replacement becoming necessary in four cases without technical problems in resurfacing the patella. We compared the results with other forms of surgical treatment reported in the literature. This treatment offers good clinical and radiological results, presenting an alternative method of managing patellofemoral osteoarthritis.

Contact stress at the anterior aspect of the tibial post in posterior-stabilized total knee replacement

BACKGROUND

Retrieval studies have demonstrated polyethylene wear and deformation of the anterior aspect of the tibial post of posterior-stabilized total knee replacements. We are not aware of any study that has analyzed the effects of the design of the femoral notch and the anterior aspect of the tibial post of posterior-stabilized total knee replacements on contact area, stress, and location. The purpose of the present study was to determine the levels of contact stress generated in three posterior-stabilized total knee replacement designs when the femoral intercondylar notch impinges on the anterior aspect of the tibial post.

METHODS

The contact area, mean and peak contact stresses, and contact location at the anterior aspect of the tibial post were determined when a posterior force of 100 N was applied to a NexGen LPS Flex, Genesis II, and Scorpio NRG total knee replacement. Measurements were performed at -15 degrees, -10 degrees, -5 degrees, 0 degrees, and 5 degrees of flexion of the femoral component both in neutral and with 5 degrees of rotation of the tibial component. Each measurement was sequentially performed five times, and the data were compared within and between the designs with use of analysis of variance and a post-hoc Scheffé F test.

RESULTS

The NexGen LPS Flex exhibited two contact areas on the medial and lateral corners of the anterior aspect of the post, whereas both the Genesis II and Scorpio NRG exhibited a single horizontal band. The NexGen LPS Flex showed the largest total contact area of the three designs at -15 degrees, -10 degrees, and 5 degrees of flexion. The NexGen LPS showed the lowest mean contact stress at -15 degrees and 5 degrees but showed the highest peak contact stress at -5 degrees and 0 degrees. The Scorpio NRG showed the highest mean contact stress under all conditions and showed the highest peak contact stress at -15 degrees, -10 degrees, and 5 degrees. With 5 degrees of rotation of the tibial component, peak contact stress increased, relative to neutral, 1.2 to twofold (depending on the flexion angle) in the Genesis II design.

CONCLUSIONS

The mean and peak contact stresses were variable for all three designs and the test conditions, approaching and in some cases exceeding the compressive yield stress for polyethylene. The geometry of the metal femoral notch and polyethylene tibial post in the axial and sagittal planes significantly affected contact area, mean and peak stresses, and contact location at the anterior aspect of the tibial post.

The influence of malrotation of the femoral component in total knee replacement on the mechanics of patellofemoral contact during gait: an in vitro biomechanical study

Malrotation of the femoral component is a cause of patellofemoral maltracking after total knee arthroplasty. Its precise effect on the patellofemoral mechanics has not been well quantified. We have developed an in vitro method to measure the influence of patellar maltracking on contact. Maltracking was induced by progressively rotating the femoral component either internally or externally. The contact mechanics were analysed using Tekscan. The results showed that excessive malrotation of the femoral component, both internally and externally, had a significant influence on the mechanics of contact. The contact area decreased with progressive maltracking, with a concomitant increase in contact pressure. The amount of contact area that carries more than the yield stress of ultra-high molecular weight polyethylene significantly increases with progressive maltracking. It is likely that the elevated pressures noted in malrotation could cause accelerated and excessive wear of the patellar button.

Differences in patellofemoral contact stresses between mobile-bearing and fixed-bearing total knee arthroplasties: a dynamic in vitro measurement

INTRODUCTION

Anterior knee pain is one of the most common problems after total knee arthroplasty (TKA). Mobile-bearing designs should improve patella tracking with a reduced rate of patella tilt as well as reduced patellofemoral contact stresses and improve knee flexion. The aim of this dynamic in vitro investigation was to evaluate the changes of patellofemoral contact stresses after TKA using fixed and mobile-bearing designs.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Seven knee specimens were mounted into a knee simulator imitating an isokinetic extension of the knee. The patellofemoral contact was measured before and after tricompartimental TKA with fixed and mobile-bearing designs using pressure-sensitive films. Contact stresses were measured from 120 degrees knee flexion to full extension with a simulated force of the quadriceps muscle up to 1,200 N. Additionally all measurements were performed with simulated co-contraction of the hamstrings muscles.

RESULTS

Fixed-bearing TKA increases patellofemoral contact stresses compared to physiologic conditions. After patella resurfacing, contact stresses increase even more. By changing the prosthesis design to mobile bearing, maximum contact stress was measured to be punctual higher than in fixed-bearing implants. In the interval between 0 degrees -30 degrees and 70 degrees -105 degrees of flexion, obviously lower pressures were evaluated for the mobile-bearing design. With cocontraction of the hamstrings, a lower contact stress of the mobile-bearing design was evident for the complete measurement of the knee extension.

CONCLUSION

An increase of patellofemoral contact stresses after patellar resurfacing in TKA could be demonstrated. This outcome implicates a higher risk of patellofemoral complications. The mobile-bearing design showed evidently lower patellofemoral contact stresses than the fixed-bearing design.

Effect of an UHMWPE patellar component on stress fields in the patella: a finite element analysis

An increased stress in the patella due to the implantation of a patellar button may also be another potential source of pain in total knee arthroplasty patients. This study assessed the location inside the patella having largest stress change after implantation of an ultra high molecular polyethylene patella button. Finite elements models of the patellae before and after implantation of patellar button were created. Experimentally determined spring constants of muscles and ligaments, and patellofemoral contacting loads were applied to the models at 30 degrees , 60 degrees , and 90 degrees of knee flexion. The Von Mises stress of the intact patella decreased with increased knee flexion, while that of implanted patella increased. Also, the stress range in the implanted patella was 3-9 times higher than in the intact one. The highly stressed region of the intact patella moved proximally with higher knee flexion angles, while that of the implanted model stayed near the central anterior patella. At 90 degrees of knee flexion, the stress in the anterodistal patella increased considerably after implantation of a patella button so that the anterodistal patella may be susceptible to be painful source after the total knee replacement.

UHMWPE for arthroplasty: past or future?

Wear debris related osteolysis is recognised as being the main cause of failure in joint replacements based on UHMWPE inserts. However, many solutions and "new" polyethylenes have been suggested in order to address this issue. This review discusses "historical" issues associated with UHMWPE, such as oxidation, sterilization method and storage, as well as "new" topics, such as crosslinking and stabilization. The final aim is to aid orthopaedic surgeons in their selection of polyethylene inserts and in the information given to the patients. The main problem for the polymer is degradative oxidation, which is caused by the combination of the irradiation used for sterilization and oxygen, and which leads to a decrease in wear resistance and mechanical properties. Irradiation and packaging in the absence of oxygen can only reduce the oxidation, while sterilization with gas (EtO or gas plasma) is the only method that effectively eliminates it. Manufacturing processes are of great relevance to the clinical duration and must be considered by surgeons. Crosslinked polyethylene has been developed for joint inserts due to its superior wear resistance compared to conventional UHMWPE; to prevent the oxidation, crosslinked polyethylene requires post-irradiation thermal treatment, which reduces its mechanical properties and which depends on the producer. Several good clinical results from the use of crosslinked acetabular cups have reported at mid-term, while early results for knee replacements are also encouraging. Recently, the use of the antioxidant vitamin E (alpha-tocopherol) has been introduced for joint prostheses in order to prevent the oxidation of both crosslinked and noncrosslinked UHMWPE.

Contact stress analysis of the conforming post-cam mechanism in posterior-stabilized total knee arthroplasty

The present study evaluated the effects of extent of conformity of post-cam design on contact area and stress at post-cam mechanism using 4 different posterior-stabilized prostheses. TRAC and Alpina with full-conformed post-cams exhibited the largest contact area at 90 degrees and 120 degrees . PFC sigma RPF with partial conformed post-cam had the largest contact area at 150 degrees . Scorpio NRG with less conformed post-cam had smaller contact area than the others. Lifting of femoral component decreased contact area and increased contact stress of TRAC and Alpina. Recent modifications of post-cam design have increased contact area, contributing to lower contact stress. None of these prostheses exhibited constant low contact stress throughout flexion. Further modifications of post-cam mechanism are necessary to provide lower contact stress throughout deep knee flexion.

Biomechanical effects of kneeling after total knee arthroplasty

BACKGROUND

Kneeling following total knee arthroplasty can be a difficult task, impairing the activities of patients to varying degrees. Little is known about the biomechanical effects of kneeling following total knee replacement. The objective of this study was to quantify the effects of kneeling on patellofemoral joint contact areas and pressures, knee joint reaction force, and patellar kinematics.

METHODS

Total knee arthroplasties were performed on eight fresh-frozen cadaveric knees, and they were tested with use of a custom knee jig, which permits the simulation of physiologic quadriceps loading as well as the application of an anterior force to simulate kneeling. The knees were tested at flexion angles of 90 degrees , 105 degrees , 120 degrees , and 135 degrees with no anterior force (mimicking a squatting position) and with an anterior force application simulating double-stance kneeling and single-stance kneeling. Patellofemoral joint contact areas and pressures were measured with pressure-sensitive film, and the knee joint reaction force was measured with use of a six-degree-of-freedom load cell. Patellar kinematics were assessed with use of digital photographs tracking fixed markers on the patella.

RESULTS

Compared with the condition without kneeling, both single-stance and double-stance kneeling demonstrated significant increases in patellofemoral contact area (p < 0.05) and pressure at all flexion angles (p < 0.05), with the exception of double-stance kneeling at 135 degrees of flexion. The resultant knee joint -reaction force increased with kneeling at all flexion angles. The compressive component of this force increased with kneeling for most conditions, while the lateral component of this force decreased significantly (p < 0.05) with kneeling only at 90 degrees , and the anterior component of this force increased significantly at all knee flexion angles (p < 0.05). Overall, kneeling had minimal changes on patellar tilt, with significant changes in patellar tilt seen only with kneeling at 120 degrees (p = 0.02 for double stance, and p = 0.03 for single stance).

CONCLUSIONS

The findings of this study suggest that kneeling at a higher flexion angle (135 degrees ) after total knee arthroplasty has a smaller effect on patellofemoral joint contact area and pressure than kneeling at lower flexion angles (<or=120 degrees ).

Effects of patellar resurfacing on contact area and contact stress in total knee arthroplasty

The objective of this study was to examine the effects of patellar resurfacing on patellofemoral joint contact pressure and contact area in total knee arthroplasty. We tested seven fresh-frozen cadaveric knees using a custom knee jig which permits the simulation of physiologic quadriceps loading. Before patellar resurfacing, the mean peak contact pressure of medial and lateral patellofemoral joints was less than 10 MPa at knee flexion angles of 30 degrees, 60 degrees and 90 degrees, that of medial and lateral patellofemoral joints were 11.63 MPa and 11.42 MPa at a knee flexion angle of 120 degrees respectively, and the mean contact area of patellofemoral joint ranged from 70 to 150 mm2. After patellar resurfacing, the mean peak contact pressure of medial and lateral patellofemoral joints ranged from 50 to 100 Mpa (P<0.05), which exceeds the yield strength of ultrahigh molecular weight polyethylene, and the mean contact area of patellofemoral joint reduced to 10-15 mm2 (P<0.05). The contact pressure of patellofemoral joint was lower than the yield strength of articular cartilage before patellar resurfacing. Our results indicate that the yield stress of UHMWPE is exceeded after patellar resurfacing.

Biomechanics of patellofemoral joint prostheses

We describe the biomechanics of the patellofemoral joint and of patellofemoral joint prostheses. It seemed that the designs and associated instruments that were studied had little research and development and that soft tissue realignment procedures often were needed because of pre-existing pathology. Factors that help these unicompartmental implants to integrate with the surrounding knee structures are discussed, particularly articular geometry, contact areas, forces and fixation. The desirability of patellar area contact geometry rather than axisymmetric buttons with point or line contact is discussed, in relation to their use in younger more active patients. Bone preservation relating to revision to total knee arthroplasty also is considered. Data on the articular geometry, stability and tracking of the designs studied are presented, showing that although most parameters are returned within normal limits, problems such as erratic subluxation-reduction effects may occur if the patellar component catches on the edge of the femoral component during knee flexion-extension. Through our results, we suggest that further implant and instrumentation research and development are needed before clinical trials leading to widespread use.

A clinical overview patellofemoral joint and application to total knee arthroplasty

The mechanical function of the patellofemoral joint is an integral part of knee biomechanics, and remains a primary source of important clinical entities. Force transmission is the most central issue and can be described by relevant anatomical and biomechanical principles. The brief review highlights these issues focusing on recent applications to total knee arthroplasty.

Kinematics of the patellofemoral joint in total knee arthroplasty

Sagittal plane patellofemoral kinematics was determined for 81 subjects while performing a weight-bearing deep knee bend under fluoroscopic surveillance. Fourteen normal knees, 12 anterior cruciate ligament (ACL)-deficient knees, and 55 total knee arthroplasties (TKAs) were assessed. Of TKAs, 39 had resurfacing with a dome-shaped patella, 8 had resurfacing with an anatomic mobile-bearing patella, and 8 were unresurfaced. TKA patellae experienced more superior patellofemoral contact and higher patellar tilt angles compared with the normal knees and ACL-deficient knees (P <.05). Patellofemoral separation at 5 degrees (+/-3 degrees ) extension was seen in 86% cruciate-retaining and 44% cruciate-stabilized TKAs and 8% ACL-deficient knees but not in the normal knees or mobile-bearing TKAs (P <.05). The patellar kinematic patterns for subjects having a TKA were more variable than subjects having either a normal knee or an ACL-deficient knee. Kinematic abnormalities of the prosthetic patellofemoral joint may reduce the effective extensor moment after TKA.

Failure of a cemented all-polyethylene patellar component of a Press-Fit Condylar Total Knee arthroplasty

A 65-year-old woman had a posterior cruciate-retaining cemented Press-Fit Condylar (PFC; Johnson & Johnson Professional, Inc., Raynham, MA) knee replacement with resurfacing of the patella using a cemented all-polyethylene, 3-peg component. Five years postoperatively, the patient developed anterior knee pain. The patella tracked normally, but radiographs showed a shift of the patellar component. At revision, there was shear failure of all 3 fixation pegs and loosening of the component. Revision with a cemented Press-Fit Condylar Sigma patellar 3-peg component (Johnson & Johnson Professional, Inc., Raynham, MA) was performed.

An in vivo determination of patellofemoral contact positions

OBJECTIVE

To determine patellofemoral contact patterns in two-dimensions for normal and implanted patients.

DESIGN

An in vivo, weightbearing fluoroscopy analysis of 14 subjects with normal knees, 12 with anterior cruciate ligament deficient knees, 14 with a posterior cruciate retaining implant, and 25 with a posterior cruciate substituting implant.

BACKGROUND

Most previous experimental studies involving the knee joint have been either in vitro or under nonweightbearing conditions.

METHODS

Subjects were studied under fluoroscopic surveillance performing deep knee bends to maximum flexion. Video images were analyzed on a computer with a two-dimensional technique of digitizing discrete points on the patella, femur, and tibia.

RESULTS

The contact position, measured from the patella mass center, was inferior on the patella at extension and moved superior during flexion. Average contact positions of the implanted knee groups were more superior than the normal knee group throughout the flexion cycle. Analysis of patellar tilt angle demonstrated a flexed posture of the patella relative to the tibia. Increase in patellar tilt angle with increasing femorotibial flexion was substantially greater in implanted knees versus normal knees. Separation of the patella from the femur in full extension was absent in normal knees, but present in 86% and 44% of posterior cruciate retaining and posterior cruciate substituting total knee arthroplasties, respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

The patellofemoral kinematics of the total knee arthroplasties analyzed in the study was statistically different than the normal and anterior cruciate ligament-deficient knees. The kinematic variations observed between normal and implanted knees may be related to disturbed femorotibial kinematics previously observed to occur following total knee arthroplasty.

RELEVANCE

Patellofemoral complications, including polyethylene wear, are a major concern in total knee arthroplasty. Since the causes of polyethylene wear are multi-factorial, abnormal patellofemoral kinematics may play a role in patellar failure.

An improved method for measuring tibiofemoral contact areas in total knee arthroplasty: a comparison of K-scan sensor and Fuji film

A computerised, real time, thin-film pressure transducer method is used to measure tibiofemoral contact area in total knee arthroplasty (TKA) devices that is easier and more reliable and reproducible as compared to the Fuji pressure-sensitive film technique. Many authors have suggested that contact areas and pressures within TKA devices can be a predictor of wear and failure of the ultra-high molecular weight polyethylene (UHMWPE) tibial insert. In this study, two contact area measurement techniques (Fuji pressure-sensitive Film and K-scan sensor system) were compared using a custom TKA testing jig designed for freedom of movement so that in any loading configuration the component found and seated in its own "home" position. The K-scan system was used to measure contact areas of one TKA design at several angles from 0 to 110 degrees flexion with loads equating to 4, 4.5, and 5 times body weight. For comparison, four ranges of Fuji film were used to measure areas at the same flexion angles but at 5 times body weight only. Contact areas measured with the Fuji films were 11-36% (p < 0.05) lower than those measured by the K-scan sensor.

Contact areas and pressures between native patellas and prosthetic femoral components

Contact areas and pressures between native patellas and a prosthetic condylar design femoral component were measured at flexion angles of 30 degrees, 60 degrees, and 90 degrees. These were compared to measurements obtained with a domed all-polyethylene patellar component. Mean native patellar contact areas were found to be fourfold greater than seen with the prosthetic patellar component. Contact stresses in the native patellas were below the yield strength of articular cartilage in 80% of the contact area. By contrast, stresses measured in the prosthetic patella exceeded the yield strength of ultrahigh molecular weight polyethylene in 64% of the measured contact area. Contact areas and stresses were not significantly effected by flexion angle. Although contact areas and stresses reflect only a part of the dynamics of the patellofemoral articulation this information would support the selective retention of the native patella in total knee arthroplasty.