Age of onset of depression and quantitative neuroanatomic measures: absence of specific correlates

The vascular depression hypothesis: mechanisms linking vascular disease with depression

The 'Vascular Depression' hypothesis posits that cerebrovascular disease may predispose, precipitate or perpetuate some geriatric depressive syndromes. This hypothesis stimulated much research that has improved our understanding of the complex relationships between late-life depression (LLD), vascular risk factors, and cognition. Succinctly, there are well-established relationships between LLD, vascular risk factors and cerebral hyperintensities, the radiological hallmark of vascular depression. Cognitive dysfunction is common in LLD, particularly executive dysfunction, a finding predictive of poor antidepressant response. Over time, progression of hyperintensities and cognitive deficits predicts a poor course of depression and may reflect underlying worsening of vascular disease. This work laid the foundation for examining the mechanisms by which vascular disease influences brain circuits and influences the development and course of depression. We review data testing the vascular depression hypothesis with a focus on identifying potential underlying vascular mechanisms. We propose a disconnection hypothesis, wherein focal vascular damage and white matter lesion location is a crucial factor, influencing neural connectivity that contributes to clinical symptomatology. We also propose inflammatory and hypoperfusion hypotheses, concepts that link underlying vascular processes with adverse effects on brain function that influence the development of depression. Testing such hypotheses will not only inform the relationship between vascular disease and depression, but also provide guidance on the potential repurposing of pharmacological agents that may improve LLD outcomes.

Organic bases of late-life depression: a critical update

Late-life depression (LLD) is frequently associated with cognitive impairment and increases the risk of subsequent dementia. Cerebrovascular disease, deep white matter lesions, Alzheimer disease (AD) and dementia with Lewy bodies (DLB) have all been hypothesized to contribute to this increased risk, and a host of studies have looked at the interplay between cerebrovascular disease and LLD. This has resulted in new concepts of LLD, such as "vascular depression", but despite multiple magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) studies in this field, the relationship between structural changes in human brain and LLD is still controversial. While pathological findings of suicide in some elderly persons revealed multiple lacunes, small vessel cerebrovascular disease, AD-related lesions or multiple neurodegenerative pathologies, recent autopsy data challenged the role of subcortical lacunes and white matter lesions as major morphological substrates of depressive symptoms as well as poorer executive function and memory. Several neuropathological studies, including a personal clinico-pathological study in a small cohort of elderly persons with LLD and age-matched controls confirmed that lacunes, periventricular and deep white matter demyelination as well as AD-related lesions are usually unrelated to the occurrence of LLD. In the same line, neuropathological data show that early-onset depression is not associated with an acceleration of age-related neurodegenerative changes. Very recent data on the critical role of glia-modulating neuronal dysfunction and degeneration in depression are discussed.

Neuropathological substrates and structural changes in late-life depression: the impact of vascular burden

A first episode of depression after 65 years of age has long been associated with both severe macrovascular and small microvascular pathology. Among the three more frequent forms of depression in old age, post-stroke depression has been associated with an abrupt damage of cortical circuits involved in monoamine production and mood regulation. Late-onset depression (LOD) in the absence of stroke has been related to lacunes and white matter lesions that invade both the neocortex and subcortical nuclei. Recurrent late-life depression is thought to induce neuronal loss in the hippocampal formation and white matter lesions that affect limbic pathways. Despite an impressive number of magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) studies in this field, the presence of a causal relationship between structural changes in the human brain and LOD is still controversial. The present article provides a critical overview of the contribution of neuropathology in post-stroke, late-onset, and late-life recurrent depression. Recent autopsy findings challenge the role of stroke location in the occurrence of post-stroke depression by pointing to the deleterious effect of subcortical lacunes. Despite the lines of evidences supporting the association between MRI-assessed white matter changes and mood dysregulation, lacunes, periventricular and deep white matter demyelination are all unrelated to the occurrence of LOD. In the same line, neuropathological data show that early-onset depression is not associated with an acceleration of aging-related neurodegenerative changes in the human brain. However, they also provide data in favor of the neurotoxic theory of depression by showing that neuronal loss occurs in the hippocampus of chronically depressed patients. These three paradigms are discussed in the light of the complex relationships between psychosocial determinants and biological vulnerability in affective disorders.

Amygdala volume in late-life depression: relationship with age of onset

OBJECTIVES

Depression is common in the elderly population. Although numerous neuroimaging studies have examined depressed elders, there is limited research examining how amygdala volume may be related to depression.

DESIGN

A cross-sectional examination of amygdala volume comparing elders with and without a diagnosis of major depressive disorder, and between depressed subjects with early and later initial depression onset.

SETTING

An academic medical center.

PARTICIPANTS

Ninety-one elderly patients meeting Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, Fourth Edition, criteria for major depression (54 early-onset depressed and 37 late-onset depressed) and 31 elderly subjects without any psychiatric diagnoses.

MEASUREMENTS

Amygdala and cerebral volumes were measured using reliable manual tracing methods.

RESULTS

In models controlling for age, sex, and cerebral volume, there was a significant difference between diagnostic cohorts in amygdala volume bilaterally (left: F[2, 116] = 16.28, p < 0.0001; right: F[2, 116] = 16.28, p < 0.0001). Using least squares mean group analyses, both early- and late-onset depressed subjects exhibited smaller bilateral amygdala volumes than did the nondepressed cohort (all comparisons p < 0.0001), but the two depressed cohorts did not exhibit a statistically significant difference.

LIMITATIONS

Limitations include missing antidepressant treatment data, recall bias, inability to establish a causal relationship between amygdala size and depression given the cross-sectional nature of the design.

CONCLUSIONS

Depression in later life is associated with smaller amygdala volumes, regardless of age of initial onset of depression.

Persistent depressive symptoms after acute coronary syndrome are associated with compromised white matter integrity in the anterior cingulate: a pilot study

BACKGROUND

Persistent depressive symptoms after acute coronary syndrome (ACS) are common and increase the risk of recurrent cardiac events and mortality. However, the neurobiological correlates of post-ACS depressive symptoms have not yet been studied.

METHODS

Three months after ACS, 22 patients were scanned for the presence of cerebral deep white matter changes and microstructural abnormalities in the anterior cingulate cortex (ACC) and dorsolateral prefrontal cortex. We used the Coffey Rating Scale of deep white matter changes and measures of fractional anisotropy derived from diffusion tensor imaging. Patients also completed the Beck Depression Inventory, and the number of cardiovascular comorbidities as well as modifiable cardiovascular risk factors were assessed.

RESULTS

Controlling for cardiovascular comorbidity, depressive symptom severity at 3 months was negatively related to fractional anisotropy in the ACC (r = -0.72, p < 0.001), but this association disappeared when controlling for cardiovascular risk factors (p = 0.21). In comparison to patients who were non-depressed at 3 months after hospitalization (n = 14), patients with persistent depressive symptoms (n = 8) exhibited more advanced deep white matter changes overall (p < 0.02), but not when controlling for cardiovascular comorbidity. Persistently depressed patients also had lower fractional anisotropy in the ACC (p < 0.05), but this effect disappeared when controlling for modifiable cardiovascular risk factors.

CONCLUSIONS

This study provides the first evidence that persistent depressive symptoms after ACS are associated with vascular brain changes. Longitudinal studies are needed to determine whether depressive symptoms precede these changes or vice versa.

Brain volume abnormalities in major depressive disorder: a meta-analysis of magnetic resonance imaging studies

OBJECTIVE

So far, there have been no attempts to integrate the growing number of all brain volumetric magnetic resonance imaging studies in depression. In this comprehensive meta-analysis the magnitude and extent of brain volume differences between 2,418 patients with major depressive disorder and 1,974 healthy individuals from 64 studies was determined.

METHODS

A systematic research was conducted for volumetric magnetic resonance imaging studies of patients with major depressive disorder in relation to healthy control subjects. Studies had to report sufficient data for computation of effect sizes. For each study, the Cohen's d was calculated. All analyses were performed using the random effects model. Additionally, meta-regression analyses were done to explore the effects of potential sources of heterogeneity.

RESULTS

Patients showed large volume reductions in frontal regions, especially in the anterior cingulate and orbitofrontal cortex with smaller reductions in the prefrontal cortex. The hippocampus, the putamen and caudate nucleus showed moderate volume reductions.

CONCLUSIONS

This is the first comprehensive meta-analysis in major depressive disorder demonstrating structural brain abnormalities, particularly in those brain areas that are involved in emotion processing and stress-regulation.

Elders with first psychiatric hospitalization for depression

OBJECTIVE

Little is known about the first psychiatric hospitalization episode of older adults with depression. The purpose of this study is to describe the proportion and characteristics of first-time inpatients admitted for late-life depression.

METHODS

Guided by the Network Episode Model and the Andersen model, this study identifies and compares the characteristics of depressed older adults with (n = 108) and those without (n = 77) prior psychiatric hospitalization, upon admission into the geropsychiatric unit, using logistic regression. Data on a lifetime history of inpatient psychiatric treatment, clinical characteristics, demographics, social resources, and psychosocial/medical service use were obtained from patients' medical records and self-reports.

RESULTS

Compared with patients who had prior psychiatric admission, first-time inpatients were associated with having: (1) late-onset depression (OR = 14.99); (2) no lifetime psychotic symptoms (OR = 0.21); (3) lower scores on the Brief Psychiatric Rating Scale (BPRS) at admission (OR = 0.96); (4) higher numbers of doctors seen (OR = 1.46); and (5) lower use of senior centers 6 months prior to the admission (OR = 0.12).

CONCLUSIONS

Depressed older adults' prior psychiatric inpatient service utilization is closely related to their past and current psychiatric needs. Also, the two groups show significant differences in health and social service use prior to the psychiatric hospitalization. However, severity of depression at admission was not different.

Separating mood disturbance from mild cognitive impairment in geriatric depression

Disentangling depression from dementia remains one of the most difficult clinical challenges for psychiatrists caring for older adults. The relationship between geriatric depression and dementia is complex for several reasons. First, cognitive impairment is often a prominent feature of depression in the elderly. Cognition may improve with successful treatment of depression but it may not normalize. Indeed, marked memory impairment in older depressed individuals may indicate a prodromal state of dementia. This review will examine issues related to depression and cognitive disorder in the elderly. The author will provide an evidence-based approach to separate mood disorder from cognitive disorder among older adults.

The brain-derived neurotrophic factor VAL66MET polymorphism and cerebral white matter hyperintensities in late-life depression

OBJECTIVE

In animal models, brain-derived neurotrophic factor (BDNF) appears to protect against cerebral ischemia. The authors examined whether the BDNF Val66Met polymorphism, which affects BDNF distribution, was associated with greater volumes of hyperintense lesions as detected on magnetic resonance imaging in a cohort of depressed and nondepressed elders.

DESIGN

Subjects completed cross-sectional assessments, including clinical evaluation and a brain magnetic resonance imaging scan, and provided blood samples for Val66Met genotyping.

SETTING

The study was conducted at a university-based academic hospital.

PARTICIPANTS

Participants included 199 depressed and 113 nondepressed subjects aged 60 years or older.

MEASUREMENT

Hyperintensity lesion volumes were measured using a semiautomated segmentation procedure. Statistical models examined the relationship between genotype and lesion volume while controlling for depression, presence of hypertension, age, and sex.

RESULTS

After controlling for covariates, Met66 allele carriers exhibited significantly greater white matter hyperintensity volumes (F(1,311) = 4.09, p = 0.0442). This effect was independent of a diagnosis of depression or report of hypertension. Genotype was not significantly related to gray matter hyperintensity volume (F(1,311) = 1.14, p = 0.2871).

CONCLUSIONS

The BDNF Met66 allele is associated with greater white matter hyperintensity volumes in older individuals. Further work is needed to determine how this may be associated with other clinically relevant findings in late-life depression.

Geriatric depression and cognitive impairment

Cognitive impairment is common in geriatric depression, and depressed individuals with co-morbid cognitive impairment are at increased risk for a number of adverse medical, psychiatric and cognitive outcomes. This review focuses on clinical issues surrounding the co-occurrence of these two conditions within the context of current research. We (1) review the clinical criteria and prevalence of depression, as well as co-morbid cognitive impairment, (2) discuss factors associated with persistent cognitive impairment in depression, including dementia, and (3) review research relevant to the assessment and treatment of cognitive impairment and dementia in the context of depression. We conclude that current research on depression and cognition can inform clinical decisions that reduce the occurrence of adverse outcomes. Clinicians are encouraged to develop proactive approaches for treatment, which may include combinations of pharmacological and psychotherapeutic interventions.

Volumetric brain imaging studies in the elderly with mood disorders

Volumetric neuroimaging studies of the elderly with affective disorders provide important insights into the underlying physiology of the illnesses. Advantages of studying the elderly include the ability to make various assessments and obtain a history differentiating subtypes of illness. However, challenges to studying the elderly include the heterogeneity of affective illnesses and confounds of medical comorbidity and medications. Volumetric assessments have provided important information in the neural mechanisms of mood regulation, especially in the overlap of cognitive disorders. This article reviews articles describing findings of volumetric analyses in elderly with unipolar depression and bipolar disorders, and compares and contrasts these findings with the larger volumetric research in affective disorders.

Greater MRI lesion volumes in elderly depressed subjects than in control subjects

Hyperintense lesions in both white matter and gray matter on T2-weighted magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) are associated with late-life depression. This large study examined differences in gray and white matter lesion volumes on brain MRI between 253 elderly depressed and 146 control subjects. White matter and gray matter lesion volumes were measured in each hemisphere using a semi-automated segmentation process and compared against depression status. Depressed subjects exhibited significantly greater total white matter (mean 7.22 ml) and gray matter (mean 0.30 ml) lesion volumes in both hemispheres than did control subjects (mean 4.87 ml in white matter and 0.18 ml in gray matter). This difference remained statistically significant even after controlling for confounders such as age, sex, race and reports of hypertension, diabetes and heart disease. Patients with late-life depression have larger white matter lesion and gray matter lesion volumes than do control subjects. Future research should combine similar volumetric techniques with methods of identifying the location of lesions specific to late-life depression.

Hippocampal changes and white matter lesions in early-onset depression

BACKGROUND

Hippocampal volume reduction and increased prevalence of subcortical white matter lesions have been reported in late-life depression. We aimed to examine whether total number of subcortical white matter lesions were associated with reduced hippocampal volume in aged female subjects with early-onset depression (< 45 years) and healthy comparison subjects.

METHODS

The study included 28 middle-aged and elderly subjects with major depression and 41 age-matched control subjects. Hippocampal, parahippocampal gyrus, and orbitofrontal cortex volumes were determined using manual tracing methods. White matter lesions were rated from T2-weighted MRI scans using a semiquantitative classification scale.

RESULTS

After controlling for total brain volume and age, patients had reduced hippocampal volume due to right hippocampal volume decrease (2.84 mL vs. 3.12 mL, F = 16.6, p < .001). Parahippocampal and orbitofrontal volumes did not differ significantly between groups. Multiple linear regression analysis indicated that reduced hippocampal volume did not significantly correlate with total number of subcortical white matter lesions (t = .673, p = .518).

CONCLUSIONS

Right hippocampal volume was reduced in aged female early-onset subjects with depression. Total number of subcortical white matter lesions was not associated with the decrease in right hippocampal volume. Our data suggest hippocampal involvement, independent of subcortical white matter lesions, in the neuropathology of early-onset depression.

Clinical characteristics of magnetic resonance imaging-defined subcortical ischemic depression

BACKGROUND

There is a substantial body of research supporting the vascular depression hypothesis of late-life depression. To update this hypothesis so it incorporates recent research, we propose that the term subcortical ischemic vascular depression may be a more accurate representation of the disease process. We sought to investigate this diagnosis as a construct by examining differences between depressed subjects with and without magnetic resonance imaging defined subcortical ischemic vascular depression.

METHODS

This case-control study examined 139 depressed elderly subjects. Demographic data, psychiatric, medical, and family history, depressive symptomatology, and functional impairment were compared between groups dichotomized based on neuroimaging findings.

RESULTS

Seventy-five (54%) of the subjects met neuroimaging criteria for subcortical ischemic vascular depression. Age was most strongly associated with increased prevalence of subcortical ischemic vascular depression. Lassitude and a history of hypertension were also positively associated with the diagnosis; a family history of mental illness and loss of libido were negatively associated with the diagnosis.

CONCLUSIONS

These data support that subcortical ischemic vascular depression may be a specific syndrome from other types of late-life depression. Further research is needed to further characterize this disorder, particularly in regards to cognitive function and treatment implications.

Serial MR imaging of volumes of hyperintense white matter lesions in elderly patients: correlation with vascular risk factors

OBJECTIVE

The purpose of the study was to examine change in volume of hyperintense white matter lesions in a cohort of community-dwelling elderly subjects without neuropsychiatric disease. SUBJECTS AND METHODS. One hundred seventeen volunteers underwent brain MR imaging on a 1.5-T scanner. Demographic data and the presence of specific medical illnesses were recorded at the time of the initial scanning. Hyperintense white matter lesion volume was measured using a supervised semiautomated technique that seeded lesions and then created a segmented lesion image. Subjects underwent repeated MR imaging at a mean of 25 months. Mean change in lesion volume and mean percentage of change were determined between the two time points. Logistic regression models were used to examine the differential effects of age, sex, race, and self-reported medical morbidity.

RESULTS

Mean baseline volume of cerebral hyperintense lesions was 4.91 cc, and at 2-year follow-up, it was 6.42 cm(2) (p < 0.0001), for a mean increase of 26.7%. Comparable results were seen in separate analyses of hemispheric hyperintense lesion volumes. Neither sex, race, nor baseline hyperintense lesion volume was significantly associated with an interval increase in lesion volume. Age (p = 0.0117) and presence of diabetes (p = 0.0215) were associated with greater change.

CONCLUSION

Elderly subjects exhibited approximately a 27% increase in hyperintense lesion volume over a 2-year period, a finding influenced by both age and medical comorbidity rates. Because hyperintense lesions can be associated with several neuropsychiatric conditions, further research is needed to determine if interventions designed to slow hyperintense lesion disease progression may improve neuropsychiatric outcomes.

Localization of age-associated white matter hyperintensities in late-life depression

OBJECTIVE

Deep white matter hyperintense lesions are associated with advanced age and late-life depression. The authors examined where age-related cerebral lesions occurred in elderly depressed and healthy control subjects.

METHODS

Eighty-seven depressed subjects and 47 control subjects underwent 1.5 T cranial magnetic resonance imaging (MRI). Utilizing a semiautomated method, a segmented image was created containing only white matter lesions. We created a statistical parametric map (SPM) separately for each subject group that displayed the association between lesions in any voxel and advanced age.

RESULTS

The SPM analysis in depressed subjects demonstrates a significant association between age and lesions found in bilateral, frontal, and left parietal regions. The analysis in control subjects found significant associations only in bilateral parieto-temporal regions, not frontal regions.

CONCLUSIONS

This study demonstrates a different pattern of age-related lesion location between depressed and control subjects. It further supports the theory that frontostriatal disconnection contributes to late-life depression.

MRI subcortical hyperintensities in old and very old depressed outpatients: the important role of age in late-life depression

OBJECTIVE

There is increasing evidence that cerebrovascular factors play a key role in the etiology of late-life depression. This study examined the severity of subcortical hyperintensities (SH) and the relationship between SH and depression characteristics in two samples of elderly depressed outpatients differing in age.

METHODS

The samples consisted of 59 subjects age 60 and over, (69+/-5.6 years), who participated in a trial of sertraline, and 111 subjects age 75 and over, (79+/-4.1 years), who participated in a trial of citalopram.

RESULTS

The citalopram group was significantly older than the sertraline group and had more severe SH (72% vs. 42% high ratings). The High SH group was significantly older than the Low SH group in the sertraline study but there was no difference in age in the SH groups in the citalopram sample. There was no relationship between SH severity and baseline depression or age of onset. However, age strongly correlated with later age of onset. There was no relationship between SH severity and cardiovascular risk factors or treatment response in the sertraline sample.

CONCLUSION

Age is a major factor for the development of SH and late-life depression. There may not be an association between SH and depression severity, cardiovascular risk factors, or treatment response in geriatric depressed outpatients. The etiologic factors and clinical course of late-life depression requires further study.

Is late onset depression a prodrome to dementia?

BACKGROUND

Recent research suggests there are clinical and biological differences between late onset depression (LOD) and early-onset depression (EOD).

OBJECTIVES

In this paper we review clinical, epidemiological, structural neuroimaging and genetic investigations of late life depression that have been performed over the past two decades and offer evidence that LOD is often a prodromal disorder for dementia.

RESULTS

LOD patients are more likely to have cognitive impairment and to have more deep white matter lesions (DWMLs). Evidence concerning cortical and temporal lobe atrophy is conflicting, while the ApoE 4 allele is not associated with LOD.

CONCLUSIONS

It is likely that LOD is not a prodrome for a particular type of dementia, but the majority of patients who do develop dementia will acquire Alzheimer's disease (AD) or a vascular dementia, as these are by far the most common causes of dementia. This issue requires further clarification with follow-up of patients over the long term.

Structural neuroimaging studies in late-life depression: a review

Which patients presenting with depression in late life will progress to a dementia syndrome has been an important research question in recent times. In this paper we review selectively structural neuroimaging investigations of late-life depression (LLD) that have been performed over the past two decades. These studies indicate that there are neuroimaging changes commonly observed in LLD patients when compared to normal controls. Findings include ventricular enlargement and sulcal widening, and reduction in volume size of frontal lobes, hippocampus and caudate nucleus. White matter lesions are more common in depressed subjects and tend to be more severe. Some studies report these changes to be more pronounced in patients who present with late-onset depression (LOD) but this has been contradicted by other studies. Preliminary work suggests that these changes may be associated with a poor prognosis but there is a dearth of systematic, well-controlled longitudinal studies.

Neuroanatomic substrates of late-life mental disorders

Advances in magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) techniques have made it possible to quantify anatomic brain abnormalities in neuropsychiatric disorders. This review focuses on controlled, quantitative MRI studies in depression, degenerative disorders, and psychosis in the elderly. Although many of the anatomic abnormalities detected are observed across disorders, the patterns of regional involvement may be more selective and disorder specific. We integrate MRI findings with relevant clinical and neurobiologic observations in an attempt to develop a cohesive model of late-life psychiatric illness. Although the model primarily alludes to the pathophysiology of late-life depression, it may have broader biologic implications for other mental disorders in the elderly.