Electrooptical relaxation spectrometry of membrane electroporation in lipid vesicles

Lipid vesicles in pulsed electric fields: Fundamental principles of the membrane response and its biomedical applications

The present review focuses on the effects of pulsed electric fields on lipid vesicles ranging from giant unilamellar vesicles (GUVs) to small unilamellar vesicles (SUVs), from both fundamental and applicative perspectives. Lipid vesicles are the most popular model membrane systems for studying biophysical and biological processes in living cells. Furthermore, as vesicles are made from biocompatible and biodegradable materials, they provide a strategy to create safe and functionalized drug delivery systems in health-care applications. Exposure of lipid vesicles to pulsed electric fields is a common physical method to transiently increase the permeability of the lipid membrane. This method, termed electroporation, has shown many advantages for delivering exogenous molecules including drugs and genetic material into vesicles and living cells. In addition, electroporation can be applied to induce fusion between vesicles and/or cells. First, we discuss in detail how research on cell-size GUVs as model cell systems has provided novel insight into the basic mechanisms of cell electroporation and associated phenomena. Afterwards, we continue with a thorough overview how electroporation and electrofusion have been used as versatile methods to manipulate vesicles of all sizes in different biomedical applications. We conclude by summarizing the open questions in the field of electroporation and possible future directions for vesicles in the biomedical field.

Lipid membranes in external electric fields: kinetics of large pore formation causing rupture

About 40 years ago, Helfrich introduced an elastic model to explain shapes and shape transitions of cells (Z Naturforsch C, 1973; 28:693). This seminal article stimulated numerous theoretical as well as experimental investigations and created new research fields. In particular, the predictive power of his approach was demonstrated in a large variety of lipid model system. Here in this review, we focus on the development with respect to planar lipid membranes in external electric fields. Stimulated by the early work of Helfrich on electric field forces acting on liposomes, we extended his early approach to understand the kinetics of lipid membrane rupture. First, we revisit the main forces determining the kinetics of membrane rupture followed by an overview on various experiments. Knowledge on the kinetics of defect formation may help to design stable membranes or serve for novel mechanism for controlled release.

Transient oscillation of shape and membrane conductivity changes by field pulse-induced electroporation in nano-sized phospholipid vesicles

The results of electrooptical and conductometrical measurements on unilamellar lipid vesicles (of mean radius a = 90 nm), filled with 0.2 M NaCl solution, suspended in 0.33 M sucrose solution of 0.2 mM NaCl, and exposed to a stepwise decaying electric field (time constant τE = 154 μs) in the range 10 ≤ E0 (kV cm(-1)) ≤ 90, are analyzed in terms of cyclic changes in vesicle shape and vesicle membrane conductivity. The two peaks in the dichroitic turbidity relaxations reflect two cycles of rapid membrane electroporation and slower resealing of long-lived electropores. The field-induced changes reflect structural transitions between closed (C) and porated (P) membrane states, qualified by pores of type P1 and of type P2, respectively. The transient change in the membrane conductivity and the transient shape oscillation are based on changes in the pore density of the (larger) P2-pores along a hysteresis cycle. The P2-pore formation leads to transient net ion flows across the P2-pores and to transient changes in the membrane field. The kinetic data are numerically processed in terms of coupled structural relaxation modes. Using the torus-hole pore model, the mean inner pore radii are estimated to be r1 = 0.38 (±0.05) nm and r2 = 1.7 (±0.1) nm, respectively. The observation of a transient oscillation of membrane electroporation and of shape changes in a longer lasting external field pulse is suggestive of potential resonance enhancement, for instance, of electro-uptake by, and of electro-release of biogenic molecules from, biological cells in trains of long-lasting low-intensity voltage pulses.

Giant vesicles in electric fields

This review is dedicated to electric field effects on giant unilamellar vesicles, a cell-size membrane system. We summarize various types of behavior observed when vesicles are subjected either to weak AC fields at various frequency, or to strong DC pulses. Different processes such as electro-deformation, -poration and -fusion of giant vesicles are considered. We describe some recent developments, which allowed us to detect the dynamics of the vesicle response with a resolution below milliseconds for all of these processes. Novel aspects on electric field effects on vesicles in the gel phase are introduced.

Electric pulses induce cylindrical deformations on giant vesicles in salt solutions

In this article, we report for the first time unusual shape changes of vesicles subjected to strong electric pulses in salt solutions of low concentration. The electric field is created by two parallel electrodes between which the vesicle solution is located. Surprisingly, the vesicles assume cylindrical shapes during the pulse. These deformations are short-lived (their lifetime is approximately 1 ms) and occur only in the presence of salt outside the vesicles, irrespective of their content. When the solution conductivities inside and outside are the same, vesicles with square cross section are observed. Using a fast digital camera, we were able to record these deformations and study the vesicle shape dynamics. The aims of this article are to report the new vesicle morphologies and their dynamics and to provoke theoretical work in this direction.

Cholesterol reduces membrane electroporation and electric deformation of small bilayer vesicles

Electric fields, similar in the order of magnitude of the natural membrane fields of cellular lipid/protein membranes, and chemical relaxation spectrometry can be used as tools to quantify the rigidifying effect of cholesterol in membranes. Small unilamellar vesicles of radius a=50+/-3 nm, prepared form phosphatidylcholine, phosphatidylserine and phosphatidyl-glycerol in the molar ratio 1:1:1 and containing the optical lipid probe molecule 2-(3-diphenyl-hexatrienyl) propanoyl)-1-palmitoyl-sn-glycerol-3-phosphocholine (beta-DPH pPC), serve as examples for curved lipid membranes. The data of electrooptical turbidity and absorbance relaxations at the wavelength lambda=365 nm are analysed in terms of membrane bending rigidity kappa and membrane stretching modulus K. Both kappa and K increase with increasing mole fraction x of cholesterol up to x=0.5. The cholesterol induced denser packing of the lipids reduces the extent of both membrane electroporation (ME) and electroelongation of the vesicles. Further on, cholesterol in the lipid phase and sucrose in the aqueous suspension reduce the extent of membrane undulation and electro-stretching.

Electro-deformation and poration of giant vesicles viewed with high temporal resolution

Fast digital imaging was used to study the deformation and poration of giant unilamellar vesicles subjected to electric pulses. For the first time the dynamics of response and relaxation of the membrane at micron-scale level is revealed at a time resolution of 30 micros. Above a critical transmembrane potential the lipid bilayer ruptures. Formation of macropores (diameter approximately 2 microm) with pore lifetime of approximately 10 ms has been detected. The pore lifetime has been interpreted as interplay between the pore edge tension and the membrane viscosity. The reported data, covering six decades of time, show the following regimes in the relaxation dynamics of the membrane. Tensed vesicles first relax to release the acquired stress due to stretching, approximately 100 micros. In the case of poration, membrane resealing occurs with a characteristic time of approximately 10 ms. Finally, for vesicles with excess area an additional slow regime was observed, approximately 1 s, which we associate with relaxation of membrane curvature. Dimensional analysis can reasonably well explain the corresponding characteristic timescales. Being performed on cell-sized giant unilamellar vesicles, this study brings insight to cell electroporation. The latter is widely used for gene transfection and drug transport across the membrane where processes occurring at different timescales may influence the efficiency.

Digression on membrane electroporation for drug and gene delivery

Membrane electroporation (ME) defines an electrical technique to render lipid membranes porous and permeable, transiently and reversibly, by external voltage pulses. Although there are numerous applications of ME to manipulate cells, organelles and tissues in cell biology, biotechnology and medicine, yet the molecular mechanism of ME is only slowly being understood. A general chemical- thermodynamical approach for the quantitative description of cell membrane electroporation has been developed to provide the framework to quantitatively rationalize electroporative cell transformation and electroporative uptake of drug-like dyes into cells, as well as electrolyte efflux from salt-filled electroporated vesicles. Mechanistically, the electroporative transfer of gene and drug-like dyes involves the coupling between an interactive contact formation of the permeates with the cell surface membrane and the structural electroporation-resealing cycle C <--> (P) where C is the closed and (P) represents a number of different porated membrane states, respectively. The experimentally accessible concentration fraction f(p) = [(P)] / ([C] + [(P)]) of porous states is related to thermodynamic and electro-mechanic parameters such as temperature and the electric field strength, membrane rigidity or curvature. The results of the theoretical approach, mainly based on electrooptical data of lipid vesicles, have been successfully used to analyze single cells and to specify conditions for the practical purpose of direct electroporative gene transfer and drug delivery, in particular in the new medical disciplines of electroporative chemotherapy and electroporative gene vaccination.