Are we destined to repeat history?

Current strategies for protein production and purification enabling membrane protein structural biology

Membrane proteins are still heavily under-represented in the protein data bank (PDB), owing to multiple bottlenecks. The typical low abundance of membrane proteins in their natural hosts makes it necessary to overexpress these proteins either in heterologous systems or through in vitro translation/cell-free expression. Heterologous expression of proteins, in turn, leads to multiple obstacles, owing to the unpredictability of compatibility of the target protein for expression in a given host. The highly hydrophobic and (or) amphipathic nature of membrane proteins also leads to challenges in producing a homogeneous, stable, and pure sample for structural studies. Circumventing these hurdles has become possible through the introduction of novel protein production protocols; efficient protein isolation and sample preparation methods; and, improvement in hardware and software for structural characterization. Combined, these advances have made the past 10-15 years very exciting and eventful for the field of membrane protein structural biology, with an exponential growth in the number of solved membrane protein structures. In this review, we focus on both the advances and diversity of protein production and purification methods that have allowed this growth in structural knowledge of membrane proteins through X-ray crystallography, nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy, and cryo-electron microscopy (cryo-EM).

Hijacked then lost in translation: the plight of the recombinant host cell in membrane protein structural biology projects

•

Membrane protein structural biologists need high-quality protein for crystallisation.

•

Recombinant proteins are central to the structural biology supply chain.

•

Understanding quality control in protein production is an emerging trend.

•

The roles of translation and protein folding in the host cell are examined.

Membrane protein structural biology is critically dependent upon the supply of high-quality protein. Over the last few years, the value of crystallising biochemically characterised, recombinant targets that incorporate stabilising mutations has been established. Nonetheless, obtaining sufficient yields of many recombinant membrane proteins is still a major challenge. Solutions are now emerging based on an improved understanding of recombinant host cells; as a ‘cell factory’ each cell is tasked with managing limited resources to simultaneously balance its own growth demands with those imposed by an expression plasmid. This review examines emerging insights into the role of translation and protein folding in defining high-yielding recombinant membrane protein production in a range of host cells.

Creation of cross-linked bilayer membranes that can incorporate membrane proteins from oligo-Asp-based peptide gemini surfactants

We designed novel bilayer-forming amphiphiles based on the cyclic oligo-Asp-based peptide gemini (PG) surfactants cr-D2C12 and cr-D3C12, which consist of -Cys(Asp)nCys- (n = 2 or 3) as a core peptide and two Cys residues containing a dodecylamidomethyl group. Dynamic light scattering and transmission electron microscopy measurements revealed the formation of spherical bilayer membranes that could incorporate the light-harvesting antenna complex 2 (LH2) from Rhodopseudomonas acidophila . Furthermore, this proteoliposome-like conjugate could be assembled onto cationized glass and mica to form planar bilayer membranes incorporating LH2. Using atomic force microscopy, we observed LH2 protruding (ca. 1.2-1.5 nm) from flat terraces of the planar bilayer membranes formed from cr-D2C12 or cr-D3C12. Thus, our designed PG surfactants are a new class of bilayer-forming amphiphiles that may be applied to the study of various membrane proteins.

Predicting experimental properties of integral membrane proteins by a naive Bayes approach

Integral membrane proteins (iMPs) are challenging targets for structure determination because of the substantial experimental difficulties involved in their sample preparation. Accordingly, success rates of large-scale structural genomics consortia are much lower for this class of molecules compared to globular targets, underscoring the pressing need for predictive strategies to identify iMPs that are more likely to overcome laboratory bottlenecks. On the basis of the target status information available in the TargetDB repository, we describe the first large-scale analysis of experimental behavior of iMPs. Using information on recalcitrant and propagating iMP targets as negative and positive sets, respectively, we present naive Bayes classifiers capable of predicting, from sequence alone, those proteins that are more amenable to cloning, expression, and solubilization studies. Protein sequences are represented in the space of 72 features, including amino acid composition, occurrence of amino acid groups, ratios between residue groups, and hydrophobicity measures. Taking into account unequal representation of main taxonomic groups in the TargetDB, sequence database had a beneficial effect on the prediction results. The classifiers achieve accuracies of 70%, 63-70%, and 61% in predicting the amenability of iMPs for cloning, expression, and solubilization, respectively, thus making them useful tools in target selection for structure determination. Our assessment of prediction results clearly demonstrates that classifiers based on single features do not possess acceptable discriminative power and that the experimental behavior of iMPs is imprinted in their primary sequence through relationships between a restricted set of key properties. In most cases, sets of 10-20 protein features were found actually relevant, most notably, the content of isoleucine, valine, and positively-charged residues.

The gramicidin ion channel: A model membrane protein

The linear peptide gramicidin forms prototypical ion channels specific for monovalent cations and has been extensively used to study the organization, dynamics and function of membrane-spanning channels. In recent times, the availability of crystal structures of complex ion channels has challenged the role of gramicidin as a model membrane protein and ion channel. This review focuses on the suitability of gramicidin as a model membrane protein in general, and the information gained from gramicidin to understand lipid-protein interactions in particular. Special emphasis is given to the role and orientation of tryptophan residues in channel structure and function and recent spectroscopic approaches that have highlighted the organization and dynamics of the channel in membrane and membrane-mimetic media.

Defining the fold space of membrane proteins: the CAMPS database

Recent progress in structure determination techniques has led to a significant growth in the number of known membrane protein structures, and the first structural genomics projects focusing on membrane proteins have been initiated, warranting an investigation of appropriate bioinformatics strategies for optimal structural target selection for these molecules. What determines a membrane protein fold? How many membrane structures need to be solved to provide sufficient structural coverage of the membrane protein sequence space? We present the CAMPS database (Computational Analysis of the Membrane Protein Space) containing almost 45,000 proteins with three or more predicted transmembrane helices (TMH) from 120 bacterial species. This large set of membrane proteins was subjected to single-linkage clustering using only sequence alignments covering at least 40% of the TMH present in a given family. This process yielded 266 sequence clusters with at least 15 members, roughly corresponding to membrane structural folds, sufficiently structurally homogeneous in terms of the variation of TMH number between individual sequences. These clusters were further subdivided into functionally homogeneous subclusters according to the COG (Clusters of Orthologous Groups) system as well as more stringently defined families sharing at least 30% identity. The CAMPS sequence clusters are thus designed to reflect three main levels of interest for structural genomics: fold, function, and modeling distance. We present a library of Hidden Markov Models (HMM) derived from sequence alignments of TMH at these three levels of sequence similarity. Given that 24 out of 266 clusters corresponding to membrane folds already have associated known structures, we estimate that 242 additional new structures, one for each remaining cluster, would provide structural coverage at the fold level of roughly 70% of prokaryotic membrane proteins belonging to the currently most populated families.

Key roles for chain flexibility in block copolymer membranes that contain pores or make tubes

Block copolymer amphiphiles that self-assemble into membranes present robust and functionalizable alternatives to biological assemblies. Coarse-grained molecular dynamics shows that thick bilayers of A-B copolymers accommodate protein-like channels and also tend to regulate transport. This occurs as flexible, hydrophilic A chains insert into the pore and obstruct water entry. A-B-A triblocks that exploit "hairpin" and "straight" conformations also show assembly into novel nanotubules and further highlight the key roles for chain flexibility in biomimetic block copolymer assemblies.

New tetragonal form of reaction centers from Rhodobacter sphaeroides and the involvement of a manganese ion at a crystal contact point

Crystals have been obtained of wild-type reaction centers from Rhodobacter sphaeroides using manganese chloride as a precipitating agent. The crystals belong to the tetragonal space group P4(2)22, with unit-cell parameters a = b = 207.8, c = 107.5 A. The crystal structure has been determined to a resolution limit of 4.6 A using a previously determined structure of the reaction center as a molecular-replacement model. The calculated electron-density maps show the presence of a manganese ion at one of the crystal contact points bridging two symmetry-related histidine residues, suggesting that the metal plays a key role in facilitating the crystallization of the protein in this form.

Controlling the folding efficiency of an integral membrane protein

Research into the folding mechanisms of integral membrane proteins lags far behind that of water-soluble proteins, to the extent that the term protein folding is synonymous with water-soluble proteins. Hydrophobic membrane proteins, and particularly those with transmembrane alpha-helical motifs, are frequently considered too difficult to work with. We show that the stored curvature elastic stress of lipid bilayers can be used to guide the design of efficient folding systems for these integral membrane proteins. The curvature elastic stress of synthetic phosphatidylcholine/phosphatidylethanolamine lipid bilayers can be used to control both the rate of folding and the yield of folded protein. The use of a physical bilayer property generalises this approach beyond the particular chemistry of the lipids involved.

Scoring hidden Markov models to discriminate β-barrel membrane proteins

A new method is presented for identification of beta-barrel membrane proteins. It is based on a hidden Markov model (HMM) with an architecture obeying these proteins' construction principles. Once the HMM is trained, log-odds score relative to a null model is used to discriminate beta-barrel membrane proteins from other proteins. The method achieves only 10% false positive and false negative rates in a six-fold cross-validation procedure. The results compare favorably with existing methods. This method is proposed to be a valuable tool to quickly scan proteomes of entirely sequenced organisms for beta-barrel membrane proteins.

Investigating the conformational coupling between the transmembrane and cytoplasmic domains of a single-spanning membrane protein. A 1H-NMR study

PMP1 is a 38-residue single-spanning membrane protein whose C-terminal cytoplasmic domain, Y25-F38, is highly positively charged. The conformational coupling between the transmembrane span and the cytoplasmic domain of PMP1 was investigated from 1H-nuclear magnetic resonance data of two synthetic fragments: F9-F38, i.e. 80% of the whole sequence, and Y25-F38, the isolated cytoplasmic domain. Highly disordered in aqueous solution, the Y25-F38 peptide adopts a well-defined conformation in the presence of dodecylphosphocholine micelles. Compared with the long PMP1 fragment, this structure exhibits both native and non-native elements. Our results make it possible to assess the influence of a hydrophobic anchor on the intrinsic conformational propensity of a cytoplasmic domain.

Solution NMR studies of the integral membrane proteins OmpX and OmpA from Escherichia coli

Membrane proteins are usually solubilized in polar solvents by incorporation into micelles. Even for small membrane proteins these mixed micelles have rather large molecular masses, typically beyond 50000 Da. The NMR technique TROSY (transverse relaxation-optimized spectroscopy) has been developed for studies of structures of this size in solution. In this paper, strategies for the use of TROSY-based NMR experiments with membrane proteins are discussed and illustrated with results obtained with the Escherichia coli integral membrane proteins OmpX and OmpA in mixed micelles with the detergent dihexanoylphosphatidylcholine (DHPC). For OmpX, complete sequence-specific NMR assignments have been obtained for the polypeptide backbone. The 13C chemical shifts and nuclear Overhauser effect data then resulted in the identification of the regular secondary structure elements of OmpX/DHPC in solution, and in the collection of an input of conformational constraints for the computation of the global fold of the protein. For OmpA, the NMR assignments are so far limited to about 80% of the polypeptide chain, indicating different dynamic properties of the reconstituted OmpA beta-barrel from those of OmpX. Overall, the present data demonstrate that relaxation-optimized NMR techniques open novel avenues for studies of structure, function and dynamics of integral membrane proteins.

In vivo detection of hetero-association of glycophorin-A and its mutants within the membrane

Protein recognition within the membrane is a crucial process for numerous biological activities. Detection of such interaction is limited because of difficulties that arise from the hydrophobic environment of the membrane. We detected direct hetero-oligomerization of the glycophorin-A (GPA) transmembrane segments in vivo through inhibition of ToxR transcription activator dimer formation. We investigated the amino acids important for hetero-oligomerization within the membrane, using peptide analog segments of the transmembrane domain of glycophorin A. The wild type ([WT]GPA) and alanine mutant ([A]GPA) were able to interfere with and inhibit the proper dimerization of the ToxR-GPA transcription factor. Conversely, a second alanine mutant ([A(2)]GPA), a glycine mutant ([G]GPA), and a scrambled analog ([SC]GPA) were virtually inactive. Binding studies reveal similar membrane partitions for [WT]GPA, [G]GPA, and [SC]GPA, whereas membrane partition of [A]GPA and [A(2)]GPA are lower. Spectral analysis of fluorescent-labeled analogs revealed a significant blue shift, indicating membrane insertion. Our results suggest that the GXXXG motif, found in homo-oligomerization, is not sufficient for hetero-oligomerization in a biological membrane, whereas an extended motif, LIXXGXXXGXXXT, is sufficient. Interfering with hetero-oligomerization within the membrane can be a useful strategy for characterizing such interactions and possibly modulating membrane protein activity.

Amino acid distributions in integral membrane protein structures

Advances in structure determination of membrane proteins enable analysis of the propensities of amino acids in extramembrane versus transmembrane locations to be performed on the basis of structure rather than of sequence and predicted topology. Using 29 available structures of integral membrane proteins with resolutions better than 4 A the distributions of amino acids in the transmembrane domains were calculated. The results were compared to analysis based on just the sequences of the same transmembrane alpha-helices and significant differences were found. The distribution of residues between transmembrane alpha-helices and beta-strands was also compared. Large hydrophobic (Phe, Leu, Ile, Val) residues showed a clear preference for the protein surfaces facing the lipids for beta-barrels, but in alpha-helical proteins no such preference was seen, with these residues equally distributed between the interior and the surface of the protein. A notable exception to this was alanine, which showed a slight preference for the interior of alpha-helical membrane proteins. Aromatic residues were found to follow saddle-like distributions preferring to be located in the lipid/water interfaces. The resultant 'aromatic belts' were spaced more closely for beta-barrel than for alpha-helical membrane proteins. Charged residues could be shown to generally avoid surfaces facing the bilayer although they were found to occur frequently in the transmembrane region of beta-barrels. Indeed detailed comparison between alpha-helical and beta-barrel proteins showed many qualitative differences in residue distributions. This suggests that there may be subtle differences in the factors stabilising beta-barrels in bacterial outer membranes and alpha-helix bundles in all other membranes.

Transverse relaxation-optimized NMR spectroscopy with the outer membrane protein OmpX in dihexanoyl phosphatidylcholine micelles

The (2)H,(13)C,(15)N-labeled, 148-residue integral membrane protein OmpX from Escherichia coli was reconstituted with dihexanoyl phosphatidylcholine (DHPC) in mixed micelles of molecular mass of about 60 kDa. Transverse relaxation-optimized spectroscopy (TROSY)-type triple resonance NMR experiments and TROSY-type nuclear Overhauser enhancement spectra were recorded in 2 mM aqueous solutions of these mixed micelles at pH 6.8 and 30 degrees C. Complete sequence-specific NMR assignments for the polypeptide backbone thus have been obtained. The (13)C chemical shifts and the nuclear Overhauser effect data then resulted in the identification of the regular secondary structure elements of OmpX/DHPC in solution and in the collection of an input of conformational constraints for the computation of the global fold of the protein. The same type of polypeptide backbone fold is observed in the presently determined solution structure and the previously reported crystal structure of OmpX determined in the presence of the detergent n-octyltetraoxyethylene. Further structure refinement will have to rely on the additional resonance assignment of partially or fully protonated amino acid side chains, but the present data already demonstrate that relaxation-optimized NMR techniques open novel avenues for studies of structure and function of integral membrane proteins.

Single-particle approaches in the analysis of small 2D crystals of the mitochondrial channel VDAC

It has been difficult to obtain better than moderate resolution in analysis of electron microscopic images of small, 2D crystals with variable lattice parameters, e.g., crystals of the channel VDAC generated by phospholipase treatment of outer mitochondrial membranes. We demonstrate that applying single-particle analysis methods to correlation-averaged images can lead to significant improvements in the attainable resolution. Application of a soft-edged fitted mask passing only the central unit cell, and excluding the positionally variable adjacent unit cells, allows improved alignment and more sensitive multivariate statistical analysis, needed to guide intelligent merging of data from different crystals.