Digital mammography: wavelet transform and Kalman-filtering neural network in mass segmentation and detection

Breast Cancer Segmentation Methods: Current Status and Future Potentials

Early breast cancer detection is one of the most important issues that need to be addressed worldwide as it can help increase the survival rate of patients. Mammograms have been used to detect breast cancer in the early stages; if detected in the early stages, it can drastically reduce treatment costs. The detection of tumours in the breast depends on segmentation techniques. Segmentation plays a significant role in image analysis and includes detection, feature extraction, classification, and treatment. Segmentation helps physicians quantify the volume of tissue in the breast for treatment planning. In this work, we have grouped segmentation methods into three groups: classical segmentation that includes region-, threshold-, and edge-based segmentation; machine learning segmentation; and supervised and unsupervised and deep learning segmentation. The findings of our study revealed that region-based segmentation is frequently used for classical methods, and the most frequently used techniques are region growing. Further, a median filter is a robust tool for removing noise. Moreover, the MIAS database is frequently used in classical segmentation methods. Meanwhile, in machine learning segmentation, unsupervised machine learning methods are more frequently used, and U-Net is frequently used for mammogram image segmentation because it does not require many annotated images compared with other deep learning models. Furthermore, reviewed papers revealed that it is possible to train a deep learning model without performing any preprocessing or postprocessing and also showed that the U-Net model is frequently used for mammogram segmentation. The U-Net model is frequently used because it does not require many annotated images and also because of the presence of high-performance GPU computing, which makes it easy to train networks with more layers. Additionally, we identified mammograms and utilised widely used databases, wherein 3 and 28 are public and private databases, respectively.

Computerized breast cancer analysis system using three stage semi-supervised learning method

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE

A large number of labeled medical image data is usually a requirement to train a well-performed computer-aided detection (CAD) system. But the process of data labeling is time consuming, and potential ethical and logistical problems may also present complications. As a result, incorporating unlabeled data into CAD system can be a feasible way to combat these obstacles.

METHODS

In this study we developed a three stage semi-supervised learning (SSL) scheme that combines a small amount of labeled data and larger amount of unlabeled data. The scheme was modified on our existing CAD system using the following three stages: data weighing, feature selection, and newly proposed dividing co-training data labeling algorithm. Global density asymmetry features were incorporated to the feature pool to reduce the false positive rate. Area under the curve (AUC) and accuracy were computed using 10 fold cross validation method to evaluate the performance of our CAD system. The image dataset includes mammograms from 400 women who underwent routine screening examinations, and each pair contains either two cranio-caudal (CC) or two mediolateral-oblique (MLO) view mammograms from the right and the left breasts. From these mammograms 512 regions were extracted and used in this study, and among them 90 regions were treated as labeled while the rest were treated as unlabeled.

RESULTS

Using our proposed scheme, the highest AUC observed in our research was 0.841, which included the 90 labeled data and all the unlabeled data. It was 7.4% higher than using labeled data only. With the increasing amount of labeled data, AUC difference between using mixed data and using labeled data only reached its peak when the amount of labeled data was around 60.

CONCLUSIONS

This study demonstrated that our proposed three stage semi-supervised learning can improve the CAD performance by incorporating unlabeled data. Using unlabeled data is promising in computerized cancer research and may have a significant impact for future CAD system applications.

Using multiscale texture and density features for near-term breast cancer risk analysis

PURPOSE

To help improve efficacy of screening mammography by eventually establishing a new optimal personalized screening paradigm, the authors investigated the potential of using the quantitative multiscale texture and density feature analysis of digital mammograms to predict near-term breast cancer risk.

METHODS

The authors' dataset includes digital mammograms acquired from 340 women. Among them, 141 were positive and 199 were negative/benign cases. The negative digital mammograms acquired from the "prior" screening examinations were used in the study. Based on the intensity value distributions, five subregions at different scales were extracted from each mammogram. Five groups of features, including density and texture features, were developed and calculated on every one of the subregions. Sequential forward floating selection was used to search for the effective combinations. Using the selected features, a support vector machine (SVM) was optimized using a tenfold validation method to predict the risk of each woman having image-detectable cancer in the next sequential mammography screening. The area under the receiver operating characteristic curve (AUC) was used as the performance assessment index.

RESULTS

From a total number of 765 features computed from multiscale subregions, an optimal feature set of 12 features was selected. Applying this feature set, a SVM classifier yielded performance of AUC = 0.729 ± 0.021. The positive predictive value was 0.657 (92 of 140) and the negative predictive value was 0.755 (151 of 200).

CONCLUSIONS

The study results demonstrated a moderately high positive association between risk prediction scores generated by the quantitative multiscale mammographic image feature analysis and the actual risk of a woman having an image-detectable breast cancer in the next subsequent examinations.

A New GLLD Operator for Mass Detection in Digital Mammograms

During the last decade, several works have dealt with computer automatic diagnosis (CAD) of masses in digital mammograms. Generally, the main difficulty remains the detection of masses. This work proposes an efficient methodology for mass detection based on a new local feature extraction. Local binary pattern (LBP) operator and its variants proposed by Ojala are a powerful tool for textures classification. However, it has been proved that such operators are not able to model at their own texture masses. We propose in this paper a new local pattern model named gray level and local difference (GLLD) where we take into consideration absolute gray level values as well as local difference as local binary features. Artificial neural networks (ANNs), support vector machine (SVM), and k-nearest neighbors (kNNs) are, then, used for classifying masses from nonmasses, illustrating better performance of ANN classifier. We have used 1000 regions of interest (ROIs) obtained from the Digital Database for Screening Mammography (DDSM). The area under the curve of the corresponding approach has been found to be A(z) = 0.95 for the mass detection step. A comparative study with previous approaches proves that our approach offers the best performances.

A novel approach to nodule feature optimization on thin section thoracic CT

RATIONALE AND OBJECTIVES

An analysis for the optimum selection of image features in feature domain to represent lung nodules was performed, with implementation into a classification module of a computer-aided diagnosis system.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Forty-two regions of interest obtained from 38 cases with effective diameters of 3 to 8.5 mm were used. On the basis of image characteristics and dimensionality, 11 features were computed. Nonparametric correlation coefficients, multiple regression analysis, and principal-component analysis were used to map the relation between the represented features from four radiologists and the computed features. An artificial neural network was used for the classification of benign and malignant nodules to test the hypothesis obtained from the mapping analysis.

RESULTS

Correlation coefficients ranging from 0.2693 to 0.5178 were obtained between the radiologists' annotations and the computed features. Of the 11 features used, three were found to be redundant when both nodule and non-nodule cases were used, and five were found redundant when nodule or non-nodule cases were used. Combination of analysis from correlation coefficients, regression analysis, principal-component analysis, and the artificial neural network resulted in the selection of optimum features to achieve F-test values of 0.821 and 0.643 for malignant and benign nodules, respectively.

CONCLUSION

This study demonstrates that for the optimum selection of features, each feature should be analyzed individually and collectively to evaluate the impact on the computer-aided diagnosis system on the basis of its class representation. This methodology will ultimately aid in improving the generalization capability of a classification module for early lung cancer diagnosis.

Computer-aided mass detection based on ipsilateral multiview mammograms

RATIONALE AND OBJECTIVES

Recent reports on advances in computer-aided detection (CAD) indicate that current schemes miss early-stage breast cancers and result in a relatively large false-positive detection rate in order to achieve a high sensitivity rate for mass detection. This paper is inspired by the interpretation procedure from mammographers. The abnormal diagnosis can be derived from multiple views but is not available through single-view image analysis.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

A new multiview CAD system for early-stage breast cancer detection, which is based on modifying the optimized CAD algorithms from our prior single-view CAD system for constructing an adaptive ipsilateral multiview concurrent CAD system, is presented in this paper. The selection and design for the training and testing ipsilateral multiview mammogram databases are described here.

RESULTS

The performance evaluation of the developed ipsilateral multiview CAD system using free-response receiver operating characteristic analysis and computerized receiver operating characteristic experiments are presented. The results indicated that the proposed multiview CAD system is significantly superior to the single-view CAD systems based on statistically standard P-values.

CONCLUSION

This paper addresses a very important and timely project. It is related to two main problems regarding the development of breast cancer detection and diagnosis: early-stage detection and diagnosis of breast cancer with digital mammogram, and overall improvement of CAD system performance for clinical implementation. In order to improve the efficacy, accuracy, and efficiency of the current CAD scheme, an entirely new class of CAD method is required. This paper is unique in that a comprehensive and state-of-the-art approach is proposed for the CAD scheme of digital mammography. From the design aspect of the CAD scheme, the proposed ipsilateral multiview CAD method is innovative and quite different from current single-view CAD methods.

False positive reduction in mammographic mass detection using local binary patterns

In this paper we propose a new approach for false positive reduction in the field of mammographic mass detection. The goal is to distinguish between the true recognized masses and the ones which actually are normal parenchyma. Our proposal is based on Local Binary Patterns (LBP) for representing salient micro-patterns and preserving at the same time the spatial structure of the masses. Once the descriptors are extracted, Support Vector Machines (SVM) are used for classifying the detected masses. We test our proposal using a set of 1792 suspicious regions of interest extracted from the DDSM database. Exhaustive experiments illustrate that LBP features are effective and efficient for false positive reduction even at different mass sizes, a critical aspect in mass detection systems. Moreover, we compare our proposal with current methods showing that LBP obtains better performance.

Testing the effect of computer-assisted detection on interpretive performance in screening mammography

OBJECTIVE

The objective of our study was to test whether the use of computer-assisted detection (CAD) improves sensitivity at no cost to specificity for the detection of breast cancer and enables more accurate assessment of fatty breast tissue compared with dense breast tissue.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

We created a stratified random sample of screening mammograms weighted with difficult cases split evenly among women with fatty breast tissue and those with dense breast tissue: 114 patients were cancer-free, 114 had cancer 1 year after screening, and 113 had cancer 13-24 months after screening. In test settings 6 months apart, 19 community radiologists interpreted 341 bilateral screening mammograms with and without CAD. We compared the sensitivity and specificity using regression models adjusting for repeated measures.

RESULTS

CAD assistance did not affect overall sensitivity (cancer by 1 year: 63.2% without CAD and 62.0% with CAD; cancer in 13-24 months: 33.5% without CAD and 32.3% with CAD), but its effect differed for visible masses that were marked by CAD compared with those that were not marked by CAD (hereafter referred to as "unmarked"). CAD was associated with improved sensitivity for marked visible cancers and decreased sensitivity for unmarked visible masses; the sensitivities without and with CAD, respectively, were as follows: marked cancer by 1 year, 82.7% versus 83.1%; marked cancer in 13-24 months, 44.2% versus 57.9%; unmarked cancer by 1 year, 37.4% versus 30.1%; unmarked cancer in 13-24 months, 29.7% versus 23.0% (p < 0.03 for both interactions between assistance and CAD marking for cancer by 1 year and cancer in 13-24 months). CAD marked 77% (70/91) of the visible cancers by 1 year and 67.3% (37/55) of the visible cancers in 13-24 months. CAD marked more visible calcified lesions (86%) than masses and asymmetric densities (67%) (p < 0.05). Overall specificity was 72% without and 75% with CAD (p < 0.02). CAD had a greater effect on both specificity (p < 0.02) and sensitivity (p < 0.03) among radiologists who interpret more than 50 mammograms per week. The results were the same for fatty breast tissue and dense breast tissue.

CONCLUSION

In this experiment, CAD increased interpretive specificity but did not affect sensitivity because visible noncalcified lesions that went unmarked by CAD were less likely to be assessed as abnormal by radiologists. Breast density did not affect CAD's performance.

A genetic algorithm design for microcalcification detection and classification in digital mammograms

In this paper, we propose a genetic algorithm design to automatically classify and detect micocalcification clusters in digital mammograms. The proposed GA technique is characterised by transforming input images into a feature domain, where each pixel is represented by its mean and standard deviation inside a surrounding window of size 9 x 9 pixel. In the feature domain, chromosomes are constructed to populate the initial generation and further features are extracted to enable the proposed GA to search for optimised classification and detection of microcalcification clusters via regions of 128 x 128 pixels. Extensive experiments show that the proposed GA design is able to achieve high performances in microcalcification classification and detection, which are measured by ROC curves, sensitivity against specificity, areas under ROC curves and benchmarked by existing representative techniques.

Ipsilateral-mammogram computer-aided detection of breast cancer

In this paper, an ipsilateral multi-view computer-aided detection (CAD) scheme is presented for mass detection in digital mammograms by exploiting correlative information of suspicious lesions between mammograms of the same breast. After nonlinear tree-structured filtering for image noise suppression, two wavelet-based methods, directional wavelet transform and tree-structured wavelet transform for image enhancement, and adaptive fuzzy C-means algorithm for segmentation are employed on each mammograms of the same breast, respectively, concurrent analysis is developed for iterative analysis of ipsilateral multi-view mammograms by inter-projective feature matching analysis. A supervised artificial neural network is developed as a classifier, in which the back-propagation algorithm combined with Kalman filtering is used as training algorithm, and free-response receiver operating characteristic analysis is used to test the performance of the developed unilateral CAD system. Performance comparison has been conducted between the final ipsilateral multi-view CAD system and our previously developed single-mammogram-based CAD system. The study results demonstrate the advantages of ipsilateral multi-view CAD method combined with concurrent analysis over current single-view CAD system on false positive reduction.

Computer-assisted detection of mammographic masses: a template matching scheme based on mutual information

The purpose of this study was to develop a knowledge-based scheme for the detection of masses on digitized screening mammograms. The computer-assisted detection (CAD) scheme utilizes a knowledge databank of mammographic regions of interest (ROIs) with known ground truth. Each ROI in the databank serves as a template. The CAD system follows a template matching approach with mutual information as the similarity metric to determine if a query mammographic ROI depicts a true mass. Based on their information content, all similar ROIs in the databank are retrieved and rank-ordered. Then, a decision index is calculated based on the query's best matches. The decision index effectively combines the similarity indices and ground truth of the best-matched templates into a prediction regarding the presence of a mass in the query mammographic ROI. The system was developed and evaluated using a database of 1465 ROIs extracted from the Digital Database for Screening Mammography. There were 809 ROIs with confirmed masses (455 malignant and 354 benign) and 656 normal ROIs. CAD performance was assessed using a leave-one-out sampling scheme and Receiver Operating Characteristics analysis. Depending on the formulation of the decision index, CAD performance as high as A(zeta) = 0.87 +/- 0.01 was achieved. The CAD detection rate was consistent for both malignant and benign masses. In addition, the impact of certain implementation parameters on the detection accuracy and speed of the proposed CAD scheme was studied in more detail.

Advances in micro-calcification clusters detection in mammography

A new mixed feature multistage false positive (FP) reduction method for micro-calcification clusters (MCCs) detection has been developed for improving the FP reduction performance. Eleven features were extracted from both spatial and morphology domains in order to describe MCCs from different perspectives. These features are grouped into three categories: gray-level description, shape description and clusters description. Two feature sets that focus on describing MCCs on every single calcification and on clustered calcifications, respectively, were combined with a back-propagation (BP) neural network with Kalman filter to obtain the best performance of FP reduction. First, nine of the eleven gray-level description and shape description features were employed with BP neural network to eliminate all the obvious FP calcifications in the image. Second, the remaining MCCs were classified into several clusters by a widely used criterion in clinical practice and then two cluster description features were added to the first feature set to eliminate the FP clusters from the remaining MCCs. The performance results of this approach were obtained using an image database of 67 real-patients mammogram images in H. Lee Moffitt Cancer Center imaging program. The proposed method successfully reduced the FP to 3.15/image, while the detection sensitivity or true positive rate improved to 97%.