p53 in noncancerous bladder mucosa as a marker of disease recurrence in patients with superficial transitional cell carcinoma of the bladder

Assessment of the extent of unpublished studies in prognostic factor research: a systematic review of p53 immunohistochemistry in bladder cancer as an example

OBJECTIVES

When study groups fail to publish their results, a subsequent systematic review may come to incorrect conclusions when combining information only from published studies. p53 expression measured by immunohistochemistry is a potential prognostic factor in bladder cancer. Although numerous studies have been conducted, its role is still under debate. The assumption that unpublished studies too harbour evidence on this research topic leads to the question about the attributable effect when adding this information and comparing it with published data. Thus, the aim was to identify published and unpublished studies and to explore their differences potentially affecting the conclusion on its function as a prognostic biomarker.

DESIGN

Systematic review of published and unpublished studies assessing p53 in bladder cancer in Germany between 1993 and 2007.

RESULTS

The systematic search revealed 16 studies of which 11 (69%) have been published and 5 (31%) have not. Key reason for not publishing the results was a loss of interest of the investigators. There were no obviously larger differences between published and unpublished studies. However, a meaningful meta-analysis was not possible mainly due to the poor (ie, incomplete) reporting of study results.

CONCLUSIONS

Within this well-defined population of studies, we could provide empirical evidence for the failure of study groups to publish their results that was mainly caused by loss of interest. This fact may be coresponsible for the role of p53 as a prognostic factor still being unclear. We consider p53 and the restriction to studies in Germany as a specific example, but the critical issues are probably similar for other prognostic factors and other countries.

Detection of human telomerase RNA in the tumour-surrounding mucosa of bladder carcinomas as a marker for premalignant transformation

OBJECTIVES

To investigate tumour tissue and non-malignant tumour-surrounding bladder mucosa (NTSBM) for expression of human telomerase RNA (hTR) as a possible marker for premalignant transformation of urothelial cells.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

From 67 patients with superficial transitional cell carcinoma (TCC), sections with representative tumour tissue and NTSBM were selected for evaluation. Sections with moderate or severe dysplasia were omitted from evaluation. hTR expression was detected with in situ hybridization using a 35S-UTP-labelled riboprobe, and analysed semiquantitatively by counting the hybridization signals.

RESULTS

In 45 of the 67 patients hTR expression was moderate or strong in tumour tissue, and in 20 hTR expression was moderate or strong in NTSBM. Moderate or strong hTR expression was detected in the NTSBM from 19 of 60 patients with pTa/pT1 tumours. Of the 56 patients who were treated conservatively, eight had tumour recurrence, of whom five had moderate or strong hTR expression in the TSBM, compared with only 14 of 48 patients without tumour recurrence.

CONCLUSION

Detecting hTR expression and the morphological distribution of hTR hybridization signals in NTSBM by in situ hybridization might indicate premalignant alterations involved in tumour recurrence.