The nature of the nucleosomal barrier to transcription: direct observation of paused intermediates by electron cryomicroscopy

Cryo-EM structures of RNA polymerase II-nucleosome complexes rewrapping transcribed DNA

RNA polymerase II (RNAPII) transcribes DNA wrapped in the nucleosome by stepwise pausing, especially at nucleosomal superhelical locations -5 and -1 [SHL(-5) and SHL(-1), respectively]. In the present study, we performed cryo-electron microscopy analyses of RNAPII-nucleosome complexes paused at a major nucleosomal pausing site, SHL(-1). We determined two previously undetected structures, in which the transcribed DNA behind RNAPII is sharply kinked at the RNAPII exit tunnel and rewrapped around the nucleosomal histones in front of RNAPII by DNA looping. This DNA kink shifts the DNA orientation toward the nucleosome, and the transcribed DNA region interacts with basic amino acid residues of histones H2A, H2B, and H3 exposed by the RNAPII-mediated nucleosomal DNA peeling. The DNA loop structure was not observed in the presence of the transcription elongation factors Spt4/5 and Elf1. These RNAPII-nucleosome structures provide important information for understanding the functional relevance of DNA looping during transcription elongation in the nucleosome.

Transcription-coupled nucleosome assembly

Eukaryotic transcription occurs on chromatin, where RNA polymerase II encounters nucleosomes during elongation. These nucleosomes must unravel for the DNA to enter the active site. However, in most transcribed genes, nucleosomes remain intact due to transcription-coupled chromatin assembly mechanisms. These mechanisms primarily involve the local reassembly of displaced nucleosomes to prevent (epi)genomic instability and the emergence of cryptic transcription. As a fail-safe mechanism, cells can assemble nucleosomes de novo, particularly in highly transcribed genes, but this may result in the loss of epigenetic information. This review examines transcription-coupled chromatin assembly, with an emphasis on studies in yeast and recent structural studies. These studies shed light on how elongation factors and histone chaperones coordinate to enable nucleosome recycling during transcription.

Multiplexing mechanical and translational cues on genes

The genetic code gives precise instructions on how to translate codons into amino acids. Due to the degeneracy of the genetic code-18 out of 20 amino acids are encoded for by more than one codon-more information can be stored in a basepair sequence. Indeed, various types of additional information have been discussed in the literature, e.g., the positioning of nucleosomes along eukaryotic genomes and the modulation of the translating efficiency in ribosomes to influence cotranslational protein folding. The purpose of this study is to show that it is indeed possible to carry more than one additional layer of information on top of a gene. In particular, we show how much translation efficiency and nucleosome positioning can be adjusted simultaneously without changing the encoded protein. We achieve this by mapping genes on weighted graphs that contain all synonymous genes, and then finding shortest paths through these graphs. This enables us, for example, to readjust the disrupted translational efficiency profile after a gene has been introduced from one organism (e.g., human) into another (e.g., yeast) without greatly changing the nucleosome landscape intrinsically encoded by the DNA molecule.

Structural advances in transcription elongation

Transcription is the first step of gene expression and involves RNA polymerases. After transcription initiation, RNA polymerase enters elongation followed by transcription termination at the end of the gene. Only recently, structures of transcription elongation complexes bound to key transcription elongation factors have been determined in bacterial and eukaryotic systems. These structures have revealed numerous insights including the basis for transcriptional pausing, RNA polymerase interaction with large complexes such as the ribosome and the spliceosome, and the transition into productive elongation. Here, we review these structures and describe areas for future research.

Structural basis of nucleosome retention during transcription elongation

In eukaryotes, RNA polymerase (Pol) II transcribes chromatin and must move past nucleosomes, often resulting in nucleosome displacement. How Pol II unwraps the DNA from nucleosomes to allow transcription and how DNA rewraps to retain nucleosomes has been unclear. Here, we report the 3.0-angstrom cryo-electron microscopy structure of a mammalian Pol II-DSIF-SPT6-PAF1c-TFIIS-nucleosome complex stalled 54 base pairs within the nucleosome. The structure provides a mechanistic basis for nucleosome retention during transcription elongation where upstream DNA emerging from the Pol II cleft has rewrapped the proximal side of the nucleosome. The structure uncovers a direct role for Pol II and transcription elongation factors in nucleosome retention and explains how nucleosomes are retained to prevent the disruption of chromatin structure across actively transcribed genes.

The lane-switch mechanism for nucleosome repositioning by DNA translocase

Translocases such as DNA/RNA polymerases, replicative helicases, and exonucleases are involved in eukaryotic DNA transcription, replication, and repair. Since eukaryotic genomic DNA wraps around histone octamers and forms nucleosomes, translocases inevitably encounter nucleosomes. A previous study has shown that a nucleosome repositions downstream when a translocase collides with the nucleosome. However, the molecular mechanism of the downstream repositioning remains unclear. In this study, we identified the lane-switch mechanism for downstream repositioning with molecular dynamics simulations and validated it with restriction enzyme digestion assays and deep sequencing assays. In this mechanism, after a translocase unwraps nucleosomal DNA up to the site proximal to the dyad, the remaining wrapped DNA switches its binding lane to that vacated by the unwrapping, and the downstream DNA rewraps, completing downstream repositioning. This mechanism may have broad implications for transcription through nucleosomes, histone recycling, and nucleosome remodeling.

A structural framework for DNA replication and transcription through chromatin

In eukaryotic cells, DNA replication and transcription machineries uncoil nucleosomes along the double helix, to achieve the exposure of the single-stranded DNA template for nucleic acid synthesis. The replisome and RNA polymerases then redeposit histones onto DNA behind the advancing molecular motor, in a process that is crucial for epigenetic inheritance and homeostasis, respectively. Here, we compare and contrast the mechanisms by which these molecular machines advance through nucleosome arrays and discuss how chromatin remodellers can facilitate DNA replication and transcription.

Nucleosome Dynamics during Transcription Elongation

The nucleosome is the basic packing unit of the eukaryotic genome. Dynamic interactions between DNA and histones in the nucleosome are the molecular basis of gene accessibility regulation that governs the kinetics of various DNA-templated processes such as transcription elongation by RNA Polymerase II (Pol II). On the basis of single-molecule FRET measurements with chemically modified histones, we investigated the nucleosome dynamics during transcription elongation and how it is affected by histone acetylation at H3 K56 and the histone chaperone Nap1, both of which can affect DNA-histone interactions. We observed that H3K56 acetylation dramatically shortens the pause duration of Pol II near the entry region of the nucleosome, while Nap1 induces no noticeable difference. We also found that the elongation rate of Pol II through the nucleosome is unaffected by the acetylation or Nap1. These results indicate that H3K56 acetylation facilitates Pol II translocation through the nucleosome by assisting paused Pol II to resume and that Nap1 does not affect Pol II progression. Following transcription, only a small fraction of nucleosomes remain intact, which is unaffected by H3K56 acetylation or Nap1. These results suggest that (i) spontaneous nucleosome opening enables Pol II progression, (ii) Pol II mediates nucleosome reassembly very inefficiently, and (iii) Nap1 in the absence of other factors does not promote nucleosome disassembly or reassembly during transcription.

Force-Dependent Facilitated Dissociation Can Generate Protein-DNA Catch Bonds

Cellular structures are continually subjected to forces, which may serve as mechanical signals for cells through their effects on biomolecule interaction kinetics. Typically, molecular complexes interact via "slip bonds," so applied forces accelerate off rates by reducing transition energy barriers. However, biomolecules with multiple dissociation pathways may have considerably more complicated force dependencies. This is the case for DNA-binding proteins that undergo "facilitated dissociation," in which competitor biomolecules from solution enhance molecular dissociation in a concentration-dependent manner. Using simulations and theory, we develop a generic model that shows that proteins undergoing facilitated dissociation can form an alternative type of molecular bond, known as a "catch bond," for which applied forces suppress protein dissociation. This occurs because the binding by protein competitors responsible for the facilitated dissociation pathway can be inhibited by applied forces. Within the model, we explore how the force dependence of dissociation is regulated by intrinsic factors, including molecular sensitivity to force and binding geometry and the extrinsic factor of competitor protein concentration. We find that catch bonds generically emerge when the force dependence of the facilitated unbinding pathway is stronger than that of the spontaneous unbinding pathway. The sharpness of the transition between slip- and catch-bond kinetics depends on the degree to which the protein bends its DNA substrate. This force-dependent kinetics is broadly regulated by the concentration of competitor biomolecules in solution. Thus, the observed catch bond is mechanistically distinct from other known physiological catch bonds because it requires an extrinsic factor-competitor proteins-rather than a specific intrinsic molecular structure. We hypothesize that this mechanism for regulating force-dependent protein dissociation may be used by cells to modulate protein exchange, regulate transcription, and facilitate diffusive search processes.

Structural basis of the nucleosome transition during RNA polymerase II passage

Genomic DNA forms chromatin, in which the nucleosome is the repeating unit. The mechanism by which RNA polymerase II (RNAPII) transcribes the nucleosomal DNA remains unclear. Here we report the cryo-electron microscopy structures of RNAPII-nucleosome complexes in which RNAPII pauses at the superhelical locations SHL(-6), SHL(-5), SHL(-2), and SHL(-1) of the nucleosome. RNAPII pauses at the major histone-DNA contact sites, and the nucleosome interactions with the RNAPII subunits stabilize the pause. These structures reveal snapshots of nucleosomal transcription, in which RNAPII gradually tears DNA from the histone surface while preserving the histone octamer. The nucleosomes in the SHL(-1) complexes are bound to a "foreign" DNA segment, which might explain the histone transfer mechanism. These results provide the foundations for understanding chromatin transcription and epigenetic regulation.

Single-molecule force spectroscopy on histone H4 tail-cross-linked chromatin reveals fiber folding

The eukaryotic genome is highly compacted into a protein-DNA complex called chromatin. The cell controls access of transcriptional regulators to chromosomal DNA via several mechanisms that act on chromatin-associated proteins and provide a rich spectrum of epigenetic regulation. Elucidating the mechanisms that fold chromatin fibers into higher-order structures is therefore key to understanding the epigenetic regulation of DNA accessibility. Here, using histone H4-V21C and histone H2A-E64C mutations, we employed single-molecule force spectroscopy to measure the unfolding of individual chromatin fibers that are reversibly cross-linked through the histone H4 tail. Fibers with covalently linked nucleosomes featured the same folding characteristics as fibers containing wild-type histones but exhibited increased stability against stretching forces. By stabilizing the secondary structure of chromatin, we confirmed a nucleosome repeat length (NRL)-dependent folding. Consistent with previous crystallographic and cryo-EM studies, the obtained force-extension curves on arrays with 167-bp NRLs best supported an underlying structure consisting of zig-zag, two-start fibers. For arrays with 197-bp NRLs, we previously inferred solenoidal folding, which was further corroborated by force-extension curves of the cross-linked fibers. The different unfolding pathways exhibited by these two types of arrays and reported here extend our understanding of chromatin structure and its potential roles in gene regulation. Importantly, these findings imply that chromatin compaction by nucleosome stacking protects nucleosomal DNA from external forces up to 4 piconewtons.

Effects of radiation damage in studies of protein-DNA complexes by cryo-EM

Nucleic acids are responsible for the storage, transfer and realization of genetic information in the cell, which provides correct development and functioning of organisms. DNA interaction with ligands ensures the safety of this information. Over the past 10 years, advances in electron microscopy and image processing allowed to obtain the structures of key DNA-protein complexes with resolution below 4Å. However, radiation damage is a limiting factor to the potentially attainable resolution in cryo-EM. The prospect and limitations of studying protein-DNA complex interactions using cryo-electron microscopy are discussed here. We reviewed the ways to minimize radiation damage in biological specimens and the possibilities of using radiation damage (so-called 'bubblegrams') to obtain additional structural information.

Nucleosome dynamics: Sequence matters

About three quarter of all eukaryotic DNA is wrapped around protein cylinders, forming nucleosomes. Even though the histone proteins that make up the core of nucleosomes are highly conserved in evolution, nucleosomes can be very different from each other due to posttranslational modifications of the histones. Another crucial factor in making nucleosomes unique has so far been underappreciated: the sequence of their DNA. This review provides an overview of the experimental and theoretical progress that increasingly points to the importance of the nucleosomal base pair sequence. Specifically, we discuss the role of the underlying base pair sequence in nucleosome positioning, sliding, breathing, force-induced unwrapping, dissociation and partial assembly and also how the sequence can influence higher-order structures. A new view emerges: the physical properties of nucleosomes, especially their dynamical properties, are determined to a large extent by the mechanical properties of their DNA, which in turn depends on DNA sequence.

Physical chemistry of nucleic acids and their complexes

Studies of the physical properties of nucleic acids began almost immediately following the discovery of the DNA structure. Early investigations focused on the stability and specificity of multi-strand polynucleotide complexes, then gradually on their interaction with other molecules, particularly proteins. As molecular and structural biology expanded to provide detailed information about biochemical mechanisms, physical studies eventually acquired the additional constraint that they should be relevant to functioning biological systems. We describe work in our laboratory that began with investigations of relatively simple questions about the role of electrostatic interactions in the stabilization of multi-strand nucleic acid structures, and evolved to studies of chromatin structure in vitro and within the nucleus.

On the role of inter-nucleosomal interactions and intrinsic nucleosome dynamics in chromatin function

Evidence is emerging that many diseases result from defects in gene functions, which, in turn, depend on the local chromatin environment of a gene. However, it still remains not fully clear how chromatin activity code is 'translated' to the particular 'activating' or 'repressing' chromatin structural transition. Commonly, chromatin remodeling in vitro was studied using mononucleosomes as a model. However, recent data suggest that structural reorganization of a single mononucleosome is not equal to remodeling of a nucleosome particle under multinucleosomal content - such as, interaction of nucleosomes via flexible histone termini could significantly alter the mode (and the resulting products) of nucleosome structural transitions. It is becoming evident that a nucleosome array does not constitute just a 'polymer' of individual 'canonical' nucleosomes due to multiple inter-nucleosomal interactions which affect nucleosome dynamics and structure. It could be hypothesized, that inter-nucleosomal interactions could act in cooperation with nucleosome inherent dynamics to orchestrate DNA-based processes and promote formation and stabilization of highly-dynamic, accessible structure of a nucleosome array. In the proposed paper we would like to discuss the nucleosome dynamics within the chromatin fiber mainly as it pertains to the roles of the structural changes mediated by inter-nucleosomal interactions.

Structural analysis of nucleosomal barrier to transcription

Thousands of human and Drosophila genes are regulated at the level of transcript elongation and nucleosomes are likely targets for this regulation. However, the molecular mechanisms of formation of the nucleosomal barrier to transcribing RNA polymerase II (Pol II) and nucleosome survival during/after transcription remain unknown. Here we show that both DNA-histone interactions and Pol II backtracking contribute to formation of the barrier and that nucleosome survival during transcription likely occurs through allosterically stabilized histone-histone interactions. Structural analysis indicates that after Pol II encounters the barrier, the enzyme backtracks and nucleosomal DNA recoils on the octamer, locking Pol II in the arrested state. DNA is displaced from one of the H2A/H2B dimers that remains associated with the octamer. The data reveal the importance of intranucleosomal DNA-protein and protein-protein interactions during conformational changes in the nucleosome structure on transcription. Mechanisms of nucleosomal barrier formation and nucleosome survival during transcription are proposed.

Mechanism of transcription through a nucleosome by RNA polymerase II

Efficient maintenance of chromatin structure during passage of RNA polymerase II (Pol II) is critical for cell survival and functioning. Moderate-level transcription of eukaryotic genes by Pol II is accompanied by nucleosome survival, extensive exchange of histones H2A/H2B and minimal exchange of histones H3/H4. Complementary in vitro studies have shown that transcription through chromatin by single Pol II complexes is uniquely coupled with nucleosome survival via formation of a small intranucleosomal DNA loop (Ø-loop) containing the transcribing enzyme. In contrast, transient displacement and exchange of all core histones are observed during intense transcription. Indeed, multiple transcribing Pol II complexes can efficiently overcome the high nucleosomal barrier and displace the entire histone octamer in vitro. Thus, various Pol II complexes can remodel chromatin to different extents. The mechanisms of nucleosome survival and displacement during transcription and the role of DNA-histone interactions and various factors during this process are discussed. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled: RNA polymerase II Transcript Elongation.

The elongation rate of RNA polymerase determines the fate of transcribed nucleosomes

Upon transcription, histones can either detach from DNA or transfer behind the polymerase through a process believed to involve template looping. The details governing nucleosomal fate during transcription are not well understood. Our atomic force microscopy images of RNA polymerase II-nucleosome complexes confirm the presence of looped transcriptional intermediates and provide mechanistic insight into the histone-transfer process via the distribution of transcribed nucleosome positions. Significantly, we find that a fraction of the transcribed nucleosomes are remodeled to hexasomes, and that this fraction depends on the transcription elongation rate. A simple model involving the kinetic competition between transcription elongation, histone transfer, and histone-histone dissociation quantitatively rationalizes our observations and unifies results obtained with other polymerases. Factors affecting the relative magnitude of these processes provide the physical basis for nucleosomal fate during transcription and, therefore, for the regulation of gene expression.

The dynamics of the nucleosome: thermal effects, external forces and ATP

With nucleosomes being tightly associated with the majority of eukaryotic DNA, it is essential that mechanisms are in place that can move nucleosomes 'out of the way'. A focus of current research comprises chromatin remodeling complexes, which are ATP-consuming protein complexes that, for example, pull or push nucleosomes along DNA. The precise mechanisms used by those complexes are not yet understood. Hints for possible mechanisms might be found among the various spontaneous fluctuations that nucleosomes show in the absence of remodelers. Thermal fluctuations induce the partial unwrapping of DNA from the nucleosomes and introduce twist or loop defects in the wrapped DNA, leading to nucleosome sliding along DNA. In this minireview, we discuss nucleosome dynamics from two angles. First, we describe the dynamical modes of nucleosomes in the absence of remodelers that are experimentally fairly well characterized and theoretically understood. Then, we discuss remodelers and describe recent insights about the possible schemes that they might use.

Mechanism of chromatin remodeling and recovery during passage of RNA polymerase II

Transcription of eukaryotic genes by RNA polymerase II (Pol II) is typically accompanied by nucleosome survival and minimal exchange of histones H3 and H4. The mechanism of nucleosome survival and recovery of chromatin structure remains obscure. Here we show how transcription through chromatin by Pol II is uniquely coupled with nucleosome survival. Structural modeling and functional analysis of the intermediates of transcription through a nucleosome indicated that when Pol II approaches an area of strong DNA-histone interactions, a small intranucleosomal DNA loop (zero-size or Ø-loop) containing transcribing enzyme is formed. During formation of the Ø-loop, the recovery of DNA-histone interactions behind Pol II is tightly coupled with their disruption ahead of the enzyme. This coupling is a distinct feature of the Pol II-type mechanism that allows further transcription through the nucleosome, prevents nucleosome translocation and minimizes displacement of H3 and H4 histones from DNA during enzyme passage.

Stochastic model for nucleosome sliding under an external force

Heat-induced diffusion of nucleosomes along DNA is an experimentally well-studied phenomenon, presumably induced by twist defects that propagate through the wrapped DNA portion. The diffusion constant depends dramatically on the local mechanical properties of the DNA and the presence of DNA-binding ligands. This has been quantitatively understood by a stochastic three-state model. Future experiments are expected to allow application of forces on the nucleosome that induce a directed sliding. By extending the three-state model, the present work studies theoretically the response of the nucleosome to such external forces and how it is affected by the mechanical properties of the DNA and the presence of DNA-binding ligands.

High-resolution dynamic mapping of histone-DNA interactions in a nucleosome

The nature of the nucleosomal barrier which regulates access to the underlying DNA during many cellular processes is not fully understood. Here we present a detailed map of histone-DNA interactions along the DNA sequence to near basepair accuracy by mechanically unzipping single molecules of DNA, each containing a single nucleosome. This interaction map revealed a distinct ~5 bp periodicity that was enveloped by three broad regions of strong interactions, with the strongest at the dyad and the other two at ~ ±40 bp from the dyad. Unzipping up to the dyad allowed recovery of a canonical nucleosome upon relaxation of the DNA, but unzipping beyond the dyad resulted in removal of histone octamer from its initial DNA sequence. These findings have significant implications for how RNA polymerase and other DNA-based enzymes may gain access to DNA associated with a nucleosome.

Structure and function of ribosomal RNA gene chromatin

Transcription of the major ribosomal RNAs by Pol I (RNA polymerase I) is a key determinant of ribosome biogenesis, driving cell growth and proliferation in eukaryotes. Hundreds of copies of rRNA genes are present in each cell, and there is evidence that the cellular control of Pol I transcription involves adjustments to the number of rRNA genes actively engaged in transcription, as well as to the rate of transcription from each active gene. Chromatin structure is inextricably linked to rRNA gene activity, and the present review highlights recent advances in this area.

Transcription through chromatin by RNA polymerase II: histone displacement and exchange

The process of transcript elongation by RNA polymerase II (Pol II) involves transcription-dependent exchange and displacement of all core histones and is tightly controlled by numerous protein complexes modifying chromatin structure. These processes can contribute to regulation of transcription initiation and elongation, as well as the chromatin state. Recent data suggest that the histone octamer is displaced from DNA at a high rate of transcription, but can survive less frequent transcription that is accompanied only by partial loss of H2A/H2B histones. Here we propose that critical density of Pol II molecules could be required for displacement of the histone octamer and discuss mechanisms that are most likely involved in the processes of histone exchange.

Histone acetylation, chromatin remodelling, transcription and nucleotide excision repair in S. cerevisiae: studies with two model genes

We describe the technology and two model systems in yeast designed to study nucleotide excision repair (NER) in relation to transcription and chromatin modifications. We employed the MFA2 and MET16 genes as models. How transcription-coupled (TCR) and global genome repair (GGR) operate at the transcriptionally active and/or repressed S. cerevisiae MFA2 locus, and how this relates to nucleosome positioning are considered. We discuss the role of the Gcn5p histone acetyltransferase, also associated with MFA2's transcriptional activation, in facilitating efficient NER at the transcriptionally active and inactive genes. The effect of Gcn5p's absence in reducing NER was local and UV stimulates Gcn5p-mediated histone acetylation at the repressed MFA2 promoter. After UV irradiation Swi2p is partly responsible for facilitating access to restriction of DNA in the cores of the nucleosomes at the MFA2 promoter. The data suggest similarities between chromatin remodelling for NER and transcription, yet differences must exist to ensure this gene remains repressed in alpha cells during NER. For MET16, we consider experiments examining chromatin structure, transcription and repair in wild type and cbf1Delta cells under repressing or derepressing conditions. Cbf1p is a sequence specific DNA binding protein required for MET16 chromatin remodelling and transcription.

Nucleosomes can form a polar barrier to transcript elongation by RNA polymerase II

Nucleosomes uniquely positioned on high-affinity DNA sequences present a polar barrier to transcription by human and yeast RNA polymerase II (Pol II). In one transcriptional orientation, these nucleosomes provide a strong, factor- and salt-insensitive barrier at the entry into the H3/H4 tetramer that can be recapitulated without H2A/H2B dimers. The same nucleosomes transcribed in the opposite orientation form a weaker, more diffuse barrier that is largely relieved by higher salt, TFIIS, or FACT. Barrier properties are therefore dictated by both the local nucleosome structure (influenced by the strength of the histone-DNA interactions) and the location of the high-affinity DNA region within the nucleosome. Pol II transcribes DNA sequences at the entry into the tetramer much less efficiently than the same sequences located distal to the nucleosome dyad. Thus, entry into the tetramer by Pol II facilitates further transcription, perhaps due to partial unfolding of the tetramer from DNA.

Transcription elongation through a chromatin template

DNA transaction events occurring during cell life (replication, transcription, recombination, repair, cell division) are always linked to severe changes in the topological state of the double helix. However, since naked DNA almost does not exist in eukaryote nucleus but rather interacts with various proteins, including ubiquitous histones, these topological changes happen in a chromatin context. This review focuses on the role of chromatin fiber structure and dynamics in the regulation of transcription, with an almost exclusive emphasis on the elongation step. Beside a brief overview of our knowledge about transcribed chromatin, we will see how recent mechanistic and biochemical studies give us new insights into the way cell could modulate DNA supercoiling and chromatin conformational dynamics. The participation of topoisomerases in this complex ballet is discussed, since recent data suggest that their role could be closely related to the precise chromatin structure. Lastly, some future prospects to carry on are proposed, hoping this review will help in stimulating discussions and further investigations in the field.

Nucleosome displacement in transcription

Recent reports reinforce the notion that nucleosomes are highly dynamic in response to the process of transcription. Nucleosomes are displaced at promoters during gene activation in a process that involves histone modification, ATP-dependent nucleosome remodeling complexes, histone chaperones and perhaps histone variants. During transcription elongation nucleosomes are acetylated and transferred behind RNA polymerase II where they are required to suppress spurious transcription initiation within the body of the gene. It is becoming increasingly clear that the eukaryotic transcriptional machinery is adapted to exploit the presence of nucleosomes in very sophisticated ways.

The nucleosome: a transparent, slippery, sticky and yet stable DNA-protein complex

Roughly three quarters of eucaryotic DNA are tightly wrapped onto protein cylinders organized in so-called nucleosomes. Despite this fact, the wrapped DNA cannot be inert since DNA is at the heart of many crucial life processes. We focus here on physical mechanisms that might allow nucleosomes to perform a great deal of such processes, specifically 1) on unwrapping fluctuations that give DNA-binding proteins access to the wrapped DNA portions without disrupting the nucleosome as a whole, 2) on corkscrew sliding along DNA and some implications and on 3) tail-bridging-induced attraction between nucleosomes as a means of controlling higher-order folding.

Construction, analysis, and transcription of model nucleosomal templates

Transcription through the nucleosome by Saccharomyces cerevisiae RNA polymerase II (Pol II) is characterized by an almost absolute block to transcription at physiological ionic strength and displacement of one H2A/H2B dimer to form a hexasome [Mol. Cell 9 (2002) 541]. In previous studies of Pol II transcription through chromatin, templates containing nucleosomes in multiple positions were used. These templates do not allow detailed analysis of the mechanism of transcription through chromatin. Here, we describe the development of a new template that is only long enough to accommodate a single nucleosome position along the DNA so that all of the templates are identical and allow for more in-depth analysis. After ligation of the nucleosome to promoter DNA or assembled elongation complexes, the mechanism of transcription through this uniquely positioned nucleosome by various RNA polymerases can be analyzed.

Nature of the nucleosomal barrier to RNA polymerase II

In the cell, RNA polymerase II (pol II) efficiently transcribes DNA packaged into nucleosomes, but in vitro encounters with the nucleosomes induce catalytic inactivation (arrest) of the pol II core enzyme. To determine potential mechanisms making nucleosomes transparent to transcription in vivo, we analyzed the nature of the nucleosome-induced arrest. We found that the arrests have been detected mostly at positions of strong intrinsic pause sites of DNA. The transient pausing makes pol II vulnerable to arrest, which involves backtracking of the elongation complex for a considerable distance on DNA. The histone-DNA contacts reestablished in front of pol II stabilize backtracked conformation of the polymerase. In agreement with this mechanism, blocking of backtracking prevents nucleosome-induced arrest. Transcript cleavage factor TFIIS reactivates the backtracked complexes and promotes pol II transcription through the nucleosome. Our findings establish the crucial role of elongation factors that suppress pol II pausing and backtracking for transcription in the context of chromatin.

Theory of Nucleosome Corkscrew Sliding in the Presence of Synthetic DNA Ligands

Histone octamers show a heat-induced mobility along DNA. Recent theoretical studies have established two mechanisms that are qualitatively and quantitatively compatible with in vitro experiments on nucleosome sliding: octamer repositioning through one-base-pair twist defects and through ten-base-pair bulge defects. A recent experiment demonstrated that the repositioning is strongly suppressed in the presence of minor-groove binding DNA ligands. In the present study, we give a quantitative theory for nucleosome repositioning in the presence of such ligands. We show that the experimentally observed octamer mobilities are consistent with the picture of bound ligands blocking the passage of twist defects through the nucleosome. This strongly supports the model of twist defects inducing a corkscrew motion of the nucleosome as the underlying mechanism of nucleosome sliding. We provide a theoretical estimate of the nucleosomal mobility without adjustable parameters, as a function of ligand concentration, binding affinity, binding site orientation, temperature and DNA anisotropy. Having this mobility in hand, we speculate on the interaction between a nucleosome and a transcribing RNA polymerase, and suggest a novel mechanism that might account for polymerase-induced nucleosome repositioning on short DNA templates.

The histone octamer is invisible when NF-kappaB binds to the nucleosome

The transcription factor NF-kappaB is involved in the transcriptional control of more than 150 genes, but the way it acts at the level of nucleosomal templates is not known. Here we report on a study examining the interaction of NF-kappaB p50 with its DNA recognition sequence in a positioned nucleosome. We demonstrate that NF-kappaB p50 was able to bind to the nucleosome with an apparent association constant close to that for free DNA. In agreement with this, the affinity of NF-kappaB p50 binding does not depend on the localization of its recognition sequence relative to the nucleosome dyad axis. In addition, the binding of NF-kappaB p50 does not induce eviction of histones and does not perturb the overall structure of the nucleosome. The NF-kappaB p50-nucleosome complex exhibits, however, local structural alterations within the NF-kappaB p50 recognition site. Importantly, these alterations were very similar to those found in the NF-kappaB p50-DNA complex. Our data suggest that NF-kappaB p50 can accommodate the distorted, bent DNA within the nucleosome. This peculiar property of NF-kappaB p50 might have evolved to meet the requirements for its function as a central switch for stress responses.

Transcription by an archaeal RNA polymerase is slowed but not blocked by an archaeal nucleosome

Archaeal RNA polymerases (RNAPs) are closely related to eukaryotic RNAPs, and in Euryarchaea, genomic DNA is wrapped and compacted by histones into archaeal nucleosomes. In eukaryotes, transcription of DNA bound into nucleosomes is facilitated by histone tail modifications and chromatin remodeling complexes, but archaeal histones do not have histone tails and archaeal genome sequences provide no evidence for archaeal homologs of eukaryotic chromatin remodeling complexes. We have therefore investigated the ability of an archaeal RNAP, purified from Methanothermobacter thermautotrophicus, to transcribe DNA bound into an archaeal nucleosome by HMtA2, an archaeal histone from M. thermautotrophicus. To do so, we constructed a template that allows transcript elongation to be separated from transcription initiation, on which archaeal nucleosome assembly is positioned downstream from the site of transcription initiation. At 58 degrees C, in the absence of an archaeal nucleosome, M. thermautotrophicus RNAP transcribed this template DNA at a rate of approximately 20 nucleotides per second. With an archaeal nucleosome present, transcript elongation was slowed but not blocked, with transcription pausing at sites before and within the archaeal nucleosome. With additional HMtA2 binding, complexes were obtained that also incorporated the upstream regulatory region. This inhibited transcription presumably by preventing archaeal TATA-box binding protein, general transcription factor TFB, and RNAP access and thus inhibiting transcription initiation.

Cbf1p modulates chromatin structure, transcription and repair at the Saccharomyces cerevisiae MET16 locus

The presence of damage in the transcribed strand (TS) of active genes and its position in relation to nucleosomes influence nucleotide excision repair (NER) efficiency. We examined chromatin structure, transcription and repair at the MET16 gene of wild-type and cbf1Delta Saccharomyces cerevisiae cells under repressing or derepressing conditions. Cbf1p is a sequence-specific DNA binding protein required for MET16 chromatin remodelling. Irrespective of the level of transcription, repair at the MspI restriction fragment of MET16 exhibits periodicity in line with nucleosome positions in both strands of the regulatory region and the non-transcribed strand of the coding region. However, repair in the coding region of the TS is always faster, but exhibits periodicity only when MET16 is repressed. In general, absence of Cbf1p decreased repair in the sequences examined, although the effects were more dramatic in the Cbf1p remodelled area, with repair being reduced to the lowest levels within the nucleosome cores of this region. Our results indicate that repair at the promoter and coding regions of this lowly transcribed gene are dependent on both chromatin structure and the level of transcription. The data are discussed in light of current models relating NER and chromatin structure.

Transcription through chromatin: understanding a complex FACT

In eukaryotic cells, genomic DNA is assembled with chromosomal proteins, mainly histones, in a highly compact structure termed chromatin. In this form, DNA is not readily accessible to the cellular machineries, which require DNA as a template. Dynamic changes in chromatin organization play a critical role in regulation of DNA-dependent processes such as transcription, DNA replication, recombination and repair. Chromatin structure is altered in transcriptionally active loci: the basic chromatin unit, the nucleosome, appears to be depleted for one histone H2A/H2B dimer. Previously, reconstitution of RNA polymerase II (PolII)-driven transcription on chromatin templates in a highly purified in vitro system led to identification of FACT (for facilitates chromatin transcription), which was required for productive transcript elongation through nucleosomes. FACT was proposed to promote PolII transcription through nucleosomes by removing either one or both H2A/H2B dimers. Here we present an overview of the earlier studies, which resulted in the initial identification and characterization of FACT, as well as the recent findings that refine the model for the mechanism of FACT function in transcription.

In vivo interactions of the Acanthamoeba TBP gene promoter

Transcription of the TATA box binding protein (TBP) gene in Acanthamoeba castellanii is regulated by TATA box binding protein promoter binding factor (TPBF), which binds to an upstream TBP promoter element to stimulate transcription, and to a TATA proximal element, where it represses transcription. In order to extend these observations to the in vivo chromatin context, the TBP gene was examined by in situ footprinting and chromatin immunoprecipitation (ChIP). Acanthamoeba DNA is nucleosomal with a repeat of approximately 160 bp, and an intranucleosomal DNA periodicity of 10.5 bp. The TBP gene comprises a 220 bp micrococcal nuclease hypersensitive site corresponding to the promoter regulatory elements previously identified, flanked by protected regions of a size consistent with the presence of nucleosomes. ChIP data indicated that TPBF is associated with the TBP, TPBF and MIL gene promoters, but not to the CSP21, MIIHC, 5SrRNA or 39SrRNA promoters, or to the MIL gene C-terminal region. Binding by TPBF to the TPBF and MIL gene promoters was confirmed by in vitro assays. These results validate the in vitro model for TBP gene regulation and further suggest that TPBF may be autoregulated and may participate in the regulation of the MIL gene.

Bacterial polymerase and yeast polymerase II use similar mechanisms for transcription through nucleosomes

We have previously shown that nucleosomes act as a strong barrier to yeast RNA polymerase II (Pol II) in vitro and that transcription through the nucleosome results in the loss of an H2A/H2B dimer. Here, we demonstrate that Escherichia coli RNA polymerase (RNAP), which never encounters chromatin in vivo, behaves similarly to Pol II in all aspects of transcription through the nucleosome in vitro. The nucleosome-specific pausing pattern of RNAP is comparable with that of Pol II. At physiological ionic strength or lower, the nucleosome blocks RNAP progression along the template, but this barrier can be relieved at higher ionic strength. Transcription through the nucleosome by RNAP results in the loss of an H2A/H2B dimer, and the histones that remain in the hexasome retain their original positions on the DNA. The results were similar for elongation complexes that were assembled from components (oligonucleotides and RNAP) and elongation complexes obtained by initiation from the promoter. The data suggest that eukaryotic Pol II and E. coli RNAP utilize very similar mechanisms for transcription through the nucleosome. Thus, bacterial RNAP can be used as a suitable model system to study general aspects of chromatin transcription by Pol II. Furthermore, the data argue that the general elongation properties of polymerases may determine the mechanism used for transcription through the nucleosome.

Structure-function relationships in nucleosomal arrays containing linker histone H5

To study the structural and functional changes accompanying the integration of histone H5 into the nucleosome structure, linear DNA species have been employed with a terminal promoter for bacteriophage T7 RNA polymerase followed by tandem repeats of a 207-bp nucleosome positioning sequence. The oligonucleosomes assembled from 12-repeat DNA and saturating amounts of core histone octamer plus histone H5 are compacted, in the presence of 1 mM free magnesium ions, to the level of the 30-nm fiber. Under these ionic conditions the efficiency in RNA synthesis and the size distribution of RNA chains obtained with this template are the same as those corresponding to the template without H5, indicating that the 30-nm fiber stabilized by H5 does not impair RNA elongation. Therefore, under our experimental conditions, incorporation of one molecule of histone H5 per nucleosome does not affect elongation of RNA even when a folded structure is produced. However, elongation is inhibited by binding of an excess of H5.

Chromatin fibers, one-at-a-time

Eukaryotic DNA is presented to the enzymatic machineries that use DNA as a template in the form of chromatin fibers. At the first level of organization, DNA is wrapped around histone octamers to form nucleosomal particles that are connected with stretches of linker DNA; this beads-on-a-string structure folds further to reach a very compact state in the nucleus. Chromatin structure is in constant flux, changing dynamically to accommodate the needs of the cell to replicate, transcribe, and repair the DNA, and to regulate all these processes in time and space. The more conventional biochemical and biophysical techniques used to study chromatin structure and dynamics have been recently complemented by an array of single-molecule approaches, in which chromatin fibers are investigated one-at-a-time. Here we describe single-molecule efforts to see nucleosomes, touch them, put them together, and then take them apart, one-at-a-time. The beginning is exciting and promising, but much more effort will be needed to take advantage of the huge potential that the new physics-based techniques offer.

Visualizing RNA extrusion and DNA wrapping in transcription elongation complexes of bacterial and eukaryotic RNA polymerases

Transcription ternary complexes of Escherichia coli RNA polymerase and yeast RNA polymerase III have been analyzed by atomic force microscopy. Using the method of nucleotide omission and different DNA templates, E.coli RNAP has been stalled at position +24, +70 and +379 and RNAP III at position +377 from the starting site. Conformational analysis of E.coli RNAP elongation complexes reveals an average DNA compaction of 22nm and a DNA deformation compatible with approximately 180 degrees DNA wrapping against the enzyme. The extent of protein-DNA interaction attributed to wrapping, however, is less than that of corresponding open promoter complexes. DNA wrapping was also observed for RNAP III elongation complexes, which showed a DNA compaction of 30nm. When the RNA polymerases were stalled far from the promoter (+379 and +377), the growing RNA transcript was often visible and it was prevalently seen exiting from the enzyme on the opposite side relative to the smallest angle subtended by the upstream and downstream DNA arms. Surprisingly, we found that many complexes had a second RNAP, not involved in transcription, bound to the growing RNA of a ternary complex. DNA wrapping in the elongation complex suggests a possible mechanism by which the polymerase may overcome the physical barrier to transcription imposed by the nucleosomes.

Spontaneous access of proteins to buried nucleosomal DNA target sites occurs via a mechanism that is distinct from nucleosome translocation

Intrinsic nucleosome dynamics termed "site exposure" provides spontaneous and cooperative access to buried regions of nucleosomal DNA in vitro. Two different mechanisms for site exposure have been proposed, one based on nucleosome translocation, the other on dynamic nucleosome conformational changes in which a stretch of the nucleosomal DNA is transiently released off the histone surface. Here we report on three experiments that distinguish between these mechanisms. One experiment investigates the effects on the accessibilities of restriction enzyme target sites inside nucleosomes when extra DNA (onto which the nucleosome may move at low energetic cost) is appended onto one end. The other two experiments test directly for nucleosome mobility under the conditions used to probe accessibility to restriction enzymes: one on a selected nonnatural nucleosome positioning sequence, the other on the well-studied 5S rRNA gene nucleosome positioning sequence. We find from all three assays that restriction enzymes gain access to sites throughout the entire length of the nucleosomal DNA without contribution from nucleosome translocation. We conclude that site exposure in nucleosomes in vitro occurs via a nucleosome conformational change that leads to transient release of a stretch of DNA from the histone surface, most likely involving progressive uncoiling from an end. Recapture at a distal site along DNA that has partially uncoiled would result in looped structures which are believed to contribute to RNA polymerase elongation and may contribute to spontaneous or ATP-driven nucleosome mobility. Transient open states may facilitate the initial entry of transcription factors and enzymes in vivo.

Spontaneous access of proteins to buried nucleosomal DNA target sites occurs via a mechanism that is distinct from nucleosome translocation

Intrinsic nucleosome dynamics termed "site exposure" provides spontaneous and cooperative access to buried regions of nucleosomal DNA in vitro. Two different mechanisms for site exposure have been proposed, one based on nucleosome translocation, the other on dynamic nucleosome conformational changes in which a stretch of the nucleosomal DNA is transiently released off the histone surface. Here we report on three experiments that distinguish between these mechanisms. One experiment investigates the effects on the accessibilities of restriction enzyme target sites inside nucleosomes when extra DNA (onto which the nucleosome may move at low energetic cost) is appended onto one end. The other two experiments test directly for nucleosome mobility under the conditions used to probe accessibility to restriction enzymes: one on a selected nonnatural nucleosome positioning sequence, the other on the well-studied 5S rRNA gene nucleosome positioning sequence. We find from all three assays that restriction enzymes gain access to sites throughout the entire length of the nucleosomal DNA without contribution from nucleosome translocation. We conclude that site exposure in nucleosomes in vitro occurs via a nucleosome conformational change that leads to transient release of a stretch of DNA from the histone surface, most likely involving progressive uncoiling from an end. Recapture at a distal site along DNA that has partially uncoiled would result in looped structures which are believed to contribute to RNA polymerase elongation and may contribute to spontaneous or ATP-driven nucleosome mobility. Transient open states may facilitate the initial entry of transcription factors and enzymes in vivo.