Twins and Chronogenetics: Correlated Pathways of Development

Heritability of Psychological Traits and Developmental Milestones in Infancy: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis

IMPORTANCE

Although infancy is the most rapid period of postnatal growth and development, factors associated with variation in infant traits are not well understood.

OBJECTIVE

To synthesize the large twin study literature partitioning phenotypic variance in psychological traits and developmental milestones in infancy into estimates of heritability and shared and nonshared environment.

DATA SOURCES

PubMed, PsycINFO, and references of included publications were searched up to February 11, 2021.

STUDY SELECTION

Peer-reviewed publications using the classical twin design to study psychological traits and developmental milestones from birth to 2 years old were included.

DATA EXTRACTION AND SYNTHESIS

Data were extracted in line with Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses and categorized using the International Classification of Functioning, Disability and Health: Children and Youth Version. Data were pooled in 3-level random effects models, incorporating within-cohort variance in outcome measurement and between-cohort variance. Data were analyzed from March 2021 through September 2021.

MAIN OUTCOMES AND MEASURES

The primary outcomes were monozygotic and dizygotic twin correlations. These were used to calculate genetic and shared and nonshared environment estimates.

RESULTS

Among 139 publications that were systematically retrieved, data were available on 79 044 twin pairs (31 053 monozygotic and 47 991 dizygotic pairs), 52 independent samples, and 21 countries. Meta-analyses were conducted on psychological traits and developmental milestones from 106 publications organized into 10 categories of functioning, disability, and health. Moderate to high genetic estimates for 8 categories were found, the highest of which was psychomotor functions (pooled h2, 0.59; 95% CI, 0.25-0.79; P < .001). Several categories of traits had substantial shared environment estimates, the highest being mental functions of language (pooled c2, 0.59; 95% CI, 0.24-0.86; P = .001). All examined categories of traits had moderate or high nonshared environment estimates, the highest of which were emotional functions (pooled e2, 0.42; 95% CI, 0.33-0.50; P < .001) and family relationships (pooled e2, 0.42; 95% CI, 0.30-0.55; P < .001).

CONCLUSIONS AND RELEVANCE

These findings may be an important source of information to guide future gene discovery research, public perspectives on nature and nurture, and clinical insights into the degree to which family history and environments may estimate major domains of infant functioning, disability, and health in psychological traits and developmental milestones.

Eight-Year Follow-up of Cognitive Development in 33 Twin Pairs

This is a follow-up study of twins, including 33 twinpairs from the Stockholm area, aiming to study the cognitive development of twins at eight years of age. The twins have been followed at different ages from birth onwards. All children were tested with the Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children in a Swedish translation (WISC). The WISC test consists of a Verbal and a Performance Scale. There were no significant differences between twin girls and twin boys on these Scales. On the Performance subtests Block Design, Object Assembly, and Coding, however, the twin girls performed significantly better than the twin boys. In comparing cognitive development for twins and singletons, the twin group had somewhat lower average scores than the singletons. Prematurity and low birth weight continued to be related to cognitive development at eight years of age. Also at this age the school teacher completed a questionnaire about the twins social behaviour and some personality traits. There was a relation between one questionnaire factor, a low score of assertiveness, and the mother's negative or ambivalent expectations concerning the twin pregnancy. The twin group with the mother's negative expectations also had significantly lower results on the subtests Comprehension and Coding. Negative mothers had more premature twins than mothers who were positive toward the twin pregnancy.

Comparative Development of Surviving Co-Twins of Vanishing Twin Conceptions, Twins and Singletons

Early loss of one fetus in a multiple gestation as a ‘vanishing’ twin is a well recognized phenomenon. It is uncertain whether this has an impact on the development of the surviving co-twin. The aim of this study is to compare the development of singletons, twins and the surviving co-twins of a vanishing twin. The 324 children born to 229 women who were recruited into the study between 1999 and 2001 formed the study population. Children were assessed at 1 year of age with Griffiths Mental and Developmental Scales. A neurological examination was performed using an optimality score to exclude those with severe neurodisability. Three hundred and five children (92 singletons, 180 twins and 33 survivors with a vanishing twin) were included. The sub- and general quotient scores in singletons and surviving co-twins of a vanishing twin did not differ significantly. Twins had significantly lower scores than singletons in all areas of development and were more likely to be born early with lower birthweights. Following adjustment for gestation and birthweight, the difference between the two groups was nullified suggesting that the slower development of twins is related to their prematurity and lower birthweight.

Biometrical analysis of individual growth curves

Longitudinal data for height (length) between birth and 2 years of age were examined for 690 Dutch Registry twin pairs. A two-stage analysis was performed, where individual growth curves were first fit to available data for each subject using a linear multiple regression procedure and estimated individual growth curve parameters were then subjected to multivariate biometrical analysis. Quadratic polynomial curves were found to adequately represent observed growth patterns for the majority of cases (median R2 = .98). A specific scalar model of sex limitation best characterized individual variation in growth curve parameters. That is, there was significantly greater genetic variation for boys than for girls in both the predicted length and rate of growth at 1 year of age and the amount of deceleration in individual growth curves across age.

Quantitative genetic analysis of longitudinal trends in height: preliminary results from the Louisville Twin Study

A preliminary series of quantitative genetic models was applied to a subset of longitudinal height data, spanning birth to maturity, gathered from twin families in the Louisville Twin Study. Descriptive Cholesky factor parameterization was found to give more satisfactory results than did a system of constraints based on a model of developmental transmission of a time-constant and time-specific factors. The results from application of two autosomal sex-limitation models are contrasted with those from a model specifying both autosomal and sex-chromosomal patterns of inheritance. The latter model was more conducive to parameter reduction. Although these models do not constitute conclusive tests of autosomal sex-limitation versus sex-linkage, the more parsimonious model is consistent with previous research suggesting a stature locus on the long arm of the Y chromosome. Heritability of height is estimated at about 90% or greater from 6 years of age on. Substantial and fairly constant longitudinal genetic correlations are found from 3 years of age on. Shared environmental effects unrelated to parental height were seen for birth length, corrected for gestational age, to height at 3 years of age, but these are not satisfactorily differentiated from possible twin effects in the present sample. The genetic consequences of assortative mating are emphasized since failure to take assortment into account can lead to overestimation of shared environmental effects and under-estimation of genetic effects. The results indicate that about 20% of within-gender variability for mature height can be attributed to the genetic consequences of assortment, even though the phenotypic marital correlation of 0.22 is quite modest. The importance of testing the assumption of multivariate normality underlying the application of the method of maximum-likelihood is also highlighted.