Management of retraction pockets of the pars tensa in children by excision and ventilation tube insertion

Management of tympanic membrane retractions: a systematic review

Importance

Tympanic membrane retraction (TMR) is a relatively common otological finding. However, no consensus on its management exists. We are looking especially for a treatment strategy in the military population who are unable to attend frequent follow-up visits, and who experience relatively more barotrauma at great heights and depths and easily suffer from otitis externa from less hygienic circumstances.

Objective

To assess and summarize the available evidence for the effectiveness of surgical interventions and watchful waiting policy in patients with a tympanic membrane retraction.

Evidence review

The protocol for this systematic review was published at Prospero (207859). PubMed, Embase, and the Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews were systematically searched from inception up to September 2020 for published and unpublished studies. We included randomized trials and observational studies that investigated surgical interventions (tympanoplasty, ventilation tube insertion) and wait-and-see policy. The primary outcomes of this study were clinical remission of the tympanic membrane retraction, tympanic membrane perforations and cholesteatoma development.

Findings

In total, 27 studies were included, consisting of 1566 patients with TMRs. We included data from 2 randomized controlled trials (76 patients) and 25 observational studies (1490 patients). Seven studies (329 patients) investigated excision of the TMR with and without ventilation tube placement, 3 studies (207 patients) investigated the wait-and-see policy and 17 studies (1030 patients) investigated tympanoplasty for the treatment of TMRs.

Conclusions and relevance

This study provides all the studies that have been published on the surgical management and wait-and-policy for tympanic membrane retractions. No high level of evidence comparative studies has been performed. The evidence for the management of tympanic membrane retractions is heterogenous and depends on many factors such as the patient population, location and severity of the TMR and presence of other ear pathologies (e.g., perforation, risk of cholesteatoma and serous otitis media).

Supplementary Information

The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1007/s00405-021-06719-3.

Tympanic membrane retraction pocket staging: is it worthwhile?

Our objectives were to review all reported staging systems of tympanic membrane (TM) retraction pockets (RP) and to report their reliability and utility to our daily clinical practice in terms of follow-up and decision making in the management of RP. We aim to propose a new management algorithm of TMRPs. We conducted a thorough research on Ovid Medline, Pubmed and Cochrane databases for English and French languages studies published between 1963 and 2012 on the retraction pocket. Studies were excluded if it were a short comments, photo clinical cases, experimental studies or round table articles. Cholesteatoma was not included in keywords, since it is considered as an advanced pathological entity with different staging and management approaches. We included 60 of 756 articles that met our inclusion criteria. Sadé and Berco proposed the first staging system of RP in 1976, while the last one was described by Borgstein et al. in 2007. From 1976 to 2007, 12 different staging systems have been described for tympanic membrane retractions. There are three broad categories of TMRPs: localized retractions of the pars tensa, generalized retractions of the pars tensa (atelectasis) and retraction of the pars flaccida. Most of the described staging systems are useful for following up the evolution of retractions over time. However, no consensus was found concerning the decision making in its management. In conclusion, proper management of TMRPs requires a reproducible, easily applicable staging system with low inter- and intra-observer variability. We propose a management algorithm that considers the functional handicap of the patient rather than the topographic description of the TM.

The prevalence of tympanic membrane and related middle ear pathology in children: a large longitudinal cohort study followed from birth to age ten

OBJECTIVE

To record with video-otoscopy the appearance of the tympanic membranes of a cross section of children aged 9 to 10 years.

STUDY DESIGN

Cross-sectional study nested within an established longitudinal study of childhood development, the Avon Longitudinal Study of Parents and Children.

SETTING

South West England, U.K.

PARTICIPANTS

Approximately 6908 of 7261 children with ages ranging from 105 to 140 months born between April 1, 1991, and December 31, 1992, were examined by trained technicians with video-otoscopy.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Two photographs were taken of each child's tympanic membranes to show the features of the pars tensa and the pars flaccida.

RESULTS

In just less than three quarters of the children, both ears were normal. Retraction of the pars flaccida was present in 9.6% of children, and that of the pars tensa was present in 7.9%. Most of these changes were mild with few severe retractions. There were 15 cases of overt or suspected cholesteatoma.

CONCLUSION

The tympanic membrane changes reflect most of the middle ear disease seen in 9- to 10-year-old children. The prevalence is low, and few children have serious disease at this stage.

Transmeatal excision of pars tensa retraction pockets with simultaneous ventilation tube insertion in children: a prospective study

Grade II and III (according to Sadé's classification) retraction pockets (RPs) in 40 ears of 30 children were excised transmeatally with simultaneous ventilation tube insertion. At a mean follow-up of 16.1 months, an intact tympanic membrane and mild, grade I retractions not requiring treatment were observed in 32 ears (80%). The mean air-bone gap had decreased from 22.4 to 9.7 dB. Two residual perforations and six recurrent grade II RPs were detected, all these eight ears undergoing further surgery. The second surgery solved both of the residual perforations and four of the six grade II recurrences. The age of the children did not influence the success rate, whereas bilateral pathology, a higher grade and more extensive RPs were associated with a higher rate of unsuccessful cases. A staging system is introduced to ease the selection of candidates with a good prognosis for this procedure.

Retraction pockets in chronic suppurative otitis media- our experience

Retractions of the tympanic membrane constitute a large proportion of ear diseases causing concern to the otologist. The clinical features in a case of retraction pocket are varied and cholesteatoma. Also, that a retraction pocket in the posterosuperior region and pars ftaccida is a precursor of cholesteatoma is now well recognized. We have studied 60 cases of retraction pockets during a period of 5 years and have attempted to find out the etiology as well as the most effective treatment in such cases. Though over the years along with a dysfunctional eustachian tube, a sclerotic mastoid has been implicated as one of the causes of Retraction Pockets, we in our study have seen a large sized mastoid antrum (beyond 2 mm vf Lateral Semicircular Canal) as a consistent feature in most of our cases. This was subjectively assessed as a surgical finding in tympanomastoidectomy and objectively assessed by a high Resolution Computed Tomography of the temporal bone. We have found that a canal wall down mastoidectomy was the most effective in preventing the recurrence of retraction pockets. In a coutry like India, canal wall down mastoidectomy offers an acceptable solution to the problem of retraction pocket as not only is the follow up of patients poor but also the "Second- Look" procedure is not always possible. The use of 1- 0 chromic catgut in the middle ear instead of the more conventionally used silastic in preventing recurrent retractions can be considered as an effective single-staged procedure.

Comparison of the incidence of cholesteatoma surgery before and after using ventilation tubes for secretory otitis media

Inserting ventilation tubes has become, probably, the most common surgical operation performed on children in the free world. In our study, we attempted to examine whether the widely used procedure of inserting ventilation tubes in children with secretory otitis media is indeed justified in the long term. For this purpose, we have studied the influence of the procedure on the formation of cholesteatoma by comparing the incidence of cholesteatoma surgery before and after using ventilation tubes in our department. The data were divided into two periods. The first period included the number of operations in the 10 years (1961-1970) before ventilation tubes were used as a routine treatment for secretory otitis media in our department. The second period included the number of operations in the last 10 years (1989-1998) following the usage of ventilation tubes over 30 years. We found that the number of cholesteatoma operations has decreased, from 413 operations in the 10 years before ventilation tubes were used to 228 operations over the last 10 years. The number of operations per 10000 of the entire population has decreased from 20 operations to 6.6 operations after using ventilation tubes (P=0.0000001). We have shown that the incidence of surgery for cholesteatoma has been declining. Having analyzed the options that might cause this decline, we believe that using ventilation tubes in secretory otitis media might help to reduce the incidence of cholesteatoma surgery in the long term.

Pars tensa retraction pockets in children: treatment by excision and ventilation tube insertion

Tympanic membrane retraction pockets involving the pars tensa are not uncommon in clinical practice. Recurrent infections, ossicular erosion and cholesteatoma are the recognized sequelae. The management options include surveillance, medical treatment and surgery. The surgical procedures range from grommet insertion to extensive tympanoplasty procedures. We report our experience with simple excision and grommet insertion, performed in 31 ears in 26 patients as day cases. The follow-up ranged from 8 to 34 months with a mean of 16 months. The procedure was successful in 23 ears (success rate of 74%). Recurrence of retraction occurred in seven ears and in one ear there was a persistent perforation. Age, previous grommet insertion and severity of retraction did not have a statistically significant influence on the final outcome. We conclude that excision and grommet insertion is a simple, safe and efficient procedure for the management of tympanic membrane retraction pockets and can be considered in preference to extensive tympanoplasty.