Collisionally activated dissociation and electron capture dissociation of several mass spectrometry-identifiable chemical cross-linkers

Mass Spectrometry-Cleavable Protein N-Terminal Tagging Strategy for System-Level Protease Activity Profiling

Proteolysis is one of the most important protein post-translational modifications (PTMs) that influences the functions, activities, and structures of nearly all proteins during their lifetime. To facilitate the targeted identification of low-abundant proteolytic products, we devised a strategy incorporating a novel biotinylated reagent PFP (pentafluorophenyl)-Rink-biotin to specifically target, enrich and identify proteolytic N-termini. Within the PFP-Rink-biotin reagent, a mass spectrometry (MS)-cleavable feature was designed to assist in the unambiguous confirmation of the enriched proteolytic N-termini. The proof-of-concept study was performed with multiple standard proteins whose N-termini were successfully modified, enriched and identified by a signature ion (SI) in the MS/MS fragmentation, along with the determination of N-terminal peptide sequences by multistage tandem MS of the complementary fragment generated after the cleavage of MS-cleavable bond. For large-scale application, the enrichment and identification of protein N-termini from Escherichia coli cells were demonstrated, facilitated by an in-house developed NTermFinder bioinformatics workflow. We believe this approach will be beneficial in improving the confidence of identifying proteolytic substrates in a native cellular environment.

Isobaric Quantitative Protein Interaction Reporter Technology for Comparative Interactome Studies

Chemical cross-linking with mass spectrometry (XL-MS) has emerged as a useful tool for the large-scale study of protein structures and interactions from complex biological samples including intact cells and tissues. Quantitative XL-MS (qXL-MS) provides unique information on protein conformational and interaction changes resulting from perturbations such as drug treatment and disease state. Previous qXL-MS studies relied on the incorporation of stable isotopes into the cross-linker (primarily deuterium) or metabolic labeling with SILAC. Here, we introduce isobaric quantitative protein interaction reporter (iqPIR) technology which utilizes stable isotopes selectively incorporated into the cross-linker design, allowing for isobaric cross-linked peptide pairs originating from different samples to display distinct quantitative isotope signatures in tandem mass spectra. This enables improved quantitation of cross-linked peptide levels from proteome-wide samples because of the reduced complexity of tandem mass spectra relative to MS¹ spectra. In addition, because of the isotope incorporation in the reporter and the residual components of the cross-linker that remain on released peptides, each fragmentation spectrum can offer multiple independent opportunities and, therefore, improved confidence for quantitative assessment of the cross-linker pair level. Finally, in addition to providing information on solvent accessibility of lysine sites, dead end iqPIR cross-linked products can provide protein abundance and/or lysine site modification level information all from a single in vivo cross-linking experiment.

Evaluating the performance of an ETD-cleavable cross-linking strategy for elucidating protein structures

Chemical cross-linking is a powerful strategy for elucidating the structures of protein or protein complexes. The distance constraints obtained from cross-linked peptides represent the three-dimensional structures of the protein complexes. Unfortunately, structural analysis using cross-linking approach demands a significant amount of data to elucidate protein structures. This requires the development of several cleavable cross-linkers with different range of spacer chains. An Electron Transfer Dissociation (ETD) tandem mass spectrometry cleavable bond hydrazone was reported. Its fragmentation with conjugated peptides showed promise for the development of a new ETD cleavable cross-linker. However, no cross-linker was developed utilizing this ETD cleavable bond. For the first time, we attempted to develop an ETD cleavable cross-linker utilizing a hydrazone bond. We overcome the pitfall for the synthesis of this cross-linker and an easy synthesis scheme is reported. In this report, we evaluated the performance of this cross-linker called Hydrazone Incorporated ETD cleavable cross-linker (HI-ETD-XL) in model peptides and proteins. The characteristic fragmentation behavior of HI-ETD-XL during electron transfer dissociation and subsequent sequence identification of the peptide fragment ions by tandem mass spectrometry allowed the identification of cross-linked peptides unambiguously. We believe the availability of this ETD cleavable cross-linker will advance structural proteomics research significantly. SIGNIFICANCE: Many cellular processes rely on the structural dynamics of protein complexes. The detailed knowledge of the structure and dynamics of protein complexes is crucial for understanding their biological functions and regulations. However, most of the structure of these multiprotein entities remain uncharacterized and sometimes is very challenging to reveal with biophysical techniques alone. Chemical cross-linking combined with mass spectrometry (MS) has proven to be a dependable strategy in structural proteomics field. However, data complexity and false identifications are significant hindrances for unambiguous identification of cross-linked peptides. Confident identifications demand structural studies with cross-linkers with different properties and variable spacer chain lengths. This new ETD cleavable cross-linking workflow will provide additional confidence to overcome these drawbacks and allow us to pinpoint cross-linked peptides confidently.

High Confidence Identification of Cross-Linked Peptides by an Enrichment-Based Dual Cleavable Cross-Linking Technology and Data Analysis tool Cleave-XL

Cleavable cross-linking technology requires further MS/MS of the cleavable fragments for unambiguous identification of cross-linked peptides. These spectra are sometimes very ambiguous due to the sensitivity and complex fragmentation pattern of the peptides with the cross-linked residues. We recently reported a dual cleavable cross-linking technology (DUCCT), which can enhance the confidence in the identification of cross-linked peptides. The heart of this strategy is a novel dual mass spectrometry cleavable cross linker that can be cleaved preferentially by two differential tandem mass spectrometry methods, collision induced dissociation and electron transfer dissociation (CID and ETD). Different signature ions from two different mass spectra for the same cross-linked peptide helped identify the cross-linked peptides with high confidence. In this study, we developed an enrichment-based photocleavable DUCCT (PC-DUCCT-biotin), where cross-linked products were enriched from biological samples using affinity purification, and subsequently, two sequential tandem (CID and ETD) mass spectrometry processes were utilized. Furthermore, we developed a prototype software called Cleave-XL to analyze cross-linked products generated by DUCCT. Photocleavable DUCCT was demonstrated in standard peptides and proteins. Efficiency of the software tools to search and compare CID and ETD data of photocleavable DUCCT biotin in standard peptides and proteins as well as regular DUCCT in protein complexes from immune cells were tested. The software is efficient in pinpointing cross-linked sites using CID and ETD cross-linking data. We believe this new DUCCT and associated software tool Cleave-XL will advance high confidence identification of protein cross-linking sites and automated identification of low-resolution protein structures.

ETD-Cleavable Linker for Confident Cross-linked Peptide Identifications

Peptide cross-links formed using the homobifunctional-linker diethyl suberthioimidate (DEST) are shown to be ETD-cleavable. DEST has a spacer arm consisting of a 6-carbon alkyl chain and it cleaves at the amidino groups created upon reaction with primary amines. In ETD MS² spectra, DEST cross-links can be recognized based on mass pairs consisting of peptide-NH₂^• and peptide+linker+NH₃ ions, and backbone cleavages are more equally distributed over the two constituent peptides compared with collisional activation. Dead ends that are often challenging to distinguish from cross-links are diagnosed by intense reporter ions. ETD mass pairs can be used in MS³ experiments to confirm cross-link identifications. These features provide a simple but reliable approach to identify cross-links that should facilitate studies of protein complexes.

Synthesis of CID-cleavable protein crosslinking agents containing quaternary amines for structural mass spectrometry

Two novel cyclic quaternary amine crosslinking probes are synthesized for structural mass spectrometry of protein complexes in solution and for analysis of protein interactions in organellar and whole cell extracts. Each exhibits high aqueous solubility, excellent protein crosslinking efficiencies, low collision induced dissociation (CID) energy fragmentation efficiencies, high stoichiometries of reaction, increased charges of crosslinked peptide ions, and maintenance of overall surface charge balance of crosslinked proteins.

Characterization and Identification of Dityrosine Cross-Linked Peptides Using Tandem Mass Spectrometry

The use of mass spectrometry coupled with chemical cross-linking of proteins has become a powerful tool for proteins structure and interactions studies. Unlike structural analysis of proteins using chemical reagents specific for lysine or cysteine residues, identification of gas-phase fragmentation patterns of endogenous dityrosine cross-linked peptides have not been investigated. Dityrosine cross-linking in proteins and peptides are clinical markers of oxidative stress, aging, and neurodegenerative diseases including Alzheimer's disease and Parkinson's disease. In this study, we investigated and characterized the fragmentation pattern of a synthetically prepared dityrosine cross-linked dimer of Aβ(1-16) using ESI tandem mass spectrometry. We then detailed the fragmentation pattern of dityrosine cross-linked Aβ(1-16), using collision induced dissociation (CID), higher-energy collision induced dissociation (HCD), electron transfer dissociation (ETD), and electron capture dissociation (ECD). Application of these generic fragmentation rules of dityrosine cross-linked peptides allowed for the identification of dityrosine cross-links in peptides of Aβ and α-synuclein generated in vitro by enzymatic peroxidation. We report, for the first time, the dityrosine cross-linked residues in human hemoglobin and α-synuclein under oxidative conditions. Together these tools open up the potential for automated analysis of this naturally occurring post-translation modification in neurodegenerative diseases as well as other pathological conditions.

Differential Tandem Mass Spectrometry-Based Cross-Linker: A New Approach for High Confidence in Identifying Protein Cross-Linking

Chemical cross-linking and mass spectrometry are now widely used to analyze large-scale protein-protein interactions. The major challenge in cross-linking approaches is the complexity of the mass spectrometric data. New approaches are required that can identify cross-linked peptides with high-confidence and establish a user-friendly analysis protocol for the biomedical scientific community. Here, we introduce a novel cross-linker that can be selectively cleaved in the gas phase using two differential tandem mass-spectrometric fragmentation methods, such as collision-induced or electron transfer dissociation (CID and ETD). This technique produces two signature mass spectra of the same cross-linked peptide, thereby producing high confidence in identifying the sites of interaction. Further tandem mass spectrometry can also give additional confidence on the peptide sequences. We demonstrate a proof-of-concept for this method using standard peptides and proteins. Peptides and proteins were cross-linked and their fragmentation characteristics were analyzed using CID and ETD tandem mass spectrometry. Two sequential cleavages unambiguously identified cross-linked peptides. In addition, the labeling efficiency of the new cross-linker was evaluated in macrophage immune cells after stimulation with the microbial ligand lipopolysaccharide and subsequent pulldown experiments with biotin-avidin affinity chromatography. We believe this strategy will help advance insights into the structural biology and systems biology of cell signaling.

Trifunctional cross-linker for mapping protein-protein interaction networks and comparing protein conformational states

To improve chemical cross-linking of proteins coupled with mass spectrometry (CXMS), we developed a lysine-targeted enrichable cross-linker containing a biotin tag for affinity purification, a chemical cleavage site to separate cross-linked peptides away from biotin after enrichment, and a spacer arm that can be labeled with stable isotopes for quantitation. By locating the flexible proteins on the surface of 70S ribosome, we show that this trifunctional cross-linker is effective at attaining structural information not easily attainable by crystallography and electron microscopy. From a crude Rrp46 immunoprecipitate, it helped identify two direct binding partners of Rrp46 and 15 protein-protein interactions (PPIs) among the co-immunoprecipitated exosome subunits. Applying it to E. coli and C. elegans lysates, we identified 3130 and 893 inter-linked lysine pairs, representing 677 and 121 PPIs. Using a quantitative CXMS workflow we demonstrate that it can reveal changes in the reactivity of lysine residues due to protein-nucleic acid interaction.

DOI:http://dx.doi.org/10.7554/eLife.12509.001

Proteins fold into structures that are determined by the order of the amino acids that they are built from. These structures enable the protein to carry out its role, which often involves interacting with other proteins. Chemical cross-linking coupled with mass spectrometry (CXMS) is a powerful method used to study protein structure and how proteins interact, with a benefit of stabilizing and capturing brief interactions.

CXMS uses a chemical compound called a linker that has two arms, each of which can bind specific amino acids in a protein or in multiple proteins. Only when the regions are close to each other can they be “cross-linked” in this way. After cross-linking, the proteins are cut into small pieces known as peptides. The cross-linked peptides are then separated from the non cross-linked ones and characterized.

Although CXMS is a popular method, there are aspects about it that limit its use. It does not work well on complex samples that contain lots of different proteins, as it is difficult to separate the cross-linked peptides from the overwhelming amounts of non cross-linked peptides. Also, although it can be used to detect changes in the shape of a protein, which are often crucial to the protein's role, the method has not been smoothed out.

Tan, Li et al. have now developed a new cross-linker called Leiker that addresses these limitations. Leiker cross-links the amino acid lysine to another lysine, and contains a molecular tag that allows cross-linked peptides to be efficiently purified away from non cross-linked peptides. As part of a streamlined workflow to detect changes in the shape of a protein, Leiker also contains a region that can be labeled.

Analysing a bacterial ribosome, which contains more than 50 proteins, showed that Leiker-based CXMS could detect many more protein interactions than previous studies had. These included interactions that changed too rapidly to be studied by other structural methods. Tan, Li et al. then applied Leiker-based CXMS to the entire contents of bacterial cells at different stages of growth, and identified a protein interaction that is only found in growing cells.

In future, Leiker will be useful for analyzing the structure of large protein complexes, probing changes in protein structure, and mapping the interactions between proteins in complex mixtures.

DOI:http://dx.doi.org/10.7554/eLife.12509.002

Protein Structural Analysis via Mass Spectrometry-Based Proteomics

Modern mass spectrometry (MS) technologies have provided a versatile platform that can be combined with a large number of techniques to analyze protein structure and dynamics. These techniques include the three detailed in this chapter: (1) hydrogen/deuterium exchange (HDX), (2) limited proteolysis, and (3) chemical crosslinking (CX). HDX relies on the change in mass of a protein upon its dilution into deuterated buffer, which results in varied deuterium content within its backbone amides. Structural information on surface exposed, flexible or disordered linker regions of proteins can be achieved through limited proteolysis, using a variety of proteases and only small extents of digestion. CX refers to the covalent coupling of distinct chemical species and has been used to analyze the structure, function and interactions of proteins by identifying crosslinking sites that are formed by small multi-functional reagents, termed crosslinkers. Each of these MS applications is capable of revealing structural information for proteins when used either with or without other typical high resolution techniques, including NMR and X-ray crystallography.

Using pLink to Analyze Cross-Linked Peptides

pLink is a search engine for high-throughput identification of cross-linked peptides from their tandem mass spectra, which is the data-analysis step in chemical cross-linking of proteins coupled with mass spectrometry analysis. pLink has accumulated more than 200 registered users from all over the world since its first release in 2012. After 2 years of continual development, a new version of pLink has been released, which is at least 40 times faster, more versatile, and more user-friendly. Also, the function of the new pLink has been expanded to identifying endogenous protein cross-linking sites such as disulfide bonds and SUMO (Small Ubiquitin-like MOdifier) modification sites. Integrated into the new version are two accessory tools: pLabel, to annotate spectra of cross-linked peptides for visual inspection and publication, and pConfig, to assist users in setting up search parameters. Here, we provide detailed guidance on running a database search for identification of protein cross-links using the 2014 version of pLink.

Mass spectrometry in studies of protein thiol chemistry and signaling: opportunities and caveats

Mass spectrometry (MS) has become a powerful and widely utilized tool in the investigation of protein thiol chemistry, biochemistry, and biology. Very early biochemical studies of metabolic enzymes have brought to light the broad spectrum of reactivity profiles that distinguish cysteine thiols with functions in catalysis and protein stability from other cysteine residues in proteins. The development of MS methods for the analysis of proteins using electrospray ionization (ESI) or matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization (MALDI) coupled with the emergence of high-resolution mass analyzers has been instrumental in advancing studies of thiol modifications, both in single proteins and within the cellular context. This article reviews MS instrumentation and methods of analysis employed in investigations of thiols and their reactivity toward a range of small biomolecules. A selected number of studies are detailed to highlight the advantages brought about by the MS technologies along with the caveats associated with these analyses.

Imidate-based cross-linkers for structural proteomics: increased charge of protein and peptide ions and CID and ECD fragmentation studies

Chemical cross-linking is an attractive low-resolution technique for structural studies of protein complexes. Distance constraints obtained from cross-linked peptides identified by mass spectrometry (MS) are used to construct and validate protein models. Amidinating cross-linkers such as diethyl suberthioimidate (DEST) have been used successfully in chemical cross-linking experiments. In this work, the application of a commercial diimidate cross-linking reagent, dimethyl suberimidate (DMS), was evaluated with model peptides and proteins. The peptides were designed with acetylated N-termini followed by random sequences containing two Lys residues separated by an Arg residue. After cross-linking reactions, intra- and intermolecular cross-linked species were submitted to CID and ECD dissociations to study their fragmentation features in the gas phase. Fragmentation of intramolecular peptides by collision induced dissociation (CID) demonstrates a unique two-step fragmentation pathway involving formation of a ketimine as intermediate. Electron capture and electron transfer dissociation (ECD and ETD) experiments demonstrated that the cyclic moiety is not dissociated. Intermolecular species demonstrated previously described fragmentation behavior in both CID and ECD experiments. The charge state distributions (CSD) obtained after reaction with DMS were compared with those obtained with disuccinimidyl suberate (DSS). CSDs for peptides and proteins were increased after their reaction with DMS, owing to the higher basicity of DMS modified species. These features were also observed in LC-MS experiments with bovine carbonic anhydrase II (BCA) after cross-linking with DMS and tryptic proteolysis. Cross-linked peptides derived from this protein were identified at high confidence and those species were in agreement with the crystal structure of BCA.

Cross-linking and mass spectrometry methodologies to facilitate structural biology: finding a path through the maze

Multiprotein complexes, rather than individual proteins, make up a large part of the biological macromolecular machinery of a cell. Understanding the structure and organization of these complexes is critical to understanding cellular function. Chemical cross-linking coupled with mass spectrometry is emerging as a complementary technique to traditional structural biology methods and can provide low-resolution structural information for a multitude of purposes, such as distance constraints in computational modeling of protein complexes. In this review, we discuss the experimental considerations for successful application of chemical cross-linking-mass spectrometry in biological studies and highlight three examples of such studies from the recent literature. These examples (as well as many others) illustrate the utility of a chemical cross-linking-mass spectrometry approach in facilitating structural analysis of large and challenging complexes.

Mass spectrometry supported determination of protein complex structure

Virtually all the biological processes are controlled and catalyzed by proteins which are, in many cases, in complexes with other proteins. Therefore, understanding the architecture and structure of protein complexes is critical to understanding their biological role and function. Traditionally, high-resolution data for structural analysis of proteins or protein complexes have been generated by the powerful methods of X-ray crystallography and nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy. More recently, mass spectrometry (MS)-based methods have been developed that provide low-resolution structural information, which contributes to the determination of the native structure of protein complexes that have remained refractory to the high-resolution methods. Native MS and affinity purification coupled with MS (AP-MS) have been used to characterize the composition, stoichiometry and connectivity of protein complexes. Chemical cross-linking MS (CX-MS) provides protein-protein interaction data supplemented with distance information that indicates residues that are in close spatial proximity in the native protein structure. Hydrogen-deuterium exchange combined with MS has been used to map protein-protein binding sites. Here, we focus on recent developments in CX-MS and native MS and their application to challenging problems in structural biology.

Chemical Cross-linking and Mass Spectrometry for the Structural Analysis of Protein Assemblies

Cellular functions are performed and regulated at a molecular level by the coordinated action of intricate protein assemblies, and hence the study of protein folding, structure, and interactions is vital to the appreciation and understanding of complex biological problems. In the past decade, continued development of chemical cross-linking methodologies combined with mass spectrometry has seen this approach develop to enable detailed structural information to be elucidated for protein assemblies often intractable by traditional structural biology methods. In this review article, we describe recent advances in reagent design, cross-linking protocols, mass spectrometric analysis, and incorporation of cross-linking constraints into structural models, which are contributing to overcoming the intrinsic challenges of the cross-linking method. We also highlight pioneering applications of chemical cross-linking mass spectrometry approaches to the study of structure and function of protein assemblies.

In vivo protein complex topologies: sights through a cross-linking lens

Proteins are a remarkable class of molecules that exhibit wide diversity of shapes or topological features that underpin protein interactions and give rise to biological function. In addition to quantitation of abundance levels of proteins in biological systems under a variety of conditions, the field of proteome research has as a primary mission the assignment of function for proteins and if possible, illumination of factors that enable function. For many years, chemical cross-linking methods have been used to provide structural data on single purified proteins and purified protein complexes. However, these methods also offer the alluring possibility to extend capabilities to complex biological samples such as cell lysates or intact living cells where proteins may exhibit native topological features that do not exist in purified form. Recent efforts are beginning to provide glimpses of protein complexes and topologies in cells that suggest continued development will yield novel capabilities to view functional topological features of many proteins and complexes as they exist in cells, tissues, or other complex samples. This review will describe rationale, challenges, and a few success stories along the path of development of cross-linking technologies for measurement of in vivo protein interaction topologies.

An integrated chemical cross-linking and mass spectrometry approach to study protein complex architecture and function

Knowledge of protein structures and protein-protein interactions is essential for understanding biological processes. Chemical cross-linking combined with mass spectrometry is an attractive approach for studying protein-protein interactions and protein structure, but to date its use has been limited largely by low yields of informative cross-links (because of inefficient cross-linking reactions) and by the difficulty of confidently identifying the sequences of cross-linked peptide pairs from their fragmentation spectra. Here we present an approach based on a new MS labile cross-linking reagent, BDRG (biotin-aspartate-Rink-glycine), which addresses these issues. BDRG incorporates a biotin handle (for enrichment of cross-linked peptides prior to MS analysis), two pentafluorophenyl ester groups that react with peptide amines, and a labile Rink-based bond between the pentafluorophenyl groups that allows cross-linked peptides to be separated during MS and confidently identified by database searching of their fragmentation spectra. We developed a protocol for the identification of BDRG cross-linked peptides derived from purified or partially purified protein complexes, including software to aid in the identification of different classes of cross-linker-modified peptides. Importantly, our approach permits the use of high accuracy precursor mass measurements to verify the database search results. We demonstrate the utility of the approach by applying it to purified yeast TFIIE, a heterodimeric transcription factor complex, and to a single-step affinity-purified preparation of the 12-subunit RNA polymerase II complex. The results show that the method is effective at identifying cross-linked peptides derived from purified and partially purified protein complexes and provides complementary information to that from other structural approaches. As such, it is an attractive approach to study the topology of protein complexes.

Cysteine tagging for MS-based proteomics

Amino acid-tagging strategies are widespread in proteomics. Because of the central role of mass spectrometry (MS) as a detection technique in protein sciences, the term "mass tagging" was coined to describe the attachment of a label, which serves MS analysis and/or adds analytical value to the measurements. These so-called mass tags can be used for separation, enrichment, detection, and quantitation of peptides and proteins. In this context, cysteine is a frequent target for modifications because the thiol function can react specifically by nucleophilic substitution or addition. Furthermore, cysteines present natural modifications of biological importance and a low occurrence in the proteome that justify the development of strategies to specifically target them in peptides or proteins. In the present review, the mass-tagging methods directed to cysteine residues are comprehensively discussed, and the advantages and drawbacks of these strategies are addressed. Some concrete applications are given to underline the relevance of cysteine-tagging techniques for MS-based proteomics.

IRMPD and ECD fragmentation of intermolecular cross-linked peptides

Despite the increasing number of studies using mass spectrometry for three dimensional analyses of proteins (MS3D), the identification of cross-linked peptides remains a bottleneck of the method. One of the main reasons for this is the lack of knowledge about the fragmentation of these species. Intermolecular cross-linked peptides are considered the most informative species present in MS3D experiment, since different peptides are connected by a cross-linker, the peptides chain can be either from a single protein, providing information about protein folding, or from two different proteins in a complex, providing information about binding partners, complex topology and interaction sites. These species tend to be large and highly charged in ESI, making comprehensive fragmentation by CID MS/MS problematic. On the other hand, these highly charged peptides are very suitable for dissociation using both infrared multiphoton dissociation (IRMPD) and electron capture dissociation (ECD). Herein, we report the fragmentation study of intermolecular cross-linked peptides using IRMPD and ECD. Using synthetic peptides and different commercial cross-linkers, a series of intermolecular cross-linked peptides were generate, and subsequently fragmented by IRMPD and ECD in a FT-ICR-MS instrument. Due to the high mass accuracy and resolution of the FT-ICR, the fragment ions could be attributed with high confidence. The peptides sequence coverage and fragmentation features obtained from IRMPD and ECD were compared for all charge states.

Xlink-identifier: an automated data analysis platform for confident identifications of chemically cross-linked peptides using tandem mass spectrometry

Chemical cross-linking combined with mass spectrometry provides a powerful method for identifying protein-protein interactions and probing the structure of protein complexes. A number of strategies have been reported that take advantage of the high sensitivity and high resolution of modern mass spectrometers. Approaches typically include synthesis of novel cross-linking compounds, and/or isotopic labeling of the cross-linking reagent and/or protein, and label-free methods. We report Xlink-Identifier, a comprehensive data analysis platform that has been developed to support label-free analyses. It can identify interpeptide, intrapeptide, and deadend cross-links as well as underivatized peptides. The software streamlines data preprocessing, peptide scoring, and visualization and provides an overall data analysis strategy for studying protein-protein interactions and protein structure using mass spectrometry. The software has been evaluated using a custom synthesized cross-linking reagent that features an enrichment tag. Xlink-Identifier offers the potential to perform large-scale identifications of protein-protein interactions using tandem mass spectrometry.

Shedding light on the frontier of photodissociation

The development of new ion activation/dissociation methods is motivated by the need for more versatile ways to characterize structures of ions, especially in the growing arena of biological mass spectrometry in which better tools for determining sequences, modifications, interactions, and conformations of biopolymers are essential. Although most agree that collision-induced dissociation (CID) remains the gold standard for ion activation/dissociation, recent inroads in electron- and photon-based activation methods have cemented their role as outstanding alternatives. This article will focus on the impact of photodissociation, including its strengths and drawbacks as an analytical tool, and its potential for further development in the next decade. Moreover, the discussion will emphasize photodissociation in quadrupole ion traps, because that platform has been used for one of the greatest arrays of new applications over the past decade.

Crosslinking combined with mass spectrometry for structural proteomics

The method of crosslinking combined with mass spectrometry is being gradually accepted as a technology enabling detailed structural information on proteins and protein complexes. Intrinsic challenges of the method, which have prevented its widespread use, are being progressively addressed by improvements in mass spectrometry instrumentation capabilities, by the development of new crosslinking reagents, and by the development of specialized software tools for processing of mass spectrometric crosslinking data. This review focuses on recent literature concerning the development of specialized crosslinking reagents and approaches for mass spectrometry-based applications. Critical features of crosslinking reagents for optimum mass spectrometric performance, such as isotopic coding, cleavability, affinity groups, structure of the linkers, and reactive groups, are assessed. Requirements for the design of crosslinking reagents to make them well suited for mass spectrometric detection and analysis are summarized.

The beginning of a beautiful friendship: cross-linking/mass spectrometry and modelling of proteins and multi-protein complexes

After more than a decade of method development, cross-linking in combination with mass spectrometry and bioinformatics is finally coming of age. This technology now provides improved opportunities for modelling by mapping structural details of functional complexes in solution. The structure of proteins or protein complexes is ascertained by identifying amino acid pairs that are positioned in close proximity to each other. The validity of this technique has recently been benchmarked for large multi-protein complexes, by comparing cross-link data with that from a crystal structure of RNA polymerase II. Here, the specific nature of this cross-linking data will be discussed to assess the technical challenges and opportunities for model building. We believe that once remaining technological challenges of cross-linking/mass spectrometry have been addressed and cross-linking/mass spectrometry data has been incorporated into modelling algorithms it will quickly become an indispensable companion of protein and protein complex modelling and a corner-stone of integrated structural biology.

Topographic studies of the GroEL-GroES chaperonin complex by chemical cross-linking using diformyl ethynylbenzene: the power of high resolution electron transfer dissociation for determination of both peptide sequences and their attachment sites

Many essential cellular processes depend upon the self-assembly of stable multiprotein entities. The architectures of the vast majority of these protein machines remain unknown because these structures are difficult to obtain by biophysical techniques alone. However, recent progress in defining the architecture of protein complexes has resulted from integrating information from all available biochemical and biophysical sources to generate computational models. Chemical cross-linking is a technique that holds exceptional promise toward achieving this goal by providing distance constraints that reflect the topography of protein complexes. Combined with the available structural data, these constraints can yield three-dimensional models of higher order molecular machines. However, thus far the utility of cross-linking has been thwarted by insufficient yields of cross-linked products and tandem mass spectrometry methods that are unable to unambiguously establish the identity of the covalently labeled peptides and their sites of modification. We report the cross-linking of amino moieties by 1,3-diformyl-5-ethynylbenzene (DEB) with analysis by high resolution electron transfer dissociation. This new reagent coupled with this new energy deposition technique addresses these obstacles by generating cross-linked peptides containing two additional sites of protonation relative to conventional cross-linking reagents. In addition to excellent coverage of sequence ions by electron transfer dissociation, DEB cross-linking produces gas-phase precursor ions in the 4+, 5+, or 6+ charge states that are readily segregated from unmodified and dead-end modified peptides using charge-dependent precursor selection of only quadruply and higher charge state ions. Furthermore, electron transfer induces dissociation of the DEB-peptide bonds to yield diagnostic ion signals that reveal the "molecular ions" of the unmodified peptides. We demonstrate the power of this strategy by cross-linking analysis of the 21-protein, ADP-bound GroEL-GroES chaperonin complex. Twenty-five unique sites of cross-linking were determined.

A photocleavable and mass spectrometry identifiable cross-linker for protein interaction studies

In this paper, we present the results of proof-of-concept experiments using a novel photocleavable and mass spectrometry identifiable cross-linker pcPIR (photocleavable protein interaction reporter). pcPIR can be dissociated under UV irradiation either off- or online before the introduction to the mass spectrometers. Photo dissociation of cross-linkers is different from either the gas phase or the chemical cleavage of cross-linkers. Different types of cross-links can be identified using the pcPIR mass relationships, where the mass of cross-linked precursor equals the sum of the masses of the released products and reporter. Since pcPIR is cleaved prior to the entrance to the mass spectrometer, the released peptides are available to be sequenced with routine collision-induced dissociation (CID) MS/MS experiments and database search algorithms. In this report, the pcPIR strategy of identifying the cross-linked peptides with on- and off-line photocleavage coupled with novel targeted data dependent LC-MS/MS is demonstrated with the use of standard peptides, bovine serum albumin (BSA), and human hemoglobin tetramer protein complex.

Elucidating the higher-order structure of biopolymers by structural probing and mass spectrometry: MS3D

Chemical probing represents a very versatile alternative for studying the structure and dynamics of substrates that are intractable by established high-resolution techniques. The implementation of MS-based strategies for the characterization of probing products has not only extended the range of applicability to virtually all types of biopolymers but has also paved the way for the introduction of new reagents that would not have been viable with traditional analytical platforms. As the availability of probing data is steadily increasing on the wings of the development of dedicated interpretation aids, powerful computational approaches have been explored to enable the effective utilization of such information to generate valid molecular models. This combination of factors has contributed to making the possibility of obtaining actual 3D structures by MS-based technologies (MS3D) a reality. Although approaches for achieving structure determination of unknown targets or assessing the dynamics of known structures may share similar reagents and development trajectories, they clearly involve distinctive experimental strategies, analytical concerns and interpretation paradigms. This Perspective offers a commentary on methods aimed at obtaining distance constraints for the modeling of full-fledged structures while highlighting common elements, salient distinctions and complementary capabilities exhibited by methods used in dynamics studies. We discuss critical factors to be addressed for completing effective structural determinations and expose possible pitfalls of chemical methods. We survey programs developed for facilitating the interpretation of experimental data and discuss possible computational strategies for translating sparse spatial constraints into all-atom models. Examples are provided to illustrate how the concerted application of very diverse probing techniques can lead to the solution of actual biological systems.

A new cross-linking strategy: protein interaction reporter (PIR) technology for protein-protein interaction studies

Chemical cross-linking coupled with mass spectrometry, an emerging approach for protein topology and interaction studies, has gained increasing interest in the past few years. A number of recent proof-of-principle studies on model proteins or protein complex systems with improved cross-linking strategies have shown great promise. However, the heterogeneity and low abundance of the cross-linked products as well as data complexity continue to pose enormous challenges for large-scale application of cross-linking approaches. A novel mass spectrometry-cleavable cross-linking strategy embodied in Protein Interaction Reporter (PIR) technology, first reported in 2005, was recently successfully applied for in vivo identification of protein-protein interactions as well as actual regions of the interacting proteins that share close proximity while present within cells. PIR technology holds great promise for achieving the ultimate goal of mapping protein interaction network at systems level using chemical cross-linking. In this review, we will briefly describe the recent progress in the field of chemical cross-linking development with an emphasis on the PIR concepts, its applications and future directions.

Identification of cross-linked peptides after click-based enrichment using sequential collision-induced dissociation and electron transfer dissociation tandem mass spectrometry

Chemical cross-linking combined with mass spectrometry can be a powerful approach for the identification of protein-protein interactions and for providing constraints on protein structures. However, enrichment of cross-linked peptides is crucial to reduce sample complexity before mass spectrometric analysis. In addition compact cross-linkers are often preferred to provide short spacer lengths, surface accessibility to the protein complexes, and must have reasonable solubility under conditions where the native complex structure is stable. In this study, we present a novel compact cross-linker that contains two distinct features: (1) an alkyne tag and (2) a small molecule detection tag (NO(2)) to maintain reasonable solubility in water. The alkyne tag enables enrichment of the cross-linked peptides after proteolytic cleavage and coupling of an affinity tag using alkyne-azido click chemistry. Neutral loss of the small NO(2) moiety provides a secondary means of detecting cross-linked peptides in MS/MS analyses, providing additional confidence in peptide identifications. We show the labeling efficiency of this cross-linker, which we termed CLIP (click-enabled linker for interacting proteins) using ubiquitin. The enrichment capability of CLIP is demonstrated for cross-linked ubiquitin in highly complex E. coli cell lysates. Sequential collision-induced dissociation tandem mass spectrometry (CID-MS/MS) and electron transfer dissociation (ETD)-MS/MS of intercross-linked peptides (two peptides connected with a cross-linker) are also demonstrated for improved automated identification of cross-linked peptides.

Ionic reagent for controlling the gas-phase fragmentation reactions of cross-linked peptides

Chemical cross-linking combined with proteolytic digestion and mass spectrometry (MS) is a promising approach to provide inter- and intramolecular distance constraints for the structural characterization of protein topologies and functional multiprotein complexes. Despite the relative straightforwardness of these methodologies, the identification and characterization of cross-linked proteins presents a significant analytical challenge, due to the complexity of the resultant peptide mixtures, as well as the array of inter-, intra-, or "dead-end"-cross-linked peptides that may be generated from a single cross-linking experiment. To address these issues, we describe here the synthesis, characterization, and initial evaluation of a novel "fixed charge" sulfonium ion-containing crosslinking reagent, S-methyl 5,5'-thiodipentanoylhydroxysuc-cinimide. The peptide products obtained by reaction with this reagent are all shown to fragment exclusively via facile cleavage of the C-S bond directly adjacent to the fixed charge during CID-MS/MS, resulting in the formation of characteristic product ions that enable the presence and type (i.e., inter, intra, or dead-end) of the cross-linked products to be readily determined, independently of the "proton mobility" of the precursor ion. Subsequent isolation and dissociation of these products by MS3 provides additional structural information required for identification of the peptide sequences involved in the cross-linking reactions, as well as for characterization of the specific site(s) at which cross-linking has occurred. The specificity of these gas-phase fragmentation reactions, as well as the solubility and stability of the cross-linking reagent under aqueous conditions, suggests that this strategy holds great promise for use in future studies aimed at the structural analysis of large proteins or multiprotein assemblies.

Ultraviolet photodissociation mass spectrometry of bis-aryl hydrazone conjugated peptides

Ultraviolet photodissociation (UVPD) at 355 nm was used to rapidly identify peptides which had been chemically conjugated through bis-aryl hydrazone (BAH) moieties. The two biomolecules of interest were separately tagged to introduce either an aldehyde or a hydrazine and then conjugated together through these functional groups to from the UV-chromogenic BAH-group. In a mock mixture of peptides, UVPD was used to screen for the BAH-conjugated peptides in direct infusion ESI-UVPD-MS and online LC-UVPD-MS methods by comparing the abundances of the ions with the laser off and with the laser on. Only the BAH-conjugated peptides were observed to photodissociate upon exposure to UV irradiation, thus affording excellent selectivity for the pinpointing the relevant conjugated peptides in a complex mixture of nonconjugated peptides. UVPD analysis of conjugated model peptides indicated that the UVPD efficiencies of these species were charge state dependent. BAH-conjugated peptides that had a mobile proton which could protonate the basic BAH-moiety underwent more efficient photodissociation than the peptide ions with sequestered protons. Ultraviolet photodissociation of BAH-cross-linked peptides also yielded more diagnostic sequence ions than CID to unambiguously locate the site of conjugation.

Chromogenic cross-linker for the characterization of protein structure by infrared multiphoton dissociation mass spectrometry

We have developed a new IR chromogenic cross-linker (IRCX) to aid in rapidly distinguishing cross-linked peptides from unmodified species in complex mixtures. By incorporating a phosphate functional group into the cross-linker, one can take advantage of its unique IR absorption properties, affording selective infrared multiphoton dissociation (IRMPD) of the cross-linked peptides. In a mock mixture of unmodified peptides and IRCX-cross-linked peptides (intramolecularly and intermolecularly cross-linked), only the peptides containing the IRCX modification were shown to dissociate upon exposure to 50 ms of 10.6-microm radiation. LC-IRMPD-MS proved to be an effective method to distinguish the cross-linked peptides in a tryptic digest of IRCX-cross-linked ubiquitin. A total of four intermolecular cross-links and two dead-end modifications were identified using IRCX and LC-IRMPD-MS. IRMPD of these cross-linked peptides resulted in secondary dissociation of all primary fragment ions containing the chromophore, producing a series of unmodified b- or y-type ions that allowed the cross-linked peptides to be sequenced without the need for collision-induced dissociation.

Proteomic approaches to the analysis of multiprotein signaling complexes

Signal transduction is one of the most active fields in modern biomedical research. Increasing evidence has shown that signaling proteins associate with each other in characteristic ways to form large signaling complexes. These diverse structures operate to boost signaling efficiency, ensure specificity and increase sensitivity of the biochemical circuitry. Traditional methods of protein analysis are inadequate to fully characterize and understand these structures, which are intricate, contain many components and are highly dynamic. Instead, proteomics technologies are currently being applied to investigate the nature and composition of multimeric signaling complexes. This review presents commonly used and potential proteomic methods of analyzing diverse protein complexes along with a discussion and a brief evaluation of alternative approaches. Challenges associated with proteomic analysis of signaling complexes are also discussed.

In vivo identification of the outer membrane protein OmcA-MtrC interaction network in Shewanella oneidensis MR-1 cells using novel hydrophobic chemical cross-linkers

Outer membrane (OM) cytochromes OmcA (SO1779) and MtrC (SO1778) are the integral components of electron transfer used by Shewanella oneidensis for anaerobic respiration of metal (hydr)oxides. Here the OmcA-MtrC interaction was identified in vivo using a novel hydrophobic chemical cross-linker (MRN) combined with immunoprecipitation techniques. In addition, identification of other OM proteins from the cross-linked complexes allows first visualization of the OmcA-MtrC interaction network. Further experiments on omcA and mtrC mutant cells showed OmcA plays a central role in the network interaction. For comparison, two commercial cross-linkers were also used in parallel, and both resulted in fewer OM protein identifications, indicating the superior properties of MRN for identification of membrane protein interactions. Finally, comparison experiments of in vivo cross-linking and cell lysate cross-linking resulted in significantly different protein interaction data, demonstrating the importance of in vivo cross-linking for study of protein-protein interactions in cells.

CrossSearch, a user-friendly search engine for detecting chemically cross-linked peptides in conjugated proteins

Chemical cross-linking and high resolution MS have been integrated successfully to capture protein interactions and provide low resolution structural data for proteins that are refractive to analyses by NMR or crystallography. Despite the versatility of these combined techniques, the array of products that is generated from the cross-linking and proteolytic digestion of proteins is immense and generally requires the use of labeling strategies and/or data base search algorithms to distinguish actual cross-linked peptides from the many side products of cross-linking. Most strategies reported to date have focused on the analysis of small cross-linked protein complexes (<60 kDa) because the number of potential forms of covalently modified peptides increases dramatically with the number of peptides generated from the digestion of such complexes. We report herein the development of a user-friendly search engine, CrossSearch, that provides the foundation for an overarching strategy to detect cross-linked peptides from the digests of large (>or=170-kDa) cross-linked proteins, i.e. conjugates. Our strategy combines the use of a low excess of cross-linker, data base searching, and Fourier transform ion cyclotron resonance MS to experimentally minimize and theoretically cull the side products of cross-linking. Using this strategy, the (alpha beta gamma delta)(4) phosphorylase kinase model complex was cross-linked to form with high specificity a 170-kDa betagamma conjugate in which we identified residues involved in the intramolecular cross-linking of the 125-kDa beta subunit between its regulatory N terminus and its C terminus. This finding provides an explanation for previously published homodimeric two-hybrid interactions of the beta subunit and suggests a dynamic structural role for the regulatory N terminus of that subunit. The results offer proof of concept for the CrossSearch strategy for analyzing conjugates and are the first to reveal a tertiary structural element of either homologous alpha or beta regulatory subunit of phosphorylase kinase.

Informatics strategies for large-scale novel cross-linking analysis

The detection of protein interactions in biological systems represents a significant challenge for today's technology. Chemical cross-linking provides the potential to impart new chemical bonds in a complex system that result in mass changes in a set of tryptic peptides detected by mass spectrometry. However, system complexity and cross-linking product heterogeneity have precluded widespread chemical cross-linking use for large-scale identification of protein-protein interactions. The development of mass spectrometry identifiable cross-linkers called protein interaction reporters (PIRs) has enabled on-cell chemical cross-linking experiments with product type differentiation. However, the complex datasets resultant from PIR experiments demand new informatics capabilities to allow interpretation. This manuscript details our efforts to develop such capabilities and describes the program X-links, which allows PIR product type differentiation. Furthermore, we also present the results from Monte Carlo simulation of PIR-type experiments to provide false discovery rate estimates for the PIR product type identification through observed precursor and released peptide masses. Our simulations also provide peptide identification calculations based on accurate masses and database complexity that can provide an estimation of false discovery rates for peptide identification. Overall, the calculations show a low rate of false discovery of PIR product types due to random mass matching of approximately 12% with 10 ppm mass measurement accuracy and spectral complexity resulting from 100 peptides. In addition, consideration of a reduced database resulting from stage 1 analysis of Shewanella oneidensis MR-1 containing 367 proteins resulted in a significant reduction of expected identification false discovery rate estimation compared to that from the entire Shewanella oneidensis MR-1 proteome.

An Aptly Positioned Azido Group in the Spacer of a Protein Cross-Linker for Facile Mapping of Lysines in Close Proximity

Cross-links between amino acid residues in close proximity can provide distance constraints for the validation of models of the 3D structure proteins. The mapping of cross-links by the identification of linked peptides in proteolytic digests is facilitated by cleavable cross-linkers that enable isolation of the cleavage products while preserving information about the linkage. We present an amine-specific cross-linker, bis(succinimidyl)-3-azidomethyl glutarate (BAMG), that fulfils these requirements. Two parallel reaction pathways are induced by tris(carboxyethyl)phosphine (TCEP) in cross-linked peptides from BAMG-treated cytochrome c. One pathway leads to cleavage of the cross-linked species, while in the other the azido group of BAMG is reduced to an amino group without cleavage. Cross-linked peptides and peptides modified by partially hydrolysed BAMG yield distinct sets of TCEP-induced reaction products. These can be isolated by reversed-phase diagonal chromatography and identified by mass spectrometry to reveal the identity of the parent compounds. The ease with which cross-link-derived reaction products can be isolated and identified indicates that the mapping of cross-links in complex biological assemblies and mixtures of protein complexes might become feasible in the near future.

Profiling the membrane proteome of Shewanella oneidensis MR-1 with new affinity labeling probes

The membrane proteome plays a critical role in electron transport processes in Shewanella oneidensis MR-1, a bacterial organism that has great potential for bioremediation. Biotinylation of intact cells with subsequent affinity-enrichment has become a useful tool for characterization of the membrane proteome. As opposed to these commonly used, water-soluble commercial reagents, we here introduce a family of hydrophobic, cell-permeable affinity probes for extensive labeling and detection of membrane proteins. When applied to S. oneidensis cells, all three new chemical probes allowed identification of a substantial proportion of membrane proteins from total cell lysate without the use of specific membrane isolation method. From a total of 410 unique proteins identified, approximately 42% are cell envelope proteins that include outer membrane, periplasmic, and inner membrane proteins. This report demonstrates the first application of this intact cell biotinylation method to S. oneidensis and presents the results of many identified proteins that are involved in metal reduction processes. As a general labeling method, all chemical probes we introduced in this study can be extended to other organisms or cell types and will help expedite the characterization of membrane proteomes.