Population Distributions from Native Mass Spectrometry Titrations Reveal Nearest-Neighbor Cooperativity in the Ring-Shaped Oligomeric Protein TRAP

Structural basis of nearest-neighbor cooperativity in the ring-shaped gene regulatory protein TRAP from protein engineering and cryo-EM

The homo-dodecameric ring-shaped trp RNA binding attenuation protein (TRAP) from Alkalihalobacillus halodurans (Aha) binds up to twelve tryptophan ligands (Trp) and becomes activated to bind a specific sequence in the 5' leader region of the trp operon mRNA, thereby downregulating biosynthesis of Trp. Thermodynamic measurements of Trp binding have revealed a range of cooperative behavior for different TRAP variants, even if the averaged apparent affinities for Trp have been found to be similar. Proximity between the ligand binding sites, and the ligand-coupled disorder-to-order transition has implicated nearest-neighbor interactions in cooperativity. To establish a solid basis for describing nearest-neighbor cooperativity in TRAP, we engineered variants constructed with two subunits connected by a flexible linker (dTRAP). We mutated the binding sites of alternating protomers such that only every other site was competent for Trp binding (WT-Mut dTRAP). Ligand binding monitored by NMR, calorimetry, and native mass spectrometry revealed strong cooperativity in dTRAP containing adjacent binding-competent sites, but a severe binding defect when the wild-type sites were separated by mutated sites. Cryo-EM experiments of dTRAP in its ligand-free apo state, and both dTRAP and WT-Mut dTRAP in the presence of Trp, revealed progressive stabilization of loops that gate the Trp binding site and participate in RNA binding. These studies provide important insights into the thermodynamic and structural basis for the observed ligand binding cooperativity in TRAP. Such insights can be useful for understanding allosteric control networks and for the development of those with defined ligand sensitivity and regulatory control.

Insights into Ligand-Mediated Activation of an Oligomeric Ring-Shaped Gene-Regulatory Protein from Solution- and Solid-State NMR

The 91 kDa oligomeric ring-shaped ligand binding protein TRAP (trp RNA binding attenuation protein) regulates the expression of a series of genes involved in tryptophan (Trp) biosynthesis in bacilli. When cellular Trp levels rise, the free amino acid binds to sites buried in the interfaces between each of the 11 (or 12, depending on the species) protomers in the ring. Crystal structures of Trp-bound TRAP show the Trp ligands are sequestered from solvent by a pair of loops from adjacent protomers that bury the bound ligand via polar contacts to several threonine residues. Binding of the Trp ligands occurs cooperatively, such that successive binding events occur with higher apparent affinity but the structural basis for this cooperativity is poorly understood. We used solution methyl-TROSY NMR relaxation experiments focused on threonine and isoleucine sidechains, as well as magic angle spinning solid-state NMR 13C-13C and 15N-13C chemical shift correlation spectra on uniformly labeled samples recorded at 800 and 1200 MHz, to characterize the structure and dynamics of the protein. Methyl 13C relaxation dispersion experiments on ligand-free apo TRAP revealed concerted exchange dynamics on the µs-ms time scale, consistent with transient sampling of conformations that could allow ligand binding. Cross-correlated relaxation experiments revealed widespread disorder on fast timescales. Chemical shifts for methyl-bearing side chains in apo- and Trp-bound TRAP revealed subtle changes in the distribution of sampled sidechain rotameric states. These observations reveal a pathway and mechanism for induced conformational changes to generate homotropic Trp-Trp binding cooperativity.

Cracking the Code: Enhancing Molecular Tools for Progress in Nanobiotechnology

Nature continually refines its processes for optimal efficiency, especially within biological systems. This article explores the collaborative efforts of researchers worldwide, aiming to mimic nature's efficiency by developing smarter and more effective nanoscale technologies and biomaterials. Recent advancements highlight progress and prospects in leveraging engineered nucleic acids and proteins for specific tasks, drawing inspiration from natural functions. The focus is developing improved methods for characterizing, understanding, and reprogramming these materials to perform user-defined functions, including personalized therapeutics, targeted drug delivery approaches, engineered scaffolds, and reconfigurable nanodevices. Contributions from academia, government agencies, biotech, and medical settings offer diverse perspectives, promising a comprehensive approach to broad nanobiotechnology objectives. Encompassing topics from mRNA vaccine design to programmable protein-based nanocomputing agents, this work provides insightful perspectives on the trajectory of nanobiotechnology toward a future of enhanced biomimicry and technological innovation.

Insights into Ligand-Mediated Activation of an Oligomeric Ring-Shaped Gene-Regulatory Protein from Solution- and Solid-State NMR

The 91 kDa oligomeric ring-shaped ligand binding protein TRAP (trp RNA binding attenuation protein) regulates the expression of a series of genes involved in tryptophan (Trp) biosynthesis in bacilli. When cellular Trp levels rise, the free amino acid binds to sites buried in the interfaces between each of the 11 (or 12, depending on the species) protomers in the ring. Crystal structures of Trp-bound TRAP show the Trp ligands are sequestered from solvent by a pair of loops from adjacent protomers that bury the bound ligand via polar contacts to several threonine residues. Binding of the Trp ligands occurs cooperatively, such that successive binding events occur with higher apparent affinity but the structural basis for this cooperativity is poorly understood. We used solution methyl-TROSY NMR relaxation experiments focused on threonine and isoleucine sidechains, as well as magic angle spinning solid-state NMR 13C-13C and 15N-13C chemical shift correlation spectra on uniformly labeled samples recorded at 800 and 1200 MHz, to characterize the structure and dynamics of the protein. Methyl 13C relaxation dispersion experiments on ligand-free apo TRAP revealed concerted exchange dynamics on the μs-ms time scale, consistent with transient sampling of conformations that could allow ligand binding. Cross-correlated relaxation experiments revealed widespread disorder on fast timescales. Chemical shifts for methyl-bearing side chains in apo- and Trp-bound TRAP revealed subtle changes in the distribution of sampled sidechain rotameric states. These observations reveal a pathway and mechanism for induced conformational changes to generate homotropic Trp-Trp binding cooperativity.

Structural basis of nearest-neighbor cooperativity in the ring-shaped gene regulatory protein TRAP from protein engineering and cryo-EM

Homotropic cooperativity is widespread in biological regulation. The homo-oligomeric ring-shaped trp RNA binding attenuation protein (TRAP) from bacillus binds multiple tryptophan ligands (Trp) and becomes activated to bind a specific sequence in the 5' leader region of the trp operon mRNA. Ligand-activated binding to this specific RNA sequence regulates downstream biosynthesis of Trp in a feedback loop. Characterized TRAP variants form 11- or 12-mer rings and bind Trp at the interface between adjacent subunits. Various studies have shown that a pair of loops that gate each Trp binding site is flexible in the absence of the ligand and become ordered upon ligand binding. Thermodynamic measurements of Trp binding have revealed a range of cooperative behavior for different TRAP variants, even if the averaged apparent affinities for Trp have been found to be similar. Proximity between the ligand binding sites, and the ligand-coupled disorder-to-order transition has implicated nearest-neighbor interactions in cooperativity. To establish a solid basis for describing nearest-neighbor cooperativity we engineered dodecameric (12-mer) TRAP variants constructed with two subunits connected by a flexible linker (dTRAP). We mutated one of the protomers such that only every other site was competent for Trp binding. Thermodynamic and structural studies using native mass spectrometry, NMR spectroscopy, and cryo-EM provided unprecedented detail into the thermodynamic and structural basis for the observed ligand binding cooperativity. Such insights can be useful for understanding allosteric control networks and for the development of new ones with defined ligand sensitivity and regulatory control.

Dissecting the structural heterogeneity of proteins by native mass spectrometry

A single gene yields many forms of proteins via combinations of posttranscriptional/posttranslational modifications. Proteins also fold into higher-order structures and interact with other molecules. The combined molecular diversity leads to the heterogeneity of proteins that manifests as distinct phenotypes. Structural biology has generated vast amounts of data, effectively enabling accurate structural prediction by computational methods. However, structures are often obtained heterologously under homogeneous states in vitro. The lack of native heterogeneity under cellular context creates challenges in precisely connecting the structural data to phenotypes. Mass spectrometry (MS) based proteomics methods can profile proteome composition of complex biological samples. Most MS methods follow the "bottom-up" approach, which denatures and digests proteins into short peptide fragments for ease of detection. Coupled with chemical biology approaches, higher-order structures can be probed via incorporation of covalent labels on native proteins that are maintained at the peptide level. Alternatively, native MS follows the "top-down" approach and directly analyzes intact proteins under nondenaturing conditions. Various tandem MS activation methods can dissect the intact proteins for in-depth structural elucidation. Herein, we review recent native MS applications for characterizing heterogeneous samples, including proteins binding to mixtures of ligands, homo/hetero-complexes with varying stoichiometry, intrinsically disordered proteins with dynamic conformations, glycoprotein complexes with mixed modification states, and active membrane protein complexes in near-native membrane environments. We summarize the benefits, challenges, and ongoing developments in native MS, with the hope to demonstrate an emerging technology that complements other tools by filling the knowledge gaps in understanding the molecular heterogeneity of proteins.

Allostery Frustrates the Experimentalist

Proteins interact with other proteins, with nucleic acids, lipids, carbohydrates and various small molecules in the living cell. These interactions have been quantified and structurally characterized in numerous studies such that we today have a comprehensive picture of protein structure and function. However, proteins are dynamic and even folded proteins are likely more heterogeneous than they appear in most descriptions. One property of proteins that relies on dynamics and heterogeneity is allostery, the ability of a protein to change structure and function upon ligand binding to an allosteric site. Over the last decades the concept of allostery was broadened to embrace all types of long-range interactions across a protein including purely entropic changes without a conformational change in single protein domains. But with this re-definition came a problem: How do we measure allostery? In this opinion, we discuss some caveats arising from the quantitative description of single-domain allostery from an experimental perspective and how the limitations cannot be separated from the definition of allostery per se. Furthermore, we attempt to tie together allostery with the concept of frustration in an effort to investigate the links between these two complex, and yet general, properties of proteins. We arrive at the conclusion that the sensitivity to perturbation of allosteric networks in single protein domains is too large for the networks to be of significant biological relevance.

Thermodynamic coupling between neighboring binding sites in homo-oligomeric ligand sensing proteins from mass resolved ligand-dependent population distributions

Homo-oligomeric ligand-activated proteins are ubiquitous in biology. The functions of such molecules are commonly regulated by allosteric coupling between ligand-binding sites. Understanding the basis for this regulation requires both quantifying the free energy ΔG transduced between sites, and the structural basis by which it is transduced. We consider allostery in three variants of the model ring-shaped homo-oligomeric trp RNA-binding attenuation protein (TRAP). First, we developed a nearest-neighbor statistical thermodynamic binding model comprising microscopic free energies for ligand binding to isolated sites ΔG0 , and for coupling between adjacent sites, ΔGα . Using the resulting partition function (PF) we explored the effects of these parameters on simulated population distributions for the 2N possible liganded states. We then experimentally monitored ligand-dependent population shifts using conventional spectroscopic and calorimetric methods and using native mass spectrometry (MS). By resolving species with differing numbers of bound ligands by their mass, native MS revealed striking differences in their ligand-dependent population shifts. Fitting the populations to a binding polynomial derived from the PF yielded coupling free energy terms corresponding to orders of magnitude differences in cooperativity. Uniquely, this approach predicts which of the possible 2N liganded states are populated at different ligand concentrations, providing necessary insights into regulation. The combination of statistical thermodynamic modeling with native MS may provide the thermodynamic foundation for a meaningful understanding of the structure-thermodynamic linkage that drives cooperativity.

Native Mass Spectrometry: Recent Progress and Remaining Challenges

Native mass spectrometry (nMS) has emerged as an important tool in studying the structure and function of macromolecules and their complexes in the gas phase. In this review, we cover recent advances in nMS and related techniques including sample preparation, instrumentation, activation methods, and data analysis software. These advances have enabled nMS-based techniques to address a variety of challenging questions in structural biology. The second half of this review highlights recent applications of these technologies and surveys the classes of complexes that can be studied with nMS. Complementarity of nMS to existing structural biology techniques and current challenges in nMS are also addressed.

Surface-induced dissociation of protein complexes on a cyclic ion mobility spectrometer

We describe the implementation of a simple three-electrode surface-induced dissociation (SID) cell on a cyclic ion mobility spectrometer (cIMS) and demonstrate the utility of multipass mobility separations for resolving multiple conformations of protein complexes generated during collision-induced and surface-induced unfolding (CIU & SIU) experiments. In addition to CIU and SIU, SID of protein complexes is readily accomplished within the native instrument software and with no additional external power supplies by entering a single SID collision energy, a simplification in user experience compared to prior implementations. A set of cyclic homomeric protein complexes and a heterohexamer with known CID and SID behavior were analyzed to investigate mass and mobility resolution improvements, the latter of which improved by 20-50% (median: 33%) compared to a linear travelling wave device. Multiple passes of intact complexes, or their SID fragments, increased the mobility resolution by an average of 15% per pass, with the racetrack effect being observed after ∼3 or 4 passes, depending on the drift time spread of the analytes. Even with modest improvements to apparent mobility resolving power, multipass experiments were particularly useful for separating conformations produced from CIU and SIU experiments. We illustrate several examples where either (1) multipass experiments revealed multiple overlapping conformations previously unobserved or obscured due to limited mobility resolution, or (2) CIU or SIU conformations that appeared 'native' in a single pass experiment were actually slightly compacted or expanded, with the change only being measurable through multipass experiments. The work conducted here, the first utilization of multipass cyclic ion mobility for CIU, SIU, and SID of protein assemblies and a demonstration of a wholly integrated SIU/SID workflow, paves the way for widespread adoption of SID technology for native mass spectrometry and also improves our understanding of gas-phase protein complex CIU and SIU conformationomes.

Protein-Small Molecule Interactions in Native Mass Spectrometry

Small molecule drug discovery has been propelled by the continual development of novel scientific methodologies to occasion therapeutic advances. Although established biophysical methods can be used to obtain information regarding the molecular mechanisms underlying drug action, these approaches are often inefficient, low throughput, and ineffective in the analysis of heterogeneous systems including dynamic oligomeric assemblies and proteins that have undergone extensive post-translational modification. Native mass spectrometry can be used to probe protein-small molecule interactions with unprecedented speed and sensitivity, providing unique insights into polydisperse biomolecular systems that are commonly encountered during the drug discovery process. In this review, we describe potential and proven applications of native MS in the study of interactions between small, drug-like molecules and proteins, including large multiprotein complexes and membrane proteins. Approaches to quantify the thermodynamic and kinetic properties of ligand binding are discussed, alongside a summary of gas-phase ion activation techniques that have been used to interrogate the structure of protein-small molecule complexes. We additionally highlight some of the key areas in modern drug design for which native mass spectrometry has elicited significant advances. Future developments and applications of native mass spectrometry in drug discovery workflows are identified, including potential pathways toward studying protein-small molecule interactions on a whole-proteome scale.

Surface-Induced Dissociation of Anionic vs Cationic Native-Like Protein Complexes

Characterizing protein-protein interactions, stoichiometries, and subunit connectivity is key to understanding how subunits assemble into biologically relevant, multisubunit protein complexes. Native mass spectrometry (nMS) has emerged as a powerful tool to study protein complexes due to its low sample consumption and tolerance for heterogeneity. In nMS, positive mode ionization is routinely used and charge reduction, through the addition of solution additives, is often used, as the resulting lower charge states are often considered more native-like. When fragmented by surface-induced dissociation (SID), charge reduced complexes often give increased structural information over their "normal-charged" counterparts. A disadvantage of solution phase charge reduction is that increased adduction, and hence peak broadening, is often observed. Previous studies have shown that protein complexes ionized using negative mode generally form lower charge states relative to positive mode. Here we demonstrate that the lower charged protein complex anions activated by surface collisions fragment in a manner consistent with their solved structures, hence providing substructural information. Negative mode ionization in ammonium acetate offers the advantage of charge reduction without the peak broadening associated with solution phase charge reduction additives and provides direct structural information when coupled with SID. SID of 20S human proteasome (a 28-mer comprised of four stacked heptamer rings in an αββα formation), for example, provides information on both substructure (e.g., splitting into a 7α ring and the corresponding ββα 21-mer, and into α dimers and trimers to provide connectivity around the 7 α ring) and proteoform information on monomers.