Discovery of Inactive Conformation-Selective Kinase Inhibitors by Utilizing Cascade Assays

Molecular basis for differential recognition of an allosteric inhibitor by receptor tyrosine kinases

Understanding kinase-inhibitor selectivity continues to be a major objective in kinase drug discovery. We probe the molecular basis of selectivity of an allosteric inhibitor (MSC1609119A-1) of the insulin-like growth factor-I receptor kinase (IGF1RK), which has been shown to be ineffective for the homologous insulin receptor kinase (IRK). Specifically, we investigated the structural and energetic basis of the allosteric binding of this inhibitor to each kinase by combining molecular modeling, molecular dynamics (MD) simulations, and thermodynamic calculations. We predict the inhibitor conformation in the binding pocket of IRK and highlight that the charged residues in the histidine-arginine-aspartic acid (HRD) and aspartic acid-phenylalanine-glycine (DFG) motifs and the nonpolar residues in the binding pocket govern inhibitor interactions in the allosteric pocket of each kinase. We suggest that the conformational changes in the IGF1RK residues M1054 and M1079, movement of the ⍺C-helix, and the conformational stabilization of the DFG motif favor the selectivity of the inhibitor toward IGF1RK. Our thermodynamic calculations reveal that the observed selectivity can be rationalized through differences observed in the electrostatic interaction energy of the inhibitor in each inhibitor/kinase complex and the hydrogen bonding interactions of the inhibitor with the residue V1063 in IGF1RK that are not attained with the corresponding residue V1060 in IRK. Overall, our study provides a rationale for the molecular basis of recognition of this allosteric inhibitor by IGF1RK and IRK, which is potentially useful in developing novel inhibitors with improved affinity and selectivity.

Chemoproteomics Identifies State-Dependent and Proteoform-Selective Caspase-2 Inhibitors

Caspases are a highly conserved family of cysteine-aspartyl proteases known for their essential roles in regulating apoptosis, inflammation, cell differentiation, and proliferation. Complementary to genetic approaches, small-molecule probes have emerged as useful tools for modulating caspase activity. However, due to the high sequence and structure homology of all 12 human caspases, achieving selectivity remains a central challenge for caspase-directed small-molecule inhibitor development efforts. Here, using mass spectrometry-based chemoproteomics, we first identify a highly reactive noncatalytic cysteine that is unique to caspase-2. By combining both gel-based activity-based protein profiling (ABPP) and a tobacco etch virus (TEV) protease activation assay, we then identify covalent lead compounds that react preferentially with this cysteine and afford a complete blockade of caspase-2 activity. Inhibitory activity is restricted to the zymogen or precursor form of monomeric caspase-2. Focused analogue synthesis combined with chemoproteomic target engagement analysis in cellular lysates and in cells yielded both pan-caspase-reactive molecules and caspase-2 selective lead compounds together with a structurally matched inactive control. Application of this focused set of tool compounds to stratify the functions of the zymogen and partially processed (p32) forms of caspase-2 provide evidence to support that caspase-2-mediated response to DNA damage is largely driven by the partially processed p32 form of the enzyme. More broadly, our study highlights future opportunities for the development of proteoform-selective caspase inhibitors that target nonconserved and noncatalytic cysteine residues.

Chemoproteomics identifies proteoform-selective caspase-2 inhibitors

Caspases are a highly conserved family of cysteine-aspartyl proteases known for their essential roles in regulating apoptosis, inflammation, cell differentiation, and proliferation. Complementary to genetic approaches, small-molecule probes have emerged as useful tools for modulating caspase activity. However, due to the high sequence and structure homology of all twelve human caspases, achieving selectivity remains a central challenge for caspase-directed small-molecule inhibitor development efforts. Here, using mass spectrometry-based chemoproteomics, we first identify a highly reactive non-catalytic cysteine that is unique to caspase-2. By combining both gel-based activity-based protein profiling (ABPP) and a tobacco etch virus (TEV) protease activation assay, we then identify covalent lead compounds that react preferentially with this cysteine and afford a complete blockade of caspase-2 activity. Inhibitory activity is restricted to the zymogen or precursor form of monomeric caspase-2. Focused analogue synthesis combined with chemoproteomic target engagement analysis in cellular lysates and in cells yielded both pan-caspase reactive molecules and caspase-2 selective lead compounds together with a structurally matched inactive control. Application of this focused set of tool compounds to stratify caspase contributions to initiation of intrinsic apoptosis, supports compensatory caspase-9 activity in the context of caspase-2 inactivation. More broadly, our study highlights future opportunities for the development of proteoform-selective caspase inhibitors that target non-conserved and non-catalytic cysteine residues.

Discovery of an Allosteric, Inactive Conformation-Selective Inhibitor of Full-Length HPK1 Utilizing a Kinase Cascade Assay

Achieving selectivity across the human kinome is a major hurdle in kinase inhibitor drug discovery. Assays using active, phosphorylated protein kinases bias hits toward poorly selective inhibitors that bind within the highly conserved adenosine triphosphate (ATP) pocket. Targeting inactive (vs active) kinase conformations offers advantages in achieving selectivity because of their more diversified structures. Kinase cascade assays are typically initiated with target kinases in their unphosphorylated inactive forms, which are activated during the assays. Therefore, these assays are capable of identifying inhibitors that preferentially bind to the unphosphorylated form of the enzyme in addition to those that bind to the active form. We applied this cascade assay to the emerging cancer immunotherapy target hematopoietic progenitor kinase 1 (HPK1), a serine/threonine kinase that negatively regulates T cell receptor signaling. Using this approach, we discovered an allosteric, inactive conformation-selective triazolopyrimidinone HPK1 inhibitor, compound 1. Compound 1 binds to unphosphorylated HPK1 >24-fold more potently than active HPK1, is not competitive with ATP, and is highly selective against kinases critical for T cell signaling. Furthermore, compound 1 does not bind to the isolated HPK1 kinase domain alone but requires other domains. Together, these data indicate that 1 is an allosteric HPK1 inhibitor that attenuates kinase autophosphorylation by binding to a pocket consisting of residues within and outside of the kinase domain. Our study demonstrates that cascade assays can lead to the discovery of highly selective kinase inhibitors. The triazolopyrimidinone described in this study may represent a privileged chemical scaffold for further development of potent and selective HPK1 inhibitors.

Identification of a New Inhibitor That Stabilizes Interleukin-2-Inducible T-Cell Kinase in Its Inactive Conformation

Interleukin-2-inducible T-cell kinase (ITK) plays an important role in T-cell signaling and is considered a promising drug target. As the ATP binding sites of protein kinases are highly conserved, the design of selective kinase inhibitors remains a challenge. Targeting inactive kinase conformations can address the issue of kinase inhibitor selectivity. It is important for selectivity considerations to identify compounds that stabilize inactive conformations from the primary screen hits. Here we screened a library of 390,000 compounds with an ADP-Glo assay using dephosphorylated ITK. After a surface plasmon resonance (SPR) assay was used to filter out promiscuous inhibitors, 105 hits were confirmed. Next, we used a fluorescent biosensor to enable the detection of conformational changes to identify inactive conformation inhibitors. A single-cysteine-substituted ITK mutant was labeled with acrylodan, and fluorescence emission was monitored. Using a fluorescent biosensor assay, we identified 34 inactive conformation inhibitors from SPR hits. Among them, one compound was bound to a site other than the ATP pocket and exhibited excellent selectivity against a kinase panel. Overall, (1) biochemical screening using dephosphorylated kinase, (2) hit confirmation by SPR assay, and (3) fluorescent biosensor assay that can distinguish inactive compounds provide a useful platform and offer opportunities to identify selective kinase inhibitors.

Deciphering the Allosteric Binding Mechanism of the Human Tropomyosin Receptor Kinase A ( hTrkA) Inhibitors

Access to cryptic binding pockets or allosteric sites on a kinase that present themselves when the enzyme is in a specific conformational state offers a paradigm shift in designing the next generation small molecule kinase inhibitors. The current work showcases an extensive and exhaustive array of in vitro biochemical and biophysical tools and techniques deployed along with structural biology efforts of inhibitor-bound kinase complexes to characterize and confirm the cryptic allosteric binding pocket and docking mode of the small molecule actives identified for hTrkA. Specifically, assays were designed and implemented to lock the kinase in a predominantly active or inactive conformation and the effect of the kinase inhibitor probed to understand the hTrkA binding and hTrkB selectivity. The current outcome suggests that inhibitors with a fast association rate take advantage of the inactive protein conformation and lock the kinase state by also exhibiting a slow off-rate. This in turn shifts the inactive/active state protein conformational equilibrium cycle, affecting the subsequent downstream signaling.

Opportunities and challenges for the development of covalent chemical immunomodulators

Compounds that react irreversibly with cysteines have reemerged as potent and selective tools for altering protein function, serving as chemical probes and even clinically approved drugs. The exquisite sensitivity of human immune cell signaling pathways to oxidative stress indicates the likely, yet still underexploited, general utility of covalent probes for selective chemical immunomodulation. Here, we provide an overview of immunomodulatory cysteines, including identification of electrophilic compounds available to label these residues. We focus our discussion on three protein classes essential for cell signaling, which span the 'druggability' spectrum from amenable to chemical probes (kinases), somewhat druggable (proteases), to inaccessible (phosphatases). Using existing inhibitors as a guide, we identify general strategies to guide the development of covalent probes for selected undruggable classes of proteins and propose the application of such compounds to alter immune cell functions.