Using Spectroscopy to Guide the Adaptation of Aptamers into Electrochemical Aptamer-Based Sensors

Direct detection of doxorubicin in whole blood using a hydrogel-protected electrochemical aptamer-based biosensor

Electrochemical aptamer-based biosensors (EABs) have been developed for multiple important biomarkers for their convenient and real-time features. However, the application of EABs in complex biological fluids has been limited by the rapid loss of sensitivity and selectivity due to inactivation and biofouling of aptamer probes and electrodes. To address this issue, we report the preparation of a simple hydrogel-protected aptamer-based biosensor (HP-EAB) for direct detection of Doxorubicin (DOX) in whole blood. The aptamer provides excellent selectivity for the electrochemical sensor, allowing the prepared sensor to accurately detect DOX in a 50-fold diluted whole blood sample. The agarose hydrogel coating on the electrode surface allows the passage of small molecules while hindering the adsorption of biomolecules from the whole blood matrix to the electrode surface. The experimental results show that the prepared HP-EAB has high stability compared with the unprotected EAB, and the HP-EAB maintains excellent detection performance after 7 days of storage. The hydrogel coating can effectively reduce the non-specific response to the whole blood matrix and prolong the life-time of the sensor. When used to detect DOX in rabbit whole blood, the HP-EAB exhibited excellent detection performance with a detection limit of 25.9 nM (S/N = 3) and a detection range of 0.1 μM-50 μM. The developed HP-EAB provides an excellent platform for the rapid and accurate determination of important analytes in complex biological fluids.

Carboxylate-Terminated Electrode Surfaces Improve the Performance of Electrochemical Aptamer-Based Sensors

Electrochemical aptamer-based (EAB) sensors are a molecular measurement platform that enables the continuous, real-time measurement of a wide range of drugs and biomarkers in situ in the living body. EAB sensors are fabricated by depositing a thiol-modified, target-binding aptamer on the surface of a gold electrode, followed by backfilling with an alkanethiol to form a self-assembled monolayer. And while the majority of previously described EAB sensors have employed hydroxyl-terminated monolayers, a handful of studies have shown that altering the monolayer headgroup can strongly affect sensor performance. Here, using 4 different EAB sensors, we show that the mixed monolayers composed of mixtures of 6-carbon hydroxyl-terminated thiols and varying amounts of either 6- or 8-carbon, carboxylate-terminated thiols lead to improved EAB sensor performance. Specifically, the use of such mixed monolayers enhances the signal gain (the relative change in the signal seen upon target addition) for all tested sensors, often by several fold, both in buffer and whole blood at room temperature or physiological temperatures. Moreover, these improvements in gain are achieved without significant changes in the aptamer affinity or the stability of the resulting sensors. In addition to proving a ready means of improving EAB sensor performance, these results suggest that exploration of the chemistry of the electrode surface employed in such sensors could prove to be a fruitful means of advancing this unique in vivo sensing technology.

Modular DNA origami-based electrochemical detection of DNA and proteins

The diversity and heterogeneity of biomarkers has made the development of general methods for single-step quantification of analytes difficult. For individual biomarkers, electrochemical methods that detect a conformational change in an affinity binder upon analyte binding have shown promise. However, because the conformational change must operate within a nanometer-scale working distance, an entirely new sensor, with a unique conformational change, must be developed for each analyte. Here, we demonstrate a modular electrochemical biosensor, built from DNA origami, which is easily adapted to diverse molecules by merely replacing its analyte binding domains. Instead of relying on a unique nanometer-scale movement of a single redox reporter, all sensor variants rely on the same 100-nm scale conformational change, which brings dozens of reporters close enough to a gold electrode surface that a signal can be measured via square-wave voltammetry, a standard electrochemical technique. To validate our sensor's mechanism, we used single-stranded DNA as an analyte, and optimized the number of redox reporters and various linker lengths. Adaptation of the sensor to streptavidin and Platelet-Derived Growth Factor-BB (PDGF-BB) analytes was achieved by simply adding biotin or anti-PDGF aptamers to appropriate DNA linkers. Geometrically optimized streptavidin sensors exhibited signal gain and limit of detection markedly better than comparable reagentless electrochemical sensors. After use, the same sensors could be regenerated under mild conditions: Performance was largely maintained over four cycles of DNA strand displacement and rehybridization. By leveraging the modularity of DNA nanostructures, our work provides a straightforward route to the single-step quantification of arbitrary nucleic acids and proteins.

Effects of Physiological-Scale Variation in Cations, pH, and Temperature on the Calibration of Electrochemical Aptamer-Based Sensors

Electrochemical aptamer-based (EAB) sensors are the first technology supporting high-frequency, real-time, in vivo molecular measurements that is independent of the chemical reactivity of its targets, rendering it easily generalizable. As is true for all biosensors, however, EAB sensor performance is affected by the measurement environment, potentially reducing accuracy when this environment deviates from the conditions under which the sensor was calibrated. Here, we address this question by measuring the extent to which physiological-scale environmental fluctuations reduce the accuracy of a representative set of EAB sensors and explore the means of correcting these effects. To do so, we first calibrated sensors against vancomycin, phenylalanine, and tryptophan under conditions that match the average ionic strength, cation composition, pH, and temperature of healthy human plasma. We then assessed their accuracy in samples for which the ionic composition, pH, and temperature were at the lower and upper ends of their physiological ranges. Doing so, we find that physiologically relevant fluctuations in ionic strength, cation composition, and pH do not significantly harm EAB sensor accuracy. Specifically, all 3 of our test-bed sensors achieve clinically significant mean relative accuracy (i.e., better than 20%) over the clinically or physiologically relevant concentration ranges of their target molecules. In contrast, physiologically plausible variations away from the temperature used for calibration induce more substantial errors. With knowledge of the temperature in hand, however, these errors are easily ameliorated. It thus appears that physiologically induced changes in the sensing environment are likely not a major impediment to clinical application of this in vivo molecular monitoring technology.

"Binding" or "Binding and Switching"? A Perspective on Resolving Conformational Changes of Surface-Attached Biomolecular Receptors

Understanding the structural reconfiguration of a biomolecular receptor remains a topic of particular interest to the biosensing community. This is because conformationally changing receptors are commonly employed in biosensors to harness their capability to bind specifically to their target. Often, such receptors are attached to surfaces so that binding can be transduced into a measurable response. Doing so, however, can impose constraints on the possible configurations they can adopt. Such constraints can ultimately influence, for example, their receptor-target binding models or their affinity, which is essential to provide the desired analytical performances in biosensors. Motivated by the idea of gaining further insights into the impact of surface attachment on conformationally switching receptors attached to surfaces, we explore here the various surface-based techniques capable of monitoring structural changes. We decided to narrow our survey to techniques that have been applied to the investigation of nucleic acids to provide an overview of their key features. We envision that this will bring a broader perspective of the field and the challenges ahead with the hopes of "finding the switch" in surface-attached biomolecular receptors.

In Silico Analysis of Binding Sites for a Novel ssDNA Aptamer Specific to Verrucarin A and Detection in Dust Extracts

An aptamer is a single-stranded oligonucleotide that serves as a chemical antibody with a high specificity and binding affinity that can recognize a wide range of molecules. Effective modification and truncation of aptamers can enhance their binding affinities to particular targets while also broadening their application for uses, such as biosensors. However, a conventional trial-and-error methodology hinders this process. Herein, we demonstrate an in silico method to elucidate the binding site of single-stranded DNA aptamer specific to verrucarin A, a mycotoxin produced by molds in indoor buildings that causes adverse effects in living organisms. The novel ssDNA aptamer exhibited a binding affinity of 29.5 nM, demonstrating a relatively strong affinity compared to those of previously reported typical aptamers for small molecules. Furthermore, the selected aptamer was highly specific toward verrucarin A among structurally related mycotoxins (i.e., verrucarol and zearalenone). The specific binding site of the aptamer predicted via molecular dynamics and molecular docking simulations was highly consistent with the results observed via truncation, single base mutation, and circular dichroism experiments. The fluorescence assay revealed limits of detection and quantification of 4.1 and 12 nM for the aptamer, respectively. Comparing our developed aptasensor with LC-MS/MS methodology revealed that it could detect verrucarin A levels in phosphate-buffered saline and dust extracts with robust precision and consistency. Our findings provide insight for future studies exploring interaction mechanisms with intended targets and practical sensing applications, such as point-of-care detection of verrucarin A.

Developing Microelectrode Arrays for the Point-of-Care Multiplex Detection of Metabolites

DNA-aptamer-functionalized electrode arrays can provide an intriguing method for detecting pathogen-derived exometabolites. This work addresses the limitations of previous aptamer-based pathogen detection methods by introducing a novel surface design that bridges the gap between initial efforts in this area and the demands of a point-of-care device. Specifically, the use of a diblock copolymer coating on a high-density microelectrode array and Cu-mediated cross coupling reactions that allow for the exclusive functionalization of that coating by any electrode or set of electrodes in the array provides a device that is stable for 1 year and compatible with the multiplex detection of small-molecule targets. The new chemistry developed allows one to take advantage of a large number of electrodes in the array with one experiment described herein capitalizing on the use of 960 individually addressable electrodes.

Dual-Purpose Aptamer-Based Sensors for Real-Time, Multiplexable Monitoring of Metabolites in Cell Culture Media

The availability of high-frequency, real-time measurements of the concentrations of specific metabolites in cell culture systems will enable a deeper understanding of cellular metabolism and facilitate the application of good laboratory practice standards in cell culture protocols. However, currently available approaches to this end either are constrained to single-time-point and single-parameter measurements or are limited in the range of detectable analytes. Electrochemical aptamer-based (EAB) biosensors have demonstrated utility in real-time monitoring of analytes in vivo in blood and tissues. Here, we characterize a pH-sensing capability of EAB sensors that is independent of the specific target analyte of the aptamer sequence. We applied this dual-purpose EAB to the continuous measurement of pH and phenylalanine in several in vitro cell culture settings. The miniature EAB sensor that we developed exhibits rapid response times, good stability, high repeatability, and biologically relevant sensitivity. We also developed and characterized a leak-free reference electrode that mitigates the potential cytotoxic effects of silver ions released from conventional reference electrodes. Using the resulting dual-purpose sensor, we performed hourly measurements of pH and phenylalanine concentrations in the medium superfusing cultured epithelial tumor cell lines (A549, MDA-MB-23) and a human fibroblast cell line (MRC-5) for periods of up to 72 h. Our scalable technology may be multiplexed for high-throughput monitoring of pH and multiple analytes in support of the broad metabolic qualification of microphysiological systems.

Codeposition Enhances the Performance of Electrochemical Aptamer-Based Sensors

Electrochemical aptamer-based (EAB) sensors, a minimally invasive means of performing high-frequency, real-time measurement of drugs and biomarkers in situ in the body, have traditionally been fabricated by depositing their target-recognizing aptamer onto an interrogating gold electrode using a "sequential" two-step method involving deposition of the thiol-modified oligonucleotide (typically for 1 h) followed by incubation in mercaptohexanol solution (typically overnight) to complete the formation of a stable, self-assembled monolayer. Here we use EAB sensors targeting vancomycin, tryptophan, and phenylalanine to show that "codeposition", a less commonly employed EAB fabrication method in which the thiol-modified aptamer and the mercaptohexanol diluent are deposited on the electrode simultaneously and for as little as 1 h, improves the signal gain (relative change in signal upon the addition of high concentrations of the target) of the vancomycin and tryptophan sensors without significantly reducing their stability. In contrast, the gain of the phenylalanine sensor is effectively identical irrespective of the fabrication approach employed. This sensor, however, appears to employ binding-induced displacement of the redox reporter rather than binding-induced folding as its signal transduction mechanism, suggesting in turn a mechanism for the improvement observed for the other two sensors. Codeposition thus not only provides a more convenient means of fabricating EAB sensors but also can improve their performance.

Electrochemical and Electrical Biosensors for Wearable and Implantable Electronics Based on Conducting Polymers and Carbon-Based Materials

Bioelectronic devices are designed to translate biological information into electrical signals and vice versa, thereby bridging the gap between the living biological world and electronic systems. Among different types of bioelectronics devices, wearable and implantable biosensors are particularly important as they offer access to the physiological and biochemical activities of tissues and organs, which is significant in diagnosing and researching various medical conditions. Organic conducting and semiconducting materials, including conducting polymers (CPs) and graphene and carbon nanotubes (CNTs), are some of the most promising candidates for wearable and implantable biosensors. Their unique electrical, electrochemical, and mechanical properties bring new possibilities to bioelectronics that could not be realized by utilizing metals- or silicon-based analogues. The use of organic- and carbon-based conductors in the development of wearable and implantable biosensors has emerged as a rapidly growing research field, with remarkable progress being made in recent years. The use of such materials addresses the issue of mismatched properties between biological tissues and electronic devices, as well as the improvement in the accuracy and fidelity of the transferred information. In this review, we highlight the most recent advances in this field and provide insights into organic and carbon-based (semi)conducting materials' properties and relate these to their applications in wearable/implantable biosensors. We also provide a perspective on the promising potential and exciting future developments of wearable/implantable biosensors.

Rationally Designed DNA-Based Scaffolds and Switching Probes for Protein Sensing

The detection of a protein analyte and use of this type of information for disease diagnosis and physiological monitoring requires methods with high sensitivity and specificity that have to be also easy to use, rapid and, ideally, single step. In the last 10 years, a number of DNA-based sensing methods and sensors have been developed in order to achieve quantitative readout of protein biomarkers. Inspired by the speed, specificity, and versatility of naturally occurring chemosensors based on structure-switching biomolecules, significant efforts have been done to reproduce these mechanisms into the fabrication of artificial biosensors for protein detection. As an alternative, in scaffold DNA biosensors, different recognition elements (e.g., peptides, proteins, small molecules, and antibodies) can be conjugated to the DNA scaffold with high accuracy and precision in order to specifically interact with the target protein with high affinity and specificity. They have several advantages and potential, especially because the transduction signal can be drastically enhanced. Our aim here is to provide an overview of the best examples of structure switching-based and scaffold DNA sensors, as well as to introduce the reader to the rational design of innovative sensing mechanisms and strategies based on programmable functional DNA systems for protein detection.

Electrochemical Aptamer-Based Biosensors for Measurements in Undiluted Human Saliva

Although blood remains a gold standard diagnostic fluid for most health exams, it involves an unpleasant and relatively invasive sampling procedure (finger pricking or venous draw). Saliva contains many relevant and useful biomarkers for diagnostic purposes, and its collection, in contrast, is noninvasive and can be obtained with minimal effort. Current saliva analyses are, however, achieved using chromatography or lateral flow assays, which, despite their high accuracy and sensitivity, can demand expensive laboratory-based instruments operated by trained personnel or offer only semiquantitative results. In response, we investigated electrochemical aptamer-based (E-AB) biosensors, a reagentless sensing platform, to allow for continuous and real-time measurements directly in undiluted, unstimulated human whole saliva. As a proof-of-concept study, we developed E-AB biosensors capable of detecting low-molecular-weight analytes (glucose and adenosine monophosphate (AMP)). To our knowledge, we report the first E-AB sensor for glucose, an approach that is inherently independent of its chemical reactivity in contrast to home glucometers. For these three sensors, we evaluated their figures of merits, stability, and reusability over short- and long-term exposure directly in saliva. In doing so, we found that E-AB sensors allow rapid and convenient molecular measurements in whole saliva with unprecedented sensitivities in the pico- to nanomolar regime and could be regenerated and reused up to 7 days when washed and stored in phosphate-buffered saline at room temperature. We envision that salivary molecular measurements using E-AB sensors are a promising alternative to invasive techniques and can be used for improved point-of-care clinical diagnosis and at-home measurements.

Raman Scattering Reveals Ion-Dependent G-Quadruplex Formation in the 15-mer Thrombin-Binding Aptamer upon Association with α-Thrombin

The discovery of DNA aptamers that bind biomolecular targets has enabled significant innovations in biosensing. Aptamers form secondary structures that exhibit selective high-affinity interactions with their binding partners. The binding of its target by an aptamer is often accompanied by conformational changes, and sensing by aptamers often relies on these changes to provide readout signals from extrinsic labels to detect target association. Many biosensing applications involve aptamers immobilized to surfaces, but methods to characterize conformations of immobilized aptamers and their in situ response have been lacking. To address this challenge, we have developed a structurally informative Raman spectroscopy method to determine conformations of the 15-mer thrombin-binding aptamer (TBA) immobilized on porous silica surfaces. The TBA is of interest because its binding of α-thrombin depends on the aptamer forming an antiparallel G-quadruplex, which is thought to drive signal changes that allow thrombin-binding to be detected. However, specific metal cations also stabilize the G-quadruplex conformation of the aptamer, even in the absence of its protein target. To develop a deeper understanding of the conformational response of the TBA, we utilize Raman spectroscopy to quantify the effects of the metal cations, K+ (stabilizing) and Li+ (nonstabilizing), on G-quadruplex versus unfolded populations of the TBA. In K+ or Li+ solutions, we then detect the association of α-thrombin with the immobilized aptamer, which can be observed in Raman scattering from the bound protein. The results show that the association of α-thrombin in K+ solutions produces no detectable change in aptamer conformation, which is found in the G-quadruplex form both before and after binding its target. In Li+ solutions, however, where the TBA is unfolded prior to α-thrombin association, protein binding occurs with the formation of a G-quadruplex by the aptamer.

Real-Time, Seconds-Resolved Measurements of Plasma Methotrexate In Situ in the Living Body

Dose-limiting toxicity and significant patient-to-patient pharmacokinetic variability often render it difficult to achieve the safe and effective dosing of drugs. This is further compounded by the slow, cumbersome nature of the analytical methods used to monitor patient-specific pharmacokinetics, which inevitably rely on blood draws followed by post-facto laboratory analysis. Motivated by the pressing need for improved "therapeutic drug monitoring", we are developing electrochemical aptamer-based (EAB) sensors, a minimally invasive biosensor architecture that can provide real-time, seconds-resolved measurements of drug levels in situ in the living body. A key advantage of EAB sensors is that they are generalizable to the detection of a wide range of therapeutic agents because they are independent of the chemical or enzymatic reactivity of their targets. Three of the four therapeutic drug classes that have, to date, been shown measurable using in vivo EAB sensors, however, bind to nucleic acids as part of their mode of action, leaving open questions regarding the extent to which the approach can be generalized to therapeutics that do not. Here, we demonstrate real-time, in vivo measurements of plasma methotrexate, an antimetabolite (a mode of action not reliant on DNA binding) chemotherapeutic, following human-relevant dosing in a live rat animal model. By providing hundreds of drug concentration values, the resulting seconds-resolved measurements succeed in defining key pharmacokinetic parameters, including the drug's elimination rate, peak plasma concentration, and exposure (area under the curve), with unprecedented 5 to 10% precision. With this level of precision, we easily identify significant (>2-fold) differences in drug exposure occurring between even healthy rats given the same mass-adjusted methotrexate dose. By providing a real-time, seconds-resolved window into methotrexate pharmacokinetics, such measurements can be used to precisely "individualize" the dosing of this significantly toxic yet vitally important chemotherapeutic.

Real-Time, In Vivo Molecular Monitoring Using Electrochemical Aptamer Based Sensors: Opportunities and Challenges

The continuous, real-time measurement of specific molecules in situ in the body would greatly improve our ability to understand, diagnose, and treat disease. The vast majority of continuous molecular sensing technologies, however, either (1) rely on the chemical or enzymatic reactivity of their targets, sharply limiting their scope, or (2) have never been shown (and likely will never be shown) to operate in the complex environments found in vivo. Against this background, here we review electrochemical aptamer-based (EAB) sensors, an electrochemical approach to real-time molecular monitoring that has now seen 15 years of academic development. The strengths of the EAB platform are significant: to date it is the only molecular measurement technology that (1) functions independently of the chemical reactivity of its targets, and is thus general, and (2) supports in vivo measurements. Specifically, using EAB sensors we, and others, have already reported the real-time, seconds-resolved measurements of multiple, unrelated drugs and metabolites in situ in the veins and tissues of live animals. Against these strengths, we detail the platform's remaining weaknesses, which include still limited measurement duration (hours, rather than the more desirable days) and the difficulty in obtaining sufficiently high performance aptamers against new targets, before then detailing promising approaches overcoming these hurdles. Finally, we close by exploring the opportunities we believe this potentially revolutionary technology (as well as a few, possibly competing, technologies) will create for both researchers and clinicians.