Mixotrophic Cultivation of Microalgae Using Biogas as the Substrate

Carbon distribution and metabolism mechanism of a novel mixotrophic Chlorella in municipal wastewater

Conventional wastewater treatment technologies primarily convert complex organic matter into dissolved inorganic carbon (DIC) and a more difficult gaseous state CO2. Most microalgae species can photosynthetically assimilate above inorganic carbon, but their heterotrophic metabolic processes often dominate in glucose-mediated mixotrophy. Herein, we investigated the carbon-fixing metabolic pathways of Chlorella sp. MIHQ61 in municipal wastewater containing complex carbon sources. The total carbon removal (73.0 %) peaked on the 6th day, and DIC removal exceeded 50.0 % as the carbon migrating amount from municipal wastewater into the microalgal cells peaked. The glucose and NaHCO3 combination promoted both autotrophic and heterotrophic metabolism. Headspace CO2 emission, enzyme activity and central carbon metabolism results implied heterotrophic metabolism occurred more actively in the early stage and autotrophic metabolism dominated late stage. Redefined mixotrophic carbon allocation by revealing time-dependent autotrophic/heterotrophic interplay. Carbon distribution and mixotrophic mechanism provided new thinking on how to utilize microalgae and wastewater resource.

A metabolic enzyme-photosynthetic machinery involved in the co-metabolism of enrofloxacin and ciprofloxacin by Chlorella pyrenoidosa

The removal of fluoroquinolone antibiotics from wastewater continues to pose significant challenges, as conventional treatment methods often prove ineffective against these persistent pollutants. However, microalgal-mediated treatment has emerged as a promising alternative, leveraging its unique potential to degrade recalcitrant contaminants. This study investigates the removal of enrofloxacin (EFX) and ciprofloxacin (CFX) by Chlorella pyrenoidosa, integrating transcriptomics, gene network analysis, and co-metabolic pathways to unravel the mechanisms driving pollutant degradation. Among the four co-metabolic substrates evaluated, glucose and glycine were identified as the most effective in enhancing the degradation of EFX and CFX, respectively. Glycine primarily upregulated genes associated with nitrogen metabolism, while glucose stimulated both photosynthesis and nitrogen metabolism pathways. This synergistic co-metabolic interaction promoted the development of an integrated metabolic enzyme-photosynthetic machinery, which enhanced electron transport, energy generation, catalytic enzyme expression, and extracellular polymeric substance (EPS) production, ultimately leading to a significant increase in the degradation rates of EFX and CFX. Mass balance analysis revealed that biotransformation processes, including defluorination, decarboxylation, hydroxylation, and other transformations, were the predominant mechanism for pollutant removal. Fluorine was detected within microalgal cells using transmission electron microscopy coupled with energy dispersive X-ray spectroscopy (TEM-EDS). A total of eight transformation products (TPs) were identified, and their non-toxic effects on three tested organisms suggest environmentally benign outcomes. These findings provide valuable insights into the mechanisms underlying microalgae-mediated degradation of fluoroquinolone antibiotics and highlight the potential of microalgae-based technologies a sustainable solution for mitigating antibiotic pollution in wastewater.

Ectoine production through a marine methanotroph-microalgae culture allows complete biogas valorization

Methanotrophs have recently emerged as a promising platform for producing bio-based chemicals, like ectoine, from biogas, offering an economical alternative to glucose. However, most studies have focused solely on CH4 consumption, often overlooking the CO2, which is both produced by methanotrophs and present in biogas, despite its potential as a carbon source for microorganisms, such as microalgae. In this study, marine methanotrophic-microalgal cultures were enriched from environmental samples collected at the North Sea coast to explore ectoine production from both CH4 and CO2 in biogas. The sediment-derived culture exhibited the highest CH4 removal efficiency and CO2 uptake, and was selected for further experiments. The culture was primarily composed of Methylobacter marinus, Methylophaga marina, and the microalga Picochlorum oklahomensis. Gas consumption, growth, and ectoine production were evaluated under varying salinity levels and osmotic stress. The NaCl concentrations above 6% negatively impacted CH4 oxidation and inhibited ectoine synthesis, while osmotic shocks enhanced ectoine accumulation, with a maximum ectoine content of 51.3 mgectoine gVSS-1 at 4.5% NaCl. This study is the first to report ectoine production from methanotroph-microalgal cultures, showing its potential for biogas valorization into high-value bio-based chemicals, like ectoine, marking a significant step toward sustainable biogas utilization.

Membrane photobioreactor for biogas capture and conversion - Enhanced microbial interaction in biofilm

The urgency to mitigate greenhouse gas emissions has driven interest in sustainable biogas utilization. This study investigates a 1 L enclosed membrane photobioreactor (MPBR) using a microalgae-methanotroph coculture for biogas capture. Operating with a hydraulic and solid retention time of 7 days and a biogas loading rate of 2.7 L /day, the introduction of gas membrane module increased CO2-C and CH4-C uptake rates by 12 % and 50 %, respectively. Biofilm formation on the membrane surface enhanced system performance, with imaging analyses revealing methanotroph predominantly located near the membrane surface and photosynthetic microorganisms distributed throughout. Metagenomic analysis showed shifts in key metabolic pathways, including increased abundance of soluble methane monooxygenase genes and enhanced vitamin B synthesis in the biofilm. These findings highlight the spatial organization and metabolic interactions in methanotroph-microalgae coculture system, providing insights into the role of membrane-induced biofilms in improving MPBR performance for sustainable biogas utilization.

Synergistic treatment of digested wastewater with high ammonia nitrogen concentration using straw and microalgae

Microalgae as a promising approach for wastewater treatment, has challenges in directly treating digested piggery wastewater (DPW) with high ammonia nitrogen (NH4+-N) concentration. To improve the performance of microalgae in DPW treatment, straw was employed as a substrate to form a straw-microalgae biofilm. The results demonstrated that the straw-microalgae biofilm achieved the highest NH4+-N removal rate of 193.2 mg L-1 d-1, which was 28.8 % higher than that of culture system without straw. The final NH4+-N concentration in the effluent met the discharge standard of 5 mg L-1. Furthermore, the total organic carbon (TOC) released from straw facilitated bacterial proliferation and the secretion of extracellular polymeric substances (EPS). The EPS and TOC increased the suspension viscosity and surface tension, thereby enhancing the residence time of CO2 in the liquid phase and promoting CO2 fixation. This study presented a novel method for the biological treatment of high-ammonia-nitrogen DPW.

Effect of NH4Cl supplementation on growth, photosynthesis, and triacylglycerol content in Chlamydomonas reinhardtii under mixotrophic cultivation

AIM

Ammonium chloride (NH4Cl) is one of the nitrogen sources for microalgal cultivation. An excessive amounts of NH4Cl are toxic for microalgae. However, combining mixotrophic conditions and excessive quantities of NH4Cl positively affects microalgal biomass and lipid production. In this study, we investigated the impact of NH4Cl on the growth, biomass, and triglyceride (TAG) content of the green microalga Chlamydomonas reinhardtii especially under mixotrophic conditions.

METHODS AND RESULTS

Under photoautotrophic conditions (without organic carbon supplementation), adding 25 mM NH4Cl had no significant effect on microalgal growth or TAG content. However, under mixotrophic condition (with acetate supplementation), NH4Cl interfered with microalgal growth while inducing TAG content. To explore these effects further, we conducted a two-step cultivation process and found that NH4Cl reduced microalgal growth, but induced total lipid and TAG content, especially after 4-day cultivation. The photosynthesis performances showed that NH4Cl completely inhibited oxygen evolution on day 4. However, NH4Cl slightly reduced the Fv/Fm ratio indicating that the NH4Cl supplementation directly affects microalgal photosynthesis. To investigate the TAG induction effect by NH4Cl, we compared the protein expression profiles of microalgae grown mixotrophically with and without 25 mM NH4Cl using a proteomics approach. This analysis identified 1782 proteins, with putative acetate uptake transporter GFY5 and acyl-coenzyme A oxidase being overexpressed in the NH4Cl-treated group.

CONCLUSION

These findings suggested that NH4Cl supplementation may stimulate acetate utilization and fatty acid synthesis pathways in microalgae cells. Our study indicated that NH4Cl supplementation can induce microalgal biomass and lipid production, particularly when combined with mixotrophic conditions.

Biosynthesis of polyhydroxybutyrate from methane and carbon dioxide using type II methanotrophs

Methane (CH4) and carbon dioxide (CO2) are the dominant greenhouse gases (GHGs) that are increasing at an alarming rate. Methanotrophs have emerged as potential CH4 and CO2 biorefineries. This study demonstrated the synchronous incorporation of CH4 and CO2 into polyhydroxybutyrate (PHB) for the first time using 13C-labeling experiments in methanotrophs. By supplying substantial amounts of CO2, PHB content was enhanced in all investigated type II methanotrophic strains by 140 %, 146 %, and 162 %. The highest content of PHB from CH4 and CO2 in flask-scale cultivation reached 38 % dry cell weight in Methylocystis sp. MJC1, in which carbon percentage in PHB from CO2 was 45 %. Flux balance analysis predicted the critical roles of crotonyl-CoA carboxylase/reductase and phosphoenolpyruvate carboxylase in CO2 recycling. This study provided proof of the conversion of GHGs into a valuable and practical product using methanotrophic bacteria, contributing to addressing GHG emissions.

Unlocking synergies: Harnessing the potential of biological methane sequestration through metabolic coupling between Methylomicrobium alcaliphilum 20Z and Chlorella sp. HS2

A halotolerant consortium between microalgae and methanotrophic bacteria could effectively remediate in situ CH4 and CO2, particularly using saline wastewater sources. Herein, Methylomicrobium alcaliphilum 20Z was demonstrated to form a mutualistic association with Chlorella sp. HS2 at a salinity level above 3.0%. Co-culture significantly enhanced the growth of both microbes, independent of initial inoculum ratios. Additionally, increased methane provision in enclosed serum bottles led to saturated methane removal. Subsequent analyses suggested nearly an order of magnitude increase in the amount of carbon sequestered in biomass in methane-fed co-cultures, conditions that also maintained a suitable cultural pH suitable for methanotrophic growth. Collectively, these results suggest a robust metabolic coupling between the two microbes and the influence of the factors other than gaseous exchange on the assembled consortium. Therefore, multi-faceted investigations are needed to harness the significant methane removal potential of the identified halotolerant consortium under conditions relevant to real-world operation scenarios.

A comprehensive report on valorization of waste to single cell protein: strategies, challenges, and future prospects

The food insecurity due to a vertical increase in the global population urgently demands substantial advancements in the agricultural sector and to identify sustainable affordable sources of nutrition, particularly proteins. Single-cell protein (SCP) has been revealed as the dried biomass of microorganisms such as algae, yeast, and bacteria cultivated in a controlled environment. Production of SCP is a promising alternative to conventional protein sources like soy and meat, due to quicker production, minimal land requirement, and flexibility to various climatic conditions. In addition to protein production, it also contributes to waste management by converting it into food and feed for both human and animal consumption. This article provides an overview of SCP production, including its benefits, safety, acceptability, and cost, as well as limitations that constrains its maximum use. Furthermore, this review criticizes the downstream processing of SCP, encompassing cell wall disruption, removal of nucleic acid, harvesting of biomass, drying, packaging, storage, and transportation. The potential applications of SCP, such as in food and feed as well as in the production of bioplastics, emulsifiers, and as flavoring agents for baked food, soup, and salad, are also discussed.

Microalgae cultivation with recycled harvesting water achieved economic and sustainable production of biomass and lipid: Feasibility assessment and inhibitory factors analysis

This study was conducted to achieve economic and sustainable production of biomass and lipids from Chlorella sorokiniana by recirculating cultivation with recycled harvesting water, to identify the major inhibitory factors in recirculating culture, and to analyze accordingly economic benefits. The results showed that recirculating microalgae cultivation (RMC) could obtain 0.20-0.32 g/L biomass and lipid content increased by 23.1 %-38.5 %. Correlation analysis showed that the extracellular polysaccharide (PSext), chemical oxygen demand (COD) and chromaticity of recirculating water inhibited photosynthesis and induced oxidative stress, thus inhibiting the growth of C. sorokiniana. In addition, the economic benefits analysis found that circulating the medium twice could save about 30 % of production cost, which is the most economical RMC solution. In conclusion, this study verified the feasibility and economy of RMC, and provided a better understanding of inhibitory factors identification in culture.

Insight into the potential mechanism of bicarbonate assimilation promoted by mixotrophic in CO2 absorption and microalgae conversion system

CO2 absorption-microalgae conversion (CAMC) system is a promising carbon capture and utilization technology. However, the use of HCO3- as a carbon source often led to a slower growth rate of microalgae, which also limited the application of CAMC system. In this study, the assimilation efficiency of HCO3- in CAMC system was improved through mixotrophic, and the potential mechanism was investigated. The HCO3- assimilation efficiency and biomass under mixotrophic were 34.79% and 31.76% higher than that of control. Mixotrophic increased chlorophyll and phycocyanin content, which were beneficial to capture more light energy. The content of ATP and NADPH reached 566.86 μmol/gprot and 672.86 nmol/mgprot, which increased by 31.83% and 27.67% compared to autotrophic. The activity of carbonic anhydrase and Rubisco increased by 18.52% and 22.08%, respectively. Transcriptome showed that genes related to photosynthetic and respiratory electron transport were up-regulated. The synergy of photophosphorylation and oxidative phosphorylation greatly improved energy metabolism efficiency, thus accelerating the assimilation of HCO3-. These results revealed a potential mechanism of promoting the HCO3- assimilation under mixotrophic, it also provided a guidance for using CAMC system to serve carbon neutrality.

Evaluating nutrient limitation in co-culture of Chlorella pyrenoidosa and Rhodobacter sphaeroides

The influence of nitrogen deficiency on microalgae-bacteria co-culture has been studied mostly with nitrogen-fixing bacteria. Photosynthetic bacteria (PSB), which are non-nitrogen-fixing bacteria, the impact of N deficiency on its co-culture with microalgae is unknown. In this study, Chlorella pyrenoidosa and Rhodobacter sphaeroides co-culture was cultivated photoheterotrophically with acetate. The impact of N starvation and different P supply levels on oil production were examined. When phosphorus was sufficient, N starvation increased the fatty acid methyl ester (FAME) content from 21.7 % to 28.2 %, and also increased the FAME yield (g CODFAME/g CODAcetate) from 0.17 to 0.22. However, the biomass and FAME productivities decreased. Sufficient phosphorus was also essential for a high growth rate and FAME productivity. Deficiencies in either N or P led to a decrease in the proportion of unsaturated FAMEs. iTRAQ analysis indicated N starvation promoted oil accumulation by driving the carbon flow to fatty acid synthesis in microalgae from co-culture. This study improves the understanding of biomass and lipid production via microalgae-PSB co-culture in photoheterotrophic cultivation. The mechanism of interaction between microalgae and bacteria needs further study.

Iron and nitrogen regulate carbon transformation in a methanotroph-microalgae system

Nutrient supply is important for maintaining a methanotroph and microalgae (MOB-MG) system for biogas valorization. However, there is a lack of understanding regarding how key elements regulate the growth of a MOB-MG coculture. In this study, a MOB-MG coculture with high protein content (0.47 g/g biomass) was established from waste activated sludge using synthetic biogas. An increase in iron availability substantially stimulated the specific growth rate (from 0.18 to 0.62 day-1) and biogas conversion rate (from 26.81 to 106.57 mg-C L-1 day-1) of the coculture. Moreover, the protein content remained high (0.51 g/g biomass), and the total lipid content increased (from 0.09 to 0.14 g/g biomass). Nitrogen limitation apparently constrained the specific growth rate (from 0.64 to 0.28 day-1) and largely reduced the protein content (from 0.51 to 0.31 g/g biomass) of the coculture. Intriguingly, the lipid content remained unchanged after nitrogen was depleted. The eukaryotic community was consistently dominated by MG belonging to Chlorella, while the populations of MOB shifted from Methylococcus/Methylosinus to Methylocystis due to iron and nitrogen amendment. In addition, diverse non-methanotrophic heterotrophs were present in the community. Their presence neither compromised the performance of the coculture system nor affected the protein content of the biomass. However, these heterotrophs may contribute to high carbon conversion efficiency by utilizing the dissolved organic carbon released by MOB and MG. Overall, the findings highlight the vital roles of iron and nitrogen in achieving efficient conversion of biogas, fast growth of cells, and optimal biomass composition in a MOB-MG coculture system.

Stress of cupric ion and oxytetracycline in Chlorella vulgaris cultured in swine wastewater

Chlorella culturing has the advantages in treatment of wastewater including swine wastewater from anaerobic digesters due to the product of biolipids and the uptake of carbon dioxide. However, there often exist high concentrations of antibiotics and heavy metals in swine wastewater which could be toxic to chlorella and harmful to the biological systems. This study examined the stress of cupric ion and oxytetracycline (OTC) at various concentrations on the nutrient removal and biomass growth in Chlorella vulgaris culturing in swine wastewater from anaerobic digesters, and its biochemical responses were also studied. Results showed that dynamic hormesis of either OTC concentration or cupric ion one on Chlorella vulgaris were confirmed separately, and the presence of OTC not only did not limit biomass growth and lipids content of Chlorella vulgaris but also could mitigate the toxicity of cupric ion on Chlorella vulgaris in combined stress of Cu2+ and OTC. Extracellular polymeric substances (EPS) of Chlorella vulgaris were used to explain the mechanisms of stress for the first time. The content of proteins and carbohydrates in EPS increased, and the fluorescence spectrum intensity of tightly-bound EPS (TB-EPS) of Chlorella vulgaris decreased with increasing concentration of stress because Cu2+ and OTC may be chelated with proteins of TB-EPS to form non-fluorescent characteristic chelates. The low concentration of Cu2+ (≤1.0 mg/L) could enhance the protein content and promote the activity of superoxide dismutase (SOD) while these parameters were decreased drastically under 2.0 mg/L of Cu2+. The activity of adenosine triphosphatase (ATPase) and glutathione (GSH) enhanced with the increase of OTC concentration under combined stress. This study helps to comprehend the impact mechanisms of stress on Chlorella vulgaris and provides a novel strategy to improve the stability of microalgae systems for wastewater treatment.

From anaerobic digestion to single cell protein synthesis: A promising route beyond biogas utilization

The accumulation of a large amount of organic solid waste and the lack of sufficient protein supply worldwide are two major challenges caused by rapid population growth. Anaerobic digestion is the main force of organic waste treatment, and the high-value utilization of its products (biogas and digestate) has been widely concerned. These products can be used as nutrients and energy sources for microorganisms such as microalgae, yeast, methane-oxidizing bacteria(MOB), and hydrogen-oxidizing bacteria(HOB) to produce single cell protein(SCP), which contributes to the achievement of sustainable development goals. This new model of energy conversion can construct a bioeconomic cycle from waste to nutritional products, which treats waste without additional carbon emissions and can harvest high-value biomass. Techno-economic analysis shows that the SCP from biogas and digestate has higher profit than biogas electricity generation, and its production cost is lower than the SCP using special raw materials as the substrate. In this review, the case of SCP-rich microorganisms using anaerobic digestion products for growth was investigated. Some of the challenges faced by the process and the latest developments were analyzed, and their potential economic and environmental value was verified.

Recent advances in CO2 fixation by microalgae and its potential contribution to carbon neutrality

Many countries and regions have set their schedules to achieve the carbon neutrality between 2030 and 2070. Microalgae are capable of efficiently fixing CO₂ and simultaneously producing biomass for multiple applications, which is considered one of the most promising pathways for carbon capture and utilization. This work reviews the current research on microalgae CO₂ fixation technologies and the challenges faced by the related industries and government agencies. The technoeconomic analysis indicates that cultivation is the major cost factor. Use of waste resources such as wastewater and flue gas can significantly reduce the costs and carbon footprints. The life cycle assessment has identified fossil-based electricity use as the major contributor to the global warming potential of microalgae-based CO₂ fixation approach. Substantial efforts and investments are needed to identify and bridge the gaps among the microalgae strain development, cultivation conditions and systems, and use of renewable resources and energy.

The mechanism of carbon source utilization by microalgae when co-cultivated with photosynthetic bacteria

Microalgae-photosynthetic bacteria (PSB) co-culture, which is promising for wastewater treatment and lipid production, is lacking of study. In this work, the combinations of 3 microalgae and 3 PSB strains were firstly screened and then different inoculation ratios of the co-cultures were investigated. It was found the best promotion was Chlorella pyrenoidosa/Rhodobacter capsulatus co-culture (1:1), where the biomass productivity, acetate assimilation rate and lipid productivity were 1.64, 1.61 and 2.79 times than that of the sum of pure microalgae and PSB cultures, respectively. Meanwhile, the inoculation ratio significantly affected the growth rate and lipid productivity of co-culture systems. iTRAQ analysis showed that PSB played a positive effect on acetate assimilation, TCA cycle and glyoxylate cycle of microalgae, but decreased the carbon dioxide utilization and photosynthesis, indicating PSB promoted the microalgae metabolism of organic carbon utilization and weakened inorganic carbon utilization. These findings provide in-depth understanding of carbon utilization in microalgae-PSB co-culture.

Applying mixotrophy strategy to enhance biomass production and nutrient recovery of Chlorella pyrenoidosa from biogas slurry: An assessment of the mixotrophic synergistic effect

Using biogas slurry to cultivate microalgae can simultaneously obtain microalgal biomass and allow nutrient recovery. Mixotrophic microalgae are widely recognized for their high biomass accumulation and low light dependence, making it possible to overcome the drawbacks of photoautotrophy. In this study, three complete metabolic modes of photoautotrophy, heterotrophy, mixotrophy and two incomplete metabolic modes with the addition of diuron and rotenone were applied to investigate Chlorella pyrenoidosa growth in biogas slurry. The results showed that the mixotrophic group obtained 1.15 g/L biomass, 30 % starch content, 99.40 % ammonium removal and 81.69 % total phosphorus removal, which were highly promoted compared to the others. The decline in chlorophyll, the simultaneous downregulation of Rubisco and citrate synthase and the increase in the actual quantum yield of PSII under mixotrophy revealed a synergistic effect: the complementation of photophosphorylation and oxidative phosphorylation greatly contributed to maximizing energy metabolism efficiency and minimizing energy dissipation loss.

Unraveling the key driving factors involved in cometabolism enhanced aerobic degradation of tetracycline in wastewater

Cometabolism has shown great potential in increasing the engineering feasibility of microalgae-based biotechnologies for the aerobic treatment of antibiotics-polluted wastewaters. Yet, the underlying mechanisms involved in improved microalgal performance remain unknown. In this study, we incorporated transcriptomics, gene network analysis, and enzymatic activities with cometabolic pathways of tetracycline (TC) by Chlorella pyrenoidosa to identify the key driving factors. The results demonstrated that cometabolism constructed a metabolic enzymes-photosynthetic machinery to improve the electron transport chain and activities of catalytic enzymes, which resulted in subsequent 100% removal of TC. Coupling formation dynamics of the intermediates with roles of identified metabolic enzymes, degradation of TC can be induced by de/hydroxylation, de/hydrogenation, bond-cleavage, decarboxylation, and deamination. Evaluation of 18 antibiotics' removal in reclaimed water showed cometabolism decreased the total concentrations of these antibiotics from 495.54 ng L^-1 to 221.80 ng L^-1. Our findings not only highlight the application potential of cometabolism in increasing engineering feasibility of microalgal degradation of antibiotics from wastewaters, but also provide the unique insights into unraveling the "black-box" of cometabolisms in aerobic biodegradation.