Environmental and Economic Impacts of Managing Nutrients in Digestate Derived from Sewage Sludge and High-Strength Organic Waste

Does resource recovery and utilization improve environmental and economic performance of rural wastewater treatment plants? A case study in Xiamen, China

Wastewater treatment (WWT) has been recognized as a major source of greenhouse gas emissions. Rural WWT often lags behind urban areas due to insufficient infrastructure construction and lack of funding to maintain operation. Selection of optimal WWT technologies in rural areas requires that environmental impacts and costs are traded-off across the entire lifecycle, including the construction, operation, and demolition phases. This study compared the lifecycle environmental impacts of different rural WWT technologies, incorporating both positive and negative externalities into the cost-benefit analysis (CBA). Results showed that the environmental and economic performance during the construction phase of small-scale rural WWT was critical, especially for the Source-separated Wastewater Treatment (SWWT), where construction contributed over 50 % of its environmental impacts and 70 % of its costs. SWWT exhibited the lowest carbon emissions, with wastewater reuse offsetting approximately 17 % of its emissions. However, its ranking of economic performance was worse due to high construction costs, meaning it is likely to be considered desirable only if a lower discount rate (<1.7 %) was used. Monetizing both positive and negative externalities can improve the economic performance of the SWWT. Notably, when positive externalities are included, its net present value remains non-negative (1.3 CNY/m³) even at discount rates as high as 10 %. Given its diverse revenues and low operation costs, SWWT is more suitable for low-income rural areas. This study proposed a framework in selecting rural WWT, considering both the construction and operation phases while integrating externalities into CBA. This can offer more informed policy insights (such as carbon price and tiered price) to support the development of sustainable rural WWT strategies.

Choline chloride-assisted thermal hydrolysis pretreatment improves short-chain fatty acid recovery from waste activated sludge

Recovery of short-chain fatty acids (SCFAs) from waste activated sludge (WAS) by anaerobic fermentation (AF) is limited by the slow rate of WAS hydrolysis. Here, choline chloride (ChCl)-assisted thermal hydrolysis pretreatment (THP) was proposed to improve the hydrolysis rate and SCFA recovery from WAS. ChCl-assisted THP (140 °C, 30 min, 0.60 g/g TSS) increased the SCFA yield by 139 % compared to the control (unpretreated) group, rising from 2629 ± 190 mg COD/L to 6276 ± 153 mg COD/L, and raised the percentage of acetic acid from 28.7 % to 58.0 %. The hydrogen-bonding effect of ChCl facilitates sludge destruction by THP and induces oxidative stress through quaternary ammonium groups to destroy cells, thus creating a synergistic effect on WAS hydrolysis. In addition, ChCl-assisted THP promotes the production of SCFAs by increasing the activity of key enzymes and enriching hydrolyzing and acidifying bacteria. This article provides a new approach to enhance SCFA recovery from WAS.

Simultaneous targeted and non-targeted analysis of contaminants in fertilizers in Quebec, Canada

In this study, an LC-MS based analytical method was developed and validated for the simultaneous targeted analysis (14 bisphenols and 14 plasticizers) and suspect screening of other plastic-related contaminants in various types of fertilizers. The ultrasound-assisted extraction method showed overall satisfactory performances, achieving a median absolute recovery of 85 % for the target compounds in different types of fertilizers. The method was applied to sixteen different types of fertilizers, including fertilizing residual materials (n = 8 types), one cattle manure, and seven mineral fertilizers collected in Quebec, Canada in 2022 and 2023. Relatively higher levels of the targeted bisphenols and plasticizers were detected in some fertilizing residual materials, such as municipal biosolids and deinking residues. 4-Hydroxyphenyl 4-isoprooxyphenylsulfone (D-8) and bis(2-ethylhexyl) phthalate (DEHP) were dominant contaminants in these matrixes, with concentrations up to 35.6 and 64.7 μg g-1 dw, respectively. A non-targeted workflow was successfully applied to municipal biosolids and deinking residues, and >30 contaminants were identified across multiple chemical families at level 1 identification confidence, with most of them previously unreported in various types of fertilizers. For example, new color developers, N-(2-((Phenylcarbamoyl)amino)phenyl)benzenesulfonamide (NKK-1304) and 2,4-bis(phenylsulfonyl)phenol (DBSP), were reported in deinking residues. This work illustrates the complexity of the contaminant mixtures in fertilizers such as municipal biosolids and deinking residues.

Cooperation of rhamnolipid and thermophilic bacteria modifies proteinic structure, microbial community, and metabolic traits for efficient solubilization and acidogenesis of mariculture solid wastes

Anaerobic fermentation combined with thermophilic bacteria (TB) pretreatment is a promising method to realize effective waste management and carbon resource recovery. However, undesirable properties of high-strength mariculture solid wastes (MSW) such as high solids concentration, excessive salinity and poor bioavailability limited the overall solubilization and acidogenic efficiency. This study innovatively introduced rhamnolipid (RL) to alleviate this adverse effect, and unveiled its cooperation with TB on enhancing organic matter dissolution and volatile fatty acids (VFAs) production. The results showed that VFAs yield from pretreated MSW was improved by 9.4-15.1 folds with enriched acetate (81.4%-94.4%) in the TB+RL groups. The co-pretreatment of RL and TB disintegrated substrate structure for efficient release of electron shuttles and biodegradable organics. This was because introducing RL reconstructed solid-liquid interfacial charge and molecular arrangement, improved thermophilic enzyme activity, and reduced apoptosis and necrosis cells of TB. Substrate bioavailability was further improved with proteinic structure shifted from α-helix and β-sheet to random coil and aggregated strands, and amide II and carboxyl groups interacted with RL molecules. These changes induced the selective enrichment of hydrolytic and acidogenic bacteria, and the upregulated expression of encoding genes responsible for transmembrane transport, protein hydrolysis, carbohydrate metabolism and acetate biosynthesis. This study provides a new strategy to overcome the bottlenecks of acidogenesis from high-strengthen organic wastes and deciphers the underlying mechanism.

Efficient incorporation of highly migratory thallium into struvite structure: Unraveling the stabilization mechanisms from a mineralogical perspective

The remediation of high-concentration thallium (Tl+) contaminated wastewater is a critical environmental concern. Current research emphasizes the effectiveness of adsorption and oxidation methods for Tl+ treatment, yet challenges persist in enhancing their performance. This study explores the feasibility of emergency Tl+ wastewater treatment and elucidates the mechanisms of Tl+ incorporation into mineral structures, with a focus on the struvite mineral as a framework for Tl+ integration via NH4+ ion exchange. To assess the efficacy and mechanisms of Tl+ immobilization, we utilized comprehensive analytical techniques, including X-ray Diffraction (XRD), X-ray Photoelectron Spectroscopy (XPS), Fourier-Transform Infrared Spectroscopy (FTIR), Scanning Electron Microscopy with Energy-Dispersive X-ray Spectroscopy (SEM-EDS), Thermogravimetric Analysis (TG), and Density Functional Theory (DFT) calculations. The findings reveal that struvite adsorbs Tl+ onto its surface, followed by an ion exchange process between monovalent cations (NH4+/K+) within the structure and Tl+. Ultimately, Tl+ is incorporated in the form of a (NH4,Tl)MgPO4 solid solution within the structure, achieving a remarkable maximum incorporation capacity of 320.56 mg/g, which significantly surpasses the capacity of typical adsorbents. The findings demonstrate significant Tl+ incorporation, validating the approach for emergency wastewater treatment and suggesting the potential of mineralogy in environmental remediation. This research contributes to advancing heavy metal wastewater treatment strategies, offering a foundation for further investigation.

A novel approach for sludge deep-dewatering via flowing-out enhancement but not relying on cell lysis and bound water release

Effective deep-dewatering is crucial for wastewater sludge management. Currently, the dominant methods focus on promoting cell lysis to release intracellular water, but these techniques often lead to secondary pollution and require stringent conditions, limiting their practical use. This study explores an innovative method using a commercially available complex quaternary ammonium salt surfactant, known as G-agent. This agent remarkably reduces the sludge water content from 98.6 % to 56.8 % with a low dosage (50 mg/g DS) and under neutral pH conditions. This approach surpasses Fenton oxidation in terms of dewatering efficiency and avoids the necessity for cell lysis and bound water release, thereby reducing the risk of secondary pollution in the filtrate, including heavy metals, nitrogen, phosphorus, and other contaminants. The G-agent plays a significant role in destabilizing flocs and enhancing flocculation during the conditioning and initial dewatering stages, effectively reducing the solid-liquid interfacial affinity of the sludge. In the compression filtration stage, the agent's solidification effect is crucial in forming a robust skeleton that improves pore connectivity within the filter cake, leading to increased water permeability, drainage performance and water flow-out efficiency. This facilitates deep dewatering of sludge without cell lysis. The study reveals that the G-agent primarily improves water flow-out efficiency rather than water flowability, indicating that cell lysis and bound water release are not indispensable prerequisites for sludge deep-dewatering. Furthermore, it presents an encouraging prospect for overcoming the limitations associated with conventional sludge deep-dewatering processes.

Multi-criteria analysis of strategies towards sustainable recycling of phosphorus from sewage sludge in Austria

To promote optimal phosphorus (P) recovery from municipal wastewater and sewage sludge with viable legal instruments, it is imperative to understand the regional and national consequences of different legal requirements for recycling. In this study we develop a scenario-based analysis to assess the environmental and economic impact of different national P recovery strategies in the context of a detailed representation of the existing Austrian wastewater infrastructure. This assessment combines material flow analysis, life cycle assessment and life cycle costing and includes the indicators P recycling rate, P utilization degree, heavy metal removal rate, share of heavy metals' content in wastewater redirected to agricultural soils, global warming potential, cumulated energy demand, terrestrial acidification potential, volume of freight transport and annual costs. The following main conclusions can be drawn. P recovery from ash shows the highest potential regarding the utilization of P from wastewater. A high P utilization from wastewater should rely on recovery technologies that decontaminate products, otherwise pollutant loads to agricultural soils might increase. P recovery to the extent of 60-85 % of P in WWTPs influent can be achieved by savings/costs of -0.8 to +4.7 EUR inhabitant-1 yr-1 in addition to current cost of the wastewater treatment/sludge disposal system. Key factors to be considered for costs are the choice of recovery process, revenues from products, and the use of existing incineration infrastructure. P recovery can lead to the reduction of greenhouse gas emissions in Austria if nitrous oxide emissions from sludge incineration are limited and efficient heat utilization strategies are implemented. There is a trade-off in terms of environmental and economic costs in choosing a more centralized or decentralized mono-incineration strategy.

Predicting maturity and identifying key factors in organic waste composting using machine learning models

The measurement of germination index (GI) in composting is a time-consuming and laborious process. This study employed four machine learning (ML) models, namely Random Forest (RF), Artificial Neural Network (ANN), Support Vector Regression (SVR), and Decision Tree (DT), to predict GI based on key composting parameters. The prediction results showed that the coefficient of determination (R2) for RF (>0.9) and ANN (>0.9) was higher than SVR (<0.6) and DT (<0.8), suggesting that RF and ANN displayed superior predictive performance for GI. The SHapley additive exPlanations value result indicated that composting time, temperature, and pH were the important features contributing to GI. Composting time was found to have the most significant impact on GI. Overall, RF and ANN were suggested as effective tools for predicting GI in composting. This study offers the reliable approach of accurately predicting GI in composting processes, thereby enabling intelligent composting practices.

Enhancing sustainable crop cultivation: The impact of renewable soil amendments and digestate fertilizer on crop growth and nutrient composition

Utilizing digestate as a fertilizer enhances soil nutrient content, improves fertility, and minimizes nutrient runoff, mitigating water pollution risks. This alternative approach replaces commercial fertilizers, thereby reducing their environmental impact and lowering greenhouse gas emissions associated with fertilizer production and landfilling. Herein, this study aimed to evaluate the impact of various soil amendments, including carbon fractions from waste materials (biochar, compost, and cocopeat), and food waste anaerobic digestate application methods on tomato plant growth (Solanum lycopersicum) and soil fertility. The results suggested that incorporating soil amendments (biochar, compost, and cocopeat) into the potting mix alongside digestate application significantly enhances crop yields, with increases ranging from 12.8 to 17.3% compared to treatments without digestate. Moreover, the combination of soil-biochar amendment and digestate application suggested notable improvements in nitrogen levels by 20.3% and phosphorus levels by 14%, surpassing the performance of the those without digestate. Microbial analysis revealed that the soil-biochar amendment significantly enhanced biological nitrification processes, leading to higher nitrogen levels compared to soil-compost and soil-cocopeat amendments, suggesting potential nitrogen availability enhancement within the rhizosphere's ecological system. Chlorophyll content analysis suggested a significant 6.91% increase with biochar and digestate inclusion in the soil, compared to the treatments without digestate. These findings underscore the substantial potential of crop cultivation using soil-biochar amendments in conjunction with organic fertilization through food waste anaerobic digestate, establishing a waste-to-food recycling system.

Advances in nitrogen removal and recovery technologies from reject water: Economic and environmental perspectives

This review critically assesses nitrogen removal technologies applied in the reject water treatment, across different stages of technological development, with a focus on their economic and environmental impacts. The prevalent use of biological processes raises concerns due to potential environmental impacts caused by N2O emissions. However, partial nitritation-anaerobic ammonium oxidation demonstrated economic benefits and the potential for positive environmental outcomes when properly operated and controlled. Furthermore, reject water, in many cases, provides sufficient nitrogen concentrations for nitrogen recovery processes, such as ammonia stripping, substituting production of industrial fertilizers and contributing to a circular economy. Nonetheless, their financial competitiveness is subject to various conditions, including the nitrogen concentration or reject water flow. As the environmental benefits of bioprocesses and economic benefits of nitrogen recovery processes may vary, it is crucial to further optimize both and investigate novel promising technologies such as electrochemical systems, denitrifying anaerobic methane oxidation or direct ammonia oxidation.

Evaluation of anaerobic membrane bioreactor treating dairy processing wastewater: Elemental flow, bioenergy production and reduction of CO2 emission

The management of dairy processing wastewater (DPW) must address water pollution while delivering renewable energy and recovering resources. A high-rate anaerobic membrane bioreactor (AnMBR) was investigated for treating DPW, and the system was evaluated in terms of elemental flow, nutrient recovery, energy balance, and reduction of CO2 emission. The AnMBR system was superior in terms of both methanogenic performance and efficiency of bioenergy recovery in the DPW treatment, with a high net energy potential of 51.4-53.2 kWh/m3. The theoretical economic values of the digestate (13.8 $/m3) and permeate (4.1 $/m3) were assessed according to nutrient transformation and price of mineral fertilizer. The total CO2 emission equivalent in the AnMBR was 44.7 kg CO2-eq/m3, with a significant reduction of 54.1 kg CO2-eq/m3 compared to the conventional process. The application of the AnMBR in the DPW treatment is a promising approach for the development of carbon neutrality and a circular economy.

Phosphorus Recovery from Whole Digestate through Electrochemical Leaching and Precipitation

Phosphorus (P) recovery from biosolids can play an important role in a circular economy. Herein, an electrochemical phosphorus recovery cell (EPRC) was proposed and examined to recover P from municipal whole digestate via simultaneous leaching and precipitation. The anode of the EPRC released P as aqueous PO₄^3--P through acidification, achieving the highest leaching efficiency of 93.3% under a current density of 30 A m^-2. When the leached P solution was treated in the cathode, native metals including Ca and Fe facilitated electrochemically mediated PO₄^3--P precipitation (EMP) and precipitated ∼99% of the leached P in the cathode chamber. Around 54.3-78.7% of total P existed in two harvestable forms: suspended solids in the cathode effluent and immobilized P in the cathode chamber. The solid products contained 28.42-33.51% of P₂O₅, comparable to the high-grade phosphate rock. Higher current densities reduced cathode scaling and resulted in a lower content of heavy metals in the solid products. An acidic solution was reused three times and effectively maintained cathode performance during a 42-cycle operation, achieving a consistent P recovery efficiency of nearly 80%. Those results have demonstrated the feasibility of the EPRC for recovering P from P-rich solid wastes.

Thiosulfate pretreatment enhancing short-chain fatty acids production from anaerobic fermentation of waste activated sludge: Performance, metabolic activity and microbial community

A novel strategy based on thiosulfate pretreatment for enhancing short-chain fatty acids (SCFAs) from anaerobic fermentation (AF) of waste activated sludge (WAS) was proposed in this study. The results showed that the maximal SCFA yield increased from 206.1 ± 4.7 to 1097.9 ± 17.2 mg COD/L with thiosulfate dosage increasing from 0 to 1000 mg S/L, and sulfur species contribution results revealed that thiosulfate was the leading contributor to improve SCFA yield. Mechanism exploration disclosed that thiosulfate addition largely improved WAS disintegration, due to thiosulfate serving as a cation binder for removing organic-binding cations, especially Ca²⁺ and Mg²⁺, dispersing the extracellular polymeric substance (EPS) structure and further entering into the intracellularly by stimulated carrier protein SoxYZ and subsequently caused cell lysis. Typical enzyme activities and related functional gene abundances indicated that both hydrolysis and acidogenesis were remarkably enhanced while methanogenesis was substantially suppressed, which were further strengthened by the enriched hydrolytic bacteria (e.g. C10-SB1A) and acidogenic bacteria (e.g. Aminicenantales) but severely reduced methanogens (e.g. Methanolates and Methanospirillum). Economic analysis confirmed that thiosulfate pretreatment was a cost-effective and efficient strategy. The findings obtained in this work provide a new thought for recovering resource through thiosulfate-assisted WAS AF for sustainable development.