Rate-Limiting Mass Transfer in Micropollutant Degradation Revealed by Isotope Fractionation in Chemostat

Acetochlor degradation in anaerobic microcosms with hyporheic sediments: Insights from biogeochemical data, transformation products, and isotope analysis

Steep redox gradients and diverse microbial communities in the anaerobic hyporheic zone create complex pathways for the degradation of herbicides, often linked to various terminal electron-accepting processes (TEAPs). Identifying the degradation pathways and their controlling factors under various TEAPs is of great significance for understanding mechanisms of water purification in the hyporheic zone. However, current research on herbicides in this area remains insufficient. Acetochlor, a commonly detected herbicide in aquatic environments, was the target contaminant in this study. Biogeochemical data, transformation products examination, and compound-specific isotope analysis (CSIA) were used to elucidate the degradation mechanisms of acetochlor under various TEAPs in anaerobic microcosms with hyporheic sediments. Results showed that carbon isotope fractionation of acetochlor during abiotic reduction by reduced sulfur species (εbulk,C = -16.4 ± 0.4‰), such as HS- and Sn2-, was significantly larger than that observed during anaerobic biodegradation (εbulk,C = -3.7 ± 0.4‰). This suggested the utility of CSIA in identifying biotic/abiotic degradation pathways of acetochlor in anaerobic environments. CSIA and transformation products examination revealed that biodegradation under Fe(III) reducing conditions and abiotic reduction by reduced sulfur species under SO42- reducing conditions were the main pathways for acetochlor degradation in anaerobic hyporheic sediments. TEAPs controlled the abilities and mechanisms of acetochlor degradation in different hyporheic sediments, which were highly associated with terminal electron acceptors (Fe(III) and SO42-), Fe(III) reducing bacteria (Geobacter and Anaerolinea), SO42- reducing bacteria (Bacteroidetes_vadinHA17), and tryptophan-like substances. This study provides important insights into the mechanisms of herbicides degradation in the hyporheic zone.

Insights into anaerobic biotransformation of polychlorinated biphenyls in Dehalococcoides mccartyi CG1 through kinetic and stable isotopic analysis

Microbial degradation processes largely govern the fate of organic contaminants in the environment. Therefore, reliable evaluation of in situ biodegradation is essential for effective on-site contaminant management. Although compound-specific isotope analysis (CSIA) shows significant potential for assessing in situ attenuation and evaluating chemical and biodegradation mechanisms, empirical evidence supporting its application in the microbial degradation of polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs) is still lacking. Microbial degradation of trace persistent organic pollutants is a multifaceted process influenced by various factors, with substrate concentration being a key factor affecting isotopic fractionation. Herein, to the best of our knowledge, for the first time, batch biodegradation experiments were conducted for analyzing the kinetics and carbon/chlorine isotope fractionation of chiral substrates (-)/(+)-PCB132 by Dehalococcoides mccartyi CG1 at varying substrate concentrations (0.3, 1.7, 2.4, 3.5, and 4.7 μM). The dechlorination of (-)/(+)-PCB132 was predominantly consistent with pseudo-first-order kinetics (kobs) in most cases. However, when the ratio of substrate concentration to the density of functional microorganisms falls below a specific threshold (<5.3 × 10-3 μmol/( × 1010 CG1 cells)), a decline in observed kobs is noted as degradation time increases, ultimately approaching the lower limit of bioavailability (kobs = 0). Notably, substantial normal isotope fractionation was observed for the first time during the anaerobic degradation of (-)/(+)-PCB132, with the isotopic enrichment factor (ƐC) varying from -1.27 ± 0.18‰ to -2.22 ± 0.01 for (-)/(+)-PCB132. Our findings indicate that, in addition to the effect of substrate concentration, the observed isotope fractionation of (-)/(+)-PCB132 was considerably affected by putative biodegradation activity. Enhanced activity within the anaerobic degradation system resulted in pronounced isotope masking. This study aims to contribute to a foundational understanding of bacterial reductive dehalogenation of PCBs at differing substrate concentrations while considering bioavailability.

Sulfamethoxazole is Metabolized and Mineralized at Extremely Low Concentrations

The presence of organic micropollutants in water and sediments motivates investigation of their biotransformation at environmentally low concentrations, usually in the range of μg L-1. Many are biotransformed by cometabolic mechanisms; however, there is scarce information concerning their direct metabolization in this concentration range. Threshold concentrations for microbial assimilation have been reported in both pure and mixed cultures from different origins. The literature suggests a range value for bacterial growth of 1-100 μg L-1 for isolated aerobic heterotrophs in the presence of a single substrate. We aimed to investigate, as a model case, the threshold level for sulfamethoxazole (SMX) metabolization in pure cultures of Microbacterium strain BR1. Previous research with this strain has covered the milligram L-1 range. In this study, acclimated cultures were exposed to concentrations from 0.1 to 25 μg L-1 of 14C-labeled SMX, and the 14C-CO2 produced was trapped and quantified over 24 h. Interestingly, SMX removal was rapid, with 98% removed within 2 h. In contrast, mineralization was slower, with a consistent percentage of 60.0 ± 0.7% found at all concentrations. Mineralization rates increased with rising concentrations. Therefore, this study shows that bacteria are capable of the direct metabolization of organic micropollutants at extremely low concentrations (sub μg L-1).

Comprehensive exploration of the anaerobic biotransformation of polychlorinated biphenyls in Dehalococcoides mccartyi CG1: Kinetics, enantioselectivity, and isotope fractionation

Anaerobic microbial transformation is a key pathway in the natural attenuation of polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs). Much less is known about the transformation behaviors induced by pure organohalide-respiring bacteria, especially kinetic isotope effects. Therefore, the kinetics, pathways, enantioselectivity, and carbon and chlorine isotope fractionation of PCBs transformation by Dehalococcoides mccartyi CG1 were comprehensively explored. The results indicated that the PCBs were mainly dechlorinated via removing their double-flanked meta-chlorine, with their first-order kinetic constants following the order of PCB132 > PCB174 > PCB85 > PCB183 > PCB138. However, PCBs occurred great loss of stoichiometric mass balance during microbial transformation, suggesting the generation of other non-dehalogenation products and/or stable intermediates. The preferential transformation of (-)-atropisomers and generation of (+)-atropisomers were observed during PCB132 and PCB174 biotransformation with the enantiomeric enrichment factors of -0.8609 ± 0.1077 and -0.4503 ± 0.1334 (first half incubation times)/-0.1888 ± 0.1354 (second half incubation times), respectively, whereas no enantioselectivity occurred during PCB183 biotransformation. More importantly, although there was no carbon and chlorine isotope fractionation occurring for studied substrates, the δ13C values of dechlorination products, including PCB47 (-28.15 ± 0.35‰ ∼ -27.77 ± 0.20‰), PCB91 (-36.36 ± 0.09‰ ∼ -34.71 ± 0.49‰), and PCB149 (-28.08 ± 0.26‰ ∼ -26.83 ± 0.10‰), were all significantly different from those of their corresponding substrates (PCB85: -30.81 ± 0.02‰ ∼ -30.22 ± 0.21‰, PCB132: -33.57 ± 0.15‰ ∼ -33.13 ± 0.14‰, and PCB174: -26.30 ± 0.09‰ ∼ -26.01 ± 0.07‰), which further supported the generation of other non-dehalogenation products and/or stable intermediates with enrichment or depletion of 13C. These findings provide deeper insights into the anaerobic microbial transformation behaviors of PCBs.

The Growth Yield of Aminobacter niigataensis MSH1 on the Micropollutant 2,6-Dichlorobenzamide Decreases Substantially at Trace Substrate Concentrations

2,6-Dichlorobenzamide (BAM) is an omnipresent micropollutant in European groundwaters. Aminobacter niigataensis MSH1 is a prime candidate for biologically treating BAM-contaminated groundwater since this organism is capable of utilizing BAM as a carbon and energy source. However, detailed information on the BAM degradation kinetics by MSH1 at trace concentrations is lacking, while this knowledge is required for predicting and optimizing the degradation process. Contaminating assimilable organic carbon (AOC) in media makes the biodegradation experiment a mixed-substrate assay and hampers exploration of pollutant degradation at trace concentrations. In this study, we examined how the BAM concentration affects MSH1 growth and BAM substrate utilization kinetics in a AOC-restricted background to avoid mixed-substrate conditions. Conventional Monod kinetic models were unable to predict kinetic parameters at low concentrations from kinetics determined at high concentrations. Growth yields on BAM were concentration-dependent and decreased substantially at trace concentrations; i.e., growth of MSH1 diminished until undetectable levels at BAM concentrations below 217 μg-C/L. Nevertheless, BAM degradation continued. Decreasing growth yields at lower BAM concentrations might relate to physiological adaptations to low substrate availability or decreased expression of downstream steps of the BAM catabolic pathway beyond 2,6-dichlorobenzoic acid (2,6-DCBA) that ultimately leads to Krebs cycle intermediates for growth and energy conservation.

Physiological and transcriptomic changes drive robust responses in Paenarthrobacter sp. AT5 to co-exposure of sulfamethoxazole and atrazine

Agricultural waterways are often contaminated with herbicide and antibiotic residues due to the widespread use of these chemicals in modern agriculture. The search for resistant bacterial strains that can adapt to and degrade these mixed contaminants is essential for effective in situ bioremediation. Herein, by integrating chemical and transcriptomic analyses, we shed light on mechanisms through which Paenarthrobacter sp. AT5, a well-known atrazine-degrading bacterial strain, can adapt to sulfamethoxazole (SMX) while degrading atrazine. When exposed to SMX and/or atrazine, strain AT5 increased the production of extracellular polymeric substances and reactive oxygen species, as well as the rate of activity of antioxidant enzymes. Atrazine and SMX, either alone or combined, increased the expression of genes involved in antioxidant responses, multidrug resistance, DNA repair, and membrane transport of lipopolysaccharides. Unlike atrazine alone, co-exposure with SMX reduced the expression of genes encoding enzymes involved in the lower part of the atrazine degradation pathway. Overall, these findings emphasize the complexity of bacterial adaptation to mixed herbicide and antibiotic residues and highlight the potential of strain AT5 in bioremediation efforts.

Degradation pathways of atrazine by electrochemical oxidation at different current densities: Identifications from compound-specific isotope analysis and DFT calculation

Current density was the key factor that impacted pollutant degradation by electrochemical oxidation, and reaction contributions at various current densities were non-negligible for the cost-effective treatments of organic pollutants. This research introduced compound specific isotope analysis (CSIA) into atrazine (ATZ) degradation by boron doped diamond (BDD) with current density of 2.5-20 mA/cm², in order to provide "in-situ" and "fingerprint" analysis of reaction contributions with changed current densities. As results, the increased current density displayed a positive impact on ATZ removal. The Ʌ_C/H values (correlations of Δδ¹³C and Δδ²H) were 24.58, 9.18 and 8.74 when current densities were 20, 4, and 2.5 mA/cm², with ·OH contribution of 93.5%, 77.2% and 80.35%, respectively. While DET process favored lower current density with contribution rates up to ∼20%. What's more interesting, though the carbon and hydrogen isotope enrichment factors (ε_C and ε_H) were fluctuate, the Ʌ_C/H linearly increased accompanied with applied current densities. Therefore, increasing current density was effective due to the larger ·OH contribution even though side reactions may occur. DFT calculations proved the increase of C-Cl bond length and the delocalization of Cl atom, confirming dechlorination reaction mainly occurred in the direct electron transfer process. While ·OH radical mainly attack the C-N bond on the side chain, which was more benefit to the fast decomposition of ATZ molecule and intermediates. It was forceful to discuss pollutant degradation mechanism by combining CSIA and DFT calculations. Target bond cleavage (i.e., dehalogenation reaction) can be conducted by changing reaction conditions like current density due to the significantly different isotope fractionation and bond cleavage.

Predicting and improving the microbial removal of organic micropollutants during wastewater treatment: A review

Organic micropollutants (OMPs) consist of widely used chemicals such as pharmaceuticals and pesticides that can persist in surface and groundwaters at low concentrations (ng/L to μg/L) for a long time. The presence of OMPs in water can disrupt aquatic ecosystems and threaten the quality of drinking water sources. Wastewater treatment plants (WWTPs) rely on microorganisms to remove major nutrients from water, but their effectiveness at removing OMPs varies. Low removal efficiency might be the result of low concentrations, inherent stable chemical structures of OMPs, or suboptimal conditions in WWTPs. In this review, we discuss these factors, with special emphasis on the ongoing adaptation of microorganisms to degrade OMPs. Finally, recommendations are drawn to improve the prediction of OMP removal in WWTPs and to optimize the design of new microbial treatment strategies. OMP removal seems to be concentration-, compound-, and process-dependent, which poses a great complexity to develop accurate prediction models and effective microbial processes targeting all OMPs.

Microbial hydrolysis of atrazine in contaminated groundwater

Degradation of the widespread herbicide atrazine has been intensively studied in soils, while its degradation in groundwater has received less attention. This work studied atrazine degradation in contaminated groundwater adjacent to its production plant. The degradation potential was first explored in groundwater enrichment cultures. A broad potential for microbial atrazine degradation was observed when atrazine served as the sole nitrogen source, even when incubated with nitrate. Hydroxyatrazine was formed by the cultures, while desethylatrazine and desisopropylatrazine were not detected. Both the atzA and the trzN genes were identified by quantitative PCR analysis, with a clear dominance of atzA. Carbon isotope enrichments throughout the degradation process varied between the different cultures, with ε values ranging from -0.6 to -5.5‰. This implies corresponding uncertainties when using compound-specific isotope analysis to estimate degradation extents. In the field samples, in-situ degradation was reflected by a high percentage of metabolites, with hydroxyatrazine accounting for >95% of the metabolites in most wells. Both atzA and trzN were detected in the groundwater at quantities of ≈10² to 10⁶ copies mL^-1, with a dominance of atzA over trzN. These results provide evidence of the high potential for atrazine hydrolysis in the contaminated groundwater.

Enhanced removal of warfare agent tri-nitro-toluene by a Methylophaga-dominated microbiome

Historical exposure of the marine environment to 2,4,6-trinitrotoluene (TNT) happened due to the dumping of left-over munitions. Despite significant research on TNT decontamination, the potential of marine microbiome for TNT degradation remains only little explored. In this study, TNT degradation experiments were conducted with sediment located near the World War I munition dumpsite - Paardenmarkt in the Belgian part of North Sea. A slow removal was observed using TNT as sole source of C and N, which could be enhanced by adding methanol. Degradation was reflected in nitro-reduced metabolites and microbial growth. 16S Illumina sequencing analysis revealed several enriched genera that used TNT as a sole source of C and N - Colwellia, Thalossospira, and Methylophaga. Addition of methanol resulted in increased abundance of Methylophaga, which corresponded to the rapid removal of TNT. Methanol enhanced the degradation by providing additional energy and establishing syntrophic association between methanol-utilizing and TNT-utilizing bacteria.

Reactive transport of micropollutants in laboratory aquifers undergoing transient exposure periods

Groundwater quality is of increasing concern due to the ubiquitous occurrence of micropollutant mixtures. Stream-groundwater interactions near agricultural and urban areas represent an important entry pathway of micropollutants into shallow aquifers. Here, we evaluated the biotransformation of a micropollutant mixture (i.e., caffeine, metformin, atrazine, terbutryn, S-metolachlor and metalaxyl) during lateral stream water flow to adjacent groundwater. We used an integrative approach combining concentrations and transformation products (TPs) of the micropollutants, compound-specific isotope analysis (δ¹³C and δ¹⁵N), sequencing of 16S rRNA gene amplicons and reactive transport modeling. Duplicate laboratory aquifers (160 cm × 80 cm × 7 cm) were fed with stream water and subjected over 140 d to three successive periods of micropollutant exposures as pulse-like (6000 μg L^-1) and constant (600 μg L^-1) injections under steady-state conditions. Atrazine, terbutryn, S-metolachlor and metalaxyl persisted in both aquifers during all periods (<10 % attenuation). Metformin attenuation (up to 14 %) was only observed from 90 d onwards, suggesting enhanced degradation over time. In contrast, caffeine dissipated during all injection periods (>90 %), agreeing with fast degradation rates (t_1/2 < 3 d) in parallel microcosm experiments and detection of TPs (theobromine and xanthine). Significant stable carbon isotope fractionation (Δδ¹³C ≥ 6.6 ‰) was observed for caffeine in both aquifers, whereas no enrichment in ¹⁵N occurred. A concentration dependence of caffeine biotransformation in the aquifers was further suggested by model simulations following Michaelis-Menten kinetics. Changes in bacterial community composition reflected long-term bacterial adaptation to micropollutant exposures. Altogether, the use of an integrative approach can help to understand the interplay of subsurface hydrochemistry, bacterial adaptations and micropollutants biotransformation during stream-groundwater interactions.

Phase-specific stable isotope fractionation effects during combined gas-liquid phase exchange and biodegradation

Stable isotope fractionation of toluene under dynamic phase exchange was studied aiming at ascertaining the effects of gas-liquid partitioning and biodegradation of toluene stable isotope composition in liquid-air phase exchange reactors (Laper). The liquid phase consisted of a mixture of aqueous minimal media, a known amount of a mixture of deuterated (toluene-d) and non-deuterated toluene (toluene-h), and bacteria of toluene degrading strain Pseudomonas putida KT2442. During biodegradation experiments, the liquid and air-phase concentrations of both toluene isotopologues were monitored to determine the observable stable isotope fractionation in each phase. The results show a strong fractionation in both phases with apparent enrichment factors beyond -800‰. An offset was observed between enrichment factors in the liquid and the gas phase with gas-phase values showing a stronger fractionation in the gas than in the liquid phase. Numerical simulation and parameter fitting routine was used to challenge hypotheses to explain the unexpected experimental data. The numerical results showed that either a very strong, yet unlikely, fractionation of the phase exchange process or a - so far unreported - direct consumption of gas phase compounds by aqueous phase microorganisms could explain the observed fractionation effects. The observed effect can be of relevance for the analysis of volatile contaminant biodegradation using stable isotope analysis in unsaturated subsurface compartments or other environmental compartment containing a gas and a liquid phase.

Kinetic isotope effects of C and N indicate different transformation mechanisms between atzA- and trzN-harboring strains in dechlorination of atrazine

Compound-specific stable isotope analysis provides an alternative method to insight into the biotransformation mechanisms of diffuse organic pollutants in the environment, e.g., the endocrine disruptor herbicide atrazine. Biotic hydrolysis process catalyzed by chlorohydrolase AtzA and TrzN plays an important role in the detoxification of atrazine, while the catalytic mechanism of AtzA is still speculative. To investigate the catalytic mechanism of AtzA and answer whether both enzymes catalyze hydrolytic dechlorination of atrazine by the same mechanism, in this study, apparent kinetic isotope effects (AKIE) for carbon and nitrogen were observed by three atzA-harboring bacterial isolates and their membrane-free extracts. The AKIEs obtained from atzA-harboring bacterial isolates (AKIEC = 1.021 ± 0.010, AKIEN = 0.992 ± 0.003) were statistically different from that of trzN-harboring strains (AKIEC = 1.040 ± 0.006, AKIEN = 0.983 ± 0.006), confirming the different activation mechanisms of atrazine preceding to nucleophilic aromatic substitution of Cl atom in actual enzymatic reaction catalyzed by AtzA and TrzN, despite the limitation of variable dual-element isotope plots. The lower degree of normal carbon and inverse nitrogen isotope fractionation observed from atzA-harboring strains, suggesting AtzA catalyzing hydrolytic dechlorination of atrazine by coordination of Cl and one aromatic N to the Fe2+ drawing electron density from carbon-chlorine bond that facilitating the nucleophilic attack, rather than in TrzN case that protonation of aromatic N increasing nucleophilic substitution of Cl atom. This study suggests considering the potential influences of phylogenetic diversity of bacterial isolates and evolution of enzymes on the applications of CSIA method in future study.

Toward Improved Bioremediation Strategies: Response of BAM-Degradation Activity to Concentration and Flow Changes in an Inoculated Bench-Scale Sediment Tank

Compound-specific isotope analysis (CSIA) can reveal mass-transfer limitations during biodegradation of organic pollutants by enabling the detection of masked isotope fractionation. Here, we applied CSIA to monitor the adaptive response of bacterial degradation in inoculated sediment to low contaminant concentrations over time. We characterized Aminobacter sp. MSH1 activity in a flow-through sediment tank in response to a transient supply of elevated 2,6-dichlorobenzamide (BAM) concentrations as a priming strategy and took advantage of an inadvertent intermittence to investigate the effect of short-term flow fluctuations. Priming and flow fluctuations yielded improved biodegradation performance and increased biodegradation capacity, as evaluated from bacterial activity and residual concentration time series. However, changes in isotope ratios in space and over time evidenced that mass transfer became increasingly limiting for degradation of BAM at low concentrations under such stimulated conditions, and that activity decreased further due to bacterial adaptation at low BAM (μg/L) levels. Isotope ratios, in conjunction with residual substrate concentrations, therefore helped identifying underlying limitations of biodegradation in such a stimulated system, offering important insight for future optimization of remediation schemes.

Linking Increased Isotope Fractionation at Low Concentrations to Enzyme Activity Regulation: 4-Cl Phenol Degradation by Arthrobacter chlorophenolicus A6

Slow microbial degradation of organic trace chemicals ("micropollutants") has been attributed to either downregulation of enzymatic turnover or rate-limiting substrate supply at low concentrations. In previous biodegradation studies, a drastic decrease in isotope fractionation of atrazine revealed a transition from rate-limiting enzyme turnover to membrane permeation as a bottleneck when concentrations fell below the Monod constant of microbial growth. With degradation of the pollutant 4-chlorophenol (4-CP) by Arthrobacter chlorophenolicus A6, this study targeted a bacterium which adapts its enzyme activity to concentrations. Unlike with atrazine degradation, isotope fractionation of 4-CP increased at lower concentrations, from ε(C) = -1.0 ± 0.5‰ in chemostats (D = 0.090 h^-1, 88 mg L^-1) and ε(C) = -2.1 ± 0.5‰ in batch (c₀ = 220 mg L^-1) to ε(C) = -4.1 ± 0.2‰ in chemostats at 90 μg L^-1. Surprisingly, fatty acid composition indicated increased cell wall permeability at high concentrations, while proteomics revealed that catabolic enzymes (CphCI and CphCII) were differentially expressed at D = 0.090 h^-1. These observations support regulation on the enzyme activity level─through either a metabolic shift between catabolic pathways or decreased enzymatic turnover at low concentrations─and, hence, reveal an alternative end-member scenario for bacterial adaptation at low concentrations. Including more degrader strains into this multidisciplinary analytical approach offers the perspective to build a knowledge base on bottlenecks of bioremediation at low concentrations that considers bacterial adaptation.

Bioaugmentation of pilot-scale slow sand filters can achieve compliant levels for the micropollutant metaldehyde in a real water matrix

Metaldehyde is a polar, mobile, low molecular weight pesticide that is challenging to remove from drinking water with current adsorption-based micropollutant treatment technologies. Alternative strategies to remove this and compounds with similar properties are necessary to ensure an adequate supply of safe and regulation-compliant drinking water. Biological removal of metaldehyde below the 0.1 µg•L^-1 regulatory concentration was attained in pilot-scale slow sand filters (SSFs) subject to bioaugmentation with metaldehyde-degrading bacteria. To achieve this, a library of degraders was first screened in bench-scale assays for removal at micropollutant concentrations in progressively more challenging conditions, including a mixed microbial community with multiple carbon sources. The best performing strains, A. calcoaceticus E1 and Sphingobium CMET-H, showed removal rates of 0.0012 µg•h^-1•10⁷ cells^-1 and 0.019 µg•h^-1•10⁷ cells^-1 at this scale. These candidates were then used as inocula for bioaugmentation of pilot-scale SSFs. Here, removal of metaldehyde by A. calcoaceticus E1, was insufficient to achieve compliant water regardless testing increasing cell concentrations. Quantification of metaldehyde-degrading genes indicated that aggregation and inadequate distribution of the inoculum in the filters were the likely causes of this outcome. Conversely, bioaugmentation with Sphingobium CMET-H enabled sufficient metaldehyde removal to achieve compliance, with undetectable levels in treated water for at least 14 d (volumetric removal: 0.57 µg•L^-1•h^-1). Bioaugmentation did not affect the background SSF microbial community, and filter function was maintained throughout the trial. Here it has been shown for the first time that bioaugmentation is an efficient strategy to remove the adsorption-resistant pesticide metaldehyde from a real water matrix in upscaled systems. Swift contaminant removal after inoculum addition and persistent activity are two remarkable attributes of this approach that would allow it to effectively manage peaks in metaldehyde concentrations (due to precipitation or increased application) in incoming raw water by matching them with high enough degrading populations. This study provides an example of how stepwise screening of a diverse collection of degraders can lead to successful bioaugmentation and can be used as a template for other problematic adsorption-resistant compounds in drinking water purification.

Multi-element isotopic evidence for monochlorobenzene and benzene degradation under anaerobic conditions in contaminated sediments

Industrial chemicals are frequently detected in sediments due to a legacy of chemical spills. Globally, site remedies for groundwater and sediment decontamination include natural attenuation by in situ abiotic and biotic processes. Compound-specific isotope analysis (CSIA) is a diagnostic tool to identify, quantify, and characterize degradation processes in situ, and in some cases can differentiate between abiotic degradation and biodegradation. This study reports high-resolution carbon, chlorine, and hydrogen stable isotope profiles for monochlorobenzene (MCB), and carbon and hydrogen stable isotope profiles for benzene, coupled with measurements of pore water concentrations in contaminated sediments. Multi-element isotopic analysis of δ¹³C and δ³⁷Cl for MCB were used to generate dual-isotope plots, which for 2 locations at the study site resulted in Λ_C/Cl(130) values of 1.42 ± 0.19 and Λ_C/Cl(131) values of 1.70 ± 0.15, consistent with theoretical calculations for carbon-chlorine bond cleavage (Λ_T = 1.80 ± 0.31) via microbial reductive dechlorination. For benzene, significant δ²H (122‰) and δ¹³C (6‰) depletion trends, followed by enrichment trends in δ¹³C (1.6‰) in the upper part of the sediment, were observed at the same location, indicating not only production of benzene due to biodegradation of MCB, but subsequent biotransformation of benzene itself to nontoxic end-products. Degradation rate constants calculated independently using chlorine isotopic data and carbon isotopic data, respectively, agreed within uncertainty thus providing multiple lines of evidence for in situ contaminant degradation via reductive dechlorination and providing the foundation for a novel approach to determine site-specific in situ rate estimates essential for the prediction of remediation outcomes and timelines.

Triple-Element Compound-Specific Stable Isotope Analysis (3D-CSIA): Added Value of Cl Isotope Ratios to Assess Herbicide Degradation

Multielement isotope fractionation studies to assess pollutant transformation are well-established for point-source pollution but are only emerging for diffuse pollution by micropollutants like pesticides. Specifically, chlorine isotope fractionation is hardly explored but promising, because many pesticides contain only few chlorine atoms so that "undiluted" position-specific Cl isotope effects can be expected in compound-average data. This study explored combined Cl, N, and C isotope fractionation to sensitively detect biotic and abiotic transformation of the widespread herbicides and groundwater contaminants acetochlor, metolachlor, and atrazine. For chloroacetanilides, abiotic hydrolysis pathways studied under acidic, neutral, and alkaline conditions as well as biodegradation in two soils resulted in pronounced Cl isotope fractionation (ε_Cl from -5.0 ± 2.3 to -6.5 ± 0.7‰). The characteristic dual C-Cl isotope fractionation patterns (Λ_C-Cl from 0.39 ± 0.15 to 0.67 ± 0.08) reveal that Cl isotope analysis provides a robust indicator of chloroacetanilide degradation. For atrazine, distinct Λ_C-Cl values were observed for abiotic hydrolysis (7.4 ± 1.9) compared to previous reports for biotic hydrolysis and oxidative dealkylation (1.7 ± 0.9 and 0.6 ± 0.1, respectively). The 3D isotope approach allowed differentiating transformations that would not be distinguishable based on C and N isotope data alone. This first data set on Cl isotope fractionation in chloroacetanilides, together with new data in atrazine degradation, highlights the potential of using compound-specific chlorine isotope analysis for studying in situ pesticide degradation.

Methodological Advances to Study Contaminant Biotransformation: New Prospects for Understanding and Reducing Environmental Persistence?

Complex microbial communities in environmental systems play a key role in the detoxification of chemical contaminants by transforming them into less active metabolites or by complete mineralization. Biotransformation, i.e., transformation by microbes, is well understood for a number of priority pollutants, but a similar level of understanding is lacking for many emerging contaminants encountered at low concentrations and in complex mixtures across natural and engineered systems. Any advanced approaches aiming to reduce environmental exposure to such contaminants (e.g., novel engineered biological water treatment systems, design of readily degradable chemicals, or improved regulatory assessment strategies to determine contaminant persistence a priori) will depend on understanding the causal links among contaminant removal, the key driving agents of biotransformation at low concentrations (i.e., relevant microbes and their metabolic activities), and how their presence and activity depend on environmental conditions. In this Perspective, we present the current understanding and recent methodological advances that can help to identify such links, even in complex environmental microbiomes and for contaminants present at low concentrations in complex chemical mixtures. We discuss the ensuing insights into contaminant biotransformation across varying environments and conditions and ask how much closer we have come to designing improved approaches to reducing environmental exposure to contaminants.

Assessment of chlorinated ethenes degradation after field scale injection of activated carbon and bioamendments: Application of isotopic and microbial analyses

Over the last decade, activated carbon amendments have successfully been applied to retain chlorinated ethene subsurface contamination. The concept of this remediation technology is that activated carbon and bioamendments are injected into aquifer systems to enhance biodegradation. While the scientific basis of the technology is established, there is a need for methods to characterise and quantify the biodegradation at field scale. In this study, an integrated approach was applied to assess in situ biodegradation after the establishment of a cross sectional treatment zone in a TCE plume. The amendments were liquid activated carbon, hydrogen release donors and a Dehalococcoides containing culture. The integrated approach included spatial and temporal evaluations on flow and transport, redox conditions, contaminant concentrations, biomarker abundance and compound-specific stable isotopes. This is the first study applying isotopic and microbial techniques to assess field scale biodegradation enhanced by liquid activated carbon and bioamendments. The injection enhanced biodegradation from TCE to primarily cis-DCE. The Dehalococcoides abundances facilitated characterisation of critical zones with insufficient degradation and possible explanations. A conceptual model of isotopic data together with distribution and transport information improved process understanding; the degradation of TCE was insufficient to counteract the contaminant input by inflow into the treatment zone and desorption from the sediment. The integrated approach could be used to document and characterise the in situ degradation, and the isotopic and microbial data provided process understanding that could not have been gathered from conventional monitoring tools. However, quantification of degradation through isotope data was restricted for TCE due to isotope masking effects. The combination of various monitoring tools, applied frequently at high-resolution, with system understanding, was essential for the assessment of biodegradation in the complex, non-stationary system. Furthermore, the investigations revealed prospects for future research, which should focus on monitoring contaminant fate and microbial distribution on the sediment and the activated carbon.

Mass-Transfer-Limited Biodegradation at Low Concentrations-Evidence from Reactive Transport Modeling of Isotope Profiles in a Bench-Scale Aquifer

Organic contaminant degradation by suspended bacteria in chemostats has shown that isotope fractionation decreases dramatically when pollutant concentrations fall below the (half-saturation) Monod constant. This masked isotope fractionation implies that membrane transfer is slow relative to the enzyme turnover at μg L^-1 substrate levels. Analogous evidence of mass transfer as a bottleneck for biodegradation in aquifer settings, where microbes are attached to the sediment, is lacking. A quasi-two-dimensional flow-through sediment microcosm/tank system enabled us to study the aerobic degradation of 2,6-dichlorobenzamide (BAM), while collecting sufficient samples at the outlet for compound-specific isotope analysis. By feeding an anoxic BAM solution through the center inlet port and dissolved oxygen (DO) above and below, strong transverse concentration cross-gradients of BAM and DO yielded zones of low (μg L^-1) steady-state concentrations. We were able to simulate the profiles of concentrations and isotope ratios of the contaminant plume using a reactive transport model that accounted for a mass-transfer limitation into bacterial cells, where apparent isotope enrichment factors *ε decreased strongly below concentrations around 600 μg/L BAM. For the biodegradation of organic micropollutants, mass transfer into the cell emerges as a bottleneck, specifically at low (μg L^-1) concentrations. Neglecting this effect when interpreting isotope ratios at field sites may lead to a significant underestimation of biodegradation.

Concentration dependent degradation of pharmaceuticals in WWTP effluent by biofilm reactors

Conventional wastewater treatment lacks the ability to remove many pharmaceuticals. This is leading to emissions to the natural aquatic environment, where these compounds pose a risk to the aquatic organisms. An advanced wastewater treatment technique that has shown promising results is Moving Bed Biofilm Reactors (MBBR). Initial degradation velocity and degradation rate constants of the pharmaceuticals are important parameters for designing an optimal MBBR system; however, the degradation efficiency varies across studies and one of the most plausible causes might be initial concentration. Thus, to verify the effect of initial concentration, the degradation of a mixture of 18 pharmaceuticals at different initial concentrations was studied. For this study MBBR's with very low BOD loading were used as they were conditioned with effluent water. The experiment was set up as a MBBR batch incubation, using effluent wastewater as medium, spiked with the 18 pharmaceuticals in seven different concentration levels (approximately 0-300 µg L^-1). The degradation of 14 out of 18 pharmaceuticals was concentration-dependent. The initial degradation velocity of the pharmaceuticals was either proportional to the initial concentration or was following a typical Michaelis-Menten kinetic. The degradation velocity of one compound, i.e., sulfamethizole might have been inhibited at high concentrations. The degradation rate constants from single first-order fittings (K_SFO) for some compounds deviated from the expected behavior at low concentrations (below 10 µg L^-1). This is suggested to be caused by simplicity of the Michaelis-Menten model, not taking possible occurrence of co-metabolism and mass-transfer limitations into account at low concentrations. This study underlines the fact that K values cannot be interpreted without paying attention to the tested concentration level. Furthermore, it shows that the used MBBRs was able to handle high concentrations of pharmaceuticals, and that the most efficient removal occurs at concentrations above 100 µg L^-1.

Phenotypic heterogeneity as key factor for growth and survival under oligotrophic conditions

Productivity-poor oligotrophic environments are plentiful on earth. Yet it is not well understood how organisms maintain population sizes under these extreme conditions. Most scenarios consider the adaptation of a single microorganism (isogenic) at the cellular level, which increases their fitness in such an environment. However, in oligotrophic environments, the adaptation of microorganisms at population level - that is, the ability of living cells to differentiate into subtypes with specialized attributes leading to the coexistence of different phenotypes in isogenic populations - remains a little-explored area of microbiology research. In this study, we performed experiments to demonstrate that an isogenic population differentiated to two subpopulations under low energy-flux in chemostats. Fluorescence cytometry and turnover rates revealed that these subpopulations differ in their nucleic acid content and metabolic activity. A mechanistic modelling framework for the dynamic adaptation of microorganisms with the consideration of their ability to switch between different phenotypes was experimentally calibrated and validated. Simulation of hypothetical scenarios suggests that responsive diversification upon a change in energy availability offers a competitive advantage over homogenous adaptation for maintaining viability and metabolic activity with time.

Impact of seasonality, redox conditions, travel distances and initial concentrations on micropollutant removal during riverbank filtration at four sites

Riverbank filtration (RBF) is a reliable water purification technique that has proven to be suitable for the removal of organic micropollutants. Its removal efficiency and dependency on a variety of factors such as redox conditions, temperatures, geology, travel times, level of initial micropollutant concentrations and seasonality were investigated during three seasonal sampling campaigns. Two anoxic (silty sand, Ems river) and two oxic (gravel, Ruhr river) RBF sites in Germany with different travel distances (42-633 m) were studied. Micropollutant concentrations were examined using a large-volume direct injection liquid chromatography method coupled to high-resolution mass spectrometry. Seasonal differences in micropollutant concentrations in the rivers were observed for chlorotolurone, diclofenac, terbuthylazine, mecoprop-P, MCPA (2-methyl-4-chlorophenoxyacetic acid) and propyphenazone. Redox dependencies in RBF were only found for sulfamethoxazole, propyphenazone, terbuthylazine and carbamazepine. Data for oxazepam, tramadol, N-desmethyl-tramadol, tilidin-desmethyl, carbamazepine and carbendazim indicate a required minimum travel distance of e.g. 100-200 m for the complete removal. Notably, travel time did not seem to be a substantial factor for their removal. High conductivity aquifers are also well suited for micropollutant removal. Seasonal initial concentration level variations showed no impact on the resulting abstraction well concentrations. Although the calculated removal efficiencies varied, they proved to be improper for seasonal raw water quality comparison. Knowledge of micropollutant behavior in riverbank filtration was broadened and RBF proved to be well suited for effective micropollutant reduction throughout the year, yet for a complete removal long travel distances or further technical purification steps are required.

Defining lower limits of biodegradation: atrazine degradation regulated by mass transfer and maintenance demand in Arthrobacter aurescens TC1

Exploring adaptive strategies by which microorganisms function and survive in low-energy natural environments remains a grand goal of microbiology, and may help address a prime challenge of the 21st century: degradation of man-made chemicals at low concentrations (“micropollutants”). Here we explore physiological adaptation and maintenance energy requirements of a herbicide (atrazine)-degrading microorganism (Arthrobacter aurescens TC1) while concomitantly observing mass transfer limitations directly by compound-specific isotope fractionation analysis. Chemostat-based growth triggered the onset of mass transfer limitation at residual concentrations of 30 μg L⁻¹ of atrazine with a bacterial population doubling time (t_d) of 14 days, whereas exacerbated energy limitation was induced by retentostat-based near-zero growth (t_d = 265 days) at 12 ± 3 μg L⁻¹ residual concentration. Retentostat cultivation resulted in (i) complete mass transfer limitation evidenced by the disappearance of isotope fractionation (ε¹³C = −0.45‰ ± 0.36‰) and (ii) a twofold decrease in maintenance energy requirement compared with chemostat cultivation. Proteomics revealed that retentostat and chemostat cultivation under mass transfer limitation share low protein turnover and expression of stress-related proteins. Mass transfer limitation effectuated slow-down of metabolism in retentostats and a transition from growth phase to maintenance phase indicating a limit of ≈10 μg L⁻¹ for long-term atrazine degradation. Further studies on other ecosystem-relevant microorganisms will substantiate the general applicability of our finding that mass transfer limitation serves as a trigger for physiological adaptation, which subsequently defines a lower limit of biodegradation.

Modeling of Contaminant Biodegradation and Compound-Specific Isotope Fractionation in Chemostats at Low Dilution Rates

We present a framework to model microbial transformations in chemostats and retentostats under transient or quasi-steady state conditions. The model accounts for transformation-induced isotope fractionation and mass-transfer across the cell membrane. It also verifies that the isotope fractionation ϵ can be evaluated as the difference of substrate-specific isotope ratios between inflow and outflow. We explicitly considered that the dropwise feeding of substrate into the reactor at very low dilution rates leads to transient behavior of concentrations and transformation rates and use this information to validate conditions under which a quasi-steady state treatment is justified. We demonstrate the practicality of the code by modeling a chemostat experiment of atrazine degradation at low dilution/growth rates by the strain Arthrobacter aurescens TC1. Our results shed light on the interplay of processes that control biodegradation and isotope fractionation of contaminants at low (μg/L) concentration levels. With the help of the model, an estimate of the mass-transfer coefficient of atrazine through the cell membrane was achieved (0.0025 s-1).

High Permeation Rates in Liposome Systems Explain Rapid Glyphosate Biodegradation Associated with Strong Isotope Fractionation

Bacterial uptake of charged organic pollutants such as the widely used herbicide glyphosate is typically attributed to active transporters, whereas passive membrane permeation as an uptake pathway is usually neglected. For 1-palmitoyl-2-oleoyl- sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (POPC) liposomes, the pH-dependent apparent membrane permeation coefficients ( Papp) of glyphosate, determined by nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy, varied from Papp (pH 7.0) = 3.7 (±0.3) × 10-7 m·s-1 to Papp (pH 4.1) = 4.2 (±0.1) × 10-6 m·s-1. The magnitude of this surprisingly rapid membrane permeation depended on glyphosate speciation and was, at circumneutral pH, in the range of polar, noncharged molecules. These findings point to passive membrane permeation as a potential uptake pathway during glyphosate biodegradation. To test this hypothesis, a Gram-negative glyphosate degrader, Ochrobactrum sp. FrEM, was isolated from glyphosate-treated soil and glyphosate permeation rates inferred from the liposome model system were compared to bacterial degradation rates. Estimated maximum permeation rates were, indeed, 2 orders of magnitude higher than degradation rates of glyphosate. In addition, biodegradation of millimolar glyphosate concentrations gave rise to pronounced carbon isotope fractionation with an apparent kinetic isotope effect, AKIEcarbon, of 1.014 ± 0.003. This value lies in the range typical of non-masked enzymatic isotope fractionation demonstrating that glyphosate biodegradation was not subject to mass transfer limitations and glyphosate exchange across the cell membrane was rapid relative to enzymatic turnover.

Isotope Fractionation Pinpoints Membrane Permeability as a Barrier to Atrazine Biodegradation in Gram-negative Polaromonas sp. Nea-C

Biodegradation of persistent pesticides like atrazine often stalls at low concentrations in the environment. While mass transfer does not limit atrazine degradation by the Gram-positive Arthrobacter aurescens TC1 at high concentrations (>1 mg/L), evidence of bioavailability limitations is emerging at trace concentrations (<0.1 mg/L). To assess the bioavailability constraints on biodegradation, the roles of cell wall physiology and transporters remain imperfectly understood. Here, compound-specific isotope analysis (CSIA) demonstrates that cell wall physiology (i.e., the difference between Gram-negative and Gram-positive bacteria) imposes mass transfer limitations in atrazine biodegradation even at high concentrations. Atrazine biodegradation by Gram-negative Polaromonas sp. Nea-C caused significantly less isotope fractionation (ε(C) = -3.5 ‰) than expected for hydrolysis by the enzyme TrzN (ε(C) = -5.0 ‰) and observed in Gram-positive Arthrobacter aurescens TC1 (ε(C) = -5.4 ‰). Isotope fractionation was recovered in cell-free extracts (ε(C) = -5.3 ‰) where no cell envelope restricted pollutant uptake. When active transport was inhibited with cyanide, atrazine degradation rates remained constant demonstrating that atrazine mass transfer across the cell envelope does not depend on active transport but is a consequence of passive cell wall permeation. Taken together, our results identify the cell envelope of the Gram-negative bacterium Polaromonas sp. Nea-C as a relevant barrier for atrazine biodegradation.