Two Dual-Function Zr/Hf-MOFs as High-Performance Proton Conductors and Amines Impedance Sensors

Proton Conduction in Zirconium-Based Metal-Organic Frameworks for Advanced Applications

Zirconium-based metal-organic frameworks (Zr-MOFs) have emerged as a promising class of crystalline porous materials, attracting significant interest in the field of proton conduction due to their exceptional chemical stability, structural flexibility, and functional tunability. Notably, proton-conducting Zr-MOFs show immense potential for diverse advanced technological applications. In this Spotlight on Applications paper, we provide an overview of proton-conducting Zr-MOFs and spotlight the recent progress of their utilization as proton exchange membranes in proton exchange membrane fuel cells (PEMFCs), light-responsive systems for proton pumps, and chemical sensors for formic acid detection. Furthermore, we also discussed the challenges, future prospects, and opportunities for promoting the application of proton-conducting Zr-MOFs.

Linkage Position-Controlled Synthesis of Diverse Zirconium Metal-Organic Frameworks with Prominent Intrinsic Proton Conductivities

Herein, by engineering the geometries of the organic linkers, two pyrrolo-pyrrole-based low-symmetry tetracarboxylate linkers (TAPPs) were successfully designed and subsequently used for the construction of two new zirconium-based metal-organic frameworks (Zr-MOFs) (IAM-10 and IAM-11). The reduction of the linker symmetry arises from both the asymmetric pyrrolo-pyrrole core and the integration of both the para- and meta-benzoate coordination groups on the linkers. Both MOFs are composed of 8-connected Zr6 nodes and 4-connected highly deformed TAPP4- linkers with the same scu topology, but distinct linker arrangements can be observed in two structures. The specific rhomb-shaped geometry together with the flexible m-benzoate groups through the rotation of the peripheral phenyl rings allows this type of TAPP linker to generate unique conformations and arrangements in MOF structures to optimize the coordination bonds with the inorganic building blocks and adapt to the final topologies. Furthermore, the presence of well-defined hydrophilic channels in the reported MOFs allowed us to evaluate the potential for proton conduction. Both IAM-10 and IAM-11 show the prominent intrinsic proton conductivities of 1.13 × 10-2 and 2.69 × 10-3 S cm-1 at 90 °C and 95% RH, making them the top-performing proton-conductive Zr-MOFs.

Inherent Ultrahigh Proton Conductivity of Two Highly Stable COOH-Functionalized Hafnium-Based Metal-Organic Frameworks

Although there has been some recent interest in the proton conductivity (σ) of highly stable carboxyl metal-organic frameworks (MOFs) made of tetravalent metal ions, given their potential applications in fuel cells and electrochemical sensing, research on MOFs constructed by hafnium(IV) ions needs to be expanded significantly. Based on this, we used two common and easily prepared phenylpoly(carboxylic acid) ligands, 1,2,4-phenyltricarboxylic acid and 1,2,4,5-phenyltetracarboxylic acid, to react with hafnium tetrachloride, respectively, creating two porous hafnium(IV)-based MOFs, UiO-66-COOH-Hf (1) and UiO-66-(COOH)2-Hf (2), with the same structure as UiO-66-Hf but with different numbers of free carboxylic groups. A series of stability assays revealed that the two MOFs had excellent structural rigidity, including thermal and water stability. More crucially, alternating current impedance experiments demonstrate that the σ of the two MOFs varies positively with humidity and temperature, reaching up to 10-3 S·cm-1 (1: 2.83 × 10-3 S·cm-1 and 2: 4.35 × 10-3 S·cm-1) under the right conditions (98% relative humidity and 100 °C). The latter roughly doubles the proton conductivity of the former, which is due to the difference in the number of free carboxyl groups, as confirmed by the structural analysis and proton conduction mechanism investigation. The high intrinsic σ of the two MOFs lays a solid foundation for their future application and affords new inspiration for developing high-performance proton-conductive materials.

A Highly Stable Multifunctional Bi-Based MOF for Rapid Visual Detection of S2- and H2S Gas with High Proton Conductivity

Metal organic frameworks (MOFs) constructed with bismuth metal have not been widely reported, especially multifunctional Bi-MOFs. Therefore, developing multifunctional MOFs is of great significance due to the increasing requirements of materials. In this work, a 3D Bi-MOF (Bi-TCPE) with multifunctionality was successfully constructed, demonstrating high thermal stability, water stability, a porous structure, and strong blue fluorescence emission. We evaluated the properties of Bi-TCPE in detecting anions (S2-, Cr2O72-, and CrO42-) in aqueous solution, along with the rapid visual detection of H2S gas and proton conduction. In terms of anion detection, Bi-TCPE achieved the rapid detection of trace S2- in aqueous solutions, while the Ksv value was 1.224 × 104 M-1 with a limit of detection (LOD) value of 1.93 μM through titration experiments. Furthermore, Bi-TCPE could sensitively detect Cr2O72- and CrO42-, with Ksv values of 1.144 × 104 and 1.066 × 104 M-1, respectively, while LOD reached 2.07 and 2.18 μM. Subsequently, we conducted H2S gas detection experiments, and the results indicated that Bi-TCPE could selectively detect H2S gas at extremely low concentrations (2.08 ppm) and with a fast response time (<10 s). We also observed significant color changes under both UV light and sunlight. Therefore, we developed a H2S detection test paper for the rapid visual detection of H2S gas. Finally, we evaluated the proton conductivity of Bi-TCPE, and the experimental results showed that the proton conductivity of Bi-TCPE reached 4.77 × 10-2 S·cm-1 at 98% RH and 90 °C, achieving an excellent value for unmodified and encapsulated MOFs. In addition, Bi-TCPE showed high stability in proton conduction experiments (it remained stable after 21 consecutive days of testing and 12 cycles of testing), demonstrating relatively high application value. These results indicate that Bi-TCPE is a multifunctional MOF material with great application potential.

Prominent Intrinsic Proton Conduction in Two Robust Zr/Hf Metal-Organic Frameworks Assembled by Bithiophene Dicarboxylate

To date, developing crystalline proton-conductive metal-organic frameworks (MOFs) with an inherent excellent proton-conducting ability and structural stability has been a critical priority in addressing the technologies required for sustainable development and energy storage. Bearing this in mind, a multifunctional organic ligand, 3,4-dimethylthiophene[2,3-b]thiophene-2,5-dicarboxylic acid (H2DTD), was employed to generate two exceptionally stable three-dimensional porous Zr/Hf MOFs, [Zr6O4(OH)4(DTD)6]·5DMF·H2O (Zr-DTD) and [Hf6O4(OH)4(DTD)6]·4DMF·H2O (Hf-DTD), using solvothermal means. The presence of Zr6 or Hf6 nodes, strong Zr/Hf-O bonds, the electrical influence of the methyl group, and the steric effect of the thiophene unit all contribute to their structural stability throughout a wide pH range as well as in water. Their proton conductivity was fully examined at various relative humidities (RHs) and temperatures. Creating intricate and rich H-bonded networks between the guest water molecules, coordination solvent molecules, thiophene-S, -COOH, and -OH units within the framework assisted proton transfer. As a result, both MOFs manifest the maximum proton conductivity of 0.67 × 10-2 and 4.85 × 10-3 S·cm-1 under 98% RH/100 °C, making them the top-performing proton-conductive Zr/Hf-MOFs. Finally, by combining structural characteristics and activation energies, potential proton conduction pathways for the two MOFs were identified.

Four Lanthanide(III) Metal-Organic Frameworks Fabricated by Bithiophene Dicarboxylate for High Inherent Proton Conduction

Currently, it is still a challenge to directly achieve highly stable metal-organic frameworks (MOFs) with superior proton conductivity solely through the exquisite design of ligands and the attentive selection of metal nodes. Inspired by this, we are intrigued by a multifunctional dicarboxylate ligand including dithiophene groups, 3,4-dimethylthieno[2,3-b]thiophene-2,5-dicarboxylic acid (H2DTD), and lanthanide ions with distinct coordination topologies. Successfully, four isostructural three-dimensional lanthanide(III)-based MOFs, [Ln2(DTD)3(DEF)4]·DEF·6H2O [LnIII = TbIII (Tb-MOF), EuIII (Eu-MOF), SmIII (Sm-MOF), and DyIII (Dy-MOF)], were solvothermally prepared, in which the effective proton transport will be provided by the coordinated or free solvent molecules, the crystalline water molecules, and the framework components, as well as a large number of highly electronegative S and O atoms. As expected, the four Ln-MOFs demonstrated the highest proton conductivities (σ) being 0.54 × 10-3, 3.75 × 10-3, 1.28 × 10-3, and 1.92 × 10-3 S·cm-1 for the four MOFs, respectively, at 100 °C/98% relative humidity (RH). Excitingly, Dy-MOF demonstrated an extraordinary ultrahigh σ of 1 × 10-3 S·cm-1 at 30 °C/98% RH. Additionally, the plausible proton transport mechanisms were emphasized.

Ligand-Functionalized MIL-68-type Indium(III) Metal-Organic Frameworks with Prominent Intrinsic Proton Conductivity

Indium-based metal-organic frameworks (In-MOFs) have now become an attractive class of porous solids in materials science and electrochemistry due to their diverse structures and promising applications. In the field of proton conduction, to find more crystalline MOFs with splendid proton-conductive properties, herein, five three-dimensional isostructural In-MOFs, MIL-68-In or MIL-68-In-X (X = NH2, OH, Br, or NO2) using terephthalic acid (H2BDC) or functionalized terephthalic acids (H2BDC-X) as multifunctional linkages were efficiently fabricated. First, the outstanding structural stability of the five MOFs, including thermal and water stability, was verified by thermal analysis and powder X-ray diffraction. Subsequently, the H2O-mediated proton conductivities (σ) were fully assessed and compared. Notably, their σ evinced a significant positive correlation between the temperature or relative humidity (RH) and varied with the functional groups on the organic ligands. Impressively, their highest σ values are up to 10-3-10-4 S/cm (100 °C/98% RH) and change in this order: MIL-68-In-OH (1.72 × 10-3 S/cm) > MIL-68-In-NH2 (1.70 × 10-3 S/cm) > MIL-68-In-NO2 (4.47 × 10-4 S/cm) > MIL-68-In-Br (4.11 × 10-4 S/cm) > MIL-68-In (2.37 × 10-4 S/cm). Finally, the computed activation energy values under 98 or 68% RHs are assessed, and the related proton conduction mechanisms are speculated. Moreover, after electrochemical testing, these MOFs illustrate remarkable structural rigidity, laying a meritorious material foundation for future applications.

Remarkable water-mediated proton conductivity of two porous zirconium(IV)/hafnium(IV) metal-organic frameworks bearing porphyrinlcarboxylate ligands

Obtaining crystalline materials with high structural stability as well as super proton conductivity is a challenging task in the field of energy and material chemistry. Therefore, two highly stable metal-organic frameworks (MOFs) with macro-ring structures and carboxylate groups, Zr-TCPP (1) and Hf-TCPP (2) assembled from low-toxicity as well as highly coordination-capable Zr(IV)/Hf(IV) cations and the multifunctional linkage, meso-tetra(4-carboxyphenyl)porphine (TCPP) have attracted our strong interest. Note that TCPP as a large-size rigid ligand with high symmetry and multiple coordination sites contributes to the formation of the two stable MOFs. Moreover, the pores with large sizes in the two MOFs favor the entry of more guest water molecules and thus result in high H2O-assisted proton conductivity. First, their distinguished structural stabilities covering water, thermal and chemical stabilities were verified by various determination approaches. Second, the dependence of the proton conductivity of the two MOFs on temperature and relative humidity (RH) is explored in depth. Impressively, MOFs 1 and 2 demonstrated the optimal proton conductivities of 4.5 × 10-4 and 0.78 × 10-3 S·cm-1 at 100 °C/98 % RH, respectively. Logically, based on the structural information, gas adsorption/desorption features, and activation energy values, their proton conduction mechanism was deduced and highlighted.

Icing on the Cake: Imidazole-Anchored Strategy To Enhance the Proton Conductivity of Two Isostructural Ce(IV)/Hf(IV) Metal-Organic Frameworks

In the field of proton conduction, the acquisition of crystalline metal-organic frameworks (MOFs) with high stability and ultrahigh proton conductivity has been of great research value and is worth continuous exploration. Here, we greenly synthesized a three-dimensional porous MOF (MOF-801-Ce) by using [(NH4)2Ce(NO3)6 and fumaric acid as starting materials and solvothermally synthesized Hf-UiO-66-NO2 by using HfCl4 and 2-nitroterephthalic acid as starting materials. A series of measurements have shown that both MOFs exhibit good water stability, acid-base stability, and thermal stability and demonstrate outstanding proton conductivity. At 100 °C and 98% relative humidity (RH), the proton conductivities (σ) could be 2.59 × 10-3 S·cm-1 for MOF-801-Ce and 0.89 × 10-3 S·cm-1 for Hf-UiO-66-NO2. To pursue higher proton conductivity, we further adopted the evaporation approach to encapsulate imidazole molecules in the pores of the two compounds, achieving the imidazole-encapsulated MOFs, Im@MOF-801-Ce and Im@Hf-UiO-66-NO2. As expected, their σ values were significantly boosted by almost an order of magnitude up to 10-2 S·cm-1. Finally, their proton-conductive mechanisms were explored in light of the structural information, gas adsorption/desorption, and other tests. The outstanding structural stability of these MOFs and their durability of the proton conduction capability manifested that they have great promise in electrochemical fields.

Redox Hopping in Metal-Organic Frameworks through the Lens of the Scholz Model

Initially proposed by Lovric and Scholz to explain redox reactions in solid-phase voltammetry, the Scholz model's applications have expanded to redox reactions in various materials. As an extension of the Cottrell equation, the Scholz model enabled the quantification of electron hopping and ion diffusion with coefficients, De and Di, respectively. Research utilizing the Scholz model indicated that, in most cases, a huge bottleneck results from the ion diffusion which is slower than electron hopping by orders of magnitude. Therefore, electron and ion motion can be tuned and optimized to increase the charge transport and conductivity through systematic investigations guided by the Scholz model. The strategy may be extended to other solid-state materials in the future, e.g., battery anodes/cathodes. In this Perspective, the applications of the Scholz model in different materials will be discussed. Moreover, the limitations of the Scholz model will also be introduced, and viable solutions to those limitations discussed.

U-type π-conjugated phosphorescent ligand sensitized lanthanide metal-organic frameworks for efficient white-light-emitting diodes

Lanthanide metal-organic framework (Ln-MOF) based phosphors for light-emitting diodes (LEDs) play an important role in the fields of solid-state lighting and display. The rational design of organic antennae to address the drawback of low extinction coefficients of the lanthanide ions is highly desired. In this work, we provide a new design strategy to achieve an energy transfer molecule with a through-space conjugated folded structure, which can strengthen the skeleton rigidity and facilitate triplet state energy transfer. Consequently, one U-type π-conjugated molecule 2,6-bis(3,5-dicarboxylphenoxy) pyridine (H4L) was selected as a light gatherer to sensitize lanthanide ions for the construction of Ln-MOFs [Ln(HL)(H2O)3]n (Eu-MOF and Tb-MOF), which exhibit a long-lived luminescence lifetime (0.88 ms for Eu-MOF and 1.31 ms for Tb-MOF) and high quantum yields (50.87% for Eu-MOF and 85.64% for Tb-MOF). Furthermore, a white LED device with a colour rendering index (89) was fabricated using the mixture of Ln-MOFs with a commercial blue phosphor.

Syntheses and High Proton Conductivities of Two 3D Zr(IV)/Hf(IV)-MOFs from Furandicarboxylic Acid

With the gradual progress of research on proton-conducting metal-organic framework (MOFs), it has become a challenging task to find MOF materials that are easy to prepare and have low toxicity, high stability, and splendid proton conductivity. With the abovementioned objectives in mind, we selected the non-toxic organic ligand 2,5-furandicarboxylic acid and the low toxic quadrivalent metals zirconium(IV) or hafnium(IV) as starting materials and successfully obtained 2 three-dimensional porous MOFs, [M6O4(OH)4(FDC)4(OH)4(H2O)4] [M = ZrIV (1) and HfIV (2)], with ultrahigh water stability using a rapid and green synthesis approach. Their proton conductive ability is remarkable, thanks to the large number of Lewis acidic sites contained in their porous frameworks and the abundant H-bonding network, hydroxyl groups, as well as coordination and crystalline water molecules. The positive correlation of their proton conductivity with relative humidity (RH) and the temperature was observed. Notably, their optimized proton conductivities are 2.80 × 10-3 S·cm-1 of 1 and 3.38 × 10-3 S·cm-1 of 2 under 100 °C/98% RH, which are at the forefront of Zr(IV)/Hf(IV) MOFs with prominent proton conductivity. Logically, their framework features, nitrogen/water adsorption/desorption data, and activation energy values are integrated to deduce their proton conductivity and conducting mechanism differences.

Design, Preparation, and High Intrinsic Proton Conductivity of Two Highly Stable Hydrazone-Linked Covalent Organic Frameworks

Assembling crystalline materials with high stability and high proton conductivity as a potential alternative to the Nafion membrane is a challenging topic in the field of energy materials. Herein, we concentrated on the creation and preparation of hydrazone-linked COFs with super-high stability to explore their proton conduction. Fortunately, two hydrazone-linked COFs, TpBth and TaBth, were solvothermally prepared by using benzene-1,3,5-tricarbohydrazide (Bth), 2,4,6-trihydroxy-benzene-1,3,5-tricarbaldehyde (Tp), and 2,4,6-tris(4-formylphenyl)-1,3,5-triazine (Ta) as monomers. Their structures were simulated by Material Studio 8.0 software and confirmed by the PXRD pattern, demonstrating a two-dimensional framework with AA packing. The presence of a large number of carbonyl groups as well as -NH-NH₂- groups on the backbone is responsible for their super-high water stability as well as high water absorption capacity. AC impedance tests demonstrated a positive correlation between the water-assisted proton conductivity (σ) of the two COFs and the temperature and humidity. Under 100 °C/98% RH, the highest σ values of TpBth and TaBth can reach 2.11 × 10^-4 and 0.62 × 10^-5 S·cm^-1, which are among the high σ values of the reported COFs. Their proton-conductive mechanisms were highlighted by structural analyses as well as N₂ and H₂O vapor adsorption data and activation energy values. Our systematic research affords ideas for the synthesis of proton-conducting COFs with high σ values.