Application of DNA- and Protein-Based Detection Methods in Agricultural Biotechnology

A green light for phytosensors?

As sentinels, transgenic phytosensor plants alert farmers rapidly to stressful conditions in crop fields. However, if improperly managed, accidental commingling of phytosensor plants with the bulk harvest could disrupt trade and raises safety concerns. With these crops nearing commercialization, proper risk management, including segregation and risk analysis, is imperative.

Field-Deployable Detection of Genetically Modified Organisms with an Integrated Method of Loop-Mediated Isothermal Amplification and CRISPR/FnCas12a

The detection of genetically modified organisms (GMOs) is crucial for regulatory compliance and consumer safety. This study presents a novel method combining loop-mediated isothermal amplification (LAMP) with CRISPR/Cas12a cleavage, termed Cas-pfLAMP, for sensitive and specific GMO detection. We developed assays for three GM events: maize DBN9936 and MON810 and soybean GTS40-3-2. By incorporating a universal protospacer adjacent motif (PAM) sequence into LAMP primers, we overcame the limitations of PAM site dependence. The Cas-pfLAMP assays demonstrated high specificity and sensitivity, with limits of detection as low as 10-12 copies per reaction. Furthermore, we developed a point-of-care testing platform integrating rapid DNA extraction, Cas-pfLAMP, and lateral flow strips for on-site GMO detection. This platform achieved comparable sensitivity to qPCR, detecting GM contents as low as 0.1% in simulated samples within 40 min. The Cas-pfLAMP method offers the advantages of PAM site independence, high specificity and sensitivity, and suitability for field testing without specialized equipment. This approach represents a promising new generation of GMO detection methods with potential applications in various scenarios.

"Blue-red-purple" multicolored lateral flow immunoassay for simultaneous detection of GM crops utilizing RPA and CRISPR/Cas12a

Advanced multiplexed testing techniques should be designed and developed to ensure an accurate and reliable evaluation for unknown samples. In this study, an efficient platform coupled with the "Blue-Red-Purple" strategy based on recombinant polymerase amplification (RPA), CRISPR/Cas12a and lateral flow strip was established, which could realize the dual-target detection of CP4-EPSPS and Cry1Ab/Ac in genetically modified crops. The lateral flow immunoassay was developed using different colored microspheres to label the antibodies to realize the visualization of results and avoid cross-reactions. The proposed method exhibits high specificity, sensitivity and stability. The visual detection limits of standard plasmids and real samples reached 10 copies/μL and 0.5 %, respectively, which could be stored at 4 °C for 12 months with high detection ability. Moreover, the entire detection process could be completed within 50 min without any complex instruments or professional operators. These findings indicated that a sensitive, specific, rapid and accurate method was established for on-site detection of GM crops.

Toothpick DNA extraction combined with handheld LAMP microfluidic platform for simple and rapid meat authentication

Adulteration of meat is a global issue, necessitating rapid, inexpensive, and simple on-site testing methods. Therefore, the present study aimed to develop a one-minute toothpick-based DNA extraction method, a handheld microfluidic chip, and a smartphone-controlled portable analyzer for detecting multiple meat adulterations. A toothpick was inserted into the meat to promote DNA release and adsorption. Furthermore, a handheld microfluidic chip was designed for DNA elution on toothpicks and fluid distribution. Finally, a smartphone-actuated portable analyzer was developed to function as a heater, signal detector, and result reader. The portable device comprises a microcontroller, a fluorescence detection module, a step scanning unit, and a heating module. The proposed device is portable, and the app is user-friendly. This simple design, easy operation, and fast-response system could rapidly detect as little as 1% of simulated adulterated samples (following UK standards) within 40 min at a cost of less than USD 1 per test.

Simultaneous detection of CaMV35S and NOS using fluorescence sensors with dual-emission silver nanoclusters and catalytic hairpin amplification strategy

A dual-emission fluorescent biosensing method was developed for simultaneous determination of CaMV35S and NOS in genetically modified (GM) plants. Two designed hairpin DNA (H1, H2) sequences were used as templates to synthesize H1-AgNCs (λex = 570 nm, λem = 625 nm) and H2-AgNCs (λex = 470 nm, λem = 555 nm). By using H1-AgNCs and H2-AgNCs as dual-signal tags, combined with signal amplification strategy of magnetic separation to reduce background signal and an enzyme-free catalytic hairpin assembly (CHA) signal amplification strategy, a novel multi-target fluorescent biosensor was fabricated to detect multiple targets based on FRET between signal tags (donors) and magnetic Fe3O4 modified graphene oxide (Fe3O4@GO, acceptors). In the presence of the target NOS and CaMV35S, the hairpin structures of H1 and H2 can be opened respectively, and the exposed sequences will hybridize with the G-rich hairpin sequences HP1 and HP2 respectively, displacing the target sequences to participate in the next round of CHA cycle. Meanwhile, H1-HP1 and H2-HP2 double-stranded DNA sequences (dsDNA) were formed, resulting in the desorption of dsDNA from the surface of Fe3O4@GO due to weak π-π interaction between dsDNA and Fe3O4@GO and leading to the fluorescence recovery of AgNCs. Under optimal conditions, the linear ranges of this fluorescence sensor were 5 ~ 300 nmol L-1 for NOS and 5 ~ 200 nmol L-1 CaMV35S, and the LODs were 0.14 nmol L-1 and 0.18 nmol L-1, respectively. In addition, the fluorescence sensor has good selectivity for the detection of NOS and CaMV35S in GM soybean samples, showing the potential applications in GM screening.

A rapid on-site visualization platform based on RPA coupled with CRISPR-Cas12a for the detection of genetically modified papaya 'Huanong No.1'

The Papaya ringspot virus (PRSV)-resistant genetically modified (GM) papaya 'Huanong No.1' has been certified as safe for consumption and widely planted in China for about 18 years. To protect consumers' rights and facilitate government supervision and monitoring, it is necessary to establish a simple, rapid, and specific detection method for 'Huanong No.1'. Herein, we developed a platform based on recombinase polymerase amplification (RPA) coupled with CRISPR-Cas12a for the detection of 'Huanong No.1'. The RPA-CRISPR-Cas12a platform was found to have high specificity, with amplification signals only present in 'Huanong No.1'. Additionally, the platform was highly sensitive, with a limit of detection (LOD) of approximately 20 copies. The detection process was fast and could be completed in less than 1 h. This novel platform enables the rapid on-site visualization detection of 'Huanong No.1', eliminating dependence on laboratory conditions and specialized instruments, and can serve as a technical reference for the rapid detection of other GM plants.

Immunoassays and Mass Spectrometry for Determination of Protein Concentrations in Genetically Modified Crops

Quantifying protein levels in genetically modified (GM) crops is crucial in every phase of development, deregulation, and seed production. Immunoassays, particularly enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay, have been the primary protein quantitation techniques for decades within the industry due to their efficiency, adaptability, and credibility. Newer immunoassay technologies like Meso Scale Discovery and Luminex offer enhanced sensitivity and multiplexing capabilities. While mass spectrometry (MS) has been widely used for small molecules and protein detection in the pharmaceutical and agricultural industries (e.g., biomarkers, endogenous allergens), its use in quantifying protein levels in GM crops has been limited. However, as trait portfolios for GM crop have expanded, MS has been increasingly adopted due to its comparable sensitivity, increased specificity, and multiplexing capabilities. This review contrasts the benefits and limitations of immunoassays and MS technologies for protein measurement in GM crops, considering factors such as cost, convenience, and specific analytical needs. Ultimately, both techniques are suitable for assessing protein concentrations in GM crops, with MS offering complementary capabilities to immunoassays. This comparison aims to provide insights into selecting between these techniques based on the user's end point needs.

Ultrasensitive and visual detection of genetically modified crops using two primers-induced cascade exponential amplification assay

The increased global cultivation area of genetically modified (GM) crops has caused severe controversies over potential health and environmental risks worldwide. There is an urgent need to verify even trace amount of a particular GM material in products. Herein, a two primers-induced cascade exponential amplification reaction combined with cationic conjugated polymers (CCPs)-based visual detection method is developed for rapid and ultrasensitive detection of GM crops. This method only uses two primers to specifically recognize the four regions of the target gene, which is easier for primer design and probably more suitable for the detection of shorter targets. By integrating the two exponential amplification reactions, as low as 5 pg genomic DNA from GM maize can be accurately detected, which is more sensitive than the single amplification-based methods. Taking advantage of the efficient fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) between CCPs and the commercial fluorescent dye SYBR Green I (SG), our method can differentiate as low as 0.01 % GM maize from a large amount of non-GM maize, which is the most accurate method so far. By changing the two primers according to target gene, our method can be modified to the detection of any other GM materials, indicating that our method is promising to be applied in other GM materials-related testing and screening system.

An outlook on the current challenges and opportunities in DNA data storage

Silicon is the gold standard for information storage systems. The exponential generation of digital information will exhaust the global supply of refined silicon. Therefore, investing in alternative information storage materials such as DNA has gained momentum. DNA as a memory material possesses several advantages over silicon-based data storage, including higher storage capacity, data retention, and lower operational energy. Routine DNA data storage approaches encode data into chemically synthesized nucleotide sequences. The scalability of DNA data storage depends on factors such as the cost and the generation of hazardous waste during DNA synthesis, latency of writing and reading, and limited rewriting capacity. Here, we review the current status of DNA data storage encoding, writing, storing, retrieving and reading, and discuss the technology's challenges and opportunities.

Aptamer-modified metal organic frameworks for measurement of food contaminants: a review

The measurement of food contaminants faces a great challenge owing to the increasing demand for safe food, increasing consumption of fast food, and rapidly changing patterns of human consumption. As different types of contaminants in food products can pose different levels of threat to human health, it is desirable to develop specific and rapid methods for their identification and quantification. During the past few years, metal-organic framework (MOF)-based materials have been extensively explored in the development of food safety sensors. MOFs are porous crystalline materials with tunable composition, dynamic porosity, and facile surface functionalization. The construction of high-performance biosensors for a range of applications (e.g., food safety, environmental monitoring, and biochemical diagnostics) can thus be promoted through the synergistic combination of MOFs with aptamers. Accordingly, this review article delineates recent innovations achieved for the aptamer-functionalized MOFs toward the detection of food contaminants. First, we describe the basic concepts involved in the detection of food contaminants in terms of the advantages and disadvantages of the commonly used analytical methods (e.g., DNA-based methods (PCR/real-time PCR/multiplex PCR/digital PCR) and protein-based methods (enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay/immunochromatography assay/immunosensor/mass spectrometry). Afterward, the progress in aptamer-functionalized MOF biosensors is discussed with respect to the sensing mechanisms (e.g., the role of MOFs as signal probes and carriers for loading signal probes) along with their performance evaluation (e.g., in terms of sensitivity). We finally discuss challenges and opportunities associated with the development of aptamer-functionalized MOFs for the measurement of food contaminants.

Collaborative Ring Trial of the Applicability of a Reference Plasmid DNA Calibrant in the Quantitative Analysis of GM Maize Event MON810

Certified reference materials (CRMs) is one of the critical requirements in a quantitative analytical method, such as in the quantification of genetically modified (GM) contents in food/feed products. Plasmid-DNA-based CRMs are becoming essential in GM content quantification. Herein, we report the construction of one plasmid DNA calibrant, pMON810, for the quantification of the GM maize event MON810 which is commercially planted and used for food/feeds worldwide, and the collaborative ring trial was used to validate its applicability. pMON10 was proven to have high specificity for the MON810 event. The limit of detection (LOD) and limit of quantification (LOQ) of real-time PCR assays of MON810 event and maize endogenous gene using pMON810 as calibrant was 2 copies/μL and 5 copies/μL, respectively. A total of eight laboratories participated in the ring trial and returned valid test results. Each sample was performed with three repeats and three parallels in each repeat. Statistical analysis of the ring trial results showed that pMON810 as a calibrant had high PCR efficiency (ranging from 0.885 to 1.008) and good linearity (ranging from 0.9933 to 0.9997) in MON810 and endogenous gene real-time PCR assays. The bias between the test values and true values ranged from 4.60 to 20.00% in the quantification of five blind samples. These results indicate that pMON810 is suitable for use as a calibrant for the quantification of MON810 events in routine lab analysis or to evaluate detection methods for MON810, as well as being used as a substitute for the matrix-based CRM of MON810.

Development of an Event-Specific Droplet Digital PCR Assay for Quantification and Evaluation of the Transgene DNAs in Trace Samples of GM PRNP-Knockout Goat

The prion protein (PRNP) gene encoding prion protein is considered a prerequisite for the occurrence of scrapie disease, and knockout of the PRNP gene in transgenic goat is one effective approach to avoid scrapie. This study aims to establish an event-specific droplet digital polymerase chain reaction (ddPCR) assay to detect and quantify the content of genetically modified (GM) PRNP-knockout goat event KoP1. The developed ddPCR assay presents high specificity, sensitivity, accuracy, precision and wide dynamic range. The limits of detection and quantification were as low as 1.44 and 7.2 haploid genome equivalent (HGE) per reaction, respectively. Furthermore, this assay was successfully applied in quantifying the goat KoP1 GM content in milk, feces and living environmental soil samples. We believe that the developed ddPCR assay has the potential to be used in the evaluation of horizontal gene transfer and the practical risk assessment of GM goat event KoP1 and its derivatives.

Rnase A Enzyme Modification of Optimized SDS Protocol for DNA Extraction Suitable for Real-Time PCR Screening of GMOs

As the number of genetically modified crops increases rapidly, their accurate detection is significant for labelling and safety assessment. Currently, real-time PCR is the “golden standard” method for GMO detection. Hence, extraction of high quality DNA represents a crucial step for accurate and efficient DNA amplification. For GMO presence evaluation in the extracted DNA from raw corn kernels and roasted soybean, we used real-time PCR method, in consistent with the ISO17025 accreditation standards. As for DNA extraction, modified basic SDS protocol by adding RNase A enzyme in different steps of the protocol, with different time and temperature of incubation was used. The results showed as most suitable, the protocol where 10 µl of RNase A enzyme was added together with the lysis buffer at 65 °C for 30 minutes. Data for DNA yield and purity for roasted soybean was 469.6±3.3 µg/ml with A260/280 absorbance ratio 1.78±0.01. Suitability of DNA extracts for GMO analysis was assessed by screening for the presence of 35S promotor and Tnos terminator. Diluted extracts in concentrations 10, 1, 0.1, 0.01 and 0.0027 ng/µl, were tested in six replicates. Positive signal of amplification (LOD) was detected in all concentrations for both genetic elements in both matrices. The LOQ for 35S and Tnos for both matrices was 0.1 ng, while for Tnos in raw corn kernels was 0.01 ng. This in-house developed DNA extraction method is simple and obtains high-quality DNA suitable for GMO screening of 35S promotor and Tnos terminator in both raw and processed matrices.

Development and evaluation of a novel loop mediated isothermal amplification coupled with TaqMan probe assay for detection of genetically modified organism with NOS terminator

In this study, we aim to develop a novel loop mediated isothermal amplification (LAMP) coupled with TaqMan (LAMP-TaqMan) method for quick qualitative detection of genetically modified organism (GMOs). We designed four LAMP primers and one TaqMan probe for the LAMP-TaqMan detection method to detect the nopaline synthase gene (NOS) terminator in GMOs. This assay enabled the amplification of DNA within ~20 min at a constant temperature of 65 °C. This assay detected as few as five copies of target sequences, which had a high specificity similar to the TaqMan qPCR method. Furthermore, the LAMP-TaqMan detection method was successfully used to amplify and detect DNA from food samples of the major crops (soybean, maize, rice, etc.). In summary, a novel LAMP-TaqMan assay has been developed, which has the similar sensitivity but takes less time than the TaqMan qPCR method. This method offers a novel approach for rapid detection of GMOs in foods.

An Event-Specific Real-Time PCR Method for Measuring Transgenic Lysozyme Goat Content in Trace Samples

Lysozymes are used in sterilisation, antisepsis, dairy additives, inflammation, and cancer. One transgenic goat line expressing high levels of human lysozyme (hLZ) in goat milk has been developed in China. Herein, we established an event-specific real-time polymerase chain reaction (real-time PCR) method to detect the transgenic hLZ goat line. The developed method has high specificity, sensitivity and accuracy, and a wide quantitative dynamic range. The limit of detection and limit of quantification was 5 and 10 copies per reaction, respectively. The practical sample analysis results showed that the method could identify and quantify transgenic lysozyme content in trace samples in routine lab analyses. Furthermore, the potential applicability in risk assessment, such as molecular characterisation and gene horizontal transfer, was confirmed. We believe that this method is suitable for the detection of transgenic hLZ goat line and its derivate.

Effect of Amount of DNA on Digital PCR Assessment of Genetically Engineered Canola and Soybean Events

Low-level detection and quantification of genetically engineered (GE) traits with polymerase chain reaction (PCR) is challenging. For unapproved GE events, any level of detection is not acceptable in some countries because of zero tolerance. Droplet digital PCR (ddPCR) has been successfully used for absolute quantification of GE events. In this study, reliability of low level quantification of GE events with ddPCR was assessed using a total of 50, 100, 200, 400, and 600 ng DNA spiked at 0.01% and 0.1% concentration levels. Genetically engineered canola (GT73 and MON88302 events) and soybean (A2704-12 and DP305423 events) events were used for the study. For samples spiked at 0.1% level, reliable quantification was achieved for the four GE events using 50 or 100 ng DNA. Few target droplets were generated for 0.01% spiked GE samples using 50 and 100 ng DNA. Increasing the amount of DNA for ddPCR generated more number of target droplets. For GE canola events, the use of 400 and 600 ng DNA for ddPCR resulted in saturation. The use of multiple wells of 200 ng DNA (instead of 400 and 600 ng per well) helped to overcome the saturation problem. Overall, the use of high amount of DNA for ddPCR was helpful for the detection and quantification of 0.01% GE samples.

Influence of Heat Processing on DNA Degradation and PCR-Based Detection of Wild-Type and Transgenic Maize

Reliable detection of genetically modified (GM) maize is significant for food authenticity, labelling, quality, and safety assessment. This study aims to evaluate the factors influencing degradation and polymerase chain reaction (PCR) amplification of DNA from the wild type and transgenic maize (events Bt-176 and MON810) during thermal treatment at 100°C and 121°C. A new PCR method was developed targeting the Cry1Ab gene to detect insect-resistant GM plants. The yield of genomic DNAs extracted by the DNeasy plant mini kit dramatically decreased while DNAs obtained by cetyltrimethyl ammonium bromide- (CTAB-) based method did not show any visible changes in the yield by the time of processing. Treatment at 100°C did not significantly affect either genomic DNAs or amplicons. Heating at 121°C induced time-dependent degradation of genomic DNAs and exogenous Cry1Ab gene; however, it did not have any considerable influence on the exogenous 141 bp amplicons or endogenous amplicons in the range of 102 bp to 226 bp with the exception of the event MON810 extracted by the DNeasy plant mini kit. More yield was observed at 226 bp than 140 bp fragment of the invertase gene. The 141 bp fragment of the transgenic CaMV 35S promoter exhibited the highest thermal stability of all the examined amplicons. Analysis of foodstuffs demonstrated 102 bp amplicons specific for the zein gene as the effective marker to detect maize in the processed foods. The obtained results demonstrate that PCR-based detection of the wild type and transgenic maize is dependent on the combination of different parameters of crucial factors such as temperature and duration of exposure, transgenic event, DNA extraction method, DNA marker, and size and location of amplicons.