Estimating the Roles of Protonation and Electronic Polarization in Absolute Binding Affinity Simulations

Isotropic Periodic Sum for Polarizable Gaussian Multipole Model

The isotropic periodic sum (IPS) method provides an efficient approach for computing long-range interactions by approximating distant molecular structures through isotropic periodic images of a local region. Here, we present a novel integration of IPS with the polarizable Gaussian multipole (pGM) model, extending its applicability to systems with Gaussian-distributed charges and dipoles. By developing and implementing the IPS multipole tensor theorem within the Gaussian multipole framework, we derive analytical expressions for IPS potentials that efficiently handle both permanent and induced multipole interactions. Our comprehensive validation includes energy conservation tests in the NVE ensemble, potential energy distributions in the NVT ensemble, structural analysis through radial distribution functions, diffusion coefficients, induced dipole calculations across various molecular systems, and ionic charging free energies. The results demonstrate that the pGM-IPS approach successfully reproduces energetic, structural, and dynamic properties of molecular systems with accuracy comparable to the traditional particle mesh Ewald method. Our work establishes pGM-IPS as a promising method for simulations of polarizable molecular systems, achieving a balance between computational efficiency and accuracy.

Enhancing MM/P(G)BSA Methods: Integration of Formulaic Entropy for Improved Binding Free Energy Calculations

Balancing computational efficiency and precision, MM/P(G)BSA methods have been widely employed in the estimation of binding free energies within biological systems. However, the entropy contribution to the binding free energy is often neglected in MM/P(G)BSA calculations, due to the computational cost of conventional methods such as normal mode analysis (NMA). In this work, the entropy effect using a formulaic entropy can be computed from one single structure according to variations in the polar and non-polar solvents accessible surface areas and the count of rotatable bonds in ligands. It was incorporated into MM/P(G)BSA methods to enhance their performance. Extensive benchmarking reveals that the integration of formulaic entropy systematically elevates the performance of both MM/PBSA and MM/GBSA without incurring additional computational expenses. In addition, we found the inclusion of dispersion can deteriorate the correlation performance (Rp) but reduce the root mean square error (RMSE) of both MM/PBSA and MM/GBSA. Notably, MM/PBSA_S, including the formulaic entropy but excluding the dispersion, surpasses all other MM/P(G)BSA methods across a spectrum of datasets. Our investigation furnishes a valuable and practical MM/P(G)BSA method, optimizing binding free energy calculations for a variety of biological systems.

Optimal Dielectric Boundary for Binding Free Energy Estimates in the Implicit Solvent

Accuracy of binding free energy calculations utilizing implicit solvent models is critically affected by parameters of the underlying dielectric boundary, specifically, the atomic and water probe radii. Here, a multidimensional optimization pipeline is used to find optimal atomic radii, specifically for binding calculations in the implicit solvent. To reduce overfitting, the optimization target includes separate, weighted contributions from both binding and hydration free energies. The resulting five-parameter radii set, OPT_BIND5D, is evaluated against experiment for binding free energies of 20 host-guest (H-G) systems, unrelated to the types of structures used in the training. The resulting accuracy for this H-G test set (root mean square error of 2.03 kcal/mol, mean signed error of -0.13 kcal/mol, mean absolute error of 1.68 kcal/mol, and Pearson's correlation of r = 0.79 with the experimental values) is on par with what can be expected from the fixed charge explicit solvent models. Best agreement with the experiment is achieved when the implicit salt concentration is set equal or close to the experimental conditions.

Assessment of Amino Acid Electrostatic Parametrizations of the Polarizable Gaussian Multipole Model

Accurate parametrization of amino acids is pivotal for the development of reliable force fields for molecular modeling of biomolecules such as proteins. This study aims to assess amino acid electrostatic parametrizations with the polarizable Gaussian Multipole (pGM) model by evaluating the performance of the pGM-perm (with atomic permanent dipoles) and pGM-ind (without atomic permanent dipoles) variants compared to the traditional RESP model. The 100-conf-combterm fitting strategy on tetrapeptides was adopted, in which (1) all peptide bond atoms (-CO-NH-) share identical set of parameters and (2) the total charges of the two terminal N-acetyl (ACE) and N-methylamide (NME) groups were set to neutral. The accuracy and transferability of electrostatic parameters across peptides with varying lengths and real-world examples were examined. The results demonstrate the enhanced performance of the pGM-perm model in accurately representing the electrostatic properties of amino acids. This insight underscores the potential of the pGM-perm model and the 100-conf-combterm strategy for the future development of the pGM force field.

AmberTools

AmberTools is a free and open-source collection of programs used to set up, run, and analyze molecular simulations. The newer features contained within AmberTools23 are briefly described in this Application note.

Transferability of the Electrostatic Parameters of the Polarizable Gaussian Multipole Model

Accuracy and transferability are the two highly desirable properties of molecular mechanical force fields. Compared with the extensively used point-charge additive force fields that apply fixed atom-centered point partial charges to model electrostatic interactions, polarizable force fields are thought to have the advantage of modeling the atomic polarization effects. Previous works have demonstrated the accuracy of the recently developed polarizable Gaussian multipole (pGM) models. In this work, we assessed the transferability of the electrostatic parameters of the pGM models with (pGM-perm) and without (pGM-ind) atomic permanent dipoles in terms of reproducing the electrostatic potentials surrounding molecules/oligomers absent from electrostatic parameterizations. Encouragingly, both the pGM-perm and pGM-ind models show significantly improved transferability than the additive model in the tests (1) from water monomer to water oligomer clusters; (2) across different conformations of amino acid dipeptides and tetrapeptides; (3) from amino acid tetrapeptides to longer polypeptides; and (4) from nucleobase monomers to Watson-Crick base pair dimers and tetramers. Furthermore, we demonstrated that the double-conformation fittings using amino acid tetrapeptides in the αR and β conformations can result in good transferability not only across different tetrapeptide conformations but also from tetrapeptides to polypeptides with lengths ranging from 1 to 20 repetitive residues for both the pGM-ind and pGM-perm models. In addition, the observation that the pGM-ind model has significantly better accuracy and transferability than the point-charge additive model, even though they have an identical number of parameters, strongly suggest the importance of intramolecular polarization effects. In summary, this and previous works together show that the pGM models possess both accuracy and transferability, which are expected to serve as foundations for the development of next-generation polarizable force fields for modeling various polarization-sensitive biological systems and processes.

The Importance of Charge Transfer and Solvent Screening in the Interactions of Backbones and Functional Groups in Amino Acid Residues and Nucleotides

Quantum mechanical (QM) calculations at the level of density-functional tight-binding are applied to a protein–DNA complex (PDB: 2o8b) consisting of 3763 atoms, averaging 100 snapshots from molecular dynamics simulations. A detailed comparison of QM and force field (Amber) results is presented. It is shown that, when solvent screening is taken into account, the contributions of the backbones are small, and the binding of nucleotides in the double helix is governed by the base–base interactions. On the other hand, the backbones can make a substantial contribution to the binding of amino acid residues to nucleotides and other residues. The effect of charge transfer on the interactions is also analyzed, revealing that the actual charge of nucleotides and amino acid residues can differ by as much as 6 and 8% from the formal integer charge, respectively. The effect of interactions on topological models (protein -residue networks) is elucidated.

Meta-Analysis Reveals That Absolute Binding Free-Energy Calculations Approach Chemical Accuracy

Systematic and quantitative analysis of the reliability of formally exact methods that in silico calculate absolute protein-ligand binding free energies remains lacking. Here, we provide, for the first time, evidence-based information on the reliability of these methods by statistically studying 853 cases from 34 different research groups through meta-analysis. The results show that formally exact methods approach chemical accuracy (error = 1.58 kcal/mol), even if people are challenging difficult tasks such as blind drug screening in recent years. The geometrical-pathway-based methods prove to possess a better convergence ability than the alchemical ones, while the latter have a larger application range. We also reveal the importance of always using the latest force fields to guarantee reliability and discuss the pros and cons of turning to an implicit solvent model in absolute binding free-energy calculations. Moreover, based on the meta-analysis, an evidence-based guideline for in silico binding free-energy calculations is provided.

Accurate Reproduction of Quantum Mechanical Many-Body Interactions in Peptide Main-Chain Hydrogen-Bonding Oligomers by the Polarizable Gaussian Multipole Model

A key advantage of polarizable force fields is their ability to model the atomic polarization effects that play key roles in the atomic many-body interactions. In this work, we assessed the accuracy of the recently developed polarizable Gaussian Multipole (pGM) models in reproducing quantum mechanical (QM) interaction energies, many-body interaction energies, as well as the nonadditive and additive contributions to the many-body interactions for peptide main-chain hydrogen-bonding conformers, using glycine dipeptide oligomers as the model systems. Two types of pGM models were considered, including that with (pGM-perm) and without (pGM-ind) permanent atomic dipoles. The performances of the pGM models were compared with several widely used force fields, including two polarizable (Amoeba13 and ff12pol) and three additive (ff19SB, ff15ipq, and ff03) force fields. Encouragingly, the pGM models outperform all other force fields in terms of reproducing QM interaction energies, many-body interaction energies, as well as the nonadditive and additive contributions to the many-body interactions, as measured by the root-mean-square errors (RMSEs) and mean absolute errors (MAEs). Furthermore, we tested the robustness of the pGM models against polarizability parameterization errors by employing alternative polarizabilities that are either scaled or obtained from other force fields. The results show that the pGM models with alternative polarizabilities exhibit improved accuracy in reproducing QM many-body interaction energies as well as the nonadditive and additive contributions compared with other polarizable force fields, suggesting that the pGM models are robust against the errors in polarizability parameterizations. This work shows that the pGM models are capable of accurately modeling polarization effects and have the potential to serve as templates for developing next-generation polarizable force fields for modeling various biological systems.

Polarization energies in the fragment molecular orbital method

Using isolated and polarized states of fragments, a method for computing the polarization energies in density functional theory (DFT) and density-functional tight-binding (DFTB) is developed in the framework of the fragment molecular orbital method. For DFTB, the method is extended into the use of periodic boundary conditions (PBC), for which a new component, a periodic self-polarization energy, is derived. The couplings of the polarization to other components in the pair interaction energy analysis (PIEDA) are derived for DFT and DFTB, and compared to Hartree-Fock and second-order Møller-Plesset perturbation theory (MP2). The effect of the self-consistent (DFT) and perturbative (MP2) treatment of the electron correlation on the polarization is discussed. The difference in the polarization in the bulk (PBC) and micro (cluster) solvation is elucidated.

Identifying the Hot Spot Residues of the SARS-CoV-2 Main Protease Using MM-PBSA and Multiple Force Fields

In this study, we investigated the binding affinities between the main protease of SARS-CoV-2 virus (Mpro) and its various ligands to identify the hot spot residues of the protease. To benchmark the influence of various force fields on hot spot residue identification and binding free energy calculation, we performed MD simulations followed by MM-PBSA analysis with three different force fields: CHARMM36, AMBER99SB, and GROMOS54a7. We performed MD simulations with 100 ns for 11 protein-ligand complexes. From the series of MD simulations and MM-PBSA calculations, it is identified that the MM-PBSA estimations using different force fields are weakly correlated to each other. From a comparison between the force fields, AMBER99SB and GROMOS54a7 results are fairly correlated while CHARMM36 results show weak or almost no correlations with the others. Our results suggest that MM-PBSA analysis results strongly depend on force fields and should be interpreted carefully. Additionally, we identified the hot spot residues of Mpro, which play critical roles in ligand binding through energy decomposition analysis. It is identified that the residues of the S4 subsite of the binding site, N142, M165, and R188, contribute strongly to ligand binding. In addition, the terminal residues, D295, R298, and Q299 are identified to have attractive interactions with ligands via electrostatic and solvation energy. We believe that our findings will help facilitate developing the novel inhibitors of SARS-CoV-2.

Recent Developments in Free Energy Calculations for Drug Discovery

The grand challenge in structure-based drug design is achieving accurate prediction of binding free energies. Molecular dynamics (MD) simulations enable modeling of conformational changes critical to the binding process, leading to calculation of thermodynamic quantities involved in estimation of binding affinities. With recent advancements in computing capability and predictive accuracy, MD based virtual screening has progressed from the domain of theoretical attempts to real application in drug development. Approaches including the Molecular Mechanics Poisson Boltzmann Surface Area (MM-PBSA), Linear Interaction Energy (LIE), and alchemical methods have been broadly applied to model molecular recognition for drug discovery and lead optimization. Here we review the varied methodology of these approaches, developments enhancing simulation efficiency and reliability, remaining challenges hindering predictive performance, and applications to problems in the fields of medicine and biochemistry.