Discovery of Potent, Highly Selective, and In Vivo Efficacious, Allosteric MALT1 Inhibitors by Iterative Scaffold Morphing

The European Federation for Medicinal Chemistry and Chemical Biology (EFMC) Best Practice Initiative: Hit to Lead

The Hit to Lead (H2L) process is an integral part of contemporary drug discovery, encompassing the optimisation of validated Hit structures into Lead molecules. High quality leads build confidence, through activity and property profiles as well as preliminary biological data, which might include validating pharmacologic hypotheses along the way, indicating that further investment in the structure(s) and target would be worthwhile. Leads have line of sight to a development candidate and bring an understanding of what priorities Lead Optimisation should address. In this set of best practices, we detail the essential criteria that characterise a good lead, which include establishing SAR from analogues and assessing preliminary DMPK indicators, selectivity and early safety parameters. We highlight the importance of identifying liabilities of the lead series and demonstrating that each can be individually modulated whilst maintaining on target potency. We make the case for having physicochemical properties as critical optimisation parameters and how ligand efficiency metrics can enable this. Then we go over general tactics that can be used to convert hits into a lead series. These include essential steps that, when performed early, increase the chance of success such as deconstructive SAR, pharmacophore and bioactive conformation determination and scaffold optimisation. Finally, we suggest decision-making criteria to substantiate confidence in further investment or, as importantly, making a recommendation to cease further work on a series.

An updated patent review of MALT1 inhibitors (2021-present)

INTRODUCTION

MALT1 paracaspase acts as a molecular scaffold and a proteolytic enzyme in immune cells. MALT1 has emerged as a promising drug target for cancer therapy, and especially for targeting MALT1 in aggressive lymphomas. Drug discovery programs have yielded potent and selective MALT1 protease inhibitors. First-in-class MALT1 inhibitors have been moved to early clinical trials to evaluate safety and efficacy.

AREAS COVERED

This review will provide an update regarding the mode of action, the chemical space and therapeutic use of MALT1 inhibitors based on recent patents and the scientific literature (05/2021-12/2024).

EXPERT OPINION

Allosteric inhibition is the preferred mode of action to inhibit the MALT1 protease. Chemical advances largely focus on improving binding and inhibition in the allosteric site of MALT1. New composition of matter has been generated, but a clinical proof for the safety and efficacy of allosteric MALT1 inhibitors is still pending. We still lack potent and selective competitive or covalent MALT1 inhibitors, indicating the challenges with targeting the active site. Further, MALT1 protein degraders and MALT1 scaffolding inhibitors have been developed, which may have distinct inhibitory profiles compared to allosteric MALT1 protease inhibitors, but more potent and selective compounds are needed to judge the feasibility and usefulness of these approaches.

MALT1 Inhibitors and Degraders: Strategies for NF-κB-Driven Malignancies

Mucosa-associated lymphoid tissue protein 1 (MALT1), a cysteine protease and the sole paracaspase in humans, plays a pivotal role in the survival and proliferation of NF-κB-dependent malignant cancers, particularly MALT lymphoma and diffuse large B-cell lymphoma (DLBCL). Dysregulated MALT1 activity is implicated in various malignancies, highlighting its importance as a therapeutic target. This Perspective provides an overview of MALT1's structural and functional characteristics, summarizes recent advancements in small-molecule inhibitors and degraders targeting this protein, and discusses compound structures, structure-activity relationship (SAR) analyses, and biological activities. We aim to inform future research efforts to enhance the activity, selectivity, and pharmacological properties of MALT1-targeting compounds, establishing a foundational framework for drug development in this critical area of cancer therapy.

Inhibition of MALT1 and BCL2 Induces Synergistic Antitumor Activity in Models of B-Cell Lymphoma

The activated B cell (ABC) subset of diffuse large B-cell lymphoma (DLBCL) is characterized by chronic B-cell receptor signaling and associated with poor outcomes when treated with standard therapy. In ABC-DLBCL, MALT1 is a core enzyme that is constitutively activated by stimulation of the B-cell receptor or gain-of-function mutations in upstream components of the signaling pathway, making it an attractive therapeutic target. We discovered a novel small-molecule inhibitor, ABBV-MALT1, that potently shuts down B-cell signaling selectively in ABC-DLBCL preclinical models leading to potent cell growth and xenograft inhibition. We also identified a rational combination partner for ABBV-MALT1 in the BCL2 inhibitor, venetoclax, which when combined significantly synergizes to elicit deep and durable responses in preclinical models. This work highlights the potential of ABBV-MALT1 monotherapy and combination with venetoclax as effective treatment options for patients with ABC-DLBCL.

Quantum-assisted fragment-based automated structure generator (QFASG) for small molecule design: an in vitro study

Introduction: The significance of automated drug design using virtual generative models has steadily grown in recent years. While deep learning-driven solutions have received growing attention, only a few modern AI-assisted generative chemistry platforms have demonstrated the ability to produce valuable structures. At the same time, virtual fragment-based drug design, which was previously less popular due to the high computational costs, has become more attractive with the development of new chemoinformatic techniques and powerful computing technologies. Methods: We developed Quantum-assisted Fragment-based Automated Structure Generator (QFASG), a fully automated algorithm designed to construct ligands for a target protein using a library of molecular fragments. QFASG was applied to generating new structures of CAMKK2 and ATM inhibitors. Results: New low-micromolar inhibitors of CAMKK2 and ATM were designed using the algorithm. Discussion: These findings highlight the algorithm's potential in designing primary hits for further optimization and showcase the capabilities of QFASG as an effective tool in this field.

Redirecting the specificity of tripartite motif containing-21 scaffolds using a novel discovery and design approach

Hijacking the ubiquitin proteasome system to elicit targeted protein degradation (TPD) has emerged as a promising therapeutic strategy to target and destroy intracellular proteins at the post-translational level. Small molecule-based TPD approaches, such as proteolysis-targeting chimeras (PROTACs) and molecular glues, have shown potential, with several agents currently in clinical trials. Biological PROTACs (bioPROTACs), which are engineered fusion proteins comprised of a target-binding domain and an E3 ubiquitin ligase, have emerged as a complementary approach for TPD. Here, we describe a new method for the evolution and design of bioPROTACs. Specifically, engineered binding scaffolds based on the third fibronectin type III domain of human tenascin-C (Tn3) were installed into the E3 ligase tripartite motif containing-21 (TRIM21) to redirect its degradation specificity. This was achieved via selection of naïve yeast-displayed Tn3 libraries against two different oncogenic proteins associated with B-cell lymphomas, mucosa-associated lymphoid tissue lymphoma translocation protein 1 (MALT1) and embryonic ectoderm development protein (EED), and replacing the native substrate-binding domain of TRIM21 with our evolved Tn3 domains. The resulting TRIM21-Tn3 fusion proteins retained the binding properties of the Tn3 as well as the E3 ligase activity of TRIM21. Moreover, we demonstrated that TRIM21-Tn3 fusion proteins efficiently degraded their respective target proteins through the ubiquitin proteasome system in cellular models. We explored the effects of binding domain avidity and E3 ligase utilization to gain insight into the requirements for effective bioPROTAC design. Overall, this study presents a versatile engineering approach that could be used to design and engineer TRIM21-based bioPROTACs against therapeutic targets.

Synthesis and biological evaluation of new series of benzamide derivatives containing urea moiety as sEH inhibitors

The pharmacological inhibition of soluble epoxide hydrolase (sEH) was shown to reduce inflammation and pain. Herein, we described a series of newly synthesized sEH inhibitors with the trident-shaped skeleton. Intensive structural modifications led to the identification of compound B15 as a potent sEH inhibitor with an IC₅₀ value of 0.03 ± 0.01 nM. Furthermore, compound B15 showed satisfactory metabolic stability in human liver microsomes with a half-time of 197 min. In carrageenan-induced inflammatory pain rat model, compound B15 exhibited a better therapeutic effect compared to t-AUCB and Celecoxib, which demonstrated the proof of potential as anti-inflammatory agents for pain relief.

Enantioselective Au(I)/Au(III) Redox Catalysis Enabled by Chiral (P,N)-Ligands

Presented herein is the first report of enantioselective Au(I)/Au(III) redox catalysis, enabled by a newly designed hemilabile chiral (P,N)-ligand (ChetPhos). The potential of this concept has been demonstrated by the development of enantioselective 1,2-oxyarylation and 1,2-aminoarylation of alkenes which provided direct access to the medicinally relevant 3-oxy- and 3-aminochromans (up to 88% yield and 99% ee). DFT studies were carried out to unravel the enantiodetermining step, which revealed that the stronger trans influence of phosphorus allows selective positioning of the substrate in the C₂-symmetric chiral environment present around nitrogen, imparting a high level of enantioselectivity.

A20 and ABIN-1 cooperate in balancing CBM complex-triggered NF-κB signaling in activated T cells

T cell activation initiates protective adaptive immunity, but counterbalancing mechanisms are critical to prevent overshooting responses and to maintain immune homeostasis. The CARD11-BCL10-MALT1 (CBM) complex bridges T cell receptor engagement to NF-κB signaling and MALT1 protease activation. Here, we show that ABIN-1 is modulating the suppressive function of A20 in T cells. Using quantitative mass spectrometry, we identified ABIN-1 as an interactor of the CBM signalosome in activated T cells. A20 and ABIN-1 counteract inducible activation of human primary CD4 and Jurkat T cells. While A20 overexpression is able to silence CBM complex-triggered NF-κB and MALT1 protease activation independent of ABIN-1, the negative regulatory function of ABIN-1 depends on A20. The suppressive function of A20 in T cells relies on ubiquitin binding through the C-terminal zinc finger (ZnF)4/7 motifs, but does not involve the deubiquitinating activity of the OTU domain. Our mechanistic studies reveal that the A20/ABIN-1 module is recruited to the CBM complex via A20 ZnF4/7 and that proteasomal degradation of A20 and ABIN-1 releases the CBM complex from the negative impact of both regulators. Ubiquitin binding to A20 ZnF4/7 promotes destructive K48-polyubiquitination to itself and to ABIN-1. Further, after prolonged T cell stimulation, ABIN-1 antagonizes MALT1-catalyzed cleavage of re-synthesized A20 and thereby diminishes sustained CBM complex signaling. Taken together, interdependent post-translational mechanisms are tightly controlling expression and activity of the A20/ABIN-1 silencing module and the cooperative action of both negative regulators is critical to balance CBM complex signaling and T cell activation.

Discovery solubility measurement and assessment of small molecules with drug development in mind

Solubility is a key physicochemical property for the success of any drug candidate. Although the methods used and their rationales for determining solubility are subject to project needs and stages along the drug discovery-drug development pipeline, an artificial boundary can exist at the discovery-development interface. This boundary results in less effective solubility knowledge sharing and data integration among scientists in both drug discovery and drug development. Herein, we present a refreshed perspective on solubility. Solubility experimentation is not a one-size-fits-all measurement; instead, we stress the importance of constructing a seamless solubility understanding of a molecule as it progresses from a new chemical entity into a drug product.

Targeting MALT1 for the treatment of diffuse large B-cell lymphoma

The activated B-cell (ABC) subtype of diffuse large B-cell lymphoma (DLBCL) has an aggressive course and is associated with poor prognosis in the relapsed or refractory setting. ABC-DLBCL is characterized by chronic active signaling of NF-κB, which is dependent on the CARD11-BCL10-MALT1 (CBM) complex. MALT1 is a key effector of the CBM complex and activates canonical NF-κB and AP-1 among other transcription factors via distinct protease and scaffold functions. There is therefore growing interest in therapeutic targeting of MALT1 for B-cell malignancies. Here, we review recent advances in therapeutic targeting of MALT1 for ABC-DLBCL. Covalent and allosteric MALT1 protease inhibitors have been developed which inhibit growth of ABC-DLBCL in preclinical models, and two clinical MALT1 protease inhibitors are being developed in phase I clinical trials. Importantly, these compounds can overcome resistance to BTK inhibitors in preclinical models. Alternative compounds blocking the scaffold effect of MALT1 are also in early preclinical development. Blockade of MALT1 protease activity may have important implications for anti-lymphoma immunity by increasing immunogenicity of ABC-DLBCL cells and also by potentiating anti-lymphoma activity of other immune cells in the lymphoma microenvironment. Together, early data suggest that MALT1 is a promising target for ABC-DLBCL and possibly other B-cell malignancies, and can have lymphoma cell-intrinsic as well as immune-mediated therapeutic effects.

Discovery and optimization of cyclohexane-1,4-diamines as allosteric MALT1 inhibitors

Inhibition of mucosa-associated lymphoid tissue lymphoma translocation protein-1 (MALT1) is a promising strategy to modulate NF-κB signaling, with the potential to treat B-cell lymphoma and autoimmune diseases. We describe the discovery and optimization of (1s,4s)-N,N'-diaryl cyclohexane-1,4-diamines, a novel series of allosteric MALT1 inhibitors, resulting in compound 8 with single digit micromolar cell potency. X-ray analysis confirms that this compound binds to an induced allosteric site in MALT1. Compound 8 is highly selective and has an excellent in vivo rat PK profile with low clearance and high oral bioavailability, making it a promising lead for further optimization.

Bioisosteres of the Phenyl Ring: Recent Strategic Applications in Lead Optimization and Drug Design

The benzene moiety is the most prevalent ring system in marketed drugs, underscoring its historic popularity in drug design either as a pharmacophore or as a scaffold that projects pharmacophoric elements. However, introspective analyses of medicinal chemistry practices at the beginning of the 21st century highlighted the indiscriminate deployment of phenyl rings as an important contributor to the poor physicochemical properties of advanced molecules, which limited their prospects of being developed into effective drugs. This Perspective deliberates on the design and applications of bioisosteric replacements for a phenyl ring that have provided practical solutions to a range of developability problems frequently encountered in lead optimization campaigns. While the effect of phenyl ring replacements on compound properties is contextual in nature, bioisosteric substitution can lead to enhanced potency, solubility, and metabolic stability while reducing lipophilicity, plasma protein binding, phospholipidosis potential, and inhibition of cytochrome P450 enzymes and the hERG channel.

A patent review of MALT1 inhibitors (2013-present)

INTRODUCTION

MALT1 is the only human paracaspase, a protease with unique cleavage activity and substrate specificity. As a key regulator of immune responses, MALT1 has attracted attention as an immune modulatory target for the treatment of autoimmune/inflammatory diseases. Further, chronic MALT1 protease activation drives survival of lymphomas, suggesting that MALT1 is a suitable drug target for lymphoid malignancies. Recent studies have indicated that MALT1 inhibition impairs immune suppressive function of regulatory T cells in the tumor microenvironment, suggesting that MALT1 inhibitors may boost anti-tumor immunity in the treatment of solid cancers.

AREAS COVERED

This review summarizes the literature on MALT1 patents and applications. We discuss the potential therapeutic uses for MALT1 inhibitors based on patents and scientific literature.

EXPERT OPINION

There has been a steep increase in MALT1 inhibitor patents. Compounds with high selectivity and good bioavailability have been developed. An allosteric binding pocket is the preferred site for potent and selective MALT1 targeting. MALT1 inhibitors have moved to early clinical trials, but toxicological studies indicate that long-term MALT1 inhibition can disrupt immune homeostasis and lead to autoimmunity. Even though this poses risks, preventing immune suppression may favor the use of MALT1 inhibitors in cancer immunotherapies.

Identification of Novel Fused Heteroaromatics-Based MALT1 Inhibitors by High-Throughput Screening to Treat B Cell Lymphoma

Development of mucosa-associated lymphoid tissue lymphoma translocation protein 1 (MALT1) inhibitors is of great value and significance in the treatment of neoplastic disorders and inflammatory and autoimmune diseases. However, there is a lack of effective MALT1 inhibitors in clinic. Herein, a novel class of potent 5-oxo-1-thioxo-4,5-dihydro-1H-thiazolo[3,4-a]quinazoline-based MALT1 inhibitors and their covalent derivatives were first identified and designed through high-throughput screening. We demonstrated that compounds 15c, 15e, and 20c effectively inhibited the MALT1 protease and displayed selective cytotoxicity to activated B cell-like diffuse large B cell lymphoma with low single-digit micromolar potency. Furthermore, compound 20c specifically repressed NF-κB signaling and induced cell apoptosis in MALT1-dependent TMD8 cells in a dose-dependent manner. More importantly, 20c showed good pharmacokinetic properties and antitumor efficacy with no significant toxicity in the TMD8 xenograft tumor model. Collectively, this study provides valuable lead compounds of MALT1 inhibitors for further structural optimization and antitumor mechanism study.

Genetic Characterization and Clinical Features of Helicobacter pylori Negative Gastric Mucosa-Associated Lymphoid Tissue Lymphoma

BACKGROUND

In Western countries, the prevalence of gastric mucosa-associated lymphoid tissue (MALT) lymphoma has declined over the last three decades. Contemporaneously, H. pylori negative gastric MALT lymphoma is increasingly encountered, and their genetic basis and clinical features remain elusive.

METHODS

A total of 57 cases of H. pylori negative gastric MALT lymphoma were reviewed and investigated for chromosome translocation by fluorescence in-situ hybridization and for somatic mutations by the targeted sequencing of 93 genes.

RESULTS

MALT1 translocation, most likely t(11;18)(q21;q21)/BIRC3-MALT1, was detected in 39% (22/57) cases, and IGH translocation was further seen in 12 MALT1-negative cases, together accounting for 60% of the cohort. Targeted sequencing was successful in 35 cases, and showed frequent mutations in NF-κB signaling pathways (TNFAIP3 = 23%, CARD11 = 9%, MAP3K14 = 9%), together affecting 14 cases (40%). The NF-κB pathway mutations were mutually exclusive from MALT1, albeit not IGH translocation, altogether occurring in 86% of cases. There was no significant correlation between the genetic changes and clinicopathological parameters. The patients showed a median of progression-free survival (PFS) of 66.3 months, and a significant superior PFS when treated with systemic versus antibiotic therapy (p = 0.004).

CONCLUSION

H. pylori negative gastric MALT lymphoma is characterized by highly frequent genetic changes in the NF-κB signaling pathways.

The Communication of Hit Quality Using Natural History Visualizations (NHVs)

High-throughput screening (HTS) often yields a list of compounds that requires prioritization before further work is performed. Prioritization criteria typically include activity, selectivity, physicochemical properties, and other absolute or calculated measurements of compound "value." One critical method of compound prioritization is often not discussed in published accounts of HTS. We have referred to this oft-overlooked metric as "compound natural history." These natural histories are observational evaluations of how a compound has been reported in the historical literature or compound databases. The purpose of this work was to develop a useful natural history visualization (NHV) that could form a standard, important part of hit reporting and evaluation. In this case report, we propose an efficient and effective NHV that will assist in the prioritization of active compounds and demonstrate its utility using a retrospective analysis of reported hits. We propose that this method of compound natural history evaluation be adopted in HTS triage and become an integral component of published reports of HTS outcomes.