Do Deep Eutectic Solvents Form Uniform Mixtures Beyond Molecular Microheterogeneities?

Examining the potential of type V DESs for the solvent extraction of metal ions

Growing interest in sustainable and efficient metal ion separation has led to the exploration of non-ionic deep eutectic solvents (DESs), also known as type V DESs, as promising alternatives to conventional organic phases in solvent extraction (SX). This work summarizes recent developments, focusing solely on the use of non-ionic DESs and excluding ionic DESs, for the separation of metal ions from synthetic and real leachates. The review does not aim to exhaustively cover all studies but focuses on the molecular mechanisms of SX, how inherent properties of DESs influence these mechanisms, and how they can be harnessed to improve the separation selectivity. It further highlights the physico-chemical properties of DESs in SX and compares them with traditional systems, emphasizing similarities and new opportunities. The overall aim is to clarify the potential and limitations of type V DESs in SX, including their often touted credentials as "green solvents", and to offer guidelines for their practical use and addressing skepticism towards novel solvents in hydrometallurgy.

Solvation Dynamics and Microheterogeneity in Deep Eutectic Solvents

Deep eutectic solvents have attracted considerable attention due to their unique properties and their potential to replace conventional solvents in diverse applications, such as catalysis, energy storage, and green chemistry. However, despite their broad use, the microscopic mechanisms governing solvation dynamics and the role of hydrogen bonding in deep eutectic solvents remain insufficiently understood. In this article, we present our contributions toward unravelling the micro heterogeneity within deep eutectic solvents by combining vibrational Stark spectroscopy and two-dimensional infrared spectroscopy with molecular dynamics simulations. Our findings demonstrate how the composition, constituents, and addition of water significantly influence the heterogeneous hydrogen bonding network and solvent dynamics within these systems. These insights provide valuable guidance for the design of next-generation solvents tailored to specific applications. By integrating experimental and computational approaches, this work sheds light on the intricate relationship between solvation dynamics and nanostructure in deep eutectic solvents, ultimately paving the way for innovative advances in solvent design.

Interplay of ethaline and water dynamics in a hydrated eutectic solvent: Deuteron and oxygen magnetic resonance studies of aqueous ethaline

For many technological processes, the impact of water addition on the properties of deep eutectic solvents is of central importance. In this context, the impact of hydration on the reorientational dynamics of the deep eutectic solvent (DES) ethaline, a 2:1 molar mixture of ethylene glycol and choline chloride, was studied. Its overall response was explored by means of shear mechanical rheology. To achieve component-selective insights into the dynamics of this material, isotope-edited deuteron and oxygen spin-lattice and spin-spin relaxometry, as well as stimulated-echo spectroscopy, were applied and yielded motional correlation times from above room temperature down to the highly viscous regime. For all temperatures, the cholinium anion was found to reorient about two times slower than ethylene glycol, while the water and the ethylene glycol molecules display very similar mobilities. While hydration enhances the component dynamics with respect to that of dry ethaline, the present findings reveal that it does not detectably increase the heterogeneity of the solvent. Merely, the time scale similarity that is found for the hydrogen bond donor and the water molecules over a particularly wide temperature range impressively attests to the stability of the native solvent structure in the "water-in-DES" regime.

Deep eutectic solvents on a tightrope: balancing the entropy and enthalpy of mixing

The large melting point depressions characterising deep eutectic solvents (DESs) are related to negative deviations from ideal mixing behaviour characterised by the excess Gibbs energy. Favourable excess Gibbs energies result from a balance between the excess entropy and enthalpy of mixing, which was experimentally determined for three choline chloride (ChCl) based mixtures using calorimetry. While the excess Gibbs energy of H2O + ChCl is enthalpy dominated, those of ethylene glycol (EG) + ChCl and 1,3-propanediol + ChCl are entropy dominated. Molecular dynamics simulations using polarisable force-fields show intermolecular hydrogen bonds between DES constituents for H2O + ChCl and EG + ChCl. Hence, inter-species hydrogen bonding does not guarantee enthalpy-dominated melting point depressions. We suggest future research to focus on tuning the entropy-enthalpy balance via the chemical nature of the DES constituents.

Viscosity effects on the dynamics of diols and diol-based deep eutectic solvents

Diols, characterized by the presence of two hydroxyl groups, form extended hydrogen-bonded networks. Increasing hydrocarbon chain length is known to elevate the viscosity of diols. Given the established influence of viscosity on solvent dynamics, it becomes imperative to comprehend the impact of viscosity on the fluctuation dynamics within diols and establish connections with hydrogen bond formation and breaking dynamics. In this study, we employ two-dimensional infrared spectroscopy to investigate the viscosity dependence of the structural evolution dynamics in three diols with varying chain lengths. Complementing our experimental approach, molecular dynamics simulations are conducted to extract hydrogen bond lifetimes. Our findings reveal a linear correlation between bulk viscosity, solvent fluctuation timescales, and hydrogen bond lifetimes. Notably, the selected diols exhibit the capability to form deep eutectic solvents upon mixing with choline chloride at specific molar ratios. In contrast to molecular solvents like diols, deep eutectic solvents are characterized by the formation of heterogeneous nanodomains, comprising various intercomponent hydrogen-bonded networks. Interestingly, our observations indicate that while the fluctuation dynamics decelerate with increasing bulk viscosity in diol-based deep eutectic solvents, the relationship between viscosity and dynamics is not linear, in contrast to the observed linearity in diols. This nuanced understanding contributes to the broader comprehension of the interplay between viscosity and dynamics in both molecular and deep eutectic solvents.

Bulk nanostructure of a deep eutectic solvent with an amphiphilic hydrogen bond donor

Neutron diffraction with empirical potential structure refinement (EPSR) show the deep eutectic solvent (DES) 1 : 4 choline chloride : butyric acid is amphiphilically nanostructured. Nanostructure results from solvophobic interactions between the alkyl chains of the butyric acid hydrogen bond donor (HBD) and is retained with addition of 10 wt% water. EPSR fits to the diffraction data is used to produce a three-dimensional model of the liquid which is interrogated to reveal the interactions leading to the solvophobic effect, and therefore nanostructure, in this DES at atomic resolution. The model shows electrostatic and hydrogen bond interactions cause the cation, anion and HBD acid group to cluster into a polar domain, from which the acid alkyl chains are solvophobically excluded into theapolar domain. The polar and apolar domains percolate through the liquid in a bicontinuous sponge-like structure. The effect of adding 10 wt% water is probed, revealing that water molecules are sequestered around the cation and anion within the polar domain, while the neat bulk structure is retained. Alkyl chain packing in the apolar domain becomes slightly better-defined indicating water marginally strengthens solvophobic segregation. These findings reveal bulk self-assembled nanostructure can be produced in DESs via an amphiphilic HBD.

A Systematic Study on the Role of Hydrogen Bond Donors in Dictating the Dynamics of Choline-Based Deep Eutectic Solvents

Deep eutectic solvents, promising green alternatives to conventional solvents, consist of a hydrogen bond donor and a hydrogen bond acceptor. The hydrogen bonding components in deep eutectic solvents form an extended hydrogen bonding network, which can be tuned to specific applications by changing the hydrogen bond donors. In this work, we have changed the hydrogen bond donor from a diol to a dicarboxylic acid by systematically replacing a hydroxyl group with an acid group one at a time to investigate the solvation structure and dynamics of the deep eutectic systems. Using a combination of ultrafast vibrational spectroscopy and molecular dynamics simulations, we compared the spectral diffusion and orientational relaxation dynamics of three deep eutectic systems using the vibrational responses of a dissolved anion. Our results indicate that although the solvation structures are marginally different across the systems, distinct differences are present in the solvent fluctuation and solute reorientation dynamics. This work provides a detailed molecular understanding of carboxylic-acid-based deep eutectic systems and how they differ from alcohol-based deep eutectic systems.

Does variation in composition affect dynamics when approaching the eutectic composition?

Deep eutectic solvent is a mixture of two or more components, mixed in a certain molar ratio, such that the mixture melts at a temperature lower than individual substances. In this work, we have used a combination of ultrafast vibrational spectroscopy and molecular dynamics simulations to investigate the microscopic structure and dynamics of a deep eutectic solvent (1:2 choline chloride: ethylene glycol) at and around the eutectic composition. In particular, we have compared the spectral diffusion and orientational relaxation dynamics of these systems with varying compositions. Our results show that although the time-averaged solvent structures around a dissolved solute are comparable across compositions, both the solvent fluctuations and solute reorientation dynamics show distinct differences. We show that these subtle changes in solute and solvent dynamics with changing compositions arise from the variations in the fluctuations of the different intercomponent hydrogen bonds.

Does Viscosity Drive the Dynamics in an Alcohol-Based Deep Eutectic Solvent?

Deep eutectic solvents, consisting of heterogeneous nanodomains of hydrogen-bonded networks, have evolved into a range of viscous fluids that find applications in several fields. As viscosity is known to influence the dynamics of other neoteric solvents like ionic liquids, understanding the effect of viscosity on deep eutectic solvents is crucial to realize their full potential. Herein, we combine polarization-selective pump-probe spectroscopy, two-dimensional infrared spectroscopy, and molecular dynamics simulations to elucidate the impact of viscosity on the dynamics of an alcohol-based deep eutectic solvent, ethaline. We compare the solvent fluctuation and solute reorientation time scales in ethaline with those in ethylene glycol, an ethaline constituent. Interestingly, we find that the solute's reorientation apparently scales the bulk viscosity of the solvent, but the same is not valid for the overall solvation dynamics. Using the variations in the estimated intercomponent hydrogen bond lifetimes, we show that a dissolved solute does not sense the bulk viscosity of the deep eutectic solvent; instead, it senses domain-specific local viscosity determined by the making and breaking of the hydrogen bond network. Our results indicate that understanding the domain-specific local environment experienced by the dissolved solute is of utmost importance in deep eutectic solvents.

An Overview of Structure and Dynamics Associated with Hydrophobic Deep Eutectic Solvents and Their Applications in Extraction Processes

Recent development of novel water-immiscible green solvents known as hydrophobic deep eutectic solvents (HDESs) has opened the gates for applications requiring media where presence of water is undesirable. Ever since they were prepared, researchers have used HDESs in diverse fields such as extraction processes, CO 2 sequestration, membrane formation, and catalysis. The microstructure and dynamics associated with the species comprising HDESs guide their suitability for specific applications. For example, varying the alkyl tail length of HDES components significantly affects the dynamics of the components and thus helps in tuning the efficiency of extraction processes. The development of HDESs is still in infancy and very few theoretical studies are available in the literature that help in understanding the structure and dynamics of HDESs. This review highlights the recent work focused on the microscopic structure and dynamics of HDESs and their potential applications, particularly in extraction processes. We have also provided a glimpse of how the integration of experiments and computational techniques can help understand the mechanism of extraction processes.

Structural and dynamical changes observed when transitioning from an ionic liquid to a deep eutectic solvent

The microscopic molecular structure and dynamics of a new deep eutectic solvent (DES) composed of an ionic liquid (1-hexyl-3-methylimidazolium chloride) and an amide (trifluoroacetamide) at various molar ratios were investigated using linear and non-linear infrared spectroscopy with a vibrational probe. The use of the ionic liquid allows us to investigate the changes that the system undergoes with the addition of the amide or, equivalently, the changes from an ionic liquid to a DES. Our studies revealed that the vibrational probe in the DES senses a very similar local environment irrespective of the cation chemical structure. In addition, the amide also appears to perceive the same molecular environment. The concentration dependence studies also showed that the amide changes from being isolated from other amides in the ionic liquid environment to an environment where the amide-amide interactions are favored. In the case of the vibrational probe, the addition of the amide produced significant changes in the slow dynamics associated with the making and breaking of the ionic cages but did not affect the rattling-in-cage motions perceived by it. Furthermore, the concentration dependence of slow dynamics showed two regimes which are linked to the changes in the overall structure of the solution. These observations are interpreted in the context of a nanoscopic heterogeneous environment in the DES which, according to the observed dynamical regimes, appears at very large concentrations of the amide (molar ratio of greater than 1:1) since for lower amide molar ratios, the amide appears to be not segregated from the ionic liquid. This proposed molecular picture is supported by small angle x-ray scattering experiments.

Tuning the solvation of indigo in aqueous deep eutectics

The solubility of synthetic indigo dye was measured at room temperature in three deep eutectic solvents (DESs)-1:3 choline chloride:1,4-butanediol, 1:3 tetrabutylammonium bromide:1,4-butanediol, and 1:2 choline chloride:p-cresol-to test the hypothesis that the structure of DESs can be systematically altered, to induce specific DES-solute interactions, and, thus, tune solubility. DESs were designed starting from the well-known cholinium chloride salt mixed with the partially amphiphilic 1,4-butanediol hydrogen bond donor (HBD), and then, the effect of increasing salt hydrophobicity (tetrabutylammonium bromide) and HBD hydrophobicity (p-cresol) was explored. Measurements were made between 2.5 and 25 wt. % H₂O, as a reasonable range representing atmospherically absorbed water, and molecular dynamics simulations were used for structural analysis. The choline chloride:1,4-butanediol DES had the lowest indigo solubility, with only the hydrophobic character of the alcohol alkyl spacers. Solubility was highest for indigo in the tetrabutylammonium bromide:1,4-butanediol DES with 2.5 wt. % H₂O due to interactions of indigo with the hydrophobic cation, but further addition of water caused this to reduce in line with the added water mole fraction, as water solvated the cation and reduced the extent of the hydrophobic region. The ChCl:p-cresol DES did not have the highest solubility at 2.5 wt. % H₂O, but did at 25 wt. % H₂O. Radial distribution functions, coordination numbers, and spatial distribution functions demonstrate that this is due to strong indigo-HBD interactions, which allow this system to resist the higher mole fraction of water molecules and retain its solubility. The DES is, therefore, a host to local-composition effects in solvation, where its hydrophobic moieties concentrate around the hydrophobic solute, illustrating the versatility of DES as solvents.

On the coupling between ionic conduction and dipolar relaxation in deep eutectic solvents: Influence of hydration and glassy dynamics

We have studied the ionic conductivity and the dipolar reorientational dynamics of aqueous solutions of a prototypical deep eutectic solvent (DES), ethaline, by dielectric spectroscopy in a broad range of frequencies (MHz-Hz) and for temperatures ranging from 128 to 283 K. The fraction of water in the DES was varied systematically to cover different regimes, starting from the pure DES and its water-in-DES mixtures to the diluted electrolyte solutions. Depending on these parameters, different physical states were examined, including low viscosity liquid, supercooled viscous liquid, amorphous solid, and freeze-concentrated solution. Both the ionic conductivity and the reorientational relaxation exhibited characteristic features of glassy dynamics that could be quantified from the deviation from the Arrhenius temperature dependence and non-exponential decay of the relaxation function. A transition occurred between the water-in-DES regime (<40 wt. %), where the dipolar relaxation and ionic conductivity remained inversely proportional to each other, and the DES-in-water regime (>40 wt. %), where a clear rotation-translation decoupling was observed. This suggests that for a low water content, on the timescale covered by this study (∼10^-6 to 1 s), the rotational and transport properties of ethaline aqueous solutions obey classical hydrodynamic scaling despite these systems being presumably spatially microheterogeneous. A fractional scaling is observed in the DES-in-water regime due to the formation of a maximally freeze-concentrated DES aqueous solution coexisting with frozen water domains at sub-ambient temperature.

Cooperative Demolition: Water's Disruption of Structures in Deep Eutectic Solvents

We report a study of cooperativity in the transition from a nonaqueous deep eutectic solvent (DES) to an aqueous solution. In some systems, a nonequilibrium region prevails at low water contents, while cooperativity is always observed at high water contents. Catechol-based mixtures exhibit a Hill constant (n_H) of ∼ 3 and an overall ΔG° of ca. -3-5 kJ/mol for the transition from DES to aqueous solution. In contrast, o-phenylenediamine-based mixtures exhibit a shift from n_H = 0 at low water contents to n_H ∼ 12 at high water contents with an overall ΔG° of ca. -13-15 kJ/mol. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first evidence for a shift from nonequilibrium to cooperative binding in a transition from nonaqueous to aqueous solutions.

Structural evolution of iron forming iron oxide in a deep eutectic-solvothermal reaction

Deep eutectic solvents (DES) and their hydrated mixtures are used for solvothermal routes towards greener functional nanomaterials. Here we present the first static structural and in situ studies of the formation of iron oxide (hematite) nanoparticles in a DES of choline chloride : urea where xurea = 0.67 (aka. reline) as an exemplar solvothermal reaction, and observe the effects of water on the reaction. The initial speciation of Fe3+ in DES solutions was measured using extended X-ray absorption fine structure (EXAFS), while the atomistic structure of the mixture was resolved from neutron and X-ray diffraction and empirical potential structure refinement (EPSR) modelling. The reaction was monitored using in situ small-angle neutron scattering (SANS), to determine mesoscale changes, and EXAFS, to determine local rearrangements of order around iron ions. It is shown that iron salts form an octahedral [Fe(L)3(Cl)3] complex where (L) represents various O-containing ligands. Solubilised Fe3+ induced subtle structural rearrangements in the DES due to abstraction of chloride into complexes and distortion of H-bonding around complexes. EXAFS suggests the complex forms [-O-Fe-O-] oligomers by reaction with the products of thermal hydrolysis of urea, and is thus pseudo-zero-order in iron. In the hydrated DES, the reaction, nucleation and growth proceeds rapidly, whereas in the pure DES, the reaction initially proceeds quickly, but suddenly slows after 5000 s. In situ SANS and static small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS) experiments reveal that nanoparticles spontaneously nucleate after 5000 s of reaction time in the pure DES before slow growth. Contrast effects observed in SANS measurements suggest that hydrated DES preferentially form 1D particle morphologies because of choline selectively capping surface crystal facets to direct growth along certain axes, whereas capping is restricted by the solvent structure in the pure DES.

Heterogeneity in hydrophobic deep eutectic solvents: SAXS prepeak and local environments

The observation of the prepeak in the simulated total X-ray scattering structure function (S(q)) reveals the presence of intermediate-range structural heterogeneity in hydrophobic deep eutectic solvents.

Connecting chloride solvation with hydration in deep eutectic systems

The Deep Eutectic Solvents (DESs) choline chloride:urea (x_ChCl = 0.33) and choline chloride:glycolic acid (x_ChCl = 0.5) were studied using viscosity-corrected ³⁵Cl NMR and MD simulations to probe the role of chloride as a function of water content.