Dynamic Duo: Vibrational Sum Frequency Scattering Investigation of pH-Switchable Carboxylic Acid/Carboxylate Surfactants on Nanodroplet Surfaces

Using the pH sensitivity of switchable surfactants to understand the role of the alkyl tail conformation and hydrogen bonding at a molecular level in elucidating emulsion stability

HYPOTHESIS

The monoalkyl diamine surfactant, N-dodecylpropane-1,3-diamine (DPDA), is expected to exhibit a pH-dependent charge switchability. In response to pH changes, the interfacial self-assembly of DPDA becomes an intermediary constituent that can potentially modify the interfacial interactions and structural assembly of both the oil and water phases. Hence, we hypothesize that as we change the pH, DPDA will respond to it by changing its charge and alkyl tail conformation as well as the conformation of adjacent phases at the molecular level, consequently affecting emulsion formation and stability. A neutral pH, resulting in a mono-cationic dialkyl amine, affects the conformation, driving an ordered self-assembly and stable emulsion.

EXPERIMENTS

The pH-sensitivity and interfacial activity of DPDA were evaluated through pH titration and interfacial tension measurements. Subsequently, a molecular-level study of DPDA, as a pH-sensitive switchable surfactant, was performed at the dodecane-water interface using SFG spectroscopy. The interpretation of the vibrational spectra was further reinforced by determining the gauche defects in the interfacial alkyl chain organization and the extent of hydrogen (H) bonding between the interfacial water molecules.

FINDINGS

By adjusting the pH of water, the charge of the adsorbed DPDA molecules, their self-assembly, the organization of interfacial molecules, and ultimately the stability of the emulsion were tuned. At pH 7.0, the SFG spectra of DPDA showed that the interfacial alkyl chains were relatively well-ordered, while water molecules also had stronger H-bonding interactions. As a result, the oil-water emulsion showed improved stability. When water was at a high pH, the water molecules had fewer H-bonding interactions and relatively disordered alkyl chains at the interface, providing desirable conditions for demulsification. These observations were compatible with the observation in bulk emulsion preparation, confirming that alkyl chain packing and water H-bonding interactions at the interface contribute to overall emulsion stability.

Bulking up: the impact of polymer sterics on emulsion stability

Encapsulation of hydrophobic active ingredients is critical for targeted drug delivery as water-insoluble drugs dominate the pharmaceutical marketplace. We previously demonstrated hexadecane-in-water emulsions stabilized with a pH-tunable polymer, poly(acrylic acid) (PAA), via a steric layer preventing particle aggregation. Using vibrational sum frequency scattering spectroscopy (VSFSS), here we probe the influence of steric hindrance on emulsion colloidal stability by tailoring the molecular weight of PAA and by adding an additional methyl group to the polymer backbone via poly(methacrylic acid) (PMAA) at pH 2, 4, and 6. At low polymer molecular weight (2 and 10 kDa), PAA adsorption is entropy driven and akin to surfactant-mediated stabilization. With 450 kDa PAA, the longer polymer chain emphasizes enthalpically favored polymer-oil interactions to initially coat the surface, and forms layers at increasing molecular weight (1000 and 4000 kDa). PMAA exhibits better oil-solubility than PAA at low concentrations but cannot accommodate the steric hindrance at higher concentrations leading to disorder. Finally, we connect our molecular-level understanding of PAA ordering with temperature-dependent dynamic light scattering experiments and observe that emulsions coated with PAA at pH 2 and 4 maintain colloidal stability from 0-90 °C, making PAA a promising polymer for hydrophobic drug delivery.

Insights into the mechanism of peptide fibril growth on gold surface

Understanding the formation of β-fibrils over the gold surface is of paramount interest in nano-bio-medicinal Chemistry. The intricate mechanism of self-assembly of neurofibrillogenic peptides and their growth over the gold surface remains elusive, as experiments are limited in unveiling the microscopic dynamic details, in particular, at the early stage of the peptide aggregation. In this work, we carried out equilibrium molecular dynamics and enhanced sampling simulations to elucidate the underlying mechanism of the growth of an amyloid-forming sequence of tau fragments over the gold surface. Our results disclose that the collective intermolecular interactions between the peptide chains and peptides with the gold surface facilitate the peptide adsorption, followed by integration, finally leading to the fibril formation.

The Surface of Colloidal Metal-Organic Framework Nanoparticles Revealed by Vibrational Sum Frequency Scattering Spectroscopy

Solvation shells strongly influence the interfacial chemistry of colloidal systems, from the activity of proteins to the colloidal stability and catalysis of nanoparticles. Despite their fundamental and practical importance, solvation shells have remained largely undetected by spectroscopy. Furthermore, their ability to assemble at complex but realistic interfaces with heterogeneous and rough surfaces remains an open question. Here, we apply vibrational sum frequency scattering spectroscopy (VSFSS), an interface-specific technique, to colloidal nanocrystals with porous metal-organic frameworks (MOFs) as a case study. Due to the porous nature of the solvent-particle boundary, MOF particles challenge conventional models of colloidal and interfacial chemistry. Their multiweek colloidal stability in the absence of conventional surface ligands suggests that stability may arise in part from solvation forces. Spectra of colloidally stable Zn(2-methylimidazolate)2 (ZIF-8) in polar solvents indicate the presence of ordered solvation shells, solvent-metal binding, and spontaneous ordering of organic bridging linkers within the MOF. These findings help explain the unexpected colloidal stability of MOF colloids, while providing a roadmap for applying VSFSS to wide-ranging colloidal nanocrystals in general.

In Situ Probing of the Surface Properties of Droplets in the Air

Surface properties of nanodroplets and microdroplets are intertwined with their immense applicability in biology, medicine, production, catalysis, the environment, and the atmosphere. However, many means for analyzing droplets and their surfaces are destructive, non-interface-specific, not conducted under ambient conditions, require sample substrates, conducted ex situ, or a combination thereof. For these reasons, a technique for surface-selective in situ analyses under any condition is necessary. This feature article presents recent developments in second-order nonlinear optical scattering techniques for the in situ interfacial analysis of aerosol droplets in the air. First, we describe the abundant utilization of such droplets across industries and how their unique surface properties lead to their ubiquitous usage. Then, we describe the fundamental properties of droplets and their surfaces followed by common methods for their study. We next describe the fundamental principles of sum-frequency generation (SFG) spectroscopy, the Langmuir adsorption model, and how they are used together to describe adsorption processes at planar liquid and droplet surfaces. We also discuss the history of developments of second-order scattering from droplets suspended in dispersive media and introduce second-harmonic scattering (SHS) and sum-frequency scattering (SFS) spectroscopies. We then go on to outline the developments of SHS, electronic sum-frequency scattering (ESFS), and vibrational sum-frequency scattering (VSFS) from droplets in the air and discuss the fundamental insights about droplet surfaces that the techniques have provided. Finally, we describe some of the areas of nonlinear scattering from airborne droplets which need improvement as well as potential future directions and utilizations of SHS, ESFS, and VSFS throughout environmental systems, interfacial chemistry, and fundamental physics. The goal of this feature article is to spread knowledge about droplets and their unique surface properties as well as introduce second-order nonlinear scattering to a broad audience who may be unaware of recent progress and advancements in their applicability.

Lysozyme Interaction with Phospholipid Nanodroplets Probed by Sum Frequency Scattering Vibrational Spectroscopy

When a nanoparticle (NP) is introduced into a biological environment, its identity and interactions are immediately attributed to the dense layer of proteins that quickly covers the particle. The formation of this layer, dubbed the protein corona, is in general a combination of proteins interacting with the surface of the NP and a contest between other proteins for binding sites either at the surface of the NP or upon the dense layer. Despite the importance for surface engineering and drug development, the molecular mechanisms and structure behind interfacial biomolecule action have largely remained elusive. We use ultrafast sum frequency scattering (SFS) spectroscopy to determine the structure and the mode of action by which these biomolecules interact with and manipulate interfaces. The majority of work in the field of sum frequency generation has been done on flat model interfaces. This limits some important membrane properties such as membrane fluidity and dimensionality─important factors in biomolecule-membrane interactions. To move toward three-dimensional (3D) nanoscopic interfaces, we utilize SFS spectroscopy to interrogate the surface of 3D lipid monolayers, which can be used as a model lipid-based nanocarrier system. In this study, we have utilized SFS spectroscopy to follow the action of lysozyme. SFS spectra in the amide I region suggest that there is lysozyme at the interface and that the lysozyme induces an increased lipid monolayer order. The binding of lysozyme with the NP is demonstrated by an increase in acyl chain order determined by the ratio of the CH₃ symmetric and CH₂ symmetric peak amplitudes. Furthermore, the lipid headgroup orientation s-PO₂^- change strongly supports lysozyme insertion into the lipid layer causing lipid disruption and reorientation. Altogether, with SFS, we have made a huge stride toward understanding the binding and structure change of proteins within the protein corona.

Molecular Orientation of Carboxylate Anions at the Water-Air Interface Studied with Heterodyne-Detected Vibrational Sum-Frequency Generation

The carboxylate anion group plays an important role in many (bio)chemical systems and polymeric materials. In this work, we study the orientation of carboxylate anions with various aliphatic and aromatic substituents at the water-air interface by probing the carboxylate stretch vibrations with heterodyne-detected vibrational sum-frequency generation spectroscopy in different polarization configurations. We find that carboxylate groups with small aliphatic substituents show a large tilt angle with respect to the surface normal and that this angle decreases with increasing size of the substituent. We further use the information about the orientation of the carboxylate group to determine the hyperpolarizability components of this group.

Peptide Orientation at Emulsion Nanointerfaces Dramatically Different from Flat Surfaces

The adsorption of protein to nanoparticles plays an important role in toxicity, food science, pharmaceutics, and biomaterial science. Understanding how proteins bind to nanophase surfaces is instrumental for understanding and, ultimately, controlling nanoparticle (NP) biochemistry. Techniques probing the adsorption of proteins at NP interfaces exist; however, these methods have been unable to determine the orientation and folding of proteins at these interfaces. For the first time, we probe in situ with sum frequency scattering vibrational spectroscopy the orientation of model leucine-lysine (LK) peptides adsorbed to NPs. The results show that both α-helical and β-strand LK peptides bind the particles in an upright orientation, in contrast to the flat orientation of LKs binding to planar surfaces. The different binding geometry is explained by Coulombic forces between peptides across the particle volume.

In Situ Detection of Chemical Compositions at Nanodroplet Surfaces and In-Nanodroplet Phases

Small-volume nanodroplets play an increasingly common role in chemistry and biology. Such nanodroplets are believed to have unique chemical and physical properties at the interface between a droplet and its surrounding medium, however, they are underexamined. In this study, we present the novel technique of vibrational sum frequency scattering (VSFS) spectroscopy as an interface-specific, high-performance method for the in situ investigation of nanodroplets with sub-micron radii; as well as the droplet bulk through simultaneous hyper-Raman scattering (HRS) spectroscopy. We use laboratory-generated nanodroplets from aqueous alcohol solutions to demonstrate this technique's ability to separate the vibrational phenomena which take place at droplet surfaces from the underlying bulk phase. In addition, we systemically examine interfacial spectra of nanodroplets containing methanol, ethanol, 1-propanol, and 1-butanol through VSFS. Furthermore, we demonstrate interfacial differences between such nanodroplets and their analogous planar surfaces. The sensitivity of this technique to probe droplet surfaces with few-particle density at standard conditions validates VSFS as an analytical technique for the in situ investigation of small nanodroplets, providing breakthrough information about these species of ever-increasing relevance.

Considerations in upconversion: A practical guide to sum-frequency generation spectrometer design and implementation

In this tutorial review, we discuss how the choice of upconversion pulse shape in broadband vibrational sum-frequency generation (SFG) spectrometer design impacts the chemical or physical insights one can obtain from a set of measurements. A time-domain picture of a vibrational coherence being mapped by a second optical field is described and the implications of how this mapping, or upconversion process, takes place are given in the context of several popular and emerging approaches found in the literature. Emphasis is placed on broadband frequency-domain measurements, where the choice of upconversion pulse enhances or limits the information contained in the SFG spectrum. We conclude with an outline for a flexible approach to SFG upconversion using pulse-shaping methods and a simple guide to design and optimize the associated instrumentation.

Interfacial Steric and Molecular Bonding Effects Contributing to the Stability of Neutrally Charged Nanoemulsions

In cosmetic, pharmaceutical, and food applications, many active ingredients have limited bioavailability in an aqueous environment, and in that context, nanoemulsions provide a mechanism for encapsulation, protection, and transport. These dispersed oil droplets are on the order of 100s of nanometers in diameter and owe their long-term stability to emulsifiers that are commonly charged. More recently, applications have been utilizing nonionic species as stabilizing agents due to their enhanced biosafety. DLVO (named after Derjaguin, Landau, Verwey, and Overbeek) theory has been central in the description of colloid stability, which emphasizes repulsive electrostatic forces, while extended DLVO theory also accounts for steric effects. Past studies of nanoemulsions have largely employed charged surfactants and polyelectrolytes, making it difficult to decouple electrostatic and steric effects as they relate to droplet stability. To better understand steric and molecular factors contributing to the stability of "uncharged" droplets, we have created nanoemulsions with sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS) and poly(N-vinylacetamide) (PNVA). Though SDS is anionic, with PNVA coating the droplet surfaces, the ζ-potentials of these nanoemulsions are ∼0 mV. Despite minimizing electrostatic contributions, these nanoemulsions are stable for upward of a month with interesting dynamics. By employing dynamic light scattering, vibrational sum frequency scattering spectroscopy, and calculating interaction pair potentials using extended DLVO theory, we learn that the thickness of the PNVA layer plays a critical role in stabilizing these "uncharged" nanoemulsions. Beyond the sterics, the molecular conformation of the PNVA strands also contributes to the droplet stability. The adsorbed PNVA strands are shown to form stratified, rigid polymer networks that prevent the nanoemulsions from rapid destabilization.