The Thermodynamics of Anion Complexation to Nonpolar Pockets

Anion-Facilitated Hydrogen-Deuterium Exchange as a Tool to Probe Weak Anion-Protein Interactions Responsible for Hofmeister Effects

Impeded by the complexity of proteinaceous structure and the very weak nature of the noncovalent interactions involved, the detailed mechanisms by which anions induce salting-in Hofmeister effects in proteins and peptides remain unclear. Here, using β-hairpin peptides as models, we examine two approaches to qualify (map) anion binding: 1H NMR chemical shifts and hydronium-catalyzed hydrogen-deuterium exchange (HDX) rate changes. We demonstrate that each salt investigated─despite an affinity too weak to quantify accurately, caused denaturation to an extent that is both peptide and anion-specific, with more charge-diffuse anions inducing a greater degree of unfolding. Our studies reveal that the HDX mapping provides more detail than chemical shift data. Thus, HDX mapping reveals two slightly different mechanisms of denaturation, depending on the nature of the anion. Namely, assisted by a N-terminal Arg residue, charge-dense Cl- is chelated by the terminal N-H groups of the hairpin and induces a small degree of denaturation, whereas charge-diffuse anions intercalate deeply into the cation-π-hydrophobic core of the peptide and induce more substantial unfolding. These findings provide a glimpse of the different mechanisms by which anions can induce the salting-in Hofmeister effect in peptides and proteins and suggest HDX as a useful tool to map weak anion binding.

Complexity associated with caprylate binding to bovine serum albumin: Dimerization, allostery, and variance between the change in free energy and enthalpy of binding

Isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC), differential scanning calorimetry (DSC), and pressure perturbation calorimetry (PPC) were used to study different aspects of the diverse interaction between the fatty acid caprylate and bovine serum albumin (BSA). The ITC thermogram was consistent with exothermic binding to a single site on BSA, which was electrostatic but had little or no hydrophobic contribution. ITC revealed that small changes to solution conditions and temperature were associated with apparent enthalpy-entropy compensation, causing large changes in enthalpy (ΔH) during binding, but with little corresponding changes in free energy (ΔG). ITC also detected a slower endothermic interaction at a low mole ratio. Dynamic light scattering suggested that this was due to dimerization or similar self-association. DSC demonstrated that further interactions took place at higher mole ratios. This was consistent with weak binding of caprylate to multiple binding sites which had a considerable impact on the structural conformation of BSA. PPC showed that the conformational change of BSA was accompanied with a reduction in surface hydrophobicity of the protein. PPC also demonstrated that in solution caprylate's hydrocarbon tail is hidden from water as no clathrate-like water is evident, which is consistent with the lack of hydrophobic contribution during binding. Cumulatively, the three calorimetric techniques offer a comprehensive view of caprylate and BSA interactions, highlighting the role of electrostatic interaction in binding accompanied by probably dimerization and considerable structural change associated with weaker binding to BSA.

Assessing Weak Anion Binding to Small Peptides

Since Hofmeister's seminal studies in the late 19th century, it has been known that salts and buffers can drastically affect the properties of peptides and proteins. These Hofmeister effects can be conceived of in terms of three distinct phenomena/mechanisms: water-salt interactions that indirectly induce the salting-out of a protein by water sequestration by the salt, and direct salt-protein interactions that can either salt-in or salt-out the protein. Unfortunately, direct salt-protein interactions responsible for Hofmeister effects are weak and difficult to quantify. As such, they are frequently construed of as being nonspecific. Nevertheless, there has been considerable effort to better specify these interactions. Here, we use pentapeptides to demonstrate the utility of the H-dimension of nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy to assess anion binding using N-H signal shifts. We qualify binding using these, demonstrating the upfield shifts induced by anion association and revealing how they are much larger than the corresponding downfield shifts induced by magnetic susceptibility and other ionic strength change effects. We also qualify binding in terms of how the pattern of signal shifts changes with point mutations. In general, we find that the observed upfield shifts are small compared with those induced by anion binding to amide-based hosts, and MD simulations suggest that this is so. Thus, charge-diffuse anions associate mostly with the nonpolar regions of the peptide rather than directly interacting with the amide N-H groups. These findings reveal the utility of 1H NMR spectroscopy for qualifying affinity to peptides─even when affinity constants are very low─and serve as a benchmark for using NMR spectroscopy to study anion binding to more complex systems.

Large anion binding in water

Large water-soluble anions with chaotropic character display surprisingly strong supramolecular interactions in water, for example, with macrocyclic receptors, polymers, biomembranes, and other hydrophobic cavities and interfaces. The high affinity is traced back to a hitherto underestimated driving force, the chaotropic effect, which is orthogonal to the common hydrophobic effect. This review focuses on the binding of large anions with water-soluble macrocyclic hosts, including cyclodextrins, cucurbiturils, bambusurils, biotinurils, and other organic receptors. The high affinity of large anions to molecular receptors has been implemented in several lines of new applications, which are highlighted herein.

On the Nature of Guest Complexation in Water: Triggered Wetting-Water-Mediated Binding

The complexity of macromolecular surfaces means that there are still many open questions regarding how specific areas are solvated and how this might affect the complexation of guests. Contributing to the identification and classification of the different possible mechanisms of complexation events in aqueous solution, and as part of the recent SAMPL8 exercise, we report here on the synthesis and conformational properties of TEEtOA 2, a cavitand with conformationally flexible ethyl groups at its portal. Using a combination of ITC and NMR spectroscopy, we report the binding affinities of a series of carboxylates to 2 and compare it to a related cavitand TEMOA 1. Additionally, we report MD simulations revealing how the wetting of the pocket of 2 is controlled by the conformation of its rim ethyl groups and, correspondingly, a novel triggered wetting, guest complexation mechanism, whereby the approaching guest opens up the pocket of the host, inducing its wetting and ultimately allows the formation of a hydrated host-guest complex (H·G·H2O). A general classification of complexation mechanisms is also suggested.

Molecular Probes, Chemosensors, and Nanosensors for Optical Detection of Biorelevant Molecules and Ions in Aqueous Media and Biofluids

Synthetic molecular probes, chemosensors, and nanosensors used in combination with innovative assay protocols hold great potential for the development of robust, low-cost, and fast-responding sensors that are applicable in biofluids (urine, blood, and saliva). Particularly, the development of sensors for metabolites, neurotransmitters, drugs, and inorganic ions is highly desirable due to a lack of suitable biosensors. In addition, the monitoring and analysis of metabolic and signaling networks in cells and organisms by optical probes and chemosensors is becoming increasingly important in molecular biology and medicine. Thus, new perspectives for personalized diagnostics, theranostics, and biochemical/medical research will be unlocked when standing limitations of artificial binders and receptors are overcome. In this review, we survey synthetic sensing systems that have promising (future) application potential for the detection of small molecules, cations, and anions in aqueous media and biofluids. Special attention was given to sensing systems that provide a readily measurable optical signal through dynamic covalent chemistry, supramolecular host-guest interactions, or nanoparticles featuring plasmonic effects. This review shall also enable the reader to evaluate the current performance of molecular probes, chemosensors, and nanosensors in terms of sensitivity and selectivity with respect to practical requirement, and thereby inspiring new ideas for the development of further advanced systems.

Weakly hydrated anions bind to polymers but not monomers in aqueous solutions

Weakly hydrated anions help to solubilize hydrophobic macromolecules in aqueous solutions, but small molecules comprising the same chemical constituents precipitate out when exposed to these ions. Here, this apparent contradiction is resolved by systematically investigating the interactions of NaSCN with polyethylene oxide oligomers and polymers of varying molecular weight. A combination of spectroscopic and computational results reveals that SCN^- accumulates near the surface of polymers, but is excluded from monomers. This occurs because SCN^- preferentially binds to the centre of macromolecular chains, where the local water hydrogen-bonding network is disrupted. These findings suggest a link between ion-specific effects and theories addressing how hydrophobic hydration is modulated by the size and shape of a hydrophobic entity.

Chaotropic and Kosmotropic Anions Regulate the Outcome of Enzyme-Mediated Dynamic Combinatorial Libraries of Cyclodextrins in Two Different Ways

We demonstrate how different anions from across the Hofmeister series can influence the behavior of enzyme-mediated dynamic combinatorial libraries of cyclodextrins (CDs). Using cyclodextrin glucanotransferase to catalyze reversible transglycosylation, dynamic mixtures of interconverting cyclodextrins can be formed wherein the relative concentrations of α-CD, β-CD and γ-CD is determined by their intrinsic stabilities and any stabilizing influences of added template (guest) molecules. Here, we find that addition of high concentrations of kosmotropic anions can be used to enhance the effects of added hydrophobic templates, while chaotropic anions can themselves act as templates, causing predictable and significant changes in the cyclodextrin composition due to weak, but specific, binding interactions with α-CD.

Cavitand Complexes in Aqueous Solution: Collaborative Experimental and Computational Studies of the Wetting, Assembly, and Function of Nanoscopic Bowls in Water

Water is the dominant liquid on Earth. Despite this, the main focus of supramolecular chemistry research has been on binding and assembly events in organic solvents. This arose because it is more straightforward to synthesize organic-media-soluble hosts and because of the relative simplicity of organic solvents compared to water. Nature, however, relies on water as a solvent, and spurred by this fact, supramolecular chemists have recently been making forays into the aqueous domain to understand water-mediated non-covalent interactions. These studies can benefit from the substantial understanding of the hydrophobic effect and electrostatic interactions developed by physical chemists. Nearly 20 years ago, the Gibb group first synthesized a class of water-soluble host molecules, the deep-cavity cavitands, that possess non-polar pockets that readily bind non-polar moieties in aqueous solution and are capable of assembling into a wide range of complexes with distinct stoichiometries. As such, these amphipathic host species are ideal platforms for studying the role of negatively curved features on guest complexation and the structural requirements for guided assembly processes driven by the hydrophobic effect. Here we review the collaborative experimental and computational investigations between Gibb and Ashbaugh over the past 10 years exploring questions including the following: How does water wet/solvate the non-polar surfaces of non-polar pockets? How does this wetting control the binding of non-polar guests? How does wetting affect the binding of anionic species? How does the nature and size of a guest size impact the assembly of cavitand hosts into multimeric capsular complexes? What are the conformational motifs of guests packed within the confines of capsular complexes? How might the electrostatic environment engendered by hosts impact the properties and reactivity of internalized guests?

A neutral porous organic polymer host for the recognition of anionic dyes in water

Neutral hosts for the recognition of anionic guests in water remain underdeveloped due to the inherent thermodynamic barrier for desolvation. To address this challenge, we have repurposed crosslinked porous organic polymers (POPs) as hosts. This polymer architecture affords a hydrophobic environment with a densely packed array of urea hydrogen bond donors to cooperatively promote anion desolvation and recognition in water. Using the principles of supramolecular design, we demonstrate through adsorption assays that the resulting Urea-POP-1 can recognize structurally different dyes containing phosphonate, sulfonate, and carboxylate anions in water. Moreover, when compared to Methyl-POP-1, a control POP lacking hydrogen bond donors, we find that the driving force for desolvation and adsorption of each dye is achieved through hydrophobic interactions with the POP backbone and, more importantly, cooperative hydrogen bonding interactions with the urea sidechains. This starting point sets the stage to exploit the modularity of our design to build a family of neutral polymer hosts with tunable pore sizes and anion preferences for fundamental investigations and targeted applications.

Spontaneous drying of non-polar deep-cavity cavitand pockets in aqueous solution

There are many open questions regarding the hydration of solvent-exposed non-polar tracts and pockets in proteins. Although water is predicted to de-wet purely repulsive surfaces and evacuate crevices, the extent of de-wetting is unclear when ubiquitous van der Waals interactions are in play. The structural simplicity of synthetic supramolecular hosts imbues them with considerable potential to address this issue. To this end, here we detail a combination of densimetry and molecular dynamics simulations of three cavitands, coupled with calorimetric studies of their complexes with short-chain carboxylates. Our results reveal the range of wettability possible within the ostensibly identical cavitand pockets-which differ only in the presence and/or position of the methyl groups that encircle the portal to their non-polar pockets. The results demonstrate the ability of macrocycles to template water cavitation within their binding sites and show how the orientation of methyl groups can trigger the drying of non-polar pockets in liquid water, which suggests new avenues to control guest complexation.

Gas-Phase Fragmentation of Host-Guest Complexes of Cyclodextrins and Polyoxometalates

Gas-phase fragmentation pathways of host-guest complexes of cyclodextrins (CDs) and polyoxometalates (POMs) were examined using collision-induced dissociation (CID). The host-guest complexes studied here were composed of two different classes of POMs-Keggin (PW₁₂O₄₀^3-) and Lindqvist (M₆O₁₉^2-, M = Mo, W)-and three types of CDs (α-, β-, and γ-CD) differing in the diameter of the inner cavity. The CD-POM complexes were generated either by mixing methanol solutions of POM and CD or through a one-step acidic condensation of tetraoxometalates MO₄^2- (M = Mo, W) with CDs for complexes with Keggin and Lindqvist anions, respectively, and introduced into the gas phase using electrospray ionization (ESI). We observe distinct differences in fragmentation pathways of the complexes of Keggin and Lindqvist POMs under high- and low-energy CID conditions. Specifically, direct dissociation and proton transfer from CD to POM accompanied by the separation of fragments is observed in CID of Keggin CD-POM complexes. In contrast, dissociation of CD complexes with Lindqvist POMs is dominated by the simultaneous loss of multiple water molecules. This unusual fragmentation channel is attributed to dissociation of the POM cluster inside the CD cavity accompanied by covalent bond formation between the fragments and CD and elimination of multiple water molecules. The observed covalent coupling of metal oxide clusters opens up opportunities for derivatization of macrocyclic host molecules using collisional excitation of gaseous non-covalent complexes.

The Hofmeister series: Specific ion effects in aqueous polymer solutions

Specific ion effects in aqueous polymer solutions have been under active investigation over the past few decades. The current state-of-the-art research is primarily focused on the understanding of the mechanisms through which ions interact with macromolecules and affect their solution stability. Hence, we herein first present the current opinion on the sources of ion-specific effects and review the relevant studies. This includes a summary of the molecular mechanisms through which ions can interact with polymers, quantification of the affinity of ions for the polymer surface, a thermodynamic description of the effects of salts on polymer stability, as well as a discussion on the different forces that contribute to ion-polymer interplay. Finally, we also highlight future research issues that call for further scrutiny. These include fundamental questions on the mechanisms of ion-specific effects and their correlation with polymer properties as well as a discussion on the specific ion effects in more complex systems such as mixed electrolyte solutions.

Stackable molecular chairs

Molecular chairs, carrying three amino acids or peptides, stack in an antiparallel fashion to give hexavalent assemblies for bottom-up construction of novel soft materials and therapeutics.

The Chaotropic Effect as an Assembly Motif in Chemistry

Following up on scattered reports on interactions of conventional chaotropic ions (for example, I- , SCN- , ClO4- ) with macrocyclic host molecules, biomolecules, and hydrophobic neutral surfaces in aqueous solution, the chaotropic effect has recently emerged as a generic driving force for supramolecular assembly, orthogonal to the hydrophobic effect. The chaotropic effect becomes most effective for very large ions that extend beyond the classical Hofmeister scale and that can be referred to as superchaotropic ions (for example, borate clusters and polyoxometalates). In this Minireview, we present a continuous scale of water-solute interactions that includes the solvation of kosmotropic, chaotropic, and hydrophobic solutes, as well as the creation of void space (cavitation). Recent examples for the association of chaotropic anions to hydrophobic synthetic and biological binding sites, lipid bilayers, and surfaces are discussed.

Thermodynamics of Anion Binding by Chalcogen Bonding Receptors

The application of chalcogen bonding (ChB) to anion recognition is an underdeveloped area of host-guest supramolecular chemistry. The chemical instability of heavier chalcogen derivatives may in part be responsible for the lack of progress. Herein, the synthesis of a new structurally simple, tellurium-based ChB binding motif is reported, the robust stability of which has enabled the thermodynamic properties for ChB halide anion binding in polar aprotic and wet protic organic solvent media to be elucidated. The thermodynamic data reveals how the subtle interplay between ChB host, anion guest and solvent dictates halide binding selectivity and affinity trends. These findings help to provide a deeper insight into the nature of the ChB-anion interaction.