Spectroscopic Evidence of Reversible Disassembly of the [FeFe] Hydrogenase Active Site

A Beginner’s Guide to Thermodynamic Modelling of [FeFe] Hydrogenase

[FeFe] hydrogenases, which are considered the most active naturally occurring catalysts for hydrogen oxidation and proton reduction, are extensively studied as models to learn the important features for efficient H2 conversion catalysis. Using infrared spectroscopy as a selective probe, the redox behaviour of the active site H-cluster is routinely modelled with thermodynamic schemes based on the Nernst equation for determining thermodynamic parameters, such as redox midpoint potentials and pKa values. Here, the thermodynamic models usually applied to [FeFe] hydrogenases are introduced and discussed in a pedagogic fashion and their applicability to additional metalloenzymes and molecular catalysts is also addressed.

Temperature Dependence of Structural Dynamics at the Catalytic Cofactor of [FeFe]-hydrogenase

[FeFe]-hydrogenases are nature's blueprint for efficient hydrogen turnover. Understanding their enzymatic mechanism may improve technological H₂ fuel generation. The active-site cofactor (H-cluster) consists of a [4Fe-4S] cluster ([4Fe]_H), cysteine-linked to a diiron site ([2Fe]_H) carrying an azadithiolate (adt) group, terminal cyanide and carbon monoxide ligands, and a bridging carbon monoxide (μCO) in the oxidized protein (Hox). Recently, the debate on the structure of reduced H-cluster states was intensified by the assignment of new species under cryogenic conditions. We investigated temperature effects (4-280 K) in infrared (IR) and X-ray absorption spectroscopy (XAS) data of [FeFe]-hydrogenases using fit analyses and quantum-chemical calculations. IR data from our laboratory and literature sources were evaluated. At ambient temperatures, reduced H-cluster states with a bridging hydride (μH^-, in Hred and Hsred) or with an additional proton at [4Fe]_H (Hred') or at the distal iron of [2Fe]_H (Hhyd) prevail. At cryogenic temperatures, these species are largely replaced by states that hold a μCO, lack [4Fe]_H protonation, and bind an additional proton at the adt nitrogen (HredH⁺ and HsredH⁺). XAS revealed the atomic coordinate dispersion (i.e., the Debye-Waller parameter, 2σ²) of the iron-ligand bonds and Fe-Fe distances in the oxidized and reduced H-cluster. 2σ² showed a temperature dependence typical for the so-called protein-glass transition, with small changes below ∼200 K and a pronounced increase above this "breakpoint". This behavior is attributed to the freezing-out of larger-scale anharmonic motions of amino acid side chains and water species. We propose that protonation at [4Fe]_H as well as ligand rearrangement and μH^- binding at [2Fe]_H are impaired because of restricted molecular mobility at cryogenic temperatures so that protonation can be biased toward adt. We conclude that a H-cluster with a μCO, selective [4Fe]_H or [2Fe]_H protonation, and catalytic proton transfer via adt facilitates efficient H₂ conversion in [FeFe]-hydrogenase.

Caught in the Hinact : Crystal Structure and Spectroscopy Reveal a Sulfur Bound to the Active Site of an O2 -stable State of [FeFe] Hydrogenase

[FeFe] hydrogenases are the most active H2 converting catalysts in nature, but their extreme oxygen sensitivity limits their use in technological applications. The [FeFe] hydrogenases from sulfate reducing bacteria can be purified in an O2 -stable state called Hinact . To date, the structure and mechanism of formation of Hinact remain unknown. Our 1.65 Å crystal structure of this state reveals a sulfur ligand bound to the open coordination site. Furthermore, in-depth spectroscopic characterization by X-ray absorption spectroscopy (XAS), nuclear resonance vibrational spectroscopy (NRVS), resonance Raman (RR) spectroscopy and infrared (IR) spectroscopy, together with hybrid quantum mechanical and molecular mechanical (QM/MM) calculations, provide detailed chemical insight into the Hinact state and its mechanism of formation. This may facilitate the design of O2 -stable hydrogenases and molecular catalysts.

[FeFe]-hydrogenase maturation: H-cluster assembly intermediates tracked by electron paramagnetic resonance, infrared, and X-ray absorption spectroscopy

[FeFe]-hydrogenase enzymes employ a unique organometallic cofactor for efficient and reversible hydrogen conversion. This so-called H-cluster consists of a [4Fe-4S] cubane cysteine linked to a diiron complex coordinated by carbon monoxide and cyanide ligands and an azadithiolate ligand (adt = NH(CH2S)2)·[FeFe]-hydrogenase apo-protein binding only the [4Fe-4S] sub-complex can be fully activated in vitro by the addition of a synthetic diiron site precursor complex ([2Fe]adt). Elucidation of the mechanism of cofactor assembly will aid in the design of improved hydrogen processing synthetic catalysts. We combined electron paramagnetic resonance, Fourier-transform infrared, and X-ray absorption spectroscopy to characterize intermediates of H-cluster assembly as initiated by mixing of the apo-protein (HydA1) from the green alga Chlamydomonas reinhardtii with [2Fe]adt. The three methods consistently show rapid formation of a complete H-cluster in the oxidized, CO-inhibited state (Hox-CO) already within seconds after the mixing. Moreover, FTIR spectroscopy support a model in which Hox-CO formation is preceded by a short-lived Hred'-CO-like intermediate. Accumulation of Hox-CO was followed by CO release resulting in the slower conversion to the catalytically active state (Hox) as well as formation of reduced states of the H-cluster.

Loss of Specific Active-Site Iron Atoms in Oxygen-Exposed [FeFe]-Hydrogenase Determined by Detailed X-ray Structure Analyses

The [FeFe]-hydrogenases catalyze the uptake and evolution of hydrogen with unmatched speed at low overpotential. However, oxygen induces the degradation of the unique [6Fe-6S] cofactor within the active site, termed the H-cluster. We used X-ray structural analyses to determine possible modes of irreversible oxygen-driven inactivation. To this end, we exposed crystals of the [FeFe]-hydrogenase CpI from Clostridium pasteurianum to oxygen and quantitatively investigated the effects on the H-cluster structure over several time points using multiple data sets, while correlating it to decreases in enzyme activity. Our results reveal the loss of specific Fe atoms from both the diiron (2Fe_H) and the [4Fe-4S] subcluster (4Fe_H) of the H-cluster. Within the 2Fe_H, the Fe atom more distal to the 4Fe_H is strikingly more affected than the more proximal Fe atom. The 4Fe_H interconverts to a [2Fe-2S] cluster in parts of the population of active CpI^ADT, but not in crystals of the inactive apoCpI initially lacking the 2Fe_H. We thus propose two parallel processes: dissociation of the distal Fe atom and 4Fe_H interconversion. Both pathways appear to play major roles in the oxidative damage of [FeFe]-hydrogenases under electron-donor deprived conditions probed by our experimental setup.

The final steps of [FeFe]-hydrogenase maturation

The active site (H-cluster) of [FeFe]-hydrogenases is a blueprint for the design of a biologically inspired H₂-producing catalyst. The maturation process describes the preassembly and uptake of the unique [2Fe_H] cluster into apo-hydrogenase, which is to date not fully understood. In this study, we targeted individual amino acids by site-directed mutagenesis in the [FeFe]-hydrogenase CpI of Clostridium pasteurianum to reveal the final steps of H-cluster maturation occurring within apo-hydrogenase. We identified putative key positions for cofactor uptake and the subsequent structural reorganization that stabilizes the [2Fe_H] cofactor in its functional coordination sphere. Our results suggest that functional integration of the negatively charged [2Fe_H] precursor requires the positive charges and individual structural features of the 2 basic residues of arginine 449 and lysine 358, which mark the entrance and terminus of the maturation channel, respectively. The results obtained for 5 glycine-to-histidine exchange variants within a flexible loop region provide compelling evidence that the glycine residues function as hinge positions in the refolding process, which closes the secondary ligand sphere of the [2Fe_H] cofactor and the maturation channel. The conserved structural motifs investigated here shed light on the interplay between the secondary ligand sphere and catalytic cofactor.

Engineering an [FeFe]-Hydrogenase: Do Accessory Clusters Influence O2 Resistance and Catalytic Bias?

[FeFe]-hydrogenases, HydAs, are unique biocatalysts for proton reduction to H₂. However, they suffer from a number of drawbacks for biotechnological applications: size, number and diversity of metal cofactors, oxygen sensitivity. Here we show that HydA from Megasphaera elsdenii (MeHydA) displays significant resistance to O₂. Furthermore, we produced a shorter version of this enzyme (MeH-HydA), lacking the N-terminal domain harboring the accessory FeS clusters. As shown by detailed spectroscopic and biochemical characterization, MeH-HydA displays the following interesting properties. First, a functional active site can be assembled in MeH-HydA in vitro, providing the enzyme with excellent hydrogenase activity. Second, the resistance of MeHydA to O₂ is conserved in MeH-HydA. Third, MeH-HydA is more biased toward proton reduction than MeHydA, as the result of the truncation changing the rate limiting steps in catalysis. This work shows that it is possible to engineer HydA to generate an active hydrogenase that combines the resistance of the most resistant HydAs and the simplicity of algal HydAs, containing only the H-cluster.

Spectroscopic investigations of a semi-synthetic [FeFe] hydrogenase with propane di-selenol as bridging ligand in the binuclear subsite: comparison to the wild type and propane di-thiol variants

[FeFe] Hydrogenases catalyze the reversible conversion of H₂ into electrons and protons. Their catalytic site, the H-cluster, contains a generic [4Fe–4S]_H cluster coupled to a [2Fe]_H subsite [Fe₂(ADT)(CO)₃(CN)₂]²⁻, ADT = µ(SCH₂)₂NH. Heterologously expressed [FeFe] hydrogenases (apo-hydrogenase) lack the [2Fe]_H unit, but this can be incorporated through artificial maturation with a synthetic precursor [Fe₂(ADT)(CO)₄(CN)₂]²⁻. Maturation with a [2Fe] complex in which the essential ADT amine moiety has been replaced by CH₂ (PDT = propane-dithiolate) results in a low activity enzyme with structural and spectroscopic properties similar to those of the native enzyme, but with simplified redox behavior. Here, we study the effect of sulfur-to-selenium (S-to-Se) substitution in the bridging PDT ligand incorporated in the [FeFe] hydrogenase HydA1 from Chlamydomonas reinhardtii using magnetic resonance (EPR, NMR), FTIR and spectroelectrochemistry. The resulting HydA1-PDSe enzyme shows the same redox behavior as the parent HydA1-PDT. In addition, a state is observed in which extraneous CO is bound to the open coordination site of the [2Fe]_H unit. This state was previously observed only in the native enzyme HydA1-ADT and not in HydA1-PDT. The spectroscopic features and redox behavior of HydA1-PDSe, resulting from maturation with [Fe₂(PDSe)(CO)₄(CN)₂]²⁻, are discussed in terms of spin and charge density shifts and provide interesting insight into the electronic structure of the H-cluster. We also studied the effect of S-to-Se substitution in the [4Fe–4S] subcluster. The reduced form of HydA1 containing only the [4Fe–4Se]_H cluster shows a characteristic S = 7/2 spin state which converts back into the S = 1/2 spin state upon maturation with a [2Fe]–PDT/ADT complex.

From protein engineering to artificial enzymes - biological and biomimetic approaches towards sustainable hydrogen production

Hydrogen gas is used extensively in industry today and is often put forward as a suitable energy carrier due its high energy density. Currently, the main source of molecular hydrogen is fossil fuels via steam reforming. Consequently, novel production methods are required to improve the sustainability of hydrogen gas for industrial processes, as well as paving the way for its implementation as a future solar fuel. Nature has already developed an elaborate hydrogen economy, where the production and consumption of hydrogen gas is catalysed by hydrogenase enzymes. In this review we summarize efforts on engineering and optimizing these enzymes for biological hydrogen gas production, with an emphasis on their inorganic cofactors. Moreover, we will describe how our understanding of these enzymes has been applied for the preparation of bio-inspired/-mimetic systems for efficient and sustainable hydrogen production.

Electrochemical Investigations of Hydrogenases and Other Enzymes That Produce and Use Solar Fuels

Many enzymes that produce or transform small molecules such as O₂, H₂, and CO₂ embed inorganic cofactors based on transition metals. Their active site, where the chemical reaction occurs, is buried in and protected by the protein matrix, and connected to the solvent in several ways: chains of redox cofactors mediate long-range electron transfer; static or dynamic tunnels guide the substrate, product and inhibitors; amino acids and water molecules transfer protons. The catalytic mechanism of these enzymes is therefore delocalized over the protein and involves many different steps, some of which determine the response of the enzyme under conditions of stress (extreme redox conditions, presence of inhibitors, light), the catalytic rates in the two directions of the reaction and their ratio (the "catalytic bias"). Understanding all the steps in the catalytic cycle, including those that occur on sites of the protein that are remote from the active site, requires a combination of biochemical, structural, spectroscopic, theoretical, and kinetic methods. Here we argue that kinetics should be used to the fullest extent, by extracting quantitative information from the comparison of data and kinetic models and by exploring the combination of experimental kinetics and theoretical chemistry. In studies of these catalytic mechanisms, direct electrochemistry, the technique which we use and contribute to develop, has become unescapable. It simply consists in monitoring the changes in activity of an enzyme that is wired to an electrode by recording an electric current. We have described kinetic models that can be used to make sense of these data and to learn about various aspects of the mechanism that are difficult to probe using more conventional methods: long-range electron transfer, diffusion along gas channels, redox-driven (in)activations, active site chemistry and photoreactivity under conditions of turnover. In this Account, we highlight a few results that illustrate our approach. We describe how electrochemistry can be used to monitor substrate and inhibitor diffusion along the gas channels of hydrogenases and we discuss how the kinetics of intramolecular diffusion relates to global properties such as resistance to oxygen and catalytic bias. The kinetics and/or thermodynamics of intramolecular electron transfer may also affect the catalytic bias, the catalytic potentials on either side of the equilibrium potential, and the overpotentials for catalysis (defined as the difference between the catalytic potentials and the open circuit potential). This is understood by modeling the shape of the steady-state catalytic response of the enzyme. Other determinants of the catalytic rate, such as domain motions, have been probed by examining the transient catalytic response recorded at fast scan rates. Last, we show that combining electrochemical investigations and MD, DFT, and TD-DFT calculations is an original way of probing the reactivity of the H-cluster of hydrogenase, in particular its reactions with CO, O₂, and light. This approach contrasts with the usual strategy which aims at stabilizing species that are presumed to be catalytic intermediates, and determining their structure using spectroscopic or structural methods.