Investigation into the Formation and Adhesion of Cyclopentane Hydrates on Mechanically Robust Vapor-Deposited Polymeric Coatings

Amorphous-like thermal conductivity and high mechanical stability of cyclopentane clathrate hydrate

The thermal conductivity κ of cyclopentane clathrate hydrate (CP CH) of type II was measured at temperatures down to 100 K and at pressures up to 1.3 GPa. The results show that CP CH displays amorphous-like κ characteristic of many crystalline clathrate hydrates, e.g., tetrahydrofuran (THF) CH. The magnitude of κ is 0.47 W m-1 K-1 near the melting point of 280 K at atmospheric pressure, and it is almost independent of pressure and temperature T: ln κ = -0.621-40.1/T at atmospheric pressure (in SI-units). This is slightly less than κ of type II CHs of water-miscible solvents such as THF. Intriguingly, unlike other water-rich type II clathrate hydrates of water-miscible molecules M (M·17 H2O), CP CH does not amorphize at pressures up to 1.3 GPa at 130 K and also remains stable up to 0.5 GPa at 240 K. This shows that CP CH is mechanically more stable than the previously studied water-rich type II CHs, and suggests that repulsive forces between CP and the H2O cages increase the mechanical stability of crystalline CP CH. Moreover, we show that κ of an ice-CH mixture, which often arises for CHs that form naturally, is described by the average of the parallel and series heat conduction models to within 5% for ice contents up to 22 wt%. The findings provide a better understanding of the thermal and stability properties of clathrate hydrates for their applications such as gas storage compounds.

Study of Sintering Behavior of Methane Hydrate Particles on the Wall Surface

The sintering of hydrate aggregates on the pipe wall is a major form of hydrate deposition. Understanding the sintering behavior of hydrates on the wall is crucial for promoting hydrate safety management and preventing pipeline blockage. However, limited research currently exists on this topic. In this study, the cohesive force strength of hydrate particles on the wall surface under different conditions was directly measured using a high-pressure micromechanical force device (HP-MMF). Subsequently, the effects of subcooling and glycine on the cohesive force were investigated. The results indicate that the cohesive force is influenced by different growth states during the process of free water on the wall surface gradually growing into hydrate. Three states with larger measured values during the growth process were selected for research. Observation showed that increased subcooling strengthened sintering by accelerating the growth rate of the hydrate film, resulting in a significant increase in cohesive force. The role of glycine in the methane hydrate system was then evaluated. Glycine was found to reduce the degree of sintering by reducing the growth rate of the hydrate film, thereby decreasing the cohesive force. The optimal concentration in the system was determined to be 0.25 wt %. Moreover, compared with low subcooling (1 °C), glycine had a better effect at high subcooling (5 °C). At 5 °C subcooling and the optimal concentration, the cohesive force in the wall droplet state decreases from 677.38 to 489.02 mN/m, the cohesive force at the low-saturation state decreases from 951.79 to 543.32 mN/m, and the cohesive force at the high-saturation state decreases from 1194.95 to 641.76 mN/m. These findings contribute to a better understanding of the cohesive force behavior of gas hydrate on the inner wall of the pipeline and provide basic data for reducing the risk of hydrate blockage.

Multifunctional Amphiphobic Coating toward Ultralow Interfacial Adhesion of Hydrates

Hydrate adhesion is a challenging issue in some practical applications. However, most current anti-hydrate coatings fail to maintain their properties when subject to crude oil and corrosive contaminants. In addition, the effect of surface properties on the nucleation of hydrates is still unexplored from a microscopic perspective. In this study, a multifunctional amphiphobic PF/ZSM-5 coating consisting of 1H, 1H, 2H, 2H-perfluorooctyltriethoxysilane modified ZSM-5 zeolite (F/ZSM-5) and adhesive polyethersulfone was fabricated by the spraying method. The interfacial nucleation and adhesion of hydrates on substrates were studied from a microscopic perspective. The coating exhibited excellent repellencies to various liquids, including water, edible oil, liquid paraffin, vacuum pump oil, n-hexadecane, and crude oil. The tetrabutylammonium bromide (TBAB) hydrate is readily nucleated on the bare Cu surface. In contrast, the coated substrate effectively inhibited the hydrate nucleation on the surface and even reduced the adhesion force to 0 mN/m. Furthermore, this coating was fouling- and corrosion-resistant and can maintain an ultralow hydrate adhesion force even after immersion in crude oil or TBAB solution for 20 and 300 d, respectively. The durable anti-hydrate performance of the coating was attributed mainly to the unique architecture and excellent amphiphobic properties enabling stable air cushions between the solid-liquid interface.

Centrifugal microfluidic-based multiplex recombinase polymerase amplification assay for rapid detection of SARS-CoV-2

The COVID-19 pandemic has spread worldwide, and rapid detection of the SARS-CoV-2 virus is crucial for infection surveillance and epidemic control. This study developed a centrifugal microfluidics-based multiplex reverse transcription recombinase polymerase amplification (RT-RPA) assay for endpoint fluorescence detection of the E, N, and ORF1ab genes of SARS-CoV-2. The microscope slide-shaped microfluidic chip could simultaneously accomplish three target genes and one reference human gene (i.e., ACTB) RT-RPA reactions in 30 min, and the sensitivity was 40 RNA copies/reaction for the E gene, 20 RNA copies/reaction for the N gene, and 10 RNA copies/reaction for the ORF1ab gene. The chip demonstrated high specificity, reproducibility, and repeatability. Chip performance was also evaluated using real clinical samples. Thus, this rapid, accurate, on-site, and multiplexed nucleic acid test microfluidic chip would significantly contribute to detecting patients with COVID-19 in low-resource settings and point-of-care testing (POCT) and, in the future, could be used to detect emerging new variants of SARS-CoV-2.

Effects of hydrate inhibitors on the adhesion strengths of sintered hydrate deposits on pipe walls

The effects of hydrate inhibitors on the adhesion of sintered hydrate deposits on pipe walls are still unexplored. Herein, a custom-built adhesion strength measurement apparatus was utilized to quantify the adhesion strengths of sintered cyclopentane (CyC5) hydrate deposits with thermodynamic inhibitors (ethylene glycol, glycerol) and low-dosage inhibitors (dodecylbenzene sulfonic acid (DBSA), sorbitan oleate (Span 80)). It was found that the hydrate adhesion strengths decreased by 69.82%-97.06% and 40.24%-94.36% with the concentration of ethylene glycol and glycerol increased from 2 wt% to 6 wt%, respectively. For DBSA and Span 80, the hydrate adhesion strength increased with concentration less than 0.01 wt% due to the acceleration on hydrate growth. The further increment of concentration leads to a dramatic reduction in adhesion strengths. Furthermore, the relatively large deviations with the predicted strengths led to the discussions of the effects of change in hydrate formation rate, crystal morphology, and also the adaption of the fitting model. Two modified models were proposed to give a better prediction/explanation of the hydrate adhesion with thermodynamic inhibitors and low-dosage inhibitors, respectively. This work provides a fundamental understanding of the adhesion mechanism of hydrate deposits with hydrate inhibitors, which is important in advancing the management of hydrate formation for preventing plugging in pipelines.

Durable Hydrate-phobic Coating with In Situ Self-Replenishing Hydrocarbon Barrier Films for Low Clathrate Hydrate Adhesion

Clathrate hydrate growth, deposition, and plug formation during oil and gas transportation causes blockage of pipelines. An effective strategy to solve this problem is to mitigate the hydrate formation and reduce its adhesion on pipe walls through a coating process. However, durability failure, corrosion, inability to self-heal, high cost, and strong hydrate adhesion remain unsolved issues. To address these challenges, in this work, we present an in situ self-replenishing nonfluorinated durable hydrate-phobic coating of candle soot particles. The candle soot coating reduces hydrate adhesion by promoting a thick barrier film of hydrocarbons between the hydrate and the soot coated substrate. The hydrocarbons permeating the soot coating display a high contact angle for water and inhibit the formation of water bridges between the hydrate and soot coated substrate. The spherical cyclopentane hydrate slides off easily on the candle soot coating inside the cyclopentane environment. The hydrate former, cyclopentane-water emulsion, and THF-water mixture have high contact angles as well as low hydrate adhesion on soot coating simultaneously. In addition, the coating is flow-induced long-term slippery, durable, low cost, anticorrosion, self-cleaning, and suitable for practical applications.

Vapor Deposition of Transparent Antifogging Polymeric Nanocoatings

This study demonstrates the coating of a transparent and robust organic thin film having an excellent hydrophilicity-based antifogging property by an initiated chemical vapor deposition (iCVD) method. iCVD was able to synthesize linear and cross-liked poly(acrylic acid) (PAA) from the vapors of acrylic acid (AA) and ethylene glycol dimethacrylate (EGDMA) using tert-butyl peroxide (TBPO) as an initiator. High deposition rates of up to 35 nm/min were observed at low deposition temperatures. It was possible to control the quantity of comonomers in the as-deposited films by adjusting the partial pressure of the EGDMA cross-linking agent. The effect of the EGDMA partial pressure on chemical structure was studied using Fourier transform infrared (FTIR) and X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS) techniques. FTIR and XPS spectra of the as-deposited films showed the complete retention of the monomer functionality during iCVD. Hydrophilicities and large-area uniformity of the coatings were revealed using water contact angle measurements. The as-deposited PAA film was the most hydrophilic with a water contact angle (WCA) of 7.0°, while cross-linking with EGDMA increased the WCA values by up to 51.7°. Results of various tests, which were based on exposing the coated surfaces to artificial fog and hot water vapor, showed the excellent antifogging property of the coatings. Films were never fogged upon extensive and long-term exposure (2 months) to humid air.

Effects of Solid Precipitation and Surface Corrosion on the Adhesion Strengths of Sintered Hydrate Deposits on Pipe Walls

A hydrate directly growing and sintering on a pipe wall is an important hydrate deposition case that has been relatively unexplored. In the present study, the adhesion strengths of a sintered cyclopentane (CyC5) hydrate deposit under different solid precipitation and surface corrosion conditions were measured and discussed. It was found that the hydrate adhesion strengths increased by 1.2-1.5× when the soaking time of the carbon steel substrate in a 5 wt % NaCl solution increased from 24 to 72 h, which reduced the water wetting angle from 112 ± 3.5° to 94 ± 3.3°. The wax coating reduced the strength of CyC5 hydrate adhesion by up to nearly 20-fold by reversing the substrate wettability and affecting the hydrate morphology. The measurements performed on scales indicate that calcium carbonate scales strengthen the adhesion strength because of the decrease in the water wetting angle. In addition, honeycomb holes on the surface reduce amplification. Furthermore, settling quartz sand on the wall reduced the adhesion strengths by decreasing the effective sintering area of the hydrate on the underlying base. Finer sand and higher concentrations led to lower strengths. On the basis of the verified linear correlation between the hydrate adhesion strength and the adhesion work of droplets on different substrates and the influence of water conversion during deposition, both an equation and a key constant parameter were obtained to predict the sintered hydrate deposit adhesion strengths on substrates.

Preventing Hydrate Adhesion with Magnetic Slippery Surfaces

Hydrate formation is a common challenge in the oil and gas industry when natural gas is transported under cold conditions in the presence of water. Coatings are one of the solutions that have shown to be a promising approach to address this challenge. However, this strategy suffers from the intrinsic existence of a solid-liquid interface causing a high rate of hydrate nucleation and high hydrate adhesion strength. This proof-of-concept study highlights the performance of a magnetic slippery surface to prevent hydrate adhesion at atmospheric pressure using tetrahydrofuran hydrates. The coating consisted of a hydrocarbon-based magnetic fluid, which was applied to a metal surface to create an interface that lowered the hydrate adhesion strength on the surface. The performance of these new surfaces under static and dynamic (under fluid flow) conditions shows that the magnetic coating gel can be a potential inhibitor for hydrate adhesion as it reduced the torque value after the formation of hydrates.

An in situ method on kinetics of gas hydrates

Gas hydrate formation is a high-risk and common flow assurance problem in subsea oil production plants. The modern strategies to mitigate hydrate formation have switched from thermodynamic inhibition to risk management. In this new mitigation strategy, hydrate formation is allowed as long as it does not lead to plugging of pipelines. Thus, understanding the growth kinetics of gas hydrates plays a critical role in risk management strategies. Here, we report a new accurate and in situ approach to probe the kinetics of gas hydrate formation. This approach is based on the hot-wire method, which probes the thermal properties of the medium surrounding the hot-wire. As the thermal properties of gas hydrate and its initial constituents are different, variation in these properties is used to probe kinetics of hydrate growth front. Through this in situ method, we determine kinetics of cyclopentane hydrate formation in both mixing and flow conditions. The findings show that at ambient pressure and a temperature of 1-2 °C, the hydrate formation rate under mixing condition varies between 1.9 × 10^-5 and 3.9 × 10^-5 kg m^-2 s^-1, while in flow condition, this growth rate drops to 4.5 × 10^-6 kg m^-2 s^-1. To our knowledge, this is the first reported growth rate of cyclopentane hydrate. This in situ approach allows us to probe kinetics of hydrate formation where there is no optical access and provides a tool to rationally design risk management strategies for subsea infrastructures.

Micro-/Nanoscale Approach for Studying Scale Formation and Developing Scale-Resistant Surfaces

Blockage of pipelines due to accretion of salt particles is detrimental in desalination and water-harvesting industries as they compromise productivity, while increasing maintenance costs. We present a micro-/nanoscale approach to study fundamentals of scale formation, deposition, and adhesion to engineered surfaces with a wide range of surface energies fabricated using the initiated chemical vapor deposition method. Silicon wafers and steel substrates are coated with poly(1 H,1 H,2 H,2 H-perfluorodecylacrylate) or pPFDA, poly(tetravinyl-tetramethylcyclotetrasilohexane) or pV4D4, poly(divinylbenzene) or pDVB, poly(1,3,5,7-tetravinyl-1,3,5,7-tetramethylcyclotetrasilohexane) or pV3D3, and cross-linked copolymers of poly(2-hydroxyethylmethacrylate) and poly(ethylene glycol) diacrylate or p(PHEMA- co-EGDA). Particles of salt (CaSO₄·2H₂O) are formed and shaped with a focused ion beam and adhered to a tipless cantilever beam using a micromanipulator setup to study their adhesion strength with a molecular force probe (MFP). Adhesion forces were measured on the substrates in wet and dry conditions to evaluate the effects of interfacial fluid layers and capillary bridges on net adhesion strength. The adhesion between salt particles and the pPFDA coatings decreased by 5.1 ± 1.15 nN in wet states, indicating the influence of capillary bridging between the particle and the liquid layer. In addition, scale nucleation and growth on various surfaces is examined using a quartz crystal microbalance (QCM), where supersaturated solution of CaSO₄·2H₂O is passed over bare and polymer-coated quartz substrates while mass gain is measured in real time. The salt accretion decreased by 2 folds on pPFDA-coated substrates when compared to that on p(HEMA- co-EGDA) coatings. Both MFP and QCM studies are essential in studying the impact of surface energy and roughness on the extent of scale formation and adhesion strength. This study can pave way for the design of scale-resistant surfaces with potential applications in water treatment, energy harvesting, and purification industries.

Explaining Evaporation-Triggered Wetting Transition Using Local Force Balance Model and Contact Line-Fraction

Understanding wettability and mechanisms of wetting transition are important for design and engineering of superhydrophobic surfaces. There have been numerous studies on the design and fabrication of superhydrophobic and omniphobic surfaces and on the wetting transition mechanisms triggered by liquid evaporation. However, there is a lack of a universal method to examine wetting transition on rough surfaces. Here, we introduce force zones across the droplet base and use a local force balance model to explain wetting transition on engineered nanoporous microstructures, utilizing a critical force per unit length (FPL) value. For the first time, we provide a universal scale using the concept of the critical FPL value which enables comparison of various superhydrophobic surfaces in terms of preventing wetting transition during liquid evaporation. In addition, we establish the concept of contact line-fraction theoretically and experimentally by relating it to area-fraction, which clarifies various arguments about the validity of the Cassie-Baxter equation. We use the contact line-fraction model to explain the droplet contact angles, liquid evaporation modes, and depinning mechanism during liquid evaporation. Finally, we develop a model relating a droplet curvature to conventional beam deflection, providing a framework for engineering pressure stable superhydrophobic surfaces.

Surfactant Effect on Hydrate Crystallization at the Oil-Water Interface

Gas hydrates pose economic and environmental risks to the oil and gas industry when plug formation occurs in pipelines. A novel approach was applied to understand cyclopentane clathrate hydrate formation in the presence of nonionic surfactant to achieve hydrate inhibition at low percent weight compared to thermodynamic inhibitors. The hydrate-inhibiting performance of low (<CMC), medium (∼CMC), and high (>CMC) concentrations of Span 20, Span 80, Pluronic L31, and Tween 65 at 2 °C on a manually nucleated 2 μL droplet showed a morphological shift in crystallization from planar shell growth to conical growth. Monitoring the internal pressure of the water droplet undergoing hydrate crystallization provides information on the change in interfacial tension during the crystallization process. The results of this study will provide information on the surfactant effect on hydrate crystallization and inhibition. At low surfactant concentrations (below CMC), a planar hydrate crystal was formed. Decreasing interfacial tension was observed, which can be related to the shrinking area of the water-cyclopentane interface. At high surfactant concentration, the crystal morphology was shifted to conical. Interfacial tension measurements reveal oscillations of the interfacial tension during the crystallization process. The oscillations of the interfacial tension result from the fact that once the crystal has reached a critical size a portion of the cone breaks free from the droplet surface, which results in a sudden increase in the available surface for the surfactant molecules. Hence, a temporary increase in the interfacial tension can be observed. The oscillatory behavior of the interfacial tension is a result of the growth and release of the hydrate cones from the surface of the droplet. We have found that the most efficient surfactant in hydrate inhibition would be the one with HLB closest to 10 (equal hydrophilic-hydrophobic parts). In this way, the surfactant molecules will stay at the interface as they observe equal affinities for both the oil and water phases. Surfactant molecules that have the strongest affinity to the interface will be able to inhibit the growth of the crystal as they will force the cones to break and will not allow them to grow.

Scalable and durable polymeric icephobic and hydrate-phobic coatings

Ice formation and accumulation on surfaces can result in severe problems for solar photovoltaic installations, offshore oil platforms, wind turbines and aircrafts. In addition, blockage of pipelines by formation and accumulation of clathrate hydrates of natural gases has safety and economical concerns in oil and gas operations, particularly at high pressures and low temperatures such as those found in subsea or arctic environments. Practical adoption of icephobic/hydrate-phobic surfaces requires mechanical robustness and stability under harsh environments. Here, we develop durable and mechanically robust bilayer poly-divinylbenzene (pDVB)/poly-perfluorodecylacrylate (pPFDA) coatings using initiated chemical vapor deposition (iCVD) to reduce the adhesion strength of ice/hydrates to underlying substrates (silicon and steel). Utilizing a highly-cross-linked polymer (pDVB) underneath a very thin veneer of fluorine-rich polymer (pPFDA) we have designed inherently rough bilayer polymer films that can be deposited on rough steel substrates resulting in surfaces which exhibit a receding water contact angle (WCA) higher than 150° and WCA hysteresis as low as 4°. Optical profilometer measurements were performed on the films and root mean square (RMS) roughness values of Rq = 178.0 ± 17.5 nm and Rq = 312.7 ± 23.5 nm were obtained on silicon and steel substrates, respectively. When steel surfaces are coated with these smooth hard iCVD bilayer polymer films, the strength of ice adhesion is reduced from 1010 ± 95 kPa to 180 ± 85 kPa. The adhesion strength of the cyclopentane (CyC5) hydrate is also reduced from 220 ± 45 kPa on rough steel substrates to 34 ± 12 kPa on the polymer-coated steel substrates. The durability of these bilayer polymer coated icephobic and hydrate-phobic substrates is confirmed by sand erosion tests and examination of multiple ice/hydrate adhesion/de-adhesion cycles.

Stable Wettability Control of Nanoporous Microstructures by iCVD Coating of Carbon Nanotubes

Scalable manufacturing of structured materials with engineered nanoporosity is critical for applications in energy storage devices (i.e., batteries and supercapacitors) and in the wettability control of surfaces (i.e., superhydrophobic and superomniphobic surfaces). Patterns formed in arrays of vertically aligned carbon nanotubes (VA-CNTs) have been extensively studied for these applications. However, the as-deposited features are often undesirably altered upon liquid infiltration and evaporation because of capillarity-driven aggregation of low density CNT forests. Here, it is shown that an ultrathin, conformal, and low-surface-energy layer of poly perfluorodecyl acrylate, poly(1H,1H,2H,2H-perfluorodecyl acrylate) (pPFDA), makes the VA-CNTs robust against surface-tension-driven aggregation and densification. This single vapor-deposition step allows the fidelity of the as-deposited VA-CNT patterns to be retained during wet processing, such as inking, and subsequent drying. It is demonstrated how to establish omniphobicity or liquid infiltration by controlling the surface morphology. Retaining a crust of entangled CNTs and pPFDA aggregates on top of the patterned VA-CNTs produces micropillars with re-entrant features that prevent the infiltration of low-surface-tension liquids and thus gives rise to stable omniphobicity. Plasma treatments before and after polymer deposition remove the crust of entangled CNTs and pPFDA aggregates and attach hydroxyl groups to the CNT tips, enabling liquid infiltration yet preventing densification of the highly porous CNTs. The latter observation demonstrates the protective character of the pPFDA coating with the potential application of these surfaces for direct contact printing of microelectronic features.

Designing Ultra-Low Hydrate Adhesion Surfaces by Interfacial Spreading of Water-Immiscible Barrier Films

Clathrate hydrates are icelike solid substances that can form inside oil and gas pipelines and are responsible for flow blockages, sometimes leading to catastrophic failures. Minimizing hydrate formation and adhesion on pipeline surfaces can effectively address this problem. In this paper, we achieve the lowering of the adhesion of cyclopentane hydrates by promoting a cyclopentane barrier film between the hydrate and solid surface. The presence of this interfacial liquid film depends on the relative spreading of cyclopentane on the solid surface in the presence of water. We study the role of surface chemistry and surface texture on the spreading characteristics of such interfacial films and their impact on hydrate adhesion. The use of the spreading coefficients as design parameters could take us a step closer to the development of effective passive antihydrate surfaces.

Polymer Thin Films and Surface Modification by Chemical Vapor Deposition: Recent Progress

Chemical vapor deposition (CVD) polymerization uses vapor phase monomeric reactants to synthesize organic thin films directly on substrates. These thin films are desirable as conformal surface engineering materials and functional layers. The facile tunability of the films and their surface properties allow successful integration of CVD thin films into prototypes for applications in surface modification, device fabrication, and protective films. CVD polymers also bridge microfabrication technology with chemical and biological systems. Robust coatings can be achieved via CVD methods as antifouling, anti-icing, and antihydrate surfaces, as well as stimuli-responsive or biocompatible polymers and novel nanostructures. Use of low-energy input, modest vacuum, and room-temperature substrates renders CVD polymerization compatible with thermally sensitive substrates and devices. Compared with solution-based methods, CVD is particularly useful for insoluble materials, such as electrically conductive polymers and controllably crosslinked networks, and has the potential to reduce environmental, health, and safety impacts associated with solvents. This review discusses the relevant background and selected applications of recent advances by two methods that display and use the high retention of the organic functional groups from their respective monomers, initiated CVD (iCVD) and oxidative CVD (oCVD) polymerization.

CVD Polymers for Devices and Device Fabrication

Chemical vapor deposition (CVD) polymerization directly synthesizes organic thin films on a substrate from vapor phase reactants. Dielectric, semiconducting, electrically conducting, and ionically conducting CVD polymers have all been readily integrated into devices. The absence of solvent in the CVD process enables the growth of high-purity layers and avoids the potential of dewetting phenomena, which lead to pinhole defects. By limiting contaminants and defects, ultrathin (<10 nm) CVD polymeric device layers have been fabricated in multiple laboratories. The CVD method is particularly suitable for synthesizing insoluble conductive polymers, layers with high densities of organic functional groups, and robust crosslinked networks. Additionally, CVD polymers are prized for the ability to conformally cover rough surfaces, like those of paper and textile substrates, as well as the complex geometries of micro- and nanostructured devices. By employing low processing temperatures, CVD polymerization avoids damaging substrates and underlying device layers. This report discusses the mechanisms of the major CVD polymerization techniques and the recent progress of their applications in devices and device fabrication, with emphasis on initiated CVD (iCVD) and oxidative CVD (oCVD) polymerization.

Durable and scalable icephobic surfaces: similarities and distinctions from superhydrophobic surfaces

Formation, adhesion, and accumulation of ice, snow, frost, glaze, rime, or their mixtures can cause severe problems for solar panels, wind turbines, aircrafts, heat pumps, power lines, telecommunication equipment, and submarines. These problems can decrease efficiency in power generation, increase energy consumption, result in mechanical and/or electrical failure, and generate safety hazards. To address these issues, the fundamentals of interfaces between liquids and surfaces at low temperatures have been extensively studied. This has lead to development of so called "icephobic" surfaces, which possess a number of overlapping, yet distinctive, characteristics from superhydrophobic surfaces. Less attention has been given to distinguishing differences between formation and adhesion of ice, snow, glaze, rime, and frost or to developing a clear definition for icephobic, or more correctly pagophobic, surfaces. In this review, we strive to clarify these differences and distinctions, while providing a comprehensive definition of icephobicity. We classify different canonical families of icephobic (pagophobic) surfaces providing a review of those with potential for scalable and robust development.