Toward Developing Discriminating Dissolution Methods for Formulations Containing Nanoparticulates in Solution: The Impact of Particle Drift and Drug Activity in Solution

Particle Size, Dose, and Confinement Affect Passive Diffusion Flux through the Membrane Concentration Boundary Layer

The authors present a steady-state-, particle-size-, and dose-dependent dissolution-permeation model that describes particle dissolution within the concentration boundary layer (CBL) adjacent to a semipermeable surface. It is critical to understand how particle size and dose affect the behavior of dissolving particles in the presence of a CBL adjacent to a semipermeable surface both in vivo and in vitro. Control of particle size is ubiquitous in the pharmaceutical industry; however, traditional pharmaceutical assumptions of particle dissolution typically ignore particle dissolution within the length scale of the CBL. The CBL does not physically prevent particles from traveling to the semipermeable surface (mucus, epithelial barrier, synthetic membrane, etc.), and particle dissolution can occur within the CBL thickness (δC) if the particle is sufficiently small (∼dparticle ≤ δC). The total flux (the time rate transport of molecules across the membrane surface per unit area) was chosen as a surrogate parameter for measuring the additional mass generated by particles dissolving within the donor CBL. Mass transfer experiments aimed to measure the total flux of drug using an ultrathin large-area membrane diffusion cell described by Sinko et al. with a silicone-based membrane ( Mol. Pharmaceutics 2020, 17, (7) 2319-2328, DOI: 10.1021/acs.molpharmaceut.0c00040). Suspensions of ibuprofen, a model weak-acid drug, with three different particle-size distributions with average particle diameters of 6.6, 37.4, and 240 μm at multiple doses corresponding to a range of suspension concentrations with dimensionless dose numbers of 2.94, 14.7, 147, and 588 were used to test the model. Experimentally measured total flux across the semipermeable membrane/CBL region agreed with the predictions from the proposed model, and at a range of relatively low suspension concentrations, dependent on the average particle size, there was a measurable effect on the flux due to the difference in δC that formed at the membrane surface. Additionally, the dose-dependent total flux across the membrane was up to 10% higher than the flux predicted by the standard Higuchi-Hiestand dissolution model where the effects of confinement were ignored as described by Wang et al. ( Mol. Pharmaceutics 2012, 9 (5), 1052-1066, DOI: 10.1021/mp2002818).

Biorelevant Dissolution Method Considerations for the Appropriate Evaluation of Amorphous Solid Dispersions: are Two Stages Necessary?

Biorelevant dissolution testing has been widely used to better understand a drug or formulation's behavior in the human gastrointestinal (GI) tract. The successful evaluation of biorelevant dissolution behavior requires recognizing the importance of utilizing suitable biorelevant media in conjunction with an appropriate dissolution method, especially for supersaturating drug delivery systems, such as amorphous solid dispersions (ASDs). However, most conventional biorelevant dissolution testing methods are not able to accurately reflect the dissolution, supersaturation, and precipitation tendencies of a drug or formulation, which could misinform ASD formulation screening and optimization. In this study, we developed a single compartment 2-stage pH-shift dissolution testing method to simulate the changes in pH, media composition, and transit time in the GI tract, and results were compared against the conventional single compartment 1-stage dissolution method. Nine model drugs were selected based on their ionization properties (i.e. acid, base or neutral) and precipitation tendency (i.e. moderate or slow crystallizer). The dissolution results confirmed that 2-stage pH-shift dissolution is the preferred biorelevant dissolution method to assess non-ionized weak base (nifedipine) and neutral (griseofulvin) compounds exhibiting a moderate precipitation rate from solution when formulated as ASDs. Finally, we designed a flowchart guidance for the appropriate biorelevant dissolution performance characterization of different categories of ASD formulations.

High drug loading nanosized amorphous solid dispersion (NASD) with enhanced in vitro solubility and permeability: Benchmarking conventional ASD

Through liquid-liquid phase separation (LLPS), it is possible to generate drug-rich nanoparticles during the dissolution of conventional amorphous solid dispersions (ASDs). These self-generated nanoparticles may improve the oral absorption of poorly water-soluble drugs by enhancing the drug's apparent solubility and effective membrane permeability. However, due to the high concentration threshold required for LLPS, conventional ASDs that can consistently generate drug-rich nanoparticles during dissolution are rare. More importantly, the quality of these meta-stable drug-rich nanoparticles is hard to control during dissolution, leading to inconsistency in formulation performances. This work has described a continuous twin-screw extrusion process capable of producing nanosized ASD (NASD) formulations that can offer better solubility and permeability enhancements over conventional ASD formulations. Two polymeric carriers, polyvinylpyrrolidone-co-vinyl acetate (PVPVA) and hydroxypropyl methylcellulose acetate succinate (HPMCAS), with a model hydrophobic drug celecoxib (BCS II), were formulated into both ASD and NASD formulations. Compared to the conventional ASD formulation, the prefabricated NASD (sizes ranging between 40 and 200 nm) embedded within a polyol matrix can be rapidly dispersed into a nanoparticle suspension in the presence of aqueous media. The resulting NASDs achieved drug loadings up to 80 % w/w and a maximum of 98 % encapsulation efficiency. Because of the TSE platform's high drug-loading capacity and high scalability, the developed method may be useful for continuously producing personalized nanomedicines.

Mechanisms and Extent of Enhanced Passive Permeation by Colloidal Drug Particles

Formulations containing nanosized drug particles such as nanocrystals and nanosized amorphous drug aggregates recently came into light as promising strategies to improve the bioavailability of poorly soluble drugs. However, the increased solubility due to the reduction in particle size cannot adequately explain the enhanced bioavailability. In this study, the mechanisms and extent of enhanced passive permeation by drug particles were investigated using atazanavir, lopinavir, and clotrimazole as model drugs. Franz diffusion cells with lipid-infused membranes were utilized to evaluate transmembrane flux. The impact of stirring rate, receiver buffer condition, and particle size was investigated, and mass transport analyses were conducted to calculate transmembrane flux. Flux enhancement by particles was found to be dependent on particle size as well as the partitioning behavior of the drug between the receiver solution and the membrane, which is determined by both the drug and buffer used. A flux plateau was observed at high particle concentrations above amorphous solubility, confirming that mass transfer of amorphous drug particles from the aqueous solution to the membrane occurs only through the molecularly dissolved drug. Mass transport models were used to calculate flux enhancement by particles for various drugs at different conditions. Good agreements were obtained between experimental and predicted values. These results should contribute to improved bioavailability prediction of nanosized drug particles and better design of formulations containing colloidal drug particles.

Comparisons of in Vitro Models to Evaluate the Membrane Permeability of Amorphous Drug Nanoparticles

The spontaneous formation of amorphous drug nanoparticles following the release of a drug from a supersaturating formulation is gaining increasing attention due to their potential contribution to increased oral bioavailability. The formation of nanosized drug particles also has considerable implications for the interpretation of in vitro and in vivo data. However, the membrane transport properties of these drug particles remain less well understood. Herein, the membrane permeation of nanosized amorphous drug particles of a model drug atazanavir was evaluated using different artificial membrane-based, cell-based, and animal tissue-based models. Results showed that flux enhancement by particles was different for the various systems used. Generally, good agreement was obtained among experiments performed using the same apparatus with different model membranes, with the exception of the Madin-Darby canine kidney cell monolayer and the Long-Evans rat intestine tissue, which showed lower flux enhancements. Franz cell-based models showed slightly higher flux enhancements by particles compared to Transwell and intestinal tissue sac models. Mass transport analysis suggested that the extent of flux enhancement by particles is dependent on the geometry of the apparatus as well as the properties of the membrane and buffer used, whereas the flux plateau concentration is dependent on the unstirred water later (UWL) asymmetry. These results highlight the complexity in characterizing the permeability advantage of these nonmembrane permeable drug particles and suggest that caution should be used in selecting the appropriate in vitro model to evaluate the overall permeability of colloidal drug particles.

Revealing the roles of polymers in supersaturation stabilization from the perspective of crystallization behaviors: A case of nimodipine

Formulating drugs into amorphous solid dispersions (ASDs) represents an attractive means to enhance the aqueous solubility of drugs. Furthermore, water-soluble polymers have proven highly advantageous for stabilizing supersaturated solutions of ASDs. However, the performance and mechanism of various polymers in stabilizing supersaturated drug solutions have not been well-studied. The aim of this study was to investigate the effects of different commercial polymers on the dissolution behaviors and supersaturation stabilization of the ASDs and to further explore the mechanism of polymer mediated supersaturation maintenance by studying the crystallization behaviors of the ASDs. In this study, nimodipine (NMD) was used as a model drug because of its poor water-solubility and fast crystallization rate in aqueous solution, and three polymers polyvinylpyrrolidone (PVP), vinylpyrrolidone-vinyl acetate copolymer (PVP VA), and polyvinyl caprolactam-polyvinyl acetate-polyethylene glycol graft co-polymer (Soluplus) was selected as the drug carriers to form the ASDs with NMD. Solid-state characterizations of the ASDs confirmed the amorphous state of the ASD systems. ASD_{PVP VA} demonstrated superior supersaturation maintenance in dissolution experiments compared to the other two ASD systems. Among the polymers tested, PVP VA most efficiently maintained dissolution of NMD and prevented its crystallization from the supersaturated solution. The ability of PVP VA to most-effectively maintain supersaturation of the drug was manifested by inhibition of crystal nucleation rather than inhibition of crystal growth following nucleation. These results suggest that nucleation inhibition was instrumental in enabling the polymer-mediated supersaturation maintenance, at least with NMD.

Mechanistic Investigation of Drug Supersaturation in the Presence of Polysorbates as Solubilizing Additives by Solution Nuclear Magnetic Resonance Spectroscopy

The introduction of solubilizing additives has historically been an attractive approach to address the ever-growing proportion of poorly water-soluble drug (PWSD) compounds within the modern drug discovery pipeline. Lipid-formulations, and more specifically micelle formulations, have garnered particular interest because of their simplicity, size, scalability, and avoidance of solid-state limitations. Although micelle formulations have been widely utilized, the molecular mechanism of drug solubilization in surfactant micelles is still poorly understood. In this study, a series of modern nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) methods are utilized to gain a molecular-level understanding of intermolecular interactions and kinetics in a model system. This approach enabled the understanding of how a PWSD, 17β-Estradiol (E2), solubilizes within a nonionic micelle system composed of polysorbate 80 (PS80). Based on one-dimensional (1D) ¹H chemical shift differences of E2 in PS80 solutions, as well as intermolecular correlations established from 1D selective nuclear Overhauser effect (NOE) and two-dimensional NOE spectroscopy experiments, E2 was found to accumulate within the palisade layer of PS80 micelles. A potential hydrogen-bonding interaction between a hydroxyl group of E2 and a carbonyl group of PS80 alkane chains may allow for stabilizing E2-PS80 mixed micelles. Diffusion and relaxation NMR analysis and particle size measurements using dynamic light scattering indicate a slight increase in the micellar size with increasing degrees of supersaturation, resulting in slower mobility of the drug molecule. Based on these structural findings, a theoretical orientation model of E2 molecules with PS80 molecules was developed and validated by computational docking simulations.

Role of Permeability on the Biopredictive Dissolution of Amorphous Solid Dispersions

An ideal dissolution test for amorphous solid dispersions (ASDs) should reflect physicochemical, physiological, and hydrodynamic conditions which accurately represent in vivo dissolution. However, this is confounded by the evolution of different molecular and colloidal species during dissolution, generating a supersaturated state of the drug. The supersaturated state of a drug is thermodynamically unstable which drives the process of precipitation resulting in a loss of solubility advantage. Maintaining a supersaturated state of the drug with the help of precipitation inhibiting excipients is a key component in the design of ASDs. Therefore, a biopredictive dissolution test is critical for proper risk assessment during the development of an optimal ASD formulation. One of the overlooked components of biopredictive dissolution is the role of drug permeability. The kinetic changes in the phase behavior of a drug during dissolution of ASDs are influenced by drug permeability across a membrane. Conventionally, drug dissolution and permeation are analyzed separately although they occur simultaneously in vivo. The kinetic phase changes occurring during dissolution of ASDs can influence the thermodynamic activity and membrane flux of a drug. The present review evaluates the feasibility, predictability, and practicability of permeability/dissolution for the optimal development and risk assessment of ASD formulations.

Drug-Rich Phases Induced by Amorphous Solid Dispersion: Arbitrary or Intentional Goal in Oral Drug Delivery?

Among many methods to mitigate the solubility limitations of drug compounds, amorphous solid dispersion (ASD) is considered to be one of the most promising strategies to enhance the dissolution and bioavailability of poorly water-soluble drugs. The enhancement of ASD in the oral absorption of drugs has been mainly attributed to the high apparent drug solubility during the dissolution. In the last decade, with the implementations of new knowledge and advanced analytical techniques, a drug-rich transient metastable phase was frequently highlighted within the supersaturation stage of the ASD dissolution. The extended drug absorption and bioavailability enhancement may be attributed to the metastability of such drug-rich phases. In this paper, we have reviewed (i) the possible theory behind the formation and stabilization of such metastable drug-rich phases, with a focus on non-classical nucleation; (ii) the additional benefits of the ASD-induced drug-rich phases for bioavailability enhancements. It is envisaged that a greater understanding of the non-classical nucleation theory and its application on the ASD design might accelerate the drug product development process in the future.

Dose-Dependent Solubility-Permeability Interplay for Poorly Soluble Drugs under Non-Sink Conditions

We investigated the solubility-permeability interplay using a solubilizer additive under non-sink conditions. Sodium lauryl sulfate (SLS) was used as a solubilizer additive. The solubility and permeability of two poorly soluble drugs at various doses, with or without SLS, were evaluated by flux measurements. The total permeated amount of griseofulvin, which has high permeability, increased by the addition of SLS. On the other hand, triamcinolone, which has low permeability, showed an almost constant rate of permeation regardless of the SLS addition. The total permeated amount of griseofulvin increased by about 20-30% when the dose amount exceeded its solubility, whereas its concentration in the donor chamber remained almost constant. However, the total permeated amount of triamcinolone was almost constant regardless of dose amount. These results suggest that the permeability of the unstirred water layer (UWL) may be affected by SLS and solid drugs for high-permeable drugs. The effect of solid drugs could be explained by a reduction in the apparent UWL thickness. For the appropriate evaluation of absorption, it would be essential to consider these effects.

Estimating the maximal solubility advantage of drug salts

Salt formation can enable the development of poorly water-soluble drugs containing at least one ionizable moiety. Not only can salts offer a solubility enhancement that can sometimes far exceed that of other commonly used solubilization strategies applied across the pharmaceutical industry, they can simultaneously bestow additional benefits such as providing low-cost formulation options. The goal of this work is to put forth a simple methodology to enable one to accurately predict the maximal solubility advantage of acidic and basic drugs whose unionized conjugate (neutral parent molecule) is poorly soluble. While published equations leveraging the Henderson-Hasselbalch/H-H relationship reasonably estimate the thermodynamic solubility limit (in systems where there is no supersaturation), under physiologically relevant conditions the maximal/kinetic solubility can play an important role in determining oral bioavailability, as in the case of amorphous drugs. Under these circumstances, a higher solubility can be maintained for short durations through drug supersaturation provided that the precipitation is slow, thereby causing deviations from H-H predictions. It is possible also that, in some instances, supersaturation could coincide with behavior previously attributed to drug aggregation in solution. The proposed methodology utilizes speciation across the pH range to allow one to determine the maximal amount of ionized and unionized drug in solution at each pH. The calculation is easily extended to cases where the counterion serves as a competing weak acid, weak base, or as a common ion. Additionally, a more thorough assessment of the Gibbs free energy change associated with the solubilization of salts is also presented, as this energy describes the key driving force for the recrystallization of the neutral parent by triggering its nucleation. Lastly, to demonstrate applicability to real-world compounds containing multiple ionizable moieties, the complex pH-solubility profile of a drug maleate salt taken from the literature is simulated.