Nanoscale Measurements of Charge Transfer at Cocatalyst/Semiconductor Interfaces in BiVO4 Particle Photocatalysts

High-Resolution Mapping of Photocatalytic Activity by Diffusion-Based and Tunneling Modes of Photo-Scanning Electrochemical Microscopy

Semiconductor nanomaterials and nanostructured interfaces have important technological applications, ranging from fuel production to electrosynthesis. Their photocatalytic activity is known to be highly heterogeneous, both in an ensemble of nanomaterials and within a single entity. Photoelectrochemical imaging techniques are potentially useful for high-resolution mapping of photo(electro)catalytic active sites; however, the nanoscale spatial resolution required for such experiments has not yet been attained. In this article, we report photoreactivity imaging of two-dimensional MoS2 photocatalysts by two modes of photoscanning electrochemical microscopy (photo-SECM): diffusion and tunneling-based modes. Diffusion-based (feedback mode) photo-SECM is used to map the electron transfer and hydrogen evolution rates on mixed-phase MoS2 nanosheets and MoS2 chemical vapor deposition (CVD)-grown triangles. An extremely high resolution of photoelectrochemical imaging (about 1-2 nm) by the tunneling mode of the photo-SECM is demonstrated.

Scanning Probe Microscopies for Characterizations of 2D Materials

2D materials are intriguing due to their remarkably thin and flat structure. This unique configuration allows the majority of their constituent atoms to be accessible on the surface, facilitating easier electron tunneling while generating weak surface forces. To decipher the subtle signals inherent in these materials, the application of techniques that offer atomic resolution (horizontal) and sub-Angstrom (z-height vertical) sensitivity is crucial. Scanning probe microscopy (SPM) emerges as the quintessential tool in this regard, owing to its atomic-level spatial precision, ability to detect unitary charges, responsiveness to pico-newton-scale forces, and capability to discern pico-ampere currents. Furthermore, the versatility of SPM to operate under varying environmental conditions, such as different temperatures and in the presence of various gases or liquids, opens up the possibility of studying the stability and reactivity of 2D materials in situ. The characteristic flatness, surface accessibility, ultra-thinness, and weak signal strengths of 2D materials align perfectly with the capabilities of SPM technologies, enabling researchers to uncover the nuanced behaviors and properties of these advanced materials at the nanoscale and even the atomic scale.

Facet-Engineered BiVO4 Photocatalysts for Water Oxidation: Lifetime Gain Versus Energetic Loss

A limiting factor to the efficiency of water Oxygen Evolution Reaction (OER) in metal oxide nanoparticle photocatalysts is the rapid recombination of holes and electrons. Facet-engineering can effectively improve charge separation and, consequently, OER efficiency. However, the kinetics behind this improvement remain poorly understood. This study utilizes photoinduced absorption spectroscopy to investigate the charge yield and kinetics in facet-engineered BiVO4 (F-BiVO4) compared to a non-faceted sample (NF-BiVO4) under operando conditions. A significant influence of preillumination on hole accumulation is observed, linked to the saturation and, thus, passivation of deep and inactive hole traps on the BiVO4 surface. In DI-water, F-BiVO4 shows a 10-fold increase in charge accumulation (∼5 mΔOD) compared to NF-BiVO4 (∼0.5 mΔOD), indicating improved charge separation and stabilization. With the addition of Fe(NO3)3, an efficient electron acceptor, F-BiVO4 demonstrates a 30-fold increase in the accumulation of long-lived holes (∼45 mΔOD), compared to NF-BiVO4 (∼1.5 mΔOD) and an increased half-time, from 2 to 10 s. Based on a simple kinetic model, this increase in hole accumulation suggests that facet-engineering causes at least a 50-100 meV increase in band bending in BiVO4 particles, thereby stabilizing surface holes. This energetic stabilization/loss results in a retardation of OER relative to NF-BiVO4. This slower catalysis is, however, offset by the observed increase in density and lifetime of photoaccumulated holes. Overall, this work quantifies how surface faceting can impact the kinetics of long-lived charge accumulation on metal oxide photocatalysts, highlighting the trade-off between lifetime gain and energetic loss critical to optimizing photocatalytic efficiency.

Molecular picture of electric double layers with weakly adsorbed water

Water adsorption energy, Eads, is a key physical quantity in sustainable chemical technologies such as (photo)electrocatalytic water splitting, water desalination, and water harvesting. In many of these applications, the electrode surface is operated outside the point (potential) of zero charge, which attracts counter-ions to form the electric double layer and controls the surface properties. Here, by applying density functional theory-based finite-field molecular dynamics simulations, we have studied the effect of water adsorption energy Eads on surface acidity and the Helmholtz capacitance of BiVO4 as an example of metal oxide electrodes with weakly chemisorbed water. This allows us to establish the effect of Eads on the coordination number, the H-bond network, and the orientation of chemisorbed water by comparing an oxide series composed of BiVO4, TiO2, and SnO2. In particular, it is found that a positive correlation exists between the degree of asymmetry ΔCH in the Helmholtz capacitance and the strength of Eads. This correlation is verified and extended further to graphene-like systems with physisorbed water, where the electric double layers (EDLs) are controlled by electronic charge rather than proton charge as in the oxide series. Therefore, this work reveals a general relationship between water adsorption energy Eads and EDLs, which is relevant to both electrochemical reactivity and the electrowetting of aqueous interfaces.

Nanometer-Resolved Operando Photo-Response of Faceted BiVO4 Semiconductor Nanoparticles

Photo(electro)catalysis with semiconducting nanoparticles (NPs) is an attractive approach to convert abundant but intermittent renewable electricity into stable chemical fuels. However, our understanding of the microscopic processes governing the performance of the materials has been hampered by the lack of operando characterization techniques with sufficient lateral resolution. Here, we demonstrate that the local surface potentials of NPs of bismuth vanadate (BiVO4) and their response to illumination differ between adjacent facets and depend strongly on the pH of the ambient electrolyte. The isoelectric points of the dominant {010} basal plane and the adjacent {110} side facets differ by 1.5 pH units. Upon illumination, both facets accumulate positive charges and display a maximum surface photoresponse of +55 mV, much stronger than reported in the literature for the surface photo voltage of BiVO4 NPs in air. High resolution images reveal the presence of numerous surface defects ranging from vacancies of a few atoms, to single unit cell steps, to microfacets of variable orientation and degree of disorder. These defects typically carry a highly localized negative surface charge density and display an opposite photoresponse compared to the adjacent facets. Strategies to model and optimize the performance of photocatalyst NPs, therefore, require an understanding of the distribution of surface defects, including the interaction with ambient electrolyte.

Visualizing Overall Water Splitting on Single Microcrystals of Phosphorus-Doped BiVO4 by Photo-SECM

Particulate bismuth vanadate (BiVO4) has attracted considerable interest as a promising photo(electro)catalyst for visible-light-driven water oxidation; however, overall water splitting (OWS) has been difficult to attain because its conduction band is too positive for efficient hydrogen evolution. Using photoscanning electrochemical microscopy (photo-SECM) with a chemically modified nanotip, we visualized for the first time the OWS at a single truncated bipyramidal microcrystal of phosphorus-doped BiVO4. The tip simultaneously served as a light guide to illuminate the photocatalyst and an electrochemical nanoprobe to observe and quantitatively measure local oxygen and hydrogen fluxes. The obtained current patterns for both O2 and H2 agree well with the accumulation of photogenerated electrons and holes on {010} basal and {110} lateral facets, respectively. The developed experimental approach is an important step toward nanoelectrochemical mapping of the activity of photocatalyst particles at the subfacet level.