Erosion-Driven Enamel Crystallite Growth Phenomenon at the Tooth Surface In Vitro

Nanoscale Study on Noninvasive Prevention of Dental Erosion of Enamel by Silver Diamine Fluoride

Here, we aimed to demonstrate the efficacy of silver diamine fluoride (SDF) in halting dental erosion caused by dietary selection and offer a potential explanation for the underlying mechanism. We investigated the surface chemical and mechanical characteristics of human tooth enamel when exposed to Coca-Cola from 10 s to 1 h, with and without the topical treatment of SDF. We analyzed the mechanical properties by measuring the enamel surface roughness and elastic modulus using atomic force microscopy and the surface chemical composition through x-ray photoelectron spectroscopy and Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy analyses, with scanning electron microscopy as a supplementary characterization method. After 1 h of immersion in Coca-Cola, the roughness changed from 83 to 287 nm for enamel without SDF treatment and 64 to 70 nm for enamel with SDF treatment. Under the same conditions, the elastic modulus changed from 125 GPa to 13 GPa for enamel without SDF treatment and 215 GPa to 205 GPa for enamel with SDF treatment. Topical coating of SDF onto enamel formed a passivation layer composed of fluorapatite and created added fluorine flux in the system, which protected the teeth from demineralization under Coca-Cola etching, as shown by morphology and chemical composition analysis as well as roughness and modulus characterization. Applying SDF to enamel minimizes changes in chemical compositions and surface roughness while improving enamel elastic modulus.

The Remineralization of Enamel from Saliva: A Chemical Perspective

The natural remineralization of enamel is of major importance for oral health. In principle, early erosions (demineralization) induced by acidic beverages and foods as well as initial caries lesions can be covered and remineralized by the deposition of calcium phosphate, i.e., tooth mineral. This remineralization effect is characterized by the presence of calcium and phosphate ions in saliva that form hydroxyapatite on the enamel surface. Although it is apparently a simple crystallization, it turns out that remineralization under in vivo conditions is actually a very complex process. Calcium phosphate can form a number of solid phases of which hydroxyapatite is only one. Precipitation involves the formation of metastable phases like amorphous calcium phosphate that convert into biological apatite in a number of steps. Nanoscopic clusters of calcium phosphate that can attach on the enamel surface are also present in saliva. Thus, remineralization under strictly controlled in vitro conditions (e.g., pH, ion concentrations, no additives) is already complex, but it becomes even more complicated under the actual conditions in the oral cavity. Here, biomolecules are present in saliva, which interact with the forming calcium phosphate mineral. For instance, there are salivary proteins which have the function of inhibiting crystallization to avoid overshooting remineralization. Finally, the presence of bacteria and an extracellular matrix in plaque and the presence of proteins in the pellicle have strong influences on the precipitation on the enamel surface. The current knowledge on the remineralization of the enamel is reviewed from a chemical perspective with a special focus on the underlying crystallization phenomena and the effects of biological compounds that are present in saliva, pellicle, and plaque. Basically, the remineralization of enamel follows the same principles as calculus formation. Notably, both processes are far too complex to be understood on a microscopic basis under in vivo conditions, given the complicated process of mineral formation in the presence of a plethora of foreign ions and biomolecules.

Amelogenin-inspired peptide, calcium phosphate solution, fluoride and their synergistic effect on enamel biomimetic remineralization: an in vitro pH-cycling model

BACKGROUND

Several methods were introduced for enamel biomimetic remineralization that utilize a biomimetic analogue to interact and absorb bioavailable calcium and phosphate ions and induce crystal nucleation on demineralized enamel. Amelogenin is the most predominant enamel matrix protein that is involved in enamel biomineralization. It plays a major role in developing the enamel's hierarchical microstructure. Therefore, this study was conducted to evaluate the ability of an amelogenin-inspired peptide to promote the remineralization potential of fluoride and a supersaturated calcium phosphate solution in treating artificially induced enamel carious lesions under pH-cycling regimen.

METHODS

Fifty enamel slices were prepared with a window (4*4 mm2 ) on the surface. Five samples were set as control healthy enamel and 45 samples were subjected to demineralization for 3 days. Another 5 samples were set as control demineralized enamel and 40 enamel samples were assigned into 8 experimental groups (n=5) (P/I, P/II, P/III, P/AS, NP/I, NP/II, NP/III and NP/AS) according to peptide treatment (peptide P or non-peptide NP) and remineralizing solution used (I; calcium phosphate solution, II; calcium phosphate fluoride solution, III; fluoride solution and AS; artificial saliva). Samples were then subjected to demineralization/remineralization cycles for 9 days. Samples in all experimental groups were evaluated using Raman spectroscopy for mineral content recovery percentage, microhardness and nanoindentation as healthy, demineralized enamel and after pH-cycling. Data were statistically analysed using two-way repeated measures Anova followed by Bonferroni-corrected post hoc test for pairwise multiple comparisons between groups. Statistical significance was set at p= 0.05. Additionally, XRD, FESEM and EDXS were used for crystal orientation, surface morphology and elemental analysis after pH-cycling.

RESULTS

Nanocrystals clumped in a directional manner were detected in peptide-treated groups. P/II showed the highest significant mean values in mineral content recovery (63.31%), microhardness (268.81±6.52 VHN), elastic modulus (88.74±2.71 GPa), nanohardness (3.08±0.59 GPa) and the best crystal orientation with I002/I300 (1.87±0.08).

CONCLUSION

Despite pH changes, the tested peptide was capable of remineralizing enamel with ordered crystals. Moreover, the supplementary use of calcium phosphate fluoride solution with peptide granted an enhancement in enamel mechanical properties after remineralization.