Why Are Water Droplets Highly Mobile on Nanostructured Oil-Impregnated Surfaces?

Unraveling the anti-biofouling mechanisms of slippery liquid-infused porous surface from molecular interaction perspective

Newly developed slippery liquid-infused porous surfaces (SLIPS) exhibit highly effective anti-fouling performance without harming organisms, making them a promising solution for both environmental and material protection. However, previous studies have primarily understood the anti-fouling effects of SLIPS from a mechanical perspective, neglecting the atomic interactions involved in the anti-fouling process. In this study, we combined microbiological experiments with multi-scale simulations to elucidate the microscopic mechanisms behind the unique anti-biofouling effects of SLIPS. After developing SLIPS with robust liquid-repellency, we characterized its physical and chemical properties and demonstrated its superior effectiveness in preventing Pseudomonas aeruginosa attachment. To probe the initial contact during bacterial attachment, all-atom molecular dynamics (MD) simulations were conducted, revealing that the liquid-liquid interface suppresses the effective pilin adhesion on SLIPS. Further analysis through steered MD, ab initio MD, and density functional theory calculations revealed that the flexible siloxane backbone and the non-polar nature of silicone oil molecules enhance the diffusivity of interfacial water and lead to the continuous nanoscale fluctuation of liquid-liquid interface, thus inhibiting the role of protein dynamics in promoting bio-adhesion. These novel insights into the characteristics of liquid-liquid and nano-bio interface during the anti-biofouling process of SLIPS may promote the future development of bio-inspired functional surfaces.

Enhancing Liquid-Vapor Phase-Change Heat Transfer with Micro/Nano-Structured Surfaces

Liquid-vapor phase-change heat transfer plays an important role in many industrial systems, ranging from power generation and air conditioning to water desalination, food processing, and thermal management of electronics and data centers. Recent advances in micro/nanofabrication have enabled desirable manipulation of multiscale dynamics governing droplet/bubble motion and capillary liquid flows for highly efficient phase-change heat transfer. However, there lacks a comprehensive review on the design and fabrication of micro/nanostructured surfaces with controlled morphology and wettability, to enhance the diverse phase-change heat transfer processes. Here, we review the advances in micro/nanostructuring for phase-change heat transfer applications. While traditional mechanical machining and sintering have commonly been used to manufacture structures down to sub-millimeter or micron scales, advanced micro/nanostructure fabrication methods such as laser texturing, oxidation, lithography-based etching, and spray coating are being utilized to manufacture surfaces with hierarchical structures or heterogeneous wettability. Droplets, bubbles, and liquid films generally experience a multiscale life cycle from nanometer scale to millimeter scale in the phase-change processes, including condensation, pool boiling, capillary-driven evaporation, and liquid film boiling. Micro/nanostructured surfaces need to be designed to coordinate different requirements of the surface wettability and morphology for the multiscale dynamics of droplets, bubbles, and films including increased nucleation, facilitated growth, accelerated transport, and departure. For active phase-change processes with pump-driven flow, including flow condensation, flow boiling, jet impingement boiling, and spray cooling, the enhancement strategies using functionalized micro/nanostructures focus on sustaining thin liquid films, strengthening thin film evaporation, promoting nucleate boiling, and regulating bubble departure within the convective liquid film. We conclude this review by a short discussion on the practical aspects of micro/nanoenabled phase-change heat transfer including reliability and scalability.

Molecular Structures of Surfaces and Interfaces of Poly(dimethylsiloxane) Incorporated with Silicone Oils Containing Phenyl Functionality

Poly(dimethylsiloxane) (PDMS) materials have been widely researched and applied as fouling-release coatings. Incorporation of silicone oils into PDMS has been shown to improve the antifouling properties of PDMS materials. In this research, we applied sum frequency generation (SFG) vibrational spectroscopy to study PDMS materials incorporated with various silicone oils containing phenyl groups in air, water, and protein solutions. It was found that the surface structures of various silicone oils varied, which results in different surface structures of PDMS with different oils incorporated. Such different PDMS surfaces interact with water molecules differently, leading to different surface hydrations. A model protein, fibrinogen, was used to study molecular interactions between oil-incorporated PDMS and biological molecules, testing the antifouling and fouling-release performance of different PDMS materials. It was found that fibrinogen has different adsorption behaviors on different PDMS surfaces, while adsorbed fibrinogen adopts bent structures. This study demonstrated that SFG can be used to deduce molecular information on silicone oil, PDMS, water, and fibrinogen on surfaces/at interfaces in situ in real-time. The different silicone oils incorporated into PDMS changed the PDMS surfaces, leading to varied interactions with water and biological media, influencing the antifouling and fouling-release activities. In most cases, the presence of silicone oils could enhance the surface hydration. However, the presence of phenyl groups could reduce the level of surface hydration. Nevertheless, our studies demonstrated that incorporation of silicone oils into PDMS led to better antifouling or fouling-release properties.

Molecular Structures of Poly(methyl methacrylate) at Different Buried Interfaces Revealed by Sum Frequency Generation Vibrational Spectroscopy

Silica or calcium fluoride (CaF2) substrate-supported poly(methyl methacrylate) (PMMA) thin films as insulating layers are commonly used in photoelectric/photovoltaic devices to improve the efficiency or stability of these devices. However, a comparative investigation of molecular structures at buried PMMA/silica and PMMA/CaF2 interfaces under thermal stimuli remains unexplored. In this study, we qualitatively and quantitatively revealed different molecular orderings and orientations of PMMA at two interfaces before and after annealing using sum frequency generation (SFG) vibrational spectroscopy. SFG vibrations were carefully assigned by using various deuterated PMMAs. SFG results indicated that, at the buried PMMA/silica interface, the side OCH3 groups were prone to lie down before annealing and tended to stand up after annealing. In contrast, the case was the opposite at the buried PMMA/CaF2 interface. The relative hydrophobicity/hydrophilicity of the two substrates and the developed hydrogen bonds upon annealing at the buried PMMA/silica interface, which is absent at the CaF2 surface, are believed to be the driving forces for different interfacial molecular structures. This study benefits the molecular-level understanding of the interfacial local structural relaxation of polymers at buried interfaces and the rational design of photoelectric/photovoltaic devices from the molecular level.

Pinning Forces on the Omniphobic Dry, Liquid-Infused, and Liquid-Attached Surfaces

Omniphobic coatings effectively repelling water, oils, and other liquids are of great interest and have a broad number of applications including self-cleaning, anti-icing surfaces, biofouling protection, selective filtration, etc. To create such coatings, one should minimize the pinning force that resists droplet motion and causes contact angle hysteresis. The minimization of the free surface energy by means of the chemical modification of the solid surface is not enough to obtain a nonsticky slippery omniphobic surface. One should minimize the contact between the solid and the droplet. Besides coating the surface with flat polymer films, among the major approaches to create omniphobic coatings, one can reveal "lotus effect" textured coatings, slippery liquid-infused porous surfaces (SLIPS), and slippery omniphobic covalently attached liquid (SOCAL) coatings. It is possible to turn one surface type into other by texturizing, impregnating with liquids, or grafting flexible liquid-like polymer chains. There are a number of models describing the pinning force on surfaces, but the transitions between states with different wetting regimes remain poorly understood. At the same time, such studies can significantly broaden existing ideas about the physics of wetting, help to design coatings, and also contribute to the development of generalized models of the pinning force. Here we review the existing pinning force (contact angle hysteresis) models on various omniphobic substrates. Also, we discuss the current studies of the pinning force in the transitions between different wetting regimes.

Building Functional Liquid-Based Interfaces: From Mechanism to Application

Functional liquid-based interfaces, with their inhomogeneous regions that emphasize the functionalized liquids, have attracted much interest as a versatile platform for a broad spectrum of applications, from chemical manufacturing to practical uses. These interfaces leverage the physicochemical characteristics of liquids, alongside dynamic behaviors induced by macroscopic wettability and microscopic molecular exchange balance, to allow for tailored properties within their functional structures. In this Minireview, we provide a foundational overview of these functional interfaces, based on the structural investigations and molecular mechanisms of interaction forces that directly modulate functionalities. Then, we discuss design strategies that have been employed in recent applications, and the crucial aspects that require focus. Finally, we highlight the current challenges in functional liquid-based interfaces and provide a perspective on future research directions.

Visualization and Experimental Characterization of Wrapping Layer Using Planar Laser-Induced Fluorescence

Droplets on nanotextured oil-impregnated surfaces have high mobility due to record-low contact angle hysteresis (∼1-3°), attributed to the absence of solid-liquid contact. Past studies have utilized the ultralow droplet adhesion on these surfaces to improve condensation, reduce hydrodynamic drag, and inhibit biofouling. Despite their promising utility, oil-impregnated surfaces are not fully embraced by industry because of the concern for lubricant depletion, the source of which has not been adequately studied. Here, we use planar laser-induced fluorescence (PLIF) to not only visualize the oil layer encapsulating the droplet (aka wrapping layer) but also measure its thickness since the wrapping layer contributes to lubricant depletion. Our PLIF visualization and experiments show that (a) due to the imbalance of interfacial forces at the three-phase contact line, silicone oil forms a wrapping layer on the outer surface of water droplets, (b) the thickness of the wrapping layer is nonuniform both in space and time, and (c) the time-average thickness of the wrapping layer is ∼50 ± 10 nm, a result that compares favorably with our scaling analysis (∼50 nm), which balances the curvature-induced capillary force with the intermolecular van der Waals forces. Our experiments show that, unlike silicone oil, mineral oil does not form a wrapping layer, an observation that can be exploited to mitigate oil depletion of nanotextured oil-impregnated surfaces. Besides advancing our mechanistic understanding of the wrapping oil layer dynamics, the insights gained from this work can be used to quantify the lubricant depletion rate by pendant droplets in dropwise condensation and water harvesting.

Electric-Field-Induced Selective Directed Transport of Diverse Droplets

Droplet directional transport is one of the central topics in microfluidics and lab-on-a-chip applications. Selective transport of diverse droplets, particularly in another liquid phase environment with controlled directions, is still challenging. In this work, we propose an electric-field gradient-driven droplet directional transport platform facilitated by a robust lubricant surface. On the platform, we clearly demonstrated a liquid-inherent critical frequency-dominated selective transport of diverse droplets and a driving mechanism transition from electrowetting to liquid dielectrophoresis. Enlightened by the Kelvin-Helmholtz theory, we first realize the directional droplet transport in another liquid phase whenever a permittivity difference exists. Co-transport of multiple droplets and various combinations of droplet types, as well as multifunctional droplet transport modes, are realized based on the presented powerful electric-field gradient-driven platform, overcoming the limitations of the surrounding environment, liquid conductivity, and intrinsic solid-liquid wetting property existing in traditional droplet transport strategies. This work may inspire new applications in liquid separation, multiphase microfluidic manipulation, chemical reagent selection, and so on.

Droplet Manipulation on Lubricant Self-Mediating Slippery PDMS Films

Further exploration is needed for sustainable and precise droplet manipulation on intelligent surfaces, especially the problem of SLIPS failure caused by lubricant loss. In this work, a self-mediating photothermal lubrication surface was designed. Through a simple preparation method, it was possible to generate a new lubrication layer through near-infrared light (NIL) and perform sustainable and precise droplet manipulation even after the surface lubricant was consumed. The thermal expansion film obtained from polydimethylsiloxane (PDMS) and nano ferric oxide, combined with the connected structure obtained through laser etching technology, effectively preserve lubricating oil. After the surface lubricating oil is consumed, under the action of NIL, the lubricating oil inside the film is squeezed out, forming a new lubricating layer. At the same time, programmable droplet transport can be achieved by inducing the direction of NIL. After turning off NIL, the lubricating oil is absorbed into the network structure, achieving good circulation. This not only reduces the loss of lubricating oil, but also facilitates the manipulation of droplets. In addition, the movement (plane and antigravity) and splitting behavior of droplets are also discussed. This sustainable and precise manipulation of liquid droplets on the LSSPF (lubricant self-mediating slippery PDMS films) surface can be widely applied in various micro reaction devices.

Synergistic Benefits of Micro/Nanostructured Oil-Impregnated Surfaces in Reducing Fouling while Enhancing Heat Transfer

Liquid-liquid heat exchangers that operate in marine environments are susceptible to biofouling, which decreases the overall heat exchange between hot and cold liquids by increasing the conduction resistance. Recently, micro/nanostructured oil-impregnated surfaces have been shown to significantly reduce biofouling. However, their potential as a heat exchanger material has not been studied. Neither is it obvious since the oil used for impregnation increases the wall thickness and the associated conduction resistance. Here, by conducting extensive field and laboratory studies supported by theoretical modeling of heat transfer in oil-infused heat exchanger tubes, we report the synergistic benefits of micro/nanostructured oil-impregnated surfaces for reducing biofouling while maintaining good heat transfer. These benefits justify the use of lubricant-infused surfaces as heat exchanger materials, in particular in marine environments.

Durable Hydrate-phobic Coating with In Situ Self-Replenishing Hydrocarbon Barrier Films for Low Clathrate Hydrate Adhesion

Clathrate hydrate growth, deposition, and plug formation during oil and gas transportation causes blockage of pipelines. An effective strategy to solve this problem is to mitigate the hydrate formation and reduce its adhesion on pipe walls through a coating process. However, durability failure, corrosion, inability to self-heal, high cost, and strong hydrate adhesion remain unsolved issues. To address these challenges, in this work, we present an in situ self-replenishing nonfluorinated durable hydrate-phobic coating of candle soot particles. The candle soot coating reduces hydrate adhesion by promoting a thick barrier film of hydrocarbons between the hydrate and the soot coated substrate. The hydrocarbons permeating the soot coating display a high contact angle for water and inhibit the formation of water bridges between the hydrate and soot coated substrate. The spherical cyclopentane hydrate slides off easily on the candle soot coating inside the cyclopentane environment. The hydrate former, cyclopentane-water emulsion, and THF-water mixture have high contact angles as well as low hydrate adhesion on soot coating simultaneously. In addition, the coating is flow-induced long-term slippery, durable, low cost, anticorrosion, self-cleaning, and suitable for practical applications.

Laser-Enabled Surface Treatment of Disposable Endoscope Lens with Superior Antifouling and Optical Properties

Endoscopes are ubiquitous in minimally invasive or keyhole surgeries globally. However, frequent removal of endoscopes from the patient's body due to the lens contaminations results in undesirable consequences. Therefore, a cost-effective process chain to fabricate thermoplastic-based endoscope lenses with superior antifouling and optical properties is proposed in this research. Such multifunctional surface response was achieved by lubricant impregnation of nanostructures. Two types of topographies were produced by femtosecond laser processing of metallic molds, especially to produce single-tier laser-induced periodic surface structures (LIPSS) and two-tier multiscale structures (MS). Then, these two LIPSS and MS masters were used to replicate them onto two thermoplastic substrates, namely polycarbonate and cyclic olefin copolymer, by using hot embossing. Finally, the LIPSS and MS surfaces of the replicas were infiltrated by silicone oils to prepare lubricant-impregnated surfaces (LIS). Droplet sliding tests revealed that the durability of the as-prepared LIS improved with the increase of the lubricant viscosity. Moreover, the single-tier LIPSS replicas exhibited longer-lasting lubricant conservation properties than the MS ones. Also, LIPSS-LIS replicas demonstrated an excellent optical transparency, better than the MS-LIS ones, and almost match the performance of the reference polished ones. Furthermore, the LIPSS-LIS treatment led to superior antifouling characteristics, i.e., regarding fogging, blood adhesion, protein adsorption, and microalgae attachment, and thus demonstrated its high suitability for treating endoscopic lenses. Finally, a proof-of-concept LIPSS-LIS treatment of endoscope lenses was conducted that confirmed their superior multifunctional response.

Oscillations of Drops with Mobile Contact Lines on the International Space Station: Elucidation of Terrestrial Inertial Droplet Spreading

We analyze shape oscillations of sessile water drops with fully mobile contact lines (CL) aboard the International Space Station. The unique microgravity environment enables the study of centimeter-sized droplets with associated inertial-capillary motions. Plane-normal substrate vibrations induce resonance behaviors quantified by frequency scans from which the natural frequencies and mode shapes are identified for nine different hydrophobic surfaces. Experimental observations agree well with, and validate, a recent spectral prediction of mobile CL sessile drop oscillations. The experimental findings help elucidate terrestrial droplet inertial spreading, a poorly understood phenomenon pervasive in many processes.

Design of Robust Lubricant-Infused Surfaces for Anti-Corrosion

A lubricant-infused surface such as an oil-impregnated porous surface has great potentials for various applications due to its omniphobicity. However, the drainage and depletion of the lubricant liquid oil remain practical concerns for real applications. Here, we investigate the effect of a specially designed bottle-shaped nanopore of anodic aluminum oxide, which has a smaller pore diameter in the upper region than the lower one, on the oil retentivity and anti-corrosion efficacy. The effects of the viscosity and volatility of the lubricant oil were further investigated for synergy. Results show that the bottle-shaped pore helps to stably immobilize the lubricant oil in the nanostructure and significantly enhances the robustness and anti-corrosion efficacy, compared to the conventional cylindrical pores with straight walls as well as the hybrid one featured with additional pillar structures. Moreover, the enlarged oil capacity in the bottle-shaped pore allows the oil to cover the underlying metallic surface effectively at cracks, enhancing the damage tolerance with a unique self-healing capability. The oil with a higher viscosity further enhances the benefits so that the bottle-shaped pore impregnated with a higher-viscosity oil shows greater anti-corrosion efficacy. It suggests that the combination of the geometric features of nanopores and the fluid properties of lubricant liquid can lead to a maximized longevity and anti-corrosion efficacy of the liquid-infused surfaces for real applications.

Bioinspired functional SLIPSs and wettability gradient surfaces and their synergistic cooperation and opportunities for enhanced condensate and fluid transport

Bioinspired smart functional surfaces have received increasing attention in recent years owed to their tunable wettability and enhanced droplet transport suggesting them as excellent candidates for industrial and nanotechnology-related applications. More specifically, bioinspired slippery lubricant infused porous surfaces (SLIPSs) have been proposed for their low adhesion enabling continuous dropwise condensation (DWC) even of low-surface tension fluids. In addition, functional surfaces with chemical and/or structural wettability gradients have also been exploited empowering spontaneous droplet transport in a controlled manner. Current research has focused on the better understanding of the mechanisms and intimate interactions taking place between liquid droplets and functional surfaces or on the forces imposed by differences in surface wettability and/or by Laplace pressure owed to chemical or structural gradients. Nonetheless, less attention has been paid to the synergistic cooperation of efficiently driving droplet transport via chemical and/or structural patterns/gradients on a low surface energy/adhesion background imposed by SLIPSs, with the consequent promising potential for microfluidics and condensation heat transfer applications amongst others. This review provides a detailed and timely overview and summary on recent advances and developments on bioinspired SLIPSs and on wettability gradient surfaces with focus on their synergistic cooperation for condensation and fluid transport related applications. Firstly, the fundamental theory and mechanisms governing complex droplet transport on homogeneous, on wettability gradient surfaces and on inclined SLIPSs are introduced. Secondly, recent advances on the fabrication and characterization of SLIPSs and functional surfaces are presented. Then, the condensation performance on such functional surfaces comprising chemical or structural wettability gradients is reviewed and their applications on condensation heat transfer are summarized. Last a summary outlook highlighting the opportunities and challenges on the synergistic cooperation of SLIPSs and wettability gradient surfaces for heat transfer as well as future perspective in modern applications are presented.

Robust and durable liquid-repellent surfaces

This review provides a comprehensive summary of characterization, design, fabrication, and application of robust and durable liquid-repellent surfaces.

Investigating Thin Silicone Oil Films Using Four-Wave Mixing Spectroscopy and Sum Frequency Generation Vibrational Spectroscopy

This article applies four-wave mixing (FWM) spectroscopy, a third-order nonlinear optical spectroscopic technique which is not intrinsically surface- or interface-sensitive, to study silicone oil thin films, supplemented by second-order nonlinear-optical sum frequency generation (SFG) vibrational spectroscopy. Although studies of thin organic films using coherent antistokes Raman spectroscopy (CARS), a special case of FWM, have been reported previously, in this study we demonstrate the feasibility of using a more general FWM process which involves three independent excitation laser beams to investigate silicone oil thin films. The results show that the FWM method has the potential to detect and provide molecular-level information on ultrathin silicone oil layers, down to a film thickness of 1 nm. This developed FWM methodology is widely applicable and can be utilized to study important issues in the biopharmaceutical field, e.g., to examine the distribution of silicone oil on syringe glass surfaces with subnanometer sensitivity. It can also be used to study the potentially slow reactions between silicone oil and glass surfaces as proposed in the literature but without direct molecular-level information.

Enhanced Water Nucleation and Growth Based on Microdroplet Mobility on Lubricant-Infused Surfaces

Lubricant-infused surfaces (LISs) can promote stable dropwise condensation and improve heat transfer rates due to a low nucleation free-energy barrier and high droplet mobility. Recent studies showed that oil menisci surrounding condensate microdroplets form distinct oil-rich and oil-poor regions. These topographical differences in the oil surface cause water microdroplets to rigorously self-propel long distances, continuously redistributing the oil film and potentially refreshing the surface for re-nucleation. However, the dynamic interplay between oil film redistribution, microdroplet self-propulsion, and droplet nucleation and growth is not yet understood. Using high-speed microscopy, we reveal that during water condensation on LISs, the smallest visible droplets (diameter: ∼1 μm, qualitatively representing nucleation) predominantly emerge in oil-poor regions due to a lower nucleation free-energy barrier. Considering the significant heat transfer performance of microdroplets (<10 μm) and transient characteristic of microdroplet movement, we compare the apparent nucleation rate density and water collection rate for LISs with oils of different viscosities and a solid hydrophobic surface at a wide range of subcooling temperatures. Generally, the lowest lubricant viscosity leads to the highest nucleation rate density. We characterize the length and frequency of microdroplet movement and attribute the nucleation enhancement primarily to higher droplet mobility and surface refreshing frequency. Interestingly and unexpectedly, hydrophobic surfaces outperform high-viscosity LISs at high subcooling temperatures but are generally inferior to any of the tested LISs at low temperature differences. To explain the observed nonlinearity between LISs and the solid hydrophobic surface, we introduce two dominant regimes that influence the condensation efficiency: mobility-limited and coalescence-limited. We compare these regimes based on droplet growth rates and water collection rates on the different surfaces. Our findings advance the understanding of dynamic water-lubricant interactions and provide new design rationales for choosing surfaces for enhanced dropwise condensation and water collection efficiencies.

Enhanced condensation heat transfer using porous silica inverse opal coatings on copper tubes

Phase-change condensation is commonplace in nature and industry. Since the 1930s, it is well understood that vapor condenses in filmwise mode on clean metallic surfaces whereas it condenses by forming discrete droplets on surfaces coated with a promoter material. In both filmwise and dropwise modes, the condensate is removed when gravity overcomes pinning forces. In this work, we show rapid condensate transport through cracks that formed due to material shrinkage when a copper tube is coated with silica inverse opal structures. Importantly, the high hydraulic conductivity of the cracks promote axial condensate transport that is beneficial for condensation heat transfer. In our experiments, the cracks improved the heat transfer coefficient from ≈ 12 kW/m² K for laminar filmwise condensation on smooth clean copper tubes to ≈ 80 kW/m² K for inverse opal coated copper tubes; nearly a sevenfold increase from filmwise condensation and identical enhancement with state-of-the-art dropwise condensation. Furthermore, our results show that impregnating the porous structure with oil further improves the heat transfer coefficient by an additional 30% to ≈ 103 kW/m² K. Importantly, compared to the fast-degrading dropwise condensation, the inverse opal coated copper tubes maintained high heat transfer rates when the experiments were repeated > 20 times; each experiment lasting 3–4 h. In addition to the new coating approach, the insights gained from this work present a strategy to minimize oil depletion during condensation from lubricated surfaces.