Discovery of a Celecoxib Binding Site on Prostaglandin E Synthase (PTGES) with a Cleavable Chelation-Assisted Biotin Probe

Probing the E3 Ligase Adapter Cereblon with Chemical Biology

ConspectusThe E3 ligase substrate adapter cereblon (CRBN) has garnered widespread interest from the research laboratory to the clinic. CRBN was first discovered for its association with neurological development and subsequently identified as the target of thalidomide and lenalidomide, therapeutic agents used in the treatment of hematopoietic malignancies. Both thalidomide and lenalidomide have been repurposed as ligands for targeted protein degradation therapeutic modalities. These agents were proposed to mimic a naturally occurring ligand, although the native substrate recognition mechanism of CRBN remained elusive. Chemical biology, which involves the use of chemical tools to modulate and probe biological systems, can provide unique insights into the molecular mechanisms and interactions of proteins with their cognate ligands. Here we describe our use of chemical biology approaches, including photoaffinity labeling, chemical proteomics, and targeted protein degradation, to interrogate the biological activities of CRBN in the presence or absence of its ligands. Our development of a photoaffinity labeling probe derived from lenalidomide, termed photolenalidomide, enabled mapping of the binding site on CRBN and identification of a new target recruited to CRBN by lenalidomide through chemical proteomics. Further derivatization of the lenalidomide scaffold afforded DEG-77, a potent degrader with therapeutic efficacy against acute myeloid leukemia. Our parallel development of chemically defined probes that are inspired by heterobifunctional targeted protein degradation agents and functionally engage CRBN in cells revealed that thalidomide is a peptidomimetic of an underappreciated protein modification termed the C-terminal cyclic imide, which arises from intramolecular cyclization of asparagine or glutamine residues and represents a degron endogenously recognized by CRBN. Protein engineering and proteomic efforts validated the CRBN-dependent regulation of proteins bearing the C-terminal cyclic imide modification in vitro and in cells and the prevalence of the C-terminal cyclic imide in the biological system. Application of C-terminal cyclic imides as a class of cyclimid ligands for targeted protein degradation led to the development of a variety of heterobifunctional degraders with distinct efficacy and target selectivity, whereas examination of the occurrence of C-terminal cyclic imides as a form of protein damage uncovered the intrinsic and extrinsic factors that predispose peptides and proteins to C-terminal cyclic imide formation and the role of CRBN in mitigating the accumulation of damaged proteins with a propensity for aggregation. Future investigation of C-terminal cyclic imides, synthetic ligands, and their relationship to CRBN biology will illuminate regulatory mechanisms that are controlled by CRBN and drive the pursuit of additional functional chemistries on proteins and the biological pathways that intercept them.

End-to-End Throughput Chemical Proteomics for Photoaffinity Labeling Target Engagement and Deconvolution

Photoaffinity labeling (PAL) methodologies have proven to be instrumental for the unbiased deconvolution of protein-ligand binding events in physiologically relevant systems. However, like other chemical proteomic workflows, they are limited in many ways by time-intensive sample manipulations and data acquisition techniques. Here, we describe an approach to address this challenge through the innovation of a carboxylate bead-based protein cleanup procedure to remove excess small-molecule contaminants and couple it to plate-based, proteomic sample processing as a semiautomated solution. The analysis of samples via label-free, data-independent acquisition (DIA) techniques led to significant improvements on a workflow time per sample basis over current standard practices. Experiments utilizing three established PAL ligands with known targets, (+)-JQ-1, lenalidomide, and dasatinib, demonstrated the utility of having the flexibility to design experiments with a myriad of variables. Data revealed that this workflow can enable the confident identification and rank ordering of known and putative targets with outstanding protein signal-to-background enrichment sensitivity. This unified end-to-end throughput strategy for processing and analyzing these complex samples could greatly facilitate efficient drug discovery efforts and open up new opportunities in the chemical proteomics field.

Chemical proteomic mapping of reversible small molecule binding sites in native systems

The impact of small molecules in human biology are manifold; not only are they critical regulators of physiological processes, but they also serve as probes to investigate biological pathways and leads for therapeutic development. Identifying the protein targets of small molecules, and where they bind, is critical to understanding their functional consequences and potential for pharmacological use. Over the past two decades, chemical proteomics has emerged as a go-to strategy for the comprehensive mapping of small molecule-protein interactions. Recent advancements in this field, particularly innovations of photoaffinity labeling (PAL)-based methods, have enabled the robust identification of small molecule binding sites on protein targets, often in live cells. In this opinion article, we examine these advancements as well as reflect on how their strategic integration with other emerging tools can advance therapeutic development.

Functionalizing tandem mass tags for streamlining click-based quantitative chemoproteomics

Mapping the ligandability or potential druggability of all proteins in the human proteome is a central goal of mass spectrometry-based covalent chemoproteomics. Achieving this ambitious objective requires high throughput and high coverage sample preparation and liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry analysis for hundreds to thousands of reactive compounds and chemical probes. Conducting chemoproteomic screens at this scale benefits from technical innovations that achieve increased sample throughput. Here we realize this vision by establishing the silane-based cleavable linkers for isotopically-labeled proteomics-tandem mass tag (sCIP-TMT) proteomic platform, which is distinguished by early sample pooling that increases sample preparation throughput. sCIP-TMT pairs a custom click-compatible sCIP capture reagent that is readily functionalized in high yield with commercially available TMT reagents. Synthesis and benchmarking of a 10-plex set of sCIP-TMT reveal a substantial decrease in sample preparation time together with high coverage and high accuracy quantification. By screening a focused set of four cysteine-reactive electrophiles, we demonstrate the utility of sCIP-TMT for chemoproteomic target hunting, identifying 789 total liganded cysteines. Distinguished by its compatibility with established enrichment and quantification protocols, we expect sCIP-TMT will readily translate to a wide range of covalent chemoproteomic applications.

Copper-Catalyzed Azide-Alkyne Cycloaddition-Oriented Multifunctional Bio-Orthogonal Linker BPPA: Design, Synthesis and Evaluation

The multifunctional linker molecules are crucial for the bio-orthogonal reaction for proteomic target profiling. Herein, we wish to present a novel type of biotin-based tetra-functional bio-orthogonal linkers 3a-3h named BPPA which, possessing a unique photolabile phenacyl ester motif, were readily prepared in 85-90% yields by a simple and green one-step protocol from commercially available and inexpensive reagents of biotin acids and 4'-ethynyl/azido 2-bromoacetophenones. The typical click reaction of BPPA linkers 3a and 3e via copper-catalyzed azide-alkyne cycloaddition (CuAAC) took place easily, resulting in the corresponding BPPA-triazole adducts 4a and 4b in nearly quantitative yields. A further cleavability evaluation of 4a and 4b demonstrated that the expected C-O bond detachment could be accomplished efficiently and rapidly by UV irradiation or by ammonia hydrolysis, respectively, resulting in the residual (hydroxyl)acetylphenyl triazole fragment supposed to be attached to proteins during biological manipulations. The BPPA linkers, with dual clickable options of either the terminal azide or alkyne clickable group, exhibit high potentials for various CuAAC-oriented bio-orthogonal reactions.

Solid-Phase Compatible Silane-Based Cleavable Linker Enables Custom Isobaric Quantitative Chemoproteomics

Mass spectrometry-based chemoproteomics has emerged as an enabling technology for functional biology and drug discovery. To address limitations of established chemoproteomics workflows, including cumbersome reagent synthesis and low throughput sample preparation, here, we established the silane-based cleavable isotopically labeled proteomics (sCIP) method. The sCIP method is enabled by a high yielding and scalable route to dialkoxydiphenylsilane fluorenylmethyloxycarbonyl (DADPS-Fmoc)-protected amino acid building blocks, which enable the facile synthesis of customizable, isotopically labeled, and chemically cleavable biotin capture reagents. sCIP is compatible with both MS1- and MS2-based quantitation, and the sCIP-MS2 method is distinguished by its click-assembled isobaric tags in which the reporter group is encoded in the sCIP capture reagent and balancer in the pan cysteine-reactive probe. The sCIP-MS2 workflow streamlines sample preparation with early stage isobaric labeling and sample pooling, allowing for high coverage and increased sample throughput via customized low cost six-plex sample multiplexing. When paired with a custom FragPipe data analysis workflow and applied to cysteine-reactive fragment screens, sCIP proteomics revealed established and unprecedented cysteine-ligand pairs, including the discovery that mitochondrial uncoupling agent FCCP acts as a covalent-reversible cysteine-reactive electrophile.

Sanglifehrin A mitigates multi-organ fibrosis in vivo by inducing secretion of the collagen chaperone cyclophilin B

Pathological deposition and crosslinking of collagen type I by activated myofibroblasts drives progressive tissue fibrosis. Therapies that inhibit collagen synthesis by myofibroblasts have clinical potential as anti-fibrotic agents. Lysine hydroxylation by the prolyl-3-hydroxylase complex, comprised of cartilage associated protein, prolyl 3-hydroxylase 1, and cyclophilin B, is essential for collagen type I crosslinking and formation of stable fibers. Here, we identify the collagen chaperone cyclophilin B as a major cellular target of the macrocyclic natural product sanglifehrin A (SfA) using photo-affinity labeling and chemical proteomics. Our studies reveal a unique mechanism of action in which SfA binding to cyclophilin B in the endoplasmic reticulum (ER) induces the secretion of cyclophilin B to the extracellular space, preventing TGF-β1-activated myofibroblasts from synthesizing collagen type I in vitro without inhibiting collagen type I mRNA transcription or inducing ER stress. In addition, SfA prevents collagen type I secretion without affecting myofibroblast contractility or TGF-β1 signaling. In vivo, we provide chemical, molecular, functional, and translational evidence that SfA mitigates the development of lung and skin fibrosis in mouse models by inducing cyclophilin B secretion, thereby inhibiting collagen synthesis from fibrotic fibroblasts in vivo . Consistent with these findings in preclinical models, SfA reduces collagen type I secretion from fibrotic human lung fibroblasts and precision cut lung slices from patients with idiopathic pulmonary fibrosis, a fatal fibrotic lung disease with limited therapeutic options. Our results identify the primary liganded target of SfA in cells, the collagen chaperone cyclophilin B, as a new mechanistic target for the treatment of organ fibrosis.

A Chemoproteomics Approach to Profile Phospholipase D-Derived Phosphatidyl Alcohol Interactions

Alcohol consumption leads to formation of phosphatidylethanol (PEth) via the transphosphatidylation activity of phospholipase D (PLD) enzymes. Though this non-natural phospholipid routinely serves as a biomarker of chronic alcoholism, its pathophysiological roles remain unknown. We use a minimalist diazirine alkyne alcohol as an ethanol surrogate to generate clickable, photoaffinity lipid reporters of PEth localization and lipid-protein interactions via PLD-mediated transphosphatidylation. We use these tools to visualize phosphatidyl alcohols in a manner compatible with standard permeabilization and immunofluorescence methods. We also use click chemistry tagging, enrichment, and proteomics analysis to define the phosphatidyl alcohol interactome. Our analysis reveals an enrichment of putative interactors at various membrane locations, and we validate one such interaction with the single-pass transmembrane protein basigin/CD147. This study provides a comprehensive view of the molecular interactions of phosphatidyl alcohols with the cellular proteome and points to future work to connect such interactions to potential pathophysiological roles of PEth.

A general approach to identify cell-permeable and synthetic anti-CRISPR small molecules

The need to control the activity and fidelity of CRISPR-associated nucleases has resulted in a demand for inhibitory anti-CRISPR molecules. The small-molecule inhibitor discovery platforms available at present are not generalizable to multiple nuclease classes, only target the initial step in the catalytic activity and require high concentrations of nuclease, resulting in inhibitors with suboptimal attributes, including poor potency. Here we report a high-throughput discovery pipeline consisting of a fluorescence resonance energy transfer-based assay that is generalizable to contemporary and emerging nucleases, operates at low nuclease concentrations and targets all catalytic steps. We applied this pipeline to identify BRD7586, a cell-permeable small-molecule inhibitor of SpCas9 that is twofold more potent than other inhibitors identified to date. Furthermore, unlike the reported inhibitors, BRD7586 enhanced SpCas9 specificity and its activity was independent of the genomic loci, DNA-repair pathway or mode of nuclease delivery. Overall, these studies describe a general pipeline to identify inhibitors of contemporary and emerging CRISPR-associated nucleases.

Design and Evaluation of a Cyclobutane Diazirine Alkyne Tag for Photoaffinity Labeling in Cells

Alkyl diazirines are frequently used in photoaffinity labeling to map small molecule-protein interactions in target identification studies. However, the alkyl diazirines can preferentially label acidic amino acids and acidic protein surfaces in a pH-dependent manner, presumably via a reactive alkyl diazo intermediate. Here, we explore the use of ring strain to alter these reactivity preferences and report the development of a cyclobutane diazirine photoaffinity tag with reduced pH-dependent reactivity, termed PALBOX. We show that PALBOX possesses differential reactivity profiles as compared to other diazirine tags in vitro and is readily incorporated into small molecules to profile their binding interactions in cells. Using a set of small molecule fragments and ligands, we show that photoaffinity probes equipped with PALBOX can label the known protein targets in cells with reduced labeling of known alkyl diazirine off-targets. Finally, we demonstrate that ligands equipped with PALBOX can accurately map small molecule-protein binding sites. Thus, PALBOX is a versatile diazirine-based photoaffinity tag for use in the development of chemical probes for photoaffinity labeling experiments, including the study of small molecule-protein interactions.

Cell-specific bioorthogonal tagging of glycoproteins

Altered glycoprotein expression is an undisputed corollary of cancer development. Understanding these alterations is paramount but hampered by limitations underlying cellular model systems. For instance, the intricate interactions between tumour and host cannot be adequately recapitulated in monoculture of tumour-derived cell lines. More complex co-culture models usually rely on sorting procedures for proteome analyses and rarely capture the details of protein glycosylation. Here, we report a strategy termed Bio-Orthogonal Cell line-specific Tagging of Glycoproteins (BOCTAG). Cells are equipped by transfection with an artificial biosynthetic pathway that transforms bioorthogonally tagged sugars into the corresponding nucleotide-sugars. Only transfected cells incorporate bioorthogonal tags into glycoproteins in the presence of non-transfected cells. We employ BOCTAG as an imaging technique and to annotate cell-specific glycosylation sites in mass spectrometry-glycoproteomics. We demonstrate application in co-culture and mouse models, allowing for profiling of the glycoproteome as an important modulator of cellular function.

PUFA-Derived N-Acylethanolamide Probes Identify Peroxiredoxins and Small GTPases as Molecular Targets in LPS-Stimulated RAW264.7 Macrophages

We studied the mechanistic and biological origins of anti-inflammatory poly-unsaturated fatty acid-derived N-acylethanolamines using synthetic bifunctional chemical probes of docosahexaenoyl ethanolamide (DHEA) and arachidonoyl ethanolamide (AEA) in RAW264.7 macrophages stimulated with 1.0 μg mL^-1 lipopolysaccharide. Using a photoreactive diazirine, probes were covalently attached to their target proteins, which were further studied by introducing a fluorescent probe or biotin-based affinity purification. Fluorescence confocal microscopy showed DHEA and AEA probes localized in cytosol, specifically in structures that point toward the endoplasmic reticulum and in membrane vesicles. Affinity purification followed by proteomic analysis revealed peroxiredoxin-1 (Prdx1) as the most significant binding interactor of both DHEA and AEA probes. In addition, Prdx4, endosomal related proteins, small GTPase signaling proteins, and prostaglandin synthase 2 (Ptgs2, also known as cyclooxygenase 2 or COX-2) were identified. Lastly, confocal fluorescence microscopy revealed the colocalization of Ptgs2 and Rac1 with DHEA and AEA probes. These data identified new molecular targets suggesting that DHEA and AEA may be involved in reactive oxidation species regulation, cell migration, cytoskeletal remodeling, and endosomal trafficking and support endocytosis as an uptake mechanism.

Development of Photolenalidomide for Cellular Target Identification

The thalidomide analogue lenalidomide (Len) is a clinical therapeutic that alters the substrate engagement of cereblon (CRBN), a substrate receptor for the CRL4 E3 ubiquitin ligase. Here, we report the development of photolenalidomide (pLen), a Len probe with a photoaffinity label and enrichment handle, designed for target identification by chemical proteomics. pLen preserves the substrate degradation profile, phenotypic antiproliferative and immunomodulatory properties of Len, and enhances interactions with the thalidomide-binding domain of CRBN, as revealed by binding site mapping and molecular modeling. Using pLen, we captured the known targets IKZF1 and CRBN from multiple myeloma MM.1S cells and further identified a new target, eukaryotic translation initiation factor 3 subunit i (eIF3i), from HEK293T cells. eIF3i is directly labeled by pLen and forms a ternary complex with CRBN in the presence of Len across several epithelial cell lines but is itself not ubiquitylated or degraded. These data point to the existence of a broader array of targets induced by ligands to CRBN that may or may not be degraded, which can be identified by the highly translatable application of pLen to additional biological systems.

Photoaffinity labelling strategies for mapping the small molecule-protein interactome

Nearly all FDA approved drugs and bioactive small molecules exert their effects by binding to and modulating proteins. Consequently, understanding how small molecules interact with proteins at an molecular level is a central challenge of modern chemical biology and drug development. Complementary to structure-guided approaches, chemoproteomics has emerged as a method capable of high-throughput identification of proteins covalently bound by small molecules. To profile noncovalent interactions, established chemoproteomic workflows typically incorporate photoreactive moieties into small molecule probes, which enable trapping of small molecule-protein interactions (SMPIs). This strategy, termed photoaffinity labelling (PAL), has been utilized to profile an array of small molecule interactions, including for drugs, lipids, metabolites, and cofactors. Herein we describe the discovery of photocrosslinking chemistries, including a comparison of the strengths and limitations of implementation of each chemotype in chemoproteomic workflows. In addition, we highlight key examples where photoaffinity labelling has enabled target deconvolution and interaction site mapping.

Labeling Preferences of Diazirines with Protein Biomolecules

Diazirines are widely used in photoaffinity labeling (PAL) to trap noncovalent interactions with biomolecules. However, design and interpretation of PAL experiments is challenging without a molecular understanding of the reactivity of diazirines with protein biomolecules. Herein, we report a systematic evaluation of the labeling preferences of alkyl and aryl diazirines with individual amino acids, single proteins, and in the whole cell proteome. We find that alkyl diazirines exhibit preferential labeling of acidic amino acids in a pH-dependent manner that is characteristic of a reactive alkyl diazo intermediate, while the aryl-fluorodiazirine labeling pattern reflects reaction primarily through a carbene intermediate. From a survey of 32 alkyl diazirine probes, we use this reactivity profile to rationalize why alkyl diazirine probes preferentially enrich highly acidic proteins or those embedded in membranes and why probes with a net positive charge tend to produce higher labeling yields in cells and in vitro. These results indicate that alkyl diazirines are an especially effective chemistry for surveying the membrane proteome and will facilitate design and interpretation of biomolecular labeling experiments with diazirines.

Generating orthogonal glycosyltransferase and nucleotide sugar pairs as next-generation glycobiology tools

Protein glycosylation fundamentally impacts biological processes. Nontemplated biosynthesis introduces unparalleled complexity into glycans that needs tools to understand their roles in physiology. The era of quantitative biology is a great opportunity to unravel these roles, especially by mass spectrometry glycoproteomics. However, with high sensitivity come stringent requirements on tool specificity. Bioorthogonal metabolic labeling reagents have been fundamental to studying the cell surface glycoproteome but typically enter a range of different glycans and are thus of limited specificity. Here, we discuss the generation of metabolic 'precision tools' to study particular subtypes of the glycome. A chemical biology tactic termed bump-and-hole engineering generates mutant glycosyltransferases that specifically accommodate bioorthogonal monosaccharides as an enabling technique of glycobiology. We review the groundbreaking discoveries that have led to applying the tactic in the living cell and the implications in the context of current developments in mass spectrometry glycoproteomics.

Cleavable linkers and their application in MS-based target identification

Covalent chemical probes are important tools in chemical biology. They range from post-translational modification (PTM)-derived metabolic probes, to activity-based probes and photoaffinity labels. Identification of the probe targets is often performed by tandem mass spectrometry-based proteomics methods. In the past fifteen years, cleavable linker technologies have been implemented in these workflows in order to identify probe targets with lower background and higher confidence. In addition, the linkers have enabled identification of modification sites. Overall, this has led to an increased knowledge of PTMs, enzyme function and drug action. This review gives an overview of the different types of cleavable linkers, and their benefits and limitations. Their applicability in target identification is also illustrated by several specific examples.

Novel Tetrafunctional Probes Identify Target Receptors and Binding Sites of Small-Molecule Drugs from Living Systems

Significant advancement of chemoproteomics has contributed to uncovering the mechanism of action (MoA) of small-molecule drugs by characterizing drug-protein interactions in living systems. However, cell-membrane proteins such as G protein-coupled receptors (GPCRs) and ion channels, due to their low abundance and unique biophysical properties associated with multiple transmembrane domains, can present challenges for proteome-wide mapping of drug-receptor interactions. Herein, we describe the development of novel tetrafunctional probes, consisting of (1) a ligand of interest, (2) 2-aryl-5-carboxytetrazole (ACT) as a photoreactive group, (3) a hydrazine-labile cleavable linker, and (4) biotin for enrichment. In live cell labeling studies, we demonstrated that the ACT-based probe showed superior reactivity and selectivity for labeling on-target GPCR by mass spectrometry analysis compared with control probes including diazirine-based probes. By leveraging ACT-based cleavable probes, we further identified a set of representative ionotropic receptors, targeted by CNS drugs, with remarkable selectivity and precise binding site information from mouse brain slices. We anticipate that the robust chemoproteomic platform using the ACT-based cleavable probe coupled with phenotypic screening should promote identification of pharmacologically relevant target receptors of drug candidates and ultimately development of first-in-class drugs with novel MoA.

Rationally Designed Polypharmacology: α-Helix Mimetics as Dual Inhibitors of the Oncoproteins Mcl-1 and HDM2

Protein-protein interactions (PPIs), many of which are dominated by α-helical recognition domains, play key roles in many essential cellular processes, and the dysregulation of these interactions can cause detrimental effects. For instance, aberrant PPIs involving the Bcl-2 protein family can lead to several diseases including cancer, neurodegenerative diseases, and diabetes. Interactions between Bcl-2 pro-life proteins, such as Mcl-1, and pro-death proteins, such as Bim, regulate the intrinsic pathway of apoptosis. p53, a tumor-suppressor protein, also has a pivotal role in apoptosis and is negatively regulated by its E3 ubiquitin ligase HDM2. Both Mcl-1 and HDM2 are upregulated in numerous cancers, and, interestingly, there is crosstalk between both protein pathways. Recently, synergy has been observed between Mcl-1 and HDM2 inhibitors. Towards the development of new anticancer drugs, we herein describe a polypharmacology approach for the dual inhibition of Mcl-1 and HDM2 by employing three densely functionalized isoxazoles, pyrazoles, and thiazoles as mimetics of key α-helical domains of their partner proteins.

Small Molecule Interactome Mapping by Photo-Affinity Labeling (SIM-PAL) to Identify Binding Sites of Small Molecules on a Proteome-Wide Scale

Identification and characterization of small molecule-protein interactions is critical to understanding the mechanism of action of bioactive small molecules. Photo-affinity labeling (PAL) enables the capture of noncovalent interactions for enrichment and unbiased analysis by mass spectrometry (MS). Quantitative proteomics of the enriched proteome reveals potential interactions, and MS characterization of binding sites provides validation and structural insight into the interactions. Here, we describe the identification of the protein targets and binding sites of a small molecule using small molecule interactome mapping by PAL (SIM-PAL). Cells are exposed to a diazirine-alkyne-functionalized small molecule, and binding interactions are covalently captured upon UV irradiation. An isotopically coded, acid-cleavable biotin azide handle is attached to the conjugated proteins using copper-catalyzed azide-alkyne cycloaddition. Biotin-labeled proteins are enriched for on-bead digestion and quantitative proteomics. Acid cleavage of the handle releases the bead-bound conjugated peptides for MS analysis and isotope-directed assignment of the binding site. © 2019 by John Wiley & Sons, Inc. Basic Protocol 1: Generation of a small molecule-conjugated protein sample following treatment of live cells Alternate Protocol: Generation of a small molecule-conjugated protein sample following treatment of cell lysate Basic Protocol 2: Copper-catalyzed azide-alkyne cycloaddition functionalization and enrichment of labeled peptides Support Protocol 1: Synthesis of acid-cleavable, isotopically coded biotin picolyl azide handle Support Protocol 2: Monitoring enrichment by immunoblotting Basic Protocol 3: Mass spectrometry analysis to identify interacting proteins and conjugation sites.