Artificial OFF-Riboswitches That Downregulate Internal Ribosome Entry without Hybridization Switches in a Eukaryotic Cell-Free Translation System

Harnessing Synthetic Riboswitches for Tunable Gene Regulation in Mammalian Cells

RNA switches regulated by specific inducer molecules have become a powerful synthetic biology tool for precise gene regulation in mammalian systems. The engineered RNA switches can be integrated with natural RNA-mediated gene regulatory functions as a modular and customizable approach to probe and control cellular behavior. RNA switches have been used to advance synthetic biology applications, including gene therapy, bio-production, and cellular reprogramming. This review explores recent progress in the design and functional implementation of synthetic riboswitches in mammalian cells based on diverse RNA regulation mechanisms by highlighting recent studies and emerging technologies. We also discuss challenges such as off-target effects, system stability, and ligand delivery in complex biological environments. In conclusion, this review emphasizes the potential of synthetic riboswitches as a platform for customizable gene regulation in diverse biomedical applications.

Simultaneous Detection of Multiple Analytes at Ambient Temperature Using Eukaryotic Artificial Cells with Modular and Robust Synthetic Riboswitches

Cell-free systems, which can express an easily detectable output (protein) with a DNA or mRNA template, are promising as foundations of biosensors devoid of cellular constraints. Moreover, by encasing them in membranes such as natural cells to create artificial cells, these systems can avoid the adverse effects of environmental inhibitory molecules. However, the bacterial systems generally used for this purpose do not function well at ambient temperatures. We here encapsulated a eukaryotic cell-free system consisting of wheat germ extract (WGE) and a DNA template encoding an analyte-responsive regulatory RNA (called a riboswitch) into giant unilamellar vesicles (GUVs) to create eukaryotic artificial cell-based sensors that function well at ambient temperature. First, we improved our previously reported eukaryotic synthetic riboswitches and WGE for use in GUVs by chimerizing two internal ribosome entry sites and optimizing magnesium concentrations, respectively, both of which increased the expression efficiency in GUVs several fold. Then, a DNA template encoding one of these riboswitches followed by a reporter protein was encapsulated with the optimized GUV-friendly WGE. Importantly, our previously established versatile method allowed for the rational design of highly efficient eukaryotic riboswitches that are responsive to a user-defined analyte. In fact, we utilized this method to successfully create three types of artificial cells, each of which responded to a specific, membrane-permeable analyte with wide-range, analyte-dose dependency and high sensitivity at ambient temperature. Finally, due to their orthogonality and robustness, we were able to mix a cocktail of these artificial cells to achieve simultaneous detection of the three analytes without significant barriers.

Cell-Free Multistep Gene Regulatory Cascades Using Eukaryotic ON-Riboswitches Responsive to in Situ Expressed Protein Ligands

One of the most pressing challenges in cell-free synthetic biology is to assemble well-controlled genetic circuits. However, no complex circuits have been reported in eukaryotic cell-free systems, unlike the case in bacterial ones, despite several unique advantages of the former. We here developed protein-responsive upregulating riboswitches (ON-riboswitches) that function in wheat germ extract to create multistep gene regulatory cascades. Although the initial two types of ON-riboswitches we first designed were less efficient than desired, we improved one of them by incorporating hybridization switches to successfully construct a pair of highly efficient, protein-responsive ON-riboswitches. Both upregulated expression up to 20-fold through self-cleavage by a hammerhead ribozyme (HHR) in response to the corresponding protein ligands expressed in situ. We then combined them with similar types of HHR-based, small-molecule-responsive ON-riboswitches regulating protein ligand expression, to create four kinds of two-step regulatory cascades. Due to the high orthogonality of all the riboswitches used, we also succeeded in regulating two-step cascades concurrently and even in creating three-step cascades. Interestingly, the switching efficiency of each multistep cascade constructed was equivalent to that of the worst step within it. Therefore, more complex cascades with additional steps could be constructed using other efficient and orthogonal, protein-responsive ON-riboswitches with minimal loss of total switching efficiency, although the reaction conditions must be optimized to prevent a reduction of expression efficiencies. Riboswitch-based cascades fashioned through our proposed strategy would aid in the construction of eukaryotic genetic circuits for programmed cell-free systems or artificial cells with functionalities surpassing those of natural cells.

Cell-Free Biosensors Based on Modular Eukaryotic Riboswitches That Function in One Pot at Ambient Temperature

Artificial riboswitches responsive to user-defined analytes can be constructed by successfully inserting in vitro selected aptamers, which bind to the analytes, into untranslated regions of mRNA. Among them, eukaryotic riboswitches are more promising as biosensors than bacterial ones because they function well at ambient temperature. In addition, cell-free expression systems allow the broader use of these riboswitches as cell-free biosensors in an environmentally friendly manner without cellular limitations. The current best cell-free eukaryotic riboswitch regulates eukaryotic canonical translation initiation through self-cleavage mediated by an implanted analyte-responsive ribozyme (i.e., an aptazyme, an aptamer-ribozyme fusion). However, it has critical flaws as a sensor: due to the less-active ribozyme used, self-cleavage and translation reactions must be conducted separately and sequentially, and a different aptazyme has to be selected to change the analyte specificity, even if an aptamer for the next analyte is available. We here stepwise engineered novel types of cell-free eukaryotic riboswitches that harness highly active self-cleavage and thus require no reaction partitioning. Despite the single-step and one-pot reaction, these riboswitches showed higher analyte dose dependency and sensitivities than the current best cell-free eukaryotic riboswitch requiring multistep reactions. In addition, the analyte specificity can be changed in an extremely facile way, simply by aptamer substitution (and the subsequent simple fine-tuning for giant aptamers). Given that cell-free systems can be lyophilized for storage and transport, the present one-pot and thus easy-to-handle cell-free biosensors utilizing eukaryotic riboswitches are expected to be widely used for on-the-spot sensing of analytes at ambient temperature.

Rational design of eukaryotic riboswitches that up-regulate IRES-mediated translation initiation with high switching efficiency through a kinetic trapping mechanism in vitro

In general, riboswitches functioning through a cotranscriptional kinetic trapping mechanism (kt-riboswitches) show higher switching efficiencies in response to practical concentrations of their ligand molecules than eq-riboswitches, which function by an equilibrium mechanism. However, the former have been much more difficult to design due to their more complex mechanism. We here successfully developed a rational strategy for constructing eukaryotic kt-riboswitches that ligand-dependently enhance translation initiation mediated by an internal ribosome entry site (IRES). This was achieved both by utilizing some predicted structural features of a highly efficient bacterial kt-riboswitch identified through screening and by completely decoupling an aptamer domain from the IRES. Three kt-riboswitches optimized through this strategy, each responding to a different ligand, exhibited three- to sevenfold higher induction ratios (up to ∼90) than previously optimized eq-riboswitches regulating the same IRES-mediated translation in wheat germ extract. Because the IRES used functions well in various eukaryotic expression systems, these types of kt-riboswitches are expected to serve as major eukaryotic gene regulators based on RNA. In addition, the present strategy could be applied to the rational construction of other types of kt-riboswitches, including those functioning in bacterial expression systems.

Facile Expansion of the Variety of Orthogonal Ligand/Aptamer Pairs for Artificial Riboswitches

An RNA aptamer that induces suitable conformational changes upon binding to a user-defined ligand allows us to artificially construct a riboswitch, a ligand-dependent and cis-acting gene regulatory RNA. Although such an aptamer can be obtained through in vitro selection, it is still challenging to rationally expand the variety of orthogonal ligand/aptamer (ligand/riboswitch) pairs. To achieve this in a facile, selection-free way, we herein focused on a specific type of ligand, 6-nt nanosized DNA (nDNA) and its aptamer that was previously selected to construct a eukaryotic artificial riboswitch. Specifically, we merely mutated one or more possible Watson-Crick base pairs in the nDNA/aptamer (nDNA/riboswitch) interactions into another base pair or pairs. Using two sets that each had 16 comprehensive mutations, we obtained three groups of several orthogonal nDNA/riboswitch pairs. These pairs could be used to create complex gene circuits, including multiple simultaneous and/or multistep cascading regulations in synthetic biology.

Eukaryotic artificial ON-riboswitches that respond efficiently to mid-sized short peptides

We chose two types of mid-sized Arg-rich peptides (Rev-pep and Tat-pep) as ligands and used their aptamers to construct efficient eukaryotic ON-riboswitches (ligand-dependently upregulating riboswitches). Due to the aptamers' high affinities, the best Rev-pep-responsive and Tat-pep-responsive riboswitches obtained showed much higher switching efficiencies at low ligand concentrations than small ligand-responsive ON-riboswitches in the same mechanism. In addition, despite the high sequence similarity of Rev-pep and Tat-pep, the two best riboswitches were almost insensitive to each other's peptide ligand. Considering the high responsiveness and specificity along with the versatility of the expression platform used and the applicability of Arg-rich peptides, this orthogonal pair of riboswitches would be widely useful eukaryotic gene regulators or biosensors.

RNA-responsive elements for eukaryotic translational control

The ability to control translation of endogenous or exogenous RNAs in eukaryotic cells would facilitate a variety of biotechnological applications. Current strategies are limited by low fold changes in transgene output and the size of trigger RNAs (trRNAs). Here we introduce eukaryotic toehold switches (eToeholds) as modular riboregulators. eToeholds contain internal ribosome entry site sequences and form inhibitory loops in the absence of a specific trRNA. When the trRNA is present, eToeholds anneal to it, disrupting the inhibitory loops and allowing translation. Through optimization of RNA annealing, we achieved up to 16-fold induction of transgene expression in mammalian cells. We demonstrate that eToeholds can discriminate among viral infection status, presence or absence of gene expression and cell types based on the presence of exogenous or endogenous RNA transcripts.

Cell-free riboswitches

The emerging community of cell-free synthetic biology aspires to build complex biochemical and genetic systems with functions that mimic or even exceed those in living cells. To achieve such functions, cell-free systems must be able to sense and respond to the complex chemical signals within and outside the system. Cell-free riboswitches can detect chemical signals via RNA-ligand interaction and respond by regulating protein synthesis in cell-free protein synthesis systems. In this article, we review synthetic cell-free riboswitches that function in both prokaryotic and eukaryotic cell-free systems reported to date to provide a current perspective on the state of cell-free riboswitch technologies and their limitations.

Riboswitches for Controlled Expression of Therapeutic Transgenes Delivered by Adeno-Associated Viral Vectors

Vectors developed from adeno-associated virus (AAV) are powerful tools for in vivo transgene delivery in both humans and animal models, and several AAV-delivered gene therapies are currently approved for clinical use. However, AAV-mediated gene therapy still faces several challenges, including limited vector packaging capacity and the need for a safe, effective method for controlling transgene expression during and after delivery. Riboswitches, RNA elements which control gene expression in response to ligand binding, are attractive candidates for regulating expression of AAV-delivered transgene therapeutics because of their small genomic footprints and non-immunogenicity compared to protein-based expression control systems. In addition, the ligand-sensing aptamer domains of many riboswitches can be exchanged in a modular fashion to allow regulation by a variety of small molecules, proteins, and oligonucleotides. Riboswitches have been used to regulate AAV-delivered transgene therapeutics in animal models, and recently developed screening and selection methods allow rapid isolation of riboswitches with novel ligands and improved performance in mammalian cells. This review discusses the advantages of riboswitches in the context of AAV-delivered gene therapy, the subsets of riboswitch mechanisms which have been shown to function in human cells and animal models, recent progress in riboswitch isolation and optimization, and several examples of AAV-delivered therapeutic systems which might be improved by riboswitch regulation.

In Vitro Selection of RNA Aptamers Binding to Nanosized DNA for Constructing Artificial Riboswitches

We here designed an in vitro selection scheme for obtaining an aptamer with which to rationally construct an artificial riboswitch as its component part. In fact, a nanosized DNA-binding aptamer obtained through this scheme allowed us to easily and successfully create eukaryotic riboswitches that upregulate internal ribosome entry site-mediated translation in response to the ligand (nanosized DNA) in wheat germ extract, a eukaryotic cell-free expression system. The induction ratio of the best riboswitch ligand-dose-dependently increased to 21 at 300 μM ligand. This switching efficiency is much higher than that of the same type of riboswitch with a widely used theophylline-binding aptamer, which was in vitro selected without considering its utility for constructing riboswitches. The selection scheme described here would facilitate obtaining various ligand/aptamer pairs suitable for constructing artificial riboswitches, which could serve as elements of synthetic gene circuits in synthetic biology.

The Theophylline Aptamer: 25 Years as an Important Tool in Cellular Engineering Research

The theophylline aptamer was isolated from an oligonucleotide library in 1994. Since that time, the aptamer has found wide utility, particularly in synthetic biology, cellular engineering, and diagnostic applications. The primary application of the theophylline aptamer is in the construction and characterization of synthetic riboswitches for regulation of gene expression. These riboswitches have been used to control cellular motility, regulate carbon metabolism, construct logic gates, screen for mutant enzymes, and control apoptosis. Other applications of the theophylline aptamer in cellular engineering include regulation of RNA interference and genome editing through CRISPR systems. Here we describe the uses of the theophylline aptamer for cellular engineering over the past 25 years. In so doing, we also highlight important synthetic biology applications to control gene expression in a ligand-dependent manner.

Mutation of the start codon to enhance Cripavirus internal ribosome entry site-mediated translation in a wheat germ extract

Wheat germ extract (WGE) is one of the most widely used eukaryotic cell-free translation systems for easy synthesis of a broad range of proteins merely by adding template mRNAs. Its productivity has thus far been improved by removing translational inhibitors from the extract and stabilizing the template with terminal protectors. Nonetheless, there remains room for increasing the yield by designing a terminally protected template with higher susceptibility to translation. Given the fact that a 5' terminal protector is a strong inhibitor of the canonical translation, we herein focused on Cripavirus internal ribosome entry sites (IRESes), which allow for a unique translation initiation from a non-AUG start codon without the help of any initiation factors. We mutated their start codons to enhance the IRES-mediated translation efficiency in WGE. One of the mutants showed considerably higher efficiency, 3-4-fold higher than that of its wild type, and also 3-4-fold higher than the canonical translation efficiency by an IRES-free mRNA having one of the most effective canonical-translation enhancers. Because this mutated IRES is compatible with different types of genes and terminal protectors, we expect it will be widely used to synthesize proteins in WGE.

Canonical translation-modulating OFF-riboswitches with a single aptamer binding to a small molecule that function in a higher eukaryotic cell-free expression system

We have found that OFF-riboswitches that ligand-dependently downregulate the canonical translation in a higher eukaryotic expression system (wheat germ extract) can be easily created by inserting a single aptamer into the 5' untranslated region (UTR) of mRNA, even if its ligand is as small as theophylline. The key is the position of the inserted aptamer: the 5' end (+0 position) is much better than other positions for inhibiting canonical translation with the aptamer-ligand complex. The data showed that ribosome loading is suppressed by a rigid structure in the 5' end, and this suppression is dependent on the structure's stability but not on its size. Although this preference of aptamer insertion point contradicts the results in a lower eukaryote, it accords with the fact that the 5'-end structural hindrance is more effective for blocking the ribosome in higher eukaryotes. Therefore, the present type of OFF-riboswitch would function in various higher eukaryotic expression systems.

Viruses, IRESs, and a universal translation initiation mechanism

Internal ribosome entry sites (IRESs) are cis-acting RNA elements capable of recruiting ribosomes and initiating translation on an internal portion of an mRNA. This is divergent from canonical eukaryotic translation initiation, where the 5' cap is recognized by initiation factors (IFs) that recruit the ribosome to initiate translation of the encoded peptide. All known IRESs are capable of initiating translation in a cap-independent manner, and are therefore not constrained by the absence or presence of a 5' m⁷G cap. In addition to being cap-independent, IRES-mediated translation often uses only a subset of IFs allowing them to function independently of canonical initiation. The ability to function independently of the canonical translation initiation pathway allows IRESs to mediate gene expression when cap-dependent translation has been inhibited. Recent reports of viral IRESs capable of initiating translation across taxonomic domains (Eukarya and Bacteria) have sparked interest in designing gene expression systems compatible with multiple organisms. The ability to drive translation independent of cellular context using a common mechanism would have a wide range of applications ranging from agriculture biotechnology to the development of antiviral drugs. Here we discuss IRES-mediated translation and critically compare the available mechanistic and structural information. A particular focus will be on IRES-meditated translation across domains of life (viral and cellular IRESs) , IRES bioengineering and the possibility of an evolutionary conserved translation initiation mechanism.