Probing the mechanism of CRP activation by site-directed mutagenesis: the role of serine 128 in the allosteric pathway of cAMP receptor protein activation

Directed evolution of the Escherichia coli cAMP receptor protein at the cAMP pocket

The Escherichia coli cAMP receptor protein (CRP) requires cAMP binding to undergo a conformational change for DNA binding and transcriptional regulation. Two CRP residues, Thr(127) and Ser(128), are known to play important roles in cAMP binding through hydrogen bonding and in the cAMP-induced conformational change, but the connection between the two is not completely clear. Here, we simultaneously randomized the codons for these two residues and selected CRP mutants displaying high CRP activity in a cAMP-producing E. coli. Many different CRP mutants satisfied the screening condition for high CRP activity, including those that cannot form any hydrogen bonds with the incoming cAMP at the two positions. In vitro DNA-binding analysis confirmed that these selected CRP mutants indeed display high CRP activity in response to cAMP. These results indicate that the hydrogen bonding ability of the Thr(127) and Ser(128) residues is not critical for the cAMP-induced CRP activation. However, the hydrogen bonding ability of Thr(127) and Ser(128) was found to be important in attaining high cAMP affinity. Computational analysis revealed that most natural cAMP-sensing CRP homologs have Thr/Ser, Thr/Thr, or Thr/Asn at positions 127 and 128. All of these pairs are excellent hydrogen bonding partners and they do not elevate CRP activity in the absence of cAMP. Taken together, our analyses suggest that CRP evolved to have hydrogen bonding residues at the cAMP pocket residues 127 and 128 for performing dual functions: preserving high cAMP affinity and keeping CRP inactive in the absence of cAMP.

The N-terminal capping propensities of the D-helix modulate the allosteric activation of the Escherichia coli cAMP receptor protein

Transduction of biological signals at the molecular level involves the activation and/or inhibition of allosteric proteins. In the transcription factor cAMP receptor protein (CRP) from Escherichia coli, the allosteric activation, or apo-holo transition, involves rigid body motions of domains and structural rearrangements within the hinge region connecting the cAMP- and DNA-binding domains. During this apo-holo transition, residue 138 is converted as part of the elongated D-helix to the position of the N-terminal capping residue of a shorter D-helix. The goal of the current study is to elucidate the role of residue 138 in modulating the allostery between cAMP and DNA binding. By systematically mutating residue 138, we found that mutants with higher N-terminal capping propensities lead to increased cooperativity of cAMP binding and a concomitant increase in affinity for lac-DNA. Furthermore, mutants with higher N-terminal capping propensity correlate with properties characteristic of holo-CRP, particularly, increase in protein structural dynamics. Overall, our results provide a quantitative characterization of the role of residue 138 in the isomerization equilibrium between the apo and holo forms of CRP, and in turn the thermodynamic underpin to the molecular model of allostery revealed by the high resolution structural studies.

Structural insights into the mechanism of the allosteric transitions of Mycobacterium tuberculosis cAMP receptor protein

The cAMP receptor protein (CRP) from Mycobacterium tuberculosis is a cAMP-responsive global transcriptional regulator, responsible for the regulation of a multitude of diverse proteins. We have determined the crystal structures of the CRP.cAMP and CRP.N(6)-cAMP derivative-bound forms of the enzyme to 2.2- and 2.3 A-resolution, respectively, to investigate cAMP-mediated conformational and structural changes. The allosteric switch from the open, inactive conformation to the closed, active conformation begins with a number of changes in the ligand-binding cavity upon cAMP binding. These subtle structural changes and numerous non-bonding interactions between cAMP, the N-domain residues, and the C-domain helices demonstrate that the N-domain hairpin loop acts as a structural mediator of the allosteric switch. Based on the CRP.N(6)-cAMP crystal structure, binding of N(6)-cAMP with a bulkier methylphenylethyl extension from the N6 atom stabilizes the cAMP-binding domain, N-domain hairpin, and C-terminal domain in a similar manner as that of the CRP.cAMP structure, maintaining structural integrity within the subunits. However, the bulkier N6 extension of N(6)-cAMP (in R conformation) is accommodated only in subunit A with minor changes, whereas in subunit B, the N6 extension is in the S conformation hindering the hinge region of the central helix. As a result, the entire N-domain and the C-domain of subunit B integrated by the cAMP portion of this ligand, together tilt away ( approximately 7 degrees tilt) from central helix C, positioning the helix-turn-helix motif in an unfavorable position for the DNA substrate, asymmetrically. Together, these crystal structures demonstrate the mechanism of action of the cAMP molecule and its role in integrating the active CRP structure.

Regulation of FNR Dimerization by Subunit Charge Repulsion

Dimerization of the global anaerobic transcription factor FNR is essential for FNR activity. Under aerobic conditions FNR is an inactive monomeric species because it lacks the oxygen labile [4Fe-4S] cluster required for dimerization. In this study, we investigated the protein side chains that inhibit FNR dimerization under aerobic conditions. Substitution of Asp(154) within the predicted dimerization helix with residues containing neutral or positively charged side chains increased FNR activity under aerobic conditions, whereas replacement of Asp(154) with Glu inhibited FNR activity similar to WT-FNR. Similar results were obtained when making analogous substitutions of Glu(150). In vitro analysis of representative FNR mutant proteins indicated that their increased activity under aerobic conditions resulted from an [4Fe-4S] independent mechanism of dimerization. In addition, simultaneous substitution of residues 150 and 154 with Lys restored inhibition of FNR activity under aerobic growth conditions. Collectively, these data indicate that charge repulsion by side chains at positions 150 and 154 is necessary to inhibit dimerization under aerobic conditions. They also suggest that a [4Fe-4S]-dependent conformational change overcomes charge repulsion between subunits under anaerobic conditions. Comparison of the trypsin sensitivity of [4Fe-4S]-FNR and apoFNR indicated that there are no major differences in protease sensitivity between these forms, whereas circular dichroism suggested that small changes in secondary structure occur between the cluster-containing FNR and apoFNR. Thus, the [4Fe-4S]-dependent conformational change necessary to overcome inter-subunit charge repulsion and create a subunit interface more favorable for dimerization must be small.

Kinetic and structural studies of the allosteric conformational changes induced by binding of cAMP to the cAMP receptor protein from Escherichia coli

The cAMP receptor protein, allosterically activated by cAMP, regulates the expression of more than 100 genes in Escherichia coli. CRP is a homodimer of two-domain subunits. It has been suggested that binding of cAMP to CRP leads to a long-distance signal transduction from the N-terminal cAMP binding domain to the C-terminal domain of the protein responsible for interaction with specific sequences of DNA. In this study, the stopped-flow and time-resolved fluorescence lifetime measurements were used to observe the kinetics of the distance changes between the N-terminal and C-terminal domain of CRP induced by binding of cAMP to high-affinity binding sites. In these measurements, we used the constructed CRP heterodimer, which possesses a single Trp85 residue localized at the N-terminal domain of one CRP subunit, and fluorescently labeled by 1,5-I-AEDANS Cys178 localized at the C-terminal domain of the same subunit or at the opposite one. The Förster resonance energy transfer method has been used to study the distance changes, induced by binding of cAMP, between Trp85 (fluorescence donor) and Cys178-AEDANS (fluorescence acceptor) in the CRP structure. The obtained results show that the allosteric transitions of CRP at micromolar cAMP concentrations follow the sequential binding model, in which binding of cAMP to high-affinity sites causes a 4 A movement of the C-terminal domain toward N-terminal domains of the protein, with kinetics faster than 2 ms, and CRP adopts the "closed" conformation. This fast process is followed by the slower reorientation of both CRP subunits.

Two cAMP receptor proteins with different biochemical properties in the filamentous cyanobacterium Anabaena sp. PCC 7120

Two open reading frames (ORFs), alr0295 and alr2325, are found to encode putative cAMP receptor proteins (CRPs) in the genome of the filamentous cyanobacterium Anabaena sp. PCC 7120. These ORFs were named cAMP receptor protein-like gene A in Anabaena sp. PCC 7120 (ancrpA) and cAMP receptor protein-like gene B in Anabaena sp. PCC 7120 (ancrpB), respectively, and those translated products were investigated. The equilibrium dialysis measurements revealed that AnCrpA bound with cAMP specifically, while AnCrpB bound with both cAMP and cGMP, though the affinity for cGMP was weak. The binding affinity for cAMP of AnCrpA showed the lowest dissociation constant, approximately 0.8 microM, among bacterial CRPs. A gel mobility shift assay elucidated that AnCrpA and AnCrpB formed a complex with the consensus DNA sequence in the presence of cAMP, although AnCrpB did not have ordinary DNA-binding motifs.

Kinetic studies of cAMP-induced allosteric changes in mutants T127I, S128A, and T127I/S128A of the cAMP receptor protein from Escherichia coli

The cAMP receptor protein (CRP) regulates the expression of several genes in Escherichia coli. The protein is a homodimer, and each monomer is folded into two distinct structural domains. After allosteric transitions resulting from the binding of cAMP, CRP specifically binds to DNA and activates transcription. We have used stopped-flow fluorometry measurements of CRP mutants bearing amino acid substitutions T127I, S128A, and T127I/S128A to study the kinetics of conformational changes in the protein induced by cAMP binding. Amino acid substitutions at positions 127 and 128 were chosen because these residues play a crucial role in interdomain and intersubunit communication during allosteric transition. Using N-iodoacetylaminoethyl-5-naphthylamine-1-sulfonic acid-labeled Cys178, localized in the protein helix-turn helix motif, we observed conformational changes in the helix-turn helix, localized in the C-terminal domain, upon binding of cAMP to high affinity sites (CRP.cAMP2) in the N-terminal domain of CRP. The rate constants for the forward and backward conformational changes depend on the amino acid substitution: kc = 3.62 s-1 and k-c = 3.13s-1 for CRP T127I and kc = 0.42 s-1 and k-c = 0.78 s-1 for CRP S128A. These values can be compared with kc = 9.7 s-1 and k-c = 0.31 s-1 for wild-type CRP. The observed conformational changes can be described by the sequential model of allostery, with the amino acid substitutions influencing the allosteric changes. In the case of the double mutant, the observed rate constant of cAMP binding supports the suggestion that this unligated mutant possesses the structure that is close to the allosteric conformation necessary for promoter binding. The results of intrinsic fluorescence measurements suggest that the formation of the CRP.cAMP4 complex results from displacement of equilibrium between the two forms of the CRP.cAMP2 complex in the mutants studied, similar to wild-type CRP. The observed conformational changes occur according to a concerted model of allostery, and isomerization equilibrium between the two CRP states depends on the amino acid substitution. The data presented in this study indicate that Ser128 and Thr127 in CRP play an important role in the kinetics of intramolecular transitions triggered by cAMP.

Functional roles of loops 3 and 4 in the cyclic nucleotide binding domain of cyclic AMP receptor protein from Escherichia coli

Cyclic AMP is a ubiquitous secondary message that regulates a large variety of functions. The protein structural motif that binds cAMP is highly conserved with the exception of loops 3 and 4, whose structure and length are variable. The cAMP receptor protein of Escherichia coli, CRP, was employed as a model system to elucidate the functional roles of these loops. Based on the sequence differences between CRP and cyclic nucleotide gated channel, three mutants of CRP were constructed: deletion (residues 54-56 in loop 3 were deleted), insertion (loop 4 was lengthened by 5 residues between Glu-78 and Gly-79) and double mutants. The effects of these mutations on the structure and function of CRP were monitored. Results show that the deletion and insertion mutations do not significantly change the secondary structure of CRP, although the tertiary and quaternary structures are perturbed. The functional data indicate that loop 3 modulates the binding affinities of cAMP and DNA. Although the lengthened loop 4 may have some fine-tuning functions, the specific function of the original loop 4 of CRP remains uncertain. The function consequences of mutation in loop 3 of CRP are similar to that of site A and site B in the regulatory subunits of cyclic AMP-dependent protein kinases. Thus, the roles played by loop 3 in CRP may represent a more common mechanism employed by cyclic nucleotide binding domain in modulating ligand binding affinity and intramolecular communication.

The role of the hydrophobic distal heme pocket of CooA in ligand sensing and response

CooA from Rhodospirillum rubrum is a heme-containing transcriptional activator that becomes activated only upon binding CO. The basis for this specificity has been probed in a CooA variant, termed DeltaP3R4 CooA, lacking two residues adjacent to the Pro(2) heme ligand, which weakens that ligand. DeltaP3R4 CooA can bind imidazole and CN(-), as well as CO, and form a 6-coordinate low spin adduct with each. However, in contrast to the case with CO, imidazole and CN(-) do not stimulate the DNA binding activity of DeltaP3R4 CooA. This result indicates that the CO-specific activation of CooA is not merely the result of creation of a 6-coordinate CooA adduct but that there must be another element to this response. One feature of CooA activation is modest repositioning of the C-helices upon CO binding, so we altered a portion of the C-helix (residues Ile(113) and Leu(116)) located near the heme-bound CO in wild type CooA, and we investigated the effect on CO-specific activation. Surprisingly, the sizes of Ile(113) and/or Leu(116) positions are not critical for CooA activation by CO, disproving a precise interaction between these residues and the CO-bound heme as a basis for the CO activation mechanism and CO ligand specificity. In contrast, hydrophobic residues at these positions contribute to the activation. Some CooA variants altered at these positions in the background of DeltaP3R4 were also found to show low but reproducible activation in response to imidazole binding to the heme. A model for the role of hydrophobicity in CooA activation and specificity is suggested.

Analysis of the L116K variant of CooA, the heme-containing CO sensor, suggests the presence of an unusual heme ligand resulting in novel activity

CooA is the CO-sensing transcriptional activator from Rhodospirillum rubrum, in which CO binding to its heme prosthetic group triggers a conformational change of CooA that allows the protein to bind its cognate target DNA sequence. By a powerful in vivo screening method following the simultaneous randomization of the codons for two C-helix residues, 113 and 116, near the distal heme pocket of CooA, we have isolated a series of novel CooA variants. In vivo, these show very high CO-independent activities (comparable with that of wild-type CooA in the presence of CO) and diminished CO-dependent activities. Sequence analysis showed that this group of variants commonly contains lysine at position 116 with a variety of residues at position 113. DNA-binding analysis of a representative purified variant, L116K CooA, revealed that this protein is competent to bind target DNA with K(d) values of 56 nm for Fe(III), 36 nm for Fe(II), and 121 nm for Fe(II)-CO CooA forms. Electron paramagnetic resonance and electronic absorption spectroscopies, combined with additional mutagenic studies, showed that L116K CooA has a new ligand replacing Pro(2) in both Fe(III) and Fe(II) states. The most plausible replacement ligand is the substituted lysine at position 116, so that the ligands of Fe(III) L116K CooA are Cys(75) and Lys(116) and those in the Fe(II) form are His(77) and Lys(116). A possible explanation for CO-independent activity in L116K CooA is that ligation of Lys(116) results in a repositioning of the C-helices at the CooA dimer interface. This result is consistent with that repositioning being an important aspect of the activation of wild-type CooA by CO.

The heme pocket afforded by Gly117 is crucial for proper heme ligation and activity of CooA

CooA, a CO-sensing homodimeric transcription activator from Rhodospirillum rubrum, undergoes a conformational change in response to CO binding to its heme prosthetic group that allows it to bind specific DNA sequences. In a recent structural study (Lanzilotta, W. N., Schuller, D. J., Thorsteinsson, M. V., Kerby, R. L., Roberts, G. P., and Poulos, T. L. (2000) Nat. Struct. Biol. 7, 876-880), it was suggested that CO binding to CooA results in a modest repositioning of the C-helices that serve as the dimer interface. Gly(117) is one of the residues on the C-helix within 7 A of the heme iron on the Pro(2) side of the heme in CooA. Analysis of a series of Gly(117) variants revealed altered CO-sensing function and heme ligation states dependent on the size of the substituted amino acid at this position; bulky substitutions perturbed CooA both spectrally and functionally. A combination of spectroscopic and mutagenic studies showed that a representative Gly(117) variant, G117I CooA, was specifically perturbed in its Pro(2) ligation in both Fe(III) and Fe(II) forms, but comparison with other CooA variants indicated that perturbation of Pro(2) ligation is not the basis for the lack of CO response in G117I CooA. These results have led to the hypothesis that (i) the heme and the C-helix region move toward each other following CO binding and the interaction of the heme with the C-helix is crucial for CooA activation, and (ii) this event occurs only when a properly sized heme pocket is afforded.

Efficient coupling of ligand binding to channel opening by the binding domain of a modulatory (beta) subunit of the olfactory cyclic nucleotide-gated channel

CNG channels in vivo are heteromers of homologous alpha and beta subunits that each contain a six-transmembrane segment domain and a COOH-terminal cytoplasmic cyclic nucleotide binding domain (BD). In heterologous expression systems, heteromeric alphabeta channels activate with greater sensitivity to ligand than do homomeric alpha channels; however, ligand-gating of channels containing only beta subunit BDs has never been studied because beta subunits cannot form functional homomeric CNG channels. To characterize directly the contribution of the beta subunit BD to ligand-gating, we constructed a chimeric subunit, X-beta, whose BD sequence was that of the beta subunit CNG5 from rat, but whose sequence outside the BD was derived from alpha subunits. For comparison, we constructed another chimera, X-alpha, whose sequence outside the BD was identical to that of X-beta, but whose BD sequence was that of the alpha subunit CNG2 from catfish. When expressed in Xenopus oocytes, X-beta and X-alpha each formed functional homomeric channels activated by both cAMP and cGMP. This is the first demonstration that the beta subunit BD can couple ligand binding to activation in the absence of alpha subunit BD residues. Notably, both agonists activate X-beta more effectively than X-alpha (higher opening efficacy and lower K(1/2)). The BD is believed to comprise two functionally distinct subdomains: (1) the roll subdomain (beta-roll and flanking A- and B-helices) and (2) the C-helix subdomain. Opening efficacy was previously believed to be controlled primarily by the C-helix, but when we made additional chimeras by exchanging the subdomains between X-beta and X-alpha, we found that both subdomains contain significant determinants of efficacy and agonist selectivity. In particular, only channels containing the roll subdomain of the beta subunit had high efficacy. Thermodynamic linkage analysis shows that interaction between the two subdomains accounts for a significant portion of their contribution to activation energetics.

Redox-mediated transcriptional activation in a CooA variant

CooA, the carbon monoxide-sensing transcription factor from Rhodospirillum rubrum, binds CO at a reduced (Fe(II)) heme moiety with resulting conformational changes that promote DNA binding. In this study, we report a variant of CooA, M124R, that is active in transcriptional activation in a redox-dependent manner. Where wild-type CooA is active only in the Fe(II) + CO form, M124R CooA is active in both Fe(II) + CO and Fe(III) forms. Analysis of the pH dependence of the activity of Fe(III) M124R CooA demonstrated that the activity was also coordination state-dependent with a five-coordinate, high-spin species identified as the active form and Cys(75) as the retained ligand. In contrast, the active Fe(II) + CO forms of both wild-type and M124R CooA are six-coordinate and low-spin with a protein ligand other than Cys(75), so that WT and Fe(III) M124R CooA are apparently achieving an active conformation despite two different heme coordination and ligation states. A hypothesis to explain these results is proposed. This study demonstrates the utility of CooA as a model system for the isolation of functionally interesting heme proteins.

Allosteric regulation of the cAMP receptor protein

The cyclic AMP receptor protein (CRP) of Escherichia coli is a dimer made up of identical subunits. Each CRP subunit contains a cyclic nucleotide binding pocket and the CRP dimer exhibits negative cooperativity in binding cAMP. In solutions containing cAMP, CRP undergoes sequential conformation changes from the inactive apo-form through the active CRP:(cAMP)(1) complex to the less active CRP:(cAMP)(2) complex depending on the cAMP concentration. Apo-CRP binds DNA with low affinity and no apparent sequence specificity. The CRP:(cAMP)(1) complex exhibits high affinity, sequence-specific DNA binding and interacts with RNA polymerase, whether free in solution or complexed with DNA. The results of genetic, biochemical and biophysical studies have helped to uncover many of the details of cAMP-mediated allosteric control over CRP conformation and activity as a transcription factor. These studies indicate that cAMP binding produces only small, but significant, changes in CRP structure; changes that include subunit realignment and concerted motion of the secondary structure elements within the C-terminal DNA binding domain of each subunit. These adjustments promote CRP surface-patch interaction with RNA polymerase and protrusion of the F-helix to promote CRP site-specific interaction with DNA. Interactions between CRP and RNA polymerase at CRP-dependent promoters produce active ternary transcription complexes.

Modeling the cAMP-induced allosteric transition using the crystal structure of CAP-cAMP at 2.1 A resolution

After an allosteric transition produced by the binding of cyclic AMP (cAMP), the Escherichia coli catabolite gene activator protein (CAP) binds DNA specifically and activates transcription. The three-dimensional crystal structure of the CAP-cAMP complex has been refined at 2.1 A resolution, thus enabling a better evaluation of the structural basis for CAP phenotypes, the interactions of cAMP with CAP and the roles played by water structure. A review of mutational analysis of CAP together with the additional structural information presented here suggests a possible mechanism for the cAMP-induced allostery required for DNA binding and transcriptional activation. We hypothesize that cAMP binding may reorient the coiled-coil C-helices, which provide most of the dimer interface, thereby altering the relative positions of the DNA-binding domains of the CAP dimer. Additionally, cAMP binding may cause a further rearrangement of the DNA-binding and cAMP-binding domains of CAP via a flap consisting of beta-strands 4 and 5 which lies over the cAMP.

Kinetic studies of cAMP-induced allosteric changes in cyclic AMP receptor protein from Escherichia coli

Cyclic AMP receptor protein (CRP) regulates the expression of several genes in Escherichia coli. The ability of CRP to bind specific DNA sequences and stimulate transcription is achieved as result of binding of an allosteric ligand: cAMP. Stopped-flow fluorimetry was employed to study the kinetics of the conformational changes in CRP induced by cAMP binding to high and low affinity receptor sites. Results of experiments using CRP labeled at Cys-178 with 1,5-I-AENS indicate change in conformation of the helix-turn-helix, occurring after the formation of CRP-cAMP(2) complex, i.e. after saturation of the high affinity sites. The observed conformational change occurs according to sequential model of allostery and is described by rate constants: k(c) = 9.7 +/- 0.1 s(-1) and k(-c) = 0.31 +/- 0.05 s(-1), for the forward and backward reaction, respectively. Results of experiments monitored using CRP intrinsic fluorescence suggest that conformational change precedes the formation of CRP-cAMP(4) complex and results from displacement of equilibrium between two forms of CRP-cAMP(2), caused by binding of cAMP to low affinity sites of one of these forms only. The observed conformational change occurs according to concerted model of allostery and is described by rate constants: k(on) = 28 +/- 1.5 s(-1) and k(off) = 75.5 +/- 3 s(-1). Results of experiments using single-tryptophan-containing CRP mutants indicate that Trp-85 is mainly responsible for the observed total change in intrinsic fluorescence of wild-type CRP.

DNA-induced conformational changes in cyclic AMP receptor protein: detection and mapping by a protein footprinting technique using multiple chemical proteases

Cyclic AMP receptor protein (CRP) is a regulator of transcription in Escherichia coli which mediates its activity by binding specific DNA sequences in a cyclic AMP-dependent manner. The interaction of CRP with specific DNA was probed by a protein footprinting technique using chemical proteases of different charge, size, and hydrophobicity. The experimental data were compared with known crystal structures of cAMP-CRP and cAMP-CRP-DNA complexes to determine a correlation between the structure of the complexes, the nature of the chemical protease and protein cleavage patterns. In addition, such comparison allowed us to determine if DNA binding in solution induced conformational changes in the protein not apparent in the crystal structure. In the cAMP-CRP-DNA complex, both the protections and the enhancements of proteolytic cleavage were observed outside of the known CRP-DNA interface, suggesting that CRP undergoes a conformational change upon binding DNA. Among the observed changes, the most interesting were those around the B alpha-helix and beta-strand 8, since this region overlaps with the activation region 2 which CRP uses for protein-protein interactions with RNA polymerase. DNA-induced changes were observed also in the region involved in CRP-CytR interaction and in CRP intersubunit contact regions. These data suggest that binding of DNA in solution induces conformational changes in CRP which can be transmitted via intersubunit contacts to regions of the protein involved in interactions with other members of transcriptional machinery.

Mapping cyclic nucleotide-induced conformational changes in cyclicAMP receptor protein by a protein footprinting technique using different chemical proteases

CyclicAMP receptor protein (CRP) regulates transcription of numerous genes in Escherichia coli. Both cAMP and cGMP bind CRP, but only cAMP induces conformational changes that dramatically increase the specific DNA binding activity of the protein. We have shown previously that our protein footprinting technique is sensitive enough to detect conformational changes in CRP by cAMP [Baichoo N, Heyduk T. 1997. Biochemistry 36:10830-10836]. In this work, conformational changes in CRP induced by cAMP and cGMP binding were mapped and quantitatively analyzed by protein footprinting using iron complexed to diethylenetriaminepentaacetic acid ([Fe-DTPA]2-), iron complexed to ethylenediaminediacetic acid ([Fe-EDDA]), iron complexed to desferrioxamine mesylate ([Fe-HDFO]+), and copper complexed to o-phenanthroline ([(OP)2Cu]+) as proteases. These chemical proteases differ in size, charge, and hydrophobicity. Binding of cAMP to CRP resulted in changes in susceptibility to cleavage by all four proteases. Cleavage by [Fe-EDDA] and [Fe-DTPA]2- of CRP-cAMP detected hypersensitivities in the DNA-binding F alpha-helix, the interdomain hinge, and the ends of the C alpha-helix, which is involved in intersubunit interactions. [Fe-EDDA] and [Fe-DTPA]2- also detected reductions in cleavage in the D and E alpha-helices, which are involved in DNA recognition. Cleavage by [Fe-HDFO]+ of CRP-cAMP detected hypersensitivities in beta-strand 8, the B alpha-helix, as well as in parts of the F and C alpha-helices. [Fe-HDFO]+ also detected protections from cleavage in beta-strands 4 to 5 and their intervening loop, beta-strand 7, which is part of the nucleotide binding pocket, as well as in the D and E alpha-helices. Cleavage by [(OP)2Cu]+ of CRP-cAMP detected hypersensitivities in beta-strands 9 and 11 as well as in the D and E alpha-helices. [(OP)2Cu]+ also detected protections in the C alpha-helix , the interdomain hinge, and beta-strands 2-7. Binding of cGMP to CRP resulted in changes in susceptibility to cleavage only by [(OP)2Cu]+, which detected minor protections in beta-strands 3-7, the interdomain hinge, and the C alpha-helix. These results show that binding of cAMP causes structural changes in CRP in the nucleotide binding domain, the interdomain hinge, the DNA binding domain, and regions involved in intersubunit interaction. Structural changes induced by binding of cGMP appear to be very minor and confined to the nucleotide binding domain, the interdomain hinge, and regions involved in intersubunit interaction. Use of different cleaving agents in protein footprinting seems to give a more detailed picture of structural changes than the use of a single protease alone.

The sequential mechanism of guanidine hydrochloride-induced denaturation of cAMP receptor protein from Escherichia coli. A fluorescent study using 8-anilino-1-naphthalenesulfonic acid

cAMP receptor protein (CRP) regulates expression of a number of genes in Escherichia coli. The protein is a homodimer and each monomer is folded into two structural domains. The biological activation of CRP upon cAMP binding may involve the subunit realignment as well as reorientation between the domains within each subunit. In order to study the interactions between the subunits or domains, we performed stopped-flow measurements of the guanidine hydrochloride (GuHCI)-induced denaturation of CRP. The changes in CRP structure induced by GuHCl were monitored using both intrinsic Trp fluorescence as well as the fluorescence of an extrinsic probe, 8-anilino-1-Naphthalenesulfonic acid (ANS). Results of CRP denaturation using Trp fluorescence detection are consistent with a two-step model [Malecki, and Wasylewski, (1997), Eur. J. Biochem. 243, 660], where the dissociation of dimer into subunits is followed by the monomer unfolding. The denaturation of CRP monitored by ANS fluorescence reveals the existence of two additional processes. One occurs before the dissociation of CRP into subunits, whereas the second takes place after the dissociation, but prior to proper subunit unfolding. These additional processes suggest that CRP denaturation is described by a more complicated mechanism than a simple three-state equilibrium and may involve additional changes in both inter- and intrasubunit interactions. We also report the effect of cAMP on the kinetics of CRP subunit unfolding and refolding.

Determination of the conformations of cAMP receptor protein and its T127L,S128A mutant with and without cAMP from small angle neutron scattering measurements

Small angle neutron scattering (SANS) measurements were performed on solutions of cAMP receptor protein (CRP) and on solutions of the T127L,S128A double mutant of CRP (CRP*) in D2O K3PO4 buffer containing 0.5 M KCl, in the absence and presence of 3',5' cyclic adenosine monophosphate (cAMP). Energy-minimized structures of the CRP were calculated by minimization of the x-ray crystallographic structure of CRP in either the exclusively "closed" form where the alpha-helices of the carboxyl-terminal domain are folded close to the amino-terminal domain and in the exclusively "open" form where the alpha-helices of the carboxyl-terminal domain are folded away from the amino-terminal domain. Neutron scattering models show that the CRP SANS data follow closely the data curve predicted for unligated CRP in the open form, whereas the cAMP-ligated data are more in agreement with the data predicted for the minimized cAMP-ligated CRP structure in the closed form. Thus, it appears that CRP undergoes a conformational change from the open form to the closed form in solution upon ligation with cAMP. The SANS data from the CRP* and cAMP-ligated CRP* are coincidental, which implies that there is very little structural difference between the two species of CRP*. This is in agreement with in vivo results, which show that whereas CRP activates transcription in the cell only in the presence of cAMP, CRP* activates transcription in the absence of cAMP, implying that CRP* is already in the correct conformation for the activation of transcription.

Interactive and dominant effects of residues 128 and 141 on cyclic nucleotide and DNA bindings in Escherichia coli cAMP receptor protein

The molecular events in the cAMP-induced allosteric activation of cAMP receptor protein (CRP) involve interfacial communications between subunits and domains. However, the roles of intersubunit and interdomain interactions in defining the selectivity of cAMP against other cyclic nucleotides and cooperativity in ligand binding are still not known. Natural occurring CRP mutants with different phenotypes were employed to address these issues. Thermodynamic analyses of subunit association, protein stability, and cAMP and DNA binding as well as conformational studies of the mutants and wild-type CRPs lead to an identification of the apparently dominant roles of residues 128 and 141 in the cAMP-modulated DNA binding activity of CRP. Serine 128 and the C-helix were implicated as playing a critical role in modulating negative cooperativity of cyclic nucleotide binding. A correlation was established between a weak affinity for subunit assembly and the relaxation of cyclic nucleotide selectivity in the G141Q and S128A/G141Q mutants. These results imply that intersubunit interaction is important for cyclic nucleotide discrimination in CRP. The double mutant S128A/G141Q, constructed from two single mutations of S128A and G141Q, which exhibit opposite phenotypic characteristics of CRP- and CRP*, respectively, assumes a CRP* phenotype and has biochemical properties similar to those of the G141Q mutant. These observations suggest that mutation G141Q exerts a dominant effect over mutation S128A and that the subunit realignment induced by the G141Q mutation can override the local structural disruption created by mutation S128A.

Effect of cAMP binding site mutations on the interaction of cAMP receptor protein with cyclic nucleoside monophosphate ligands and DNA

Although cAMP binding to wild type cAMP receptor protein (CRP) induces specific DNA binding and activates transcription, cyclic nucleoside monophosphate (cNMP) binding to the CRP mutant Ser128 --> Ala does not, whereas the double CRP mutant Thr127 --> Leu/Ser128 --> Ala activates transcription even in the absence of cNMP. Isothermal titration calorimetry measurements on the cNMP binding reactions to the S128A and T127L/S128A mutants show that the reactions are mainly entropically driven as is cAMP binding to CRP. In contrast to cAMP binding to CRP, the binding reactions are noncooperative and exothermic with binding enthalpies (DeltaHb) ranging from -23.4 +/- 0.9 kJ mol-1 for cAMP binding to S128A at 39 degrees C to -4.1 +/- 0.6 kJ mol-1 for cAMP binding to T127L/S128A at 24 degrees C and exhibit enthalpy-entropy compensation. To account for the inactivity of the S128A mutant, in vitro and in vivo DNA binding experiments were performed on the cAMP-ligated S128A mutant. The cAMP-ligated S128A mutant binds to the consensus DNA binding site with approximately the same affinity as that of cAMP-ligated CRP but forms a different type of complex, which may account for loss of transcriptional activity by the mutant. Energy minimization computations on the cAMP-ligated S128A mutant show that amino acid conformational differences between S128A and CRP occur at Ser179, Glu181, and Thr182 in the center of the DNA binding site, implying that these conformational changes may account for the difference in DNA binding.